r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Apr 13 '21

Proposal to increase the bonus to 25% for people who earned less than 10K Moons.

202 Upvotes

edit: this is just an idea to bounce around for a future proposal. Not an actual poll.

This would be just an amendment to the current 20% bonus we already have for holding distributed Moons in your vault. It will still be 20% for people who earned 10K moons or more through distribution.

This will help new people, and help level the field with the Moon rich.

With mainnet not up, and a lot of new people, this will also help new people from being tempted into moving their funds from their vaults pre-mainnet, and potentially losing their funds.

Alternatively, we can do 3 tiers:

30% for people who earned 1-999 Moons

25% for people who earned 1K-9.999K

20% for people who earned 10K+

Or just target the new people and do 25% just for people under 1K, as an extra incentive when you are still new or haven't earned much, to get you jump started, and not feel discouraged by people with high Moon counts.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Aug 18 '21

ANNOUNCEMENT We are enforcing a toughened stance on self stories

199 Upvotes

Self-stories have become quite common here. It's good to have feelgood content every so often.

Sadly, we have seen an increase in low-effort self-story posts and false stories. After significant discussion, we are toughening our stance on self-stories.

Rule 5. Content Standards now includes the following:

Self-story posts are not allowed unless they are related to cryptocurrency news and/or analysis. Self-stories require concrete proof in the post ideally, or by modmail for sensitive information. Self-story posts like my dad bought bitcoin, I sold all my coins to buy a truck, etc., are not allowed. Please include proof when posting self-stores as comments where applicable.

Self-story comments in the daily continue to be allowed, but please include proof in these. Comments that have no proof and are suspected of being false may be removed.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Apr 06 '23

Discussion This is not an attack but more of a clear the air post in hopes of stuff like this not happening again as it doesn't look good for moons ...

189 Upvotes

Ok first of all alot of users are currently talking about this amongst themselves and thought it's best to make a post to find some answers and to find some way of this kind of thing not happening again !

two mod wallets involved in insider trading. they timed it so PrinceZero1994 would get all the profit from a sponsor buying 10eth worth of moons from sushi  

  0xd8999b20a813aab2ae7f0d61af8a94a4c8e05043

  Belonging to PrinceZero1994

    0x155Db796a298c389C3DB69392ad74620e359cd3f

  Belonging to MrMoustacheMan.

    yesterday: sponsor asked mods to burn 68,400 moons to hire the banner for a month. sponsor sent 10 WETH to MrMoustacheMan in this tx

  https://nova.arbiscan.io/tx/0x6ab108b08d0237569183f9f586ce78e578c562644c7956016860404aac2c90ee

  MrMoustacheMan starts buying moons from SushiSwap with the sponsor WETH:  

  https://nova-explorer.arbitrum.io/tx/0x7cddb5d5dfb261d97448524f427b80ee84c99947802431deacfad21dee18e1c7

    https://nova-explorer.arbitrum.io/tx/0xaf31fa8be3e628f17a12d727c76fbb39e09ca4df2349cf46336525909552c491  

  https://nova-explorer.arbitrum.io/tx/0x535aa74ecabd777fb664aab350cab2d96520c6f825a91633cd68bb455e7b03aa

  https://nova-explorer.arbitrum.io/tx/0x16d7a78bdd0bcecaf544ee531af074bb520f9839edd60340c163354e5cc0be4f

  The final moon buy with sponsor's WETH happened here:

  https://nova-explorer.arbitrum.io/tx/0xaa5b846099a89db7bfd8b9ecd4573f020c51a3d9ff104698707c6848c2ee14aa

  27 seconds later, PrinceZero1994 dumps 27,721.831 MOONs for 3.8 WETH on SushiSwap, absorbing most of the profit from the sponsor's moon buying:

  https://nova-explorer.arbitrum.io/tx/0xd246553bbf330e818b31315629d781a5192dcc19f394a1ea2d66da8c20e073f2

  confirm that wallet belongs to PrinceZero1994 on the second page of txs here:

  https://ccmoons.com/explore?query=0xd8999b20a813aab2ae7f0d61af8a94a4c8e05043

  conclusion: moderators PrinceZero1994 used insider knowledge to benefit from a sponsor buying 10eth worth of moons,although the moons were burned PrinceZero1994 absorbed most of the positive price action.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Aug 09 '21

Discussion Ah yes. This is also why we should allow Metadiscussion in the Mainsub. So people actually see this shit.

Post image
122 Upvotes

r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Nov 16 '23

Moons Proposal: Rebuild MOON Distribution and Tipping using the Community Point application known as u/AvatarBot

119 Upvotes

Hey Gang! I am a developer for r/Coneheads and many other community point projects.

My application runs through the bot account known as u/AvatarBot

Just recently, I have deployed a test version of how MOON distribution and tipping can be reborn, in your own image.

The current test-state of distribution is as follows

  • Once a posts ages 24 hours, the user is rewarded a fixed rate of 0.01 MOON mining rewards per upvote.

  • Mining rewards are stored off-chain

    • Mining rewards be tipped to other users gas free, wallet connect free.

    • Mining rewards can be converted to tokens using a !withdraw comment command

    • Tokens are sent to the user's Reddit vault wallet from a hot wallet with no wallet connection required

Above is the base design that can be altered to fit the needs of r/CryptoCurrency. The application can also support user flairs as I have restored flairs for r/ethtrader.

No matter the vision, I'm here to support the MOON project and I want to be a part of its rebirth!


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Oct 06 '21

Governance [Governance] I propose that users be notified whenever a governance poll is posted. This will boost voting numbers and moons distribution too.

106 Upvotes

In this most recent round of governance polls (Round 18), there was an "emergency poll" that has not yet been seen by most redditors.

[Emergency Proposal] Remove users from moon distribution due to bypassing karma limits

I don't know if there is a way to ensure that everyone gains access to their +1.25% moons distribution, but I would appreciate receiving a notification when the original poll(s) are posted, AND if/when an update is posted as well.

Considering that these governance polls determine the future of the subreddit and still only receive 6k votes (as of the time of this post), we can do more to ensure that voting takes place AND that people make the most of the moons that they earned.

Edit: If you need evidence of why this would be beneficial for not only boosting vote turnout but also moon distro, please see this post that I made earlier this evening reminding r/cc users to vote before the polls expire. The number of “thanks for the reminder” comments is telling.


Edit: it has been suggested, and I agree that an “opt out” option should be available.

Edit 2: a mod has pointed out that they don’t have the tools to notify everyone, BUT, the admin do via a similar format to the “predictions” tab where you can “vote/bet” for future coin price actions. This would appear to be the best option for the time being.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Aug 30 '23

Moons There is clear voting/Karma manipulation going on in the subreddit

105 Upvotes

When the snapshot was released today, I went through all the top karma earners, and I noticed something. It’s clear that most of them are manipulating the system for moons. I wanted to specifically mention the culprits , but I read the rule on witch-hunting so I won’t mention any names unless I’m specifically allowed to.

But looking at some of their profiles, one can see that they are consistently getting more upvotes on their replies to comments (not post) which I have never seen anywhere on Reddit. It’s one thing to get more upvotes when replying some comments a few times but to consistently get more upvotes, despite not saying anything radically different? That’s sketchy as hell.

Also, as earlier stated in a post here, most of them just casually chat on the daily discussion and for some reason, they are pulling 5 upvotes in an obscure comment somewhere down the daily discussion? And getting x2 multiplers? The post calling this out is, not surprisingly, getting downvoted to hell.

If nothing is done, I guess what it would take to be a top earner is to gather a group of fellow moon farmers and just start a random discussion on the daily discussion chat and start upvoting each other?


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Sep 02 '21

Discussion Guide on how to reach 15K karma (the honest way).

92 Upvotes

As the author of the 15K cap proposal, I'd like to give out some tips on how to hit that cap.

I want to give everyone a chance to be competitive, and have a more even playing field.

But not by using bots, spamming, or anything like that. I'll teach you the honest way.

The mechanism.

First understand the basic mechanism of karma and moons. There's a set amount of moons distributed every 28 days. It doesn't matter if only 5 people participated with 10 karma or 5 million with 100 million karma. The same amount is distributed. And it's a proportional distribution.

It's a set amount every month. It was 1.6M moons in this distribution. And it's reduced by 2.5% every new distribution.

Moon is calculated by karma, not the amount of upvotes or downvotes you get. A lot of people think it's the same thing, but it's not. Karma is calculated by a weighted algorithm. So for instance, a post with 20k upvotes may only get 6k karma. But if you know your moon rules, you also know that posts are all capped at 1K karma. So those 20k upvotes will get you 1K karma anyway.

The roadblock.

15k karma is not something Reddit users typically get in a month. Only a small portion of active Redditors even get 15K in a year.

What makes it extra difficult, is there is a 1k cap on posts. So you can't just hit the jackpot with a single post that gets 30,000 upvotes.

Overcoming this will require a lot of participation, trial and error, and maybe unusual activity. Unusual results require unusual activity.

You'll need to make the most out of your comments and posts, so you don't end up wasting your time.

You'll want your post to be at the top of the hot page, and your comments at the top of of posts that are at the top of the hot page.

The Karma

For the purpose of hitting 15K, here's the part you need to know about karma.

1-Comments

Karma for comments counts double on this sub. This might make it sound like you should just comment as much as possible. But comments in the daily or on an already popular post, have the hardest time with visibility. For instance, in the daily, you might post a gold nugget that everyone loves, but with the amount of activity, your comment gets buried out of visibility in a couple minutes.

Comments on popular posts with already 200 comments, will also be buried.

Start commenting more in the new section on good posts. Don't forget to upvote those posts, so they become more visible, and your comment also becomes more visible. If your comment and that post gets good traction, you could end up with a top comment of a top post.

2-Posts

Comedy posts only get 10% karma. So stay away from those.

If you can write a good post, on a subject that hasn't been talked about to death, you can maybe hit that 1K karma.

It helps if you really bring out good points, have some supporting material, and make it more than just a paragraph of fluff, generalities, or wild claims.

The subject should be something either very pertinent about a classic subject, or something about new headlines or something that resonates with a current fad.

You want to think of what's popular, but without boxing yourself in with just populist narratives. Sometimes going outside that box can get you noticed more.

But that's only half that battle. Viability is the other half.

How to hit the visibility jackpot.

It's all about hitting the visibility jackpot to get those top numbers. And it's gonna require a little luck in the end, so it won't happen every week.

It's 1/3 luck, 1/3 timing, and 1/3 making the right post.

This is a mob driven system for picking quality content, and you're not facing a panel of experts, the name of the game is also popularity.

Make a good comment on a post that will become popular, and pick a popular topic to post about that will spark interest.

Even if you have a great post, it won't automatically get traction. Reddit is a visibility game, and posting at the right time to the right people can make a big difference in getting that visibility, and being bumped at the top of the hot page.

When to post?

Part of hitting that jackpot, is posting at the right time.

There's different time zones to deal with, user behavior, demographic, and peaks times of activity.

There's various sites that give you analytics on past data of when there was the most activity or when posts received the most upvotes. https://dashboard.laterforreddit.com/analysis/

Generally, weekdays in the morning and lunchtime is when people spend the most time on social media. For Reddit the sweet spot is when America wakes up and Europe is finishing off work.

You'll get the best opportunity if you hit the right time. But there's still an element of luck. Hopefully you won't post when grumpy people are viewing, and instead people interested in your topic will be around.

The Cliches

While it might be tempting to repeat what's already been successful, and do things like writing "unpopular opinion" in your title, it's best to stay away from those if they've become overused. Don't buy high on what's already been popular and might be past its peak already. Try to go with what will become popular.

The penmanship.

Now I get that most people aren't gonna be William Faulkner. But what good is having an interesting topic and great points, if you can't communicate that effectively?

For writing a convincing piece that will hit the nail on the head, make sure you have a point you can drive home. In more technical term, a thesis statement.

You'll need supporting arguments that hits your points from all angles.

I'm not gonna go into all the details, they're already here in this book: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Elements_of_Style


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Nov 17 '21

Unpopular Opinion: Unpopular Opinion titles are overused. Thus, we are now removing them under rule 9.

90 Upvotes

Rule 9: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/wiki/expanded_rules#wiki_rule_9_-_suitable_titles_and_flairs

The filters now include certain terms like "Unpopular Opinion". We will add other items as we see certain overused tropes emerge.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Apr 14 '23

Governance Yesterday I had 1 ETH drained from my wallet due to clicking a malicious link that is being spread all over Reddit right now by a MASSIVE army of scammers/bots. I was permabanned from r/cc after sharing this, no warning.

83 Upvotes

I was banned from r/cryptocurrency last night with no reason stated after recounting my experience being robbed of 1 ETH.

At this moment at least 100 fake accounts are mobilizing for the sole purpose of spreading and brigading malicious links . One of the addresses associated with this activity has moved around $500k of stolen funds. They are downvoting any comments or posts calling them out. Full context and links are given in the post. Stay safe people.

The following is a summary of my account as well as the results of the digging and investigations that followed it. My post had over 150 upvotes and 150 comments before it was brigaded to the bottom.


Earlier today I stupidly clicked a link in r/rocketpool that took me to a malicious page and somehow MetaMask got connected (possibly my fault) and next thing I know, .99 ETH is gone forever. That was my Reddit crypto bounty; moons. Avatar gains, ARB drop, Moonplace.io etc. I was proud of that 1 ETH as it represented my participation in this incredible community.

I already made a threadabout my incident earlier but now that we have more information I wanted to make a post with the sole purpose of putting these scumbags on blast.


Here’s the Tx on etherscan:

https://etherscan.io/tx/0x5bcf46315bc3f96e53d0453b8362d30d65c257993f6dab148e0affe1362b39a1


The impeccable investigative work below was provided in record time courtesy of u/zoomercoomer9000

This one is messy.

Your thief

  1. 0x744e309a515C0393d53aAff504BE9399D18ECEa7

Has, in the past, sent a total of $72,000 in 117 separate transactions to:

2. 0x4e5c564fE3DA52c1F88C6A95163A91d0FDb1898F

https://i.imgur.com/r29Xn2x.jpg

And that address has, in the past, sent a total of $504,000 in 62 separate transactions to:

3. 0x7cDad3c28bbC46420B6b5B1018b67A8E4Daa14A9

https://i.imgur.com/XcPR1HS.jpg

Due to the large outgoing volume, we can say with some degree of confidence that these also belong to the scammer. Now, the third address has directly sent to a number of KYC exchanges.

His Kraken customer deposit address: 0xA0f581E91eC1cC578A5Bb1A308a285e8Bcc6F13F

His Binance customer deposit address: 0x43130861B5d233dd4398bb8f2863D4024D64318e

As mentioned above, this is a messy situation involving intermediary wallets. But there is a sizeable trail leading back to those KYC deposit addresses.


The Kraken team was good enough to supply their Response:

Unfortunately, we are unable to provide any information about other Kraken accounts. This is to protect our clients against attempts to use this information for malicious purposes. Any requested information can only be provided to verified law enforcement officials.

We advise that u/jesschester file a police report and ask law enforcement officials responsible for this investigation to contact us by submitting the Compliance and Legal request. https://support.kraken.com/hc/en-us/requests/new

We would like to emphasize that, for your security, we cannot confirm, imply, or deny whether the details provided are associated with any Kraken account.

Jimbo from Kraken Support 🐙


 Another person whose comment I don’t have time to track down pointed out this following address which is associated with the theft and might possibly be an exchange:

0xd5FBDa4C79F38920159fE5f22DF9655FDe292d47

For full credit refer to the link of my original post.

That’s the basic gist of all that I posted before being permanently banned from r/cryptocurrency without warning. I still haven’t been given a reason. I have been an active member for years and never have any issues with mods or other users. Can anyone please provide some sort of information about why the content of my posts has caused me to be banned? Or attempt to hazard a guess? I’ll take whatever information you have because the mods can’t be bothered and I am at a loss 😕 . It has not been a very good day losing so much money and being expelled from my most active online community in the same fell swoop. I am feeling kind of down and confused.

UPDATE: I was unbanned from r/cc thank god it was just an automod bot that banned me for sharing the malicious link.

UPDATE 2: I have filed a report with the FBI with the scammers addresses and other info. I plan to reach out to Kraken and Binance soon as well.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Aug 22 '21

Moons Which moderators have been selling their MOONS?

82 Upvotes

EDIT: Updated post here, includes all mods: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/pa89vf/moderator_moon_transactions_on_rinkeby_testnet/?sort=new

Three out of ten moderators have sold MOONS without disguising it. The last transfer to the xDai network from Rinkeby testnet occurred on July 23th.

Only SamsungGalaxyPlayer has transferred Moons back (about 36k) making his net transfers out about 94k.

This shows when the transfers occurred:

Proof of sales:

shimmyjimmy97 - https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/address/0xe48a23fCc56B3F2EB87646F2a61E400209418416/token-transfers

shimmyjimmy97 sold 192,275 xMoon across 22 transactions and received 23,491 xDai in return. His cost basis was therefore 0.122 xDai/xMoon.

samsunggalaxyplayer - https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/address/0x6F46C585237C78ec144Be0C8764028b22EA046C6/token-transfers

SamsungGalaxyPlayer sold 94,835 xMoon across 34 transactions and received 7,871 xDai in return. His cost basis was therefore 0.083 xDai/xMoon

mediumadhesiveness5 -https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/address/0x7Ea5945079b1204011EdB7992419C11FD458c183/token-transfers

MediumAdhesiveness5 sold 32,000 xMoon across 32 transactions and received 3,304 xDai in return. His cost basis was therefore 0.103 xDai/xMoon

Disclaimer:

  • This data doesn’t include any obfuscated transfers to or from the xDai network. Only direct transfers are included.

  • This data doesn’t account for any transaction failures. It is possible double counting occurred.

  • This analysis only includes transfers from Rinkeby testnet to xDai network.

Shoutouts to:

  • u/ominous_anenome for ccmoons.com which made it easy to lookup moderator wallets

  • u/redditsgarbageman who suggested I do this analysis

  • Etherscan for the complete Rinkeby Testnet transaction data


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Feb 05 '18

Mods need to take a step back.

79 Upvotes

There is no need for this level of moderation.

The "2 per page" rule, is in my opinion utterly ineffective. What it's doing is giving the moderators an excuse to lock & sort by controversial on posts they disagree with. If a cryptocurrency has more than 2 posts on the front page then it's probably for a good reason, and deserves to be there. Let the users decide, there's no need for this level of micromanagement.

The drastic & unneeded changes they just made to VEN are imo ridiculous. So a moderator of the VEN community encourages people to upvote posts there, you tell him to stop & he says that he can do what he wants - this causes you guys to completely stop all discussion of VEN for a whole month? That's honestly fucking pathetic. Pretty ironic that one of the most tightly modded subs stands for a censorship-free & decentralized world.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Mar 08 '23

Moons Moons have done nothing but reduce the quality and in-depth discussion happening on /r/CC

77 Upvotes

Title

Imo moons have presented an incentive to just shit post as much as possible and just regurgitate shitty articles to generate upvotes

By extension, we also see that extremely often things are downvoted en-masse likely in some attempt to increase the bot farm owners proportion of moons

I wish that this arbitrary money printer wasn't a thing, and that in-depth discussion was actually rewarded with engagement


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Aug 08 '21

Discussion Pandora's box has been opened and every month makes it harder to curb the bad-faith engagement with the subreddit.

77 Upvotes

TL;DR - I've been a part of the /r/CryptoCurrency sub for 4 years now, so long before Moons. While no subreddit is perfect, I don't think I've ever seen a subreddit so filled with bad-faith posting as in the last few months.

I think Moons are and will be a net positive to the community, but at the moment I think I can effectively argue that the current distribution favours bad-faith engagement over genuine participation.

What is bad-faith engagement?

Simply put, it's interacting with the subreddit not because of interest in participating in a community, but instead to maximise financial gain with low-effort, phoney participation.

What this means is that those that post in bad-faith have found the most effective ways of receiving karma back for time spent in the sub.

So then what is "genuine participation"

Far from pretending I'm the arbiter of what is good and what is not, I think it's common sense for anyone to separate the wheat from the chaff. Genuine engagement would be sharing information, providing helpful answers, asking important, newbie or hard questions, having a little fun, etc etc.

In essence, it's just participation done for the sake of sharing knowledge and information, for challenging opinions and beliefs and generally, being active without spamming.

Governance.

The admins have provided us with tools to govern ourselves. We (users and moderators) can decide on polls to change how Moons distribution works and with this, we can shape the direction of the subreddit. Currently, we have decided that certain posts receive more karma, certain posts receive less.

I believe this tool is crucial to shaping the subreddit but there is a finite limit on its usefulness which I fear we have already exceeded.

What I mean by this is, how can you ever curb bad faith engagement with the subreddit if every month, a higher proportion of voting power is given to those who chiefly engage in bad-faith posting?

Every month the balance of power shifts over and we see more people awarded moons for bad-faith participation that includes, but is not limited to:

  • Spamming of certain types of content, such as GIFs - which by their bright, attention grabbing nature and ability to show pop-culture media, put them on a higher probability of upvotes.

  • Spamming of asinine, low-effort content, particularly in the Daily Discussion

  • Immediate, barely relevant comments posted before a topic is 20 seconds old in New or Rising

  • Frequent reposts of popular topics, such as Robinhood reminders, Coinbase Pro reminders etc.

  • Creation of brand new accounts with subscription bought, solely to post like hell on this subreddit.

The bone I have to pick with these types of posts is that the value added to the subreddit is not proportional to the karma received and thus, in my view, they are gaming the system.


The Breakdown

On the face of it, some of these might not seem so bad - but this is purely a superficial view.

GIF Spam

GIF spam is bad because they very often have little if anything to do with the topic of discussion at hand. Yet they receive upvotes, because its human nature to get a hit of endorphine when someone else posts something you like - if I am a fan of Rick & Morty, then I would be more likely to notice a Rick & Morty GIF and upvote the content.

GIF spam also tends to accompany very low-effort content. If I post "Bears are out today" and then slap a GIF of a bear in a river, what is the value added to the subreddit, really? But I am rewarded for this value a disproportionate amount.

I will note that since my poll I think the awareness of this issue has increased and I have noticed an overall lower amount of GIF spam than there was before. As 3 out of every 4 users voted for my proposal it does show that people were getting sick of the GIFs.


Comment spam

The spamming of low-effort content is chiefly centred in the daily discussion threads. We have some 15 or so moderators - how can they be expected to moderate a thread with 30 or 40 thousand comments? It's impossible, so most of the bad-faith posting sadly flies under the radar.

Looking at the users in and around the top of the distribution month-on-month reveals a worrying trend. Someone made a thread about it here

The top way to get in the high ranks of each distribution is to just spam the shit out of comments. All day, every day, as much as you can.

Ask yourself, is this genuine participation? Or is this just jumping on the bandwagon of whatever coin is pumping, or whatever sentiment is currently trending. Where is the value added?


New/Rising abuse

What we're seeing is a flood of people now noticing that their posts, often well-informed, intelligent write ups and discussions are getting 200 comments and about 30 upvotes.

I've been using the Internet for some 20 years, and any time there's a kind of vote/comment duality in play, I've never once seen comments regularly outnumber votes.

The goal here is clear. Try and get a top comment. This isn't commenting because you found the article or write up interesting and you want to engage, it's simply write "the first witty thing you can think of" and then drop out the thread and hope others upvote it.

The sad thing is that if these people upvoted the thread, it actually wouldn't cost them anything and it gives them a greater chance of being seen.


Reposted topics

Have I reminded you all about that time when Robinhood prevented GME stock from being bought? Oh, you haven't heard for 25 hours? Ok let's roll.

The volume of this kind of spam is so mind-blowing that when you lay it out like this, which is still missing tens of posts, you can see it for what it is - users wait until X days have passed and then have their turn at posting it.

It's simply taking a popular opinion and recycling it over and over. Do these people really care about RobinHood? I doubt it.


Brand new accounts

I'm also noticing a huge trend of <1 month old accounts, created and immediately buying the premium subscription to circumvent the age & karma posting requirements. These guys hit the ground running, immediately leaving hundreds of comments in the daily discussion threads. You can't fool yourself into believing there is not an agenda at play.

But how the hell do you point this out without sounding like "I don't like new members?"

Thing is, I doubt these are new members at all. I think they are alt accounts based on the behaviour - they know exactly what to do to farm moons, and it's almost unanimous that if you see a premium account <2 months old they will be doing one thing - sitting in the daily discussion writing 200+ comments per day, every day.

Look at some of these accounts:

15 pages of posts in 24 hours

Proof that users are using alts to farm moons (This particular user, I've been on his case for months since I saw he was plagiarizing comments and spamming the daily)


What does the community think?

These aren't just my observations. More and more posts are now reaching the front page. "How are accounts earning 15,000 karma?" "What are the top accounts doing to earn so much karma?"

You know what the top replies are - "Shitposting"

What we're doing as a community is saying "There is no point in genuine engagement with the community any more. Just shitpost and shitpost and shitpost"

How does this get fixed?

The real question to ask is, does the community even care enough to get it fixed?

I believe they do, the problem is that while a large segment of the community is against spam and bad-faith engagement, an equally large segment appears to view the sub through the lens of "How do I make as much money as possible as fast as possible?"

What's out of balance here is the distribution of moons. From a moon-farming view, it's simply not economical to post in good faith any more. Why bother writing a large discussion of the merits of ETH vs ADA, or BTC vs Nano, when you will receive 150 comments and 12 upvotes? It's much easier to look at what's pumping, hop in the daily and write "Go LTO!" or "Where my ADA gang at?"

And every month this divide gets wider and wider.

Harassment, intimidation and suppression.

If I were a user acting in bad-faith, and someone proposed a vote to stop that, I would do everything I could to keep the status quo.

Straight away, this would include:

  • Downvoting the poll - If it reaches front page, it is more likely to pass

  • Downvote all comments supporting the poll - the more unpopular voices of agreement look, the more likely the poll is to fail

  • Conjure a phoney list of reasons why the poll is overly punitive - to cast shadow of doubt on the polls intentions

  • Use disinformation to again cast doubt on the polls intentions - to use history as an example, pretend like a user proposing to limit Moons from GIF's is a "GIF hater" or "fun hater"

  • Harass or bully the user - this has the double effect of making people reluctant to post controversial polls in the future

To fix it, Mods need to get serious.

I don't want this to be seen as an attack or unfair criticism of moderation, which has been a tough job and particularly around the bullrun.

We're starting to see some of that toughness take place now, with a ripple caused last week when off-topic comments in the daily were met with a chance of temporary & permanent bans. The trouble with this is that's it's reactionary moderation to prevent or limit the behaviour instead of proactive rules that discourage it from ever blossoming.

And as I've gone over, the proactive rules via governance have less chance of passing every month.

We already know that unless polls are almost unanimous, they won't pass. I don't think the admins ever considered that there could be such a large subset of users negatively participating which would ever control such a large stake of Moons.

But this is the situation we find ourselves in and the governance polls simply aren't good enough - you're giving the moon-wealthy bad actors the ability to vote to continue bad acting.

As a community, mods & all, we need to find ways of preventing bad-faith engagement that do not impact good-faith engagement.

This is what I am proposing:

Reduction in Karma for GIF-only comments, or low-character count comments with GIF's

  • Obviously this poll was popular within the community but fell just short of passing

  • The idea here is to penalize the terminal GIF-posters.

  • While occasional GIF posters will receive a very minor penalization of total karma, they will receive a larger total share of karma overall because the GIF spammers will not get it, therefore regular premium users who post GIFs occasionally are not affected.

Only count the first x top-level comments per user, per thread for karma.

  • As it stands, the daily thread is un-moderatable and a hot-bed for bad-faith posts which add zero value to the sub.

  • This would prevent people sitting in a thread all day for the purpose of karma farming, but still allows them to participate in long-form conversation in other threads.

  • Regular users do not make a habit of posting multiple top-level comments in threads so are unaffected.

  • With less top-level comments in the daily, users could actually discuss things, the thread wouldn't be out of date in 20 minutes and more importantly, it would be moderatable.

Award a proportion of moons not just for karma, but also the top-level comments received in a thread

  • I don't know if this is possible, but it would certainly help the people that take time to write content to benefit the sub and see more comments than posts.

  • The idea here is to try and push discussion out of a 30,000 comment thread and more into the guts of the subreddit, which is more moderatable.

Disqualification of moons awarded for repetitive posts

  • If the moderators have such a tool, then great. Some of these posts are useful, but there's a naive expectation that this sub needs to constantly remind people NOT to buy off Robinhood (which is quick and easy) and instead faff around with multiple exchanges, FIAT onramps etc, all based off their perception of a company. (Disclaimer, I don't particularly like RH)

  • So while useful, repetitive information shouldn't be eligible for moons and therefore the repetition is not rewarded and should go down.

Remove the ability to post on brand-new accounts if Premium Subscription is bought

  • I know, I know. Removal of features for premium is a contentious topic but it's clear this is being used for abuse. Perhaps this won't be necessary if some of the other ideas are implemented and it's less lucrative to spam.

  • Perhaps another avenue is for admins to check brand-new premium accounts IP addresses for activity on other accounts and then make them ineligible for Moons.

Disqualify users acting in bad faith from receiving moons

  • This really, really shouldn't require a full-on vote from the community to bar a user from earning moons for bad-faith engagement.

  • The mods have the power of banning and passing information to the admins and it should be exercised to protect the community and deliver a higher-proportion of Moons to genuine participants.

The big idea

I think the best option the mods could implement for now is a revamp of the flair system.

Currently, it's all over the place. Users do not have great ways to tag their posts, especially in comparison to places like /r/techsupport

We should remove all current flairs and assign a new system that gives a relationship to Flair and moons multipliers.

  • Analysis

  • Debate

  • Anecdote

  • Meta

  • Update

  • Governance

  • FAQ

  • Good-to-know

There's more I've missed, but the idea is that flair types such as "Analysis" and "Debate" should earn a multiplier to moons, such as 1.25x, links should receive something like 0.75x, Anecdotes 0.25x, Good to Know 0.25x etc.

The moderation this would require is ensuring posts on the front couple pages are flaired properly. If users are flairing "Anecdotes" as "Analysis" to try and skim more moons, adjust it and ban repeat offenders.

The objective here is to encourage the content I believe the subreddit wants to see - helpful information, chances to debate etc

It then stops being lucrative to spam repetitive topics, or link farm.


As I said in the TL;DR the objective here is to turn the sub away from its current trajectory, which is a subreddit for moon farmers, by moon farmers. And instead, look at proportionally rewarding the users that add value.

The best way to do this is to implement rules that penalize bad-actors while have little or no impact on the regular users of this sub.

If you got this far, thanks for reading. I enjoy the concept of Moons and I like earning them, but I was here before Moons and I'd still be here if they were taken away next month. I don't think we can say the same for a lot of accounts who are currently posting.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Apr 07 '23

Suggestions There should be governance for how mods are allowed to trade

74 Upvotes

I work at a bank. I have access to large amounts of data regarding trades/orders. Due to this I’m what’s considered a “finra associated individual”. This means all my trades are monitored and I am not allowed to sell a stock I’ve purchased until at least 30 days have passed. Now to be clear, I don’t even really have access to data I’d need to insider trade. Regardless because I potentially could be, I can’t day or swing trade. This removes any appearance or potential for insider trading.

Given recent events I’m not seeing why mods shouldn’t be held to a similar standard. I think 30 days is excessive, however a 8 hour hold period before selling and a lockout from trading 8 hours before and 8 hours after banner purchases would be something. I don’t think mods should be prevented from trading, however they should not be using insider knowledge to give themselves an edge.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Nov 25 '21

Discussion I analyzed how the top 30 users got 15K karma this round. Revealing a key factor that helped them, which is not the factor I initially expected.

74 Upvotes

Posts

I looked at the posts first. Which didn't take long.

Hardly any of the top 30 users got their karma from posts. There were very few posts, not many got many upvotes. Some didn't even post anything at all.

There was nothing out of the ordinary from the few that did have a couple posts that got them the 1K max. They were just the usual topics people keep posting all the time:

Comments

This is clearly where the 15K karma came from.

All 30 users had at least a few comments with 100+ upvotes. And at least one or two with 200-1,500 upvotes.

200 upvotes isn't necessarily 200 karma. It can be 160 karma. Or it could be 270 karma.

In either case, karma on comments is doubled in this sub. So 200 upvotes could be 320-540 karma.

Quantity of comments

Did they all comment like mass production factories?

Only a few accounts had over 30 comments a day. The majority had closer to 15 comments a day.

Most of their comments only had about 2-3 upvotes average. So the majority of the karma came from the few highly upvoted comments.

So it didn't come from simply commenting the most. Just commenting enough.

Quality of comments

So those few highly upvoted comments must have been exceptional, very helpful, original, have great insight, or analysis, right?

I'll let you be the judge of that.

Here's a sample of the typical comments that hit the high upvotes:

These are honestly the typical comments most users make.

So what got them the upvotes?

What got them the upvotes:

In short visibility.

All these comments are actually inside those few successful posts that got at the top of the hot page.

And those comments are some of the first you see on those top posts.

Those posts that are now seen all over Reddit, and popping up on everyone's page. At least those that Reddit thinks will be interested in this.

It's essentially like hitting the SEO jackpot.

But there's a little more to it. If you comment on a post that's already hot, you're already too late. Your comment is gonna be buried.

Those comments got hundreds of upvotes, because they commented before the post got hot, and were lucky to be one of the first comments that got the first few upvotes.

It might sound a little disappointing, but it's literally a lottery.

Some of my own top voted comments, aren't exactly my best either:

How did that get over 150 upvotes? But when I post an original post, helpful guides, or in-depth analysis with charts and everything, I only get about 30 upvotes.

I wrote that comment when I was browsing "new". And was one of the first comments that got the most upvotes.

Also, I commented on a post that hit the sweet spot of site activity.

The best time to post on this sub, is typically weekdays (Wednesday is usually the best day) when America wakes up, but UK and Europe is at work, maybe on a late lunch break.

So that's about 7-8am EST. But if you look online there's sites that will give you all the sweet spots.

Conclusion

This is not to say that good posts don't get upvoted. I still have a few of my good content that got a ton of upvotes.

A few of the comments I saw were actually pretty good.

Also, if your comment is not at least a little funny, a little helpful, or clever, or resonates with the community, visibility alone won't help you.

This is just saying that the correlation is not as strongly tied to quality as we might think. And not quantity either. The stronger correlation may actually be visibility.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Oct 19 '23

Moons [Brainstorm] Potential Solution For Moons Future

73 Upvotes

Hello,

Reddit is discounting RCPs Program, they are getting out of Moons and leaving the community to take care of them.

We need to take the most efficient route for Moons. Don’t over complicated things, to make Moons run on the lowest levels of trust and highest levels of decentralization. Users already expressed their lack of confidence and trust with yesterday’s news and events.

Solution?

Keep the same contract, make Reddit transfer ownership to the burn address - Moons 100% safe, trustless and can’t be rugged by anyone. System running on Conversion of Energy/Moons like law:

No more Moons minting, the Moons that already in the system will be used for everything: Distribution for users/mods, LP rewards (+ TMD) etc.

But Moons from where exactly?

Subreddit Revenue - all the Moons that the subreddit is producing (Banner, AMAs / Giveaways and any new use cases).

The Revenue will replace Moons minting that we used to. This approach emphasizes the value that the users and subreddit is producing, and distributing it back to the users or Moons ecosystem.

After 3 years, the inflation was still high at 1,200,000 Moons per month, at ATH that was 600,000$ of potential sell pressure just to keep the current price! While the Revenue was barely 100,000 Moons per month.

That’s fair approach, like a team working in a business and splitting the revenue between them. Minting more Moons is like saying the above team is taking loan 10x their revenue each month and splitting it between them - money can’t be minted for free and there’s price to pay later.

There’s a lot of development / trust / issues like bugs or hacks associated with creating new contracts and new distribution systems. We need to keep it simple and minimalistic.

Pros:

• 0% risk for potential bugs or hacks

• No need for code audit (expensive)

• Doesn’t need to make CEX change anything which can risk cutting their support for Moons.

• Makes the user actively searching for new ways to increase the subreddit revenue - they can even reach out to companies and projects and offer them marketing on the subreddit- this increases the user Moons distributions.

• Quality content- no forced engagement and farming, users will engage because they want to, and get some Moons in return instead of posting just to earn Moons.

• Attractive investment - one of the major “red flag” for investors is big inflation - especially if the coins are given for free! The cost to produce Moons was basically 0$ which means big sell pressure as users didn’t lost anything even if they sold for low price. When the inflation is suddenly 0, there would be supply shock. The Moons accumulation race will begin and I’m sure ATH will be reached and maintained in no time.

• Might bring back the users who left after all the Moons farming that sent on.

Cons:

• “Distribution Shock”, users will be “shocked” to see that the new distribution is only ~10-15% of what it used to be. Well it more not be a problem since the next 1-2 distributions are cancelled anyway.

• We might see less activity - that depends on the price. If Maxxers received 7k Moons worth 1,500$ in the past and now they are getting 1k Moons, Moons price need to be +1$ for them to get the same reward in usd - this is possible since there will be supply shock.

Conclusion

Moons were popular mainly because Reddit was behind them- it’s a brand and well known company, that I believe what kept their value and attracted investors from the outside.

Now that part is gone, and Moons are losing some of their main features like displaying balance in the vault, ability to tip , special membership etc.

To balance that we need supply shock and stop the minting machine.

This is simple solution that is risk free, easy to implement and doesn’t need big maintenance.

Later we can discuss on KM, Goverance for non earned Moons, tipping and wallet registration.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Nov 11 '21

Discussion For proof of LRC brigading, just check their discord. I have followed LRC long before the GME and of late, they have been mass upvoting and shilling it from Discord

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Apr 16 '23

Discussion Moderator Trading Update

71 Upvotes

Last week it was brought to our attention that there was a potentially problematic trade performed by a member of the moderator team.

The moderator in question, PrinceZero (PZ), has been a very active trader of moons long before joining the moderation team. In this instance, it’s possible PZ was able to execute a sale shortly after a price increase due to information the public did not know. This sale netted him ~$750 more than if he had sold the same amount of moons before the price increase. PZ maintains that the inside information did not impact his trade, and that price alerts ~10 minutes before his sale helped him identify the trading opportunity.

In either case, this activity has damaged the community’s trust and we apologize for it happening. We also want to emphasize that MrMoustacheMan has no fault in what transpired. He was simply facilitating a buy-and-burn of moons on behalf of an organization who wanted to rent the banner, but did not want to buy moons directly. Some users jumped to the conclusion that MrMoustacheMan was complicit in this trade, leading to the spread of false accusations in the meta subreddit and elsewhere.

Since this was reported to us, we have been in active discussions internally and with the community . We would like to thank everyone for their input and patience during this time, and have the information below to share about the path forward.

PrinceZero has been removed as a moderator. This decision was not taken lightly. PZ did an excellent job helping us in the fight against manipulation since even before they were an official moderator and we appreciate their help towards the improvement of r/CryptoCurrency. Please direct all feedback to the mod team, there will be no tolerance for harassing PrinceZero.

25% of PZ’s mod distribution will be burned to account for the profits from this trade.

u/newbonsite, who put together the excellent post reporting this matter will be tipped 1,000 Moons.

Finally, to prevent this from happening again we will be taking steps to control inside information and corresponding mod trades. Inside information will be limited to only the mods who are working on it. In most cases, we do not have information about when events like a buy, burn, or listing will happen. In cases where we do have inside information, we will advise mods to avoid trading in the time surrounding an event.

Please keep in mind that Moons is an active, public ecosystem where we do not always have inside information (often deliberately). In the event that there is another instance where a mod trade suspiciously coincides with an event, we welcome reports from the community and will investigate the incident as we have done here.

Thank you for reading. Please let us know your questions, concerns, or feedback below.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Jan 17 '22

Moons New Moon Calendar 2022

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Nov 20 '21

Suggestions Mods should add the reason for not-obvious post removals

69 Upvotes

My purpose here is not to complain about my personal experience, but try to improve the quality of this subreddit. I'm a crypto content creator and almost everyday I post on r/Cc a short analysis about a certain crypto to help others do their own research. Yesterday was the turn of Loopring (LRC) and my post got a lot of upvotes (more than 800). It was the 47th post of a loong thread of crypto short analysis and I never had any problems with the others. Anyway, my post (which was ABSOLUTELY not a shilling post) got removed and when I asked the reason, they told me the post was vote manipulated by the Loopring reddit and discord community. Now, why the OP of a non shilling post has to be punished for others mistakes is beyond my comprehension, but at least, for cases like this (when the removal reason is not obvious), should the mods inform the OP about the situation? I really think they should, what do you think?

P.S. Today I tried to post the same analysis again (accepting the loss of karma and moons) but mods removed it again. Without telling me the reason. I don't know what to think anymore...


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Jul 11 '21

Governance How To Submit A Governance Proposal

Thumbnail reddit.com
67 Upvotes

r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Aug 10 '21

Governance Governance polls comment sections should be active for 48 hours before you can vote.

63 Upvotes

This will allow people to argue their points of view and let others see them before they vote. Many people in the comments sections have said they wish their could change their vote after reading the comments because someone brought up something that they hadn't thought about prior to voting.


r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • • Nov 04 '21

Discussion The “max post per coin” rule is insane. How do you post anymore? No wonder front page is full of self stories and nonsense

62 Upvotes

Almost any post about a specific coin gets taken down because of the max post per coin rule. What’s worse is that the post gets removed even if you check the coin you want to post about is not at the limit. Clearly the bot that checks this is broken or malfunctioning.

And many posts about coins are just coin ABC made ATH or overtook SHIB or something lame, so you can’t even post any decent news about these coins.

The front page now is just filled with self posts about price predictions, comedy stories , JIM CRAMER REMINDOOOOOR. Gave the kids to choose portfolio. The whole front page looks like the daily now. There is not one specific coin related post in the top 10 posts. If there is any important news or development regarding a coin, it will get taken down.

It’s almost as if low quality stuff is all that’s allowed now.