This last coronations dlc was my breaking point with this game. I have 2000 and all the dlc and tried my best to like it, as evidenced by my playtime, as it covers my favourite time period in history, but after the absolute sham that was the last dlc, I re purchased the dlc subscription for ck2 and booted up the game.
I have almost 1000 hrs logged into it compared to as mentioned 2000 for ck3. I used to play it when I didn’t have a powerful enough machine to run ck3 and hadn’t played it much since I ugraded.
At first I tried vanilla which was great, but then I remembered the great hip mod that was available and played that instead. Hip takes everything ck2 vanilla does very well and enhances it to another echelon.
Below is a non-exhaustive list of the many things that Ck2 gets right which ck3 gets totally wrong:
Preface
Though I’ll mainly be comparing ck3 to ck2 hip, everything hip does better than ck3 is also true for ck2 vanilla, as I said, hip is enhances vanilla mainly in the cosmetic category (much prettier map, nicer art for events), some extra flavour, and a few lightly reworked mechanics.
Also, yes I understand ck2/hip is in its final form however, holy fury, the final dlc was released 6 years after release and no more dlc came after that. We’re five years in already with 3 and there are still so many issues.
The map
Ck2 hip in my opinion has the prettiest map of all strategy games, and completely obliterates ck3’s disgusting mess. The hip map is genuinely lovely to look at. As a mostly MENA player, what they did to North Africa in ck3 with its blobs of impassible terrain and other ugly passable blobs in the central southern maghreb is disgusting, but the whole map is ugly to look at in general.
Events
In hip these are great, they are short and sweet, the art is absolutely immaculate and most importantly they are not constantly spammed in your face in the most inconvenient of times.
In ck3 it feels like the same 10 events are constantly on a loop. Scheme at court, bastard child, the 20th plague in 5 years and the same three options of dealing with it, like seriously, could they just make dealing with plagues dynamic? If not just let us automate it forever, it’s such a nuisance.
All the events are a nuisance. And they’re so long and drawn out, ’m playing a game dude, when I want to read I’ll read my books. And don’t get me started on the writing quality or the gimmicky backgrounds that accompany them, with the silly 3D models donning a dumb facial expression.
It’s also very refreshing to get away from X=48% chance Y=52% change nonsense. That just breaks immersion completely.
Finally, I’ve played everywhere from an Almoravid Saharan Berber to a coastal Berber, to an Arab, a Greek, a Latin, a Saxon, the events are diverse for each, and you actually feel like you’re playing a different culture each time, unlike with 3’s generic events.
Activities
Very similar to events in that they are short and to the point and overall much more enjoyable in hip. You don’t have to go through the same tedious process of skipping a million events you’ve already seen a million times. As a mainly MENA player, the hajj event is lovely, with a different prophetic Hadith each time, sometimes they repeat but who cares, it’s a short event with like 2 sentences.
I must say the lack of a travel mechanic is also nice, as I just find it tedious and inconsistent in 3. The events are so frequent and so long winded, and quite frankly cringe and goofy. It’s inconsistent in that you must travel for certain things, and for others you can just teleport, like with commanding armies.
Finally, I must emphasise this, as a MENA player, my immersion gets completely nuked by activities in ck3. The MENA world is extremely segregated when it comes to gender even today, let alone 1000 years ago. It’s just the culture of the region, and it’s so immersion breaking seeing men and women freely interacting with non-spouse and non-familial characters in events as a Muslim character. Not to say it was right or wrong, but It’s literally fantasy at this point. This is literally the Middle East, in the Middle Ages for crying out loud.
Ai competence
The ai is much, much more proficient at playing the game. It’s not perfect, but they feel alive and capable.
They actually make money, expand naturally and organically, not by the sheer luck of being given a conquerer trait. They engage in diplomacy, offering you non-agression pacts once in a while, and this sometimes leads to them adopting Islam or Christianity if they’re pagan. In a war between you and the ai, if you have similarly sized realms and manpower, winning is far from a foregone conclusion as it is in 3.
The hard and very hard difficulties also provide a challenge without doing what ck3 does, which is to blatantly cheat for the ai by giving them super stable realms, giving them a disgusting amount of gold aswell as giving them dirt cheap mercenary costs, which they in turn use to buy out every single mercenary company against you leaving you unable to buy any yourself.
The lack of modifiers from artifacts and buildings
In ck3 it’s nonsensical. Oh right, this regalia item gives me +20% tax income in floodplains (like what in the actual f), this random blue level table gives me +20 vassal opinion and that trinket gives me +50% fertility.
This is way less of a thing in hip and when it is the modifiers actually make logical sense as well as being much less powerful.
In addiction, the lack of ability to make artefacts from nothing is refreshing, as it leads to such a disgusting amount of indestructible clutter all over the place in ck3, is a much too powerful decision, and the ai never takes advantage of it.
No modifiers from buildings
Stacking buildings that make units literally unbeatable and turns knights into supermen is not a thing in hip. Enough said.
The only things that can somewhat be abused in ck2 vanilla, which are the buildings that increase retinue limits, have been totally removed from hip, they’re not available neither in regular buildings or trade posts.
Speaking of that,
War
Where does one even start with this. In ck2 your vassal units don their leige’s colours, and are risen from your vassals’ capital’s, there is no such thing as magically raising them all in the other corner of your empire in which they somehow cover thousands of kilometres in like 30 days.
Yes, that’s right, in ck3 I am able to raise all of my troops in Iberia in 30 days despite my capital being in baghdad. That’s almost 5000 km. That should take 6 months at least, and that’s with everyone man being on horseback. Those on foot or camel would take even longer. 30 days…… just lol.
The retinue system in hip does allow you to declare war near your enemy’s border but this is simply something the player should choose to avoid for the sake of rp.
Levies are not stone and stick wielding peasants with 10 damage in hip, instead they are a mix of different real units. You also have flanks each with a commander on each, much more realistic.
The battle tactics are also much more interesting and even more challenging in hip than ck2 vanilla and the ongoing battle graphic is just light years ahead. Oh, don’t forget about the free and magically-spawning ships in ck3.
Laws
My oh my. I love this so much in hip. Crown laws, which are very difficult to max out, needing increasingly larger, boat loads of prestige for each of the 5 levels. Prestige also isn’t easily farmed in hip as is the case with hunts and feasts in ck3. It’s a much scarcer commodity, which is great.
Only at the highest level of crown authority can one enforce laws forbidding the vassals of their realm from declaring internal and external wars.
There are also centralisation laws, title revocation laws, administrative laws, and vassal obligation laws for leaning more towards tax’s or levies, and laws for how harsh the obligations are, and for every type of vassal, as opposed to ck3’s tedious contract micro management. NIGHT . AND . DAY
Factions
This then brings me to factions, ck2 vanilla factions are already challenging enough, but hip takes it even further. There will always be a set of factions present no matter what, including the glory, prosperity, tradition and court factions. These will never disappear and it’s your job as the ruler to constantly appease them.
Their satisfactions change depending on if their relevant expectations are met and should they not be for a while, and should the faction have enough combined manpower to declare war, they will. On the other hand, appease them and you will gain their approval and some occasional monitory gifts.
Also, lower crown authority factions are a constant thorn in the side, but the good, challenging kind. In ck3 I’ve never seen a lower crown authority faction, in fact, factions as a whole are basically redundant.
Adventurer threats
I’ve had several adventurer dynasty members leave my realm, gather support, build an army, and declare war on me, attempting to claim their alleged birthrights from my character.
This is great for immersion, and in the Muslim world it happened quite a lot, with Al-Hakam I of cordoba infamously executing several Umayyad family members after defeating them in battle, after they did exactly that: left, gathered support, built armies and attempted to take their supposed birthrights. His father Hisham I also had a massive battle against his elder brother Sulayman years before.
This, had NEVER happened to me in ck3, I don’t even know if it’s possible quite frankly. This is with the maximum amount of adventurers being enabled in the game settings. Still crickets…
Mortality
This is much better in hip. And I can’t remember the last time my character lived to 65. In ck3 I regularly reach 80+.
Money sinks
I have yet to play a campaign in hip in which i have more gold than I know what to do with, in contrast with 3, where it happens in every single campaign with zero exceptions.
In hip there’s always things to spend gold on, and great works are a great feature and likewise a great money sink for when you’re very wealthy. Hospitals are an unmatched money sink too. Also in hip I can be charitable and give a specific amount of money to the ai, if I occasionally do end up reaching the point where I have excess gold.
Focus’ vs lifestyle trees:
Focus’ are infinitely superior to lifestyle trees. Once again we have the problem of a ridiculously op mechanic that the player easily takes advantage of, while the ai doesn’t. The results of lifestyle trees are totally busted.
An example of this is taking the stewardship tree with a ruler, maxing out every tree in your sleep, even if stewardship wasn’t what your education was based on, and then when that ruler dies the realm income plummets almost 60 or 70% at times. Like how did the dude magically gain all that income per month by clicking a button, can we see what he put in place to achieve that?
Either all the infrastructure that ruler put in place (which we don’t see) all magically and totally collapsed upon his death, or the trees are just stupidly op.
Focus’ are great, provide some minor bonuses and the ai gets all the same bonuses as the player. They give nice, short and sweet flavour events connected to them, that’s it.
Bloodlines vs legacies
I prefer bloodlines as a MENA player, as it actually helps the ai. For me matrilineal marriages, which is how many bloodlines get passed down, are disabled by Islam, but the non Islamic ai have it available, contrast this with where the player is always maxing out multiple legacy’s in ck3 while the ai struggles to to get a single legacy lmao. Again, it’s night and day.
Ambitions vs oaths
Oaths (and the coronation event in general) are a disaster, I’m already sick of the activity. Ambitions are great, hip has what feels like a million options to choose from, from getting married, to raising an heir, to accumulating wealth, winning a war etc, and you get a nice non-op reward when completing then, as it should be.
Immersion and every culture and religion feeling diverse/flavourization
As a predominantly MENA player in both games, I was surprised. For the longest time I’ve been begging for a bay’ah (pledge of allegiance) Friday sermon mechanic for ck3, but when I was back on hip it hit me, I was asking for those mechanics because I thought that’s what the game needed, in reality it’s because of how shallow the game is thus I thought more mechanics would solve the problem but really it would just paper over the cracks.
Ck3 has 2 major struggles, both of which include Muslim realms, yet playing as a Muslim is still un immersive even with the major mods like rice and Muslim enhancements enabled.
In Hip the Muslim world still feels alive. The hajj and ramadan events are once again short and sweet and each time there is a new Hadith mentioned im during the hajj pilgrammige.
I also received a spontaneous event about the Hadith prophecy of a great Muslim general conquering Constantinople and if my character could be the one.
They also get little things correct that many won’t notice, for example Yusuf Ibn Tashfin the Almoravid ruler refusing to take the caliphal “Ameer Al mu’mineen” title in real life, instead being granted the lesser “Ameer Al muslimeen” by the caliph in Baghdad, showing Yusufs awe and admiration of the caliphal institution, and pledging allegiance to it, yet still being independant in reality. He has the “Ameer Al muslimeen” title in hip. Another cool thing is the Almoravid ruler wearing a face veil when leading a battle. Truly so immersive.
Also, hip adds even more flavourful events to different cultures that the already adequate ck2 vanilla already has. It really makes you feel like you’re playing in that part of the world.
And these sorts of things are great for role play. Rp happens in the mind, you need just a little stimulation to get you going and then you can start to create diffident scenarios in your head.
I don’t need a bunch of paragraphs telling me exactly what is what, that’s not conducive to role play at all.
Side note, while I don’t play there often, catholic, viking and Byzantine play is also phenomenally flavourflul and diverse in hip. Just so good. The church mechanics are great, the imperial mechanics are great, pagan reformation mechanics are great. Another win for hip.
Start dates
Ck2/hip has an incredible feature in which you can start in any year from 1066 onwards. Vanilla has an interesting 769, and hip has 1204. Add to this 936 and 867 and there’s a clear winner.
I didn’t even mention society’s, which are a great little feature and mostly sit in the background.
In closing, there are so many fundamental flaws almost 6 years into ck3. Until core mechanics are totally revamped and overhauled, I will not buy another ck3 dlc or return to the game in general. It’s just not good enough from the new paradox.
Edit: Spelling errors.