r/CriticalThinking101 • • Mar 18 '20

Einstein's Idea of Time is Wrong: Time Contraction

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Aug 23 '20

Your thinking is more biased than you think it is! Click to know more

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Sep 05 '20

Help me with logic and critical thinking assignment

1 Upvotes

The director of the International Health Foundation recently released this announcement:

“A new medical test that allows the early detection of a particular disease will prevent the deaths of people all over the world who would otherwise die from the disease. The test has been extremely effective in allowing doctors to diagnose the disease six months to a year before it would have been spotted by conventional means. As soon as we can institute this test as a routine procedure in hospitals around the world, the death rate from this disease will plummet."

a)       Write down the CONCLUSION of the above argument.

b)       What are the PREMISES of the above argument.

c)       What are the ASSUMPTIONS in the above argument.

d)      What are the fallacies in the above argument? (mention at least three)

e)      Suggest how the above arguments could have been strengthened or improved.

Really confused with part c and d.


r/CriticalThinking101 • • Jun 03 '15

Hans Rosling and Ola Rosling: How not to be ignorant about the world

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Aug 23 '22

Traditional vs Progressive Lifestyles

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Oct 12 '20

The problem with…words. Understanding Atheism

3 Upvotes

I’ve mentioned that TLOB will promote or champion certain themes that we feel are important to our followers and to society at large. The first theme I want to highlight is….Critical Thinking.

In due course TLOB will produce a series of articles and videos on multiple topics but all will have the theme of Critical Thinking at its foundation.

For example.

Today’s article and the video to follow, will be on the subject of Understanding Atheism. It will NOT be a promotion or a critique of either Atheism or Theism, it will simply be an explanation of common misunderstandings surrounding the use of these words and hopefully allow us to think more critically about the way we use words and question if the way we use them is in fact rational.

So, let’s start by understand some definitions?

If you do this by assuming that all you have to do is read your preferred dictionary to understand what a word means, then you’ve just fallen at the first hurdle.

Sadly, many people believe that dictionaries are some form of arbiter about what a word should mean.

Everyone who believes this should memorise this phrase…

“Dictionaries are descriptive NOT prescriptive”

In short, dictionaries tell you how people currently USE a word, not what it SHOULD mean.

This is why dictionaries are constantly updated. The way we use words not only changes but each word can have multiple usages at any one time.

What you should do when discussing a subject with anyone is, understand how they are using a word, then let them know what you mean when you use a word. If the usages differ, then agree to discuss the concepts attached to each usage so you both know what the other is talking about.

Now, let’s look at Atheism.

Should we examine the usages of Atheism?

Well, in this case, since “A”-“Theism” is in fact a noun, formed by adding the “A” at the start of another noun to indicate “without theism”, then it makes sense to look at the root noun first.

So let’s start by looking the usages of Theism. (Source: dictionary.com)

Noun:

  1. The belief in one God as the creator and ruler of the Universe

  2. Belief in the existence of a god or gods

Looking at these usages it can be inferred that anyone who fits usage 1 will automatically be covered by usage 2. 1 is therefore a subset of 2.

Now let’s look at the usages of Atheism.

Noun:

  1. The doctrine or belief that there is no God.

  2. Disbelief in the existence of a supreme being or beings.

Once again, Looking at these usages it can be inferred that anyone who fits usage 1 will automatically be covered by usage 2. 1 is therefore a subset of 2.

Now, for simplicity’s sake, for both words, let’s continue with the usage described in number 2 as it clearly encapsulate both usages.

So, regarding the question “Do you believe God exists?”

Well, ignoring all the rabbit holes we could go down with reference to the words “God” or “exist”, the question clearly pertains to a persons BELIEF.

And, this is where most people go off the rails. How?

By failing to recognise that belief is binary.

For any one claim, you either do believe it or you don’t. There is no middle ground.

“But” I hear you say, “why can’t I just say that I don’t know?"

Well, that’s because you’re not answering the question. The question is about what you believe and saying, “I don’t know” is telling us about your knowledge.

We are now of course introducing Gnosticism and Agnosticism and we are all familiar with the use of Agnosticism as the cop out, mythical position of neither believing nor not believing.

Let me demonstrate why this position is impossible with the flip of a coin:

Coin flipper: Do you believe it’s heads?

Observer: I don’t know

Coin flipper: I know you don’t know but I’m asking you what you believe. Do you believe it’s heads?

Observer: Until I see the coin, I can’t believe it’s heads

Coin flipper: So, you DON’T believe it’s heads

Observer: No, but I don’t believe it’s tails either

Coin flipper: Thant’s fine, as not believing either until there is evidence either way is the logical, default position!

So, let’s assume that we all accept that belief is binary.

Anxiety levels usually rocket at this point as many people realise they can’t cop out by claiming the neutral position of agnosticism, and therefore feel they are being forced to say... “I do not believe God exists”.

But, what they fail to understand is they are incorrectly equating this statement with, “I believe God does not exist.”

I’ll say that again in case you missed it:

“I do not believe God exists,” is NOT the same as saying, “I believe God does not exist.”

To demonstrate, let’s look at the claims about God.

The question asked was A) “Do you believe God exists?”

Your answer can either be

  1. Yes…I believe God exists

OR

2) No…I do not believe God exists

But, we could also have asked B) “Do you believe God does not exist?”

Your answer can either be

  1. Yes…I believe God does not exist

OR

2) No…I do not believe God does not exist (Note: that’s a double negative)

This therefore means…

A Theist answering question A) would say, 1) Yes…I believe God exists

Therefore, on answering question B) they would say, 2) No…I do not believe God does not exist

So, an Atheist answering question A) would say 2) No…I do not believe God exists

However, on answering question B) they could say 1) Yes…I believe God does not exist (See the Red circle in the Venn diagram attached)

BUT, they could just as correctly answer 2) No…I do not believe God does not exist

In short, an Atheist can lack a belief in either proposition. Why? Because it’s the same situation as being an observer of a coin flip. As long as there’s a hand on top of the coin you are justified in not believing the coin is heads AND simultaneously, not believing the coin is tails.

The trick is to remember that we are talking about what you believe and not what you know.

So let’s review this by introducing a Venn diagram (attached to post).

The outer circle is all the people on the planet.

The Blue circle is all the Theists on the planet - anyone who believes there is a God or Gods.

Therefore the Yellow area & Red circle are all the Atheist - anyone who doesn’t believe there is a God or Gods.

The Red circle is those that believe there is no God or Gods - These people are Atheists they just add a claim (There is no God or Gods) to their disbelief in a God or Gods.

Let me know your comments and questions


r/CriticalThinking101 • • Mar 08 '22

What type of logic am I using here? Is there a better way to think? My theory on how to "take over" a government.

3 Upvotes

Why have a coup d'etat? When you can infiltrate an organization?

Let me know if I'm in the wrong subrreddit.

Coups tend to be bloody and super risky. And it is my understanding that they normally fail and you kind of need to "infiltrate" an organization too. What's a coup without a top general? yah know.

Is infiltrating an organization really that hard? Puppets leaders.

Why were we unable to infiltrate the Taliban? Did we hand pick the new Taliban leader? My understanding is that he is more moderate that other options.

Also, in an organized religion-the only way to really control the future of the church is internally. No external threat can really take it down.. Just the way religion is sometimes.

Infiltrating takes a longggggg time, patience, and the original mission is probably never followed through. Coups are deadly and risky.

What are some external groups that influence an organization? Lets do a thought experiment.

Lets think about the Republican party. You got the Christian conservatives, libertarians, neoconservatives, and the moderates. These factions are super hard to control because it's largely democrats in that the platform is built in the image of the mind's of the individuals.

But... what about special interest groups and bribes??

The Koch's special interest groups, The Royal Family, the Rothschilds, the Russian Oligarchs. These powers are the ones that can work behind the scenes and can really alter an organization.

So, if you are a spy agency then this is the best way of altering an organization. So, if you can control people in power, then you can control the organization. Unless, that puppet turns on you lol.

My thinking is why didn't we do this with the Taliban? Why weren't we able to get inside the inner circle?

And then the Catholic church. Why can't certain people get into the inner circle?

I would assume it's because it's hard to build alliances with the inner circle, unless you have something to offer. Thats where convincing and bribing comes into play.

If you are convincing an immoral greedy inner circle person, then they will respond to cash or promises of power.

If you are convincing a moral man, then the only way to really convince him is via logic.

I would assume that the Taliban comprises of "moral" people who REALLY believe in what they are doing.

That leads to my question. Was a high-ranking leader of the Taliban convinced? In order to convince someone you would probably need extensive time talking to them-AKA prison.

Abdul Ghani Baradar was second in command in the Taliban I believe. He was in prison in Pakistan for many years. I don't know if he talked to U.S. agents.

Now. How does one convince Abdul Ghani Baradar to become a "puppet"? He is probably "moral man" that sincerely believes in his beliefs. Two options that I can think of:

  1. Brainwash him

  2. Deprogramming him

Brainwashing would probably only yield short term results and you probably need a very tight leash in order to do this.

I think deprogramming is better because this yields long term results. And in order to do this you would need a deprogramming expert that would be a good fit. In the end, only Abdul Ghani Baradar can "figure out" he was wrong or he can "double down" on his Taliban beliefs.

Let me know what you think.


r/CriticalThinking101 • • May 04 '16

5 tips to improve your critical thinking - Samantha Agoos

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Oct 13 '15

Infographic: 20 Cognitive Biases

Thumbnail
highexistence.com
5 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 28 '15

Anecdotal evidence reliable? One man says "yes."

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Dec 22 '21

It’s a hard life

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 20 '15

A good way to get subs to this place would be to post /r/CriticalThinking101 sarcastically after someone posts something niave.

13 Upvotes

Is this too brazen? I feel like it might be.


r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 20 '15

Qualia Soup - Open-mindedness

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 25 '15

Thinking Critically - The University of British Columbia

Thumbnail
learningcommons.ubc.ca
6 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 19 '15

An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments

Thumbnail
bookofbadarguments.com
8 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 20 '15

How about a recommended reading list for the side bar?

14 Upvotes

I'm thinking of good reads that specifically address critical thinking skills at a beginners level. So I might leave things like Shermer's The Believing Brain, or Grayling's Down among The Dead Cities out for being too specific or advanced.

Let me start the ball rolling with;

The Demon Haunted World by Carl Sagan


r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 23 '15

Critical Thinking: a 23-part animated series funded by the University of Utah

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 23 '15

Cognitive biases. How to not be stupid

Thumbnail
bbc.com
4 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 20 '15

Qualia Soup - Critical Thinking

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 19 '15

Less Wrong: a powerful community dedicated to refining and promoting the art of rationality

Thumbnail
lesswrong.com
9 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 20 '15

List of cognitive biases

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
8 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 21 '15

Critical Thinking - In depth animated course

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 20 '15

A List of Fallacies

Thumbnail
pzxc.com
10 Upvotes

r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 20 '15

"Term of Art"

8 Upvotes

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Term_of_art

I hear the likes of Deepak Chopra misusing the "terms of art"/nomenclature(s) of science in order to impress audiences. Judging by pseudo-science book sales, events and media appearances it works.

Who needs humility and "we don't know yet"s, when conartists are jumbling together words like "quantum", "consciousness", etc. to sound like the answers are simply too complex for the layperson to comprehend?


r/CriticalThinking101 • • Apr 24 '15

What's it called when someone ignores most of an argument and fixates on a single point.

4 Upvotes

For example, if A were to say, "On its best day, <movement> was a huge overreaction to a non-issue surrounded by a cloud of misogynistic troglodytes" and B's response was, "<movement> isn't misogynistic and here's why...." what rhetorical or logical antipattern is B engaged in?