Warning, long post ahead! TLDR; Replace the sliders with a variety of tactical instructions that mimic real-life cricket tactics.
***
Another suggestion I have for improving bowling and batting tactics/immersion is to make them more reflective of real life bowling tactics. Of course, this all depends on what is possible with your game engine. The core idea is that rather than just having sliders ranging from defensive to attacking, introduce more specific tactical instructions that reflect real cricket. This is inspired by how newer version of Football Manager have tactical instructions that you select from, instead of a long set of sliders.
In Cricket Team Manager for example, you could have the following bowling and batting tactics to select from. Each would have different pros/cons depending on players skills and pitch conditions – I've tried to give some examples of this below, but these lists could easily be extended to create more tactical flexibility. Ideally a manager could also issue these as instructions on the team sheets before the match starts, informed by team selection and the strengths/weaknesses of individual players.
Fast Bowling
Reverse Swing: Uses late movement in the air, generally targeting the stumps with inswinging or outswinging deliveries. Highly effective with an older ball and in dry conditions, but requires specialist bowlers with excellent control and reverse-swing ability. Ineffective with a newer ball and on wickets that have not deteriorated.
Off-Stump Channel: Classic test match line for an opening fast bowler. Increases the chance of slips catches, particularly against more aggressive batting with a newer ball. Weakens in effectiveness as the ball gets older, and if the ball isn’t swinging. Think the sort of Test match lines Josh Hazelwood and Pat Cummins bowl.
Around the Wicket: A tactic for right-arm fast bowlers bowling around the wicket to right-handed batsmen (or vice versa), creating an awkward angle across the batsman and encouraging edges or mistakes outside off stump. Particularly effective against batsmen uncomfortable with the angle, but can become predictable. Real-life example: Mitchell Johnson's bowling around the wicket to England's right-handers during the 2013–14 Ashes series.
Leg-Side Trap: Targets the batsman's body and leg stump, with a packed leg-side field designed to induce a mistimed pull, hook or glance. Can be highly effective against aggressive batsmen but risks conceding easy singles and leg-side boundaries if the bowling lacks accuracy. Real-life example: England's Bodyline tactics against Don Bradman and Australia during the 1932–33 Ashes series.
Classic Swing Bowling: Focuses on generating conventional swing through the air, generally targeting the corridor outside off stump or swinging the ball into the pads. Particularly effective with a newer ball and in overcast or humid conditions, but loses effectiveness as the ball deteriorates.
Wobble Seam: Uses an unstable seam position to generate unpredictable movement off the pitch, making it difficult for batsmen to judge whether the ball will move away or come back in. Particularly effective on pitches offering seam movement, but requires high technical skill and control. Real-life example: Pat Cummins and Josh Hazlewood's use of wobble-seam deliveries during Australia's 2025/26 Ashes campaign.
Wide Outside Off: Bowls a consistent line outside the batsman's hitting arc, often with a packed off-side field and deep cover protection. Designed to frustrate aggressive batsmen and restrict scoring opportunities, particularly in limited-overs cricket, but can concede wides or allow batsmen to leave deliveries in Test cricket. Real-life example: Australia's bowling plans against India's middle order during the 2023 ODI World Cup final, restricting scoring opportunities through disciplined lines and fields.
Change of Pace: Uses a combination of slower balls, cutters and changes in trajectory to disrupt the batsman's timing. Particularly effective against aggressive batsmen in limited-overs cricket, but requires good disguise and execution to avoid being dispatched. Real-life example: Dwayne Bravo's extensive use of slower balls and cutters during the West Indies' successful 2012 and 2016 T20 World Cup campaigns.
Spin Bowling
Flight and Deception: Deliberately tosses the ball higher and slower, using flight, dip and drift to tempt batsmen into attacking shots. Increases the chance of mistimed shots and catches to close fielders, but can be vulnerable to aggressive batsmen who use their feet. Real-life example: Shane Warne's famous dismissal of Mike Gatting in the 1993 Ashes. Requires bowlers with high accuracy and high turn.
Attack the Pads: Bowls a consistent line at the stumps and pads, looking to exploit the possibility of LBWs, bowled dismissals and bat-pad catches. Particularly effective against batsmen who struggle to play spin off the back foot, but can be vulnerable to sweep shots. Real-life example: Ashwin and Jadeja running through touring teams in the sub-continent.
Outside Leg – Leg-Side Trap: Bowls around the wicket, targeting a line outside leg stump with a packed leg-side field and close catchers. Encourages batsmen to play across the line and creates opportunities for catches and bat-pad dismissals. Particularly effective against right-handed batsmen, but can be vulnerable to sweeping and paddling. Real-life example: Australia's use of Nathan Lyon around the wicket to left-handed batsmen, particularly targeting the rough outside their leg stump.
Defensive Off-Side: Bowls a consistent line outside off stump with a packed off-side ring, encouraging batsmen to take risks to score. Designed to build pressure and restrict scoring rather than generate immediate wicket-taking opportunities.
Quicker and Flatter: Uses faster, flatter deliveries with subtle variations in pace and trajectory, making it difficult for batsmen to get forward or use their feet. Effective on slower pitches and in limited-overs cricket, but reduces the opportunity to generate turn and deception through flight. Real-life example: Sunil Narine's bowling for Kolkata Knight Riders during the IPL, where his flatter trajectory and variations made him exceptionally difficult to score against.
Batting – Defensive/Attacking
Rotate the Strike: Prioritises singles and twos, favouring shots into gaps and working the ball around the ground rather than attempting boundaries. Reduces dot balls and builds partnerships but generally limits the scoring rate. Real-life example: Michael Bevan's finishing role for Australia in ODI cricket, particularly his ability to accumulate singles and twos under pressure.
Find the Boundary: Looks to score boundaries through conventional ground strokes, targeting gaps and exploiting loose deliveries. Increases four-hitting opportunities without necessarily increasing aerial shots, but risks edges and mistimed strokes when attempting to force the ball. Real-life example: Virat Kohli's ODI batting, particularly his ability to find boundaries through gaps rather than relying on sixes.
Go Aerial: Prioritises lofted shots, clearing the infield and targeting boundaries. Increases the likelihood of sixes and attacking scoring but also significantly increases the risk of catches. Particularly useful in limited-overs cricket when trying to accelerate. Real-life example: Glenn Maxwell's aerial hitting during Australia's 2023 ODI World Cup campaign.
Work the Ball Around: Focuses on nudges, deflections, flicks and placement into unprotected areas, particularly square of the wicket. Useful against defensive fields and to maintain momentum, but offers relatively few boundary opportunities.
Leave and Defend: Prioritises playing straight, defending good deliveries and leaving balls outside off stump. Reduces dismissal risk and helps see off challenging bowling spells, but results in a low scoring rate.
Batting – Situational
These could be selected in combination with any of the above batting tactics.
Attack the Spin: Looks to disrupt spin bowlers through aggressive footwork, sweeps, reverse sweeps and lofted shots. Can put spinners under pressure and force changes to their line and length, but increases the risk of LBW, bowled and caught dismissals.
Attack the Pace: Looks to dominate fast bowlers through aggressive drives, pulls, hooks and cuts. Particularly effective against predictable or short-pitched bowling, but increases the risk of edges and mistimed shots against high-quality pace.
Target a Particular Bowler: Identifies a specific bowler as the preferred scoring target, taking greater risks against them while playing conservatively against others. Can exploit weaker bowlers or disrupt a bowling rotation, but risks losing a wicket against a bowler who has the upper hand.