r/CrackedColdCases • • Nov 14 '18

Case Reviewed & Summarized My brothers’ 12 year old murder case finally solved

505 Upvotes

Just found this sub and thought I would share my story. My brother, Joseph Douglas, was murdered in 2006 and his decaying body was found by a hunter off a county road in a nearby town. The cause of death was found to be a point blank gunshot wound to the back of the head inflicted by a shotgun. It’s crazy that I am now the age he was when he died (20). He left behind two young kids, siblings, and parents who all loved him. I honestly think that we never expected justice or closure for this crime. However, shortly after starting my freshman year of college in late 2017, a breakthrough confession came in and we can now finally put a name and a face to this. It has definitely been bittersweet, as this person turned out to be his roommate/close friend who even attended his funeral and was around throughout my childhood. I was able to attend a court hearing and go through my brother’s entire case file, including crime scene photos, which in a weird way gave me more closure about it all. I’m rambling now, but I guess I just wanted to put this out there to share the story and spread the thought that a case can always be solved, even when all hope seems lost. article after confession/more info

Old photo of us right after the birth of his son. Me, Joe, and my nephew


r/CrackedColdCases • • Nov 30 '22

Baby Doe IDENTIFIED "The Boy in the Box", also known as "America's Unknown Child", has finally been IDENTIFIED after 65 years

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
415 Upvotes

r/CrackedColdCases • • Jun 16 '20

ARREST Alissa Turney's stepfather charged 19 years after Arizona teen went mysteriously missing from school in 2001

405 Upvotes

Michael Turney was long believed to have been behind Alissa's disappearance, but he was charged only this week.

https://meaww.com/19-years-after-alissa-turney-disappeared-police-set-to-charge-her-stepfather


r/CrackedColdCases • • Jul 05 '22

SUSPECT Identified My sister Michelle Koski's 32 year old cold case solved using genealogy records for a DNA match.

371 Upvotes

My sisters 32 year old cold case was recently solved. I was about 12 when it happened, which makes me 44 now. I saw that it was posted here, on youtube, and elsewhere. Some outlets did not show the face of Robert A Brooks, while others did, and a couple other details that were left out, but were generally available at other news outlets. I had a few hours left and put together a video, but wasn't able to get it online until I had returned back home. I put it on instagram (jsk_78) and youtube (links are below) but it is mostly what people had seen on the news with a couple other things.

Michelle Koski 32 year old cold case solved

https://www.instagram.com/p/CfosPRmLeG4/ (picture of my father holding Michelle in 1973)

https://www.instagram.com/p/Cfn1AF1pyqi/

Twitter put up a sensitivity warning on my account, so I guess nobody can really see anything there and I gave up.

Some of the news outlets did not show the picture of the killer, Robert A. Brooks, who passed away in his late 40s of alcoholism in 2016. The odds of the testing methods used gave a 1.2 quadrillion chance of it not being this person, which was enough to close out the cold case.

Michelle Koski's father, my dad, passed away in 2001 not ever getting the answers he had been searching for. The last thing he ever said was "Bart", nobody really understood what this meant. Bart, also known as Rick Bart, was the Snohomish County Detective working with my father to try and identify the suspect in 2001. My father Stephen Koski had been very active in trying to solve the case, even going as far as looking at satellite imagery back then, and a website called Dignity Of Victims Everywhere (DOVE).

Brooks wasn't on anyone's radar, his records were sealed due to being a juvenile, which had protected him his entire living life from being identified and caught.

I had hope to say a few words at the conference in Seattle, but it did not work out that way to anyone's fault. Not many knew I would be there, I arrived Thursday morning from Hawaii, ended up sleeping at the airport for a few hours, and then headed out after some travel delays.

Thank you for everyone who showed up, and those who saw and read the story online. It was really very hard for me to believe this day would ever come, and I still have a hard time believing this really happened after 32 years.


r/CrackedColdCases • • Dec 19 '19

John Doe IDENTIFIED 'It came as a total shock': Remains found in 1998 identified as 10-year-old boy, family had no idea he and his mother were dead

359 Upvotes

In 1998, a lawn-maintenance crew made a disturbing discovery near I-85 in Mebane. Under a billboard on Industrial Drive were the remains of a child.

For nearly 20 years, the identity of the young murder victim remained a mystery despite dogged efforts by the Orange County Sheriff's Office to solve the crime.

Now, with modern DNA technology, the case has finally been cracked, bringing long-awaited answers.

"With technology what it is today, crimes that have gone unsolved before are now ripe for resolution," Orange County Sheriff Charles Blackwood said.

Blackwood announced Tuesday morning that the young victim was Robert "Bobby" Adam Whitt. He was 10 years old.

It all started Sept. 25, 1998, when a tractor operator noticed a skull at the edge of a wood line. Authorities were called.

Orange County deputies responded and discovered the decomposed human remains. No matches were found in national computer databases of missing children and media attention generated few leads during the next couple of decades.

"I always kept the case-file box under my desk, where it was purposefully in my way," said Maj. Tim Horne, an Orange County investigator who worked the case from the day the boy's remains were found. "Every time I turned, it hit my leg. I did this so the little boy couldn't be forgotten."

Early in the investigation, Dr. Douglas Ubelaker of the Smithsonian prepared a rendering of the boy. Later, forensic sculptor Frank Bender, who had been featured on the TV show "America's Most Wanted," created a bust of the child.

Despite the creative efforts, no one was able to identify the victim.

In more recent years, improved DNA technology was applied to the case. The Orange County Sheriff's Office worked collaboratively with the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children and the North Carolina Medical Examiner's Office. Ancestry DNA provided information that the boy was first-generation biracial Caucasian and Asian.

Then came a major breakthrough. Dr. Barbara Rae-Venter, a genetic genealogy consultant credited with helping authorities solve the Golden State Killer case, reviewed the DNA findings, leading to the identification of a probable close relative of the child's.

With that information, detectives contacted various members of the child's genetic family tree. At 1:44 p.m., on Dec. 26, 2018, a member of Bobby's immediate family got in touch after investigators left a voice mail. The relative provided the sheriff's office with the child's name and important details related to the case.

For the first time, detectives knew the slain child was Bobby Whitt, who had been born Jan. 7, 1988, in Michigan, and had been raised in Ohio.

"This case is an example of dogged determination of investigators who refused to give up," Sheriff Blackwood said. "The efforts of Maj. Tim Horne and the entire investigation division were exemplary."

After speaking to Bobby's family, detectives suspected that Bobby's mother had also been killed about the same time.

Bobby's family members said their brother told them Bobby's mother left for Korea, taking Bobby with her. That's the story they'd lived with for two decades.

However, with the help of the NC Medical Examiner's Office, investigators found there was an unidentified female victim matching details of Bobby's mother in Spartanburg County, South Carolina.

DNA tests confirmed the two bodies belonged to Bobby and Myong Hwa.

The suspect is the boy's father. He's in jail and has been since the 1990s on an unrelated federal charge.

According to the Spartanburg County Sheriff's Office, he confessed to the murder of both victims within several months of each other in 1998.

"It appears neither this county nor Orange County are the location of either homicide from 20 years ago," the sheriff's office said in a release, so the suspect's identity is not being released "until the jurisdictional question can be answered."

Sheriff Blackwood credited Horne's relentless effort, as well as rapidly advancing science for helping clear the mystery and deliver justice for all involved.

"It speaks a lot to the fact that, you know, you may have committed a crime, you may think you've gotten away with it...and if you're out there, and you think you have," Blackwood said, "Time's probably getting close to being up."

Text from this article.

Wikipedia


r/CrackedColdCases • • Aug 07 '19

Jane Doe IDENTIFIED Nearly 40 years ago, a Murdered Woman know as "Orange Socks" in 1979 was discovered in Georgetown, TX. She has Been Identified as 23yr old Debra Jackson

289 Upvotes

On Halloween 1979, a womans murdered body was discovered in a concrete culvert in Georgetown, TX. She had been strangled and was completely nude except for an orange sock on each foot. Williamson County Texas Sheriff announced today that she has been identified as 23yr old Debra Jackson.

Killer Henry Lee Lucas confessed to her murder. He was sentenced to death. He later recanted. His sentence was commuted to Life in prison, primarily because his story couldn't be collaborated. LE stated the DNA of two men had been found under her fingernails.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.statesman.com/news/20190807/breaking-40-years-after-her-death-debra-jackson-of-abilene-identified-as-orange-socks%3ftemplate=ampart


r/CrackedColdCases • • Jan 20 '20

ARREST Suspected ‘Pillowcase Rapist’ who terrorized South Florida women in early 1980s has been arrested

284 Upvotes

Authorities have arrested a man they believe is the notorious “Pillowcase Rapist,” who was blamed for attacking over 40 women in South Florida during the early 1980s.

Law-enforcement sources identified the suspect as 60-year-old Robert Eugene Koehler, a registered sex offender from Palm Bay. He was arrested on Saturday and is being held at a jail in Brevard County to await transfer to Miami-Dade.

The Pillowcase Rapist terrorized women from South Miami to Deerfield Beach between May 1981 and February 1986. Using a pillowcase, towel or shirt to hide his identity, the rapist broke into town homes and apartments and attacked at least 44 women.

But for years, detectives could not identify the Pillowcase Rapist, despite a large-scale manhunt. Detectives conducted stakeouts, checked hundreds of leads, passed out fliers and even created a sculpture from one victim who saw his face.

Investigators also explored the possibility that the attacks may have been committed by more than one rapist. The task force created to find the attacker was ultimately disbanded in 1987.

At the time, police detectives said the rapist was likely young, athletic and white and with no discernible accent. From lab tests, they concluded his blood type was O, but with a rare subgrouping characteristic found in 1 percent of the population. They also knew he wore a size 10 1/2 shoe.

Among his victims were a schoolteacher, nurse, airline flight attendant, artist, model, health spa instructor, insurance executive, publicist and student. All but one lived in townhouses or apartments. He usually entered their homes through unlocked sliding glass doors and open windows, threatening them with a knife, assaulting them quickly and sometimes stealing cash.

Details of what led police to Koehler remained unknown Monday. The case was investigated by Miami-Dade police, the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Koehler would have been in his early 20s during the sex-attack spree. FDLE lists him as a registered sex offender for a sexual battery conviction in 1991 in Palm Beach County.

---

Source:

Miami Herald - Miami's 'Pillowcase Rapist' from 1980s arrested, cops say

Other links:

NBC Miami - Alleged South Florida ‘Pillowcase Rapist’ Accused of Attacking Dozens of Women Arrested

New York Post - Suspected ‘Pillowcase Rapist’ who terrorized women in the 1980s arrested

Heavy.com - Robert Koehler Accused of Being ‘Pillowcase Rapist’


r/CrackedColdCases • • Dec 08 '22

Baby Doe IDENTIFIED "The Boy in the Box" identified as Joseph Augustus Zarelli after 66 years

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
281 Upvotes

r/CrackedColdCases • • Jan 30 '20

Jane Doe IDENTIFIED "LIME LADY" Identified after 40yrs. Tamara Lee Tigard

256 Upvotes

She was an Army Veteran. In March of 1980, Tamara went for a walk near her Las Vegas home and simply vanished. She was found on April, 18th, 1980. Her 21st birthday.

LE believe she was dead for approximately 10 days. What happened between March and April 18th? Las Vegas to Jones, OK is 1,135 miles.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/kfor.com/2020/01/30/breaking-officials-identify-oklahomas-lime-lady-at-heart-of-40-year-old-cold-case/amp/

Update: Tamara married C. Carr (don't want to identify him on here) on 24 February 1979. Clark County, NV.

He does have an extensive criminal record dating back to the 80s. He lives in TN. He's 61yrs old.

You can find her husband's complete information on Find a Grave

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/206671416/tamara-lee-tigard


r/CrackedColdCases • • Mar 06 '20

UPDATE **UPDATE** Formerly known as "Racine County Jane Doe" Peggy Lynn Johnson-Schroeder was laid to rest next to her mother and grandparents in Belvidere, IL

254 Upvotes

Peggy Lynn Johnson-Schroeder was peacefully laid to rest on Wednesday, 4 Mar 2020 next to her mother and grandparents in Belvidere, IL. Many LE personnel and locals attended the solemn ceremony.

Her killer is awaiting trial in IL.

https://www.wifr.com/content/news/1999-Jane-Doe-laid-to--568502621.html


r/CrackedColdCases • • Feb 07 '20

ARREST 40yr Old Cold Case Solved. The Murder of 18yr old Michelle Martinko, Cedar Rapids, IA

254 Upvotes

Jerry Burns, 64yrs, arrested on Wednesday, 19 December 2019. He is accused of stabbing. Michelle Martinko, 18yrs, a Kennedy High School Senior.

Martinko, after choir practice, headed to the Westdale Mall on the southwest side of Cedar Rapids, which had opened less than two weeks prior. She had $180 on her, and was shopping for a new winter coat. She asked her close friend and fellow twirler Jane Hansen if she’d like to join, but Hansen declined; she had some homework to catch up on.

"Michelle had been wearing a rabbit fur coat,” Sue said, “and there was bloody rabbit hair all over the car. They found Michelle lying on her back, slumped over the passenger seat of the Buick, and leaning against the car door.”

https://littlevillagemag.com/michelle-martinko-murder-trial/


r/CrackedColdCases • • Dec 16 '19

SUSPECT Identified DNA Used to Solve Decades-Old Cold Case Murder of 11-Year-Old Julie Fuller. The murderer died in 2004

246 Upvotes

Fort Worth police say they've solved the decades-old cold case murder of an 11-year-old girl using DNA phenotyping.

On June 27, 1983, Julie Fuller was reported missing after she'd gone to take out the trash at the Kensington Motel in Arlington.

Fuller and her family had only recently arrived in North Texas, having moved to the United States from England.

Fort Worth police say they've solved the decades-old cold case murder of an 11-year-old girl using DNA phenotyping.

On June 27, 1983, Julie Fuller was reported missing after she'd gone to take out the trash at the Kensington Motel in Arlington.

Fuller and her family had only recently arrived in North Texas, having moved to the United States from England.

"You have an 11-year-old girl who's left in the woods, nude, clearly she had been raped," said homicide Det. Tom O'Brien. "That is going to get your attention."

The investigation turned cold and, until now, the identity of the girl's killer had never been confirmed.

However, using new DNA technology, O'Brien now says he's cracked the case and identified the person they believe took the child's life.

The break began in February 2018 when detectives reached out to Parabon Nanolabs to obtain a Snapshot DNA phenotyping report -- DNA phenotyping, police said, is "the process of predicting physical appearance and ancestry from unidentified DNA evidence."

Using DNA evidence obtained in the Fuller investigation, Snapshot produced trait predictions for the unidentified DNA. By combining those predictions with individual guesses about face shape and eye and skin color, composites were created to show what the girl's killer may have looked like at ages 25, 45 and 65 years of age. Various ages were created since investigators didn't know anything about the girl's killer.

Detectives then sent the DNA to a private genealogy company which matched the evidence with DNA it had on file from a relative of the suspect.

Police contacted the suspect's family, got more samples of their DNA, and positively linked him to the crime.

"No doubt," O'Brien said.

Police said the killer was James Francis McNichols, who died in 2004 in Iowa at the age of 52.

"I would have loved to have had him held responsible for what he did to this little girl," the detective said.

O'Brien now hopes this new technology can solve other old murders.

"The Fort Worth police department has over 1,000 unsolved cold cases," he said. "This technology is going to be utilized for any case we have we're able to use it."

Article found here: https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/dna-used-to-solve-decades-old-cold-case-murder-of-11-year-old-julie-fuller/2273172/


r/CrackedColdCases • • Jan 13 '20

RESOLVED Suspect identified in 1976 rape and murder of 16-year-old Pamela Maurer

243 Upvotes

On Jan. 13, 1976, Pamela Maurer of Woodridge was abducted and murdered, her body found near College Road and Maple Avenue in Lisle.

The investigation into the 16-year-old Downers Grove South student’s death remained unsolved — until now. Based on new DNA evidence used for the first time in Illinois to solve a murder, investigators concluded that she was raped and strangled by Bruce Lindahl.

He died in 1981 after he bled to death while stabbing another victim.  The coroner said his wounds were self inflicted.

Now police say evidence connects Lindahl to several other victims.

Maurer was last seen alive on Jan. 13 around 9:30 p.m. when she left her friends to go purchase a soft drink at a McDonald’s. Her body was discovered the next morning by road workers.

Investigators were able to create a DNA profile based on evidence taken from Maurer’s body in 2001. However, that profile never led to a match in the DNA database. That’s because Lindahl had died long before and had never been convicted.

Last year, more sophisticated DNA profiling was able to create a detailed description of the suspect, including hair and eye color and even facial shapes. The image on the upper right in the photos above is a composite based on the DNA results.

Investigators then created a geneological family tree based on those results and determined the DNA matched Lindahl. The odds of the DNA matching another person was 1 in 1.8 quadrillion. Lindahl lived in the area at the time of Maurer’s murder.

Investigators traveled to Texas to inform Maurer’s father and brother.

Late last year, investigators got a court order to exhume the body obtain the DNA from Lindahl’s remains to build the profile.

Now police believe Lindahl is responsible killing Deborah Colliander. At first Lindahl was charged with raping Colliander, who manged to escape from the attack.  However, two weeks before Lindahl’s trial, Colliander disappeared after leaving her job at a hospital.

Without a witness, the case against Lindahl was dropped.  Her body was found on April 28, 1982  in a field on Oswego Twp. After she disappeared, a friend of Lindahl’s came forward to say Lindahl offered him money and drugs to kill Colliander. The friend was a heavy drinker, never acted on the offer and never told police about it until later.

By that point, Lindahl had already died. He killed himself, police said, after stabbing Waubonsie High School senior Charles Huber 28 times.  The motive for that attack was never determined.

Investigators also think Lindahl may have something to do with the disappearance of Deborah McCall, a student at Downers Grove North.  She was last seen alive in November, 1979. Photos of her were found in one of Lindahl’s residences.

And there may be other victims in the 1970s and before his death, police said. The new evidence will be used to open additional investigations.

Investigators set up two tip lines:   630 407 8107  and 630 271 4252.

—

Source:

CBS Chicago - Police Solve 44-Year-Old Murder Case Of Pamela Maurer Of Woodridge; Bruce Lindahl May Have Killed More Women, Police Say

Other links:

DuPage County State’s Attorney Office Press Release - Murderer Identified in 1976 Murder of Pamela Maurer

Chicago Tribune - Authorities in DuPage County say they know who killed 16-year-old girl in 1976. DNA data led to man who died during commission of another slaying in 1981.


r/CrackedColdCases • • Nov 23 '19

ARREST 39yr old Cold Case Solved. The Murder of 25yr old newlywed Kathleen Doyle in Norfolk, Virginia

243 Upvotes

On August 31, 1980, 25-year old Kathleen (nee O'Brien) Doyle, an aspiring author started a journal. Perhaps a bit self conscious Kathleen wrote, "I will most likely write so that anyone looking over my shoulder would neither raise an eyebrow nor really raise too much interest." Kathleen was writing about her past in order to understand herself and where she fit into the future.

She was living as a Navy wife in Norfolk, Virginia. Kathleen's husband of nine months, Lt. Stephen Doyle, was away at sea on the USS Eisenhower and Kathleen was living with "Ike" their orange tabby in a small framed house on Granby Road. It was in an upper middle class neighborhood and several Navy families lived in the vicinity. It was not a place where violent crime often visited.

Nine days after her first journal entry, Kathleen was found lying on the floor of her bedroom. She'd been beaten, bound and gagged, punched, kicked, stabbed, raped and strangled. It was a brutal overkill.

On Friday November 22d, 2019 her killer Dennis Bowman, 70, was arrested in Michigan based on forensic evidence found at the crime scene.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/fox17online.com/2019/11/22/allegan-county-man-arrested-in-virginia-cold-case-murder/amp/


r/CrackedColdCases • • Jan 26 '20

ARREST Roommate confesses to the 2004 murder of Adam Brundage

242 Upvotes

https://www.inquirer.com/news/daman-smoot-adam-brundage-bucks-county-cold-case-20200121.html

Daman Smoot, 37, has been charged with criminal homicide in the October 4, 2004 death of 26-year-old Adam Brundage.

Smoot is expected to plead guilty to third-degree murder. He is already serving 5 to 10 years in state prison for a 2011 domestic assault in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania.

In 2004, Brundage bought a house in Quakertown, Pennsylvania with money inherited from his father. He met Smoot through mutual friends, and the two became roommates.

When Brundage disappeared that October, Smoot gave the older man’s family and friends conflicting information about his whereabouts. He told some that Brundage had fled to Wisconsin because of a warrant for his arrest, and to others he said Brundage was in drug rehab in West Virginia.

Police in upper Bucks County reopened Brundage’s case in April and “continued to press” Smoot, whom they had considered a suspect all along.

On January 9, Smoot confessed he beat Brundage in the back of the head with a baseball bat on October 4, 2004 as the two argued at the Haines & Kibblehoue Quarry in Chalfont, where Smoot worked as a heavy-equipment operator.

Smoot held his hand over Brundage’s nose and mouth “until he was certain Brundage was dead,” then buried him in a sand berm so deep that investigators suspected he used machinery.

Smoot led investigators to the makeshift grave as part of his plea deal.


r/CrackedColdCases • • Jul 08 '22

ARREST 1982: Anne Pham: Cold case murder of Seaside girl Anne Pham solved; 70-year-old Nevada man arrested

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
234 Upvotes

r/CrackedColdCases • • Jun 05 '19

ARREST Prosecutors charge 61-year-old man with 1993 murder of 9-year-old Angie Housman

Thumbnail
kmov.com
233 Upvotes

r/CrackedColdCases • • May 28 '20

ARREST Ancestral DNA Match Leads to Arrest of Serial Rapist in Connecticut

229 Upvotes

Hartford Courant is reporting an arrest in a string of rapes that began in 2001 allegedly perpetrated by a local fireman.


r/CrackedColdCases • • Feb 26 '21

ARREST Arrest made in 1981 rape and murder of 35-year-old Sylvia Quayle

227 Upvotes

Forty years after a woman was found murdered in her home in Cherry Hills Village, police have arrested a suspect. David Dwayne Anderson, 62, is accused of killing Sylvia Quayle.

Her father found her body the morning of Aug. 4, 1981. She was nude and she had been strangled, stabbed and shot.

She was 35 years old at the time.

Investigators collected and preserved 140 pieces of evidence from the scene.

Two years later, in 1983, investigators using alternate light source testing determined a piece of the area rug near the body contained potential foreign material.

In 1995, the rug was sent to CBI for testing.

In 2000, a male DNA profile was developed.

The identity of that man remained unknown until Jan. 29, 2021 — after the Cherry Hills Police Department teamed up with Mitch Morrissey at United Data Connect to conduct genetic research.

Investigators took sequenced DNA from the scene and uploaded that data to two different general open source websites: Family Tree DNA and GEDmatch.

“We started to then get connected people that were related to the individual that we were looking for,” explained Morrissey.

Morrissey said the “tree” they were looking at had over 3,300 people — and it took a huge amount of effort to narrow that down to one suspect.

“It is extensive background work, we use DNA for that, we use all kinds of newspapers, public records, find out about these people and who they’re related to, and eventually get it down to one suspect,” Morrissey said.

Once they identified David Anderson, they had to test his DNA.

Jan. 18, investigators were able to get a DNA sample from Anderson — by collecting his trash. On a discarded can of Vanilla Coke, they found DNA that matched the DNA found on the area rug.

Anderson was arrested on Feb. 10 in Nebraska and is expected to be returned to Colorado to face charges. Anderson faces two counts of first-degree murder.

One alleges Quayle was killed after deliberation; the other alleges she was killed in the commission of another felony.

Morrissey said he wanted to investigate this case because he wanted justice.

“When I read this case and realize that her father found her, in the condition that I know she was in, the way that she was left, after being brutalized and killed,” Morrissey said in a news conference on Thursday. “I can imagine, as a father myself of a young woman about this age, to have a morning like that.”

“I know he’s not here, and for me that’s part of the hardest part of solving these 40 year old cases, and we’ve solved quite a few of them now, is that some of the people that want answers, they need closure, they don’t get it. Because they’re gone,” Morrissey said.

“I am proud to be able to tell Sylvia’s sister and brother-in-law that the men and women of our department have anticipated the opportunity to make this announcement for almost 40 years,” Cherry Hills Village Police Chief Michelle Tovrea stated.

“My thoughts are with the family, we can only try to understand the deep pain and sense of loss you have experienced,” Tovrea said. “I am pleased there is a path moving forward to seek justice in her death.”

Source


r/CrackedColdCases • • Jul 23 '20

Jane Doe IDENTIFIED Huntington Beach Jane Doe (1968) and her killer have been identified

227 Upvotes

Her throat was slit. She wore a flower print blouse and purple pants. Her body was found in a bean field in Huntington Beach. Her shoes, size 7, offered a clue – they were made in upstate New York.

Teams of cops and young cadets walked side-by-side through the muddy field near the corner of Newland Street and Yorktown Avenue. They found tire tracks and a cigarette butt.

But there was nothing to identify her.

She has been known as “Jane Doe” or by the coroner’s code “68-00745-C.” She was raped, killed and dumped out the passenger’s side of a car.

And now, after 52 years, thanks to some slick genealogical work, both the victim and the alleged killer have been identified.

In June, Huntington Beach detectives, using familial DNA analysis, informed a family in Maine that a missing runaway from 1968 was the answer to the oldest Jane Doe homicide case in Orange County.

The woman was identified as Anita Louise Piteau, whose family tree runs through Augusta and Lewiston, Maine. Police on Wednesday, July 22 said they believe she was killed by a man named Johnny Chrisco, who died at age 71 in 2015. Very little is known about him, said Huntington Beach Police Department public information officer Angela Bennett.

Huntington Beach detectives have known the identity for more than a month but did not make a formal announcement to the public or confirm Piteau’s identity until inquiries from the Southern California News Group this week. Their announcement was slowed because they had been making a video series about the case – the video has been shelved – and to coordinate with Piteau’s family, Bennett said.

In the meantime, the county coroner’s website still listed the Huntington Beach body as an unidentified Jane Doe as of late Wednesday afternoon.

A burial service for Anita Piteau was held this past weekend in Maine and an Orange County law enforcement contingent flew there to participate.

“We got a call in June, and they said it was confirmed,” said Jean Pichette, a distant cousin of Anita Piteau. “They said, ‘We closed the case.’”

Pichette said his cousin Steve Sabo, who lives in Maryland and works at the Pentagon, drove nine hours to Maine last weekend to attend the funeral.

Earle Robitaille, now 89, was the commander of the Huntington Beach detective bureau in March 1968 when Anita Piteau was killed.

“Her throat was slit from ear to ear,” he said. “There’s no identification, and DNA was not even in the picture. It was obviously sexually motivated to a degree.”

Robitaille described the search of the field, in which they found clothing, a cigarette butt and tire tracks. The clothing would later become the break in the case.

“We preserved it, thank God,” he said.

Robitaille said his detectives were sent on a “wild goose chase” by a forensic dentist who said the victim’s dental work was shoddy and probably done in Mexico.

“That threw everything off,” he said.

Former homicide detective Pat Ellis, who started working on the case with his partner Mike Reilly in 2010, said he received confirmation about the identification “in the last few days.”

“I’m happy she’s been identified and that she went back home with her family,” Ellis said.

Amy Spanfellner, who works as a “search angel” for ancestry.com, said she has been talking about the case with Huntington Beach detectives since 2017. She has a missing relative named Emily Roberta Jordan. She said she initially thought the Orange County Jane Doe might have been her relative. When she learned it wasn’t her relative, she was asked to help police.

Spanfellner said she was originally told the police didn’t have enough DNA from Jane Doe’s body.

“I pushed and educated the detective on private DNA labs,” she said. “They didn’t even have sufficient DNA on (Jane Doe).”

The body was exhumed in 2019, but “that turned out to be a dead-end,” Ellis said.

Ellis said the Orange County Coroner buried the unidentified body in Newport Beach (instead of in a potter’s field) so that police in the future could find the body for additional testing.

Ellis retired in January. One of his last acts as a homicide detective was to order retesting of Jane Doe’s clothing. That’s when they got DNA hits that led Piteau and Chrisco.

Once they had a hit, they called Colleen Fitzpatrick, who is the founder of Identifinders International and does genealogical research for the Orange County District Attorney’s Office.

Fitzpatrick began to build family trees with distant cousins of Jane Doe.

“She’s going to be in those trees,” Fitzpatrick said.

It was a Saturday when she discovered the name Steve Sabo. And a detective gave Sabo a call.

“That was the ‘Oh my God’ moment,’ Fitzpatrick said.

Reached by phone Tuesday, Sabo said he was contacted by police in June and asked, “Was I aware of anybody who was missing in my family?”

Sabo and Pichette, who had never met Anita Piteau, found an obituary of a distant cousin, Constance Saucier. In that obituary, they found the following reference: “Connie was predeceased by her parents, her sister Theresa Piteau Gallagher, her brother Robert Piteau and her sister Anita Piteau (missing since 1970).”

The date was incorrect, but the identity was not. Pichette said he’s heard stories in his family that Anita ran away from home in Maine when she was a teenager. He found the information in a book of family history written in French.

He had not heard of Anita until he started research after the phone call in May.

“It’s quite surprising,” Pichette said.

Another distant relative of Anita’s, identified on Twitter as @MLBlue40 posted on June 20.

“I never met her. I have no idea what person she was. She died in 1968, I was born in 1979. She was robbed of her life and I was robbed of someone I could have known. Her name was Anita Louise Piteau. She was only 26.”

In the tweets, @MLBlue40 wrote that the Piteau family was informed about Anita’s alleged killer.

The owner of the @MLBlue40 account, who did not respond to a request for an interview, wrote: “The killer died in 2015 of throat cancer. He was never caught and escaped justice. We cant even tell her oldest sister about it cause shes in a nursing home for Dementia and shes been waiting the longest to find out what happened to her missing sister. Life is cruel and unfair.”

Other tweets from @MLBlue40 read: “Her own Mother died without ever knowing what happened to her daughter …

“She died bitter. My Mom said that my Grandma said ‘thanks a lot Anita! You couldnt even come see me on my death bed.’ I think she took it personally, like she abandoned us. I dont think anyone wanted to believe she was killed.”

Robitaille, the former Huntington Beach commander of the detective bureau, said he was sitting in his kitchen when detectives laid out the case in front of him.

First, they showed him that Jane Doe was Anita Piteau.

“She was star struck, and came to California to make it in the movies,” Robitaille said. “I was tickled to death they identified her.”

Then they told him about the alleged killer, Johnny Chrisco, whose DNA was found on the victim’s clothing.

Chrisco was in the Army, Robitaille said. They had a booking photo of him from the Orange County Jail in 1971. Robitaille said Chrisco was the spitting image of serial killer Rodney Alcala, who was called “The Dating Game Killer.”

“They were like twins,” Robitaille said.

He said he wishes Chrisco would have faced justice for the murder of Piteau.

“He died of throat cancer,” Robitaille said. “That’s a fairly good punishment.”

Robitaille called Piteau family members in Maine to tell them the news. He said he hopes the revelations gave them some sense of closure.

“I apologized that we couldn’t have done more at the time,” Robitaille said.

Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer praised the dogged pursuit by the Huntington Beach Police.

“Nothing, not even the death of the killer himself, will deter the pursuit of justice,” Spitzer said. “The death of a 26-year-old woman who was left in a farm field raped, beaten and her neck slashed haunted generations of Huntington Beach police officers who refused to give up on identifying Jane Doe and finding the person who robbed a young woman of a lifetime of memories.

“After more than five decades, advances in investigative genetic genealogy did what old-fashioned police work could not: give Jane Doe a name and identify her killer. It is technology and the determination of the Huntington Beach Police Department and prosecutors, forensic scientists and investigators from the Orange County District Attorney’s Office that allowed Anita’s family to finally bring her home and lay her to rest. The death of Johnny Chrisco prevented the full imposition of justice for Anita’s murder, and that is a wound that will never heal, but it was the dogged pursuit of justice that ensured that it was not if, but when, we would finally be able to tell Anita’s loved ones who killed her.”

Huntington Beach Police Chief Rob Handy said the work to find justice for Piteau showed the dedication of the police and prosecutors.

“I am extremely grateful and proud of the extraordinary efforts of the active and retired members of the Huntington Beach Police Department and the Orange County District Attorney’s Office in their tireless pursuit of justice for Anita and her family,” he said. “The fact they never stopped working this case for more than five decades is a tremendous testament to the two departments and our law enforcement profession.

“There is nothing more important to a victim and their family to know that law enforcement will never give up. Although the suspect was no longer alive to face the consequences, providing the family with the information of what happened to Anita and allowing them to properly lay her to rest is of tremendous importance.”

Anita Louise Piteau was buried in Waterville, Maine, next to Constance Saucier.

About 20 people, including three members of the Huntington Beach Police Department and an Orange County District Attorney’s Office investigator, were in attendance.

Investigator Dave Dierking gave a timeline of the case to explain the police work to the audience.

“There was no justice, but it was closure,” Sabo said. “Now the family had an answer to why she disappeared.”

Source


r/CrackedColdCases • • Sep 23 '25

UPDATE Elizabeth and Jasmin Ramos Found Alive After 36 Years (1989)

226 Upvotes

r/CrackedColdCases • • May 05 '20

Resolved Idaho police say they have solved the rape and murder of a 9-year-old girl, Daralyn Johnson, nearly 38 years ago—for the second time.

225 Upvotes

The right man has finally been charged in 1982 Murder of Ms. Daralyn Johnson, 9, Nampa, ID

David Dalrymple, 62, who is already serving time for molesting a child, was charged Monday, 4 May 2020 with killing Daralyn Johnson, 9, a crime another man was convicted of only to be exonerated after 18 years on death row.

Daralyn left her home in Nampa at 8 a.m. on Feb. 21, 1982, but never made it to school. Her body was found by fishermen three days later in a drain ditch near the Snake River.

An autopsy determined that she had been sexually assaulted and beaten, though the cause of her death was drowning.

After a yearlong investigation, a local man named Charles Fain was arrested on less-than-ironclad evidence: His hair was similar to hair found on the body; he had a car that looked like one seen near the crime scene; and jailhouse informants testified against him.

Fain passed a polygraph, but the jury that convicted him never heard about it and he was locked up on death row—where he continued to proclaim his innocence.

In 2001, Fain was exonerated after DNA tests that were not available at the time of his conviction showed he was not the killer.

In 2018, Sheriff Kieran Donahue’s office sent a pubic hair that was found on Daralyn’s body to a lab in California, and genealogical DNA sleuthing led investigators to Dalrymple’s family, according to a probable cause affidavit.

He was already doing 20 to life for kidnapping and sexually abusing a little girl in 2004, and police believe he has more victims. They said they have identified two other girls who say they were molested by him but never reported it.

Dalrymple, 62, was questioned in prison in February but denied being in Nampa at the time of Daralyn’s murder, according to prosecutors. However, investigators were able to disprove his various alibis.

Because of the coronavirus pandemic, authorities will wait until the summer to serve the arrest warrant on him.

https://www.thedailybeast.com/david-dalrymple-charged-with-1982-murder-of-daralyn-johnson-crime-that-landed-charles-fain-on-idaho-death-row?via=desktop&social=Reddit


r/CrackedColdCases • • Dec 05 '23

Jane Doe IDENTIFIED A woman wearing high heels and a gold ring was found dead by hunters in Indiana 41 years ago. She's now been identified.

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
224 Upvotes

r/CrackedColdCases • • Jan 20 '21

Teen who drowned in motel pool in 1966 identified as Jolaine Hemmy

224 Upvotes

https://www.star-telegram.com/news/state/texas/article248607760.html

This is a really weird one for me. An unidentified teen was found dead after she drowned in a motel pool in Pecos, TX on July 5, 1966. She came to the hotel with a man and they identified themselves as Mr. and Mrs. Russell Battuon.

While the man was reported to have been in the couple's motel room at the time she was in the pool, following her death, the man had asked the office at the Ropers Motel for his registration card, saying it was the only form of identification he had to go to the hospital. He never arrived at the hospital.

Surprising that it took her family until 2019 to possibly identify her. My biggest questions are:

  1. Why did she and this man end up in Texas so far from home?

  2. How did she know this guy?

  3. Why did he want his registration card back if it had the wrong name on it? Maybe it had his photo too?


r/CrackedColdCases • • Feb 22 '21

Jane Doe IDENTIFIED Valentine Sally has been identified as 17-year-old Carolyn Eaton

221 Upvotes

Coconino County Sheriff Jim Driscoll confirmed identification of a female found deceased on February 14, 1982 on Interstate 40 west of Williams. This case has generated a great deal of local and statewide interest and has become commonly referred to as the “Valentine Sally Case”.

Detectives with the Coconino County Sheriff’s Office have positively identified the female as 17-year-old Carolyn Eaton, of St. Louis, Missouri. Her body was found nearly 40 years ago on the north side of Interstate 40 west of Williams, Arizona.  Detectives have been working with the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC), National Missing and Unidentified Person System (NamUs) and the Arizona Department of Public Safety to identify “Valentine Sally” through familial DNA.  This process utilized a private company that specializes in DNA processing for submission into online databases for genetic comparison. Information obtained from this database search identified a relative of “Valentine Sally”.  Through this process, detectives were able to locate potential family members of Carolyn, obtain DNA samples from them, and confirm the identity of the body as Carolyn. Identification of unidentified victims is a difficult and lengthy process and can be costly to agencies looking to identify victims of crimes.  Recent breakthroughs in DNA technology have allowed Law Enforcement Agencies to identify victims as well as suspects in cold cases such as these.

This case began on February 14th in 1982 (Valentine’s Day), when the body of a deceased female was located on the north side of Interstate 40 at mile post 151.8 by an Arizona DPS Officer assisting a motorist along the highway.  Coconino County Sheriff’s Office Detective Sgt. Jack Judd, now retired, began this investigation as the responding detective working on this case.  Detective Sgt. Judd continued working this case throughout the remainder of his career following up on numerous leads.  The investigation passed through many detectives over the years since the initial report and transitioned to cold case detectives when all other leads were exhausted.

Recently, with the assistance of grant funding through NCMEC the Coconino County Sheriff’s Office was able to utilize DNA samples from “Valentine Sally” to complete the familial DNA search for relatives of “Valentine Sally.”   This funding from NCMEC allowed for testing through a private vendor that led to the identification of family members.

Detectives traveled to the St. Louis area to interview family members.  It was found that the family members had a sibling who ran away from home around Christmas time in 1981.  Detectives were able to retrieve DNA samples from relatives, which matched the DNA profile from “Valentine Sally.”  This ultimately led to confirmation and the positive identification of “Valentine Sally” as Carolyn Eaton.

During the investigation, detectives worked with the St. Louis County Police Department Missing Persons detectives when contacting the family, who lives around the greater St Louis area.   Detectives also worked with the Bellefontaine Neighbors Police Department, Missouri where Carolyn lived before running away around Christmas 1981/New Years of 1982.

Now that the victim has been identified, Detectives are working leads that have been developed to identify any possible suspects. Detectives, along with the Cold Case Squad of the Coconino County Sheriff’s Office continue to vigorously work this case.  At this time, there are no suspects identified but the case remains under investigation as a homicide.

Sheriff Driscoll wants to thank community members, assisting law enforcement agencies, Sheriff’s staff, and the victim’s family who have worked for so long to identify Carolyn and put some level of closure to this tragic case.

Source