As someone who only read horror for years, I’ve been dipping into the cozy fantasy genre and I’m so eager for more! However, I find that a lot of the popular titles feel a little YA for me somehow, and while they’re fun, I find myself wanting something a little more mature sometimes. I’m not necessarily talking about spice or stakes or anything specific; more like a combination of writing style, plot elements, character development, and just the general vibe, I guess?
My gold standard is A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping, if that helps. Complex main character, really good romance (that felt adult), interesting (but not complicated) magic system, solid coziness. I also liked The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, but not quite as much.
I read The Spellshop, and am in the middle of The Enchanted Greenhouse, and while they’re okay, they feel a little juvenile to me. Disney-ish, maybe, if that makes sense. Same with Legends and Lattes, Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea, and, to a lesser extent, House on the Cerulean Sea. I don’t like the coziness to feel forced or overdone— although I know some people like that!
I read the first Emily Wilde, which was better, but didn’t blow me away.
I like romance (no matter the genders), I like simple fantasy elements, I like a naturally cozy vibe, and a good mix of humor and serious topics. I don’t mind spice, as long as it doesn’t feel shoehorned in.
Any recommendations would be very welcome!