r/CowboyAction • • May 11 '26

Lack of realism

0 Upvotes

I’m looking to get my start in cowboy action shooting (I’m just working on sourcing a decent belt honestly, that will probably be it’s own thread eventually), but one thing has bothered me from the start, realism, or the lack there of.

NCOWS is probably a better fit for me than SASS, but unfortunately the nearest NCOWS groups and events are hundreds of miles from me, and I’m just not looking to travel that far and pay for a hotel for a couple of nights just to shoot a match, so that leaves me with SASS.

There is a lot I like about SASS but there are a few things in the rules that just irk me and I wonder if anyone else feels the same way. For me I look at it as more of a living history thing, a way for me to get a feel for the old west era more than it is a shooting sport, if I just want a game I would just do IPSC (or more likely USPSA or brutality, for a whole other kind of realism reason). But yet at a casual glance it seems like the rules were written more for gamers than history nerds like me. There are a few specifically that bug me:

Can’t load more than 5 rounds in your revolver. Why? I take issue with this for 2 reasons, 1, this was very clearly targeted at the 1873 users, but not everyone uses an 1873 (believe it or not, shocking I know, there were other and even BETTER *Gasp!!!!!* choices available st the time and even in competitions today, and many of those do not have the 1873’s “issue” (for example, cap and ball revolvers, certain cartridge conversions, and the hand ejector) yet they still can’t load more than 5 just because they want to keep it “fair” for the 1873 people, but would real life have been fair? No. Practical gun selection should be as much of an issue now as it was back then, some guns are just better than others and should not be handicapped in the name of balance. 2, There is no historical backing that I am aware of that only loading 5 was ever done, let alone done commonly, and honestly short of dropping the gun or trying to force the trigger to pull with two fingers it’s really not even an issue now, O get the safety nazi thing, but since your only loading on the firing line anyway then immediately shooting is it really that hazardous to load all the chambers?

No reloading on the clock. In a real gunfight sometimes you have to reload, even though it’s not that common it does still happen, and even though many “just carried another gun” not everyone did nor could most people afford to. I feel like the no reload thing was again a balancing decision just because otherwise the 1873 people would get completely smoked by the Schofield people, but I refer to what I said about weapon selection.

No shooting while moving. In a real gunfight you would at the least go to cover, yet in most forms of cowboy action shooting you just stand there out in the open and never go from behind the bench. Would an action shooting element be so much to ask for? The other shooting sports do it fine, so you can’t tell me it’s a safety issue.

Single action only. Double actions existed in the old west and in fact were very popular, eventually outselling the single actions, there were even some semi autos in the period, yet competitors are artificially restricted to single actions, again presumably in the interest of balance.

Only 2 rounds in shotguns. Why? That rule makes zero sense, what purpose does a pump action have if you can only load 2 rounds? The only thing that makes sense here is that they are trying to handicap everyone not using a side by side. Balance again.

Popgun loads. The rules allow for unrealistic popgun loads. Anyone carrying these guns in the actual old west would likely have been carrying full loads, so I really think that a game that is supposed to be based on history should require full power.

Just too much emphasis on gaming and not enough on history or realism.

What are your thoughts?


r/CowboyAction • • Aug 08 '24

Howdy

1 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • Feb 03 '23

What holster is the most practical?

1 Upvotes

If I take cowboy action shooting, I wanna know what holster is the most comfortable to wear in both horseback and when walking. My gun of choice would be the 1847 walker or 2nd model dragoon.


r/CowboyAction • • Jan 27 '23

What's the toughest nickel or nickel-like finish?

0 Upvotes

A lot of people say nickel is the toughest finish to have on your gun. What's the toughest of them all, or what similar finish fits the description I mentioned?


r/CowboyAction • • Jul 31 '24

Summer Rodeo Roundup: Cheyenne, Utah, and More! $1 Million in payouts!

Thumbnail self.cowboyscowgirls
0 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • Aug 04 '22

Study on Firearm Owners and Suicide Prevention

10 Upvotes

[A moderator approved me posting this message] Hello! My name is Logan Smith, I’m a Clinical Psychology Ph.D. student at Oklahoma State University. I’m doing research into how firearm owners prefer to learn about suicide prevention, and I could use your help.

We want to learn what firearm owners think about suicide prevention messages, and who they want to hear those messages from. Many of the current efforts to teach firearm owners about suicide prevention – such as safe storage of your firearm, or recognizing the warning signs of a suicidal crisis – have not been successful. It is believed that this might be due to firearm owners preferring to learn about suicide prevention from different people than the ones reaching out to them.

That’s why it’s important to hear from real firearm owners, like you.

The research that I am doing is an important step in understanding why firearm owners might prefer certain messengers over others. While there is no direct compensation for participating in this study, your participation would provide valuable data for our study. Anyone who currently is, or ever was, a firearm owner is welcome to participate in this project.

All of your answers are kept completely anonymous; we won’t ask any identifying information about you, or keep a list of who responded. We will not be attaching your answers to your personal identity in any way. This research has been approved by the Institutional Review Board at Oklahoma State University. The study should take about 20-30 minutes to complete; for some people, it can take longer, and for others it can be shorter.

If you’re interested in participating, have questions about eligibility, or would like to know more, please send me a direct message on here or an email at [email protected].

Thank you for taking the time to read this!

To participate, please click on the link below:

https://okstatecas.co1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_4VMW7rf6zzQF1Ai


r/CowboyAction • • Jan 20 '23

How good is the Schofield?

1 Upvotes

For anybody who uses the Schofield, what is it like? How tough is the gun? How practical is it? And is it worth the money? Give honest opinions and thoughts.


r/CowboyAction • • Nov 30 '19

Cowboy Sheriff, Weight of the Badge, Speed Drawing

Thumbnail
instagram.com
0 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • Jun 02 '17

Anyone have this?

Thumbnail
ebay.com
0 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • May 31 '22

What your Shotgun says about you Cowboy Edition

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • Nov 26 '25

The harsh truth about real 19th‑century American cowboys — you’ll be surprised

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Most people think cowboys in the Wild West rode free, owned their horses, and lived a life of freedom. Actually… many didn’t even own their horse — they rented it. Their pay was often meager, and full payment came from risky cattle drives, herd‑delivery bonuses, and seasonal jobs. Their daily life was brutal: long rides, unpredictable weather, and no social safety net.

If you’re interested in real history of the Old West beyond the Hollywood myth, I made a short documentary‑style video exploring the real earnings, social status and hard life of American cowboys. (Link in profile)

What do you think — was the cowboy life really as romantic as movies show?


r/CowboyAction • • Jan 13 '23

Is an open top gun or a kirst konverter more practical?

2 Upvotes

I'm wondering what kind of open top gun is more durable and more practical for a certain revolver. There's the kind that the 1871 revolver has, which is awesome (in the movie, the outlaw josey wales, the colt walkers from the movie were like the 1871 open top), then there's the kirst konverter. I love how you can put the plate and new cylinder for cartridges, and then you can swap it out with the percussion cylinder if you prefer loading it traditionally. But overall, what is better? Both irl AND an old west setting. If I met a gunsmith who's willing to do either, what's the most practical design?


r/CowboyAction • • Jun 07 '21

After a second look, seems like I have some dents/discoloration on my ports of the barrel of my python. It’s hard to take a good picture. Any suggestions?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • Jan 25 '23

Non-leather holsters?

0 Upvotes

I'm looking for old-west style holsters that aren't made of leather. Any vegetarian/non-animal material works, while of course wanting it to be practical for cowboy action shooting.

Suggestions for where to look or specific items you've liked? Thanks!

Edit: cartridge belts, etc., too!

Edit #2: from the comments, I'm thinking I probably want to go in the direction of something like this: https://youtu.be/wh_y8CFWuy4?t=352 . Very interested to hear if people have experience with canvas holsters etc. and/or know where to buy good quality.

Edit #3: the video above at around 7:35 gives some interesting history as to why for some purposes canvas was more desirable than leather

Edit #4: the belt in the video is a Mills Belt, made by this guy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anson_Mills . A repro here has a date of 1881: https://regimentalarms.shop/product/reproduction-mills-cartridge-belt-with-buckle/ . I've also come across something called a prairie belt (made famous in the movie Crossfire Trail) that looks like this https://www.wolfearsequipment.com/product-page/m-1876-belt-45-70-only (that one has leather though).


r/CowboyAction • • Sep 26 '26

Genuine question how did you choose between the 357 and the 45?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Sorry if this has been asked. This sport has been introduced to me and looks exciting. When looking at my options it seems both rounds are very popular and I am wonder which way I should go. Any thoughts would be helpful. Thanks!


r/CowboyAction • • Jan 10 '23

Can custom order guns be made?

1 Upvotes

One example is a colt walker with an 1872 open top conversion. Is it possible? (And is requesting an ever bigger colt walker possible also?)


r/CowboyAction • • Jan 20 '23

Is it possible to custom order a lemat?

0 Upvotes

There are lemats, but I'm wondering if it's possible to custom order one to hold 8 .38 caliber bullets and one .410 shotgun (reason is so the walls of the gun have more metal to hold hotter rounds like the .357)


r/CowboyAction • • Jan 16 '23

Can you use the colt walker with winter gloves?

1 Upvotes

This may sound ridiculous, but I'm curious if you can use it effectively with winter gloves in the cold. Is the trigger guard big enough?


r/CowboyAction • • Mar 06 '26

What would be the best way for someone wanted to carry two revolvers and a knife on their person?

1 Upvotes

* Specifically during the Wild West era


r/CowboyAction • • Mar 01 '24

Freedom Arms 454

0 Upvotes

Hey yall,

My pawpaw left me a FA 454 with a 8" ported barrel, with instructions to never sell it. I don't hunt with handguns. I'd like to try Cowboy Shooting..so im thinking of cutting down the barrel. How do yall judge balance so i know where to cut?.


r/CowboyAction • • Nov 08 '24

How much does a Ruger New Vaquero weigh?

0 Upvotes

With a 4.62" barrel, .45 Colt?

Ruger's website says 40 ounces:

https://ruger.com/products/vaqueroBlued/specSheets/5102.html

I got to wondering how much bigger my old Vaquero is, since I've never seen the 2005-present smaller version in real life, so I figured the weight would give me an idea.

It turns out that mine only weighs 40.8 ounces (I weighed it on two different digital scales, both of which read exactly 1 pound when weighing a 1-pound scale calibration weight). However, that's with a steel ejector rod housing that I ordered from Ruger's website several years ago to replace the stock aluminum one. It weighs about an ounce more than the stock one, so my gun's original stock weight would have been about 40 ounces.

How can the bigger Vaquero weigh the same as the smaller one? Ruger's website must have the weight wrong, so does anyone know how much it really weighs?


r/CowboyAction • • Sep 03 '23

Cowboy catto

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • Jun 02 '17

Yes or No?

Thumbnail
ebay.com
0 Upvotes

r/CowboyAction • • May 15 '23

Is a Buscadero rig actually good, or only for show?

2 Upvotes

It's a nice rig that can help an individual draw fast, but can one use it in, say, horseback, or when sitting down? If any use this rig please tell me.


r/CowboyAction • • May 23 '22

Anyone want to sell some 45lc ammo? Even reloads or whatever. I can’t find any online for less that .85c a round and that sucks. TY or know where I can get ammo nothing fancy just something that goes bang lol

2 Upvotes