I'm seriously debating returning my HexClad cookware to Costco after years of recurring issues, and I'm curious what other Costco members would do.
I purchased two sets:
December 2019: HexClad 7-Piece Cookware Set (Item #1198193) - $349.99
December 2021: HexClad 6-Piece Saucepan Set (Item #1394630) - $299.99
Both sets were purchased directly from Costco, and I still have the original receipts.
My warranty history:
May 2023: My 10" hybrid frying pan was replaced under warranty.
March 2025: Filed a warranty claim for my 8" hybrid frying pan.
August 2025: Filed a warranty claim for my large skillet.
August 2025: Filed another warranty claim for my 10" hybrid frying pan, which had already been replaced in May 2023.
May 2026: Filed a warranty claim for my 3-quart saucepan.
And now, in November 2026, I have TWO MORE saucepans that need replacing because the nonstick coating is coming off.
To be fair to HexClad, they've never denied any of my warranty claims. They've only asked for photos of the affected cookware and proof of purchase. Their warranty service hasn't been the problem.
The problem is how frequently I've needed to use it.
I take good care of these pans. I'm not overheating them, abusing them, or doing anything outside normal household cooking. Yet I've repeatedly experienced issues with the coating deteriorating.
Here's what frustrates me even more:
I've noticed a significant difference between HexClad's original nonstick coating and the newer reformulated version.
Original coating: Much better nonstick performance, but the coating eventually deteriorates and starts coming off.
Newer coating: Considerably more durable in my experience, but the nonstick performance is practically nonexistent compared to the original.
It feels like I've traded one problem for another. The older pans performed better but didn't hold up, while the newer ones seem to last longer but don't perform particularly well as nonstick cookware.
I've owned these sets for approximately five and seven years now, and I'm questioning whether continuing to replace individual pieces indefinitely really makes sense.
I understand these aren't new purchases, and I certainly don't want to abuse Costco's generous return policy. But these were premium-priced pans marketed as durable, long-lasting cookware with a lifetime warranty.
I'm genuinely torn.
Should I continue relying on HexClad's warranty, or is it reasonable to return both sets to Costco after years of repeated problems?
For those who've owned HexClad long-term, have you experienced similar coating failures? Has anyone else noticed how poorly the reformulated coating performs compared to the original?
And for Costco employees or longtime members, would you consider returning these after this many years reasonable, given the repeated issues and documented warranty history?
I have both original Costco receipts and email correspondence documenting my warranty claims.
What would you do?