Hey folks ^^
Inspired by the lovely guys at Corridor in with CK2 and everything else that they've done over the years to get me into visual art, I've been working on something I think this sub will appreciate.
TL;DR: Most VHS filters fake the look by stacking blurs, noise and row-shift sliders on top of your footage. I tried simulating the actual machine instead: the magnetic tape, the spinning heads, the deck's circuitry and the TV. The VHS look comes out of that physics on its own.
The idea came from music production. Synth people will know physical modelling synthesis. Instead of playing back a sample of a violin, you simulate a vibrating string, a bow and a wooden body, and the sound emerges from that. Plugins like Pianoteq work this way, and it's why they respond so naturally when you push them. I wondered whether the same approach would work for video, and it turns out it does.
What happens to your footage:
Your picture gets turned into a real FM signal (luma sits around 3.4–4.4 MHz, like a real deck), with the colour carried "under" it at about 629 kHz, just like actual VHS.
That signal gets "written" to a simulated strip of magnetic tape: slanted helical tracks, measured in micrometres.
A simulated head reads it back. Dust, creases, head clogs, oxide shedding and tracking errors are physical things on that tape, not overlays. A crease stays at the same height in the picture. A clogged head ruins every other field. The deck's dropout compensator patches holes using the line above, the way real hardware did.
The playback electronics come next, and they can age: dried-out capacitors, drifting resistors and a sagging power supply each change the picture the way they would in a 30-year-old machine.
Finally the TV decodes it, sync separator and all. That's where the flagging at the top of the screen and the tearing come from.
So you don't dial in "12 lines of tracking noise." You dial in "6 micrometres of mistracking" or "28 years in a damp attic," and the tracking noise is whatever that machine would really produce.
Other things it does:
SP, LP and EP tape speeds, with the differences following from track width and tape speed rather than separate presets
Generation loss (dubbing a dub of a dub, dubs of dub music can not me accomodated for yet.)
Composite video artefacts
Linear audio that shares the same wow, flutter, hum and dropouts as the picture, because it's the same tape
An "outside world" panel for interference: a phone buzzing next to the deck, an AM radio station leaking into the head wires, a magnet held near the CRT bending the beam, a dodgy light dimmer on the same circuit
A GUI with a green-phosphor schematic view where every setting is drawn as a part of the circuit, plus a plain panels view if you'd rather just use sliders
What it isn't (yet):
It isn't real-time. It's a lot slower than pixel-based tools because it simulates tens of millions of samples per second of video. I think a GPU version could speed it up massively, but that's still future work.
It's NTSC only right now. I'm working on PAL (proper 625-line/50 Hz, plus NTSC tapes played into a PAL telly), and also the camera-tube "comet tail" light trails you see in old BBC studio footage.
It's a standalone app and command-line tool for now, not a plugin for Resolve/AE/Premiere. A plugin is on the list.
Big respect to ntsc-rs, by the way. It's fast, polished and a fantastic tool, and I'm not trying to replace it. This is a different approach that trades speed for "it actually happened in a machine." Honestly I think the two could complement each other.
It's free for non-commercial use: github.com/allthemalware/vhs-phys
I'd love feedback, especially from anyone who still has real decks and tapes lying around and can tell me where it looks wrong. And if Niko and the gang ever want to throw some footage through it, I'd be over the moon.
With all the love I can muster
allthemalware