r/Cookies • • Dec 18 '25

Pricing?

Post image

Hi, my gingerbread cookies cost about $5 to make per dozen (I use high quality ingredients), and they take me about an hour to make (not including bake or chill time) and minimum wage in my state is $15/hour. Is $20 per dozen a fair price?

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

6

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

Well thanks to everyone who gave me actual advice. And to everyone trying to insult me and tell me my time and effort isnt worth even a single dollar... my hideous cookies already made me almost $200. So Im just going to do what I want. Thanks for nothing.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/OneTwoPandemonium Dec 19 '25

Especially on Reddit! I’ve left a majority of the subs I initially joined because people can just be so unkind.

OP, if you want to join r/cookiedecorating, people are a bit kinder over there. And there are lots of people who make cookies similar to yours!

7

u/maggiethekatt Dec 18 '25

The advice in this post is wild. $20/dozen for homemade cookies is absolutely reasonable, and yes, even for "basic" cookies, which these aren't because they have frosting, which is an extra step. "Basic" cookies are the variety packs I sell of chocolate chip, m&m, oatmeal raisin, and snickerdoodle, simple drop cookies that I get $10 for the 4 pack at every weekend market and pop-up that I do. Frosting is an extra step, even if it's not intricate frosting like royal icing. I was going to suggest $25/dozen and every other homemade baker I know in every home based baking group I'm in would support this.

5

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

Thanks for being kind. It really helps to hear from someone that my prices arent outrageous. I might lower in the future just to hopefully increase my sales. I just wasn't expecting this kind of behavior over cookies. I get they're not the prettiest cookies to ever be made but I didnt think they were completely worthless lol.

8

u/peppermintschnepps Dec 18 '25

I would never pay $20 for a dozen cookies

2

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

How much then?

-1

u/peppermintschnepps Dec 18 '25

No more than $1 a cookie

1

u/Difficult_Club903 Dec 18 '25

Where do you buy cookies?

1

u/Disneyhorse Dec 19 '25

You don’t have to. I won’t pay $50 for a dozen cookies at Crumbl but lots of people love them and I have someone at the office who buys them by the dozen to bring in. I personally am pretty good at baking and would rather make my own. But people who don’t bake will pay $20+. Honestly, ingredients are so expensive that it’s not that bad.

4

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

You know, i never expected to get so many rude messages from randos on the internet who dont even have to buy my cookies. I was looking for actual advice from people and not insulting messages. Sorry that im an amateur and still figuring things out. Geez people get a life.

6

u/peppermintschnepps Dec 18 '25

You got actual advice, none of which was insulting, just genuine & trying to help Take care

0

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

I said messages, not comments...

1

u/NewYorker1283 Dec 18 '25

You didn't give advice. You gave your opinion on how much you wouldn't pay for them.

3

u/NewYorker1283 Dec 18 '25
  1. You absolutely should be including bake and chill time in your labor time. It's still you using your skill and time.

  2. How big are they? I think that depends on how much you should charge.

2

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

Depending on the shape of the cookie cutter about 5-6 inches

4

u/NewYorker1283 Dec 18 '25

That's definitely a big cookie. I don't know where you live, but I sell very similar cookies for 3 for $15 in NY, and I have never heard anyone complain. Here's a photo of mine, for reference.

https://imgur.com/a/LymOfS4

3

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

I live in NM so its definitely cheaper out here lol. But that makes me feel better about my prices. Thank you so much for your help and I really appreciate your kindness. I dont know what about my cookies got people so worked up lol.

4

u/NewYorker1283 Dec 18 '25

I have no idea either but I’ve had similar interactions on here from people who probably can’t even cook store bought Pilsbury cookie dough. Don’t let it get to you.

8

u/Mountain-Gap-1478 Dec 18 '25

I charge $20 for 12 cookies and if there are extra flavors, I charge $2. My last order was 3 dozen cookies with different flavors and I made $66 and was given a tip of $15.

3

u/Mountain-Gap-1478 Dec 18 '25

Also for everyone saying this is basic cookie with icing. Its not a chocolate chip cookie or a sugar cookie. Its a GINGERBREAD Cookie cut out and iced. Takes time to make this type. Kudos to the OP because my gingerbread cookies come out boring and rock hard (I don't sell them for this reason)

2

u/Missmagentamel Dec 18 '25

Not with that very basic frosting job on them.

1

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

How much then?

1

u/Missmagentamel Dec 18 '25

Depends on your area but $8ish I guess.

3

u/PretendHistory6904 Dec 18 '25

I think $20 dollars is a fair price. By the time you roll out and refrigerate dough and cut out the cookies, you’re looking at a couple of hours. Mixing icing and decorating is time consuming as well. It’s those that have never made these types of cookies, that will lowball you. Trust me, at the end of the day cookies take time, especially ones you are selling.  You definitely want to make the money worth it. I’d actually charge $25 for 5-6 inch cookies. That’s a good size. 

2

u/mashed-_-potato Dec 18 '25

It’s hard to tell how big they are based on the picture. If they are small, I’d charge a bit less. If you wanted to be able to charge more, you could try to do some more intricate icing designs. But also if you are already making a good amount of sales, no need to lower your price.

2

u/OneTwoPandemonium Dec 19 '25

My question is, how much money would make it worth it for you? I was charging $3/cookie for my custom decorated cookies and I realized I was not enjoying it and it wasn’t worth it. So now I do $4/cookie. I feel like it’s well worth my time, and I consistently get 2-4 customers each month which is the perfect amount for me.

Charge what you feel like would be worth your effort, and if somebody doesn’t want to pay the price, they’re not your ideal customer.

5

u/justme35555 Dec 18 '25

In a bakery a cookie like they would be $3.99. $20 is fair

2

u/peppermintschnepps Dec 18 '25

No they wouldn't, it's a basic cookie with basic icing, nothing fancy or intricate

1

u/Connect_Progress_488 May 19 '26

Hater ass energy lol

1

u/peppermintschnepps May 20 '26

Wow, took you 5 months to come up with that "insult" or feedback or whatever. Good job, buddy 👏

1

u/Connect_Progress_488 May 20 '26

Lmao as if I've been sitting on this post for five months, troll. 

3

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '25

Nothing. These aren’t really (skill wise) to be sold.

1

u/Aneuday0321 May 03 '26

$20 for a dozen gingerbread cookies with icing is not bad. There’s a local sourdough bread baker in my area who charges $25 for a dozen basic sourdough chocolate chip (normal sized as well).

4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Potential-Pear5514 Dec 18 '25

They are about 5-6 inches in diameter. I work full time so I dont have time to make intricate designs. Also how much then? No one has given me advice on that other than saying NOOOOOOO WAYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!! So I'm exactly where I started...