I have my first impressions of Jacquy Pfeiffer’s The Art of French Tarts…not sorry I got this the day it was released! I made the Pear Tart Bourdaloue from the “Les Classiques” section for a potluck today and it was polished off pretty quickly. Pictures show the sliced tart, the full tart, the pastry (Pate sucree, sorry for no accents!) before being rolled out, and the almond cream.
Some background…I used to work basically right across the Chicago River from the French Pastry School that Pfeiffer ran. I once went to a croissant demo they did, and immediately loved him…free croissants! free petit pain at chocolat! What’s not to love…although that’s how I learned they use sheeters to get that perfect pastry. I worked too darned much to ever take one of their enthusiast courses, but when he published his James Beard Award winning The Art of French Pastry I got it. I can’t say I have made many of the recipes from that book, but I have made the Yule log twice, the second time with variants, some of the cookies and tarts, and it’s one of my favorite references. In particular, following an article from his co-author Martha Rose Shulman in the NY Times, I realized the joy of tart shell recipes that let you make one now and freeze the other half (or two thirds if I cheat and use three 7 1/2” tart pans, perfect for two!), ready rolled out and frozen. I have made the pate sucree (sweet tart dough) from that book at least a dozen times yielding maybe 30 tarts (one recipe = two 9” or three 7 1/2”). So I wanted to start with a recipe that used that.
The differences in the recipe in the new book are subtle. The recipe tweaks the proportions ever so slightly. But the biggest difference was that the original said to take the entire dough, form it into a rectangle, refrigerate it overnight, and then the next day divide it and roll it out, while the new one says to divide it in half and roll each half into a 1/2” high circle and then refrigerate it. It is WAY easier to roll that circle into a tart shape the next day than if you are using half a rectangle. There are a few more subtle details that I appreciated.
Beyond the pastry, the instructions for poaching the pears yielded a perfect result, and the almond cream came together really fast by hand, one of the options. One distinction in the new book was that he expressed a preference for unbalanced almond flour, so I used that for the pastry and the almond cream. I probably should have dried my pears off better, but the end result was still great. Another addition in the new book, perfect for me, is that in every recipe he tells you whether to use the convection setting on your oven or not…this one was not, which, since I usually do use it, could have resulted in overbaked pastry.
There are also a number of reasons why I love his books. He uses King Arthur flour, which is easy for me to get. He uses Spice House spices, and I can walk to one of their outlets. He uses Plugra butter, again easy for me to get. No guesswork on ingredients! But the biggest surprise was learning that despite the instructions in the book about using a stand mixer with a paddle, he writes his actual mixer is an Ankarsrum, which has been what I use for the last five years or so. He says he uses the single wire beaters for nearly everything, which is what I was doing, but I wasn’t sure if I was missing something by giving up my Kitchenaid.
With another tart shell in the freezer, I look forward to maybe a chocolate tart, and I will probably also try one of the different doughs with the apple tart in the new book. I didn’t love the almond topping for the apple tart in the first book, but the new one uses a crumble topping and looks delicious.