r/ControlTheory • u/Trevor521 • 11d ago
Technical Question/Problem Controller Tuning
Hi mods, I’m a control engineer at CSI and I’ve built a desktop app that fits a FOPDT model to an open-loop step test and compares Ziegler-Nichols, Cohen-Coon and IMC/Lambda tunings in closed-loop simulation. Would a post sharing it (with a link to a waitlist) be acceptable under rule 6, or is there a preferred format or thread for this? Happy to keep it to the technical content if that’s better. Thanks.
0
Upvotes
•
•
•
u/seekingsanity 10d ago
If you see the temperature response start to curve up before the temperature starts to curve down, you have a second order plus dead time system. This occurs because of the time constant of the sensor. In real life I haven't seen many FOPDT systems. What people do is ignore the sensor time constant.
Z-N and C-C are very limited. They are OK or better than nothing for temperature control. IMC/lambda tuning are much better.
I have not had any luck using these methods for motion control/integrating systems.
You should look into system identification. When you master that, you begin to realize that one tuning method does not fit all.
Here is a video controlling a SOPDT that has a long dead time. I show the math. You can see the deadtime limits the values of the closed loop time constant. A faster response can be obtained using a Smith Predictor or MPC but MPC would require a lot of calculations every cycle because it must look past the dead time.
peter.deltamotion.com/Videos/SOPDT1.mp4