NEED ADVICE ASAP - Fresh in the trades attempting a 70th Birthday Surprise 12x16 Deck Rebuild For Mother In Law—Tell Me If My Plan Sounds on point or feel free to drop some advice or tips. I’m fresh in the carpentry trade and have spent a lot of time learning and reading as well. This is my second deck project. I have it stripped down and the excavator is here so There’s no turning back now 😂
So I am Kicking off the rest of this “BIG” to me project today while my mother-in-law is out of town ahead of a surprise party next week for her 70th birthday. The deck is in rough shape and needs code upgrades, so I’m tackling it as a surprise to save her a big bill. This is only my second time doing this kind of deck work alone as I’m very fresh in the trades but consider myself handy and willing to learn, I’m trying to do everything by the book without cutting corners and keeping safety as my number one priority.
Previous build context:
I previously added stairs to a small cantilever deck behind my detached garage (originally a step-out landing, set up as a secondary exit), adding supports and concrete piers to handle the extra load.
Digging down on that first job was rough—especially pouring a formed concrete landing pad that took around 40–80 lb bags of cement and a big mixer, almost more work than the stairs themselves. Dropping threaded rod into Sonotubes for post standoff plates worked well for me there. In hindsight I should have used 6x6s on that project as well but now I’ve learned and will do so especially as it’s code and this is a way bigger deck and not cantilevered.
Current state & tear-down:
Stripped the deck down to bare framing; joists are solid with no rot, and I’ve pulled 1,000+ nails.
Currently has 3 bouncy stringers nailed in from the back with no brackets and resting directly on dirt—swapping to 4 stringers with Simpson ZMAX Strong-Tie connectors.
Replacing direct-buried 4x4 posts with 6x6 posts sitting on concrete piers to bring it up to code.
Materials & fasteners:
Joists: Joist tape over the clean joists.
Fasteners: 2-1/2" #9 GRK all-purpose screws and 1-1/2" Strong-Drive SD screws for stringer brackets/clips, L-brackets connecting 6x6 posts under the deck, and post hardware at the bottom piers.
Stairs: Keeping the existing 7" rise / 10" run (code-compliant and comfortable), cutting 4 new stringers out of 2x12x16s.
Today’s plan & timeline:
Pull the old stringers to drop weight, then shore up the deck \\\\\\\~2 ft back from the front edge using 2x6 ledgers top/bottom with 5–6 vertical 2x4 studs so I have clearance to dig.
Planning to tie a rope to the front framing and keep light upward tension with the mini excavator bucket as a backup safety measure while shoring is in place.
Using a mini excavator instead of an auger because of all the rocks in the yard (I dug \\\\\\\~3.5 ft on old posts a few years back and didn't hit concrete, though I wouldn't be surprised if some is down there).
Digging 4 ft deep for footers with crushed stone in the bottom, covering holes until concrete arrives early next week, and setting post standoff plates with threaded rod dropped into Sonotubes.
Landing pad: Instead of pouring another massive formed slab with 40+ bags and a big mixer like my last stair landing, I’m looking at a 300–500 lb stone (like bluestone) set on crushed stone/gravel and use the excavator to move it and place it even with the ground so it doesn’t throw off the 7" rise / 10" run layout. That will make it easy for me to just make a new set of 4 stringers instead of 3 and follow the same rise and run on the 2x12x16s I got. A small-load concrete truck will pour the Sonotubes next week and make my life easier.
Looking for feedback:
Does my shoring, pier, and excavator-backup plan make sense, or am I missing anything?
Any recommendations on the best stone to set stringers on? Any other tips , tricks extra things I should consider? Do you think I should dig down an extra cement pier behind the stairs and add mid span support? It’s 10 stairs and never had one prior. I did add one on my other set of stairs I did but those were a much longer span.
Starting the day now—I’ll post an update tonight with how it goes. Appreciate any advice as I’ve gotten a lot of good help from this page in the past and if my mother-in-law bought a Ford to pay a professional to do what she would do it in a heartbeat, but it’s not in her budget. So the next best option that I had was for me to do it. She’s been a good mother-in-law, so she deserves it. I take pride in trying to do things the right way, and my most important thing is making sure that everything is safe. Although this is not my trade, I do consider myself pretty handy. and willing to learn. I feel by fixing this for her, it’s better than leaving it in the current condition where it was rotted posts, rotted boards up top, etc, with no way to get it fixed.
Since I also couldn’t afford to pay to have it fixed for her, all I could offer was my labor for free. In the end, this has cost about $3000 out of pocket for all materials and rentals, and I think it’ll be a big upgrade from what it was and a lot safer as many deck boards where getting so thin your foot could go threw it and the 4x4s would sway a bit as well as the stringers were bouncy and starting to pull off the rim joist since there’s no brackets. I hope to surprise her on her 70th birthday when she gets back in town and have it all finished up by next week.
Ps - pictures at the end is of the deck I fixed up at my house. If I was to do it again, I would not use those plastic post holders and I would tie everything indirectly to the framing much stronger that way but still learning. Also, the propane tanks have been removed, as I installed that mini split. It was a cantilevered deck prior, but with me adding the stairs, I felt that added a lot of weight, so I added the two support posts, now that I’m doing this deck and I’ve learned a little bit more, I’m doing the support post in 6 x 6s like I should’ve done on that one. definitely a learning process. I will probably go back and switch them to 6 x 6s at some point soon even know everything is solid on that one - took me the most time to do the landing pad and learn how to measure and cut stringers for my first time.