r/ComputerEngineering • u/Difficult_Echidna590 • 19d ago
[Career] Why Does Computer Engineering Have Higher Unemployment Than Computer Science?
I originally planned to major in Computer Science, but I changed my mind to Computer Engineering because I want to explore both hardware and software. My thinking was that this would give me more career options after graduation and make me more adaptable to changes in the technology industry.
However, I recently saw data showing that Computer Engineering graduates have a higher unemployment rate than Computer Science graduates. This confuses me because Computer Engineering is a broad, technically demanding degree that covers both hardware and software.
I want an honest, evidence-based analysis of the following:
Why might Computer Engineering have a higher unemployment rate than Computer Science despite offering knowledge of both hardware and software?
Does this happen because hardware engineering has fewer job openings, because employers require more specialized skills, because of the current technology job market, or for other reasons?
Does Computer Engineering actually give graduates access to more career options, or am I overestimating the advantage of having both hardware and software knowledge?
Why does Computer Engineering have lower underemployment despite its higher unemployment rate? What does that tell us about its career prospects?
How do the career prospects, entry-level opportunities, salaries, and long-term growth of Computer Engineering compare with Computer Science and Electrical Engineering?
Considering that I will graduate around 2031–2032, what risks should I consider? Don’t pretend to know exactly what the job market will look like.
7.If my priorities are employability, a good salary, career flexibility, and the ability to move between hardware and software, which degree structure makes the most
38
u/ragged-robin 19d ago
Actual CE jobs are niche, there's not that many roles open comparatively which makes it very competitive. CE majors who can't get CE jobs fall back to software roles, which is now super flooded with people more prepared for the bar to get in. Then they fall back to IT type of roles, which again is ultra flooded these days. So you do have a lot of versatility to pivot up and down the tech industry ladder, but the industry itself is going through an existential crisis in recent times.
19
u/Hawk13424 BSc in CE 19d ago
They can also pivot to EE jobs. I work at a semiconductor company. The bulk of our designers are CE. Some EE for analog. Some physics for process technology.
9
u/ragged-robin 19d ago
In my head I just lump EE jobs with "CE jobs" but yeah more verbosely it's always been CE -> EE -> SWE -> IT/Tech Sales. This was the case when I graduated in 2013 and it's still true today, except there's waaaaay more people applying to the same jobs at every level now
1
2
u/Snoo_4499 19d ago
What are IT type of roles?
1
u/ragged-robin 19d ago
roles along the path of a sys admin, cybersecurity, systems engineering, tech sales, traditionally starting with lowly helpdesk
17
u/gravity--falls 19d ago
the underemployment for CS degrees is worse than for CE degrees.
The odds of working in your field, so subtracting the chance you are unemployed or underemployed, are better for CE than for CS.
6
u/BlueBlueCatRollin 19d ago
CE here currently looking for a job. I have some speculation, part of that lines up with what you are suggesting.
I do think that "software" is the larger field, where it is reasonably possible to pivot from one discipline to the other, which helps CS people find a spot (not saying it's a good market rn, just allows for more flexibility than CE). Pivoting in CE fields (at junior-level) feels harder to me. If you specialized in FPGA design, nobody is going to consider you for an IC design or embedded role, and vice versa.
from what I hear, hardware or hardware-related has always had a very high entry bar, my pure gut feeling says higher than software. Might be due to longer development cycles, and because the average cost of mistakes is higher (from a product redesign perspective)
I feel like CE is more academic in nature than CS or EE, makes for good stuff to write papers about, but not that many specific CE things to make money with. The CE industry areas that are coming to my mind, that CE is more suited for than CS and EE, would be full-stack embedded design (not only the software or only the hardware), FPGAs, low-level programming like GPU drivers, and some areas of IC design. None of them is particularly large, in the grand scheme of things. Many people write papers about processor or memory architectures, algorithm optimization on hardware, how much of that ever finds its way into the industry aka yields an industry job?
like others said, when you're trying to go into pure software or pure hardware, you're competing with people who are doing only that.
Yes, it always depends on the individual portfolio, but in the light of this discussion, why should I consider a CE person that has a CS portfolio? I might be totally wrong, but my feeling is that, on average, a CE person has to being "more" to the table than a CS person, in order to have same chances on the job market.
4
u/marcuslawson 18d ago
Dude, with AI, forget SWE altogether. Claude can code that shit - why bother with an engineer?
For hardware, I guess there are still roles? But make sure you can code graphics chips (assembly or C++) to make the AI work.
Unless the AI bubble bursts, AI has fucked all of tech.
I am going into plumbing. Everyone still shits, right?
(35 year SWE here)
3
u/GlobalCurry 19d ago
Computer Engineering has always had a lower employment rate than Computer Science students aiming for SWE and companies actually prefer pure EE for many of the electrical roles CE students would target. It was like that before learn to code and AI also.
3
u/Emotional_Fee_9558 19d ago
Outcompeted by EE for hardware type roles, outcompeted by CS for software type roles. There are roles in which CE receives preferences by they are rare.
3
u/TrashyGames3 19d ago
Crap I was planning to switch from EE to CE but now this comment section is scaring me .w.
8
u/Chemical_Variety4696 19d ago
Usually if you don’t have internship while at college you are doomed.
And they target software jobs which they are not great at.
14
u/Phantom_August 19d ago
No, stop that. Just because you don't get an internship in college doesn't mean you're never getting a job. There are new grad jobs that plenty of people get.
2
1
u/ragged-robin 19d ago
Definitely not a guarantee but at the end of the day experience > no experience, so an internship puts you in a better position than someone else who only has school on their resume. This is even more true now than it was in the past with current market conditions
-3
1
u/GlobalCurry 19d ago
I totally skipped internships and got a full time job while still in college, it's not that difficult - or at least wasn't in the past.
2
u/No_Drag2264 19d ago
Honestly no one is going to be able to answer these questions rigorously without using post hoc explanations that are just guesses
1
u/Agitated-Wishbone-84 19d ago
Either pick CS or EE. Both are better choices depending on what you are trying to target.
1
u/Kingbacon01 17d ago
As a CE graduate and now working for 3 years, I found that my skillset applied very well in a small company that required me to wear many hats to get the job done. I started on working on the hardware, firmware, and low level cpp since there wasn’t anyone else that could bridge that gap. Since then I have fallen more into a staff engineer role, but maybe there is better luck for CE grads in smaller companies.
1
u/Tbetcha 17d ago
Idk where you work but staff engineer level with 3 years experience seems kinda crazy and completely unrealistic.
1
u/Kingbacon01 6d ago
I’ve got a knack for that kind of work and it’s the role I was pushed into by the CEO and the other engineers. Note, our team only has ~15 engineers so I wouldn’t consider myself comparable to a staff engineer at a large company, but still get the job done well.
1
u/nian2326076 14d ago
Computer Engineering can indeed face higher unemployment rates, often due to the greater demand for software roles compared to hardware ones. Companies frequently prioritize software skills, which can make it challenging for hardware-focused graduates. To improve your employability, concentrate on developing a solid software foundation, particularly in programming and data structures. You can use LandOffer to find relevant job opportunities that match your skills and interests.
1
u/Syphari 19d ago
More people need software than hardware, it’s always been like this.
It’s why EE is a better pick because you can lean into all the other subfields when the market has dry spots.
0
-3
u/RequirementRude5217 19d ago
Because they are essentially Jack of all Trades master of none. They know software and hardware but not as deep as Ee or CS. If companies want software choose a cs grad. If they want hardware choose an EE grad, because they both respectively have deeper knowledge of their domain. If you want to do CE, do an EE major with CS minor,. It’s essentially the same thing but now you can do EE jobs with the higher domain expertise. It’s what I did
25
u/BronzeGstring 19d ago edited 19d ago
This is such a commonly regurgitated myth
As if a pure EE or CS grad is a master of anything
Employers care way more about your skills and experience than whatever your degree says
You think a company is turning down A CE major with an SWE internship for a CS with no intenrships?
2
u/TravelOk1410 19d ago
Why not use a fair comparison? If both resumes are equal with the only difference being their major, then yea a company is more likely to choose a CS major over a CE major for a SWE role.
2
u/BronzeGstring 19d ago
Well real life isn’t a simulation
There’s nothing like identical candidates except one small difference
Whoever demonstrates their skills and experience better in the interview gets the job
There’s way more to hiring than just what you majored in when it comes to tech
someone with an EE job but no EE degree
1
u/KiroTheImmortal 14d ago
Except you are forgetting how modern applications work. It is filtered out by the same things a simulation compiles. Checkboxes and term counters.
1
u/BronzeGstring 13d ago
ATS isn’t rejecting a CE major for a software position, especially if the skills and experience clearly allign
Stop coping
1
u/Fluffy_Gold_7366 19d ago
What field did you end up working , more HW focused or SW focused?
4
u/RequirementRude5217 19d ago
I ended up in Embedded Systems. An even mix of both. But I did a ton of self study and my own huge project to find a job, as well as an internship. It took me 3 months to find one
4
2
u/Fluffy_Gold_7366 19d ago
What kind of project?
4
u/RequirementRude5217 19d ago
Built a raspberry pi tank with an rpi pico driver for motors and servos that I could drive on my laptop over WiFi with pan and tilt camera
2
2
-3
u/Fearless-Hamster-926 19d ago
Only someone with bad judgement would choose to do CE in the first place so that poor judgement trickles down to bad job seeking abilities.
103
u/zacce 19d ago
Higher unemployment rate because of CpE who targeted SWE roles. They were competing against CS majors who are better suited for SWE.