r/ComputerEngineering • u/NecessaryChair3180 • Feb 27 '25
Will ai take over computer engineering. Is it even worth it to study it in college???
Basically, the other day me and my friends were in our AVID classes and they were asking us our plans for the future, college, etc. I said I wanted to became an Computer Hardware Engineer and study in Computer Engineering and a lot of people started telling me theirs no point bc ai will take my job. I really have no other talent or interest in any other jobs so atp is it even worth it to study it in college. I've asked people and they said I shouldn't be worrying about it bc I'm only 15 and in my sophomore year and I should be worrying about normal kid things but I worry for my future. I feel as if I don't make up my mind now then if I do it last minute I won't be prepared. Is it worth it or not or do I have to change my career path.
6
50
14
u/CharacterWriting9609 Feb 27 '25 edited Mar 01 '25
one of my professors said even the name itself (AI-artificial intelligence) is just a marketing scheme- there’s nothing intelligent about it. it’s basically just a tool and not even a well developed one yet, so don’t worry, it won’t replace engineers anytime soon, if ever
2
u/pairoffish Mar 02 '25
AI as we know it is just the same sort of computer algorithms we've been using for decades, albeit with faster processing and better algorithms but they work essentially the same way. Data > algorithm > result. Sometimes the results are way off but the "AI" would have no way of knowing this, it can't think for itself. There is no actual intelligence going on there and we're still very far from that.
2
Aug 31 '25
Sorry but your professor has a vested interest in that opinion and is frankly ignorant … you understand that these “tools” are constantly learning. It’s more of an issue of processing. Once an ai has enough processing power it will be infinitely smarter and more capable than the most intelligent human . Look at chess and computers and it will be the same trajectory.. computers beat chess masters 100% of the time. That used to be considered impossible. Now consider the fact that the government has been playing with sentient AI for some time. Coding,intelligence work,engineering will 100% be better done by an AI by 2030 and probably already is… they are also capable of processing data instantly where as a human takes hours months or years… they will be better than us in about every way
16
u/TwistedNinja15 Feb 27 '25
Do calculators replace math majors? That's kinda the same thing it's a tool, an important one but tools advance fields, they don't replace them.
1
u/robogame_dev Feb 27 '25
In your example, yes, calculators did replace people - they replaced the occupation of "computers" - people who were paid to do calculations that moved to calculators: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_(occupation)
> The term "computer", in use from the early 17th century (the first known written reference dates from 1613),[1] meant "one who computes": a person performing mathematical calculations, before electronic calculators became available. Alan Turing described the "human computer" as someone who is "supposed to be following fixed rules; he has no authority to deviate from them in any detail."[2] Teams of people, often women from the late nineteenth century onwards, were used to undertake long and often tedious calculations; the work was divided so that this could be done in parallel. The same calculations were frequently performed independently by separate teams to check the correctness of the results.
7
u/TwistedNinja15 Feb 27 '25
They replaced a subset of a profession in the field of mathematics. I was talking about math majors in my comment because OP was talking about majors in college.
2
u/robogame_dev Feb 27 '25
The operant question for OP is whether the material in their school’s CE program is preparing them for a pre-calculator or post-calculator work market. Whether it’s a major or an occupation is the same from the context of op’s question, which is about whether they’ll be able to market the skill they’re acquiring.
After the calculator, human calculators could not market doing calculations. It’s a good analogy to OP’s concern, after the ______, human computer engineers could not market doing ________.
1
u/TheKrazy1 Feb 28 '25
Most people who were employed as computers at the time digital computing came about then became the digital computer operators.
1
Sep 06 '25
Yes maybe 1 in every 100-200 since one person can do the job of 100 people after things got automated... Idk whats up with people and only looking at one angle on things. A.I is not limited like a calculator. It is advancing every single second its basically in its infancy stage we havent even seen the real product. Its not even comparable to the computers we use today, your computer doesnt learn things on its own, and its NOT EVEN in the final state that they are aiming for... Yall are hilarious. A.I is about to change the world for the better or worse.
2
u/iTakedown27 Mar 02 '25
So, where does the AI run? All software runs on hardware. You know who makes that? CE. AI is not fully capable of replacing someone's job because it makes mistakes, and lacks the intuition to solve problems beyond its training data (it's improving with think/reason but still not perfect). Don't listen to your peers because they don't even know about how AI is made or what computer engineering even is.
1
u/burncushlikewood Feb 27 '25 edited Feb 27 '25
I don't think so, in fact AI will create jobs, computers are good at many things but some things they're not. I believe AI will assist us, and create more knowledge based jobs, and automate mundane tasks
1
Sep 06 '25
Yeah except when did your computer absorb the entirety of the internet, analyze it then start learning? You guys are belittling the technology severely. Its only getting better as they scan thousands of books that arent even on the internet giving it insane computing power. You guys also forget the brain is nothing more than a biological computer. If they can build one thats faster, more efficient and accurate (albeit not free willed like us) then apply them to robots... well good luck to everyone around the world keeping any job. A.I in its current state far surpasses the smartest human on earth. It makes mistakes yes... what does that prove exactly? So would the smartest person who ever lived on this earth. One day it will be much more accurate than it is now too...
1
u/bliao8788 Mar 04 '25
yes it is taking over we all gonna be the people in cyberpunk 2077 the government are big tech industries robot automations are doing all works birth rate declined normal people are watching VR all day
1
u/CreativeComposer1271 Nov 18 '25
A lot of people are living in denial, AI will take over most of the engineering jobs in the near future.
1
u/Shadow1126 Jan 31 '26
I do agree but a small but important clarification
They will replace most of our CURRENT jobs
By then we will have different jobs that require the same major but different tasks
It's a very bad and stupid idea to let ai automate itself
And think about it, it's not some nonprofit good for all company who developed ai
No these companies are money hungry and I get you might say they don't want to pay salaries but it's way cheaper to hire underpaid workers then to set up a multiple AI system with checks and Automated mantainance, And also all the money spent in servicing that hardware and routine mantainance
Companies won't risk an investment like that which might or might not even work
Think about it, for people to actually advance and make fully automated tasks via ai the norm, somebody has to do it first
And spend A LOT of money to start it up, and it might not even work
And nobody wants to do that first step when you can hire someone to do it for cheap
So majors will still be used 20-30 years at least into the future, ai is good, but it's good compared to the previous versions we saw
And those aren't even 2% of what we would need for ai to be able to do proper automation risk free
Energy and water consumption is also a big issue
I could go on and on but il be honest you probably forgot about this comment and there is no use unless you want me to keep listing reasons
1
u/Moist_Hospital2684 Feb 04 '26
It will take over some of the redundant coding jobs. CE will become more about baby sitting AI and like quality control and project management. But it won't be manual coding like the past
1
u/Unhappy-Newspaper854 Mar 25 '26
Soy ing sistemas hace 20 años, y lo real es que con una IA una sola persona hace lo que hacian 5 10 años atras, o sea ahi nomas tenes 3 puestos menos, va ver demanda claculo que siempre de gente muy espezializada q trabaje usando IA, perooo para 2030 una sola persona abarcaria el trabajo de 10, entonces va ver trabajo si va ver, pero por un puesto habra 1000 solicitantes, o sea mientras mas especializado estes mas chances vas a tener, pero es matarte estudiando cosas complejas para manejar una empresa y cobrar un poco mas que el remisero, ya el panadero de la esquina sacaria el doble ajaj
0
20
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '25
Nah, we will get more jobs and work lol
Ai is not that good and it's not easy to replace engineers at all, projects are big, there is a lot of stuff in order to run it successfully along with ai, there's security matters, you can't just use all client data with an ai assistant etc
It's difficult, at least it helps a lot more instead of googling, but it's a fun thing engineering, hard but funny.
Now it struggles a lot with circuits and they need a lot of context which means a huge prompt. But most of the time you're going to lose more time giving him the perfect prompt than doing the task, or at least need to divide it.
Jobs more prone to get replaced are the basic ones like HR or administration jobs where they read documents etc
Ai will evolve a lot but so we will do it too, like we always did.
Look at CAD programs, before that there were a lot of people in huge rooms drawing stuff they needed. Now we use programs like CAD and those people have evolved to just use that and make their job easier, not to lose it.
We need more engineers! Always! If not, who's going to handle all the hardware and the AI? Us of course.
You'll have more work here and more opportunities, so don't worry about it, keep studying and if you can study in advance about AI so you'll take advantage of it in college while learning!