r/ComputerEngineering • • Nov 04 '24

[Project] Can this technically be called a computer? Its got 2 registers and can do load, store, add, sub, NAND, jump, jump if zero, output and halt operations. Are there any good computer-building habits i have to follow? Also would this be feasible on a breadboard?

Post image
97 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

68

u/SokkasPonytail Nov 04 '24

Can this technically be called a computer

Does it compute things? If yes, yes. If no, no.

16

u/Carbonrade Nov 04 '24

I guess that was a low-bar question. Thanks, regardless..

9

u/SokkasPonytail Nov 04 '24

To answer your breadboard question, it may take a few but yes, give it a shot. It's always fun to create a monster and see it work.

And as far as "good habits", don't use components you don't need. I haven't given your image too deep of an inspection but from what I've seen it looks fine. I'm sure there's always more optimizing you can do but really it all depends on what level you're building at. As long as you're not cramming pointless components into your stuff you're on the right track. Reading documentation for the components you're using is usually the best bet for using a component "correctly".

18

u/RE-SUCc Nov 04 '24

Is this Turing complete?

Sorry I'm just doing a light glance at the logic

5

u/Carbonrade Nov 04 '24

yeah

16

u/RE-SUCc Nov 04 '24

Congratulations! It's a computer.

5

u/RE-SUCc Nov 04 '24

Also yes you can set this up on a breadboard. But it'll be massive.

1

u/Khalid-MJ Nov 05 '24

I hate that im a senior computer engineering student and I don’t know what that means

3

u/BornAce Nov 07 '24

It looks a lot more like a state machine.

1

u/Carbonrade Nov 07 '24

Arent all real-world computers state machines?

1

u/BornAce Nov 07 '24

In a sense, yes. While a state machine is designed to model simple, well-defined behaviors with a limited number of states, a real computer can handle intricate computations with vast amounts of data and complex logic but is still considered a finite state machine simply because it can't think outside the box. This is changing a little bit with AI coming into the picture.

6

u/monocasa Nov 04 '24

Yep, it's turing complete.

3

u/HONKACHONK Nov 04 '24

A computer:

✅Has memory

✅Has input

✅Has output

✅Does some sort of computation/manipulation

Being Turing complete could also be added to those requirements, but looks like this one is also Turing complete

2

u/64-Bits Student Nov 04 '24

What simulation software is this?

2

u/RE-SUCc Nov 04 '24

Logisim

1

u/Muhannad_Alghamdi Nov 08 '24

I recommend to search about MIPS Architecture CPU using same software “Logisim”

You will build more functional computer and also can be programmable using Assembly language in MARS