r/ComputerEngineering • • Apr 24 '24

[Discussion] The culture divide between computer engineering and computer science is becoming quite noticeable

Slightly off topic from actual computer engineering (this question is genuine interest and I just wanna hear some ideas), but I think workplace/professional culture is a large part of talk in the “tech” industry today. Even in college it is incredibly noticeable, the divide between computer science and computer engineering.

From what I have seen on the internet and picked up from my classes in college, it seems those that lean into computer engineering (or computer science with concentration in hardware) tend to really be nerdy for the topic of computers. They might not have to give up all their time for it, but it seems that these types of people tend to enjoy learning about the stuff and genuinely enjoy their classes. I know me and my computer engineering pals either are really into programming or really into hardware and we like to mess around with little projects and are genuinely interested in the topic.

Meanwhile, I find computer science majors (specifically those going into software engineering/ software and systems degrees) and software engineers (career wise) to complain quite a bit about their coursework/jobs and tend to not really enjoy what they do. It is kind of strange to me why this occurs because it seems like a recent shift within the last 10 years has caused a major uptick in software engineers who are basically over glorified finance majors working in web dev who constantly talk about their “stack” and are really interested in shit like crypto and blockchain. Also there is a lot of people who get into it because they think it’s “easy” money and that it’s not as hard as engineering. The field is WILDLY oversaturated

I am not necessarily trying to shit on the computer science majors out there, I know some great guys. But I also know wayyy too many shitty people in my cs classes as compared to my computer engineering classes and I’m more of wondering what caused this divide? I don’t think computer science is that easy, but it seems like it’s because universities have began spoonfeeding cs majors because of the huge crowd piling into the cs classes that make sit easy to float by on Cs. Also it’s just kind of annoying when I’m trying to discuss programming with other people and they start talking about their tech stack and all this overly complex mumbo jumbo that doesn’t even make a difference. I like to call these guys “tech hipsters”

What do you think? Does it matter? Does it not matter? Do these people annoy you? Are you this person (if so I’m sorry)? Most importantly, what led to the state of cs that it is in right now.

89 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

60

u/conan557 Apr 24 '24

Computer engineering is too hard. CS is a lot easier. It makes sense why people pick CS. But doing that limits the potential that they could have had for other fields. example? Some the CS people could have been great doctors, teachers, physician assistants, physical therapists, etc…

3

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 24 '24

Very true!

11

u/TheKiznaProject Apr 24 '24

Can confirm, transferring from cpeg to comp sci currently after realizing it’s too hard.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

What class was the breaking point for you? Really curious cause I didn’t know people did this I thought if you want out of CE you’d switch to something like IT or Data Science

1

u/Interesting_Cookie25 Apr 26 '24

I feel like data science is further from CE than it is CS, almost like you’re skipping a step to get there

And IT is somewhere in between but more focused on specific types of careers that people mostly see as a separate thing

Just curious, what makes you associate CE with those versus CS? For me, its been a lot of low level programming, embedded systems, and some processor design work, so its not exactly close to CS but much closer than that compared to Data Science or IT

9

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

I just completed my senior project and am getting ready for graduation, I looked at the enrollment numbers and saw that my school’s CMPEN has 62 people graduating this semester while our CMPSC has 280. After talking to my group mates (Al other Comp Eng majors) about it that is basically what they told me and that they all have friends who switched. I never thought that was something that happens, I’ve heard the computer people drop into IST if they can’t cut it but never that CE switch from CS. It’s honestly really surprising I feel like they are so similar. Is CE really noticeably harder.

5

u/oklol555 Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24

Computer Engineer is too hard

The difficulty of your degree depends entirely on what school you went to. Look up the exams at top schools like MIT and compare them to your average school.

While you're both taking Calculus I, in terms of difficultly, it's like Calculus 1 vs Calculus 100000000.

Degrees outside of top schools are pretty easy and doable for most people.

7

u/bihari_baller Apr 25 '24

As long as it’s ABET accredited, it doesn’t matter where you get your degree.

0

u/oklol555 Apr 25 '24

ABET is the bare minimum really and not really sign of quality. There are tons of low rank/no-name and online diploma mills with ABET accreditation.

2

u/bihari_baller Apr 26 '24

and not really sign of quality.

That's the entire point of ABET. To get a standard to adhere to.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24

[deleted]

1

u/bihari_baller Apr 26 '24

Yeah, good schools like UIUC, Purdue, CU-Boulder, Georgia Tech and the likes all offer online degrees. They're certainly not diploma mills.

-1

u/Warguy387 Apr 25 '24

the fuck is calculus 1000 lol do you just mean analysis

26

u/lightmatter501 Apr 25 '24

I think that what you are seeing is a distinction between “software engineers” and “programmers”. I know a lot of CE people don’t like software engineers as a term, but let me explain why I think there is a subset of CS people who do qualify.

I’m CS, which to me means that gate level upwards is what I need to care about. I know verilog (but prefer VHDL and Chisel), I’ve built a RISC-V CPU in an FPGA (not a very good one, but it functioned), and I’ve had to implement PICe gen 3 and 4 because some dumbass bought FPGAs without hard IP blocks for it. I also know Haskell and Erlang, which are pretty far from the metal, among many languages in between.

I primarily work on distributed databases. Something like 80% of the codebase is formally verified against a variety of issues. FPGAs are used as accelerators and as a way to provide real time cores for some processes on an x86 server. I consider this an engineering project, because it’s mathematically checked to only exhibit desirable properties to the greatest extent possible (the last 20% would require months of super-computer time to verify). Some of the properties include “will continue to function without interruption if 2 arbitrary continents disappear” (simulating widespread catastrophic power grid failure) and “will continue to make progress as long as the network is not infinitely bad” (packet loss/corruption/asynchrony). This is a complex system by necessity, not because we want to use serverless web 3.0 javascript powered by edge microservices to pad our resume. We build it following standard engineering methodologies, adapted for “it costs 20 minutes of compile time to produce a prototype of a new design, not a week of shipping”, which does change a lot. If civil engineers could snap their fingers, have a bridge show up and then drive a bunch of stuff across it, cause an earthquake and then make a bomb go off before saying “oops forgot the middle support”, and reverting it back to where it was before, they would be less careful too. CE sees some of this because you will frequently be far less careful with what you write to an FPGA than what you would tape out and send to a fab.

Most people with a CS degree would be hopelessly lost in this project. That is because there is a pool of software engineers who do actual engineering work inside of CS, and then a big pool of people who would have failed out of an engineering program but made it through a CS program that got slapped together when the field exploded in popularity. That second group are the programmers. The first group is where passionate people who are exposed to the existence of actual engineering in software frequently end up. These are the people who would still be CS if we had the same exam requirements that CE does.

The reason that CS exploded is because most software can fail with an “Oopsie woopsie, we did a bad” error page without any issues, but when it’s not failing it acts as a massive productivity multiplier. This creates an incentive to have a bunch of people who barely know what they’re doing under a senior developer who could probably do the whole thing themselves given enough time because they still make the company money. You’ll notice that companies which sell to businesses and provide strict SLAs tend to have people who would qualify as engineers working for them, because there’s a financial incentive to have people who actually know what they’re doing. CE has much larger consequences for failure on average, so the minimum bar has to be set much higher.

If the bar for CS was set where I think the CE bar is, at least 80% of developers would be looking for work. The remaining 20% would be the exceptions to your complaints. There would still be some shiny tech chasing, but we all know that if it cost nothing to get FPGAs with interesting hard IP blocks, or if you could 3d print an ASIC in your basement with a $200 machine, that CE would probably have similar tends and hot new technologies because getting to play with cool stuff is fun.

“CS with a focus on hardware” is the group you are most likely to see, and is one of the two groups I have a foot in. There’s also distributed systems, where you are expected to design systems that will survive some number of catastrophic hardware failures, yet still be able to ingest tens to thousands of gigabytes of data per second. There’s the people doing the actual math behind AI and ML, who are closer to mathematicians than engineers. Then there are the people who focus on CS theory, who are making new languages and algorithms. There is very much a core group of passionate, competent people in CS, but few of us wanted to write HTML and JS for a living, and it’s not actually that hard, so we hand those jobs out to almost random people who show up and learn a little. CE doesn’t have a low stakes, low effort area to put people in.

1

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 25 '24

I like this post a lot, explains a lot. Thank you!

7

u/CompEng_101 Apr 25 '24

People going in to computers for the money is nothing new, but there probably been an uptick. Software Engineering is seen as a good way to make money, CPEG is less talked about. And kids are more conscious of the economics of college degrees. When I went to undergrad 25+ years ago there was a lot of talk about using college to explore your interests and ‘chase your dreams’.

The last 20 years or so have been a steady drumbeat of media stories about college debt and fear of ‘useless’ degrees in the humanities. As a result there has been a shift towards STEM subjects and you get more people picking a degree based on what will give the best return on investment. In this subreddit you probably see at least a question a week which boils down to ‘which career path will make me the most money?’ And where the asker doesn’t even mention which path they find personally interesting.

With the costs of college and general economic uncertainty I can’t blame students for trying to make pragmatic career choices, but it is kinda sad to see so many folks pursuing something out of profit and not passion.

5

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 25 '24

See, I can’t necessarily blame students for choosing cs as a career path because of what you talked about, but it is kind of ridiculous just how oversaturated the market is, and just how many people there are in cs/software engineering. I do feel for them though; but I feel like even without humanities everyone has something that interests them a little that makes money. For instance my girlfriend is an artist and really wanted to go into cs for the money (I never discouraged it but I knew she would hate it). She then took a one off chemistry class and found she loved it and got into biochemistry and now she’s doing pharmaceutical sciences. I feel like these people just say “let’s do what makes the most money” when those talents and skills could be allocated in something that they just don’t know they like.

You made great points though, and I do think it’s sad that we live in a world where that is necessary to survive

2

u/CompEng_101 Apr 25 '24

but it is kind of ridiculous just how oversaturated the market is

Maybe. I'm always a little wary about pronouncements that a computing field is oversaturated, because I've been hearing variants of that for decades. In the early 2000s, after the dot-com bubble burst, CS was declared oversaturated. Shortly after, as out-sourcing picked up, CS was oversaturated because everything would be shipped to India. At other times, I've seen folks declare that NoCode, Bootcamps, or AI were going to make CS degrees obsolete within a few years. Through all of this, the employment rates for people with CS degrees have remained generally high and higher than most other degrees.

But, it's also important to recognize that a lot of folks with CS (or other engineering degrees) often don't become 'practicing' engineers – they go into law, management, politics, teaching, etc... Even in these fields, the engineering background is useful and helpful, so even if the actual engineering discipline is oversaturated, the skills are pretty useful elsewhere. I don't expect to see breadlines of CS degree holders any time soon. :-)

I do feel for them though; but I feel like even without humanities everyone has something that interests them a little that makes money. 

This is probably true. I think it is unfortunate the way that the education system is set up which makes it difficult to discover your interests and really get a feel for what different careers really entail.

I feel like these people just say “let’s do what makes the most money” when those talents and skills could be allocated in something that they just don’t know they like.

Definitely true. It's like the Knuth quote: "Premature Optimization is the Root of All Evil.' :-)

2

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 25 '24

Haha love the knuth quote! And yes, I’m sure it’s just really blown up. I have tried to equate the idea of oversaturation to just how people perceive it online: I feel as though quite a lot of cs guys are online a lot so maybe that’s why theees much more representation in the internet and it’s just perceived oversaturation. Who knows haha!

11

u/itsfrancissco Apr 24 '24 edited Apr 25 '24

I also find this strange. Many CS students are there for the money rather than for the sake of interest. Very few are the people who go for engineering while not liking it. The people who pick CE already know how hard it is and are already experienced in terms of mathematics… For example, I have a midterm exam in differential equations tomorrow morning and none of my friends is studying because it’s easy for us, we’re already programmed this way. We enjoy math. On the other hand, (and what I actually found strange) is how CS students (not all of them of course) tend to hate maths and struggle with it although it goes hand in hand with technology… I am also currently taking data structure, a CS elective in my program that most CS students hate and discouraged me to take… Like… WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING HERE IF YOU’RE HATING ON A CRUCIAL SUBJECT FOR YOUR MAJOR!? I rarely notice CS students enjoying things, while I see myself along my fellow CE competing against each other in projects and actually enjoying giving all our time for the sake of a successful project. Again, I’m not talking about all CS students, but about a really good portion still… One reason I didn’t switch to CS is that I found I wouldn’t enjoy not building robots, circuits etc… So it seems that the REAL computer scientists are the ones doing computer engineering…

7

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 24 '24

I think its so strange how cs students hate math because if we’re looking at the actual definition of computer science it came straight from discrete math, set theory, and graph theory, which is very high level math, but most of undergrad just touches on very basic stuff needed for software engineering

8

u/Tittytickler Apr 25 '24

I got my degree in CS and I love math, but I went the data science/machine learning route ¯_(ツ)_/¯. Liking math and hands on stuff is probably why I like doing hobbyist embedded stuff.

3

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 25 '24

You sir are the type of cs guy I like :D. Seriously I think if you love math doing the cs/data science/ machine learning is great combo and its people like that that I find to be much more passionate about the stuff

3

u/Tittytickler Apr 25 '24

Yea honestly the biggest reason I wound up sticking with CS even though I also love the CSE is because it was going to take me at least an extra year to graduate... I just turned 30 so that was becoming a bit too much. Luckily I've been doing full stack development this entire time but still, just wanted to lock down that degree. I do have a serious passion for it!

1

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 24 '24

Absolutely this!!!

5

u/KublaiKhanNum1 Apr 25 '24

Yeah, the School I went to CS was actually part of the Math Department. Computer Engineering on the other hand was in the School of Engineering. I choose CE as I thought it might be more practical than purely theoretical. I like to tinker and experiment. CE had more opportunities for that.

2

u/Zerx_ILMGF Apr 25 '24

I honestly had no good math background going into this, i mean i had to take precal in my uni , but I hated it at first but then slowly started loving math, but i still find it hard. Some of my friends with math background have no trouble with my current cal 2 class. Which is very interesting and i wish i had a math background

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24

Its true and I think the saturation in CS is in part due to the amount of people joining for pay and eye candy. Programs are also incredibly easy to cheat thru without learning anything. Majority of my school's CS program cheated thru the major and everyone could tell when we got to our capstone class. CS as a major is going thru a "businessification" where there are less and less nerdy and genuinely interested folks pursuing it (at least from my exp)

1

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 26 '24

Yes! This is exactly what I see too! It sucks because I love cs and programming

4

u/hauntedyew Apr 25 '24

There’s a reason why you have a whole new cohort of CompSci graduates without job prospects who only know front end design and have zero passion for computers at all. The university’s marketed CompSci and the potentially big salaries quite well.

1

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 25 '24

Yeah it’s crazy!

3

u/bobking01theIII Apr 24 '24

I think part of it is that in (at least my) secondary school, comp eng is way more hands-on and project-oriented. I joke about my labs amounting to "Spend 3 hours turning on an LED" but they really encourage you to do shit on your own and make stuff, especially since my school lets you grab whatever components you need for free as long as you can return them.

Meanwhile, all the enouragement CS students get is... programming contests? I compared posters in the eng department and the CS department at my school since they're in the same building and most of the CS stuff is seminars and job search help while the engineering students have double digits worth of posters for engineering clubs (including inter-program clubs like EV design).

1

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 25 '24

That’s so cool they let u get components! My physics professor (I’m doing a physics minor and research with him) knew I was pretty interested and let me have some but hard cool. I agree 100% on the project orientedness.

There is way more engineering stuff as well at my school. It’s kind of funny, we have programming competitions too, but me and my other computer engineering friend are the ONLY ONES who do it. Kind of crazy the only two competent enough programmers are computer engineers LMAO

2

u/Fabulous-Ad-2003 May 03 '24

Can confirm CE is very hard. I will say reqs for CS were higher in terms of gpa, which to some is harder. I think the CE reqs were a 2.8 and the CS were 3.5 - PAC12 school

1

u/C_Sorcerer May 03 '24

Very true, I believe ours is like this too!

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

As a CS major who is regretting not choosing computer engineering because I am truly nerdy about computers and wanna do hardware and software I am really enjoying my classes even the math it's really hard and I am not doing great but still enjoying lol mean while my CS pals truly hate everything we take except programming lol so ye I noticed this

1

u/C_Sorcerer May 09 '24

Yeah but that doesn’t mean if you are cs that you don’t care! You seem to really care. It’s just an overgeneralization and a trend I see in cs but it’s just so odd how we’ve gotten to this point!

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

Because tons of people literally just like being called software engineers and entered because everyone keeps saying money money

Just wait until the recent layoffs news get everywhere and CS is gonna be the smelly disgusting people again who literally love keyboards more than their parents

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24

The comments make me wanna switch from CS to Comp eng lol

2

u/C_Sorcerer Apr 25 '24

Haha you should! However if you can’t for some reason, you should either do a hardware related concentration or you should stick with software but just separate yourself from the crowd by doing really good and learning more and doing projects. Whatever you choose I’m sure you’ll do great!

5

u/Dotsially Apr 25 '24

I did the same. It is pretty hard, especially math courses but my experience with programming from CS makes it a bit easier. Its definitely not for everyone tho you need to enjoy the work and have a lot of motivation to go through with it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24

Are u happy w ur choice? What made u wanna move?

4

u/Dotsially Apr 26 '24

Didn't feel like I was actually learning anything in CS. I really wanted to know how computers work from the bottom up. Instead I was working with web frameworks and java... So yea definitely happy with my choice.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24

That describes my current situation pretty well lol

2

u/Tar-det-inte Jan 19 '25

Wow this sounds like me right now. I'm about a year into my CS degree, and having programmed since teenage years I have maybe squeezed a couple of learnables from all my classes. About the equivalent of 2 weeks-worth of hobby programming time. The classes feel so pointless it's actually hard to pay attention to them.

Super considering CE right now...

2

u/schweinjager Apr 25 '24

I don't know how far along you are, but I made that switch early on and haven't looked back since. I have been enjoying the coursework and classmates so much more... especially the classmates part, I couldn't make any friends in cs, and not for a lack of trying! But in CE it's hard not make friends with a lot of your classmates.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24

First year still...I just would like to do something more hands on

No because I also have this exact problem about not making friends in CS despite trying. Why is it easier in CE?

2

u/schweinjager Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24

There were a lot of reasons for me, one of them is that we have a lot of Chinese foreign exchange students in our cs program, and I found that they tend to stick together in their own circles and not really branch out much. I have been flat out ignored by them when I try to interact, even in the classroom. I'm not hating on them, of course, that's just my experience. But the biggest reason for me is that I was in it for the passion, but it felt like everyone around me didn't actually enjoy CS, there were quite a few people I tried to befriend who were only in it for the money, or were just putting in little to no effort. The same sort of people doing that in CE get filtered out like freshman year. So by the time you are a junior, everyone around you has their passions and interests aligned. You also have the added bonus of significantly reduced class sizes, as there just aren't as many CE students as CS. Meaning you will be around the same people throughout your degree.

I'm definitely with you on your struggles though, it was pretty lonely in cs.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24

Well, I'm actually glad to hear its not really a ME issue. Everyone seems a bit souless and unmotivated I just assumed thats how tech people were lol.

I've been reviewing what I think is the comp engineering course outline my uni provides, and while it doesn't explicitly mention 'computer engineering,' upon examining the syllabus, it seems to align closely. As someone who is actually doing the degree, could you agree that the content covered in this program appears to resemble that of a computer engineering degree?

I am thinking of contacting the uni as well ofcourse and asking. What stumps me is that they write possible careers as:

  • Computer systems engineer

  • Software engineer

https://www.qut.edu.au/courses/bachelor-of-engineering-honours-computer-and-software-systems

2

u/schweinjager Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24

It is definitely not a you issue, a lot of people I've met in Engineering have a pretty similar experience. Looking at the your course outline, it seems to be very similar. I am from the US, where 'software engineer' isn't a protected term like 'aerospace engineer' is, so a lot of things that aren't engineering at all get labeled software engineering, so the title kinda loses its meaning. It seems to me like your program is a dedicated software engineering course, which is like a CS degree with a major focus on Hardware, or a CE degree without the EE aspect. the only difference I see with my course syllabus, is that we are required to take a specific math classes; Calc 1 through PDE, some physics; classical and EM, and three semesters of analog circuit design/theory. But the core CE classes, like digital systems design, embedded systems design, and computer systems are very similar to yours I think. I would definitely talk to an advisor though and get more information.

And yeah, those careers look about right, a CE could land you one of those jobs over here. Albeit with more career variety. For instance I'm taking some dedicated VLSI design and fabrication classes, with hope that I could get a career in it.

Here is a link to my course syllabus, it is missing a few required classes though, but nothing major.

https://www.ece.utah.edu/ce-requirements/

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24

Hmm thank you very much for looking into it. So, I guess this degree I'm looking at is more software engineering than computer engineering. Now I'm not so sure if I should transfer.

Thanks again :)

1

u/schweinjager Apr 25 '24

Happy to help, good luck.

2

u/vocaloidfan12434907 Apr 26 '24

I see that you go to the U. I have an unrelated question as a high school senior going to the U next year. I accepted direct admit to engineering and then direct admit to computer science. Is it possible to still switch to computer engineering before starting college? It's alright if you can't answer this question though.

2

u/schweinjager Apr 27 '24

I did the exact same thing you did, both direct admit to the school of engineering and CS department. I made the switch to computer engineering freshman year, and it was like a 5 min process with an advisor. It should be really easy to switch to CE before you start. I'm guessing you haven't had your initial meeting with an advisor for on boarding, that would be a good chance to talk to them about it. I wish you luck.

Feel free to DM me specific questions, I'd be happy to help.

2

u/vocaloidfan12434907 Apr 27 '24

Wow thats simpler than I thought. You're right that I haven't had an initial meeting yet, so I probably will get to doing that soon. Thanks for the help!

2

u/schweinjager Apr 27 '24

Happy to help, good luck.