r/ComputerEngineering • • Dec 29 '23

Why is computer engineering getting bashed?

I’ve seen some computer science graduates belittling computer engineering in terms of pay, studies and work. Im currently in my last school year and I’m interested in computer engineering but the bashing pops up. Please help to convince me out with info on why computer engineering is good

251 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/LegitGamesTM Dec 30 '23

This is kind of true, although CS majors do get an advantage over software engineer jobs (high level).

10

u/yaeh3 Dec 30 '23

What I meant is that it isn't black and white. If these three majors applied for the same software job, the one with most experience and knowledge is going to get hired.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23

[deleted]

3

u/yaeh3 Dec 30 '23

That is the opposite for us here in Germany. College status does not matter at all. A CE that went to a shitty applied university that does absolutely no math and laughably easy coursework and exams is equal to CEs that go through Calculus 1,2,3, excruciating exams and all the stupidly hard EE physics classes. Absolutely crazy to me. It is because employers do not care if you know how to do fourier transformations at the end of the day.

3

u/Karyo_Ten Dec 30 '23

Me hiring people for doing GPU-accelerated cryptographic Fourier Transform (aldo called NTT, Number Theoretic Transform) 🤨

1

u/yaeh3 Dec 30 '23

You might be the only person in the world hiring for this job. Just kidding. You get my point though. A lot of the coursework we do in a tough curriculum won't be necessary for employment. Most of CEs go into software anyway.

4

u/Karyo_Ten Dec 30 '23

You would be surprised, it's widely used for:

  • all Post-Quantum Cryptography today requires lattices which requires Fast Fourier Transform

  • Error-Correcting Codes, used in ECC RAM or file system like ZFS or BTRFS requires fast fourier transform

  • All Fully Homomorphic Encryption, getting big for private deep learning, require very fast GPU FFT, even considering FPGA.

  • Zero Knowledge proofs as well require very fast GPU FFT or FPGA.

  • Shamir Secret Sharing to securely create shared secrets / threshold signatures where M people out of N can sign a message on behalf of the group.

The high performance cryptography field has grown tremendously and there are many companies with millions to tens of millions in VC funding that are eother bottlenecked by it or trying to solve it.