r/ComputerEngineering • u/Waveparticle44 • Sep 12 '23
Is A Computer Engineering Degree Worth It Now?
I am at my final year of high school and I am considering pursuing Computer Engineering for post-secondary education. I know that there has been a great demand for computer engineering in the past decade and there are a lot of career options to choose from. I tried to explain it to my parents and they're concerned that it won't be stable career in the future because of AI.
Are their concerns valid? Should I choose another career pathway if I am aiming for stability and long-time employment?
73
u/computerarchitect CPU Architect Sep 12 '23
I see no risk. I can't even get ChatGPT to produce good code (not just correct, but look like it was written by a professional) for anything beyond trivial stuff. It's even worse for circuit design.
2
Sep 11 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/computerarchitect CPU Architect Sep 12 '24
I'm glad you're having fun with it! There's some extreme joy seeing those work.
50
u/Affectionate_Wave_19 Sep 12 '23
It's always people who have minimal idea about tech that have those opinions. Who exactly will operate, maintain, and create A.I that'll suppossedly take over the world??
8
u/Affectionate_Wave_19 Sep 12 '23
Although I'll admit I'm biased but still ai will only create more jobs not remove but that's just my take just another ce student 🤷♂️
16
u/WumboAsian Sep 12 '23
It will create more jobs. But it will also take some jobs
9
2
u/shrubbyspex Sep 14 '23
Correct, replace’s the lower competence jobs though. Creates more higher competence jobs
37
u/TacticalBastard Computer Engineering + Science Sep 12 '23
Saying AI is replacing jobs in Computing is like saying that there are no more mathematicians after the Computer was invented.
6
u/adambjorn Sep 17 '23
I think this is the best analogy on the topic I have heard, going to steal this.
1
27
u/-dag- Sep 12 '23
Let me recount a story I've told before.
When I started college, IBM was in the toilet and my dad thought I was making a terrible, terrible mistake by pursuing a computer engineering degree.
I now make good money working on compilers for HPC and AI.
You'll be fine.
17
u/monocasa Sep 12 '23
Computer engineering will be the last to be automated by AI. Someone has to keep tabs on the AI.
14
u/I_burn_stuff Sep 12 '23
It's an engineering degree. There's an extremely good chance that it's going to still be in demand in a century.
12
Sep 12 '23
Computer engineering is great. Where did you hear otherwise? You’ll learn about electronics/circuits/programming/design etc. which is an awesome foundation on which to build a rewarding career. I’m a mechanical engineering major and I enjoyed the circuits class/lab I took so I considered switching to CpE for a while but frankly I just enjoy ME so I’m sticking with it. However, from the research that I did I knew that CpE (like many other engineering disciplines) offered the potential to provide a great career and good income, but like a lot of things in life what you get out of it will largely depend on what you put into it.
3
u/RayTrain Sep 12 '23 edited Sep 12 '23
I've been using ChatGPT a lot lately and it's pretty useless for anything technical. It gets things wrong every time I give it anything. AI is a valuable tool if you use it right for some things but it's absolutely not replacing any engineer any time even sort of soon. FWIW I'm an AI grad student and have been a full firmware engineer for a bit over 2 years. Other important notes, they could say that about literally any other career too, someone is going to have to be around to make sure whatever the AI does is actually managed properly and works, someone still needs to fully understand the code the AI produces, someone needs to have the knowledge and skills to prompt the AI to produce exactly what code is needed and confirm that code generated is correct, your parents have absolutely no idea what they're talking about, and they should stop giving in to media fear mongering over 'scary new technology'.
4
u/Phantom_August Sep 12 '23
With all do respect to your parents, they have no idea what they're talking about. No A.I is going to make a field in engineering become useless. If A.I does take over engineering, then it's likely that everyone else's job has been taken over.
2
u/AKAK999 Sep 12 '23
Don't worry bro, you will be the one to serve our future lord and Savior, there'll be plenty of jobs and money to be make lol
2
u/Dota2Curious Sep 12 '23
I heard the market is saturated at the moment but who knows what it’ll look like in the future.
3
u/WumboAsian Sep 12 '23
It should be put clear that typically, Computer Engineering refers to low-level programming of circuits. Things like Verilog, System Verification, VLSI. It is programming, but has quite a bit of Electrical Engineering knowledge involved.
Your comment sounds more so like Computer Science which is more of high-level programming. Stuff like Software Engineering, Data Science, Cybersecurity. This is not to say that people who have gotten CE degrees can’t work in Tech (which I hate that this is the coined term because a good chunk of “tech” is missing in the term like EE and ME and it just refers to software, but that’s a different conversation). It is actually very common for CE majors to just go into Tech.
Overall, my personal opinion is that CE makes you more robust as you should leave college with electrical engineering knowledge + programming capabilities. Whereas CS puts you in only programming, but you get different flavors of it. I think it is a lot easier to pick up programming outside of a college environment compared to engineering.
6
1
u/_hacker_404 Nov 21 '24
I graduated CE about a year ago, honestly the market is messed up for everyone. It’s more of a post covid crisis than a engineering crisis. Society nowadays needs lots of engineer especially CE/ EE.
I was talking to a friend of mine (a lawyer) and they don’t have any jobs. You have 60 people competing for 1 role…
Lots of my friends in EE are working in CE/SWE at the moment. The nice thing about CE is you have a certain flexibility to go for a swe job or (a bunch of) EE job.
As for AI, I think it will affect every other fields before affecting CE/EE. Plus even if software get hit, you have a CE degree you switch into something more hardware related/ electronics/ electrical.
1
May 21 '25
Hey, which degree is more useful in the long run? I’m starting college this summer and I’m in a dilemma whether to choose comp engineering or comp sci. I’m currently in comp engineering but might wanna change to comp sci before college starts. I feel comp engineering is more difficult compared to comp sci.
1
u/NotAQuietKid Jan 29 '26
its been two years, do yall think these opinions are still viable to the next 4?
1
1
u/Mjlkman Sep 12 '23
Yes, but do note it's now more popular because unfortunately so many people go for computer science and get rejected; they go for similar fields just to graduate and find a Career in software engineering unrelated to computer engineering.
So it will be more competitive if you're going to a big school keep note of that. Best journey on your travels!
1
u/theonehaihappen Computer Engineering Sep 12 '23
Two points:
(1) The current hype around "AI" is something to be concerned about, just not in the terms your parent are thinking. Are your parents engineers or other tech professionals? I guess not. It is probably a good idea to try to explain the limitations of the current generation of bullshit generators to them in an analogy I have grown fond of:
"AI" like ChatGPT are like talking parrots. Parrots hear phrases, interpret context clues, and makes noise depending on the situation. But they have no understanding of the meaning of the spoken word "grape" other than if the human says "do you want a grape?", it makes noise imitating the words "polly wants grape" and it gets a grape. It has not learned to answer a question, it has learned that in response to hearing certain noises to make certain noises to get a reward. However, many parrots are much smarter than this. They can piece certain contexts together and express themselves. "AI" isn't and can't. It just remembers much more input and can try lots of ways to put an output together that satisfies its reward/success function before presenting one. The result is a very convincing Imitative Parrot.
(2) (DISCLAIMER: I am from Germany, and did not experience your secondary education first-hand.) "I am aiming for stability and long-time employment" the CE employment sector seems relatively stable. There is known wage dumping in areas that are hubs for the tech economy, which is also usually overpriced and cost-of-living barely affordable even for mid-level engineers. My recommendation would be to look for a small to medium sized tech company that is not located in an overprized hub, has existed for 5+ years, is not a perpetual start-up, and does not seem to have high employee turnover. If possible, look for remote work opportunities that allow you to move where\when you want and can afford.
But that comes after getting a degree. When starting out, you should ask yourself two questions:
Am I good at what I am doing?, and
do I enjoy doing it?
And you should ask them early, already in Uni/College, before sinking a lot of money and time into a degree for something you hate/suck at. (both usually go hand in hand)
From what I have gathered reading about your education system, I would recommend going to an inexpensive college/uni, getting a side job in a tech company early on. Even if it is only being on call in first-level support. If the work does not suit you, switch to something else. Even a year or two of (life-)experience will give you more perspective.
Good luck.
1
Sep 12 '23
It's far from a concern yet. Even if the technology could really replace us, remember management always need someone to blame when stuff goes wrong.
1
u/promotionartwork Sep 12 '23
I will be really surprised if we see an AI troubleshooting hardware and software simultaneously in the near future.
1
u/dsmth2 Sep 12 '23
Yeah I can't even get chatgpt to handle things like calculating time complexity for simple code. I can usually challenge it and it will defer to whatever I present. We are safe for now
1
1
u/ThanosCarinFortnite Sep 12 '23
When it comes to tech ignore anyone not qualified. To the average person tech is magic. But to the bright minds if society… its also magic unless they work in tech. Modern AI is gimmicky. Its neat and gets clicks but far from useful in a development environment on its own, only with heavy supervision is it useful (and usually just to automate tedium). Regardless of how educated or how much authority someone has, if they arent in tech they’re most likely talking out of their ass.
1
u/Mental_Resource_1620 Sep 12 '23
Its a good career but COMPETITIVE. everyone is going to comp sci or comp eng. You cant just get a 4yr degree and think you'll get a job, you NEED to be good at it. Personal projects, always learning new software/programs. Its hard but it pays well.
1
u/AdVast2933 Sep 12 '23
So which would you consider easier to get into: EE or CompE?
1
u/Mental_Resource_1620 Sep 12 '23
Depends Where you live. If you live in a big city, and plan on getting a job in the city, getting a comp E job will be nearly impossible. I saw a job listing for remote comp sci job in NYC with 1.2K applicants. If you plan on living in the suburbs not near a city, ur competition is less so either EE or CE you could get into, also depends what technical side you want to do
1
u/boxcarbrains Sep 12 '23
Go for it but be careful of the cost. Do what you can to make it as little as possible.
I come from psychology and have a masters in quantitative visual perception, we did a ton of AI work. Really just use chatGPT for debugging these days and mainly program and optimize an ERP lol
1
1
Sep 12 '23
NO, it's actually quite the opposite. These AI or large language models require a lot of computational resources and really need Hardware people to design more efficient hardware for them. If you don't believe just check out NVIDIA stock prices and you will realize their stock booms after the ChatGPT hype. Also, you can possibly work for medical-related jobs too, which are usually stable.
1
u/Daxelol Sep 15 '23
Computer Engineering will only grow as a field overall. AI, ML, Cyber Security, etc. are all growing fields and desperately need highly educated and talented individuals.
1
u/C_Sorcerer Sep 15 '23
If by some degree AI takes over computer science, you'll have the electronics knowledge, which can't be simulated even near as well as programming. Even at that, AI is pretty dumb and I dont see either career going out in the future. I think your safe my man. And dont let your parents influence you, parents dont realize it but they can be the worst influence sometimes in college decisions
1
Sep 15 '23
If your goal is to be a c/c++ dev, VLSI, fpga programmer, CE is decent. But don't expect to get a job as an analog EE. If you like writing low level code and definitely don't want to be a web developer, I would chose CE over CS. You're experience may vary, but it's like getting 75% of a EE degree and 25% of a CS degree.
1
u/Skwirch Sep 15 '23
Seems like a fine choice to me, so long as it interests you. I'm a MechE, and AI tools have been extremely unreliable and pretty much useless. I really don't believe that AI will be taking engineering jobs any time soon.
1
u/nicknooodles Sep 15 '23
AI will improve the life of computer engineers, not replace them. You also need computer engineers to design and maintain AI lol.
1
u/IMAUMBN Sep 16 '23
It's worth pursuing if you don't mind never finishing your education because computer science requires keeping updated with current practices, I took 2 years of computer engineering courses and then changed to business admin because of this
1
1
u/ginger_daddy00 Sep 16 '23
Computer Engineering is a great career and is generally a modification of electrical engineering curriculum. Artificial intelligence might take away jobs in the software industry, but these will be the low low-skilled low risk jobs that are now taken by offshore programming or boot camp graduates or some other nonsense. A degree in computer engineering will open the door to fields that will be difficult to automate such as real-time safety critical embedded applications.
1
43
48
Sep 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/UrBoiJash Apr 12 '24
Im torn between CS (at a top 25 school) and CE (at a top 100 school). I'm not sure which one will be best for future job opportunities. My end goal is to end up at a government agency, NASA or Lockheed.
1
1
u/Kryptonite7x7 Mar 12 '25
I cant seem to find many CE listed in europe %95 of them are listed as CS, why?
1
u/hutdug321 Oct 09 '24
hey i just want to ask if this is really true specially for someone who will be a college graduate by 2028? because I've heard that the tech market is bad right now thanks!
1
u/TheNinthEmperor Sep 15 '23
Maybe a little bit for physics as well, a lot of money is being put into quantum computers and hardware. Although it does overlap with ECE and CS, there a lot of physics people getting into it (like myself)
1
5
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '23 edited Aug 05 '24
cagey payment rotten wipe foolish light liquid dependent gullible attempt
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact