r/ComputerChess • • 6d ago

Stockfish 19 vs alpha zero

What do you think who would win between stockfish 19 and alpha zero

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

9

u/ramen2581 6d ago

Stockfish 19 is about 500 elo stronger.

4

u/starnamedstork 6d ago

AlphaZero beat Stockfish 8, but that's almost a decade ago. AZ has not seen development in that time, and SF has. I think it's pretty safe to say that Stockfish 19 would win, and it's not even close. It would also beat Deep Blue.

1

u/Bunslow 2d ago

stockfish 19 on a 1995 pentium could crush deepblue

1

u/starnamedstork 1d ago

But to run that you will need a shitload of RAM compared to what was normally available on a 1995 computer. And that is if you can even compile it for a pentium. I think my computer in 1996 had 8 MB, the NNUE network in SF 19 can hardly fit the tip in there, let alone the whole thing.

2

u/Bunslow 1d ago

https://nicholas.carlini.com/writing/2026/algorithmic-improvements-chess.html

There you can read how it's done and play vs an actual physical pentium. It's at minimum 3300 elo, plenty to crush deep blue or any human

1

u/starnamedstork 1d ago

Nice. Although that is a pretty beefy workstation by 1995 standards. Also note that the 3300 CCRL rating performance claimed by the test Is not really directly comparable to 2700 or 2800 FIDE ratings from 1996, a point the author also points out near the end. Still cool though.

2

u/ElegantEvidence3668 5d ago

Stockfish 19 without a doubt. You can even nerf it to calculate 400x slower (so it's roughly the same speed as AlphaZero) and it would still beat Stockfish 8 by bigger margins.

1

u/ChessLabAcademy 6d ago

I'd put my money on Stockfish 19. AlphaZero was incredible when it came out, but chess engines have come a long way since then.

The thing is, AlphaZero played against a much older version of Stockfish, so those results don't really tell us how it would do today.

Leela Chess Zero (Lc0) is probably the closest thing we have to AlphaZero that we can actually test against modern Stockfish. They use a similar approach, although they're not the same engine.

I'd love to see the two go head-to-head under the same conditions, with equal hardware, time controls and a decent number of games. Until then, it's really just an educated guess. But yeah, my money's on Stockfish.

2

u/EvilNalu 5d ago

Lc0 likely reached AlphaZero strength by 2019. It is undoubtedly far stronger than AZ now, as is Stockfish 19 of course.

1

u/dsjoerg 5d ago

I cant figure out what equal hardware means since Leela requires a GPU to perform well but Stockfish et al are tuned to perform on CPU

Equal FLOPS? Equal $ cost of hardware?

1

u/ChessLabAcademy 5d ago

Fair point. Equal hardware was probably the wrong way to put it. Stockfish and Leela use hardware so differently that matching FLOPS wouldn't tell us much.

I'd go with equal hardware budgets, with each engine running on the setup it's best suited for, and the same time controls. Maybe also run a separate test with both on the same machine.

Neither is a perfect comparison, but at least we'd have something meaningful to work with.

1

u/annihilator00 2d ago

It sounded like it, but just in case I checked and Pangram says 100% of that reply is possibly AI.

https://www.pangram.com/history/4c648434-5656-4858-a482-7834f8f3d42f

1

u/ChessLabAcademy 2d ago

I don't understand the point you're trying to make.

Did I use ChatGPT to word my reply? Yeah, I did. What's wrong with that? The point I was making about comparing the engines is still what I think.

If you disagree with what I said, I'm happy to discuss it. Otherwise, you haven't added anything helpful to the discussion. Are you just here to troll?!