35
u/Meta_Donor Sep 15 '24
I play both 1.21 and 1.8.9 and 1.8.9 is much harder, but that doesnāt make it better. 1.21 PvP is all about timing and positioning, but 1.8.9 is all about fast paced comboing and block placement. I play one after the other some days because both are fun. Just comes down to personal preference
6
3
-11
Sep 15 '24
no 1.21 is about making idiots walk on your obsidian and blowing them up with these things called "end crystals"
4
u/-TV-Stand- Sep 16 '24
That's called crystal pvp, not normal 1.21 pvp. But even that is much more complicated.
-13
Sep 15 '24
normal pvp in 1.21 absolutely sucks bc you got bowspammers crossbowspammers and strafers that annoys the heck out of you
12
5
3
10
18
u/YoFoNL Sep 15 '24
you can hit select in 1.8
im a 1.20 pvper but hitting 10 cps isn't that hard
7 cps is enough
1
0
u/Upset_Ad_3846 Sep 16 '24
Thatās just not true lol
0
u/YoFoNL Sep 17 '24
skill issue
0
u/Upset_Ad_3846 Sep 17 '24
lol not my fault you play against low skilled/leveled players who allow you to combo them with 7 cps lmfao
1
u/YoFoNL Sep 17 '24
no i have 12 cps but you can compete in casual combat with 7cps
i main 1.20 now cuz i don't like to destroy my hands every day
7
u/oniann Sep 15 '24
My favoriye part about this meme is that this is exactly how 1.7/1.8 pvpers felt when the devs added 1.8/1.9
17
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 15 '24
Ppl think that 1.8 pvp is all about cps, thats not true, i get 7 cps and that i do pretty good, u need to know how to play, not just spam with ur sword at ur opponent
-6
u/oConjunction Sep 15 '24
i agree but if you want to be good good you need at least 14 cps. Bcs burst butterfly clicking is OP. There are no top rbw or pot players who dont get 14+
3
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 15 '24
I have a wireless logitech office mouse + keyboard, gl in getting 14 cps with that.
1
-2
u/oConjunction Sep 15 '24
yep 14 not rlly possible lmao. 12 is tho and that should be enough if you have perfect movement.
2
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 15 '24
I dont think that even 12 is possible :p, the most cps i saw someone getting with it is around 8.5 and that was realllyyy hard. And 7 cps is pretty ok for pvp.
1
u/oConjunction Sep 15 '24
7 cps with good movement should win like 90% of fights. try butterfly clicking on ur mouse if u can i get 14 on gpx superlight even though it has high debounce time.
1
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 15 '24
The mouse is too small for butterfly, and it cant double click, and i tried butterfly but it got me like 5 cps
1
u/Ok-Ambition-3881 Sep 16 '24
You can try jitter
1
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 16 '24 edited Sep 16 '24
As i said, i cant double click, so no any of these clicking methods
1
u/Ok-Ambition-3881 Sep 16 '24
You canāt double click while jitter clicking, itās a single click method
→ More replies (0)1
2
u/itzTanmayhere Sep 15 '24
fr burst butterfly click>>> 24 cps butterfly even though i butterfly click 24-26 consistently i click in burst to automatically hit select
2
u/Silent_Toe3963 Sep 15 '24
The #1 pot player Deproved clicks 10 and the #3 player M0difier jitter clicks like 12 so yea there's that. Butterflying high cps is easy and therefore cancer but there are ways to counter it.
1
u/oConjunction Sep 15 '24
jitterclicking is fine but 7 cps is not enough to be competitive at all. I was more focused on rbw since thats the community I'm more a part of.
1
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 16 '24 edited Sep 16 '24
7 cps is pretty ok if yk how to w tap and blockhit, im diamond at classic duels so yea it is pretty good. And i dont think i can get motr than that without my mouse getting broken or smth.
1
u/oConjunction Sep 16 '24
classic duels is a rod gamemode.... Plus diamond is like nothing.
1
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 16 '24
Yea feshing rod is pretty important there, and diamond is 500 wins, so not nuthing.
1
u/oConjunction Sep 16 '24
a round of classic is only around 20 secs though so say you have 2 wlr its only 4 hours
1
u/bill_cipher345 Sep 16 '24
Yea but that not 50/50, lots of times i duel pro ppl, but like very very very pro ppl, with grandmaster at everything or celestial, and thats realy hard, and considering my ping is 260-370, thats nearly impossible to win those fights.
1
u/oConjunction Sep 16 '24
yeah but even if you triple that time its 15 hours, which is not a lot. Plus, I was talking about pot, boxing and rbw more since rod gamemodes are different from those. i don't think there is one player in rbw pugs and prem who doesn't butterfly click because 14 cps is objectively just better so if you can why not.
→ More replies (0)1
u/Catgod262 Sep 15 '24
Thatās just not true
1
u/oConjunction Sep 16 '24
name one rbw allstars player who doesnt click 14+ and does well.
1
u/Catgod262 Sep 17 '24
ranked bw players are not the standard for a good player lmao. Also just because they use it doesnāt mean they have to, cps is easy to learn and does give an advantage so many players obviously will click fast, doesnāt mean you canāt be good or canāt beat someone who clicks 4x your cps Only game where you need cps no matter what is sumo.
1
3
7
u/AnIdioticPigeon Sep 15 '24
1.16 pvp takes too long for my dumbass bridge player brain to handle
3
u/SfErxr Sep 15 '24
most 1.8 bridge players iāve seen are pretty good at 1.16. they learn it quickly
3
4
u/OrangestCatto Sep 15 '24
nah but fr, the minecraft pvp community has some serious self control issues. all games have toxic ppl but damn minecraft players are something else
2
2
u/JamBloxify_370 Sep 15 '24
I switched to 1.9 pvp because it just showed a lot of different possibilities and potential with PvP. Newer stuff means probably newer ways to utilize it in a PvP environment.
2
u/MostaFosko Sep 16 '24
Wait I donāt understand
What is the difference between 1.9 , 1.16 , 1.21 combat?
My question is why he mentioned 1.16
4
u/Alternative-Approach Sep 15 '24
1.9 combat is better for survival, you can hit mobs in area, it's really useful in farms. But for PVP, 1.8 is the best and it's not even debatable. Fighting other players on 1.9 is just BORING.
In the new combat system, most of the time, you and your opponent just exchange hits, for every hit you land, you receive one, and inevitably whoever has the better equipment ends up winning. In 1.8 combat, the outcome of each fight is more uncertain and depends more on the skill of the players, so a player with weaker equipment has a chance of overcoming an opponent with better equipment if they are more skilled.
4
Sep 15 '24
this is just wrong, you arent gonna win in 1.9+ by sheer luck against somebody better than you, and although equipment obviously helps, you can still get clapped by a sweatlord without helmet
1
-1
u/Whycantitypeanything Sep 15 '24
1.9 is far less luck and gear based. A good player can take okay players 1v3 ( sometimes even 1v5+ if they're just better ) just because of better game sense , as in when to aggro , when to heal , who to target etc etc
1.9 + requires far more brain usage , while 1.8 is just W tapping, spacing and right click to pot ( more in uhc but don't wanna write a list )
Also "most of the time trade hits" sounds like someone can't combo in newer ver? If you say netherite blocks kB you can combo that with good timing or play the smp meta and just use knock back 1 on your sword . Also even if you do trade hits , it's not a stalemate as the person who kept more HP / saturation before a crit trade wins it , so its largely health management
Shields are a beast of their own. Tons of shield patterns to learn and being able to recognise one within seconds to insta break a shield before it's even visible, baiting shield to make opponent waste a hit trying to break it ( unless they know cool down trick but pretty much noone does ) having unpredictable shields to not get yours broken
Mending armor , a thing generally not seen in 1.8 as fights end too quickly, but is another point of failure for many players. Being able to split exp across all armor pieces, doing it fast , watching for aggro mends ( or doing them yourself) .
I've listed a ton of crap , and there's more I haven't talked about. 1.9+ is just far more game sense / knowledge based compared to 1.8s fast paced mechanical skill no brain play
If 1.8 is fun to you , that's okay but 1.9 is simply far more advanced which imo is a good thing as a shallow combat system does not feel good imo
4
u/Catgod262 Sep 16 '24
I swear both sides of these arguments never even play the other version enough to know what theyāre talking about. 1.9 is not more gamesense than 1.8 nor does it take more ābrain usageā.
First paragraph you talk about when to agro, when to heal, who to target, etc. all of these things are in 1.8 too. Later you bring up mending armor and shields but donāt talk about 1.8 rods, golden heads and apples, and many more things.
Itās so obvious that you havenāt even gotten close to good at 1.8 pvp with how you describe it. For reference if youāre good at 1.8 pvp you need to memorize patterns players do with rod strafes and lava. Predict their movement and take advantage of small openings you create so you can chain a combo. I could rant about this stuff for ever but I donāt care enough. 1.9 has many of these things too but as someone who has played both modes 1.9 is a lot easier.
1
1
1
1
u/leuxeren Sep 16 '24
Most of the time is the opposite way, I like to play 1.8 from time to time and then people get like "1.8 suxx, 1.9 pvp better" like bro I didn't say anything and you're already arguing
1
1
u/MatchSpectator Sep 16 '24
I switched to 1.9 4-5 years ago after playing 1.7 my entire life, most people are not willing to switch and try New stuff and they just hate because its different xd
1
1
u/jst_evo Sep 16 '24
As a 1.8 pvp main who clicks on average about 16-18 cps, this is bullsh*t. Cps does not really matter anymore nowadays in terms of pvp. There are a lot of factors that goes into 1.8 pvp so this meme honestly so dumb.
1
u/Willing_Ad_1484 Sep 16 '24
Op is a bot, and is literally like 4 days old. Stole a meme from 1.16 like 4 years ago and y'all still arguing
1
1
1
-6
Sep 15 '24
I hate 1.8
2
1
0
-1
u/UniversityPitiful823 Sep 15 '24
Everyone saying cps isnt that important is prob just not high enough lvl to understand, that if you and your opponent both know all the current strats very well. Then cps does play role. It makes most things easier.
1
u/skilledgamer55 Sep 16 '24
They probably aren't even teir tested in anything
1
u/UniversityPitiful823 Sep 16 '24
If you think tier tests are a good mesuring tool you havent played against actuall good players. Most of them dont play tiertests
1
-1
Sep 15 '24
The new combat has a lower skill cap and an easier learning curve, there was a lot of people with poor internet or a less powerful computer that just couldnāt get the hang of it. Iāve been playing Minecraft since I was 12 and 1.8 pvp still has me confused. How does everyone have 9 block reach? Iām always told to āgit gudā which is fucking annoying. I canāt start a combo if they always get the first and the last hit I feel like everyone is hacking on hypixel and I just canāt take 1.8 pvp seriously it feels like a joke to me. Maybe Iām just stupid but seriously though when I look at YouTubers they donāt have an issue then thereās me getting fucking railed by everyone.
2
u/Whycantitypeanything Sep 15 '24
Lower skill floor , higher skill ceiling on 1.9
Its just that experienced players in 1.8 have a far easier way to steamroll newbies , whilst in 1.9 they at least get a couple hits although they will still usually qd.
1.8 has high skill floor and okay skill ceiling
So it's harder to get into but its a lower skill ceiling before fights are won by micro things and micro improvements , whilst 1.9 even the best players have lots of room to improve due to far larger set of options , play styles and possibilities
1
u/Silent_Toe3963 Sep 16 '24
Well first of all, it could definitely be a skill issue, I need to see your gameplay to confirm. Second of all, it is true to confirm your suspicions that there is a cheater problem and itās only increased over time. And you can definitely start a combo if you donāt get the first hit, some even deliberately avoid getting the first hit, itās called hit selecting. The reason why YouTubers ādonāt have an issueā is cause they donāt upload the times when they do have an issue, which is a lot more than they would like to admit, also they can get targeted if their identity is revealed ingame.Ā
115
u/TomatilloCrazy9629 Sep 15 '24
when people think 1.8 is about cps, thats a dead argument