r/CompetitiveForHonor • u/PastoralMeadows • Aug 15 '22
Discussion Two changes which would dramatically improve the game and kill the defensive meta for good
TL;DR:
All dodge attacks are now considered a light parry
All dodge bashes now have increased GB vulnerability
For all of the great changes the developers have made to improve For Honor, there's still two changes which prevent the Offensive Meta from being truly realized. At the moment, dodge bashes are very frustrating to deal with during mixups (especially against Shinobi) because you can't catch them with a feint-GB. At most you'll punish them with your own dodge attack netting you 15 damage, but this neuters offense and makes gameplay horribly stale. Dodge heavies are similarly frustrating and offer very little risk to the defender, especially if externaled. Increasing the GB vulnerability on bashes and standardizing dodge attack parry punishes would force the defending player to make more deliberate reads. These two changes would effectively kill the defensive meta for good.
19
Aug 15 '22
Nerfing the defensive meta by hitting defensive moves only helps the characters who are already able to throw attacks without much fear. Pirate, Raider, BP, etc. Congratulations, you haven't actually helped anyone south of A-tier attack, you've just kneecapped their options and further cemented their status as punching bags. Either character specific offensive buffs or across the board offense changes that make it less risky and more effective to throw basic attacks is the only healthy way to fight the defensive meta.
-8
u/PastoralMeadows Aug 15 '22
Nerfing the defensive meta by hitting defensive moves only helps the characters who are already able to throw attacks without much fear.
We need to focus on improving and strengthening offensive tools. Changes like the ones I've suggested would ideally come with reworks or buffs to existing characters. We should never prioritize the defensive tools over a character's offense.
3
5
u/OGMudbone909 Aug 15 '22
I'd be fine with all dodge attacks being light parries if they were 533-600ms and usable from 200-500 in dodge, all being enhanced, and all chaining whether on hit/block/whiff.
1
u/PastoralMeadows Aug 15 '22
Yeah sounds good. Although perhaps you can fill me in on why the delay is necessary? Couldn't reaction monsters use this to effectively punish bashes and other attacks on reaction?
1
u/OGMudbone909 Aug 15 '22
So they dont feel like shit and are actually good tools.
We dont need more nuxia dodge attacks.
8
u/LimbLegion Aug 15 '22
Changes nothing about how most of the things in the game are reactable and also doesn't address anything about how strong blocking is as a tool, as it's generally the only tool you actually need.
All this does is make various dodge attacks absolutely terrible defensively and nothing else is fixed.
-2
u/PastoralMeadows Aug 15 '22
I suggested many months ago that chip damage be dramatically increased and to make bashes&unblockables unreactable. Sure, I see this as a packaged deal. Characters can have an array of defensive tools, but they should heavily punished on incorrect read.
6
u/Knight_Raime Aug 15 '22
Chip damage doesn't matter if it can't kill. Since strong players will still be able to react to most offense in the game this does nothing to solve that.
1
u/malick_thefiend Aug 16 '22
That’s not really true lol even if chip can’t kill damage is damage. Going from blocking three attacks and I have to hit you five times to kill vs blocking three attacks and now I only have to hit you four times to kill DOES make a difference.
Though I agree that it doesn’t really solve the problem lol but to say it doesn’t matter is a bit hyperbolic as well
2
u/Knight_Raime Aug 17 '22
Yes it is hyperbolic. But you came to the conclusion on your own so I don't really need to explain it. Increasing chip doesn't actually make offense better for any game mode. Given the context of FH's mechanics you cannot reliably use chip in a consistently meaningful way.
Chip is more valuable in other games because it's backed up with a bunch of mechanics and combat that can absolutely take advantage of it. That's why I think it's more fair to fall bashes chip damage in FH.
It's the closest comparison that can be made given what FH is.
-1
u/PastoralMeadows Aug 15 '22
I'd love to make Chip Damage deadly. As I mentioned in my previous post we'd need to make existing offense unreactable as well.
4
u/Knight_Raime Aug 15 '22
You can't make chip damage kill because that would be incredibly catastrophic for 4's. The closest we have to enabling something similar to this is when someone is bleeding they can be killed from chip. We can't have bleed be too accessible to the cast otherwise it would be just as disruptive as having chip kill by default. But I do think we could squeeze a bit more of it in at some point.
Making offense as a whole unreactable is basically impossible due to the high variance of how kits work (even given how simplistic the game actually is.) On top of that you'd really have to kill the readability of most animations to actually achieve that which we would never want to do.
Reacting to offense is actually in other fighting games as well. It's just less problematic in traditional fighters partially because there's more systems at play in those games (and thus more things to do) but also damage is usually done through strings and combos. Where as FH entirely relies on guaranteed punishes either from GB's or parries to things like animation locks enabling ganks.
FH does have offense outside of those things in the form of whiff punishing and recoveries in general but it doesn't have the tools to build off of those instances to create things like footsies and more varied combat.
Ultimately we don't need offense to be truly unreactable given the nature of how 4's are. But we can and should strive to have smarter offense. A good example of this is feintable static bashes. Where as an absolute shitter example of offense we need to get away from is Midjay's axe stance.
0
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 16 '22
If chip dmg wasn't so important why was it nerfed like twice? The 3rd feat that increases chip dmg got nerfed twice, so I'm confused why they nerfed it so much, I used it all the time before the nerfs bcs I know it mattered a lot.
1
u/Knight_Raime Aug 17 '22
I cannot recall any such time the devs intentionally nerfed chip damage globally other than when we reduced the damage with CCU. And even then that wasn't targeted at chip.
They did nerf a feat that increased chip damage but one of those times it was actually bugged.
My point is that FH can't take advantage of chip damage because of the game it inherently is. Chip in other fighters can be bolstered by either temporary health states in which the player can recover it or use it as a resource (DNF duel being the most recent example) or the chip adds a level of threat to the blocking since blocking usually has a meter of some kind. So you can risk either a counter state or a guard getting broken. Both of which can spell a touch of death combo.
At best chip allows a quicker health lead in duels after a good punish. But that can't be built upon due to how the game is in 4's. So while it does have "value" to some degree it's very meaningless in the grand scheme of the game. Hence why I said it doesn't matter.
-1
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 17 '22
I am talking about the 3rd feat being nerfed twice. To me it shows how powerful chip dmg is.
1
u/Knight_Raime Aug 18 '22
My response doesn't change.
-2
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 18 '22
Then I wish Ubi would revert the changes so I can use that feat again, it's so much wasted dmg.
2
u/lerthedc Aug 15 '22
I would be open to this but I also kind of like how dodge attacks vary in effectiveness and vary in punish. Orochi and zerk have undodgeable and delayable dodge attacks but have light parry punish to make up for it, while hito and shaolin have mediocre dodge attacks but they are heavy parry punish. A potentially better route is to tweak the overpowered dodge attacks like pirate while also giving characters more ways to deal with heavy dodge attacks, like full blocks, crushing counters, and undodgeables. But admittedly, this route takes more work.
0
u/PastoralMeadows Aug 15 '22
To be perfectly honest I don't see a standardization of dodge attacks as being detrimental. In fact, I see it as necessary. Instead we should advocate for more powerful, reliable, and diverse offensive tools. A character can have several defensive tools (see Kyoshin) but they should be heavily punished on correct read.
1
u/lerthedc Aug 15 '22
That's what I'm saying though. If every character had access to good damage full block, crushing counter, deflects, or Undodgeable, then it would allow for better punishes on heavy dodge attacks. Characters like shaolin can handily punish heavy dodge attacks because he has three of the four options I listed and they all do >20 damage. This is more interesting than just feinting to parry and it does comparable damage.
Having variety in the dodge attacks generally makes it easier to vary and balance other aspects of the character. The main problem right now is that some characters have absurd dodge attacks like pirate, and some characters like medjay, kensei, hito, etc. Have no better way to deal with heavy dodge attacks other than feint to parry.
25
u/doctorzoidsperg Aug 15 '22
this does not fix the issue whatsoever ngl. nerfing dodge bashes is something im in favour of though so that's cool at least
21
u/DaniUsagi Aug 15 '22
Dodge bashes should just be as reactable as dodge attacks, imo. The fast dodge attacks are 533ms but dodge bashes should be at least 600ms, since dodging is more difficult than parrying AND doesn't always guarantee a punish because of dodge bashes with recovery cancel.
Edit: Side dodge bashes, the defensive ones, of course
3
u/Big_Hoshiguma Aug 15 '22
I read the title and first line and stopped there.
You can’t seriously be suggesting that extremely telegraphed, unfeintable 600ms+ attacks are worthy of a top heavies worth of HP for wanting to try and stop your opponents offense so that you can start your own. Also what about WM, JJ or Tiandi, who have extremely slow, feintable dodge heavies, are they not exempt from this?
That won’t discourage people from playing defensively, if anything it will encourage people to turtle even harder than before as dodge attacks become suicidal to attempt. Not to mention how drastically this affects the game beyond 1v1’s. The effects this would have on 2’s and 4’s would be unfathomable in terms of neutering teamfight/peel power across the whole roster.
Just no.
0
u/PastoralMeadows Aug 15 '22 edited Aug 15 '22
You can’t seriously be suggesting that extremely telegraphed, unfeintable 600ms+ attacks are worthy of a top heavies worth of HP for wanting to try and stop your opponents offense so that you can start your own.
I'm suggesting that, yes.
That won’t discourage people from playing defensively, if anything it will encourage people to turtle even harder than before as dodge attacks become suicidal to attempt. Not to mention how drastically this affects the game beyond 1v1’s. The effects this would have on 2’s and 4’s would be unfathomable in terms of neutering teamfight/peel power across the whole roster.
That hasn't stopped characters like Berserker and Orochi from being functional in 2s and 4s. It would be extremely favorable to aggressive players and destroy turtling. Of course attacks like bashes and unblockables would need to be made unreactable (as well as removing parry flash) but ultimately the defensive meta would be gone.
1
u/Big_Hoshiguma Aug 15 '22
Care to explain to me how dodge attacks are “defensive” or “turtling”?
Because defensive play entails that you are actively eliminating and taking as few risks as possible to mitigate incoming damage. While a dodge attack is an offensive counter move, you are taking a risk and making a read to attempt to start your own offense.
Defensive play = Risk elimination
Offensive play = Risk taking
These are antithetical to one another, you cannot say that taking a risk to counter you opponent and start your offense is defensive play. Hell it’s in the name, dodge attack.
1
u/lerthedc Aug 15 '22
How would this change increase the turtle meta? If I know that I can punish dodge attacks harder, that lowers the risk of my offense since the defender will be more reluctant to use their dodge attack.
Before his nerfs, orochi was high tier in both 4s and 1s all while having a light dodge attack, so clearly that doesn't ruin the game.
The main reason I might oppose this change is that it reduces variety in characters. Orochi and zerk have light parry dodge attacks, but they are also undodgeable and very delayable. Characters like shaolin and hito have heavy dodge attacks, but they are pretty mediocre, so it balances out, at least in 4s. I think a potentially better solution is to give characters more options to beat dodge attacks, like full blocks, crushing counters, and undodgeables, but that would also take more work.
5
u/OkQuestion2 Aug 15 '22
i would say that for the bashes instead of having increased gb vulnerability they have increased guard break recovery as to give one when dodged on reaction to the bash but i would be fine with either option
also on a less important note i believe the damage of dodge attacks would be better if the usual was 14 instead of 16
7
u/Knight_Raime Aug 15 '22
Defense remains as strong as it is for 2 reasons. The general reactability of most of the game's attacks, and that the game still hinges entirely on guaranteed punishes.
Both of these things are much less problematic in 4's because there's so much more going on then just one dude fighting another dude. Trying to solve these problems is like looking at the game as a traditional fighter when it isn't.
I'm also frankly sick of people thinking defense shouldn't be viable. It should absolutely still exist and still be viable. The problems we had pre CCU weren't strictly based in how powerful defense could be. It was also how unrewarding offense was.
Nerfing defensive side dodge moves isn't going to make offense better. If anything it would have the opposite effect of making offense more brain dead since they don't have to worry about a potential strong punish for over committing. Defense doesn't need to be adjusted anymore beyond heros lacking some options.
The devs should 100% be focused on making offense more viable.
1
u/Cablefrayer Aug 16 '22
This would turn any stamina bully like warlord and jorm and cent into absolute monsters. It would not kill defensive meta.
Edit: not saying I’m against it
1
u/PastoralMeadows Aug 16 '22
Stamina draining attacks in general need to be removed. Jorm needs a total rework, moreso than any other character.
6
u/oopsIforgotmyalt Aug 15 '22
Al this would do is make people turtle and no one would ever commit to attacking because you've made the punish on every feint to GB 24-38 DMG, all depth is now gone from mixups as all UB and feintable bashes are 50/50s, characters like warden are made even shallower as he is now never gonna throw a bash in chain as the UB heavy is always the stronger option. Additionally characters like kyoshin would have no reason to use bash/undodgable mixups in favour of spamming kaze UB as it is now just as effective as his intended mixup with higher damage. Fights would be over way quicker as most punishes are now heavies, but most importantly this does nothing to address the real reason why defense is so strong such as the reactability of many moves at high level and the strength of blocking. This change overall destroys the strength and balance of so many of the roster, while not doing anything to address the more prevalent issues at high level play that make the game so defensive.
2
2
u/Cripplechip Aug 15 '22
Yeah, nah. Don't think attacks and bashes that do at most 12 damage should be punished with a raw heavy. That's stupid.
2
4
u/Errorcrash Aug 15 '22
Almost all heroes have a pretty hefty punish for dodge attacks...
If you want to make them all light attacks you need to also make them all delayable and give them some other property, and deflect to be worth the potential light parry. You can't seriously compare Berserker's dodge attack to Gryphon's? I think there's an argument to be made for non delayable defensive bashes as they force you to move during team fights and break hyper armor without a way to parry them... but I mean come on let's not dance this dance again shall we?
0
u/FallenDeus Aug 15 '22
make them all light parries, but in return i want the ability to hard feint, soft feint into gb, and they should be enhanced.
3
u/MeTheYu Aug 15 '22
I have been thinking this exact thing for a while. Imo the defensive meta is still alive and breathing. Especially in 4v4 where you can easily external the dodge attack, making it unparriable.
1
1
u/redditperson38 Aug 15 '22
I used to really hate shinobi bash kick, until you realize it’s not meant for you to be able to feint a heavy, UB, dodge attack whatever into GB you’re supposed to slow down and wait for an opening. Don’t immediately just smooth brain try to go into your attack if u dodge the kick most shinobi will do the backflip in which case u GB that and then u get ur heavy do that a few times cause shinobis can’t help themselves and you get easy heavies. Now if u struggle dodging the fist bash to begin w then that’s another issue entirely
1
1
u/DefenderOfWaifus Aug 15 '22
I’ve always been curious what it would be like if every hero in the game had a reflex gaurd. Static blocking isn’t really a thing in a majority of fighting games
1
0
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 15 '22
I just want all attacks to be parriable regardless if the attack is locked onto you. Only reason why dodge attacks are spammed so much is bcs ppl can just lock onto someone on the other side of the team fight and have safe attacks on everyone else. Pirate being the worst offender.
3
Aug 15 '22
That is not a problem with dodge attacks, it’s a problem with the properties some dodge attacks have. External defense is extremely strong that’s why aggressing on a single person and trying to treat teamfights as a 1v1 is not good. You have to change your mindset, it’s a team mode, communicating with your team, and confirming damage is the way to play
0
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 15 '22
You mean how I cannot punish dodge attacks bcs I was in a hit stun that only allows blocking and parrying and not dodging, is a problem of me not communicating with my team?
That the only way to punish pirate dodge attack in a teamfight is only with GB, is difficult to do bcs I'm not communicating with my team?
I'm not treating it as 1v1, it's bcs dodgeattacks are so safe in teamfights that they are spammed everywhere. I have to play hyper armor hero to trade, I am perfectly aware how to play in a teamfight, and with that knowledge I'm saying what changes I want.
Also in 4v4 there is no "confirming dmg" the moment you try to set someone up, their teammates will punish you for it.
It's made of hyper armor, unparriable dodge attacks, big hitboxes and feats.
1
Aug 16 '22
Many times, and many dodge attacks you can’t parry. Feinting into a light is a possible way to catch them if they are spammed into your guard but generally if you are getting externally spammed, you are out of position and your teammate can punish. There are a lot of nuances to situations in team fights and many dodge attacks escape pretty much every mixup in the game. So don’t agress, if they are only ever worried about defense communicate with your team to agress onto someone else, and not every character has an option that externally negates everything. So communicating when someone on your team agresses on that person and you pre peeling is a way to play it.
Also I don’t think you know how to play teamfights at all. From your problems and the way you describe the interactions it doesn’t sound like you understand teamfights.
-1
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 16 '22
I see the problem now, you only have experience playing the game in 4 stack and not randoms. OK let me change the premise, 4v4 without voice chat.
You saying that I don't understand teamfight sounds the exact same as rich ppl saying "my yacht got scratched" to a normal person.
1
Aug 16 '22
I usually queue with one other person if I ever queue mm, and no one in mm understands team fights that well.
-1
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 16 '22
Ah yes, it's definitely THEM not understanding how team fights work, DEFINITELY not bcs they are random ppl playing solo unlike you that only plays with a friend on voice chat, since you don't even know how to coordinate with random players without voice chat.
Let me make something very clear, ganking and team fights in voice chat against solo players not on voice chat, should always be a free win. Especially when ganking on voice chat requires 0 skill.
Ganking with random players means I have to predict what my teammate is trying to do and then coordinate with him, without a single word or feeding revenge.
Solo queue is completely different from voice chat groups.
1
Aug 16 '22
Queueing with a friend doesn’t mean I’m always in fights with him. We have two other teammates as well. And really I don’t need coordination or anything to out fight casual match making players. Just by positioning knowledge and years of experience they are pretty easy to beat. But people that don’t play competitively might have a harder time.
For me it’s essentially like playing an FPS game when your 5 ranks above the people your fighting in casual and just out aiming everyone. But for people of similar skill in match making positioning, utility etc… matters a whole lot more.
If you want to beat people who are just externally spamming, learn how to get away from it. Learn good positioning, learn what you can do against it.
-1
u/Tein_Meizeshi Aug 16 '22
Yes ofc you are outskilling them with a pirate, very convincing indeed. I wish you good luck in you tournaments, PRO.
Your argument of "learn good positioning, learn what you can do against it" definitely invalidates my arguments about the current problems of random matchmaking, especially the ones about how me and my teammates cannot coordinate against these dodge attacks bcs we are not on a voice chat. And how the current game design allows such cheap dodge attacks to exist.
2
u/MKUltra76 Aug 16 '22
You have the wrong mindset why are you here if you dont wanna hear what works? Dont have friends to play? There's many servers you can go to to find people to play/learn with. You could learn all those things or adapt to your random teammate but no you want an easy way out instead of learning the game and how it works.
→ More replies (0)
0
25
u/PKR_Live Aug 15 '22
+all dodge attacks are enhanced.