r/CompetitiveApex • • Mar 25 '21

Console Undeniable proof that the #4 and #6 Xbox Preds are DDoSing servers after we knock them. I’m posting on Twitter for more attention but please help get this traction - Console Ranked is literally unplayable with 5 of every 6 games being DDoSed

4.4k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • May 01 '22

it was a green screen Thank you

3.2k Upvotes

Hi everyone, NiceWigg here. I wanted to say thank you for all the support this weekend. It was truly the best 3 days of my career. It still doesn’t really feel real. The games were amazing and I couldn’t be more excited for LAN to be back. Thank you also for always pointing out what you liked in my casting but more importantly what you didn’t like throughout my watch parties leading up to this. I worked hard to make sure that I was the best version of myself so everyone can enjoy the games. I hope it was good enough. Huge shoutout to all the love for Greek. He is such a great guy and entertainer. I know the kind words and positive messages mean a lot to him. It wouldn’t of been the same without him. We love y’all a ton and thank you again.

SEE YALL AT CHAMPS.


r/CompetitiveApex • • May 08 '21

Discussion Best Bocek Take!

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • May 13 '24

Roster News ImperialHal Leaves TSM

Thumbnail
twitter.com
2.4k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Nov 22 '21

Fluff Goodbye Snipe

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Mar 18 '24

Clearing up misconceptions about the ALGS hack

2.1k Upvotes

Some background to establish credibility: I work in cybersecurity as a white hat hacker. I've been losing my mind reading some of the misinformation which has been being spread about the ALGS hack so here's a quick list of clarifications.

What happened?

Hal and Gen both had cheats toggled on by a hacker, mid-ALGS game. On Gen's screen, a cheat menu of some sort popped up: https://www.twitch.tv/genburten/clip/SparklingDarlingApeKlappa-iYd-e5Nns_gMcGuv

How did this happen?

The short answer is nobody knows for sure at this point. Anybody other than someone on Respawn's incident response team or the hacker themselves who claims to know for certain what happened is not telling the truth. However, here are some possibilities for how this might have happened:

Phishing

If both Hal and Gen were tricked into downloading malware onto their computer, that malware could obviously contain cheats which the hacker could then activate during a game. This type of attack is called phishing. I believe this to be the less likely scenario, for reasons I mention in the next section, but it is absolutely possible.

Remote code execution

RCE is a type of vulnerability in which an attacker is able to get code running on a computer remotely (i.e., over the internet). If an attacker were to find an RCE, they would be able to put cheat software onto Hal and Gen's computers and cause it to execute. They would also allow the attacker to do considerably more malicious things, like stealing personal data from the computer (passwords, etc.), installing ransomware (which encrypts all your files and tries to force you to pay a ransom to get them back), etc. As a result, this is something of a nightmare scenario. RCE is a very severe vulnerability in any context.

Unfortunately, it's also the more likely scenario, in my opinion. From what I can tell, the hacker behind this attack has a history of developing advanced cheats, meaning they're technically proficient and familiar with the security measures of both the Apex client and servers. The hacker themselves has also claimed that this is an RCE (source: coldjyn), but tbh I think they would claim this for clout regardless of whether they actually had an RCE or not.

If you would like to learn more about RCE in general, here's a short overview: https://www.crowdstrike.com/cybersecurity-101/remote-code-execution-rce/

Have games had RCEs before?

Apex specifically has not had any publicly known RCEs, but plenty of other games have had RCEs discovered in the past. This includes CSGO, the entire Dark Souls series, Minecraft, and a whole bunch of Call of Duty games.

Am I in danger if I play Apex?

Maybe. I personally have uninstalled Apex to be safe right now, and think you should do the same if you are on PC. Although the odds that you specifically will be targeted with an RCE out of several million Apex players are fairly low, I would recommend not taking that risk. Avoid EA games for a couple days until Respawn/EA at least put out a statement about the incident, and give some indication of the severity of it.

Minor edit: As some have pointed out in the replies, if you leave Apex installed and just don't open it you'll probably be fine as well.

Some common misconceptions

  • "This was done with Webhooks." I can confidently say that this is nonsense and the person who tweeted it is talking out of their ass. Webhooks are generally unrelated to what the vast majority of online games use for connections from the client to the server. It's maybe theoretically possible that for some cursed reason Apex uses webhooks for something, but it is extremely unlikely that the vulnerability is actually a webhook thing, and frankly from the way the source of this info wrote their Tweet I have zero confidence that they know what they are talking about.

  • "This is an Easy Anticheat issue." While this is certainly possible, there's nowhere near enough information to be able to tell if this is the case or not. Anything people say is at this point just speculation. The same goes for "This is an R5 issue," "This is an Apex client issue," "This is an Apex server issue," "This is a Source Engine issue," etc. It is too early to tell where the vulnerability is. The only one of these that I have a somewhat confident take about is R5, which I think is fairly unlikely to be the attack vector here. However, that is just my personal opinion.

    • Update: EAC has stated that they conducted an investigation and are "confident that there is no RCE vulnerability within EAC being exploited."

  • "Apex uses remote code execution." RCE is a vulnerability/bug, not a feature. If there is RCE in Apex, it is caused by a flaw rather than there by design.

  • "This wouldn't be an issue if Apex had root/kernel-level anticheat." Easy AntiCheat is root-level.

  • "This is an issue because of root-level anticheat." It is possible to securely implement a root-level anticheat. An anticheat being root-level does not create RCE; it makes it so that in the event of an RCE, the impact is higher. This is why Riot, creators of Vanguard, have a fairly generous bug bounty program for Vanguard. They know that having Vanguard be secure is critically important, so they offer $100k to researchers who discover and report vulnerabilities in it.

  • "This is because of the ALGS client." The ALGS client no longer exists; players play on their normal client and account.

  • "The hack works through friend requests." Once again, this is possible but purely speculation at the moment. Same goes for all the other theories floating around (hacking through gifts, observers, the server itself, etc.)

  • "This can't happen on LAN." A little-known fact is that Apex LANs are not actually on a local network, despite the name. They just have a dedicated server somewhere nearby lol. So it's possible that this could have happened at a LAN event as well. I have heard pros mention that at LAN they are forced to tinker with certain files to get the queueing to work, but I do not know what this entails or whether this is sufficient to isolate the game clients from the open internet.

Other takeaways

It has long been my belief that video game companies need to take security far more seriously than they currently are. Despite making systems as complicated as many "normal" tech companies, many game companies don't even have security teams and do not subject their systems to sufficient security auditing. The reason for this is often that executives are unwilling to invest money into security until a major incident happens, because there is not an immediately apparent profit from it. Security teams don't make a product that you can sell to people, so many executives view them as a money pit.

I don't know if this is the case at Respawn, but I would not be surprised. From some cursory googling, I wasn't able to find a CISO (Chief Information Security Officer). Their existing security team seems to be primarily focused on anti-cheating measures. I can't find any bug bounty programs or even a vulnerability disclosure process apart from the broader one handled by EA. My takeaway from this is: Please do not harass random Respawn developers about this incident. If this whole thing is indeed an RCE, that's most likely the result of structural or managerial failures at Respawn rather than because the developers just didn't work hard enough. Every time I've tested a product with bad security, it has been because the team behind it was underfunded, understaffed, etc.


r/CompetitiveApex • • Feb 19 '21

Discussion Albralelie’s new suggestion for Caustic gas change

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • May 24 '24 Take My Silver

Discussion Fallout absolutely cooking Phony with honesty

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Sep 25 '24

I miss TSM ImperialHal

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Jan 30 '24

Fluff/Humor Is this accurate?

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Aug 18 '21

Discussion Yes

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • May 24 '23

Discussion HisWattson Speaking Facts

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Aug 08 '21

Fluff The State of Apex in Season 10 - Wallhack Legends

1.8k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Aug 03 '22

Ranked The state of ranked

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Jul 09 '22

Highlight Hal showing insane sportsmanship Spoiler

Thumbnail
clips.twitch.tv
1.7k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Jan 26 '22

Fluff Hal's Prophecy About Snipedown Came True

1.7k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • May 23 '24 Heart of Silver Take My Silver

New TSM

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Apr 15 '22

Fluff A love letter to the community.

1.7k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Oct 26 '22

Fluff One year later and Snip3 has left Halo and is most likely coming back. And y’all downvoted me.

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Aug 06 '23

Addressing the elephant in the room.

1.6k Upvotes

Updated below but I still want the core understanding of my feelings of my hardship of the last few months to be heard so I'm keeping this up.

Two days ago I learned through a reddit post that I was banned along side other notable LGBT + LGBT advocates (for trash talking - for sure.), I reached out to select people asking whether I was banned or not (or to even have a simple conversation really) and was met with a block from one and ignored from another. Keep in mind I haven't talked about Nick, enabled my chat to talk about or talk shit about him, I simply wanted to move on since June and I really tried to. But with recent events I don't really know how I can sit idly and watch this go down without telling my side.

(Probably a wall of text coming because this is my real unfiltered feelings since June.)June (Pride month) was one of my personal biggest mistakes in my pro career, trying to be a notable LGBT figure and really own up to who I wanted to be. Every since those posts got a lot of traction i've seen an egregious amount of hate and words should never be used against others with minimal thought process. The bad outweighed the good in this situation - yes I stuck up for what I believed in and for others who can't get their voice heard, but the amount of shit i've seen in last two months really fucked me up to be blunt. I was ready to retire and move on from this esport because of how uncomfortable the environment was. Call me soft or a pussy or whatever makes you feel better for thinking this way, no amount of success or fame or money was worth the shit I was going through. (Just turn off your monitor haha 4Head.)

My interest isn't to get Nick cancelled or even reprimanded, or even to try to get myself invited to the League. I just want to be heard from this situation and make it clear that this situation is being handed so weirdly that is a slice of 50k really worth it?

*edit - I have recently spoke to Nick and i'm told it was nothing to do with people being a part of the LGBT or the advocation of it, and I am choosing to believe him. He has also asked me to join the gauntlet which I have chose to decline. I don't want anymore turmoil about this, simply just want to mind my own business and leave it at that.

My objective was to be heard and I got my voice heard. I'm okay with that.


r/CompetitiveApex • • Jul 17 '22

Fluff HisWattson comes at the CEO

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Jan 27 '23

Fluff Truly two of the greatest Apex duos of all time

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Mar 14 '22

Highlight Insane 2 minute sequence from TSM (ALGS Split 2)

1.6k Upvotes

r/CompetitiveApex • • Mar 08 '21

Fluff Please let this man cast the next ALGS

Post image
1.6k Upvotes