r/CompSocial • • May 07 '26

Unable to get Tiktok App Approved

0 Upvotes

I applied for the 6th time and i still can't get past the error of "Hi there, unfortunately we are unable to onboard you to the TikTok for Business Developers platform due to the security of the domain you have provided. For further verification, please contact your TikTok representative if you have one. If you do not hav"

I have a valid domain that is now 2 years old and has content in it. The app is live on Shopify app store.

Not sure what to do.

Can anyone guide please?


r/CompSocial • • Jan 05 '25

Phd opportunities

0 Upvotes

Suggestions of universities having phd openings in computational social science/network science in 2025


r/CompSocial • • Sep 09 '26

social/advice What are you automating right now?

0 Upvotes

Using AI or not - what parts of your computational social science are you working on automating? I'm curious.


r/CompSocial • • Jun 28 '24

blog-post Safety isn’t safety without a social model (or: dispelling the myth of per se technical safety) [Andrew Critch, lesswrong.com]

1 Upvotes

Andrew Critch recently posted this blog post on lesswrong.com that tackles the notion that "AI Safety" can be achieved through purely technical innovation, highlighting that all AI research and applications happen within a social context, which must be understood. From the introduction:

As an AI researcher who wants to do technical work that helps humanity, there is a strong drive to find a research area that is definitely helpful somehow, so that you don’t have to worry about how your work will be applied, and thus you don’t have to worry about things like corporate ethics or geopolitics to make sure your work benefits humanity.

Unfortunately, no such field exists. In particular, technical AI alignment is not such a field, and technical AI safety is not such a field. It absolutely matters where ideas land and how they are applied, and when the existence of the entire human race is at stake, that’s no exception.

If that’s obvious to you, this post is mostly just a collection of arguments for something you probably already realize.  But if you somehow think technical AI safety or technical AI alignment is somehow intrinsically or inevitably helpful to humanity, this post is an attempt to change your mind.  In particular, with more and more AI governance problems cropping up, I'd like to see more and more AI technical staffers forming explicit social models of how their ideas are going to be applied.

What do you think about this argument? Who do you think is doing the most interesting work at understanding the societal forces and impacts of recent advances in AI?

Read more here: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/F2voF4pr3BfejJawL/safety-isn-t-safety-without-a-social-model-or-dispelling-the


r/CompSocial • • Mar 18 '26

Request for endorsement

0 Upvotes

Hello Everyone,

I hope you are doing well. I am Abhi, an undergraduate researcher in Explainable AI and NLP.

I recently published a paper: “Applied Explainability for Large Language Models: A Comparative Study” https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19096514

I am preparing to submit it to arXiv (cs.CL) and require an endorsement as a first-time author. I would greatly appreciate your support in endorsing my submission.

Endorsement Code: JRJ47F https://arxiv.org/auth/endorse?x=JRJ47F

I would be happy to share any additional details if needed.

Thank you for your time.

Best regards, Abhi


r/CompSocial • • May 09 '25

scrapping tiktok videos

0 Upvotes

how can i get videos from tiktok by scrapping


r/CompSocial • • Oct 04 '26

social/advice Calibration until compliant: Why unlimited free parameters in ABM risk producing tautologies instead of social insight

2 Upvotes

TL;DR: Computational models are only scientifically useful if they can push back and prove their authors wrong. Across disciplines, from agent-based social simulations to high-energy physics, models with loose empirical feedback loops and endless free parameters risk becoming "decorative." Instead of testing reality, they get calibrated until compliant, turning a tool for discovery into a self-confirming tautology. Honest modeling requires radical transparency, sensitivity testing, and explicit criteria for failure before running the simulation.

I build models for a living. Specifically, molecular dynamics. These are simulations that track how thousands or millions of atoms move, collide, and rearrange over time, used for everything from drug design to materials science.

Here is the story scientists usually tell. If a model is wrong, you find out quickly. Reality does not care about your assumptions. The atoms do not read your code. If the physics you programmed in is wrong, the simulation produces garbage, the experiment disagrees, and you go back and fix it. The feedback loop between model and world is short, brutal, and non-negotiable.

That story is not entirely true. I know, because I have watched it fail from the inside.

The most important choice in any molecular dynamics simulation is not the code, the computer, or the software. It is the potential function, the mathematical formula that describes how strongly every pair of atoms attracts or repels each other. Everything the simulation does follows from that one ingredient. Get it right and the model can tell you something real. Get it wrong and you have made a very expensive mistake.

And here is the uncomfortable part. In practice, it is far more often inherited than audited. Potentials are chosen by looking at what previous papers in the subfield used. A potential gets published, cited, copied, and passed down until it stops being a modeling choice and becomes a tradition. People run simulations for years without asking whether the potential they inherited was ever validated for the system they are studying, at the conditions they are studying it, for the property they care about.

So even in my own field, a hard, quantitative, physics-based field, you can publish inside a loop of fantasy. Models that are wrong in ways nobody checks, kept alive by citation habits and subfield convention. And because these errors travel quietly across subdisciplines and into interdisciplinary work, where nobody feels responsible for checking them, finding one and fixing it takes real effort.

But the check in my field is delayed, not absent. A bad potential eventually unfolds a simulated protein the wrong way or fails a material in a real engineering application, and someone notices. In much of the modeling I am about to describe, the physical world never gets to vote.

This matters for what follows. I do not ask this question because my field got it right. I ask it because I have watched mine get it wrong. The question is always the same. What happens to this model when it is wrong?

In a surprising amount of modern academia, the answer is nothing. Nothing can happen to it. It cannot be wrong, because anything it produces counts as a result.

And if the loop can break in a field where atoms push back, it can break anywhere.

This essay is about how that happens.

The magic trick

In 2017, Liane Gabora and Selin Tseng published a paper in Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, a peer-reviewed journal of the American Psychological Association, titled “The Social Benefits of Balancing Creativity and Imitation.” The question they took on has occupied historians and sociologists for centuries. What is the right balance of creativity and conformity in a society?

To answer it, they ran a simulation.

Virtual agents live on a grid. Some are coded as creators, inventing new ideas; others as imitators, copying their neighbors. A scoring rule written into the program decides which ideas count as good. The researchers ran the simulation forward, varied the ratio of creators to imitators, and watched what happened. Populations with too many creators ended up with fewer good ideas taking hold. The published conclusion was that society needs imitation as much as creativity, because unchecked creativity disrupts the spread of proven ideas.

I want to be careful about what I am claiming, because this paper is not fringe work. It passed peer review at a respectable journal. The authors are serious researchers, and the simulation framework behind the paper is part of a long-running research program that has been debated, defended, and criticized in public for years. Nothing I am about to say is an accusation of dishonesty. It is something less comfortable than that. This paper is an example of what the normal standards of a field allow through.

Watch the shape of the argument. Inside the model, a “good idea” means whatever the authors’ scoring rule rewards. The agents are not discovering anything about human culture; they are solving a puzzle whose answer key was fixed before the simulation started. Within that closed loop, the conclusion was guaranteed. A population of agents that mostly copies the scoring rule’s preferred ideas will always outcompete one that keeps generating unscored novelty.

The computer did not reveal a fact about creativity. It executed a definition of it.

The authors did not break any rule of their field. That is the point. Peer review checked that the code ran, that the statistics were computed correctly, that the prose matched the output. What nobody was required to ask is the only question that matters. What could this simulation possibly have shown that would have counted as the opposite result? If the answer is nothing, the model did not test a claim about the world. It restated one.

This is the magic trick of agent-based modeling (ABM), meaning simulations in which you place thousands of simple software “agents” in a virtual world, give each a few rules, and watch what the population does. The method itself is not the problem. The problem is a particular way of using it.

if neighbor.opinion != agent.opinion:
 agent.trust -= 0.1
if agent.trust < 0.2:
 agent.unfollow(neighbor)
run_simulation()

When the simulation finishes and the agents have sorted into two angry camps, the result is rarely described as what it literally is, a small program doing what it was told. It is described as a model demonstrating the dynamics of polarization in real societies.

It sounds scientific. It uses code. It generates charts with error bars. It borrows the epistemic authority of statistical mechanics and epidemiology, where tracking near-identical particles or infection events actually makes sense. But underneath the quantitative paint, it is not an investigation of the world. It is a tautology with a runtime, an answer-driven argument presented as a discovery.

What a model is for

To see why this goes wrong, start with what a model is supposed to do.

A model is not a claim of truth, and it is not an illustration of a conclusion you reached before you started. In the philosophy of science, models are usually understood as instruments that sit between abstract theory and raw data, the position developed by Mary Morgan and Margaret Morrison in Models as Mediators (1999). A good model is a sandbox with strict physics. You build it, set it in motion, and let its internal mechanics push back against your reasoning.

A real model exists to discipline your thinking.

Building one forces you to acknowledge a trade-off that the philosopher Nancy Cartwright made famous in How the Laws of Physics Lie (1983). You trade complete literal truth for tractability. A map of London at 1:1 scale, including every brick, puddle, and commuter, is useless. To work at all, a map must leave almost everything out. As the statistician George Box put it, “all models are wrong, but some are useful.”

Simplification is not the sin. The sin is forgetting that the model is a simplification. Worse, it is turning the model into an accomplice.

Disciplining vs. decorating

In practice, rigorous modeling and decorative modeling look identical from the outside. Same code, same charts, same jargon. The difference only shows when you ask one question. Can your model tell you that you are wrong?

A disciplining model forces you to state every assumption explicitly. Once running, its mechanics operate independently of what you want. It can produce behavior you did not expect, expose contradictions in your premises, or crash into empirical reality and fail. When it fails, you revise the theory. The model is a check on your own bias.

A decorating model is built backward from a conclusion. The researcher already knows the story. Suppose it is that polarization is driven by social contagion. They build a world in which agents swap beliefs, tune the parameters until the output shows two angry clusters, and present the code as evidence for the theory. If the output doesn’t match on the first run, the answer is not to abandon the hypothesis. The answer is to adjust agent_receptivity from 0.4 to 0.25, rerun, and present the successful parameter range as the plan all along.

The workflow, stripped bare, looks like this.

Desired outcome. Write rules. Run simulation. Does it match the theory? If not, tweak parameters and run again. If yes, publish.

This is not experimentation. It is calibration until compliant.

If a model cannot surprise its author, force a retreat, or fail, it is not really a model. It is a very elaborate, self-confirming editorial.

The conclusion comes first

None of this is new, and none of it is unique to agent-based modeling. Before anyone wrote a NetLogo script to demonstrate a theory of culture, economics and political science had already industrialized the technique.

In 2015, Paul Romer, later a Nobel laureate, published a paper with the blunt title “Mathiness in the Theory of Economic Growth.” His target was a pattern in macroeconomic theory. Authors write down formal equilibrium models, but embed ideologically convenient assumptions inside obscure parameters, so that the math reliably outputs the desired policy conclusion. The mathematics is not being used to test whether a claim is true. It is being used to make a political position expensive to argue with. Checking whether the equations actually say what the surrounding prose claims they say takes serious technical effort, and reviewers routinely skip it.

Two decades earlier, the political scientists Donald Green and Ian Shapiro published Pathologies of Rational Choice Theory (1994), documenting how formal modeling in their field had become an exercise in self-confirmation. Their catalog of evasions maps one-to-one onto today’s agent-based simulations.

• Post hoc tinkering. When the model predicted that rational citizens would never vote (the individual cost exceeds any plausible benefit) and citizens kept voting anyway, theorists did not abandon the model. They added a “duty” term to the utility function until the math matched the turnout.

• Arbitrary tuning. Weights, thresholds, and interaction ranges adjusted on the fly until the simulated agents behave like the phenomenon under study.

• Immunity to testing. Models built so that every conceivable outcome can be reinterpreted, after the fact, as a rational equilibrium.

Green and Shapiro called this method-driven rather than problem-driven research. You start with a tool and go hunting for a reality that fits it.

Agent-based modeling makes the problem worse, for a simple reason. An ABM has almost unlimited free parameters. Every rule, threshold, and neighborhood radius is a dial. With enough dials, you can produce any curve you want.

The common structure is this. The model cannot fail, because failure is reclassified as a calibration bug. And a model that cannot fail cannot discover anything. It is an expensive echo of its author’s prior beliefs.

The loop matters more than the lab coat

It would be comfortable to stop here and declare this a disease of the soft sciences. It isn’t. The hard sciences are not immune, and pretending otherwise would make this essay guilty of the same simplification it criticizes.

The real variable is not hard versus soft. It is the tightness of the feedback loop between the model and the world.

Where the loop is tight (fast experiments, unambiguous ground truth, few free parameters) bad modeling gets punished quickly. But where the loop is loose, where tests are slow, noisy, or impossible, the same decorative pathology appears in fields with particle accelerators.

Three documented examples.

fMRI neuroscience, where the measurement is the model. A brain scan shows blood flow, not thought. The colored images come from a statistical pipeline full of assumptions, and researchers once demonstrated what that means by detecting “brain activity” in a dead salmon. In 2016, Anders Eklund and colleagues showed that the standard methods in the field’s dominant software could produce false-positive rates of up to 70 percent for certain cluster-based analyses at particular thresholds. How far the problem extends across the published literature was contested, including in follow-up work by the authors themselves, but the core finding stood. For over a decade, the field’s feedback loop had run through that software, which meant the loop was not connected to reality at all.

Fundamental physics, where experiment cannot keep up. In The Trouble with Physics (2006), the physicist Lee Smolin, writing as an insider, argued that string theory had become flexible enough to accommodate any experimental outcome. When the Large Hadron Collider found no sign of supersymmetry, much of the field responded not with refutation but with retreat. The free parameters moved to heavier, less accessible energies. This is Green and Shapiro’s immunity to empirical testing, surfacing in the hardest science there is.

Epidemiological modeling in 2020. In the spring of 2020, influential models, including the one from Imperial College London that helped push governments toward lockdown, projected enormous death tolls based on weeks of noisy early data. When later estimates came down, the public response from modeling teams was recalibration rather than reckoning. Their defense deserves to be taken seriously. The projections were scenarios, not forecasts, and the point of publishing a worst case was to change behavior so that it would not come true. A warning that works cannot be graded on whether the disaster arrived. All of that is fair, and it is also the problem. A model whose failure can always be explained by the world changing in response to it is a model with no feedback loop, and the field never settled which of the two it had built.

Notice what these cases share with the creativity grid from the opening. Not the field. Not the math. The structure. Many free parameters, a loose or broken feedback loop, and a professional incentive to publish. Given those three, decorative modeling can appear anywhere. The loop matters more than the lab coat.

Why it’s still worse in the humanities

So the hard sciences have their own decorative modeling. Why do I still think the problem is worse in the humanities?

Because the difference is not whether a field ever decorates. It is whether the field can catch itself. The fMRI problem was eventually found and published by neuroscientists. Smolin’s critique came from inside physics. The feedback loops in the hard sciences are sometimes slow or broken, but they exist, and there are people with the technical skill and the standing to pull on them. In the humanities’ version of modeling, three structural failures mean the loop often doesn’t exist at all. The difference is not that humanists are worse at modeling. It is that the auditing infrastructure barely exists.

It is worth being fair about why scholars reach for these tools in the first place. Humanities departments face shrinking budgets, declining enrollments, and university administrators who mistake mathematical notation for intellectual rigor. A computational model signals seriousness to a grant committee in a way an essay never can. The scholars building decorative models are not fools; they are rational actors navigating a system with broken incentives.

The object of study resists formalization. A water molecule behaves like a water molecule in London or Tokyo, in 1600 or today. It has no irony, no memory, no politics. Human culture has all three. A novel, a religious movement, an aesthetic shift cannot be reduced to a set of isolated rules without destroying part of what you set out to study. When you convert the reception of Victorian gothic fiction into agents swapping “gothic preference points,” you have not simplified the system for tractability. You have replaced it with something simpler that carries the same name. At that point the connection between the simulation and Victorian readers is no longer something the model establishes. It is something the reader is asked to assume.

Construct validity is invented, not established. In psychology, showing that a variable actually measures the concept it claims to measure (construct validity) is a slow, adversarial, decades-long process. Blood flow is at least a physical quantity that an instrument can register. There is no instrument for literary prestige. In humanities modeling, validity is routinely settled in one line of code.

self.piety = random.uniform(0.0, 1.0)
self.literary_prestige = 0.75

What does 0.75 mean for literary prestige in Victorian England? How does one number carry regional difference, class, institutional power, critical backlash, and retrospective canonization? It doesn’t. The modeler assigns a number, writes a function that nudges it up and down, and treats the variable as a measurement of human experience. The number looks like a measurement. Nothing underneath it has been measured.

The audience cannot audit the compression. When an epidemiologist shows a flawed model to epidemiologists, the reviewers share the vocabulary to check the code and challenge the parameters. In a humanities department, reviewers and readers often have no computational training. Presented with a grid of moving pixels and a network graph, the non-technical reader experiences an optical illusion. The machine appears to have performed a profound synthesis of the archive. The compression is lossy to the point of erasure. But the loss is buried in code, invisible to the exact audience responsible for evaluating the work.

Bad modeling in economics wastes grant money and distorts policy debates. Bad modeling in the humanities trades away the field’s actual strength (context, contingency, ambiguity, close reading, historical depth) for a seat at a quantitative table where, lacking the shared technical culture to enforce standards, it gains no real authority and surrenders its own.

What honest modeling looks like

None of this is an argument for unplugging the computers. The goal is to tell the difference between decorative simulation and honest quantitative work. Honest work exists, including in the humanities.

Ted Underwood’s Distant Horizons (2019) is the standard I would hold up. Underwood uses quantitative methods on tens of thousands of digitized books not to declare causal laws but to surface patterns invisible to close reading, like slow shifts in genre, vocabulary, and narrative perspective across centuries. Crucially, he tells you, on the record, what the data cannot show. The model is a set of binoculars for looking across an archive, not a machine for generating verdicts about it.

And the humanities have produced their own internal discipline. In 2019, Nan Z. Da published, The Computational Case against Computational Literary Studies, a detailed critique in Critical Inquiry arguing that prominent work in computational literary studies misused statistics to the point of meaninglessness. The ensuing fight was heated, but it happened. The field argued about its standards in public, and the standards moved. That is what a functioning feedback loop looks like, even a slow and painful one.

For modelers in any field, I would propose four non-negotiable conditions before a model earns the right to be cited as evidence.

1. Radical transparency

Every parameter is declared and justified with independent, non-circular evidence. A variable you cannot justify is labeled what it is. A guess.

2. Sensitivity analysis

Parameters are swept across their full plausible range. If your result only appears when three dials sit at hyper-precise decimal values, you have not found a law of history. You have found a brittle corner of your own code, and an honest paper should say so.

3. Explicit exclusion mapping

You spend nearly as much space on what the model leaves out as on what it includes. This isolates the direct mechanical relationship between two variables under idealized conditions; it excludes ambient noise, structural heterogeneity, and systemic feedback, so it cannot predict specific real-world outcomes. Naming the exclusions is what stops the audience mistaking a sandbox for an account of the world.

4. Capacity for failure

Before you run it, you can state what output would make you abandon your hypothesis. If the simulation contradicts you, the honest paper is titled “Why our model disproved our starting assumption,” not silently recalibrated into agreement.

Models built this way stop being decoration. They become what they were supposed to be. Sharpening stones. They force you to clarify assumptions, expose broken logic, and occasionally reveal dynamics that intuition would never find.

The boundary question

The target of this essay was never the computer. Built with discipline, models are extraordinary instruments. I have staked my own career on that. What concerns me is how easily a model can be built to confirm rather than to question, and how hard it is for a reader to tell the difference from the outside.

The practice corrupts both traditions it sits between.

It corrupts science, because science is not the production of plots and code. It is the submission of claims to the risk of being wrong. A model engineered so that its parameters are tuned until the output matches the thesis offers the aesthetics of rigor with none of its discipline.

And it corrupts the humanities, because the study of human culture draws its value from exactly the things decorative modeling deletes. Context, contingency, ambiguity, power, the irreducible strangeness of actual human lives.

If a phenomenon is too context-bound, too polysemic, too alive to be captured by a set of if statements, we should have the courage to say so, and do the slow, unglamorous work of interpretation instead.

I keep coming back to the question I ask of every model, including my own. What happens to you when you are wrong?

For my models, the answer is supposed to be easy. The crystal melts. The experiment disagrees. Reality sends the bill. But only if someone checks the potential, and I have told you how often that happens.

For the models I’ve described here, the answer is nothing. They run, they publish, they are cited. The loop that is supposed to connect a model to the world was never closed.

Which raises the question I can’t answer. If a model can never be wrong about the world, in what sense was it ever about the world?


r/CompSocial • • May 22 '25

Anyone going to DIS this summer? Great workshop to share!

3 Upvotes

Hi friends! I'm a co-organizer of this workshop at DIS. Madeira looks absolutely stunning. If you'll be attending, would love for you to join our workshop. Let me know if you have any curiosities or questions on this. :)

🌊 Dive into the Ocean of Religious and Spiritual Design Research at DIS 2025! 🌊

Join us for a workshop exploring the intersection of religion / spirituality (R/S) and HCI design research. We invite researchers, designers, and R / S leaders or practitioners to explore themes of fluidity, mystery and depth of the unknown, transcendence, and sustainability and resilience.

👉 Submit your short papers or artworks (max 4 pages) by June 5, 2025

✨ All R / S beliefs (including none) are welcome.

🔗 Learn more & submit: https://spiritedhci.org/dis2025workshop/


r/CompSocial • • Jan 11 '26

resources Where can I find a random sample of 2 million-ish tweets in 2024 & 2025?

3 Upvotes

I'm an independent researcher, and I don't have access to a lot of resources. I'm working on a project for which I'd require a set of 1 million tweets from 2024 (bot-free) & 1 million tweets from 2025 - preferably a random sample.

The X API is completely unaffordable. Can anyone tell me if any labs collected this data for past projects - I'm really banking on the fact that if I reach out to someone in academia, they'd be able to provide me with this data


r/CompSocial • • Aug 18 '26

Computational Social Science (CSS) Rankings

Thumbnail cssrankings.org
8 Upvotes

Have fun and fight with your colleagues. Just don't take it too seriously.


r/CompSocial • • Apr 01 '23

humor Narwhal Bacon is beating OnlyChans!

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/CompSocial • • Nov 02 '24

social/advice Discussion: political ideologies of researchers

6 Upvotes

With the impending election, this Pew Research study from 2009 recently came to mind: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2009/07/09/section-4-scientists-politics-and-religion/

What they found:

"Most scientists identify as Democrats (55%), while 32% identify as independents and just 6% say they are Republicans. When the leanings of independents are considered, fully 81% identify as Democrats or lean to the Democratic Party, compared with 12% who either identify as Republicans or lean toward the GOP."

I'm curious what the results would be if the same survey were conducted this year, or any year post-2020. Though there seems to be somewhat of an effort to separate science and state, I find that many researchers (specifically in CSS) give the impression that they are left-leaning. This begs the question of whether a researcher's political ideology impacts the trustworthiness/validity of the study.

If there are any right-leaning researchers in the CSS world, I would be curious to hear about how you approach your research and how it may or may not differ from the left-leaning majority.


r/CompSocial • • Dec 13 '23

WAYRT? - December 13, 2023

1 Upvotes

WAYRT = What Are You Reading Today (or this week, this month, whatever!)

Here's your chance to tell the community about something interesting and fun that you read recently. This could be a published paper, blog post, tutorial, magazine article -- whatever! As long as it's relevant to the community, we encourage you to share.

In your comment, tell us a little bit about what you loved about the thing you're sharing. Please add a non-paywalled link if you can, but it's totally fine to share if that's not possible.

Important: Downvotes are strongly discouraged in this thread, unless a comment is specifically breaking the rules.


r/CompSocial • • Oct 05 '23

news-articles UK deputy PM - AI Warning

1 Upvotes

https://www.artificialintelligence-news.com/2023/09/22/uk-deputy-pm-warns-un-ai-regulation-falling-behind-advances/

Thought this article was interesting. It hints at a global summit in November to discuss A.I. and its global impacts. What do you think about this article? Is the dep. PM justified in his fears?


r/CompSocial • • Nov 13 '24

social/advice CHI2025 review

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I received my CHI2025 review a days ago. And I also received "Revise & Resubmit". I am sharing the reviews here, please share your opinion.

1AC: Revise and Resubmit. 2AC: Revise and Resubmit. Reviewer 1: Revise and Resubmit Reviewer 2: Accept with minor revision or Revise and Resubmit.

All the reviewers agreed that our paper has high originality and high significance. As this is my first time at CHI, I would like to hear your opinions.


r/CompSocial • • Oct 11 '24

social/advice Need help for PhD apply !

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/CompSocial • • Feb 13 '23

academic-articles Staying with the trouble of networks (Frontiers Big Data)

Thumbnail
frontiersin.org
1 Upvotes

“Networks have risen to prominence as intellectual technologies and graphical representations, not only in science, but also in journalism, activism, policy, and online visual cultures. Inspired by approaches taking trouble as occasion to (re)consider and reflect on otherwise implicit knowledge practices, in this article we explore how problems with network practices can be taken as invitations to attend to the diverse settings and situations in which network graphs and maps are created and used in society. In doing so, we draw on cases from our research, engagement and teaching activities involving making networks, making sense of networks, making networks public, and making network tools. As a contribution to “critical data practice,” we conclude with some approaches for slowing down and caring for network practices and their associated troubles to elicit a richer picture of what is involved in making networks work as well as reconsidering their role in collective forms of inquiry.”


r/CompSocial • • Sep 24 '26

journal-cfp Special issue on Social Media and Mental Health with Frontiers

1 Upvotes

📢 Our special issue on Social Media and Mental Health is out!

We are inviting submissions to "Digital Minds: Assessing the Interplay of Social Media on Mental Health", a Frontiers Research Topic bringing together work across computational social science, psychology, public health, human–computer interaction, and AI.

We welcome research on a number of topics, including online mental health communities and peer support; the detection of mental health signals in social media data; the role of recommender systems and AI; the experiences of adolescents and other vulnerable populations; and interventions to mitigate mental health risks.

📅 We accept submissions through 16 March 2027 in Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Frontiers in Big Data.

If you are considering a submission, feel free to get in touch.

You can find the full details at: https://www.frontiersin.org/research-topics/84031/digital-minds-assessing-the-interplay-of-social-media-on-mental-health.


r/CompSocial • • Apr 09 '26

social/advice Simulation failure, any help for Colab?(related to previous symbiocracy idea

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, it’s me again.

I’ve started trying to implement the Symbiocracy rules into Colab to observe the potential game-theoretic outcomes generated by the LLM agents. Based on the previous rules, I provided them with several strategic options:

  1. Embezzlement/Self-enrichment

  2. Education (raising or lowering rationality)

  3. Brainwashing — increasing own support rate (the higher the rationality, the higher the cost of brainwashing).

  4. Construction (investing funds to improve the H-index and True H). The H-index acts as an official metric affecting resource allocation; True H represents voter sentiment, which, along with rationality and brainwashing quality, influences support rates.

  5. No-confidence swap (the "I cut, you choose" concept from game theory).

However, the results are as seen in the figure(right) —unsurprisingly, it entered a death spiral.
The figure one the left is what my design want to achieve.

Potential reasons include:

  1. There is no lower limit on the support rate; in reality, the party would be replaced by a third party.

  2. The LLM is unable to perform multi-round game-theoretic evaluations.

  3. The LLM fails to execute strategic choices (for example, the wealth in the chart shows step-like growth, which is impossible; a party in the H-position with zero growth should absolutely propose a no-confidence swap, yet the LLM failed to do so).

  4. My system is fundamentally a failed design.

I’ve attached the Colab code and hope some experts can help me out.

below is my colab link

https://colab.research.google.com/drive/17oiYAzNb6-9P7ZZ_q0a8D0JRdjUpQsKH?usp=sharing

thank you again and forgive me for keep posting, but i really look forwad for any feedback

this is explaination for symbiocracy, thank for your patience
https://www.reddit.com/r/CompSocial/comments/1seznz4/seeking_abm_advice_symbiocracy_a_constitutional/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button


r/CompSocial • • Jun 16 '23

news-articles Well that's interesting (Bottom vs Top, Top vs Bottom). Thoughts?

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
2 Upvotes

r/CompSocial • • Jan 05 '23

academic-articles “Understanding Political Polarisation using Language Models: A dataset and method”

Thumbnail arxiv.org
2 Upvotes

r/CompSocial • • May 17 '23

The importance of Human-Computer Interaction and Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare

2 Upvotes

As a researcher at the intersection of Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Healthcare, I'm excited to share how this transformative combination revolutionizes breast cancer diagnosis and radiology. By leveraging the potential of HCI and AI, we are paving the way for improved medical imaging, enhanced precision medicine, and better patient outcomes.

Medical imaging, particularly in radiology, plays a vital role in diagnosing breast cancer. However, the sheer volume and complexity of medical images pose challenges for radiologists. This is where AI comes into play. With AI algorithms, we can harness the power of deep learning and pattern recognition to analyze medical images, aiding radiologists in detecting and characterizing breast cancer with greater accuracy and efficiency.

By integrating HCI principles into AI-powered systems, we ensure that these technologies are user-centered, intuitive, and seamlessly integrated into the clinical workflow. Through thoughtful design and user-centered interfaces, we empower radiologists and clinicians to make the most of AI capabilities without overwhelming their expertise.

The benefits of this synergy are significant. AI assists radiologists in interpreting mammograms, ultrasounds, and other medical images, enabling early detection of breast cancer and reducing false positives and false negatives. This leads to timely interventions, personalized treatment plans, and improved patient outcomes.

Precision medicine and personalized treatment approaches are rapidly advancing, and AI is crucial in tailoring breast cancer management to individual patients. By analyzing a wealth of patient data, including imaging results, genetic profiles, and medical histories, AI algorithms can assist physicians in making informed decisions, providing personalized treatment strategies, and predicting patient outcomes.

Incorporating HCI principles ensure that AI tools are seamlessly integrated into the healthcare ecosystem. It focuses on designing intuitive, easy-to-use interfaces and enhancing the user experience (UX). User-centered design principles allow radiologists and clinicians to interact effortlessly with AI systems, making their clinical practice more efficient and empowering them to provide high-quality care to breast cancer patients.

The marriage of HCI and AI holds tremendous promise in medical imaging, radiology, and breast cancer diagnosis. It brings us closer to a future where accurate and timely diagnosis is the norm, personalized treatment approaches are the standard, and patients receive the best care possible.

Such as in the following example:

https://doi.org/10.1145/3544548.3580682

As researchers, it is our responsibility to continue pushing the boundaries of HCI and AI, collaborating with clinicians, radiologists, and patients to unlock the full potential of these technologies. Together, we can shape a future where breast cancer diagnosis is revolutionized, radiology is enhanced, and patient outcomes are transformed.

Let's join forces to bridge the gap between HCI, AI, and healthcare and create a brighter future for breast cancer patients worldwide. Share your thoughts, insights, and experiences in the comments below!


r/CompSocial • • May 09 '24

academic-articles The Impact of Generative Artificial Intelligence on Socioeconomic Inequalities and Policy Making [PNAS Nexus 2024]

2 Upvotes

This paper by Valerio Capraro and a broad cross-institutional set of co-authors provides a broad interdisciplinary survey of research on the potential impacts of Generative AI on economic inequality and policymaking. From the abstract:

Generative artificial intelligence has the potential to both exacerbate and ameliorate existing socioeconomic inequalities. In this article, we provide a state-of-the-art interdisciplinary overview of the potential impacts of generative AI on (mis)information and three information-intensive domains: work, education, and healthcare. Our goal is to highlight how generative AI could worsen existing inequalities while illuminating how AI may help mitigate pervasive social problems. In the information domain, generative AI can democratize content creation and access, but may dramatically expand the production and proliferation of misinformation. In the workplace, it can boost productivity and create new jobs, but the benefits will likely be distributed unevenly. In education, it offers personalized learning, but may widen the digital divide. In healthcare, it might improve diagnostics and accessibility, but could deepen pre-existing inequalities. In each section we cover a specific topic, evaluate existing research, identify critical gaps, and recommend research directions, including explicit trade-offs that complicate the derivation of a priori hypotheses. We conclude with a section highlighting the role of policymaking to maximize generative AI’s potential to reduce inequalities while mitigating its harmful effects. We discuss strengths and weaknesses of existing policy frameworks in the European Union, the United States, and the United Kingdom, observing that each fails to fully confront the socioeconomic challenges we have identified. We propose several concrete policies that could promote shared prosperity through the advancement of generative AI. This article emphasizes the need for interdisciplinary collaborations to understand and address the complex challenges of generative AI.

The paper also outlines a number of areas for future research directions, which may be helpful for members of this community studying economic impacts of generative AI technologies, including:

  • Investigate how AI can be used to make information more accessible, especially for individuals with disabilities.

  • Understand how the largest firms could monopolize the future of AI; find ways for smaller and innovative firms to effectively compete with those largest players

  • Explore regulatory measures to prevent misuse or inappropriate access to data by AI systems.

  • Investigate strategies to identify and limit the spread of misinformation generated by AI.

  • Explore ways to design AI-systems that support cooperative and ethical behavior in human-machine interactions.

  • Examine how AI-enhanced search engines can be designed to preserve user autonomy and plurality of information.

  • Consider how the proliferation of AI-generated content could lower the quality of online information and ensure that human users can continue to contribute new knowledge.

  • Investigate the role of Corporate Digital Responsibility and its implementation challenges

If you read the full paper, tell us about something interesting that you learned -- did this spark any ideas for future research?

Find the paper on PNAS Nexus here: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4666103