r/Communist • u/sovietbrutal • 12h ago
r/Communist • u/Distinct_Let9742 • 2d ago
How is China socialist if it has a free market?
reddit.comr/Communist • u/dariors12 • 2d ago
Ho un dubbio che da sempre mi assilla sull'ideologia comunista
reddit.comPremetto col dire che con questo post mi rivolgerò alle persone che non ragionano per ideologia o partito preso, quindi, se pensi di rispondere con una frase alla Berlusconi o con qualcosa con della oggettiva "pochezza", non rispondere.
Sono in quarta superiore e, nell'ultimo anno, come usualmente succede a questa età (e io sono anche in ritardo) mi sto orientando per le prime volte all'interno della politica, cercando di osservare e capire le diverse ideologie.
Negli ultimi tempi ho deciso di iniziare studiando quello che è il pensiero marxista.
Più nello specifico, ho già letto e compreso il "manifesto del partito comunista" e "lavoro salariato e capitale" e ho già comprato (ma devo ancora leggere) "salario, prezzo e profitto" e, di Lenin, "stato e rivoluzione"; inoltre, in parallelo sto svolgendo anche tutto quello che è il lavoro storico, più nello specifico dall'epoca zarista in poi, dato che a scuola non ci sono ancora arrivato.
Quindi, aggiungendo anche i vari video su YouTube, penso di avere già, anche se non approfondite, basi sull'ideologia comunista.
Il problema è che, guardando i social, mi escono tantissimi video di persone (anche radicalizzate) che, anche se sembrano colte, dalla mia visione esprimono discorsi apparentemente senza senso.
Ad esempio ho visto molte persone che esaltano le figure di Lenin e Stalin, che a mio avviso (anche senza i gonfiamenti della propaganda capitalista nei dati storici delle vicende accadute) hanno portato molte disgrazie anche verso l'umanità.
Oppure, piú semplicemente, pensando tra me e me, nel mondo odierno l'ideologia comunista non mi sembra realizzabile.
C'è qualcuno che mi potrebbe chiarire questi miei dubbi? Inoltre, conoscete altri canali attivi (anche di reddit) dove posso dibattere su questi argomenti?
Grazie in anticipo
r/Communist • u/vicxjules • 3d ago
American Marxists Fundamental Works
I have just finished Black Reconstruction with my reading group
(We've previously read Blood In My Eyes by George Jackson and Revolutionary Suicide by Huey Newton)
We are attempting to find actual American revolutionary Marxist theorists that critically engaged with this country's history and social conditions.
So far we've found excellent works with Du Boise being the most thorough and having the most clarity on the reality of the American situation - and Jackson's works being more of a polemic with deep insight as well , and Newton being more autobiographical.
We've some criticisms of Davis but have engaged and done with the works of Claudia Jones (although she's metropolitan bouncing back and forth between Trindad + Tobago, The US, and UK)
But we're really trying to find what are some really foundational American Marxist theorists who were revolutionary minded but also had a massive grasp on the political and social conditions of this country.
A theorist who's work should be foundational text for any American communist organizations.
Suggestions are welcomed - thank you
r/Communist • u/Accomplished-Food272 • 4d ago
SIMPLE dyslexia friendly book about communism/socialism/marxisme
hiiii i really want to learn more about socialism but everyone tries to explain it in complaceted ways ? I think i need to learn from the beginning and make small staps to read more complecaded books about the theme. ( i would preffer a more populair book so i can borrow it from the libery)
do you have any tips?
r/Communist • u/Financial_Might_6816 • 4d ago
What’s a good French communist subreddit?
reddit.comr/Communist • u/Game_And_Walk • 4d ago
Looking for sources about the imperialism of the Canadian Armed Forces
The timing of this post is intentional.
r/Communist • u/i_just_wanna_be_me • 6d ago
What would "far left" even look like?
reddit.comr/Communist • u/Habakuk-Beneke • 6d ago
Una legge elettorale per il grande capitale
reddit.comr/Communist • u/Classic-Machine-5249 • 7d ago
Sanders and Warren look for deals with Trump as his attorney general threatens Democrats
r/Communist • u/itzbenitez • 7d ago
cpusa or psl
im asking this because im wondering what would be the best party to join as a ML. psl seems more attractive bc they have the most motion compared to other left wing orgs and have been growing but they also have allegations in terms of either them working with cops and basically only protesting rather than organizing or and not to mention their SA allegation which is very concerning. CPUSA on the other hand while they have lots of instances of them being incredibly revisionist, they seem to be much more keen on their beliefs but unfortunately dont have that big of a presence in the american communist community. what would be better to join?
r/Communist • u/Ugo_Boros • 7d ago
Comminism in DnD
Guys, I'm making my own world in the board role-playing game DnD, and I want to know your opinion. I want to make a socialist/communist dwarf state. Can you give me some advice to understand how such a state should be organized?
r/Communist • u/gayeggyolk • 8d ago
Am I bad for voting Democrat in the midterms?
Hello, Reddit Communists. I’m hoping to get thoughtful answers and not just harsh reactions. Though I get if I need some sense slapped into me.
As I’ve gotten older (I’m only 23, but still), I’ve gotten more involved in politics, especially socialist and communist ideas. I admire the work socialist and communist groups are doing and want to help my own community.
For the midterms, I voted Democrat because I felt cautious about abstaining from voting altogether. Though I know Democrats are imperialist and capitalist and plenty corrupt—and I have every intention of holding the candidates accountable beyond voting—I felt like it was too risky to vote differently. I’m happy to see socialist movements getting a bit more popular, but it still feels too small on a bigger scale.
The guilt has been eating at me these past couple days. I think about all the exploitation happening overseas and feel overwhelmed with grief. So, I want to hear your opinions. How can I be sure I’m doing real good?
r/Communist • u/Amazing_Assumption50 • 8d ago
Unlearning propaganda about past communist/socialist leaders
I may have made a post similar to this, so I apologize any repetition.
I was talking with another communist online, and as I was going through their account, I noticed that they were a big supporter of Fidel Castro, and in another post they mentioned they were anti-fascist. I was taught that leaders like Castro were fascists, and I brought up my confusion to them, adding that I may have been taught wrong about him and other such leaders. They responded that Castro was in fact communist, which solidifies my theory that I was in fact taught very wrong about a lot of past socialist and communist leaders. Ive gone through the manifesto and the principles of communism, and I’m in the middle of Blackshirts and Reds, but I’m looking for media/works to unlearn whatever I’ve been taught, and some suggestions (and maybe just general corrections) would be great.
I also have a question relating to this, but is it possible to idealize/follow the teachings and principles of past socialist/communist leaders while also criticizing them? I’ve seen backlash about this from other communists
r/Communist • u/redoctobernz • 9d ago
Sick of the usual parties
Sick of the usual parties in nz. I want something modelled on China’s system
strong state direction, public ownership of key industries, long term planning, and workers’ interests first.
Are any of the existing left parties actually pushing this, or are they all just watered down?
r/Communist • u/Significant-Ask7545 • 9d ago
Rite Of Passage
Well it happens to any communist it seems, I've been banned from R/communism due to the mod getting upset with something completely unrelated to my comment on the subreddit. He disliked that I was using my punk band to spread pamphlets for CPUSA and DSA rather then "telling people to read Capitol"
r/Communist • u/WorkingMan26 • 9d ago
Living in America
What Communist party in America best represents actual Communism and would be the recommended one to join?
r/Communist • u/Classic-Machine-5249 • 9d ago
After Republican election debacle, Democrats pledge “bipartisan common ground” with Trump
r/Communist • u/Scyobi_Empire • 11d ago
There is a concerning amount of self proclaimed anarchists and so called communists celebrating the bourgeois beating the bourgeois in the US election
reddit.comr/Communist • u/Pristine_Sea_6749 • 10d ago
Um país plenamente comunista no futuro é possível?
Gente, to querendo criar um livro de ficção futurista sobre o assunto. Então o comunismo pleno em pelo menos um país, e pode ter em mais de um, porém ainda não me decidir se em todos, JÁ É PLENO. Quero desenvolver esse país QUE JÁ É PLENO. Então pensar no que ele precisa/tem /oferece/funciona/etc. Vamos pensar em país auto suficiente/auto sustentável que não depende do comércio com outros países para ... Qualquer coisa. PLENO, A SUPERAÇÃO JÁ ACONTECEU. Ainda não decidi o contexto político externo. Mas dentro do próprio país,quais os limites?
E tipo, já tenho uma boa base e soluções até. Levem em consideração que com futuro nós conseguimos socializar a tecnologia. No livro quero me ater ao nível tecnológico atual. Pelo menos de funcionalidade.
A questão é, gostaria de discutir mais situações problemas, conceitos, termos, que eu ainda não pensei.
Se puderem contribuir, agradeço.
r/Communist • u/Habakuk-Beneke • 10d ago
Il Futuro del Pessimismo e dell'Individualismo (Georges Palante, 1914)
reddit.comr/Communist • u/Gold_Ad3045 • 11d ago
What ideology would best fit an global revolutionary movement?
I'd like the opinion of those of you who understand Marxist/leftist ideologies better than I do.
I'm working on a science fiction universe about an alien invasion and I've created movements with different ideologies to fill in the lore. The idea is that these movements of often opposite ideologies, would compete for legitimacy in the fight against the invader, claiming to be the legitimate representatives of humanity.
I created a leftist movement for this universe, but I'm unsure which ideology would be most suitable to define this movement.
The movement would advocate for a world revolution and the unification of humanity around a global socialist republic, where there would be centralized production and total collectivization of the means of production.
I initially thought of making them Stalinists, however, Stalinism advocated the idea of "socialism in one country," which doesn't fit with this movement, which advocated for something on a global scale.
Which ideology would best fit a movement that advocates for socialism on a global scale? Would Trotskyism fit in?
Note: This post is not for self-promotion; I will only post the link to the series if a moderator expressly allows it.
r/Communist • u/GregGraffin23 • 11d ago
On the Dialectic, the Revolution, and the Dominion of Capital
On the Dialectic, the Revolution, and the Dominion of Capital
I. The debt to Hegel
Whoever undertakes to criticise the political economy of our age must first settle his account with Hegel, and I make no secret of the debt. As a young man in Berlin I was bound to that philosophy as to a strict master. I sat among the Young Hegelians, and like them I believed that the world might be set right by a sufficiently thorough criticism of religion and philosophy. I have since learned otherwise. Yet when, not two years ago, I was occupied with the question of how the economic categories are to be arranged and linked, I happened to take up Hegel’s Logic once more, and it rendered me no small service in the treatment of my material.
What Hegel taught, before all else, is that nothing in the world is fixed. Every form is a moment in a movement, and every existing thing carries within it the germ of its own negation. The mind that has grasped this can no longer regard property, wage-labour or the State as eternal ordinances of Nature. They are passing products of a particular stage of history, and they will pass away.
II. The mystification
Yet this great thinker stood upon his head. With Hegel the Idea is the demiurge of the real world, and the real world is but the outward appearance of the Idea. History becomes the self-development of the Spirit, and men its unconscious instruments. In my criticism of his Philosophy of Right I found that legal relations and forms of State are to be understood neither from themselves nor from the so-called development of the human mind. They are rooted in the material conditions of life, which Hegel, following the English and French writers, comprehends under the name of “civil society”. The anatomy of that society is to be sought in political economy. As I have stated in the preface to my recent Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, it is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but their social being that determines their consciousness.
I have never denied him his due. In the Phenomenology he grasped labour as the act by which man creates himself, and he perceived the estrangement that dwells in it. But the labour he knew was the labour of the mind, abstract and bloodless, and the real workman with his blistered hands found no place in it. The dialectic in his hands is mystified, and the rational part must be separated from the mystical. Rightly understood, it lets nothing impose upon it and is critical and revolutionary in its essence. That is why the German professors, who now find it convenient to treat Hegel as a thinker outgrown, have so little love for his method. A doctrine that recognises in the existing order the necessity of its own dissolution is an unwelcome guest at their table.
III. Engels, Hess and Weitling
I did not make this journey alone. Frederick Engels, whose friendship is the best fortune of my life, came to the same conclusions by his own road, as the manufacturer’s son who had seen Manchester with his own eyes. His Outlines of a Critique of Political Economy, which appeared in the Deutsch-Französische Jahrbücher, I have called a brilliant sketch, and it first turned my attention to the economic categories. We wrote The Holy Family together against the Young Hegelians, and later, in Brussels, we resolved to settle accounts with our former philosophical conscience. That manuscript we abandoned to the gnawing criticism of the mice, having accomplished our main purpose, which was to clear up the matter for ourselves. His book upon the English working class, and the money he sends me from his counting-house, have served the cause in different but equal measure.
Moses Hess belongs to those early days. In the Rhenish years he was among the first to carry communism into German philosophy, and his writings upon money and upon the alienation of man directed my own thoughts. But Hess remained in the clouds. His “true socialism”, like that of many Germans of those years, took the real struggles of the French proletariat and translated them into the phrases of the Hegelian school. This is the vice of our nation. We make philosophy out of what the French make into action.
Wilhelm Weitling is a different case, and I speak of him with respect. He is a journeyman tailor, and in 1844 I wrote that the German bourgeoisie could show no work on its own emancipation to compare with his Guarantees of Harmony and Freedom. It was the immeasurable and brilliant debut of the German workman. But when we met in Brussels he had become a prophet, with a scheme for redeeming the people by sentiment, inspiration and conspiracy. I told him plainly that to rouse the workers with fantasies, without strict scientific ideas, is a dishonest game of preaching, and that ignorance has never yet helped any man. He took it ill. I do not, however, withdraw my first judgment. The workman who thinks is worth more than all the philosophers.
IV. Robespierre and the Terror
Hegel himself analysed the Terror, in the Phenomenology, as the issue of an abstract freedom that tolerates nothing between itself and the individual. I would add what Hegel could not see: that the Jacobins were making a bourgeois revolution. Robespierre and Saint-Just believed they were restoring the ancient republic of virtue, Sparta and Rome. They failed to see that the modern bourgeois society, with its free competition and its industry, was being born under their hands, and that their Terror was merely the plebeian manner of sweeping away the feudal remnants that stood in its path. The Terror served that society, and Robespierre fell when he tried to subordinate it to an ancient ideal that its own interests could not endure. The men of the Revolution performed the task of their time in Roman costume and in Roman phrases, and the costume deceived them as to their purpose.
V. Napoleon, tragedy and farce
Napoleon came after, and he completed the Terror by putting permanent war in the place of permanent revolution. He despised the bourgeois, yet he guarded their interests. He regarded the State as an end in itself and bourgeois society as a mere treasurer, to be kept in order and made to pay. He gave the French peasant his allotment, and the allotment became the foundation of the Empire. Hegel, who saw in him a great historical figure, remarked somewhere that all great facts and personages in world history occur, as it were, twice. He forgot to add that the first time is tragedy, and the second time farce. The elder Bonaparte conquered Europe. His nephew has conquered the French ballot-box, and the sight of him should teach us more about history than all the philosophy of Berlin.
VI. Capital and its contradictions
I come now to the system under which we live, to which this method must be applied. The bourgeois economists present capital as a fact of Nature, like gravity or the seasons. We see it as a social relation, historically produced, and bearing within it a contradiction that Hegel himself would have recognised.
Capital can grow only by setting labour in motion, yet it grows by paying that labour less than the value it creates. The surplus thus extracted is the source of profit and of the accumulation of the rich. The labourer, compelled by want to sell his labour-power, produces a world of wealth that stands over against him as an alien and hostile power. The more he creates, the poorer he becomes. This is estrangement, which the philosophers spoke of in the abstract, found in the factory and the workshop. In its feverish pursuit of gain, capital respects neither the health of the operative, nor the childhood of the little ones sent into the mills, nor the earth from which all wealth ultimately springs. It makes of all things a commodity and measures every human relation by the cash-payment. I hold it to be the great evil of our time, and the cause of a misery that is not accidental but inherent.
And here again Hegel is our guide. A system that lives by the contradiction between social production and private appropriation must sharpen that contradiction until it can no longer contain it. The class it calls into being, the proletariat, becomes the negation of the order that created it. What the bourgeoisie produces above all are its own grave-diggers.
VII. The unfinished work
Hegel held that philosophy comes always too late, that the owl of Minerva spreads its wings only at the falling of the dusk. I would answer that the task is not merely to interpret the world, but to change it. Of Hegel I retain the movement and the contradiction, the whole terrible and fruitful dialectic. I leave the Idea, which was never more than his own shadow cast upon the wall.