24
u/futureislookinstark LEFT HAND UP Apr 29 '23
Was it a reach sure, but two rounds is not true. We got CB2 and our nickel. Time for Benjamin st juste to take that next step. Fuller can move to McCains position
-26
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Yeah, that’s the thing tho — it’s a reach.
The player may turn out fine. But he could have turned out fine on one of our third round comps instead while we got an OL with the second.
13
u/com-mis-er-at-ing Apr 29 '23
theres no way to know if another team would have taken him tho. the media is not the arbiter of value. clearly this draft in particular, mockers and media have not had similar value as GMs have on a number of players.
-13
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Who cares if another team takes him? It’s a 3-4th round safety.
11
u/Januse88 🐷Tuddyhead🐷 Apr 29 '23
Or he's a second round safety and the media doesn't know what they're talking about
-6
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Had you ever heard of this guy? Honestly
9
u/Januse88 🐷Tuddyhead🐷 Apr 29 '23
Yes. But it doesn't matter who you or I have heard of. It matters who GMs have on their big boards.
11
u/com-mis-er-at-ing Apr 29 '23
Says who? Mel Kiper? The other media talking heads who all parrot each other? I think fans need to realize that teams do not have the same opinion of players as media. And fans are left clinging to preconceived values that they’ve read about from outsiders.
Clearly he is a round 2 safety. Because an NFL team decided to make him one. Why is that opinion worth less than the media or fans who guesstimated he wouldn’t be?
7
u/qotsa_gibs COMMAND DEEZ NUTZ Apr 29 '23
Man, this is spot on. They have a whole room full of analysts and evaluators whose soul job is to pick players. Sure, they will they get it wrong sometimes, but they've been pretty good in recent years.
1
u/zimzam2019 Fuck Dan Snyder Apr 29 '23
I agree with you but at the same time this could be said to any criticism of the coaching staff or front office, they are obviously better football minds than everyone in this sub but we’re here to talk about what we think they shoulda done
2
u/com-mis-er-at-ing Apr 29 '23 edited Apr 29 '23
You can absolutely see a coach’s success/failure by the Ws and Ls and by the overall performance of the team. We can easily judge players coaches and the front office. But doing so the day of a pick strictly bc of preconceived values based on media and people who echo the media, is entirely illogical. I’m not saying coaches are infallible, I’m saying the barometer by which fans are judging draft picks is supremely fallible.
See my reply to pickled eggs below this. Expectations set by media do not have merit simply because they exist. It is human nature to accept the first piece of information we receive to be accurate and any following information that disagrees w our first dataset will be deemed “inaccurate.” This is true of people in almost any context. It is how our minds work.
It is also completely stupid. And the proper reaction to a disagreement of data isn’t to label it inaccurate (ie this player is a 3rd or 4th round S because I was told he was last week, therefore when today I am told by another party that he is a 2nd round S, I can disregard that viewpoint as incorrect). The proper reaction is to acknowledge a disagreement and if able, make a new evaluation of both datasets without the bias of which dataset you believed first.
You will and surely have seen this reflected in a million different contexts. One of the least consequential contexts is the NFL draft.
1
u/zimzam2019 Fuck Dan Snyder Apr 29 '23
I really do completely agree with what you’re saying. It’s just tough because as fans lots of us have just spent a decent chunk of our available hours in last two months reading/listening about the draft and now have opinions on it and want to share them. I’ve been seeing a lot of replies similar to yours whenever anyone complains and you guys are always right, the person complaining is not smarter about football than the media that they initially thought were correct, and is really not smarter than the actual football decision makers that they now think are wrong, but I kind of want to defend their right to shit on our football decision makers because our football decision makers have not proven themselves to be good at their jobs compared to their peers. It is just people talking about something they don’t know that much about, but that’s what all of this is to an extent. But also you guys are correct. I don’t know. Maybe following the draft is just stupid and I should stop doing it
1
u/com-mis-er-at-ing Apr 29 '23 edited Apr 29 '23
This mentality should actually make following and watching the draft more fun, unless the joy you get from the draft is just complaining about picks.
Team building is exciting and full of possibility. Detaching from the idea that “these media rankings have supreme validity” let’s you enjoy the potential of every selection.
If anything it makes the surprises even more fun. Both for you team and other teams. It was wild seeing 2 RBs go top 12, didn’t expect that, it’s crazy and damn maybe it works out for Lions and Falcons.
You can see the whole draft as a fun experience not one where you nitpick and ridicule based on blind belief in a flawed dataset. And you don’t have to have frustration for your team or schadenfreude for others. There can be guys you really want but when you don’t get them it’s not the end of the world bc no one knows anything.
It’s always easy to find things to complain about in life, so why add an additional (and 100% verifiably completely illogical) reason to complain. It’s much more exciting to find joy and potential in a draft.
But also… completely disregard all of this if you just like watching the draft the way you like watching the draft. But try not to let it upset you too much or ruin your day if it doesn’t go how you’d have liked. Let it the highs be real high and the lows be not-too-low.
1
u/zimzam2019 Fuck Dan Snyder Apr 29 '23
Yeah we agree just talking about slightly different things. This might not have been the best post to make this point on because this post does seem to be driven by media perception, all I’m saying is in general it’s fine for someone to be upset if they disagree with how Ron & co are going about team building. I tend to prefer the wait-and-see mentality because like you’ve said, it’s nuts to think that I know more about team building than people who do it for their jobs, but I also don’t think we should be trying to force that mentality on everyone.
“Media” is a super broad term. I think people who are just parroting Kiper or their draft “expert” of choice do come across as dumb, but the media that you refer to is how all of us have learned everything we know about the draft. Media includes every analyst and beat reporter.
It’s impossible to actually know if someone who is perceived to be a reach actually was or not because the other FOs aren’t gonna release their boards. With the exception of the superfans who have time to grind tape on every prospect, all we have is aggregation of media opinions. I don’t personally think it’s constructive to get mad about a perceived reach, but I also understand that if people spend a decent amount of their time thinking about an event and then it doesn’t go their way, they’re gonna get mad about the outcome. I don’t think we need to tell them all to shut up, I think that’s a super valid way of consuming sports which is what we’re all here to do.
-2
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Yeah. Like everyone who evaluates prospects for a living.
8
u/com-mis-er-at-ing Apr 29 '23
Minus everyone employed by teams to do so. Medias job is to market the evaluation of players, the secondary assignment is to actually evaluate them. A hypothetical best scout on earth would not be on a broadcast team if they didn’t have a brandable persona. They would, on the other hand, have 32 job offers in the NFL.
I understand the frustration of picks not matching established expectations but that does not speak to merit of those established expectations, just their existence.
-1
5
u/Rex_Grossman_the_3rd Apr 29 '23
I remember people saying we reached on Terry as well.
"How are you going to sornd a 3rd round on a special teamer?!"
Idiots.
-1
20
u/ChaseTheAdverb Slingin Sammy Apr 29 '23
Give these guys a chance. Remember Dotson?
-9
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Dotson was like a 7 pick reach. This was like a 37 pick reach. Dude’s coming in as S4 at best. Could have had an OL1 — and this guy later.
14
u/salamanderman10 Apr 29 '23
These posts crack me up. Like any of us know where guys will go. If we did, we would be rich betting vegas odds
6
u/futureislookinstark LEFT HAND UP Apr 29 '23 edited Apr 29 '23
But bro OP has Jartavius as Safety number 4 on OPs board so obviously he’s a reach because OP is actually an amazing scout it’s just that teams always look them over cause teams don’t know how to scout for their scouts
0
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
What board was he top 4 on, scout?
6
u/futureislookinstark LEFT HAND UP Apr 29 '23
You literally said in this same thread he was your 4th best safety
1
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
He’s Washington’s fourth best safety, numnut.
6
u/futureislookinstark LEFT HAND UP Apr 29 '23 edited Apr 29 '23
Percy butler didn’t even play you can’t tell me he’s better than Martin already. Stop bitching about things you don’t know yet and set a remind me for next year when he starts in the slot/nickel.
1
1
u/futureislookinstark LEFT HAND UP Apr 29 '23
Remindme! 1 year
1
u/RemindMeBot Apr 29 '23
I will be messaging you in 1 year on 2024-04-29 04:01:47 UTC to remind you of this link
CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.
Info Custom Your Reminders Feedback -2
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
That’s a cheap out. He was projected as late 3. And who cares if someone snaps up our S4 before us. Even if he turns out ok it was a major reach.
37
Apr 29 '23
I hate when people say a player was a reach you have no idea how other gms value these guys your just looking at mock drafts
2
u/Stupidityorjoking Apr 29 '23
This is exactly it. The entire reach conversation and the whole, "we could have gotten him 2 rounds later" is the dumbest conversation. Its like people want these dudes to tune into ESPN to make sure our big board lines up with whatever Mel Kiper is saying. The entire reach conversation is based on the media. I absolutely want them operating without any outside influence and without caring about whether Bucky Brooks is gonna kill them for an alleged reach. I want them focusing on how guys fit our scheme.
Go look back at how those legendary Seahawks drafts were received. They got killed for it.
-12
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Do you think this was a good pick?
15
u/t_rex_reflex Apr 29 '23
Bro did you read what he just said?
-4
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
No one from PFF to ESPN to CBS to a plethora of blogs or any outlet or any analyst had this guy as a second rounder except, as far as we know, Ron. Eagles and Giants snickering rn taking the OL we passed up.
Cool special teams safety tho
12
u/HughJaynis My Wife Left me for Josh Harris Apr 29 '23
“THE BLOGS TOLD ME THIS GUYS A 4TH ROUNDER DURRRRRRR”- PickledEggs420
-2
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Detail for me how you got a never heard of safety as a second rounder, please.
5
u/HughJaynis My Wife Left me for Josh Harris Apr 29 '23
I didn’t, Ron did and he’s not a 4th rounder he’s a second rounder. These are indisputable facts.
-1
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Ron got him as a second rounder.
6
u/HughJaynis My Wife Left me for Josh Harris Apr 29 '23
Exactly. He’s a second rounder, are you slow?
-1
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Yeah. I’m slow. I stop and think, is this no name at a non premium and non need position worth a second rounder. And then I slowly pore over that And the conclusion I come to is that there are so many apologists out there like you who are literally like IQ slow.
→ More replies (0)3
u/chicomagnifico giving away free ☕ Apr 29 '23
Bro…no one in an actual NFL position cares what a talking head has to say about NFL prospects. “Who the hell is Mel Kiper anyways?”
0
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Tell me why this pick is good
2
u/chicomagnifico giving away free ☕ Apr 29 '23
Because a professional coach, who has made a professional decision, with a professionally good history of drafting made it. You are just another armchair GM on Reddit. Good night sir.
-1
-6
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Yeah. Do you think it’s a good pick?
15
u/djhobbes Apr 29 '23
God damn man. Your feelings got HURT tonight.
-1
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
You misread that like Ron misreading a safety
12
u/t_rex_reflex Apr 29 '23
Who drafted Curl? Who drafted Forrest? Fuck out of here dude.
4
u/KingAjizal Fuck Dan Snyder Apr 29 '23
Right? Talk shit about Ron as game tactician and FA evaluator, but the dude drafts generally pretty well.
2
u/djhobbes Apr 29 '23
No.. I don’t think I did.
I don’t like Ron. I don’t trust Ron. But none of us know how any of these picks will turn out. Grading a pick on draft night is a fools errand.
3
Apr 29 '23
Personally I think stylistically he’s a great fit for us. He the top nickel in this draft and he will likely step in and play Bobby/3rd safety role right away. There’s been 5 O-lineman drafted in the 34 picks since we drafted all will likely play guard or center in the nfl fine skipping out on them if we think this guy is a day one starter/difference maker. I like the pick but I’m not a scout.
19
u/The_JDBrew I Got JD5 On It Apr 29 '23
Man, why do NFL teams waste so much money on scouting departments? Obviously they should just check this sub to get the real scoop. What a bunch of fools, paying someone when you could get real data right here for free.
-4
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
You know who does the obvious consensus and it totally fucking works? Howie Roseman
-5
u/PeregrineT Apr 29 '23
This is a very dumb argument when you look at the past results of our scouting department
5
u/The_JDBrew I Got JD5 On It Apr 29 '23
Eh. In recent drafts the results have been pretty decent. A lot of starters or quality rotational pieces in the middle and late rounds. Everyone keeps saying this is the most talented roster this team has had in many years, but then complains about a couple of draft misses. How do you think that quality roster was built? Not that long ago this team was bereft of talent had zero depth. They have finally moved into a place where they have roster decisions to make on some quality players. That’s happened through good draft picks. The entire secondary is late round picks that have worked out well, now an influx of talent there should push that into a really nice spot. D-line is all good right now, no need to mess with it this year. LB could use some depth, but they basically play nickel all the time so there’s only 2 LBers on the field and Davis has played well and so has Hudson. So depth there is all they need. After they addressed the OLine mostly through FA they were only going to draft OL early if a premium prospect fell that far and they didn’t. They are just drafting depth. Which is where you wanna be on day 3.
I actually think the scouting and drafting of this team has been one of the few things it’s done well in the past 3-4 years. Yeah the Davis pick is a little wonky, and damn do I wish they woulda drafted Herbert of over Young. But many of their picks fans of this team questioned and bemoaned have worked out quite well. Go back and look at the draft grades for some of these guys when they were drafted and think about how you view them as a player now. You’d probably be surprised to see a D rating on a few really good pieces.
Not perfect, but not bad.
1
u/PeregrineT Apr 29 '23
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/was/draft.htm
Id suggest its pretty poor, 8 years of struggles with the good year being 2019 because of Sweat and Terry. Look at 2018, 2020, 2021, and 2022 is the unknown as always.
1
u/The_JDBrew I Got JD5 On It Apr 29 '23 edited Apr 29 '23
Your chart highlights my point. I said past 3-4 years. 19-22 were all pretty successful drafts. Since 2019 they’ve drafted 15 quality starters. Now they haven’t retained all of them, but most. That’s actually a pretty good return rate. Examine other teams’ drafts over the past 4 years and pay attention to the number of player they drafted who are currently starters in the league. Netting an average of 4 league average or better starters each year in the draft indicates pretty successful scouting and evaluation.
2019: Sweat McLaurin Martin Holcomb
2020: Young Gibson Young Hudson Curl Charles
2021: Davis Cosmi StJuste Forrest
2022: Dotson Mathis Robinson Jr (We’ll see what Howell is)
These are all quality starters or high-end rotational players. These guys represent basically the core of this team which with improved line play and a nfl worthy qb will be a competitive team.
1
u/PeregrineT Apr 29 '23
You have some very rose colored glasses on those players. You literally just named players regardless of whether they have done anything or even played(Mathis). Some of those guys were part of the dreadful Oline play last year, but to you they are good.
1
u/The_JDBrew I Got JD5 On It Apr 29 '23
Jury is still out on Mathis. Hasn’t really had an opportunity to get into the mix. The OL don’t really have a stat that can be referenced, but Cosmi will likely earn a significant role going forward which speaks somewhat to his evaluation. To the eye test, he was not the issue with that line.
My point being, pick a few teams that you feel draft very successfully and examine their draft classes over the same 4 year stretch and see how many quality starters or key rotational pieces they have netted. Top picks are not an indication of a teams scouting. It’s the middle rounds, the meat and potatoes of a draft, that show the quality of the scouting department. A team isn’t build on 1st round picks, it’s build with it’s depth. Day 2 and early Day 3 of a draft are where teams get the guys like Forrest, Curl, St. Juste, BRob, and obviously the future hall of famer (LOL) Sam Howell.
All that being said, I was little surprised to see them take Forbes over Gonzo on Thursday. Hoping it works out like the Dotson pick last year. Which was a stellar trade back. Getting them this years probably starting RB and QB while still bringing in one of the best WR in the draft class.
I understand where your viewpoint comes from, I just look at their mid round picks and are pretty solid pieces being added there and can’t help but think some of the negative feelings people express about their drafts are a bit unwarranted.
16
5
2
u/justinthepink22 Apr 29 '23
Legit been weak on the coverage side and haven’t seen us draft a 1st or 2nd round DB in years. Granted some of our guys did show up it’s one of our weaknesses. If they can play well and give the D Line more time to pressure it’s only going to cause that many more sacks, fumbles, and interceptions. It’s too bad the teams that are winning Super Bowls are offensive teams not defensive, we promote Eric to HC after Harris cleans up and become a more offensive minded team.
We are on the right track, Dan is gone, life is good, football is back on the menu in… Landover, Maryland.
1
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
I commend you on a thoughtful answer but it’s a fourth or fifth safety with a second round pick on a team that needs starters.
2
u/MartianExile1 Apr 29 '23
I swear, we are going to have the exact same season. A Super Bowl calibre defence that has to 1v3 the opposing team and our offense. At least this year we won’t have a bunch of cans on our schedule to dilute ourselves into thinking this roster building strategy can work. Last year the preseason SOS was near the bottom and this year is near the top.
1
u/-Lights0ut- Apr 29 '23
OL and Secondary are the highest needs imo. I don't care if we are reaching on those positions.
1
1
-4
u/icepak39 Apr 29 '23
Exactly. He was overdrafted.
-5
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Overdrafting a safety has become an annual tradition here.
5
Apr 29 '23
Lol who? Forrest is a 5th round pick and Kurl is a 7th rounder. Washington hasn’t taken a safety above the 4th round since Laron Landry
-2
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Percy Butler, who is apparently so uninspiring that we need a second round safety. Troy Apke and Sua Cravens if you want to dig into the vault. Forrest too. Turned out ok but coulda had him two rounds later.
Just because a minority of them turn out ok doesn’t mean they weren’t overdrafted
3
-6
0
u/Frognaros Apr 29 '23
soon we will have a new coach from our new owner and the fanbase will realize how bad the Ron years have been.
-7
u/DCSports101 Apr 29 '23
Sua cravens energy
1
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
You’re getting downvoted but not sure why. Overdrafting combine safeties is an annoying tradition.
-3
Apr 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
THANK YOU!
2
u/PickledEggs420 Apr 29 '23
Eagles don’t think twice about taking two top ten guys every first round.
1
u/Januse88 🐷Tuddyhead🐷 Apr 29 '23
I think if Nolan Smith was a top 10 talent he probably wouldn't have dropped to pick 30, but what do I and ~20 NFL scouting departments know? Less than Mel Kiper probably

17
u/salamanderman10 Apr 29 '23
Def not 2 rounds early and still a starter at a position of need.