r/CommandCode • • 5d ago

Command Code GOAT or OpenCode Go?

Which one is better if you only use Deepseek V4.1 Flash and GLM 5.3 Flash? Are there any cheaper or better value subscriptions than Command Code GOAT and OpenCode Go?

25 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

13

u/HeadLeadership8763 5d ago

They say Mistral sub gives more than both combined for less money than both combined

4

u/Embarrassed-Salt6590 5d ago

yeah but cost 3/2 the cost of one of the subs

2

u/Chemical_Hawk_6307 5d ago

they're doing a promo for students at 6.65 a month

3

u/Embarrassed-Salt6590 5d ago

the promo one only give u 130 usd worth of usage via the vibe api
the full priced one give u almost double that

3

u/Prize_Tiger_2504 5d ago

Still if you are a student, it is even more value than OC or CC.

Investigate the cache hit rates before deciding though. If the rate is less than 90% it might still end up costing more if OC/CC have >97% cache hit rates

1

u/mbpDeveloper 5d ago

Does mistral has claude api support too ? Can i use claude cli without proxy ?

1

u/Embarrassed-Salt6590 4d ago

Vibe api is openai compatible u can put it in any harness u want lowkie and use it Note claude cli isn't the best target for the models the api offers check other harnesses like opencode hermes pi ect

1

u/Prize_Tiger_2504 4d ago

You need not use Mistral's vibe CLI, although it seems to be improved a lot.

2

u/hj-core 5d ago

Does Mistral always charge peak price of DS 4.1 Flash? The doc shows a Input 0.3/M, Cache 0.007/M and Output 1.2/M.

https://docs.mistral.ai/inference/model-selection-guide?models=deepseek-v4-flash-1017,zai-glm-5-3-flash,zai-glm-5-3

1

u/hj-core 4d ago

I think I will give it a try after my command code goat ended. Even with Always-Peak DS v4.1 Flash, it still looks attractive if it brings $300 to a $15 subscription, and OpenRouter shows it has a pretty good TPS.

1

u/openference 2d ago

Mistral cache hit sis 75% which means its worth $50 not $300 of usage

8

u/bigheartenergy17 5d ago

Despite bad commentary on CommandCode, it just has more stable performance for DeepSeek than OpenCode in my experience. I have issues with OpenCode performance from time to time that can be frustrating. Other than the API key suddenly disappearing issue recently, I haven't had any issues with CommandCode and performance is much more consistent.

6

u/ahmadawaiscom 5d ago

Glad to hear. We'll keep making it more and more stable. :)

1

u/MichBeckMC 4d ago

I'm currently also using glm 5.3 Flash, deepseek v4 Flash, Gemini 3.8 Flash, minimax m3.1 Flash, and Jev via Commandcode.ai. Absolutely no problems. The only thing is that the usage history could go back a bit further, but other than that...

I use it via my Hermes Harness.

1

u/ultrabuckner 3d ago

How do you set via Hermes ? Teach me

4

u/wherestron 5d ago

Both. One on the 15th. One on the 30th. DS 4.1F. This is the way.

1

u/Flashy-University-27 5d ago

I am round robin my DSF delegates between OpenCode Plus, CommandCode GOAT, Mistral Pro, and DSF direct, with delegation rebalancing based on usage across each at the point of any lead spawning a new delegate

Fable 5.2 and Opus 5.5 on architecture in slightly different ways, Opus 5.5 merges the result of that via a decision tree presented, passes it off to an Opus 5.5 lead who delegates narrow scoped spec to to DSF while managing and passing back to the lead above him. Astra, Sol, Carbon, Argon available to leads for reviews. Kimi K3.1 Pro for design draft work, Opus 5.5 for draft polish.

Meta concept design and entirely external repo review is handled by Grok Bot, and any manual work that is worth throwing into a Gemini chat since antigravity pools are separate is done by me to access "free" Carbon/Argon usage.

1

u/openference 5d ago

You're ruining your cache hits meaning you're usage is costing more you shouldn't balance. Finish 1 first

1

u/Flashy-University-27 5d ago edited 5d ago

Nope, each delegate finishes their scope and closes the session or is reutilised by the lead, it depends. Cache hit isn't effected. When I had sessions running forever and doing it the other way, that was ruining my cache hit and bloating context.

The delegate does not control the balance / round robin, delegation is a script for each model, provider, and effort variant. Only leads have access to launch these scripts. For example DSF on CommandCode wraps the cmdc CLI, DSF on OpenCode wraps the OpenCode CLI, and so on. Then I have an orchestration layer above that handling terminals across nodes, Atuin history built in, chezmoi syncing between harnesses, a meta harness managing it all, etc. Right now I am unifying all of these pieces to be in-house under one singular piece of software that will ultimately have its own harness built into it - but the system works incredibly well as it is now.

1

u/Pirateshack486 5d ago

One you ruining cache, have each session stay with a provider.

2 command ode will deny tasks opencode says yes to. It's much better for liability and making sure you aren't doing anything illegal, but having your chat flip-flop between yes and no as it hops providers must make for some Interesting errors

1

u/Flashy-University-27 4d ago

No I am not check my other comment. I never experience the problem you're having unless it is RE related and even then, not really.

3

u/inefficientnose 5d ago

I honestly rarely hit my commandcode limit, and I always hit the opencode limit.

2

u/Pirateshack486 5d ago

Opencode is more relaxed about things like pingscans etc, commandcode seems to have an extra layer saying this stuff may be malicious. Also check deeprelay

2

u/MarcusAurelius68 4d ago

DeepRelay is only cheaper if your cache hits are under 85%.

1

u/Pirateshack486 4d ago

Now that's useful :) all these sites are offering various deals and structuring them oddly so it's a nightmare to compare... my cache hits above 90% for agentic, so that does work for me to know

3

u/MiraiHatada 5d ago

Using both, and tbf one month ago I couldn't tell because they work literally the same. and now oc run into the performance and stability problem that halven the speed (like around 90t/s with high chance) while commandcode keeps the same performance (150+ for most) as it was before

result in cc's definitive win, but i dont want the 'people' to realize this becauce it feels like mass flooding in may cause the same problem

2

u/Acceptable_Switch_76 5d ago

CC does not have the free users to deal with, OC should go the same route

1

u/_mannen_ 5d ago

Have you seen any errors in billing like double charge for caching etc? 

1

u/rizaldywirawan 1d ago

with CC, do you use the CMD_ZDR=1 env? there's a chance the speed will slowdown too while you activate ZDR mode

1

u/ExpertPerformer 5d ago edited 5d ago

I'm using both side-by-side for DeepSeek V4.1 only and OpenCode runs noticeably slower then CommandCode at many hours of the day. CommandCode is always consistent. I don't see any major difference between the two.

My usage so far is 78% on CommandCode for 6.3Bil Tokens and OpenCode is 42% at 3.4 Bil. They're virtually identical on overall usage for cost.

1

u/Pirateshack486 5d ago

Tell each of them to download a YouTube video, especially with ytdlp, I have my system download the video, pull key frames and use to summarize the video along with subtitles. Commandcode is very very against it.

1

u/doc_haz 4d ago

I've been using both CommandCode GOAT and OpenCode Go pretty heavily, mostly with DeepSeek V4.1 Flash.

Honestly, I prefer CommandCode, and it's not really close in terms of my experience so far. It feels noticeably faster and more efficient, especially when working on large coding projects.

I'm currently working on native PC recompilation projects, so these agents get pushed pretty hard lol.

I've used around 382M tokens on CommandCode and 1.2B on OpenCode. Monthly usage is sitting at just 6% and 7% respectively, which is honestly crazy for $10 each.

Both are great value, but my CommandCode agent has become one of my favorites. It just seems to get things done faster and with less friction.

If I had to keep only one, I'd definitely choose CommandCode GOAT.

1

u/Early_Divide3328 4d ago

I prefer Command Code GOAT because OpenCode Go limits how much you can use any single model per month. So if your plan is to use only Deep Seek 4.1 Flash you can do that and get >$60/month usage for $10. If you tried doing that with Open Code Go - you would probably only get around $20 to $30 of usage before you have to use GLM 5.3 Flash or Mini Max Flash to finish the month.

1

u/ineedallyourinfo 3d ago

i am using both 10$ plan. I use CC for 15 days and next 15 days opencode.

1

u/more_air8756 3d ago

As a light user, I prefer command goat open code to modify user policies.

1

u/Ecstatic-Diet-1375 5d ago

Commandcode gives you more models variety

1

u/martinderm 5d ago

Both of course 🤣

1

u/rizaldywirawan 1d ago

do you have any reason not to use big labs subscription such as OpenAI or Claude for $20?

2

u/martinderm 1d ago

No, but their small models are inferior to deepseek. I have a Claude 20 dollar sub for sonnet and frontier escalation. Workhorses are opencode go and commandcode goat.

1

u/rizaldywirawan 1d ago

May i know how much tps do you get with deepseek on opencode go?

1

u/martinderm 1d ago

I have no idea it works in background. If tps is if concern to you deepseek api is also great value and definetly faster.

1

u/rizaldywirawan 1d ago

To be honest, i tried the API directly. The tps is above 100+, but commandcode also do the samething i so thought i will stick with it. I haven't tried with opencode go, usually the tps will show at the end of the response

1

u/martinderm 1d ago

I use both, they feel pretty exchangeable

1

u/thomas29needles 5d ago

The OpenCode UI is three orders of magnitude better than Command Code. On my laptop OC starts within a second, Command Code takes ages to initialize. Also, I have a feeling that models running through Command Code are slower than through OpenCode. I performed a few tests in which I ordered a new model in a fresh session to do a deep repo analysis (a repo I know well) and the time to complete the task was always longer in Command Code.

0

u/pasteldebytes 5d ago

Try the plan finder or plan comparison tools at https://deepfrugal.com/tools