Hello fellow coop gamers! I'm a big fan of couch coop gaming and I've played a lot of titles over the years, mostly with my spouse. I thought I would give a short summary and our thoughts on the various games we played. I hope people with similar interests will find it useful.
UPDATE: 3 years later, I made a followup post with another 20+ games, check it out if you want more recommendations.
A few notes before I get to the games. We are both in our 30s with day jobs and responsibilities. That means we use gaming to relax after work, 30 minutes to an hour a day, maybe 4 times a week. This means that we tend to enjoy games that work well for this.
The game has to be easy to pick up with simple, intuitive controls and mechanics. It helps if it's easy to start, has convenient stop point where we can put it down and feel like we actually progressed. Since we are looking relaxation after work, we don't really have the time or the willpower to "git gud", games above a certain difficulty threshold are off putting to us. We have little to no interest in story, espacially since my spouse does not speak much English. Our setup is a PC connected to a 4kTV, and we mostly play with wireless controllers. Since we are sitting quite far from the screen, any game with small icons, a lot of text or intricate menus is out.
With that in mind, here's a list of the games we played, in order of how much we enjoyed playing it. Also, English is not my first language so I apologise for any mistakes or flat writing. Any game recommendations are also welcome!
Our favorites
Overcooked! 1 and 2
The best couch coop game in the known universe. You are chefs in an overhead 3D kitchen, tasked with preparing meals and ensuring the kitchen runs smoothly. The coop elements are prefectly implemented, you really need to work together to get high scores. Sometimes we have a discussion while the level is loading to decide who will be in charge of what. There are a ton of levels, they are varied with various hazards, meal types and challenges. There are also a bunch of expansions to it, so you can really play this for a long time if you want. The difficulty is whatever you want it to be with the scoring system. Easy to get into, easy to learn controls, tons of fun. There is really nothing bad I could say about it, go and get it now!
Lovers in a dangerous spacetime
One of the first games we played together and remains one of our all time favorites. You have to guide a spaceship through a cute 2D enviroment with a colorful neon art style. This one is our gold standard for a coop game. The ship has different systems (guns, shield, engines, etc) which you have to manage together in order to survive. Variable difficulty, great level design and gameplay and the feeling of working together are all in this one. I can't recommend this enough, in fact, if you don't have this one in your collection, stop reading and get it right now!
Trine 1,2,3,4
2D game with a fantasy theme. Our favorite puzzle platformer series. You have 3 characters who have different abilities each, and you can switch between them at will. The best part is the level design. The obstacles are made in a way that you can solve them with any character if you are smart about it. A lot of times we could progress with our makeshift solution, but I was pretty sure what we did was not the intended solution. It has basic fighting stages to break up the puzzles a bit. You also unlock new abilities as you progress. The 4th installment came out recently, If you only get one, get this one, but all of them are good games. Maybe the you can skip the 3rd one, they tried to make it 3D-ish, and apparently it was so expensive and difficult to make that they had to cut a lot of content. It's still a decent game though.
Broforce
YES! This is one of our recent favorites. It's a side scrolling 2D shooter with an 8-bit(ish) art style and retro action heroes theme. Played it from start to finish Many characters to play with different weapons, over the top fights and just all around craziness in this one. It really works for us because it's fast paced, easy to play and it's just difficult enough to keep it interesting. Coop vise, this could be a single player game and would play the same, although you have to help each other get back in the game if one of you gets killed. Since it has destructible environment and friendly fire, it is an endless source of fun to get killed by each other “accidentally” I recommend Broforce if you like retro 2D shooting games, action and the expendables movies. On the minus side, the screen is colorful but really cluttered, and the characters are small, so if you like your games to have clear visuals, maybe you won't like it as much.
No heroes here
This one is surprisingly good. A coop tower defense style game with 2D eight bit graphics and the mechanics of overcooked. You are defending a castle, and are in charge of shooting cannons as well as making gunpowder and preparing traps and cannonballs. The difficulty is just right, with optional levels for added challenge. The gameplay has enough variety to stay fresh through the game. I highly recommend it if you like tower defense and overcooked.
2) We liked these a lot
Shift Happens
2D puzzle platformer with a size-change gimmick. This one is surprisingly good, you control 2 bubbly guys who can change sizes in order to do various things. The coop elements are heavily factored in, you are throwing and pulling each other all the time. The puzzles are well made and fun to solve. Sometimes it can get a little too difficult, but you also get better as you progress. This is the only game on the list that we replayed from start to finish to get all bonus points and objectives. I recommend it to fans of puzzle platformers.
Nine Parchments
Colorful wizard-shooter action game with an overhead isometric view. Looks very nice, have easy to use controls and fun gameplay. You go to the next area, monsters pop up, you kill them, easy. The coop elements are strong, you can combine your spells, and use spells to support and supplement each other. There is also friendly fire which is always fun. There's not much variety, but the gameplay loop is solid, and it has new enemies and environments to mix it up a little. One warning though, this is a pretty hard game, especially when you haven't got used to it yet. There is a point in one of the early levels where a lot of fire-bulls are coming at you at the same time, we almost gave up on the game at that point. Other than this caveat, I wholeheartedly recommend it.
Rayman Origins
Very nice 2D platformer. The colorful cartoonish artstyle goes well with the fast-paced gameplay, the controls are very nice as well. It's not too difficult, at least at first, so when you get to the challenging levels you are already invested in it. As a coop game, you are basically just progressing together, there is no real way to help each other except for killing enemies and reviving fallen players, but the gameplay is so good that we didn't really had a problem with that. I recommend it if you like fast-paced platformers.
Unravel 2
Beautiful 2D puzzle platformer. You control two “thread-dolls” (I'm sure there's a better word for them but English is not my first language so I can't think of any) who are connected by a thread. You have to use your threads and each other to navigate through the environment. It's really fun, challenging and endearing. One thing though, it's an EA game and it's not on steam.
3) These ones are good but have some flaws
Badland
You control two flying black balls trying to evade obstacles and maneuvering the terrain. Has a lightly physics based gameplay. This one was pretty fun, it's one of those easy to start, hard to master kind of games. It can be really frustrating sometimes so it might not be for the casual gamers, but it's really fast paced so it was not a big problem for us. Even though you might retry a segment 30 times, it still only takes like 5 minutes to do so. The gameplay is really basic, but it has enough variety to keep it interesting. As for coop elements, you have to watch out not to get in each other's way, and also a lot of times one of you gets killed and it's up to the other to get to a point where the other gets “revived”. We didn't finish it because it started freezing at a certain point, which turned out to be a graphics card related problem. I really recommend Badland if you don't mind a little difficulty and reflex-based gameplay with phisics.
Ibb and obb
2D puzzle platformer with a gravity-reverse gimmick with simple but charming visuals. The coop aspect is really strong, you literally cannot proceed if you are not helping each other. It was really fun and atmospheric. It can get a bit difficult and tiresome sometimes, but we still managed to get to the end. I recommend this one if you like puzzle platformers.
Unruly heroes
2D beat-em-up with colorful animal characters based on a Chinese story. The levels and the enemies are fun, the boss fights are challenging and the beat-em-up gameplay feels good. The 4 heroes each have some special abilities that are kind of mandatory to proceed at some point in the game, other than that they play pretty similar. I have to mention the unlockable skins, which is a nice addition. We had fun playing it until the fire level, where suddenly the game became a lot more difficult and we lacked the resolve to power through it. It's a great beat-em-up for those who are up for the challenge.
Putty Pals
Puzzle platformer with a cute art style. You have to work together to overcome obstacles by using some special abilities. There are also some areas where only one of you can go. Pretty short and simple game, nothing to write home about, but it's nice and relaxing.
Portal 2
THE puzzle FPS. You use a portal gun to connect various points on the level and navigate the environment. This one is really fun, the puzzles are inventive and it feels rewarding when you figure something out. The reason we stopped playing halfway through is that my SO becomes easily disoriented by the FPS perspective and the rapidly changing angles and environments. Ifyou don't have this problem though, definitely give it a go!
4) The ones we didn't like so much
Chariot
Physics based 2D game where you have to navigate a chariot through the environment. The graphics are nice and the gameplay is solid. There's not much action, it's more of a puzzle game of sorts. It feels like a real coop game, but at the same time, I feel like there's always one player doing things while the other is just sorta “hanging in there” (sometimes literally). It's not a bad game, but we don't really play it all that much. The reason being that it's kinda difficult, it feels like you are working your way through the levels, and for some reason we always feel very tired after playing a few levels. Check it out if you like physics based puzzle games.
Battleblock theater
2D platformer with short levels and cartoon style. Pretty simple game, picked up because the art style looked fun. Played around 20 levels of it so far. It's not bad, we play it from time to time, but for some reason we never feel the urge to play this one, I don't really know why, we just find it not very engaging. The co op elements are not very deep but they are there, sometimes you'll have to throw the other player to reach platforms, that sort of thing. I don't really recommend it, but pick it up if it's on sale and you are looking for a simple co-op platformer.
Monaco
An overhead stealth game with stylized 8-bit artstyle. You are controlling robbers on a heist, each with different abilities. You have to accomplish your objectives by evading guards, hiding, opening doors, etc. It has a really great coop feel to it, you really have to work together to accomplish your objectives. Why we didn't like it was that the characters and the environment is incredibly tiny and it's hard to see what's going on. This is a problem when sometimes you have to react on the spot to something or make a decision where to run or hide. Check out the trailer and decide if it's something you would be bothered by.
Lego Star Wars: The Force Awakens
We've heard a lot of good things about the lego games and decided to give this one a go. It's a 3D 3rd person shooter/adventure/puzzle game. We played a couple of levels but ultimately we didn't really like the gameplay. The puzzles seemed arbitrary and hard to figure out what to do, the action gameplay wasn't all that fun, and ultimately there are too many cutscenes interrupting the gameplay. I'm sure it's fun to some but we just didn't find it all that enjoyable.
Castle crashers
Aaaand this is why I'm probably gonna get a bunch of downvotes. I know it's really popular and it's almost every “best coop games ever” lists, but we just didn't like it. It's a 2D beat em up with cartoon art style and a medieval knights theme. We played until the river level, and didn't find it all that engaging. The main problem was that is was quite difficult, and the fights weren't all that satisfying to play over and over, so we just sort of gave up. There wasn't any feel of “working together” either, we just kinda fought alongside each other. Since it's really popular, I'm sure it's a good game, it just didn't work for us so I wouldn't recommend it. Check it out if you like beat em ups, it might do the trick for you.
Red Rope: Don't fall behind
Your two characters are connected by a rope and have to use it to trap and kill shadow monsters before they touch you. Overhead view with a dark 8-bit art style. We didn't really like this one. One reason is that it's kind of gloomy and dark which we didn't find appealing. The game also has no tutorial whatsoever, you are just dropped into a word and can wander around without any directions or explanation. It's also pretty difficult from the get go.
Human fall flat
3D physics puzzle game where you navigate through the environment by using some really hard to use controls. We stopped playing after 2 levels, it felt really difficult and we weren't having much fun. And since we were not very good at the controls, we never knew if what we wanted to do was not possible or we just didn't try hard enough. Check it out if you like physics based puzzle games and the “arm-simulator” experience.
Magika
Got this because it looked similar to 9 parchments, which we enjoyed greatly. It is a similar game, sort of a predecessor made by the same company iirc, but it just felt really, really old, both in graphics, controls and game design, so we didn't really play it beyond the first level.
5) Honorary mentions
These games do not fit the criteria for one reason or another but we enjoy playing them so I just wanted to give them some attention
Unrailed!
The reason it's not on the list is that we haven't played it yet. It looks super exciting and it might just be the next overcooked!, but I don't want to play it while it's still in early access. I wanted to give it some attention nevertheless, chances are we are gonna enjoy it.
Nidhogg 2
A fighting game with simple controls and a fun reviving mechanic, sort of like a tug of war with fighting game mechanics. It has a really nice 16-bit art style, it's light enough not to take seriously, and even when you lose, it's fun. We played it for a while, and while it was fun, it got boring with repetitive plays. It can also be a problem if you are evenly matched and the fighting goes on forever. But it's a good, fun game for a couple of hours, and we still play it from time to time.
Stick Fight
Another fast-paced 2D fighting game. Just like Nidhogg, it's a 1 on 1 fight between stick figures. The selling point of this one is the pace (matches can be over in seconds, in 15 minutes you can face off a 50 times) and the variety of weapons. Since matches are so quick, winning and losing doesn't really matter. Highly recommended if you don't mind playing against each other.
Dead Cells and The Binding of Isaac
Single player rogue-like games. The reason I want to mention them because we both have hundreds of hours sunk in these two games, and they are really enjoyable to watch the other person play through. So while they are not coop games (Isaac has coop mode but it's not very good, I heard it's getting a proper one in the new DLC due this year though), they kinda supply a sort of “gaming together on the couch” experience.
That's all, thank you for reading!