r/Clojure • • Apr 13 '21

Extremely disappointed

Casually browsing the sub today, and ran across a link to the Clojurists Together Board Nominations.

My day was going on calmly and as usual, until I clicked that.

There, I found this extremely problematic paragraph:

The Board shall nominate no more than 12 candidates seeking board membership in any given election. In nominating candidates for Director positions and in choosing the number of candidates to nominate overall, the Board shall use reasonable efforts to maintain a Board composition consisting of at least: (1) 25% female Directors, (2) 25% non-Caucasian Directors, and (3) 35% from any category(ies) of persons (e.g., race, gender, ability) commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time and then-currently under-represented in the technology industry, in each case as determined by the Board in its reasonable discretion.

I am extremely confused, and disappointed, that such arbitrary criteria such as sex and race are apparently being used as filters like this. Those are the very definition of racism and sexism, are they not?

Another way of reading all of the above is: "only 15% of the board can be white men". How is that not extreme discrimination against white men?

Why? Because historically most open-source software was written by white men?

Ok, first of all, how about some gratitude then? Because clearly all this software improves all of our lives, no matter your sex or color or whatever arbitrary attribute you want to single-mindlessly focus on.

And second, what do the competent people that happen to be white and happen to be men (both attributes they had no choice in, by the way) have to do with it? Is it fair, really, to cast them aside?

What if they were the most competent candidates?

What does that inevitably do over time?

And finally, how can anyone - both the privileged person who gets a seat because of their color and/or genitalia, as well as anyone from the outside making a judgement/call - now be sure that person X is there because they are really the most competent for the job, or because the room needed to be filled by some people of a certain sex and/or a certain color and/or more random attributes that are surely to come? (not sure if anyone brought it to their attention, but midgets are very under-represented in technology! and their absence in CT's board clearly must mean rampant discrimination according to their interpretation of the facts, no?)

"commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time" - this is basically *everyone* at some time or another in history.

"currently under-represented in the technology industry" -- so we have moved from equality of opportunity to equality of outcome, have we? What evidence is there that unless a distribution based on arbitrary attributes is proportional, that this automatically means discrimination?

What a narrow way of seeing things. Do I care that Rich is white, blue, red, pink or whatever? No, I care that he writes quality software, and evidently he does.

Do you care if the commercial pilot flying you home is of whatever color, do you care about the sexual orientation, or do you care that this person is the most competent person for the job, which incidentally in this case also means you stand the best chances at making it home alive?

Ditto for the surgeon. And countless other things.

This is a very troublesome direction, far-left ideology metastasizing inside tech communities. And I am incredulous that no one is calling it out.

This is not the way.

0 Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

101

u/dantiberian Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Hi u/darth_zidious

I'm the secretary for Clojurists Together. I can explain a bit more about this policy, you've misinterpreted how it impacts the board structure.

Some background: There are 7 seats with a staggered board. This year there are 4 board seats up for election and next year there are 3 board seats available. There are 12 candidates for our members to vote for (ranked choice preference voting).

Another way of reading all of the above is: "only 15% of the board can be white men".

Firstly, this policy is used for selecting the 12 people able to stand for board nominations. There are no requirements on the structure of the board. The makeup of the board will be determined by our members voting.

Secondly, the 25% + 25% + 35% guidelines for selecting board members is not cumulative.

Note that the board is currently >50% white men.

And finally, how can anyone [...] now be sure that person X is there because they are really the most competent for the job, or because the room needed to be filled by some people of a certain sex and/or a certain color and/or more random attributes that are surely to come?

As noted above, this policy applies to board applicants. All board seats are elected by Clojurists Together members because our members thought that they were the best person for the job.

Lastly, why do we have this policy?

Clojurists Together wants to have a board made up of people which represent a wide range of perspectives from the Clojure community.

If our members wanted to change or discuss this policy further, they would be able to raise this at the next members meeting.

Note that you can also fund Clojure projects directly, Clojurists Together is not the only way to support the Clojure community.

22

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Clojurists Together wants to have a board made up of people which represent a wide range of perspectives from the Clojure community.

My only criticism is the assumption that race and gender are proxies for different perspectives. The most important diversity is of education, experience, areas of expertise, language, culture, etc.

5

u/nonrecursive Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

I am genuinely curious about your comment. Are you saying that people of different races and genders don't have different experiences from each other that are grounded in their race and gender? I am also curious about why you highlight education, experience, etc as most important for diversity?

13

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Are you saying that people of different races and genders don't have different experiences from each other that are grounded in their race and gender?

I think race and gender can affect experiences and perspectives, but you can gather a group of people with diverse racial and gender makeup who all have similar perspectives. A group made up entirely of professors from ivy league universities are probably going to have less diverse perspectives than a group made up of a mix of individuals ranging from professors to engineers to self-taught coders.

I am also curious about why you highlight education, experience, etc as most important for diversity?

If you want diversity of ideas, focusing only on race and gender is extremely limiting. I believe your educational background, experience (e.g. working in private sector, public (government), teaching, open source, etc), the languages you speak, the culture you were raised in, etc cannot be ignored when assembling a group of people with diverse perspectives.

If the goal is diverse perspectives, why focus only on race and gender?

4

u/nonrecursive Apr 13 '21

Thank you!

0

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

OP here - wholeheartedly agree with this comment.

14

u/lvh Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

I agree: you can't essentialize people to their gender or race. Firstly, there's a catchall for more generic underrepresented communities. More importantly: it turns out getting broad expertise, for example, mostly just happens -- and there is no systemic implicit bias against, say, "people who work in scientific computing", so course correction rules don't really come in to play.

I wholeheartedly cosign the idea that people should vote who they think is best, and I certainly think that many of the categories you describe are important. For example, I intend to vote for Chris Nuernberger because I think their work is fantastic, I think a Python bridge is very important for the Clojure community, particularly for ML/AI. Chris and I ostensibly have many things in common (white dudes in the US running consultancies and with experience bridging Clojure with FFI), but area of expertise is the deciding factor there.

24

u/Wolfy87 Apr 13 '21

Thank you for your work and this excellent explanation! :)

I definitely want as many different voices and backgrounds as possible deciding where my contributions go. So good to see!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ArtisticBack Apr 13 '21

The guideline singles out the minimum targets for women and minorities, but what is the minimum representation for Caucasian men?

35% from any category(ies) of persons (e.g., race, gender, ability) commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time and then-currently under-represented in the technology industry

Do Asians and Indians classify in this category?

13

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Good news: bylaws can be amended, and if there's ever any risk of Caucasian men becoming underrepresented that's relatively easy to fix. Fortunately: we are nowhere near at risk of being underrepresented.

6

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

Individuals are not proxies for their race or sex. Every person not on the board is "underrepresented" on it, regardless of their race or sex, and the inclusion of someone who happens to match their race or sex does not exactly help someone have their technical concerns heard by the board. Does the fact that I share a race and sex with Daniel Compton mean he's more likely to listen to my input on CT? Are the white male board members only listening to input from other white men?

8

u/lvh Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Great! The membership can still vote for whomever they want. If they feel gender and race are irrelevant, or that the people of underrepresented groups are worse candidates, they can vote for someone else.

> Every person not on the board is "underrepresented" on it

I am not going to get into a semantic debate of how representation works from first principles, come on, you understand what "representative democracy" means. People vote for who they want representing them based on whatever metric they want. Members have indicated race and gender are two they care about, so this makes sure they have a choice there. If you care about something else, great, vote for someone else.

You are gonna vote right? You're a member and all? I'd be happy to give you a refund if you're unhappy with the work we've been doing. Or are you just mad about how other people spend their time and money on things that benefit you?

1

u/Krackor Apr 14 '21

This kind of snide condescension and dismissal of the public's concerns does not reflect well on your organization.

6

u/lvh Apr 14 '21

I engaged with the core of your argument, you did not do the same. So now we’re down to tone, a standard you don’t uphold for yourself.

4

u/Krackor Apr 14 '21

You haven't addressed the criticism. You've just said "if you don't like our policies, you have to join our organization and vote for different policies before your criticism will be considered".

→ More replies (16)

0

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21 edited Apr 18 '21

Hello, sorry for the late reply - been offline for a few days.

I stand corrected regarding the percentages (it did seem quite extreme, even as such things tend to go)

As noted above, this policy applies to board applicants. All board seats are elected by Clojurists Together members because our members thought that they were the best person for the job.

I am not sure that I understood correctly: If the board applicants are subject to the rules detailed previously, and if board members had to start as board applicants (is this correct?), then it seems to me that there is a filter based on the arbitrary identifier of race ? And thus "because our members thought that they were the best person for the job" is really " because our members thought that they were the best person for the job AFTER filtering".

Clojurists Together wants to have a board made up of people which represent a wide range of perspectives from the Clojure community.

Understandable, what I find problematic is equating that with giving people who match certain unrelated characteristics an automatic advantage, while excluding others, for the same reasons -- and note that I can type that statement without referring to any one group based on criteria like race.

Ultimately though, it's your organization, and you won't hear from me any calls to "cancel" CT or whatever.

But I do think it's wrong to exclude or elevate people based on those attributes. Didn't we spend decades figuring that out? And now we're making exceptions, and we all should know where that leads.

If our members wanted to change or discuss this policy further, they would be able to raise this at the next members meeting.

They can, for now, but I suspect it won't be long before anyone who tries is called a racist, as I have been a few times in this thread (by the way, I'm not white -- which for some people, strangely enough, also means that I can't be racist .. which is complete nonsense, of course).

So why do I care so much if I'm not white? Because you can paint it in different colors, but the underlying thing is the same.

We had the right idea - pay no attention to race, focus on merit. It's sad to see this being slowly subverted now.

Note that you can also fund Clojure projects directly, Clojurists Together is not the only way to support the Clojure community.

Of course!

-7

u/moooooovit Apr 13 '21

i want board seat as well

7

u/frankiesardo Apr 14 '21

Can I just say that I am extremely proud of how the community is handling this debate. It's a difficult topic to discuss and as you expect it elicits a wide range of emotions.

Bar the occasional inflammatory comment, there are many, many thoughtful answers, and when incongruences are pointed out posters are happy to admit their mistakes and reformulate.

You can see people genuinely asking for clarification without attacking each other and expressing their views with a clarity you rarely see even in online newspapers or other forums. Bravo all.

0

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

I agree, and I am also extremely surprised that the post blew up like it did! I was gone for a few days and came home to this. Most of the discourse is civil, which is good.

35

u/j19sch Apr 13 '21

Hi u/darth_zidious, I'd recommend you dive deeper into the arguments behind the position you're opposing. I'm not saying you should agree with them, but your post doesn't show much awareness of those arguments. A possible place to start could be this podcast series: https://www.sceneonradio.org/seeing-white/

To illustrate with some examples:

  1. Racism and sexism are not only about individuals unrightfully bringing race or sex/gender into a decision. They are also about the way our societies are set up to make things harder when you're for example not a white male.

  2. Having quota can be a good way to have people make changes to how they find candidates. Stephen Colbert realized at one point that all his writers were Ivy League white dudes, because that's the kind of people the current writers have in their network. He had to actively broaden the way they looked for new writers to get more diversity.

  3. You say things should be based on competence and should ignore race, sex, etc. There's a point to be made that's not the case currently and that half-competent men get selected over actually competent women: https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/may/10/why-do-so-many-mediocre-men-rise-to-the-top

1

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

I heavily recommend understanding more about Postmodernism, where all those ideas you mentioned originate from.

This is not to say that there isn't some truth in them, but that is precisely the problem: they take that small kernel of truth and run wild indeed with it.

PM me if you're interested in some books about the subject!

4

u/alpheus Apr 13 '21

That first paragraph is a master-class in diplomacy.

4

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

Can you imagine anyone disagreeing with you for reasons other than ignorance or racist intent? Why do you presume that OP is merely ignorant?

4

u/j19sch Apr 13 '21

Yes, I can. I said to OP it's fine to disagree after diving deeper into the position they're opposing, so that covers the ignorance part. I can also imagine someone disagreeing for other reasons than ignorance or racist intent, for example that a quota puts a burden on people who have too little influence on the causes of inequality.

As to why I presume OP is ignorant: I gave three examples of where I think OP does not address the common arguments in this kind of discussion. Perhaps OP is not ignorant of those, but chose not to address them. In that case I'd welcome OP saying so.

2

u/Krackor Apr 14 '21

It poisons the well to start off your response with the presumption that OP is ignorant of the arguments you mention. Is this how you approach every disagreement you have? By telling them they're probably just ignorant of your position? The points you brought up are entry level arguments about diversity, and it's not hard to find substantial disagreements with those arguments. How about assuming the OP has an informed opinion and asking to understand why they would disagree with you, instead of immediately dismissing their opinion as ignorant?

4

u/j19sch Apr 14 '21

I agree I could have phrased my post better by bringing up only the lack of awareness in the post and avoid any reference to my perceived lack of awareness in OP.

2

u/Krackor Apr 14 '21

I appreciate that, thanks.

3

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

They did not presume. They responded based on evidence, and provided examples.

21

u/SimonGray Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

This is a very troublesome direction, far-left ideology metastasizing inside tech communities.

At this point, it is just typical US institutional policy - not far-left at all. America doesn't really have a proper left-wing, it just has liberalism (which is arguably centrist or even centre-right from a European PoV) and as of late this "successor ideology".

As for it "metastasizing" in tech communities, no not really. It is still fairly unique to the US, with some spillover in English-speaking countries like the UK and Canada.

Edit: Predictably, downvotes are flying left and right in this comment section. My advice to everyone is to try to understand the motivation of the other side rather than casting them as some kind of extremist. The funny thing about this issue is that both perspectives tend to frame the opponent as racist/sexist/and so on.

0

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

At this point, it is just typical US institutional policy - not far-left at all

I don't see why that matters (US institutional policy is a reflection/implementation of something, and that something is postmodernism, which is radical left rubbish), and indeed it does prove a concerning point.

As for it "metastasizing" in tech communities, no not really. It is still fairly unique to the US, with some spillover in English-speaking countries like the UK and Canada.

It's not just in tech, but it's been getting more virulent in tech lately.

21

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

At best, this is an ill-informed, poorly-argued, knee-jerk reaction to something that OP disagrees with. At worst, it's a shrill dog whistle. There have been several posts in this thread arguing that we should not read it as the latter, but the post is book-ended by inflammatory language, which makes that hard.

After fundamentally misunderstanding what the "extremely problematic paragraph" is about, as has been pointed out by u/dantiberian, OP immediately launches into a bald and bare-faced statement that sets the tone for the rest of the post:

Why? Because historically most open-source software was written by white men?

Ok, first of all, how about some gratitude then?

There is no need for this statement to support OP's argument, unless that argument is: "white men have done all of these good things for you, have some respect".

In the middle, we have this bit of snark:

(not sure if anyone brought it to their attention, but midgets are very under-represented in technology! and their absence in CT's board clearly must mean rampant discrimination according to their interpretation of the facts, no?)

This is clearly disingenuous, given that OP uses an outdated term considered offensive by many little people. Furthermore, the argument itself is fallacious, given that little people are likely included in the "35% from any category(ies) of persons...[who] have suffered from discrimination".

After a series of arguments indicating that OP is arguing based on feeling and conjecture, instead of research and data, OP concludes with:

This is a very troublesome direction, far-left ideology metastasizing inside tech communities. And I am incredulous that no one is calling it out.

Not only is the ideology in question not far-left (using affirmative action as a proxy), but this statement fails to mention, or possibly realize, that the entire post is arguing in support of a right-wing ideology. OP has the gall to criticize something for being political, while bringing politics into a space that rarely discusses it.

But sure, maybe this post isn't trying to rally support for a racist ideology, let's consider the argument then.

I am extremely confused, and disappointed, that such arbitrary criteria such as sex and race are apparently being used as filters like this. Those are the very definition of racism and sexism, are they not?

This is, in fact, not the definition of racism or sexism, as generally used in the colloquial sense, and especially not in the academic sense, where both terms are understood to be used in contrast to the dominant portions of society.

Moving on, and again taking OP's argument in good faith:

Another way of reading all of the above is: "only 15% of the board can be white men". How is that not extreme discrimination against white men?

OP's math is wrong here, given that "35% from any category(ies) of persons...[who] have suffered from discrimination" likely includes trans men, raising the percentage of white men allowed to 50%.

Moving on

And second, what do the competent people that happen to be white and happen to be men (both attributes they had no choice in, by the way) have to do with it? Is it fair, really, to cast them aside?

What if they were the most competent candidates?

Competence is not a single value, nor is it the right value to use for judging the candidacy for the given position. Something like "effectiveness" is probably better. If your goal is to develop an inclusive community where everyone feels safe to contribute, than being a non-white-male contributes significantly toward the effectiveness of that person.

OP argues that Clojurists Together has a narrow way of seeing things, but OP's point itself is narrow and misses the point entirely.

What a narrow way of seeing things. Do I care that Rich is white, blue, red, pink or whatever? No, I care that he writes quality software, and evidently he does.

Clojurists Together has the following goals, taken directly from their site

  • Support open source software, infrastructure, and documentation that the Clojure/ClojureScript community relies on.

  • Support other community initiatives like Google Summer of Code

Neither of these goals requires writing "quality software". When choosing projects to support, a diverse group of people is inherently going to bring more opinions to the table. This is a studied phenomenon. So, yes, board members with diverse backgrounds are likely to increase the efficacy of the board as a whole, which stands in contrast to the other jobs OP lists, which are all largely individualistic or limited in scope, making them poor analogies for the point OP is trying to make.

4

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21 edited Apr 18 '21

Yours is a long reply (thanks for putting in the effort!), with many points, but nevertheless, I will try to address your points.

At best, this is an ill-informed, poorly-argued, knee-jerk reaction to something that OP disagrees with.

Ill-informed it is not, I can assure you.

Poorly-argued, maybe, but then again it was not my intention to write a bulletproof argument fully backed by credible sources - that would probably be a book or at least a series of blog posts, not a reddit post.

Knee-jerk reaction, not so much, and this is related to not being ill-informed as well. There is a strong current of postmodernism underneath such policies, and if you cannot see it, or cannot see the harm that it will bring, then I doubt it will be one post of mine that'll change your mind - but I am happy to provide some books that go much further and in my opinion explain the issue(s) pretty well - send me a pm if you're interested.

There is no need for this statement to support OP's argument, unless that argument is: "white men have done all of these good things for you, have some respect".

There is no need in your opinion.

You have to read it in context, and before that sentence, I wrote: "Another way of reading all of the above is: "only 15% of the board can be white men". How is that not extreme discrimination against white men?" (which by the way is not exactly correct [the percentage] as dantiberian explained here)

And therefore, I didn't write it to demand that white men get some respect, but as a guess as to why such extreme discrimination (which again, is not as extreme, see link above) seemed to be fair game.

I hope you can better recognize my intention with writing that sentence in light of those facts.

In the middle, we have this bit of snark

It wasn't snarky. I think your perceptions are beginning to color things a bit too much. See below.

This is clearly disingenuous, given that OP uses an outdated term considered offensive by many little people.

Yeah, here's the thing. English is my 3rd language, and I don't live in an Anglo country. Midget is the term I know, and as far as I am concerned it's a funny word that means no disrespect.

If anything, little people sounds insulting, but whatever: there is the postmodern undercurrent once again, everything problematized, everything evidence of oppression, coupled with the victimhood culture angle, where oh my god, no one can ever be offended.

Needless to say then, what I wrote was meant as disingenuous, and once again, in light of the clarification, I hope that you can see that.

After a series of arguments indicating that OP is arguing based on feeling and conjecture, instead of research and data

Once again I make myself available to provide you with several books on the subject. There is, indeed, plenty of research and data there to examine.

This is, in fact, not the definition of racism or sexism, as generally used in the colloquial sense, and especially not in the academic sense, where both terms are understood to be used in contrast to the dominant portions of society.

No, that is the postmodernist definition of racism, redefined precisely so that they can be racist against white people, who as the majority (in the countries in question, anyway) are seen as automatically oppressive.

For everyone else, racism is being an ass to someone because of their race.

Not only is the ideology in question not far-left (using affirmative action as a proxy), but this statement fails to mention, or possibly realize, that the entire post is arguing in support of a right-wing ideology. OP has the gall to criticize something for being political, while bringing politics into a space that rarely discusses it.

Affirmative action is racist and sexist by definition, and is at irreconcilable odds with Liberalism. Only postmodern academics say that it isn't, because as exposed above, they reformulated the language precisely to avoid impaling themselves as racists and sexists.

Also, not only is there nothing in the post that's specifically right-wing, but also, who is really injecting politics into the community, when a prominent organization is injecting postmodernist thought (which itself is inherently political, and radically so, by the way) via their policies?

And then you go on to accuse the one who stands out to point it out as bringing politics to a space that rarely discusses it. Yeah.. disingenuous indeed.

If your goal is to develop an inclusive community where everyone feels safe to contribute, than being a non-white-male contributes significantly toward the effectiveness of that person.

Inclusive, more postmodern stuff. At this point I do have to wonder if you understand that's where it comes from?

Why wouldn't anyone not feel safe contributing? No one cares, at least until very recently, where under the guise of "fighting racism" everything is about race, ditto for sexism.

When choosing projects to support, a diverse group of people is inherently going to bring more opinions to the table.

Diverse based on what sort of arbitrary criteria? Yours? Because there is literally an infinite array of possibilities we could pick from, but - and again, the postmodern undercurrent, the everything being about power, the oppressor-vs-victim dynamics from Marxism - it seems to be all about race and sex these days.. which all but the academics and the trained ideologues correctly perceive as being racist and sexist, by the way.

OP argues that Clojurists Together has a narrow way of seeing things, but OP's point itself is narrow and misses the point entirely.

Needless to say, I profoundly disagree with your conclusion!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '21

For how long this follow-up is, I'm struggling to glean anything new from it. Other than using "postmodern" as a means of dismissing 70+ years of thinking on the subjects out-of-hand, not a single new idea is raised. The rest is a bunch of weasel words, insults, and gaslighting. I assure you that my interpretation of your language as inflammatory is correct.

Everything you say still sounds ill-informed. No one is required to believe you when you make a weak argument, but claim that actually you're very well versed on the subject.

Advice: check out the number of down votes you have, and consider that maybe that your views are from a previous century (you know, pre-postmodernism).

4

u/xlfe Apr 14 '21

You said it better than I could, thank you.

6

u/Logitropicity Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Ooh. That last paragraph is good. For Clojurists Together specifically, this makes lots of sense. I definitely didn't consider that in my own response elsewhere in the thread, and (at a glance) I don't think that's addressed anywhere else in this thread either, especially that study.

10

u/nonrecursive Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Thank you for clearly calling out that the OP uses dog whistles, and that his whole post is inflammatory and harmful. Thank you, too, for clearly pointing out the dishonesty of OP saying this is "far-left ideology" without also plainly stating that they are advocating for far-right ideology.

31

u/xlfe Apr 13 '21

I disagree. I'm a proud supporter of Clojurists Together including this policy.

18

u/darth_zidious Apr 13 '21

That is fine (to disagree), although I don't understand what pride could possibly have with it.

It would also be more interesting if you laid out your argument(s) in favor of their policy. I've outlined mine in the OP.

I realize that reddit doesn't lend itself very well to long and well-thought discussions because the threads quickly become cumbersome to read (at least that's my experience), but if you could at least support your position rather than saying "I disagree", it could be more interesting.

14

u/xela314159 Apr 13 '21

It’s complicated. While I think OP is overreacting, as a European I’m reasonably surprised at the very liberal political bias of the US IT community. Sometimes it’s morphing into cancel culture and it seems to me this is what worries OP. See the Uncle Bob saga - I think we can appreciate or not his coding books independently of his politics, and history doesn’t look kindly on groups that limit freedom of speech or burn books.

Thought experiment: let’s put a quota for other underrepresented groups with grievances - say, I don’t know, Trump voters? :)

7

u/servingwater Apr 13 '21

"Cancel Culture" has nothing to do with liberal or conservative, as both do it.
It has also existed for years and "Cancel Culture" is just the latest new term for it, but it seems it is mostly used to frame it as a liberal thing.
Yet conservatives "boycott" things and people they don't agree with all the time.

0

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

It's one thing to "boycott" and not give someone your hard-earned money, it's quite another to demand they become unemployable, lose their income streams, get deplatformed from everywhere, and generally live as impoverished (no income streams, remember) social pariahs.

The Cancel Culture phenomenon is very clearly tied to the Postmodernist Woke Left in America today, and it is inherently totalitarian. I think only a profound ignorance of the situation would allow for a different interpretation here specifically (no offense).

2

u/servingwater Apr 18 '21

That is Historical revisionism at its finest (no offense).
Who do you think wanted to "cancel" Rap/HipHop, Rock, Video Games, interracial marriage, practically any religion other than Christianity etc.
What do you call what was done to Kaepernick or the Dixie Chicks? What about when Ellen came out as gay? Beyonce when she came out with lemonade or formation? The list goes on and on. But going by how upset you are in your OP and not mentioning the "Woke left" as well as insinuation that whoever does not agree with your interpretation must be profoundly ignorant, I'm not surprised by your selectiveness. You see only want you want to see.....

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 19 '21

I assumed it would be obvious that I was writing about cancel culture nowdays.

I am sure you can find some instances of conservative-leaning people canceling people nowdays as well, but to me it seems self-evident that this particular problem lies more on the left in our time.

But anyway, this was not supposed to be a left vs right thing, and if you want to make it about that, then understand that if I have a problem with anything, it is with the extremes on either side - but for whatever reasons we don't seem too immunized against far left nonsense, while almost everyone recognizes far right nonsense.

1

u/servingwater Apr 19 '21

I don't want to make it about left or right. Which is why I pointed out this ill conceived notion that "cancel culture" is a left problem only or even predominantly left issue.

4

u/buried_treasure Apr 17 '21

other underrepresented groups with grievances - say, I don’t know, Trump voters?

I think you are misunderstanding the purpose of quotas. They're not intended to salve the feelings of people who have "grievances" (your words).

They are there to right the historic wrongs done to groups that were systematically refused the same opportunities as others, by state-level operators.

Trump voters may feel hard done by, but imagine if you were forced to declare your voting pattern on every job application form and then Trump voters were having that used to deny them jobs.

That's the difference.

17

u/slifin Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

The strange thing about this post - is that it implies we shouldn't care about race and gender etc of employees in various jobs, but the whole point of this post is that you care very much about the race and gender of the candidates of Clojurists together

When it comes to caring about non-whites or non-males it's a harsh libertarian meritocracy attitude, when it's about whites it's a socialist auto pass?

Either way, the goal isn't one or the other, the aim here is a balanced set of candidates so that the best projects can get funded where best is defined by a diverse set of people

Balance is incredibly important in all walks of life, if you populate your company with all people that know SQL and not much else how well are you going to be able to make a front end app? If you balance your diet by just eating chips how well is your health going to fare?

Clojurists together are just saying they have a lot of white males and need other prospectives so they're "hiring" for those extra prospectives

It would be really strange to publically denounce an organisation if they put out an advert looking for HR people, to say that they're racist against devs just because that particular advert wasn't for them

As a backer, I would say it's almost their obligation to do this, if there's an app created in China, India, Africa, or other places that may be outside the bubble of white males then I want Clojurists together to know about it and be considering it for funding too

I'd rather not mention what my favourite Clojure software is in the scope of this conversation but I know for a fact it wasn't coded by a white person and it's amazing, the world has a lot to offer and Clojurists together can't afford to be myopic

5

u/justaperson2342 Apr 13 '21

The strange thing about this post - is that it implies we shouldn't care about race and gender etc of employees in various jobs, but the whole point of this post is that you care very much about the race and gender of the candidates of Clojurists together

They are saying we shouldn't care about race and gender when deciding who to appoint. You shouldn't favor white people, and you shouldn't favor black people.

When it comes to caring about non-whites or non-males it's a harsh libertarian meritocracy attitude, when it's about whites it's a socialist auto pass?

No, it's not okay in both circumstances.

It would be really strange to publically denounce an organisation if they put out an advert looking for HR people, to say that they're racist against devs just because that particular advert wasn't for them

Are they planning on reverting this rule once they get enough non-white males?

I'd rather not mention what my favourite Clojure software is in the scope of this conversation but I know for a fact it wasn't coded by a white person and it's amazing, the world has a lot to offer and Clojurists together can't afford to be myopic

I also hugely admire someone in the Clojure community who is not a white male, and would be excited to have many more like them. You seem to think the alternative to this policy is one where only white people get to participate. Nobody is advocating for that.

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

They are saying we shouldn't care about race and gender when deciding who to appoint. You shouldn't favor white people, and you shouldn't favor black people.

Yes, correct (OP here).

Also, as stated elsewhere, I'm not even white - that seems to shock many people here (which again, is that racism against white people that they prefer to continue ignoring, but I digress).

6

u/Wolfy87 Apr 13 '21

Very well said! It's shocking to see people being upset about this concept and others (very few) agreeing with them in the comments. Especially when the language being used is terms like "leftist ideology". Such a weird phrase to me, but I don't live in the US where they seem to throw that sort of thing around as an insult.

I'm guessing people that oppose this also oppose initiatives like Clojure Bridge and CodeBar? I hope I'm mistaken, I thought we were past that kind of thinking in the Clojure community, I guess some people are still holding on.

0

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

You really should educate yourself on Postmodernism, which is what is driving initiatives like the one I criticized (I am the OP, by the way).

Very quickly you will come to understand that it is rooted in radical leftism.

It may be a weird phrase to you, but it does not mean that it is not accurate.

PM me if you're interested in some good books!

1

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

I'd rather not mention what my favourite Clojure software is in the scope of this conversation but I know for a fact it wasn't coded by a white person and it's amazing, the world has a lot to offer and Clojurists together can't afford to be myopic

I think you might have misunderstood my intentions and my concerns.

To expand only on this last paragraph of yours, I go one step further and almost never know the race or sex of whoever wrote whatever software. And when I do know, it's an accident from having checked someone's profile or whatever.

To me, that doesn't matter. At all.

1

u/slifin Apr 18 '21

I agree I do not understand your intentions and concerns I am having a hard time empathising with you when you publicly post that you are indifferent to the characteristics of people that make your software

There are many people I will never know, who often live far away that have helped make my computers, clothes, food and many other things I enjoy in my life, I am not proud that I do not know their genders, races or other aspects of them as human beings

I do not consider it "one step further" to do the same to software authors, unless that step is a step towards dehumanisation

1

u/darth_zidious Apr 19 '21 edited Apr 19 '21

It's not dehumanizing at all, I don't think.

Software is software, words are words, philosophies are philosophies, and so on and so forth .. I don't give more or less value to a work because of the color of the skin of the person who wrote it or their particular arrangement of sex chromosomes.

People get interested in what they get interested, and there will be differences in interest based on countless factors.

Now, for sure, sometimes the sex, geographical origin of the author might be relevant, I am not denying that. But that's specific cases for specific reasons, not a gigantic all-encompassing filter.

As far as I am concerned, the name of the game is theoretically enabling as many people as possible to be able to do the things they want to do, and this is what was understood by "equality" for a long time.

Now it's becoming "equity", where some benevolent figure from above who happens to know the precise configuration that society should assume (and more often than not tells you there is invisible and all-pervasive racism/sexism in society, that no one can see but they can, and that the dominant groups are all oppressive and therefore destroying them is only fair game) dictates that it should be so.

That's a very different, and in my opinion very dangerous, concept.

12

u/charkui Apr 13 '21

I read and understand the explanations, but for me its still: there's racism outside, so we're gonna be racist in a "good and inclusive way".

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

That is basically how I see it as well, and that is why I think it's wrong.

I can see the good intentions, but I don't think treating people in special ways because of their race is the right way to go about it.

0

u/childofsol Apr 14 '21

Racism != discrimination

Racism is the systemic, structural system of biases and norms which benefits one race over another. Policies like this are not racist, they are anti-racist in that they are an attempt to address the imbalances we face because of a long, and continued, history of racism.

7

u/joinr Apr 14 '21

Policies like this are not racist, they are anti-racist in that they are an attempt to address the imbalances we face because of a long, and continued, history of racism.

That's racism with extra steps and frosting on it, e.g. justification for "good" racism. You can't be anti-racist by judging somebody based on their race. Either you leave race out, or you don't. If you don't, you are perpetuating the racism instead of stopping it.

1

u/childofsol Apr 14 '21

Race is not, and has not, been left out of it.

Fighting against any kind of equity measures meant to address the current and historical imbalance amount to nothing more than the privileged class scrabbling to keep its grip on an advantaged position.

This is a widely accepted and extensively reasoned about view. Just because it offends the sensibilities of people first coming across it does not mean that this is "racism with extra steps"

5

u/joinr Apr 14 '21

Equal opportunity is acceptable. Precluding opportunity based on race is cafe kkk. This tact can be dressed in all sorts of finery, but the means used to pursue the ending of injustice is inherently unjust and self defeating as it perpetuates racism.

5

u/charkui Apr 14 '21

Thank you for your explanation. But are those norms somewhere i can read them where they explain that some race have benefits over another? In the same way that the policies of this post can be read, or is somekind of "hidden" discrimination? If those norms exists then how these "good race policies" are better than eliminate and fight against all those kinds of discrimination? I thought that not being racist its the opposite of the racism, but these policies are like "being racist in a good way to fight against the always ilegal race discrimination"? Its not racist the person who care about race? Or its just the person who discrimintates? For me those are different ideas.

1

u/donald-ball Apr 14 '21

Assuming good faith, you might try How to Be an Antiracist or So You Want to Talk About Race.

I don’t actually perceive good faith on your part, to be frank.

3

u/charkui Apr 14 '21

What will be good faith? Accepting it and dont ask how this solves the problem? I understand those positions, but that doesnt mean that im not gonna ask about how it solves it. Personally i prefer policies without any kind of seggregation, i understand that these ideas want to help people, but as many things in life, maybe this have some tradeoffs, im sure that cant be perfect, even without seggregations as i prefered. Ideas and policies can improve with critics, even those that sound completely good and with any tradeoff.

1

u/donald-ball Apr 14 '21

Educate yourself on your own time. The “I’m just asking questions” bit wears thin after you’ve heard it for the thousandth time.

18

u/mutualconfusion Apr 13 '21

Why? Because historically most open-source software was written by white men?

Ok, first of all, how about some gratitude then?

Gross.

1

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

Yeah? How so?

Do you dispute the fact? Or do you recoil at the fact?

Or?

5

u/Logitropicity Apr 13 '21

Hi, u/darth_zidious, just point out something others haven't yet brought up, since this thread seems to be turning into a mixture of discussion and CMV.

Some quick points:

Before we dive into my main argument, I wanted to point out a neat interview with John Stewart, the comedian. Stewart makes three points, which we'll connect back to the software/Clojure community in a bit:

  1. By instituting paid internships, as opposed to unpaid internships, you get more diverse hires, simply because otherwise their parents can't afford to send their kids to a 3-month unpaid stint.

  2. They didn't receive non-white applicants from their recruiters until they asked for them. The recruiters, their tributaries, are complicit too.

  3. Diversity simply makes things better - I assume he means that it makes the jokes better.

Point 1

I think you can agree at the very least, point 1 isn't racist at all. It's just reaching out to people of different socioeconomic backgrounds. It's just paying people to do their jobs. It's just widening your applicant pool, and taking the cream of the crop from a wider area.

Point 2

For other organizations, the HR who screens applicants & the managers who hire them are different people. If, like in comedy, HR isn't bringing diverse hires to management, then it would be a case of HR recruiters being racist, intentionally or not, and the managers having to deal with it afterwards, wouldn't it?

It seems reasonable to double check and simply remind HR that they should attempt to combat any conscious or unconscious biases they have. I think that simply reminding people (HR) to not be racist isn't a particularly racist thing to do, let alone a "far-left ideology" that will "metastasize" to other organizations.

For Clojurist Together in particular, this is a moot point. The board members are the recruiters. They are the ones recruiting new board members. It's up to them to avoid being racist, intentionally or not.

Point 3

You could argue that this isn't comparable to us - no matter how successful Stewart is, he's a comedian, and we're software people, and you can't compare apples to oranges, and you can't directly measure how funny you are anyways.

But, software is in a similar position. It's not like we can directly measure how clean or maintainable a piece of software is either.* I think it would be a reasonable first guess or hypothesis that "diversity simply makes software or the software-making process better" would also hold true for us. And furthermore, there's no way to test this hypothesis either unless someone tries it.

You're welcome to have a different hypothesis, of course, but similarly, I think it'd be fine if Clojurist Together, or any other organization for that matter wants to try diversity. If they have a different hypothesis than you, I can respect that as well.

Final Thoughts

I think that in a sense, you are half-correct, half-incorrect. I would agree with you that Clojurists Together's board policy seems to be clumsy. It is an inelegant solution to a lack of diversity.

The only things I personally can appreciate about their policy is that they think that diversity is important, and that they are specifically trying to nominate POC, women, etc.**

I think that they could stand to improve on Point 1. What's going on with their management hiring decisions? How come diversity isn't simply an emergent property of picking the best talent, as opposed to it being a top-down decision?

If Comedy Central can change their hiring practices so that diversity (and therefore we hypothesize, quality) is an emergent property of their hiring practices, why can't the tech community do the same?

I think the tech community would do well to look at what's preventing them from tapping into the talent of all people, as opposed to only using the talent of their current demographic distribution.

Surely, being able to leverage the talent of more people is better than leveraging the talent of less, no?

* Well, not before you become wildly successful & get large viewership numbers, anyways. And even then, you can't measure how successful a joke will be before you tell it.

**This is similar to the Rooney Rule u/birawa8575 pointed out.

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

I think you can agree at the very least, point 1 isn't racist at all. It's just reaching out to people of different socioeconomic backgrounds. It's just paying people to do their jobs. It's just widening your applicant pool, and taking the cream of the crop from a wider area.

Zero problems with that, of course!

I think that simply reminding people (HR) to not be racist isn't a particularly racist thing to do, let alone a "far-left ideology" that will "metastasize" to other organizations.

I really suggest you look into postmodernism. If you understand it, you can see it permeating initiatives such as the one I pointed out, and you will understand why it is far-left stuff, and why it has metastasized.

And furthermore, there's no way to test this hypothesis either unless someone tries it.

But it's been tried, it's all of open-source, heh. Do you know any project that's rejecting contributions based on race or sex?

I mean, if you look really deep I'm sure there will be some (personally I don't know any, but then again I never went looking for it).. but certainly that is not the mainstream - and way beyond that, it's not even something that anyone is thinking about.

I think it'd be fine if Clojurist Together, or any other organization for that matter wants to try diversity. If they have a different hypothesis than you, I can respect that as well.

It's their organization, as far as I am concerned to me that largely means they can do whatever they want.

Nevertheless, I do think that equity as opposed to equality is a big mistake, and considering that more and more university-educated students who were indoctrinated into postmodernist thought there are making their ways to government and the private sector, and considering that very real and very negative implications of that will inevitably follow (I don't want all in here, but PM me if you want some good books about it), I did think it wise to speak up, before this sort of thing becomes normal and then mandatory ("you disagree with equity, you're a racist").

1

u/Logitropicity Apr 18 '21 edited Apr 18 '21

Hmm. We might be at an impasse then.

I'm not entirely sure what your goal is. Are you opposed to the goal of diversity? Do you have issues with how it's being implemented? Do you think that the goal of diversity is somehow detrimental to equality, as opposed to Clojurists Together's implementation of diversity? What are you trying to accomplish with your arguments?

I don't have any issue with Clojurists Together's goal of diversity, but I do wish they had a better implementation of it (though to be fair, as u/lvh points out, a better solution doesn't seem to currently exist).

My current understanding of your argument is that you think that "reminding people that they shouldn't be racist" is somehow racist and therefore detrimental to equality. And, ah, I didn't see any sentences that show that the former implies the latter except for something about postmodernism. And, I will reveal the rest of my argument later. So you know that I am not lying or trying to trick you, the SHA-256 of the argument I will reveal is: A7A815B1E94FC44F6F09A7441D5732B1984E73880A284B4A7367C8EE3BD0B8C9 .

To be frank, I'm not sure why postmodernism needs to be involved. Can you give a quick rundown of postmodernism? Do you think that this is exclusive to the far-left? I've already PM-ed you for books, but having a quick overview is useful too.

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 19 '21

Are you opposed to the goal of diversity?

Imposed diversity, yes. Because by definition, if you had to select based on other attributes besides competence, you are longer going for the cream of the crop.

Besides the obvious problems (do you want your pilot on your next flight home to be of the "right" color, or do you want the pilot to be the best one available?), then you also have to ask yourself what other people will rightly question when they see a candidate that matches whatever special criteria were deemed important enough to discriminate in favor of by the diversity officers: "does this person really deserve to be here?"

What better way to create cynicism and indeed, stoke the fires of the very racism and sexism such policies allegedly are designed to combat?

Go one step further. What do you think a person who's honest with themselves thinks about themselves when they realize the only reason they got the job is because of their color or sex?

If they have some sense into them, they'll be ashamed.

Diversity for diversity's sake is a fool's errand, but even worse than that is discriminating against perfectly good people who had the best skills for the job, based on their skin or sex - the very definition of racism and sexism.

Do you think that the goal of diversity is somehow detrimental to equality [...]

Yes. Different people will choose different things. Obviously I don't have a problem with leveling the playing field in that sense, even though it will never be perfect - but I think it's undeniable that it is several orders of magnitude better than it was not so long ago, and almost assuredly it is better than it's ever been.

One very good documentary to learn more about this subpoint in particular is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E577jhf25t4&list=PLd9_g7lAICxtlGbxh4_z8ik178o8CDPnv ... a quick explanation here to potentially interest potential readers: in the most "equality" (as opposed to equity) countries in the world, it turns out that the sex-differences in terms of career choice and so on are even more extreme. In a very simplified way, this is because they worked hard to eliminate as many of the cultural/societal factors as possible, and that has the effect of maximizing the biological dimension. And so you get even more male engineers than usual (things), and even more female teachers and nurses (people, caring) than usual.

So another problem I have with the equity line of thought is that it assumes everyone is absolutely the same and we all ought to have the same interests, which is demonstrably false: but since people who expose that sort of argument tend to start from the viewpoint that society is a massive oppressive machine ruled by powerful groups who keep everyone else down, and everything is about power .. and considering that the "equality" policies have not had the effects they have desired.. now the game has moved on to imposing the result they ought to see, reordering society from the top-down in the process, and discriminating against many of the "powerful groups", the vast majority of whom are just normal people living normal lives. And again, though it should not matter, bear in mind that I'm neither white nor do I live in a western country.

1

u/Logitropicity May 01 '21

Before I forget, here's the hashed text:

http://onlinemd5.com/

MD5 & SHA1 Hash Generator For Text

Checksum type: SHA-256

Specifically, I think that postmodernism doesn't need to be involved because it's just good manners to try not be racist. (Actually, it's more than just good manners, but that's not the point.) It calms people down and lets you have lots of friends, because you avoid accidentally hurting people - or at least, that's my personal experience. I'd hope my friends and coworkers would tell me if I have bad manners (so I can correct myself), and so I would do the same for them. If they didn't tell me I was doing something so embarrassing, I'd think they were out to get me!

I'll get around to the sources you gave me sometime. They're a bit long!

As for me, some sources I heard from reddit include this:

https://hbr.org/2021/04/how-one-company-worked-to-root-out-bias-from-performance-reviews

The solution they present seems simple enough! Just asking for more proof during the review process was enough to weed out some unconscious racial bias, forcing managers to really promote people based on their competence. It's not a complete solution, but it's certainly better than before.

Of course, HBR also presents this:

https://hbr.org/2016/07/why-diversity-programs-fail

So it's also important to be careful and not be too heavy-handed.

4

u/lvh Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Do you have a proposal for how the foundation could amend its bylaws to be less clumsy?

> I think that they could stand to improve on Point 1. What's going on with their management hiring decisions? How come diversity isn't simply an emergent property of picking the best talent, as opposed to it being a top-down decision?

We are all volunteers. It is true that that refers to point 1 and that paid positions might help, but as someone intimately familiar with the internals of the Python Software Foundation, I don't think we're able to pay anyone a salary yet without jeopardizing operations.

2

u/Logitropicity Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Haha, I wish I did. I'm in the same boat as you. I'm not well read on the topic.

A diner can say that the chef's food doesn't taste good, but not know what's in the recipe exactly. So too, I don't know what the exact solution for Clojurist Together, or for the tech industry, is, but I do know that Comedy Central seems to have a "better tasting" solution.

Actually, for the tech industry as a whole, they might want to consider holding free-of-charge summer camps, similar to YMCA Camps, that teach kids to code. Or, similar to how libraries might hold free read-aloud sessions for kids, they might offer free code-along sessions for kids. Snacks too! But these would help things in a decade or so, and they aren't a set of rules that an organization could implement.

A PoliSci or Management major might be able to help with organization rules or hiring policies. Somebody with a humanities degree, maybe. Idk exactly, but certainly not in the direction of "somebody who knows how to implement efficient sorting algorithms".

4

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

We did consult with those experts: this is one of the things they suggested. (They are, of course, not mutually exclusive with things like, say, ClojureBridge.)

2

u/Logitropicity Apr 13 '21

Oh, are you part of the board? Hmm. That's rough then, dude. It's certainly better than nothing. It's also probably not the end-all, be-all of diverse hiring practices, so...I guess there's still room for the experts to improve!

Tough position you're in. Hope you guys find a better solution eventually. As for me, I'm hoping to study this issue from a different angle in either my future grad studies or self-studies.

5

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

I am one of the founders, and its current President, and do about 50% of the ops work :)

1

u/Logitropicity May 01 '21

Since 17 days ago, I did pick up on this, which does have a partial solution: https://hbr.org/2021/04/how-one-company-worked-to-root-out-bias-from-performance-reviews and also this, which has some info about some common pitfalls: https://hbr.org/2016/07/why-diversity-programs-fail

More articles are tagged under diversity there. I don't know if you've heard of or implemented them already, but the first article seems like a good example of what I was talking about: diversity being an emergent property of management practices.

I hope it helps! We're cheering you on! I know I am, at least.

1

u/Logitropicity Apr 13 '21

Why am I getting downvoted? I am not trying to insult OP, and I am trying to bring something new and relevant to the table.

If you disagree with me, comment! Let's discuss.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21 edited Jul 08 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Logitropicity Apr 13 '21

Err, I think you misunderstood my point. I'm saying that even though comedy and software initially look like they are as different as apples are to oranges, we are comparing apples to apples, for the purposes of our discussion.

5

u/donald-ball Apr 13 '21

I am a contributor and delighted by this policy, which is, for what it’s worth, not even a bit unusual in the realm of non-profit organization by-laws. The OP is clearly intending to kick up a storm and I reject them utterly.

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

The OP is clearly intending to kick up a storm and I reject them utterly.

That you believe this might have something more to do with the fact that you seem to automatically suspect anyone who disagrees with your point of view, and less with my intent to kick up some storm.

I voiced my concerns, nothing more.

0

u/donald-ball Apr 18 '21

Says the troll who created an account specifically and temporally for this post. GTFO.

1

u/Michaelmrose Apr 20 '21

Likely because they would prefer to voice the thought without someone calling their employer and trying to get them fired. Just because you wouldn't do it doesn't mean someone else wouldn't.

6

u/p1ng313 Apr 13 '21

As much as I respect your position, and even share some of it, the more I study this issue the more I think it's not very good to paint it with such broad strokes as you have. On a vacuum, of course it shouldn't matter what ethnicity, color or background someone is. But we don't live in a vacuum, and even if I somewhat disagree with positive discrimination I believe the problem isn't as clear cut.

For example, there is a well known bias where people tend to go for other people that look like you Another problem is how do you make up for all the negative discrimination in the past? If you don't do something, how is the problem going to be fixed?

I think the era where hackers only cared about the code and nothing more is disappearing, nowadays every project has some sort of social weight whether they like it or not, due to possible exposure over the internet. I would prefer that people didn't discriminate and everyone was fair, but unfortunately this doesn't happen.

Again, I don't think you are doing good by painting the problem with such black-and-white strokes.

1

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

On a vacuum, of course it shouldn't matter what ethnicity, color or background someone is. But we don't live in a vacuum, and even if I somewhat disagree with positive discrimination I believe the problem isn't as clear cut.

Ultimately, if you accept this line of thought, you undermine Liberalism itself.

I am assuming that you agree that is a bad thing, of course.. some people (postmodernists) think that's fine, even better than fine indeed.

I think the era where hackers only cared about the code and nothing more is disappearing.

Perhaps it ought to make a roaring comeback?

5

u/joinr Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

People should vote with their $ then. You can start an alternative that does not discriminate in this way and advertise it just as Clojurists Together does. I believe they are a 501c6 tax-exempt trade association or business league. There can be more than one of these with different bylaws and membership and goals. I think you can legally define your bylaws to prevent this kind of stuff as well (sounds like non-profits have a lot of leeway on how they manage themselves).

I had been thinking about donating some money again, but these policies are a deterrent. The alternative (ceteris paribus) is to support individuals or charities instead.

14

u/darth_zidious Apr 13 '21

Oh yes, don't get me wrong, I don't like what they are doing but I don't think it should be illegal. As you said, people should vote with their $.

I just find it troublesome that this kind of thing is going on, seemingly without much push-back (maybe I'm wrong?) and wanted to bring attention to it.

Also, I suspect that many people will not be comfortable discussing such matters out in the open, and given the cancel culture phenomenon, perhaps I can't blame them - but then this cancer is going to continue growing unchallenged and speaking the truth gets harder, not easier.

There is a lot of radical leftist ideology embedded in such positions, and perhaps people don't necessarily appreciate what they are swallowing when they capitulate to the social pressure of not questioning obviously racist & sexist policies for fears of being singled out as racist and sexist themselves.

15

u/joinr Apr 13 '21

There is nothing really new under the sun, including all forms of discrimination and cancel culture (except cancellation used to mean death by the state or the mob).

It's both sad and ironic that - as I went to look through the candidates list and compare them ostensibly to the standards quoted by the bylaws, the candidate pool doesn't seem to be meet their prescriptions or proscriptions (absent some intersectionality test that's not public knowledge). I don't have the gender/race/sexuality/historical discriminated population data for all the candidates - and I don't think I should. I hope they did not have to fill out forms to that effect in order to check the necessary boxes.

It's weird and depressing to have to go through a list of people - who I know directly and indirectly - and try to apply the mental gymnastics to put them into the appropriate bucket so that they can make the cut when someone nominates them. These are all extremely talented and dedicated folks (the people that I recognize from code and conferences; I give the benefit of the doubt that unfamiliar folks are in the same high competency bracket, based on public contributions I can find, and the general observation that most folks pursuing these public spheres are more competent developers than me).

5

u/guywithknife Apr 13 '21

They do say that they try to hit those percentages, not that they have to. So the candidate list not hitting the percentages seems consistent with their policy, as long as they reasonably attempted to hit the numbers.

32

u/birawa8575 Apr 13 '21

sounds like it's just in the nomination, similar to the [Rooney Rule](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rooney_Rule) which I think is a pretty reasonable. You have to at least get people who are systemically discriminated against to the table -- if they're no good, the nomination will not turn over into a position.

This isn't close in any way to far left ideology. You sound out of touch when you say it.

35

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

I’m glad to give Clojurists Together a small bit of money each month and I was glad to see this policy.

I’m frankly disappointed to see anyone upset at the notion that we need to take active steps to increase our diversity.

2

u/asiergaldos Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

There are plenty of talented females, non-caucasians and under-represented people in the Clojure community, so I don't see any issue here.

The outcome, with or without this criteria, would be exactly the same.

ps: I agree with this policy, btw.

1

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

There are plenty of talented females, non-caucasians and under-represented people in the Clojure community, so I don't see any issue here.

I am sure that there are, and I am pretty positive that many, maybe most of them would balk at the pandering being done to the supposed benefit of their "group".

I know I am (I am not white, that counts for something for people who think like that, right? Funny, for me it means nothing.. but ok)

8

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

If the outcome would be the same then get rid of the policy because it advertises racist intent.

3

u/asiergaldos Apr 14 '21

Are you a member of Clojurists Together?

14

u/stecrupeme Apr 13 '21

Thanks OP, now I know about Clojurists together and I will consider donating to them.

7

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Welcome and thanks! We'll try our hardest to make sure it goes to the right places :)

14

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

If you are a member, I'd be happy to give you a refund. If you are not a member, I would ask you not to use language of "metastasizing cancer" to describe what other people do with their time and money, particularly when that thing they do benefits you (by funding open source infrastructure).

15

u/emil0r Apr 13 '21

With the potential of this to completely blow up in the community's face, I missed the part about the bylaws, and do find it deeply troubling. It is identity politics seeping into tech :|.

13

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Are you a member? I'd be happy to refund you if you feel deceived. (And Latacora will 2x that amount.) It doesn't look like you're on the members list, so I'm surprised to hear you bothered to read the bylaws and missed this.

6

u/emil0r Apr 13 '21

My comment is to be taken at face value. I am deeply troubled that politics seeps into tech, as evidenced by this thread, which reads like a more polite flame war on facebook.

As a fan of the Clojurist Together project, I would be saddened to see the community support lessened because of political bickering.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21

Like it or not, everything is political, including your statement here. You are explicitly voicing the political opinion that identity politics do not belong in tech, and therefore implicitly voicing support for your presumed status quo.

4

u/emil0r Apr 15 '21

I am voicing the opinion that any real world politics does not belong in tech. In this particular case it is identity politics. Opposing introduction of real world politics into tech could technically be construed as being political, but it's really splitting hairs.

So far among the comments, I have seen people I admire for their technical skills, fall for the allure of calling people out, albeit gently most of the time, like an iron club wrapped in soft padding. It divides and sets parts of the community against each other. Everyone loses in a situation like this.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21

First, the policy in question is the exact opposite of identity politics, defined as "a tendency for people of a particular religion, race, social background, etc., to form exclusive political alliances, moving away from traditional broad-based party politics". The policy is seeking to do the exact opposite by increasing diversity.

Second, this policy did not cause the schism in the community that you're concerned about-- OP bursting in here to rail against the policy did.

Third, your tone is incredibly patronizing. I am not "splitting hairs", I am pointing out what is obvious based on the language you use and the talking points you adhere to. The posters here are not "fall[ing] for the allure of calling people out", they are doing the work of making this an inclusive space and fighting for the ability for minorities to be welcome here. You claim to care about the community, but the way you talk sounds like you look down upon the members.

Last, this is not a flame war. This is one of the defining conversations of our times. It will follow you into every community you participate in. You cannot avoid it. You have chosen not to avoid it by getting involved. By simply asking for peace, you are asking for others to tacitly accept dog whistles for white supremacy. That will tear down the community far faster than working to root out the rot.

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

they are doing the work of making this an inclusive space and fighting for the ability for minorities to be welcome here

Hello, I am the OP and I am not white (I am part of a minority).


Your speech is deeply disturbing to me and caused me great offense and distress.

I do not feel included. Because I feel this way clearly you must be a terrible terrible racist, and you cannot be allowed to express your opinions anymore.

Or I won't feel safe here.

I just don't feel safe when anyone disagrees with me like this. What will the moderators do?

(everything below the horizontal line is fabrication, but could very easily not be -- DO YOU SEE THE PROBLEM?)

2

u/emil0r Apr 15 '21

So we went from everything is political to I am asking others to tacitly accept dog whistles for white supremacy? Nice... see my point?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

This is extremely disingenuous: politics is injected into tech via initiatives such as these, and then everyone who disagrees with politics being injected via the backdoor this way and wants to react, is accused of discussing politics.

Do you see the problem?

10

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

As far as I can tell the people who are doing the complaining aren't members, and the board answers to its constituents.

11

u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21

Reminder: don't downvote because you disagree. If you disagree, write a rebuttal or upvote one.

I personally believe diversity issues will be better addressed if OP's misgivings can be voiced and discussed with high visibility.

7

u/donald-ball Apr 13 '21

I can do both.

23

u/freakhill Apr 13 '21

you american people are weird

2

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Are you saying that about OP, or the Clojurists Together bylaws for having that rule?

9

u/freakhill Apr 13 '21

OP

9

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Hah. Interestingly I’ve seen this described as both “only Americans could have that rule” and “only Americans could get upset about this”. And it’s extra funny because I (founder, President) am a naturalized American from Belgium and Daniel is from New Zealand.

13

u/freakhill Apr 13 '21

that kind of rules kind of pops up all around the world (at least in europe and asia, for like at least 10+ years, mostly about female representation)

but the whole "my day was ruined" "far-left ideology metastasizing" overreaction seems typically american.

seeing from afar these extreme dudes seem like "a normal american". you did have your whole trump episode.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

but the whole "my day was ruined" "far-left ideology metastasizing" overreaction seems typically american.

This sounded strange to me as well.

4

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

Heh, Americans haven't seen anything resembling "far left" in 100+ years.

0

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

Yeah, I'm neither American nor white.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Doombuggie41 Apr 13 '21

And just like that, I'm signing up for a Clojurists Together membership.

8

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Welcome and thank you!

4

u/pacerpower Apr 13 '21

Same! Thanks for all the hard work you do, lvh.

2

u/_shreve Apr 13 '21

They don't have to be mutually exclusive. You could hire 4 BIPoC Women and give the other 8 seats to white men.

0

u/Michaelmrose Apr 20 '21

Wouldn't that actually disadvantage BIPoC men who are worth fewer diversity points?

Lets propose you were hiring for 10 jobs with 100 applicants. Say your applicant pool is just as diverse as your population in terms of race but not gender. Say 70% white and 80% male. So you have.

56 white men 24 non white men 14 white women 6 non white women

In order to pick the 6 white men you are picking the top 11% of applicants. In order to select 4 non white women you are picking the top 67% for lack of options.

For any group of applicants wherein you can order them in terms of desirability for the job the optimal selection process is one in which you simply fill n positions by selecting the top n of the ranking. The only way to achieve a specific racial mix is to substitute a lower ranking individual for a higher one because by definition you have already hired the individuals above position x who have the desired race. Bigotry is always sub optimal.

For example if 4 of 6 highest performers were black and the hiring manager considering how to hire for the 7th position decided the team needed more white people because he's a racist by definition the 2 higher ranking white people that exist are already on the team. The only white people are all by definition lower ranked than unlucky number 7. Any swap he makes to whiten the team will make it weaker.

Racism of any variety makes us weaker.

8

u/DefiantAverage1 Apr 13 '21

You guys are weird for not finding this policy weird.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

This is pure virtue signaling. Nothing more.

Clojure is practiced by 90% white men. That's just the way it is, putting minorities in visible positions will do diddly squat to make young black girls interested in programming. They know this, they're not idiots. They just want to look virtuous.

5

u/vattenpuss Apr 14 '21

putting minorities in visible positions will do diddly squat to make young black girls interested in programming.

Do you have some sources for that?

3

u/lvh Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

"That's just the way it is": does that mean it's immutable, or are you saying *this* will do nothing about it? Are there efforts you would consider sincere, say, actually hiring people, running trainings, investing in their companies, et cetera?

7

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

I mean this will do nothing about it.

The underlying issue is that hardly anyone outside white men have any interest in this stuff at all. That may be due to cultural norms, but this isn't your culture, it's someone else's and you've got no business trying to tell them what they should be interested in. The best you can do is be welcoming, and honestly that's a pretty big hump to get over. If you went to a new place and it was all (say) hispanic women, you'd probably feel a little out of place, even if they were the nicest people on earth.

4

u/lvh Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Are any of those things (investing, hiring, organizing trainings) examples of butting into peoples cultures and dictating what they should be interested in, or are they examples of giving people who have already indicated an interest similar opportunities offered to others?

> If you went to a new place and it was all (say) hispanic women, you'd probably feel a little out of place, even if they were the nicest people on earth.

Do you see how that same rationale might apply to, say, women of color who might feel a little out of place in a room full of white dudes even if they were the nicest people on earth? That sounds like an argument in favor of representation :)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

That's what I meant: you can't unilaterally change the representation. You can't forcibly change people's interests. (I didn't mean to imply you were doing that, just saying it wouldn't be ethical even if it was possible). So you're stuck with mostly white people until a) others get interested and b) overcome the intimidating ratio, slowly.

3

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Well, hang on: previously you were saying shouldn't, now you're saying "can't". Do you mean "can't" in the moral sense synonymous with shouldn't, or in the "it won't work" sense, or both? If the latter: would you accept evidence from other similar organizations where inclusion efforts did work as evidence that it could work and that interest isn't really the problem?

You may not have meant to imply that I am forcing anyone to do anything, but do you agree that you described my efforts as insincere?

4

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Sure. If inclusion efforts work, it's because there's interest. I'm not sure how you measure "working" though. Hiring people deliberately by race obviously changes the representation, but it may not fix the underlying inequality.

Edit: I don't really care about intent or how consciously aware people are of what they're really doing. You can't argue with people about their internal state. I treat everything as deliberate. I don't care if that offends you. It's just too easy, especially on the internet, to say "woopsie daisy, didn't mean it".

5

u/lvh Apr 14 '21 edited Apr 14 '21

Some examples (I've given the concert musician example elsewhere, so I'll stick to personal ones here):

  • At Latacora and at my previous employer, we use work sample tests as a technical hiring challenge. These have a rubric, which is as objective as possible: you either get the vuln, or you don't. All we did is started advertising in places where underrepresented groups were not different and hence might reasonably feel unwelcome: women in CS groups, Blacks In Technology... (Note: "started", not " to the exclusion of others".). We now have way more queer folks, people of color, and women across the board, including in technical and leadership roles.

  • At PyCon, for the program committee (the thing that decides which talks get slots), we removed names from the submissions. Diversity of speakers improved: women are less underrepresented than they were (I don't have the current figures because I am no longer involved in the program committee but my understanding is they're well north of 35% female speakers). Similar outreach efforts as above; more recent ones have focused on POC speakers, and judging by the roster that's working out too.

  • Parenthood is not gendered, but society does put more emphasis on women doing childcare tasks. We added childcare and a mothers room at PyCon. Female attendance improved, a good number of people made use of those faciltiies, and it was one of the most common call-outs in the conference feedback.

Of course, these aren't randomized controlled trials. It's possible that we just happened to get all of the good non-white dude applicants that week, but that seems pretty unlikely. It's possible some other outreach effort is what really did it for PyCon. But the goalpost wasn't "this specific intervention is effective", it's "change is possible if we try".

We did not lower a bar. We introduced objective standards and removed places for subjective bias to take hold. Diversity improved.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Let's pick that second one apart first; I'll comment on the former later.

I am referring specifically to your first comment:

This is pure virtue signaling. Nothing more.

Clojure is practiced by 90% white men. That's just the way it is, putting minorities in visible positions will do diddly squat to make young black girls interested in programming. They know this, they're not idiots. They just want to look virtuous.

(emphasis mine)

It sure sounds like you are saying I do not believe what I am saying, hence, you are characterizing my efforts as insincere. Right? You say "I don't care if you are consciously aware or not, you can't argue with people about their internal state" then I would recommend not going on the Internet and telling random people what their internal state is, because it sure seems like you, a person I don't believe I've ever met or interacted with, went out of your way to impugn my motives.

Would putting my own money where my mouth is convince you that I do in fact believe what I am saying?

→ More replies (9)

6

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

the industry being homogenous leads to in-group bias, racism, sexism, other forms of discrimination, salary gap, slow or unachievable career progression. these are just some of the issues.

quotas are not the panacea but they positively affect the ecosystem in the long term by expanding opportunity for candidates today, growing the candidate pool in the future.

if it comes at the cost of slightly reducing hiring opportunity for folks that already have advantage to being hired - so be it, i'm willing to pay that price.

turning this into right/left identity politics game is just dumb and shows your real motive. though i suspect you're just a troll.

6

u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21

I disagree with OP, but find his reaction understandable. Without prior exposure to them, it can be natural to find quotas disturbing. If you think selfishly maintaining one's provilege is the only possible "motive" for opposing them, you're missing something big. I recommend you be more charitable, and suggest that you might be harming inclusion by representing the cause as you are.

4

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

I only mentioned motive in relation to OPs attempt to attach political labels. There is absolutely no need to be charitable for this kind of behavior.

5

u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21

Even so, there are more sensible responses to this kind of behavior than impugning motives.

3

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

you're right. i have too little patience when i suspect bad faith argument these days.

2

u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21

I can relate :) this last answer does your credit!

-3

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

But in reality e.g. an individual white man is actually disadvantaged in hiring compared to women. The few women who do apply have much higher chances of being hired. The fact that simply due to the higher number of male applicants most positions will end up with men doesn't change that it is highly unjust and discriminatory to the individual.

1

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

The few women who do apply

do you not see the selection bias here?

5

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

I don't see any injustice with people self-selecting for different interests. If you want you are free to convince women to go into tech rather than whatever else they were going to do, but it is completely unacceptable to implement discriminatory policies against other groups to force some outcome.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

There are many examples where self-selection is a product of discrimination. If a company provides really bad maternity benefits then lots of women will avoid it. That's self-selection but it's rooted in some form of unequal opportunity.

If you're not white and apply for a job in a company where everyone is white and during the hiring process you feel excluded (different references, networks, jokes, goals, etc) you'll probably avoid all white workplaces in the future. That's self selection as well but it stems from a plethora of socioeconomic reasons.

If you have to help your parents or grandparents at home because they lived in a time and place where they couldn't even have access to higher education, that's self determination but the circumstances are heavily skewing the possible choices you have to begin with.

I hope it makes sense to you as to why we have to look past self-selection regarding those issues.

8

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

Actually I would absolutely agree with alleviating unequal opportunity. The point is that I object to it being so focused on race and gender.

There are many circumstances in which your familial situation can cause you to be disadvantaged. Support and outreach should be based on the actual situation. It does not make sense to say we support people who are poor and uneducated because e.g. of past racism, but we don't support other poor and uneducated people because they are white and there are already enough successful white people. Things like race are not directly causal for hardship, but only somewhat correlated, and it is wrong to infer the level of hardship based on them. Every person should be treated as an individual worthy of support if they are in a disadvantaged position.

2

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

There is a category for that in that same bylaw. The rule does not say "race and gender are the only things you are allowed to take into consideration", it only says "here are two examples of things you have to take into consideration". Childhood poverty, reduced access to education, refugee status, survivor status.... all sound like things that can be valuable things to bring to the table in the right context.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

people self-selecting for different interests

don't you think all the discrimination, in-group bias, difficulties in career progression, etc will affect that "self-selection"?

7

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

So between being preferentially hired, being provided special mentoring and networking opportunities, and being encouraged everywhere in the media, how exactly is a woman in tech nowadays in any way disadvantaged compared to a man?

A million different personal, social, and random factors influence the self-selection, but it is not automatically unjust simply because it has some correlation with gender. If women don't express the will to pursue tech, it is just a pointless discussion about free will and social determinism, but not a moral issue.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

This system offers great opportunities for communities who historically have been disadvantaged, are sometimes frowned upon and who, most likely do not benefit of the same network people who aren't discriminated against do.

Calling this "far left ideology" or "identity politics" as I've seen in the thread is really peculiar in my opinion. I, for one, am glad we're going towards a more inclusive environment in tech.

6

u/txrom_ Apr 13 '21

Agreed. I was kinda gobsmacked reading OPs post. It really showed a lack of familiarity with the issues faced by discriminated groups.

11

u/la-rokci Apr 13 '21

A genuine question - what are those issues?

7

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

You can read this article from the Pew Research center, a non partisan, charitably funded, research center. Said article also has testimonies.

You can also read the section II (p.16) of the Diversity in high tech report, which was mandated by a governmental commission.

5

u/la-rokci Apr 13 '21

Thanks for the links, I skimmed them over and have learned a bit more about the issues involved.

I fail to see how the bylaws are helpful though. If we are even unintentionally discriminate towards gender, race etc., these bylaws force us to discriminate intentionally. Reading the testimonies from your first article makes me aware of the issues at play, but I don't want specific numbers to end up causing someone more appropriate to lose the position.

TLDR; I don't think we can solve discrimination with "better" discrimination.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Thanks for taking the time to read the article.

I think that the fear of missing on someone more appropriate is quite overplayed to be honest. We've been missing out on great people because they just didn't have the resources to get to these functions. Hopefully it'll get better.

5

u/pcjftw Apr 13 '21

I agree with this

The world has lost its way and we're seeing extremist left wing liberalism overflowing, keep things very simple:

We don't need a "Code of Conduct" we just need to make sure to "not be a jerk to others".

We don't need representations, we just need to hire based purely on merit, if you're badass in writing Clojure or any other language, you will remain a badass regardless of your shape or colour.

TL;DR content not container, don't be a jerk. Just pure common sense.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

This is a terribly myopic take, if merit was all there is to anything, discrimination wouldn't be an issue.

12

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

It's bizarre to say we don't have meritocracy and conclude from that we need more discrimination. The opposite is the case.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

The opposite is the case.

Which is exactly what people creating more inclusive work places are doing. Giving a chance to people who historically didn't have one and allowing similar opportunities even when you've been discriminated against in the past and present.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[deleted]

0

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

No, it's "rectifying past injustices that lead to a poorer education" this time...

5

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

You don't rectify bad education with preferential selection to boards of directors. You rectify it with good education.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/pcjftw Apr 13 '21

but surely positive discrimination is just as bad as negative discrimination?

Hence it's better to stick to merit, yes I understand in the real world there are biases, however I do think in the engineering world, good systems developed by good engineers tend to out pace bad systems made by bad engineers, and in the end since engineering is goal oriented those racial/sexual basis are less pronounced. Ergo we don't need to be told like little children to conduct ourselves like decent human beings?

10

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

but surely positive discrimination is just as bad as negative discrimination?

This is a false equivalence, positive discrimination merely tries to provide equal opportunities to everyone, while negative discrimination keeps a bunch of people down.

Even if you do think that, discrimination at the workplace is well documented, for example in the field of labor economics. Since that's the case, and tackling decades of discrimination takes time, positive discrimination allows to lift some of the burden on discriminated communities. Since we are so oblivious about our own biases, we can use positive actions to improve the workplace. Otherwise, we are missing out on talented people and fostering unequal environments.

10

u/emil0r Apr 13 '21

How is excluding a candidate in favour of another candidate based on immutable characteristics providing equal opportunity to the excluded candidate?

3

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

But...it's already not an equal opportunity. This is what all the talk of "privilege" is about.

Say you're a tech-oriented black kid. Due to historical redlining, the neighborhood you grow up in is worth less than an equivalent white neighborhood.

Since your neighborhood is worth less, the real estate taxes are lower, and therefore your community school isn't as good. Maybe the computers are out-of-date. Maybe they can't afford computers at all. Despite all that, you managed to get good grades and get into uni and a CS program.

However, your fellow white students had, and have, advantages you don't. This applies in myriad other ways, continuing into the future, too. The research is out there for people of good will and curiosity to find.

So, knowing this black kid had disadvantages, if you don't compensate for this effect, it's a roundabout racist way of telling him, "Tough shit. This other guy may or may not actually be better, but he definitely looks better."

Martin Luther King: "It’s all right to tell a man to lift himself by his own bootstraps, but it is cruel jest to say to a bootless man that he ought to lift himself by his own bootstraps."

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

That's a very good question people who are discriminated against are surely asking themselves.

2

u/pcjftw Apr 13 '21

So I do agree with some of that, but I think there is some very careful nuances that need to be taken into consideration, I'm all for wider inclusion as I suspect most people are, I think the issue maybe when it's "forced or faux inclusion" as in the "inclusion" sake is the only weighting in the hiring decision, I think that's what most people are against?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ribelo Apr 13 '21

but surely positive discrimination is just as bad as negative discrimination?

Isn't discrimination just discrimination? Positive discrimination is some kind of oxymoron probably only possible in English. Any form of discrimination is wrong. Any attempt to equalize at the cost of others is wrong.

all animals are equal but some animals are more equal than others

1

u/lilactown Apr 13 '21

You're arguing about fairness but that's irrelevant here. When we're talking about discrimination against people, the reason it's bad is due to the outcomes- injustice and equality. Justice and equality are not the same thing as fairness.

4

u/ribelo Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Sorry, I'm not a native speaker. Social justice is equalizing opportunities for some at the cost of others. This is the complete opposite of what appears in my language dictionary under the word justice. There is no need to equalize any opportunities. History has taken a strange path from racism, to indifference and to omit race, finally to positive discrimination. Instead of stopping to divide people other than through merit, we assign unnecessary labels and categorize them by sex and race.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

2

u/Doombuggie41 Apr 13 '21

We don't need a "Code of Conduct" we just need to make sure to "not be a jerk to others".

I would LOVE to find a community where you could just tell someone to not be a jerk and they listen/understand. Unfortunately, often times folks need very pointed examples of what being a jerk consists of.

2

u/SickMoonDoe Apr 13 '21

Get over yourself.

1

u/veydar_ Apr 13 '21

It's always fascinating to watch someone dig their own hole

1

u/asiergaldos Apr 17 '21

far-left policy?

https://www.economist.com/leaders/2021/04/10/design-bias-is-harmful-and-in-some-cases-may-be-lethal

"This means including women and non-white individuals in design teams. Eliminating design bias is not just about equality or doing the right thing, although all of these are important. It is also about creating products that meet the needs of women and the vast, non-white majority of the world’s population. It is one of those welcome areas where the best path is not just the right one, but often the profitable one, too. "

1

u/Michaelmrose Apr 20 '21 edited Apr 22 '21

Edit: it's clear that this wasn't represented fairly from the start.

0

u/zackteo Apr 13 '21

Was surprised to see such a post in r/Clojure. But glad to see that the responses are generally quite kind and informative :)

14

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

It's so pretentious to assume that OP needs to be "informed". This disagreement is not caused by a lack of information on the OP's side.

2

u/RollinDeepWithData Apr 14 '21

The disagreement is absolutely cause by a lack of understanding on the OPs side. Ignoring all the misunderstanding of social issues, he clearly doesn’t understand the process for this either. These quotas are only being applied to the nominees for the board, not the structure of the board itself.

4

u/Krackor Apr 14 '21

If you actually cared to learn about the criticisms you might find that they are better informed them you think. Assuming ignorance and bad faith from people who disagree with you is no way to go through life.

3

u/RollinDeepWithData Apr 14 '21

Oh hey you’re ignoring that the OP literally didn’t understand the process here, everything else aside again.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[deleted]

4

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

blind

I would happily support a blinded, objective, merit-based system if we had one! That's how we hire at Latacora, for example.

How do you propose we make the selection blind? For concert musicians, the answer is easy: we now put them behind a screen and make them take their shoes off, and somehow that improved the diversity of orchestras.

For this position, experience and merit is important -- so how do we make it "blind"?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[deleted]

4

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Same goes for orchestra musicians. Nobody making the hiring decisions thought they were racist, and yet, diversity increased when we made musicians try out behind a screen and with their shoes off.

2

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

If diversity had decreased instead would you still support blind auditions?

1

u/lvh Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Sure? I think it's unlikely that will happen because every time we try it seems to go up. This isn't even a hypothetical: at my company, we hire using a work sample test process with an objective scoring rubric. Fortunately there, like with concert musicians, there's room for an objective standard to test to. I don't know a way to do that for these board positions.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 18 '21

That is indeed how I see it: Hire the most qualified people, and don't be racist/sexist/whateverist.

7

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

> but you can't do that at the expense of hiring less qualified people just to have diversity.

Can you show me the part of the bylaw that does that? Because what it says is "for finding nominees" and "reasonable efforts", not "fire elected white dudes until you have the right ratio".

4

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Your “...” cuts out the part of that sentence that restricts it to nominations.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

I suggest we stick to the text and not try to guess the motives of the author, especially when one of the participants in the conversation is one of the authors.

3

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

The artificial constraints only kick in at a ~2x underrepresentation, and, as pointed out before: this is only for nominees. If the non-white-dude nominees really were all to be terrible and only there because of "diversity hire" rules, the membership can simply not vote for them.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

Again, this rule affects nominees, not board positions. There are 12 candidates, and only 4 positions open. To use your analogy: this says you have to have actually consider the alternatives and decide against them, and not just decide that you have picked the best tool (because of course we are all perfect rational actors with perfect information, not subject to subjective biases), pat yourself on the back and call it day. This makes sure there is breadth of choice across dimensions voting members have indicated they care about.

Are you a member? If you are unhappy, I will give you a refund. If you are not a member, then I will go back to working for the membership, doing what I want with my unpaid time, and spend significant amounts of money (my company is the largest sponsor currently, tied with Roam) on funding open source Clojure work that benefits everyone. All the while occasionally being called a "metastasizing cancer" by the Internet :)

2

u/darth_zidious Apr 19 '21

Hey, let's be fair.

I did not call you (or even your work) a "metastasizing cancer", and I don't think I even used the word cancer itself.

Just because I am deeply critical and suspicious of the Postmodernist thought that inspires initiatives such as the one I am criticizing in the OP, it does not mean that I think you are a bad person (you could be, you could not be, but I tend to assume the best intentions, life is saner this way), and it does not mean that everything else you do (for the community) is called into question.

Let's keep separate things separate. My criticism with the OP is about a very specific thing. Important yes, in my opinion anyway, but specific.

2

u/donald-ball Apr 14 '21

“less qualified”