r/ClevelandGuardians • • 17d ago

Last attempt of a guardian themed character hat logo for the team.

Post image
0 Upvotes

just took what some of you were saying before and expanded on it.


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Dec 01 '24

Discussion Bluesky

1 Upvotes

Anyone on guards twitter transition to Bluesky or at least post on there occasionally?

Trying to switch from twitter/x, slowly but surely


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Mar 06 '24

Discussion The Dolans aren't bad owners

0 Upvotes

I don't understand all of the hate that the Dolans get...sure, there have been some bad moments ("enjoy him" comes to mind pretty immediately). But largely they have:

  1. Hired great people (Shapiro, Antonetti, Francona) and let them do their jobs.

  2. Been aggressive in the international signing market (by far the best ROI and a big reason why our farm system is churning out contributors year after year).

  3. Provided the assets needed to take a swing when it made sense (Swisher/Bourn, Andrew Miller, Edwin Encarnacion - hell, even Josh Bell/Mike Zunino looked reasonable after the 2022 that we had).

  4. Avoided arbitration almost entirely - no one wants to go through that with a player that you're trying to keep.

And the team that they have owned has:

  1. Been a model of consistency and stability.

  2. Developed great young players year after year.

  3. Made some savvy trades to take advantage of higher-spending teams in desperate situations.

  4. Won the 4th most games in the majors since 2013, despite consistently being bottom-5 (or in the bottom half, at best) in team payroll. (and seriously, the other low-spending teams are also at the bottom of the standings in that time period, outside of Tampa).

Look...Cleveland isn't New York or Los Angeles. And the MLB payroll structure and cash flow is absolutely fucked and almost twice as dependent on local TV/media as any other sport. We're consistently in the bottom half of attendance (which accounts for ~40% of team revenue when you include parking/concessions), have a terrible TV deal (~23% of team revenue - and in the bottom 7 of the league). Maybe things will pick up if the league ever handles our TV deal (this had an impact for the Dbacks last year). And despite this local dependence, the Dolans have remained steadfast that they won't move the team to a bigger market. And they have continuously fielded competitive teams even with these limited resources.

If there was a salary floor, a more even cash flow of revenues (less local dependence) and more incentive for teams to retain their homegrown players, we'd be looking at some of the best owners in the game. IMO it's more of a league issue than it is an owner issue.

All of the "sell the team" talk just seems like bitter fans who never want to lose any player or want to overpay for free agents (when this is usually the worst ROI that you can get - and there are hundreds of examples of these free agent deals aging terribly). Would you rather sign/draft a bunch of toolsy middle infielders and hope that you can develop them into contributors, or pay Carlos Correa $200M guaranteed? Would you rather draft/sign and develop Chase DeLauter, George Valera, Steven Kwan, etc., or pay Brandon Nimmo $162M? Would you rather churn out stud pitchers year after year, or pay the near-40 year old Verlander/Scherzer duo over $200M combined and owe them each a ton of money when you aren't competitive and trade both away mid-season? The Yankees are paying Giancarlo Stanton another $118M over the next 4 seasons - is that what people want us to do?

They aren't perfect, but I think that we have better owners than most people realize. Most low-spending teams (and probably quite a few high-spending ones) would love to be in our situation year after year, and ownership certainly plays a role in that. Would love to hear why I'm wrong though!


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jan 18 '22

Talked with Cleveland Fans in the Bronx about the new name! What do the Cleveland fans think?

0 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Mar 30 '26

Discussion Ok so I gave it a shot for nearly 5 years. But this logo ain't it...

Post image
1 Upvotes

I love the newer C logo. I've come around on the name, Guardians. But 4-5 years has to be enough time to change this abomination right?


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jan 27 '25

Discussion For those just joining Bluesky, you can add feeds to your Home. There is a fairly good Guards feed already up. It has all the posts and news about the Guards you need. All you have to do is tap the # on the home screen, search for the feed you want, tap the feed and click the pin to add it to home.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Nov 09 '23

Discussion Any chance the Guardians double their payroll and sign Ohtani?

0 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Nov 10 '19

The fact that the Browns get more love than the Tribe in this city is sickening.

0 Upvotes

Love that is entirely unfounded. I don’t understand the loyalty to such trash.


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jul 17 '25

Is Jose’s team friendly contract impeding a Kwan extension?

1 Upvotes

We all agree - Jose is the GOAT. But has his “team friendly” contract created a ceiling that is keeping this team from paying market price for other players, Kwan included?

:::sponsored post by The Dolans:::


r/ClevelandGuardians • • May 11 '25

Discussion I thought the point of paying for Guardians TV was that every game would be available?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jan 25 '19

I'm going to keep a list of all the free agent opportunities that Mike Chernoff and the rest of the Tribe Front Office have blown so far this offseason, just for future reference.

0 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Feb 17 '26

Twitter/X ban discussion

0 Upvotes

First and foremost, this is not a political discussion.

I’d like to propose a Twitter/X ban discussion. This off season this place has been a ghost town and not as busy during the actual season as years past in my opinion.

I have seen so many interesting Guardians Photos/videos/stories on X that I wouldn’t be able to post and they get automatically deleted.I could screenshot them but I don’t feel like doing that. This is purely a Sports conversation and not a political one.

Maybe I’m way off in my thinking in this. Would anyone be up for a ban reconsideration post?


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jun 29 '25

Booooooooooooooooo If Paul Dolan Cares...

0 Upvotes

TW: Extreme Doomerism

It's extremely bold to assume that Paul Dolan actually gives a single fuck about this team beyond counting his money after we get suckered into caring and buying tickets and merch and all that.

But okay. Let's assume for the sake of an argument/discussion that there is a man somewhere inside there that actually gives a fuck about this team.

Then I think it's time to move the fuck on from Chris and Mike.

I am no longer moved by their ability to simply keep things competitive. I am no longer moved by the status quo being to hope to win about 80 games and pray.

It was a really, really interesting experiment to see if doing enough to just be competitive every year is enough to get you over the hump.

But we have officially been set back by these guys.

It is inexcusable to have a season like last year, make the ALCS and get by all possible metrics WORSE. Not when your core was as young as that team. Not when it was obvious you need to build on it and strike now.

Stuffing player options for the future and dragging your feet on call ups when you need to fight NOW to correct your season, to not waste another year of Kwan and the lifeline Jose Ramirez gifted you (GOD what would this team look like without him?)

This organizations pitching factory is dead. The defense first contact heavy approach apparently is dead.

Press press and press some more is the mantra.

These dudes cannot and have not been able to develop hitters for about a decade now. Steven Kwan looks like an accident you stumbled into.

Nevermind the good graces we once gave them for their trading ability and finding diamonds in the rough.

Matthew Boyd was a saint. Hey, remember when they signed Edwin Encarnacion that one time?

Wonderful. For every one of those there's a half dozen Josh Bell's and Junior Camineros.

I am not convinced you are winning a world series with these guys at the helm.

Maybe they thrive in another system. Under a different ownership group.

If Paul Dolan has a SPINE in this team he would make the moves and shake up the house.

But I would bet he'll just hide behind them till he finally stops jumping with one foot in and one foot out the door.

Make no mistake, the grass isn't always greener. We probably would have sucked a whole lot at times if these guys weren't here.

But I mean it with all my heart and soul, I don't see it happening with these guys in charge, and I'd rather suck for 20 years if it means we win a World Series once instead of playing the fanbase for fools year in and year out.

I hate this so much dawg

End of rant. Fuck you and I'll see you tomorrow.

Edit: Edwin was signed not traded for

Edit 2: Thanks for letting me play the villain here and venting/participating in this thought experiment. It's clear a lot of us are feeling hurt rn and I wish baseball can find a way to not have problems like this that the other sports leagues in this country don't have. At the end of the day nothing is gonna change from the top down till Dolan steps aside and we're gonna keep shooting for "just enough to keep fans interested". Maybe we'll have a crazy September run or something...who knows...✌️


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Dec 17 '20

Discussion :tipi: Cleveland Majors/C Majors

8 Upvotes

Trying to come up with an alternative option besides the ones everybody has already mentioned. The Majors or C Majors would be in reference to the Rock and Roll hall of fame without sounding too basic like Rockers or Rollers. The C in the logo can be stylized as a musical symbol like this.

Spiders probably the run away favorite, but what do you think about this option? What’s your favorite potential name that you’ve heard so far?


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Feb 25 '20

Can we finally ditch the block C and rebrand to these yet???

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jan 01 '22

Happy New Year! Here are two of my "rare' Cleveland Indians hats.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Apr 22 '26

I love Hammy and Jose, but...

0 Upvotes

I'm really tired of hearing that promo every pre game and every other inning . Maybe they could drop that back to twice a game.


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Aug 21 '23

Discussion Should we trade one of our young stud arms (Bibee, Williams, Allen) for an mlb ready power bat?

1 Upvotes

This offseason, I personally think it's necessary. This team can not hit. Having 5 star pitchers is a great sounding plan, but we can not do anything if we have 0 ability to produce run support. If you could get a 30 home run guy in return for Gavin Williams, can we logically say no?


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Apr 15 '21

Discussion :tipi: Random Lindor Update

0 Upvotes

Francisco (not Frankie) Lindor is, ummm, not tearing much up in NY to start his highly paid stint there.

I get it, only 9 games, but this just brings back memories of him being truly overvalued here in Cleveland.

222/389/259

Zero HRs and one double. Yuck.

He never was, isn’t now, and never will be worth $341M sheckles. Prior to 2019, I’ll admit, I wanted the Indians to shell out and keep this guy. But now, he’s turned out to be all about the money, and not the player he once was when it seemed like it was only about the game.

I truly believe this, IF, and only if, the Indians can find a way to get Rosario comfortable in one position with regular everyday ABs, the production on the field will feel like Lindor never left.


r/ClevelandGuardians • • May 04 '25

Discussion Does anything strike you as odd about these 2 MLB notifications?

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jul 07 '25

This is depressing.....

0 Upvotes

Yainer Diaz for Myles Straw

F Lindor for Giminez (gone), Rosario (gone), Greene (????), Josh Wolf (gone)

Junior Caminero (future young star) for T Myers (gone)


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jan 27 '24

First multicolor 3d print to hang on the wall

Post image
97 Upvotes

Getting that baseball itch already. Decided to 3d print a piece to hang on the bar wall. Going to work on a Guardians one to pair with it later!


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jun 11 '26

Promotional Items

0 Upvotes

I have a major beef here. If you're wearing an opposing team jersey you should not get the promotional item for the game. I'm going to lose it Saturday when I see Detroit fans with Gavin's bobblehead. Ugh!


r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jun 27 '25

Exhausting

2 Upvotes

This is my team and all, but they are tiresome to watch. Pitching, which has been better the past month, rarely goes more than five innings. Just like last year. I know he was sick on opening day, but Bibee is supposed to be the ace? Please! Ortiz has have some of nastiest pitches in the league, but the dude is the definition of inconsistent. Every team saw what the bullpen did last year. Since it hasn’t changed much, all the teams have taken note.

The batting lineup only has two players that can hit consistently. No need to name them. We know who they are. When they slump, there’s no one to pick em up. The number 2 batter is a revolving door. When you wonder why Jose’s RBI total isn’t anywhere near what it has been, that is why. 4-9 batters probably produce the fastest 2 half innings in baseball. Nothing comes out of them. Are they allergic to hitting? How are they the only team that can consistently find a spot to hit where a defender is at? If Kwan and Ramirez have bad outings, it’s reasonable to assume they will be the victim of a no hitter sooner than later. Leave it to this lineup to make a plus 7 ERA pitcher look like an hall of famer.