r/Clemson • • Mar 12 '20

Hardly an adequate response

Online for a single week after spring break?

Look, I'm not a fan of the online-only option (I don't think students learn as much through online classes as they do in-person, but I respect that everyone learns differently) but as I safety measure, I think it's necessary.

That being said, IF our students contract COVID-19 while away on spring break, it could take them two weeks before they displayed symptoms. During this time, they're still able to pass it on to others. Why wouldn't we just be proactive and move to online-only for at least two weeks following Spring break?

Also, us moving to online for 1 week after spring break isn't really consistent with the decisions that other universities have made because most others have gone online for the remainder of the semester, extended spring break and/or implemented e-learning for at least two weeks.

I am still very displeased with how they're handling this situation. They have not been transparent with anyone throughout this process which has contributed to our confusion.

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

18

u/tharvey11 Faculty | Alumni Mar 12 '20

I agree, the best response (from a campus safety standpoint) would have been to cancel Spring Break.

-7

u/CappuccinoLuver Mar 12 '20

I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not (tone is tough to judge via written text) only because I think students would have rioted if the university canceled spring break, and others have sarcastically suggested this is a possible response.

I'm not sure if this would have made the situation better or worse. However, I do think it would have minimized the concern of students potentially returning as carriers of COVID-19.

Ultimately, I think this highlights how Clemson officials aren't prepared to handle a situation of this magnitude.

9

u/tharvey11 Faculty | Alumni Mar 12 '20

Half serious/half sarcastic (it's pretty much my default tone). If you're strictly concerned about campus safety and minimizing the spread of the virus, it would have been the best call to make (probably in addition to moving to online classes and cancelling all on campus events, guest speakers, tours, etc)

But yes, students would have thrown an even bigger fit than they already are. Extending spring break a week (with no classes) that a lot of students wanted is not a better option. All that would do it force the rest of the semester to be completed in a shorter time span, which would hurt learning outcomes more than they already will be by this situation. Students would be just as likely to contract the virus during the second week as they would the first and bring it back to campus.

The reason UofSC did that (in my faculty-member opinion) is because they have largely not planned as extensively for this eventuality as we have. (Contrary to what some students believe, all faculty members have had plans ready in case we go online for at least a week.) I've heard from colleagues in Columbia and before the announcement, hardly any faculty there had made any plans to move online. The extra week is to give them a chance to plan.

Moving to online classes post-spring break is the right call (though I wish they would have handled the transparency over the decision making process better), and I suspect they will extend it more than a week, since they clearly left that option open. I think going short and extending as needed is better than committing to a longer measure now, which may turn out to not be necessary (who knows though.)

1

u/CappuccinoLuver Mar 12 '20

I’m a graduate teacher or record, so while I don’t get all of the correspondence that faculty members do, I do get some of them. I’ve been preparing for online only course of action for at least a week, along with others graduate teaching assistants and faculty members of my department.

Also, I understand that doing a short period of time first and then extending might be better than extending for a long period of time initially. However, two things: incubation period for this virus is roughly 2 weeks, so extending online-only for 2 weeks to start would have been an ideal approach; and the administration has not been as transparent or organized with their approach as they could have been. Not only would 2 weeks have been enough time to determine if any students have symptoms (not that they’d be able to get tested since our country barely has enough available) but it would have given our university administration two weeks to become more organized in their approach to handling this situation.

I do agree that extending spring break an extra week (without classes) was never a good idea. I think that would have just increased the likelihood of exposure while away from campus + as you said, made it so that we had to complete the semester in less time.

4

u/tharvey11 Faculty | Alumni Mar 12 '20

14 days is estimated to be the 99th percentile of the incubation period. The mean incubation period is about 5 days, with ~75% of cases exhibiting symptoms within a week and ~95% of cases within 10 days. Source

Assuming students have an equally likely chance of contracting the virus every day they are gone, ~95% of students that contract the virus will be exhibiting symptoms before in-person classes are scheduled to resume. I'd imagine any student exhibiting symptoms on campus/locally will result in automatically extending the return to normal instruction.

A week (plus a weekend) should also be enough time to begin seeing if students are contracting the virus on campus/locally (not all, but some) in which case I'd imagine we'd reevaluate not just extending online classes, but closing for the remainder of the semester.

1

u/olidus Mar 12 '20

Additionally, if the situation grows worse and there are a rash of cases in the area, Clemson can always extend the online action

2

u/olidus Mar 12 '20

How are they not prepared?

9

u/winterpoet66 Mar 12 '20

The problem with the 2 week thinking is that it doesn't really matter how long the break is. You're assuming it should be 2 weeks so that more students have time to show symptoms, but all that will happen is they will have more time to contract it. No matter how long the break is someone could catch it the day before they come back to Clemson. The 2 week logic only really works if someone is infected the day they leave campus.

-3

u/CappuccinoLuver Mar 12 '20

I didn’t mean they should have extended spring break, I meant they should have done online courses for 2 weeks, following spring break, instead of one.

3

u/winterpoet66 Mar 12 '20

It has the same effect tho. The university told people to stay home during e-learning if they could.

2

u/WaterYouGonnaDew Mar 12 '20

What difference would it have made though? Students could very well have already been exposed to the virus this week, in which case the one-week closure of (physical) classes provides adequate time for sick students to get tested. If tests turn out positive (assuming anyone is tested), it’s very likely admin. will just extend its contingency plan through April.

1

u/olidus Mar 12 '20

Assuming of course, someone does get sick. I am waiting for the proposition for students to go get COVID-19 to test the administration's "unpreparedness"

28

u/tc1988 Mar 12 '20

It's a fluid situation. I don't think anyone would be surprised if it becomes 2 weeks, 3 weeks, the rest of the semester, etc. as the situation worsens in this counrty.

Clemson is simply taking a cautious approach at the moment because you can always cancel more, but you can't go back and "uncancel".

20

u/MedicalRaisin Mar 12 '20

you can always cancel more, but you can't go back and "uncancel".

I don't know why this is so hard for people to wrap their minds around.

6

u/olidus Mar 12 '20

They want drama