r/ClayBusters • • Sep 20 '22

Question/Poll

I have heard multiple representations from other members of my gun club that loading 3+ shells and shooting more than 2 thrown clays before reloading on a skeet field is “unsafe.” While it is against the rules of a skeet match, I tend to disagree with the safety argument. For clarity, all others on-field were behind the shooter, all shooters were utilizing the field to practice specific stations/shots, there were no barrel-flagging violations, no shells loaded or shots taken off-station, nor were there any other indicia of unsafe conduct. Am I mistaken in this position?

I’ve been shooting for going on 25 years and have never before heard this complaint on the practice field.

tl:dr - is there anything intrinsically unsafe about shooting clays with more than two shells in the gun?

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

16

u/Indifferentchildren Sep 20 '22

The sporting clays range where I shoot has a 2-shell safety rule. I expect that it's happened that shooters have thought that their guns were empty, when they were not. Limiting to two shells might reduce the risk of that happening?

3

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22

Valid. All members must show clear and safe before leaving the station.

10

u/otnot20 Sep 20 '22

Recently someone was doing that exact thing and put his pump in the gun rack with one still in the magazine.

0

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22

No such issues in this case. Our shooters must have an open action and show clear before leaving the station.

6

u/FearTheLorax Sep 20 '22

I think safely wise you shouldn't load more than the number of birds you're going to shoot at the station and obviously don't leave the station with a loaded gun. Beyond that I don't much see what the number of shells in the gun has to do with safety. The only argument I could kinda see is if your accidently load more shells than you decide to shoot when practicing and then you have to manipulate a loaded gun to unload it. As far as practicing though if your watch any videos from professional shooters they all stress the importance of a preshot routine. I think packing your gun with 5 shells would give it a totally different balance than it would have in competition and the preshot routine couldn't be the same either.

1

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22

That was the case here. 3 birds, 3 shells.

2

u/FearTheLorax Sep 20 '22

Sounds safe to me.

5

u/Full-Professional246 Sep 20 '22

The short answer is no.

I have shot several 3-bird events. There you have to load 3 shells.

Custom is why we limit to 2-shells. It matches up with the rules of the typical target games.

There is an argument about expectation of only 2 shells loaded but that is mitigated with proper gun handling. This is something that should be done anyway in my opinion. If shooters are diligent with open actions outside the shooting stand/position, there is no risk.

2

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22

Thank you. This was my gut reaction to the conduct complained of. The shooter in question is as experienced, if not more so, than I. I am trying to ensure my take is not flawed, or that I am missing some fundamental safety rule in this circumstance.

For additional context, it is my opinion that this “violation” was pretextual to penalize the shooter. In the 15+ years that I have been a member, I have seen this done frequently and to my knowledge it has never been an issue.

1

u/guitarock Sep 28 '22

But what is the reasoning behind allowing it? It’s a potential safety issue because others expect you to only have 2 shells. No reason besides laziness not to limit it to 2 at a time

1

u/Full-Professional246 Sep 28 '22

But what is the reasoning behind allowing it?

That is not the question. The question is whether there is an inherent SAFETY issue. And as I pointed out - there is not an INHERENT safety issue.

It’s a potential safety issue because others expect you to only have 2 shells.

This is only an issue if you violate other far more important rules - such as open actions outside the shooting stand, unsafe barrel locations, loading gun outside shooting stand, etc.

Anyone who relies on the 'he shot 2 shells' for safety is not a safe shooter.

And yes - I have seen a shooter hit a true pair with one shot and proceed to try to walk out of the stand with a loaded gun.

No reason besides laziness not to limit it to 2 at a time

I would say there is no reason to make this limit without cause. Tournaments make sense because of the explicit rules in each shooting organization. Even then, I have shot 3 bird events which REQUIRE loading more than 2 shells. But just shooting clays casually for fun lacks those rules.

We need to be more inclusive and less judgemental for things that don't truly impact safety. This is one of those cases in my mind where you are creating rules merely to create rules.

If you want to change my mind, please explain exactly how this is a truly a safety issue when following every other rule for safe gun handling.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Full-Professional246 Sep 29 '22 edited Sep 29 '22

Here’s the thing; we want as many layers of safety as possible. I’m as much of a zealot as anyone of the basic safety rules, but I acknowledge that people make mistakes.

Sure. But ask yourself this. Does this rule actually generate any safety?

I don't think it really does.

There’s a reason everyone on our ranges must walk around with double guns broken and semi actions facing outward.

Yes - because those rules are the foundational safe gun handling rules. Each one of them has a measureable and definite benefit.

Of course, if everyone always follows the other safety rules this would never be required, but we have to acknowledge people will sometimes slip up. Would you argue these rules are superfluous too?

No but they are not the same type of rule.

A person is already loading shells into the shotgun. It could be one or two. What is really the difference between 2 and 3? It is equally as likely a person could load 2 shells and shoot only once right?

That is your problem. This rule isn't really about safety.

If you had the rule to load the shells only for the targets you plan to shoot - it would make sense. Of course you can always plan to shoot more targets and for whatever reason not be able to and still end up with a loaded gun - even with just 2 shells.

So again. Please detail exactly WHY the 3rd shell is unsafe but 2 shells is not.

If you want people to follow rules, you should be able to detail EXACTLY why this is needed. I can explain the reasons behind the safe gun handling rules. I can explain the reasons for shot size limitations. I can even explain why some ranges have to prohibit steel shot (ricochet potential) or lead shot (environmental hazard). I can even explain why ranges don't allow home defense barrels on clays fields (to easy to swing in unsafe directions in shooting stands).

What I cannot do is explain why 2 shells is the limit by rule when I could very easily set an event, on the exact same course as a 3-bird shoot and require shooters to load 3 shells to compete.

I would add, if your basis is 'expectation' or 'assumption' by others, you are on shaky grounds. I mean we have open actions so we don't have to assume the gun is unloaded, we know the bolt is not closed on anything. We don't assume guns are empty and let people point barrels anywhere. We assume the gun may be loaded so the barrel is always in a safe direction.

When you try to impose too many rules - especially those without basis, people start ignoring them. The problem here is, those people may ignore rules that have a solid basis too.

2

u/alkinsey Sep 20 '22

I would say the rule is there for the most common scenario. Most shooters are only throwing 2 clays and you should only load the same number of shells as you shoot. As long as you adhere to the latter part of that statement I don't see too much of an issue. Proper gun safety would still need to apply but rules can't be made for every scenario so I tend to look at the principle of the rules.

2

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22

In this case it has never been enforced and was now utilized in an attempt to expel one of our members.

2

u/alkinsey Sep 21 '22

Yeah that's a huge overreaction.

1

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 21 '22

That was my thought as well but needed a gut check from others in the community

2

u/zluta Sep 20 '22

What makes it a practice field? Because you’re shooting on it? If you want to mess around, go out to the back 40 with a hand thrower, not a gun club with rules. 2 shells in the gun at a time for skeet and sporting clays, 1 for trap.

2

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22 edited Sep 20 '22

By practice field, I mean not a match. Our members primarily use our fields to train up for hunting season, not for competition. To my knowledge, only 4-5 members actually compete. To reiterate, this has been a fairly regular practice and, in my 15+ years as a member, has never been complained of before now.

Edit: I’m a board member of the club in question and trying to ascertain whether this merits the reaction it received from another board member who claims that this is solely a safety issue. I would not want to take punitive action against a member for otherwise safe conduct.

4

u/otnot20 Sep 20 '22

I’m also a board member of a club and all this warrants is a reminder to only load two shells.

2

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22

Makes sense. In my experience, as a general member and as a director/officer, no such rule has been in place.

1

u/zluta Sep 21 '22

It’s more of a common sense safety rule while at an establishment. While you may feel confident and competent to load 3 or 4 shells in and mess around, someone else new to shooting may see that and think it’s the way things are at clubs. Before you know it, they are walking around the parking lot unknowingly loaded because they aren’t familiar with the weapon. Like I said, out on the back 40 anything goes. Clubs are supposed to have rules for a reason.

1

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 21 '22

We’re strict about unloading, opening the action, and showing clear before leaving each station. There’s a fairly intensive safety briefing for new shooters and new members. All fields are monitored for compliance. I typically shoot at least one round with new people to make sure they’re following our protocols. This particular instance involved an experienced shooter who followed all of the above. I’m trying to get a sense of whether this other board member is overreacting. They used the multiple shell issue to try and expel a member of 15 years.

Edit: Or whether I am under-reacting

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22

I have the trap range to myself from time to time and i was told to only load one at a time even if it's just me and I'm not changing stations or anything. Rules are rules i don't argue with the range marshals. But is it in actuality less safe? Of course not.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22

Only for doubles can you load two at my club. You'll get a stern talking to if you load more than 1 on singles.

I did not learn this the hard way, but a few buddies sure did.

1

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 20 '22

Understood. My question is why doing so is problematic. Thus far, and having posed that question to the complainant, all I’ve received is a vague response claiming only that it’s unsafe.

My job is to ensure that our shooters are safe, but also are able to have fun and train in a reasonable manner. I suspect the complaint arose from personal issues with the shooter in question and is pre-textual in nature. If I’m going to recommend a course of action, I need to be sure I am adequately knowledgeable on the subject.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22

Well, maybe for peace of mind, I've been flagged by some of the old guys more times than I want to admit, finger on the trigger, action closed.

All it takes is one incident where the gun goes off to change the rules.

1

u/Technical-Clothes237 Sep 21 '22

Very true. I’ve shot with this person for 15 years and never had any concerns about him endangering others. My point in posing his question is to get other’s opinions so I can better assess the scenario and make a balanced determination without unnecessarily infringing on membership rights. In this case there were no other indicia of unsafe conduct, just the three shells in the firearm.

3

u/Giant_117 Sep 20 '22

Do I think it's unsafe? Not really. Do I understand why it's done? Yup.

Remember, safety rules are created to cover the lowest common denominator.

3

u/Wolfman87 Sep 23 '22

There's nothing intrinsically unsafe about it. The thing with shooting clubs and competitions is that there will be a lot of armed people around. It makes sense to have redundant or superfluous safety measures in place. It only takes one idiot.

2

u/richg99 Sep 20 '22

If there are no rules on the books that say "Only Two Shells"...then the "offender" is only breaking precedent, not rules.

That shouldn't be a cause to remove/penalize his membership...it should be a cause to amend the rules if "Two Shells" are the norm for your group.

The complaining member should be talking to the board about a change, not to the member with the three shells. IMHO.

1

u/TC-abcd Sep 20 '22

My trap club requires maximum number of shells to 1 unless you’re shooting doubles.

And doubles has to be set up by the trap help, so they know who is and is not shooting doubles.