r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/TheGentleDominant • Oct 19 '22
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/bborother • Mar 24 '22
Meme Leftists don't tolerate intolerance
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/[deleted] • Feb 13 '21
Discussion/Question I'm confused
I'm a right libritarian and I don't really understand what's happening here. To me this seems like you basic woke left sub that just trashes outher people's ideas without presenting it's own.
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/Ok-Mastodon2016 • Jul 04 '22
Meme It's crazy how the war in Ukraine showed the real face of some left movements, even defending NATO nowadays...
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/Elbrujosalvaje • Jul 31 '22
Discussion/Question When self-described "anarchists" mobilize the institutional power of the state to deplatform, cancel or censor opponents, are they not conferring legitimacy on the state itself as guarantor of the right to freedom of speech?
This post is a classic example of the phenomenon I'm referring to:
Here we have "classical libertarians" using institutional authority, i.e. for profit corporations and the NZ government's designation of a certain group as "terrorist," to deplatform, cancel or censor Jordan Peterson. Regardless of what the man thinks, it's difficult to see how this call for censorship is justifiable from a classical libertarian perspective.
A further question:
Shouldn't classical libertarians be opposed to deplatforming, cancelling or censoring opponents because it establishes a hierarchy of individuals based on different degrees of wrong-think and right-think?
Why or why not? Please cite classical libertarian sources.
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/TheGentleDominant • Sep 14 '21
Meme She’s playing her role in the political system.
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/saturday_lunch • Jan 21 '21
Educational/Information What do y'all think of Ayn Rand's work?
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/BluSentry • Jul 30 '21
Discussion/Question Any Criticisms or Corrections Anyone Would Like To Share?
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/Empty-Nebula-646 • Nov 21 '24
Discussion/Question Left wing populism
So we have seen a lot of left wing populism in the last couple of years, with Bernie in 2016 serving as a good starting point.
I personally feel left wing populism sucks the revolutionary spirt put of a movement and turn it into reformist dribble.
However I was wondering yalls take on it
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/dnm314 • Oct 16 '20
Discussion/Question Voting Is Not Harm Reduction
"When proclamations are made that “voting is harm reduction,” it’s never clear how less harm is actually calculated. Do we compare how many millions of undocumented Indigenous Peoples have been deported? Do we add up what political party conducted more drone strikes? Or who had the highest military budget? Do we factor in pipelines, mines, dams, sacred sites desecration? Do we balance incarceration rates? Do we compare sexual violence statistics? Is it in the massive budgets of politicians who spend hundreds of millions of dollars competing for votes?
Though there are some political distinctions between the two prominent parties in the so-called U.S., they all pledge their allegiance to the same flag. Red or blue, they’re both still stripes on a rag waving over stolen lands that comprise a country built by stolen lives.
We don’t dismiss the reality that, on the scale of U.S. settler colonial violence, even the slightest degree of harm can mean life or death for those most vulnerable. What we assert here is that the entire notion of “voting as harm reduction” obscures and perpetuates settler-colonial violence, there is nothing “less harmful” about it, and there are more effective ways to intervene in its violences.
At some point the left in the so-called U.S. realized that convincing people to rally behind a “lesser evil” was a losing strategy. The term “harm reduction” was appropriated to reframe efforts to justify their participation and coerce others to engage in the theater of what is called “democracy” in the U.S.
Harm reduction was established in the 1980s as a public health strategy for people dealing with substance use issues who struggle with abstinence. According to the Harm Reduction Coalition (HRC) the principles of harm reduction establish that the identified behavior is “part of life” so they “choose not to ignore or condemn but to minimize harmful effects” and work towards breaking social stigmas towards “safer use.” The HRC also states that, “there is no universal definition of or formula for implementing harm reduction.” Overall, harm reduction focuses on reducing adverse impacts associated with harmful behaviors.
The proposition of “harm reduction” in the context of voting means something entirely different from those organizing to address substance use issues. The assertion is that “since this political system isn’t going away, we’ll support politicians and laws that may do less harm.”
The idea of a ballot being capable of reducing the harm in a system rooted in colonial domination and exploitation, white supremacy, hetero-patriarchy, and capitalism is an extraordinary exaggeration. There is no person whose lives aren’t impacted everyday by these systems of oppression, but instead of coded reformism and coercive “get out the vote” campaigns towards a “safer” form of settler colonialism, we’re asking “what is the real and tragic harm and danger associated with perpetuating colonial power and what can be done to end it?”
Voting as practiced under U.S. “democracy” is the process with which people (excluding youth under the age of 18, convicted felons, those the state deems “mentally incompetent,” and undocumented folx including permanent legal residents), are coerced to choose narrowly prescribed rules and rulers. The anarchist collective Crimethinc observes, “Voting consolidates the power of a whole society in the hands of a few politicians.” When this process is conducted under colonial authority, there is no option but political death for Indigenous Peoples. In other words, voting can never be a survival strategy under colonial rule. It’s a strategy of defeat and victimhood that protracts the suffering and historical harm induced by ongoing settler colonialism. And while the harm reduction sentiment may be sincere, even hard won marginal reforms gained through popular support can be just as easily reversed by the stroke of a politician’s pen. If voting is the democratic participation in our own oppression, voting as harm reduction is a politics that keeps us at the mercy of our oppressors.
While so many on the left–including some Indigenous radicals–are concerned with consolidation of power into fascists hands, they fail to recognize how colonial power is already consolidated. There is nothing intersectional about participating in and maintaining a genocidal political system. There’s no meaningful solidarity to be found in a politics that urges us to meet our oppressors where they’re at. Voting as harm reduction imposes a false solidarity upon those identified to be most vulnerable to harmful political policies and actions. In practice it plays out as paternalistic identity politicking as liberals work to identify the least dangerous candidates and rally to support their campaigns. The logic of voting as harm reduction asserts that whoever is facing the most harm will gain the most protection by the least dangerous denominator in a violently authoritarian system. This settler-colonial naivety places more people, non-human beings, and land at risk then otherwise. Most typically the same liberal activists that claim voting is harm reduction are found denouncing and attempting to suppress militant direct actions and sabotage as acts that “only harm our movement.” “Voting as harm reduction” is the pacifying language of those who police movements.
Voting as harm reduction is the government issued blanket of the democratic party, we’re either going to sleep or die in it.
To organize from a position that voting is an act of damage limitation blurs lines of the harm that settler and resource colonialism imposes.
Under colonial occupation all power operates through violence. There is absolutely nothing “less harmful” about participating in and perpetuating the political power of occupying forces. Voting won’t undue settler colonialism, white supremacy, hetero-patriarchy, or capitalism. Voting is not a strategy for decolonization. The entire process that arrived at the “Native vote” was an imposition of U.S. political identity on Indigenous Peoples fueled by white supremacy and facilitated by capitalism."
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/[deleted] • Jan 01 '22
video r/ChildFree: What is "Baby Trapping"?
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/[deleted] • Aug 31 '22
Discussion/Question Do you consider agorism a left-wing ideology?
self.ideologypollsr/ClassicalLibertarians • u/[deleted] • Jun 07 '22
Discussion/Question A potential work around to the problem of externalities in an anarchist environment
This is a followup to my previous post here about externalities. I did some more thinking
So I used to be very pro pigouvian taxes but I have somewhat soured on them for a couple reasons.
it's hard to determine the total social cost of production for many of the same reasons it is hard to centrally plan an economy
it's possible the tax will have to be very high to encompass the total social cost of production and this can lead people to black market goods. We see this all the time today
So that leaves me with an important question. How do we properly price in negative externalities into the price we pay?
And the only real answer I could come up with is Coasian bargaining. However that too has limitations, namely the existence of market power and transaction costs.
However, that got me thinking. In today's digital world, transaction costs are at an all time low. Everything and everyone is connected and a few clicks away. So that leaves the issue of market power. If I am a simple homeowner, I don't own that much land, just my yard and the ground under my house right? But what if, instead of just owning that, me and my whole community, as well as other communities along a river or a lake or whatever environmental thing we wanna protect collectively owned it. Each community member has an individual share and 1 vote in management. Different collectives could be run differently, some with appointed representatives, others with direct democracy, etc. This would enable the collective owners of a river of lake or whatever to bargain as a group, and help negate market power of bigger firms. Is it 100% effective? No. The real world is complicated. However, this does help facilitate as close as we can get to coasian bargaining and thus a much more efficient distribution.
Plus, this dramatically simplifies payment and reduces transaction costs. Are they 0? No. But close as we can get in the real world. Payment can be distributed to members directly or collectively managed and put towards solving the issue (so, like if a factory polluted a river, payment could he directed towards building filtration systems, or helping pay for Healthcare associated with the pollution for everyone along the river, etc).
Would something like this be viable in the 21st century? Why/why not?
Black marketers and others would be violating the rights of this collective by polluting and community members directly would have an incentive to oppose this, as opposed to the pigouvian tax case.
This isn't a perfect solution and it doesn't really work for something like air pollution (that will probably have to be negotiated by a national government, but that's still not enough, cause believe it or not, air moves between countries. Maybe a global body would have to exist and that's somewhat difficult to see happening anytime soon. So I am not really sure what to do there).
What's your take?
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/Elbrujosalvaje • Jul 24 '22
Discussion/Question Does thinking in terms of "left" and "right" make any sense from an anarchist perspective?
How can anarchists see themselves as "left" when the rest of the so-called Left (left with a capital "L") is entirely authoritarian statist and collectivist? Non-leftist libertarians range from mild to moderate authoritarian statist and collectivist, i.e. social welfare left-liberalism to heavily authoritarian statist and collectivist, i.e. Marxist-Leninist. It doesn't make sense to associate anarchism, a fundamentally libertarian ideology that rejects the state, with authoritarian statist, collectivist leftism, which is the antithesis of libertarianism.
The left-right political dichotomy becomes even more problematic when we consider the fact there are right-leaning "libertarians" who embrace freedom, liberty, individualism, personal autonomy and self-determination way more than the so-called Left; or when traditionally leftist parties are more conservative (i.e. classically liberal) than traditionally right-wing parties. It just seems that the current left-right divide is so messy it doesn't adequately map onto a simple left-right political spectrum.
It looks like a new political spectrum is needed to adequately make sense of the messiness of the contemporary left-right divide. But so far, whatever one wants to say about the authoritarian statist and collectivist Left and the authoritarian statist Right (which includes ancap and other right-leaning "libertarians" because they want private states), anarchism is an ideology that stands apart as its own distinctive belief-system that transcends the left-right divide.
For the new divide, I tentatively suggest two spectrums:
anarchism--->authoritarian statism (the traditional Right) --->authoritarian statist collectivism (the traditional Left)
anarchism--->authoritarianism--->authoritarian statism + statist collectivism
OR
classical libertarianism--->authoritarianism--->authoritarian statism + statist collectivism
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/Brotherly-Moment • Jun 15 '21
Educational/Information Meet your new landlord: Wall Street
self.stupidpolr/ClassicalLibertarians • u/_neatpicking • Aug 23 '24
Direct Action/Mutual Aid If you REALLY want to win "The Revolution", we need to be building our own decentralized WeChat NOW!
galleryr/ClassicalLibertarians • u/prince-matthew • Jul 04 '22
Discussion/Question What is your opinion of NATO?
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/MahknoWearingADress • Aug 09 '21
News A New Sub - r/DankLeftHistoryMemes - Has Just Dropped
Hello and welcome one and all to r/DankLeftHistoryMemes!
This sub was designed to be a fusion of both r/DankLeft and r/HistoryMemes so that people of all ideological persuasions can come learn about history through a leftist lens of analysis (maybe with a sprinkle of dialetical materialism, too).
Unlike other leftist subreddits, this is not designed to be a "circle-jerk". Instead, this is a place for both leftists and non-leftists alike to congregate without fear of judgment or ridicule.
We do, however, operate under the banner of "tactical leftist cooperation" instead of the more common "left unity" (See rule 13). As such, ideologies like Maoism, Marxism-Lenninism-Maoism, Stalinism, Hoxhaism, Dengism, and Posadism, are not welcome (See rule 13.1).
Marxism-Lenninists, however, are more than welcome to participate.
Here are two examples of the content you might see in this sub:
Hope to see you there!
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/roarde • Dec 21 '21
News ATTENTION! I am calling for a GENERAL STRIKE to occur on DECEMBER 25th. Don't go to work or school. Stay home with family and friends!! If it works out, let's do another one JANUARY 1st. OK. That is all. Ponies. #generalSTRIKE #December25th #D25 • Vermin Supreme (TM) on Twitter
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/Foundation1914 • Dec 12 '20
Discussion/Question So this isn't an anti-authoritarian sub? This is an anti-right wing jerkfest?
This is actually disappointing. Theres no actual anarchist discussion or theory here, y'all just like to talk about how capitalism sucks dick and shitpost about ancaps?
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/bborother • Mar 21 '22
Meme Contemporary Western Tankie Sophistry
r/ClassicalLibertarians • u/JustHereForCuteness • Apr 21 '21