r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 20 '26

America Isn’t an Oligarchy

Thumbnail
thefp.com
0 Upvotes

From Tyler Cowen writing in the Free Press:

Is America ruled by an oligarchy—that is, a small group of tightly knit, self-serving, and very wealthy people?...

Let’s look at the facts. First, in people’s daily lives, they typically interact with their state and local governments more than with the feds. And if you look at what state and local governments do, most of it is driven by voter demand, and I do not mean billionaire or oligarchic voters.

Most state and local government spending goes toward schools, roads, and increasingly, Medicaid. None of those reflect the agendas of most billionaires. For example, Medicaid dollars flow particularly to lower-income recipients. Hospitals and doctors receive income from this program, but reimbursement rates are relatively low, and many of the best doctors do not accept Medicaid patients and don’t make a living from the program.

Now look at the federal budget. The major components of spending are Medicare, Social Security, Medicaid (joined with the states), defense, and interest on the national debt. Those programs are a mix of popular and necessary, and they were not put in place, and are not kept in place, by billionaires or oligarchs...

[A] large number of policies and regulations are obscure, difficult to understand, and affect relatively small numbers of Americans. In those cases, special interests very often get their way. Voters may vaguely sense that something is wrong or that they are being screwed over, but they have no obvious recourse...

Teachers fight for the rights of teachers’ unions, plumbers may support occupational licensing to limit competitors, and doctors may not wish to have the law allow nurse practitioners to take over many of their duties. It is hard to build new homes in cities such as San Francisco, mostly because current homeowners do not want them to be built. Sometimes special-interest groups include billionaires, but very often they do not, or they involve billionaires only to a small degree...

It is fair to say that the affluent have an advantage in American politics, as indeed they do in virtually everything, and that the poor stand at some disadvantage. The reality is that different income classes, at least within each party, largely agree about politics, even if the two parties have very different visions of where America should be headed...

It is also correct to suggest that President Trump, who is a billionaire, conducts some of his administration’s policies to enrich himself and his friends, including through the corrupt mechanism of selling a family-linked cryptocurrency to those who seek influence. That is a bad way to run the country, but do not confuse it with the hypothesis that oligarchs run the entire government or set most of its policies.

Most policies are still determined either by voter desires or by traditional special-interest groups, for better or worse. Resenting the very wealthy or imagining that they have created a special “oligarch” class is just another way of running away from our very real problems.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 27 '26

Article Calling People Bigots is Zero-Sum Thinking

Thumbnail
decentered.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Apr 06 '26

Classical Liberal I would’ve voted against the 1964 Civil Rights Act because of Article II

0 Upvotes

I would’ve voted against the Civil Rights Act, specifically because Title II is such a egregious violation of a individual’s property rights. State enforced Segregation and Federally enforced Integration break the same set of property rights, just differently.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • 6d ago

Discussion Individuals should be free to immigrate and seek employment across national borders without government-imposed numerical limits.

8 Upvotes

If classical liberalism holds that government should not unnecessarily interfere with voluntary association and economic exchange, what principles justify restricting those freedoms are national borders?

236 votes, 4d ago
107 Strongly Agree
54 Agree
35 Disagree
40 Strongly Disagree

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • 25d ago

The Net Present Value of the California Billionaire Tax Act ("permanently lost income tax collections from departures more than offsets the one-time wealth tax revenue, yielding a [negative] net present value")

Thumbnail
nber.org
2 Upvotes

This paper examines the revenue and migration impact of the 2026 California Billionaire Tax Act, a one-time 5 percent tax on the worldwide net worth of individuals exceeding $1 billion...The present value of permanently lost income tax collections from departures more than offsets the one-time wealth tax revenue, yielding a net present value of negative $38.9 billion. Across 100,000 simulated revenue and discount rate combinations, 85 percent of plausible outcomes produce a negative net present value of state revenues.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 09 '26

There’s Nothing Democratic About These Socialists (nearly half of the DSA’s highest leadership body "openly identify as communists")

6 Upvotes

From The Atlantic:

It’s true that the DSA [Democratic Socialists of America] has areas of ideological overlap with the Democratic Party, and would at least directionally support classic Democratic policies such as a higher minimum wage, defending social spending, and opposing the Trump administration. But the DSA’s version of democratic socialism goes far beyond routine public functions such as garbage collection and Social Security (which most Republicans, not to mention Democrats, support), or even aspirational policies such as Medicare for All...

The DSA has become...more illiberal, and more dogmatic...

A decade ago, the excitement generated by the Bernie Sanders presidential campaign on the left and the frightening rise of Donald Trump spurred an influx of tens of thousands of young members. Some of the new recruits were Marxist-Leninist organizers who saw the DSA’s growing membership as fertile ground.

Sectarian conflict broke out among rival factions vying to steer the group’s suddenly growing membership. In 2018, some of the DSA’s older activists formed the North Star caucus, an internal group to defend...antiauthoritarian principles from its newer authoritarian-minded entrants...

The DSA’s Red Star caucus was formed the year after the North Star caucus, in an apparent rebuke. It writes [in 2024] that nearly half of the members of the National Political Committee, the DSA’s highest leadership body, “openly identify as communists”....These left-wing factions have realigned the organization in firm opposition to liberal democracy...

What the DSA demands of the Democrats is not merely to advocate more generous social policies, or more cautious foreign affairs, but to welcome, or at least accept, authoritarians as their coalition partners. Democrats are likely to face the same kind of pressure that Republicans confronted with MAGA’s hostile takeover: first to ignore their allies’ sinister goals, and then to rationalize and eventually justify them.

As authoritarian elements gain strength, they become more essential to the success of a political coalition, and the price of confronting them rises. The Republican Party has long since passed the point of no return. The easiest time to draw clear moral lines against the encroachment of illiberalism within one’s own camp is at the beginning.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jun 04 '26

Article How to fight back against Gen-Z socialism

Thumbnail economist.com
6 Upvotes

The first step is for free-market liberals to stop apologising. A series of popular criticisms of capitalism, each containing a grain of truth, has in aggregate obscured the fundamental wisdom that private enterprise is at the root of human prosperity. Yes, people aren’t always rational, as behavioural economics shows. True, inequality matters and growth is better when broad-based. Free trade and globalisation create losers as well as winners. But this is the best time in human history to be born, given record real incomes, high life expectancy and low rates of extreme poverty.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Oct 09 '26

Discussion Non-aggression principle + Logic = Georgism

7 Upvotes

The non-aggression principle states that you cannot inflict aggression on another person unless in self-defense, where aggression is defined as harm to them or their property, or unwanted interference. So, let us apply logic:

P1) The non-aggression principle is true.

P2) People deserve to own 100% of what they create.

C1) Therefore, you cannot forcefully take anything man-made from anyone (using P1 and P2).

P3) Banning someone from the natural world is an act of aggression.

P4) Land ownership is an act of banning all human beings, except oneself, from a piece of the natural world. (Indeed, when all the land is owned, non-landowners are banished from the whole natural world.)

C2) Land ownership is an act of aggression (using P3 and P4).

C3) Land ownership requires compensation for the land lost (using P1 and C2).

C4) Georgism is true (using C1 and C3).


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Apr 09 '26

AYN RAND

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Sep 01 '26

Article Civil Society Under Threat

Thumbnail
freopp.org
4 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • 24d ago

Discussion Patents and copyrights are government-created monopolies that restrict competition and innovation.

4 Upvotes

Patents and copyrights grant creators exclusive rights over certain uses of their intellectual creations. Supporters argue that these protections encourage innovation by allowing inventors and creators to benefit financially from their work.

Critics argue that intellectual property protections constitute government-granted monopolies that restrict competition, discourage independent innovation, and create artificial scarcity.

149 votes, 21d ago
49 Strongly Agree
46 Agree
25 Disagree
29 Strongly Disagree

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Aug 18 '26

Who Will Pay for Democratic Socialism’s $200 Trillion Cost?

Thumbnail cato.org
4 Upvotes

The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) propose new spending that could more than triple federal outlays. They propose the government pay for health care, housing, higher education, and electricity. Jobs are government-guaranteed, retirement benefits are expanded, paid family leave is universal, fossil fuels are eliminated, and reparations are paid. 

The DSA platform claims that the bill for all this will be sent to “the richest individuals and corporations.” Tally up that bill, and it ballparks between $71 trillion and $212 trillion in new spending over the next decade. Confiscating every dollar of high-end wealth and corporate profits would cover only a fraction of those costs. The DSA agenda necessitates high taxes on middle-class Americans.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • 19d ago

Discussion The government should have the authority to nationalize privately owned industries when doing so is deemed necessary to serve the public interest.

6 Upvotes

To what extent do you support government nationalization of Industry? Are their circumstances in which nationalization is justified, such as national emergencies, natural monopolies, critical infrastructure, or national security? Or should private ownership remain protected regardless of the perceived public benefit?

144 votes, 16d ago
51 Strongly Agree
36 Agree
29 Disagree
28 Strongly Disagree

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 14 '26

Other Copyright reform petition

Thumbnail
chng.it
1 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 28 '26

Audio/Video Yaron Brook on Capitalism

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

Brook lectures on capitalism- excellent stuff.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Mar 05 '26

Classical Liberal Trump’s Unauthorized Strikes on Iran Take America’s Imperial Presidency to New Heights

Thumbnail cato.org
2 Upvotes

What are we to make of the present actions taken in Iran? It increasingly appears that regardless of which party holds the presidency, the executive branch continues to involve the nation in foreign conflicts with little meaningful restraint. Though I sympathize deeply with the Iranian people, the President ought not to wield the power to initiate violent action against another nation without the clear consent of the people through their representatives in Congress.

The Constitution vested the power to declare war in the legislature for precisely this reason to prevent the concentration of such grave authority in a single office. This conflict also appears to lack broad public support, even among many within the President’s own political coalition.

A republic cannot long endure if the decision to wage war is divorced from the will of the citizenry. The classical liberal in me asks several simple but essential questions: Is the threat real and immediate? Is there genuine domestic consensus? What will be the human cost? What will be the economic burden?

If our system of checks and balances is to remain meaningful, we must ask what reforms are necessary to restrain executive overreach and restore the constitutional order intended by the founders. Beyond discussion alone, what practical changes might ensure that the power to take the nation to war is once again exercised with the deliberation and consent that a free republic demands?


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Mar 12 '26

Classical Liberal Wealth Taxes Raise Less Revenue Than You Think

Thumbnail cato.org
2 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jun 13 '26

Article One economist's villainous blueprint to manage global poverty

Thumbnail
latimes.com
2 Upvotes

"A core confusion of the degrowth ideology is its conflation of inequality and poverty, which are in fact two very different things. Reducing inequality by making everyone poorer is not a victory for the poor. The billions of people still lagging in the global income distribution have one realistic path out: growth. Dynamic, market-driven, property-rights-protected growth is the only proven path to prosperity. It’s also the path to environmental improvement, which costs money.

Degrowth is the ultimate luxury belief. It’s dreamed up by tenured professors in Paris and progressive think-tank pundits in Brussels. These are people who already have high incomes, comfortable apartments, generous healthcare and pensions and whose ideas would pull up the ladder on billions of poor people."


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Apr 29 '26

Image E.C. Riegel

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 25 '26

Discussion What political party do you follow for classical liberalism?

3 Upvotes

Many political parties are focused on just classical liberalism or a broader right-wing or libertarian ideology.

My top 3 that fit classical liberalism for me are:

  1. Liberal Party USA

  2. Libertarian Party

  3. Repubilcan Party (GOP)


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Apr 17 '26

Article Thin Libertarianism: Ideal Theory, PPE, & the Real World

Thumbnail
prosociallibertarians.substack.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jun 03 '26

Article Beware the Neo-Primes

Thumbnail
mises.org
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Aug 09 '26

Article Redistributing Wealth Means Redistributing Power to the State

Thumbnail cato.org
3 Upvotes

Because redistribution uses coercive political power to assign one person’s resources to purposes chosen by others, it requires justification. Need may establish a powerful claim upon our assistance, but it does not automatically establish an unlimited political claim upon the property, labor, and choices of others.

Once redistribution is institutionalized, it does not merely move money from the rich to the poor. It transfers authority from individuals and civil society to the state, which increasingly assumes control over income, savings, work, family incentives, and social initiative. What is truly redistributed is authority from individuals and voluntary associations to a centralized administrative state.

This transfer of authority cannot operate as a single act. Redistribution requires a permanent political machinery of extraction, distribution, and revision. Once taxation is regarded not merely as a means of raising revenue but as an instrument for producing a preferred social pattern, political power is invited permanently into the questions of who has too much, who has too little, who deserves assistance, and who must surrender resources to provide it.

The concern is not moral hard-heartedness. It is the danger of political power without intelligible limits. The more the state attempts to equalize outcomes through political management rather than voluntary aid, family support, mutual assistance, charity, and civil society, the more it must centralize command. 


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 06 '26

Article New Poll: Nearly Half of Americans Don’t Know What America’s 250th Is Celebrating

Thumbnail cato.org
4 Upvotes

86% are grateful to be American, 70% say Founding principles remain relevant today, 57% say the US has moved away from its founding principles, 56% worry the US could lose its freedom over the next 50 years. 58% say no political party should be trusted with too much power.


r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 07 '26

Article The Education of a European Liberal | A classical liberal rebuttal of Thielism

Thumbnail
nikodemskrobisz.substack.com
4 Upvotes