r/ClassicalEducation • • Mar 25 '23

What are some thinkers with great knowledge in classics?

4 Upvotes

Some figures that come to mind are Christopher Hitchens, Umberto Eco, Harold Bloom, Noam Chomsky, Jordan Peterson and Bishop Robert Barron, but I am sure there are many more.

Who are some other people who could be included in the list?


r/ClassicalEducation • • May 11 '25

Classical Education /= Great Books

14 Upvotes

I see many people here mistaking classical education for reading "great books". This is not classical education–don't waste your time if that is what you seek.

What is classical education? Here's an excerpt from Nichomacus' Introduction to Arithmetic from 100AD:

"[...]Again, to start afresh, since of quantity one kind is viewed by itself, having no relation to anything else, as ‘even,’ ‘odd,’ ‘perfect,’ and the like, and the other is relative to something else and is conceived of together with its relationship to another thing, like ‘double,’ ‘greater,’ ‘smaller,’ ‘half,’ ‘one and one-half times,’ ‘one and one-third times,’ and so forth, it is clear that two scientific methods will lay hold of and deal with the whole investigation of quantity; arithmetic, absolute quantity, and music, relative quantity.

And once more, inasmuch as part of ‘size’ is in a state of rest and stability, and another part in motion and revolution, two other sciences in the same way will accurately treat of ‘size,’ geometry the part that abides and is at rest, astronomy that which moves and revolves.

Without the aid of these, then, it is not possible to deal accurately with the forms of being nor to discover the truth in things, knowledge of which is wisdom, and evidently not even to philosophize properly, for “just as painting contributes to the menial arts toward correctness of theory, so in truth lines, numbers, harmonic intervals, and the revolutions of circles bear aid to the learning of the doctrines of wisdom,” says the Pythagorean Androcydes, “is the knowledge of these things.” Likewise, Archytas of Tarentum, at the beginning of his treatise On Harmony, says the same thing, in about these words: “It seems to me that they do well to study mathematics, and it is not at all strange that they have correct knowledge about each thing, what it is. For if they knew rightly the nature of the whole, they were also likely to see well what is the nature of the parts. About geometry, indeed, and arithmetic and astronomy, they have handed down to us a clear understanding, and not least also about music. For these seem to be sister sciences; for they deal with sister subjects, the first two forms of being.”

Plato, too, at the end of the thirteenth book of the Laws, to which some give the title The Philosopher, because he investigates and defines in it what sort of man the real philosopher should be, in the course of his summary of what had previously been fully set forth and established, adds: “Every diagram, system of numbers, every scheme of harmony, and every law of the movement of the stars, ought to appear one to him who studies rightly; and what we say will properly appear if one studies all things looking to one principle, for there will be seen to be one bond for all these things, and if anyone attempts philosophy in any other way he must call on Fortune to assist him. For there is never a path without these; this is the way, these the studies, be they hard or easy; by this course must one go, and not neglect it. The one who has attained all these things in the way I describe, him I for my part call wisest, and this I maintain through thick and thin.” For it is clear that these studies are like ladders and bridges that carry our minds from things apprehended by sense and opinion to those comprehended by the mind and understanding, and from those material, physical things, our foster-brethren known to us from childhood, to the things with which we are unacquainted, foreign to our senses, but in their immateriality and eternity more akin to our souls, and above all to the reason which is in our souls.

Emphasis mine.

Reading "great books" is fine, just don't confuse it with becoming educated. I'm not sure why this narrative persists.

If you want a classical education, the method and course of studies cannot be more clearly indicated than above from the classical authors themselves.

Thank me later:

  1. Grammar: Greek + Latin (many sources)

  2. Logic: Porphyry's Isagoge, then Aristotle's Organon.

  3. Rhetoric: Aristotle Rhetoric

  4. Arithmetic: Nicomachus Introduction to Arithmetic

  5. Geometry: Euclid Elements of Geometry

  6. Music: Boethius De Musica

  7. Astronomy: Ptolemy Almagest

The above is just the beginning, and should keep you occupied for a few years. As an adult, begin with Arithmetic and Logic. You will reap the fruits of your labour in a relatively short amount of time in the form of increased discernment of falsehood and sophistry (such as the sort which councils you to study "great books").

At Plato’s Academy, it is said that students spent around 30 years studying these subjects (with different texts, of course) before they were even allowed to begin philosophy proper—dialectic, etc.—which took another 15 years. Without that foundation, they were considered unfit for wisdom.

Putting this out there in case it helps someone avoid wasting their finite time on this earth.


r/ClassicalEducation • • Mar 16 '23

CE Newbie Question "Great Books" with female, people of color, lgbtq writers?

1 Upvotes

Hello, I've been making my way through the Great Books of the Western World (1952) and I'm loving every second of it. However, I would love to get more diverse perspectives from the Western World. Can anyone recommend the above types of writers that I could add to my "Great Books" list? Thank you so much!

Edit: Wow. Thank you so much for the responses! I have so many new authors to explore that I had never heard of before. This is really fantastic.


r/ClassicalEducation • • Mar 09 '25

When You Mention Socratic Method and They Look at You Like You Just Summoned a Demon

0 Upvotes

It’s like you casually bring up the Socratic Method at dinner, and suddenly you’re the weird one. “You want me to ask questions? About what?” Yes, Karen, about life, not what’s on Netflix! It’s as if the entire concept of deep thought just evaporates the moment you mention a philosopher. Ugh, modern education, am I right? Let’s reclaim the art of thinking - one perfectly structured question at a time!


r/ClassicalEducation • • May 01 '26

Question We enrolled our daughter in a classical private school and now I’m seeing people online saying classical education is RACIST😳 any Asian or Black or Hispanic parents here with kids in classical schools? I’d love to hear your real experiences.

10 Upvotes

Our 4 year old daughter is starting preschool this fall and we’ve been looking at private schools.

We found one near us, toured it, and honestly loved it.

Compared to other Pre K classes we saw, this one felt very intentional, less clutter on the walls, not overstimulating, very limited use of gadgets/computers.

They also said kids are typically able to read by the time they enter kindergarten, which really impressed us. It felt like a place where our tuition would actually go toward real learning.

But now I’m seeing people online say that “classical education” can be racist and it’s making me second-guess our decision.

We live in an area where most families are white. Our daughter already goes to a dance school where most kids are white but that’s only for an hour, nothing bad will happen. School would be 8 hours a day, so it feels different and more important.

I’m worried about things like whether she’ll feel included & whether teachers are attentive and supportive?

Are there any parents here especially Asian or Black or hispanic parents who have experience with classical schools? Should we move forward with the application or reconsider? What should we look for or ask before making a final decision?


r/ClassicalEducation • • Feb 18 '26

Has a classical work ever quietly reshaped the way you see your own life?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’ve been spending more time with classical literature lately (especially French and Spanish novels), and I’m struck by how differently these works move compared to contemporary writing.

There’s something about the slowness, the moral weight, the interiority — the way characters are shaped by their environment, by duty, by desire — that feels more formative than entertaining.

I’m curious:

Have you ever read a classical work that subtly changed the way you understood yourself?

Not in a dramatic “this transformed my worldview overnight” way — but in a quieter sense. A book that lingered. That sharpened your perception of beauty, failure, ambition, love, or even boredom.

For me, I’m realizing that classics don’t just tell stories — they seem to train attention. They demand patience. They reshape taste.

I’d love to hear which works did that for you, and why.


r/ClassicalEducation • • Jun 24 '21

I made r/WesternCivilisationII after getting permabanned and muted from r/WesternCivilisation

0 Upvotes

I got banned from there for arguing against their justification for the American colonisation.

So, I figured I could make a clone sub of the original, but without the bigotry and obsession with exclusivity.

If anyone's interested, please join r/WesternCivilisationII. Thanks.


r/ClassicalEducation • • Jul 21 '20

Robert Hutchins on the meaning of the Great Books, is he overselling them? Are they REALLY this important?

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Jan 06 '25

CE Newbie Question I am a queer leftist, but I particularly value the Western cultural canon regardless. Am I not alone?

73 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Mar 03 '21

Celebrate and discuss the Western tradition at r/WesternCivilisation

0 Upvotes

Hello all,

You’re all welcome to join me at my new sub r/WesternCivilisation to discuss the Western experience. Topics for discussion pertain to history, philosophy, art, architecture, tradition and custom. Moreover, there is room for discussing the particular intellectual and social movements that have arisen in antagonism against Western values - like socialism, secularism, and scientism.

Thank you.


r/ClassicalEducation • • Jun 13 '26

How do we help a 16-year-old reflect on whether she enjoyed a rigorous literary exercise (Reading Plato/Ion)

0 Upvotes

Hello there, I run a startup that helps students explore academic domains by simulating their core activities. I work one-on-one with students and I'm currently working with a 16-year-old who has just finished her IGCSE year, including Literature in English, and we've designed an exercise to give her a taste of college-level literary study:

  1. A written literary analysis of Plato's Ion

  2. A dry run presenting it to a small audience

  3. A collaborative discussion with readers who know the text well

  4. A Socratic debate with an LLM on the same text

My main question: how do we help her reflect on what she actually enjoyed in this process, so she gets a decisive signal about whether she'd thrive in structured, rigorous literary study? If you wondered why I chose Plato/Ion, here are my thoughts. This student is also weighing Law and Psychology alongside Literature. She is a budding musician, enjoys poetry and is drawn to the drama genre for its conversational style. So this dialogue felt like it could provoke her ideas around the creative process, especially its central question whether a performer or a creator truly knows their art. Last, I did want to give a literary text that reflects the rigor required in the field.

I'd also welcome general feedback on the design itself — especially from students currently reading Ion or anyone in higher ed. I've read the text myself and listened to a few interpretive discussions, but I don't have a literature background.


r/ClassicalEducation • • Mar 13 '26

Roman mosaics animated into realistic scenes — what can these ancient works tell us about daily Roman life?

2 Upvotes

Been experimenting with bringing ancient art back to life using AI, and this one came out better than expected. The workflow was: source high-quality Roman mosaic images → Nanobanan2 for image refinement and scene building → Kling 3 for video animation → Suno for the epic orchestral soundtrack.

The contrast between the flat mosaic tiles and the fluid, photorealistic motion is what makes it work visually. Mosaics are perfect source material because they already have a strong compositional structure — the AI has clear "instructions" to work with.

Full video: youtube.com/watch?v=lAJJSe3LYrk

Curious what other ancient art styles you'd want to see transformed this way. Greek vase paintings? Egyptian tomb hieroglyphics? Medieval illuminated manuscripts?


r/ClassicalEducation • • Jan 27 '26

Is the education system flawed?

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Feb 05 '21

He Wants to Save Classics From Whiteness. Can the Field Survive?

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
7 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Nov 04 '22

What are your thoughts on creationism? Since I’m new I want understand the difference Between a catholic school vs Protestant school. And does classical education apart from teaching Christianity and other religion’s aspect have any biases ?

0 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Sep 14 '23

Happy birthday Star Spangled Banner!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Jul 21 '23

Muslims and Christians Have More in Common than We Think!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • May 11 '22

Question Are the classics wasted on young minds?

18 Upvotes

My title line is intentionally provocative, but I do wonder: is a classical education actually fruitful for young minds? I have to agree with Plato that a good Philosophical education may be best saved for older students.

I'm returning to the classics as a 40-year old, and I'm sometimes shocked by how new they feel, despite having read some of them in the past. Granted, "reading" them usually meant an excerpt in a textbook or skimming them in Philosophy or English class. The classics I did read at my leisure in my late teens and early 20s are now mostly forgotten, except for the major themes. Even books that I found intellectually stimulating then, are entirely different now. It's one thing to read Montaigne and Seneca as a kid who thinks they'll live forever, and quite a different experience to read as a middle-aged adult.


r/ClassicalEducation • • Nov 04 '20

Beauty On europhilia

15 Upvotes

I don't spent a ton of time on this sub, but I enjoy it. However, I'm concerned by that a fancy for all things europe could be undermining the community and turning it into a much less substantive sub. I'm reminded of Ralph Waldo Emerson's passage in self-reliance:

It is for want of self-culture that the superstition of Travelling, whose idols are Italy, England, Egypt, retains its fascination for all educated Americans. They who made England, Italy, or Greece venerable in the imagination did so by sticking fast where they were, like an axis of the earth. In manly hours we feel that duty is our place. The soul is no traveller; the wise man stays at home, and when his necessities, his duties, on any occasion call him from his house, or into foreign lands, he is at home still and shall make men sensible by the expression of his countenance that he goes, the missionary of wisdom and virtue, and visits cities and men like a sovereign and not like an interloper or a valet.

I have no churlish objection to the circumnavigation of the globe for the purposes of art, of study, and benevolence, so that the man is first domesticated, or does not go abroad with the hope of finding somewhat greater than he knows. He who travels to be amused, or to get somewhat which he does not carry, travels away from himself, and grows old even in youth among old things. In Thebes, in Palmyra, his will and mind have become old and dilapidated as they. He carries ruins to ruins.

Travelling is a fool's paradise. Our first journeys discover to us the indifference of places. At home I dream that at Naples, at Rome, I can be intoxicated with beauty and lose my sadness. I pack my trunk, embrace my friends, embark on the sea and at last wake up in Naples, and there beside me is the stern fact, the sad self, unrelenting, identical, that I fled from. I seek the Vatican and the palaces. I affect to be intoxicated with sights and suggestions, but I am not intoxicated. My giant goes with me wherever I go.

I don't mean to disparage europe itself, let alone the great thinkers that have come from the region, but posts (like those listed below) that show pretty pictures are better suited for r/europhilia than they are for r/classicaleducation

It is borderline self-evident that "western" heritage is, by and large, a european heritage. That said, this sub is at its best when it is a place for people to increase their understanding of western thought. You see this trend towards superfluity in many subs where pretty pictures of a certain type take over. I hope for better from this sub.


r/ClassicalEducation • • May 05 '21

Dr. Fauci Has a Classics Degree! - Tales of Times Forgotten

Thumbnail
talesoftimesforgotten.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Jun 18 '21

A Latin Experts Odyssey: from the Vatican to the Gay Rights Movement

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicalEducation • • Feb 03 '25

Question Dress Code for Classical Christian Teachers

0 Upvotes

I will be working at a classical Christian school next year. The students wear uniforms, and the girls have to wear skirts - so I assume female teachers wear skirts, too. I have heard that this is the case in a lot of classical schools. So, I need ideas for outfits that don't make me look matronly. Where do you all shop? Any wardrobe ideas, including shoes, would be helpful. TIA!


r/ClassicalEducation • • Apr 26 '22

Parents - Attend the Liberation of Education Conference Free

5 Upvotes

The Liberation of Education online conference is happening today and tomorrow evening. You can attend for free and, if you can't make the times, access all the recordings if you register here for free.

Lots of great speakers including Michael Strong and Kerry McDonald. I'll be talking about the importance of and how to nurture the young spirit tomorrow evening.
A sample of my writing, "University Education As It Might Be And Ought To Be."
I'm working on opening Reliance College, based on the classics and aimed at developing autonomous and entrepreneurial young people.

Hope some of you can make it!


r/ClassicalEducation • • Jan 04 '23

Recommendations for fiction written in the past couple hundred years?

3 Upvotes

Perhaps some modern novelists have repackaged some of these heroic myth/stories as to be more "readable" for the modern person.

Basically just looking for good virtuous fiction and thought this sub would yield recommendations that are not degenerate

appreciate any reply


r/ClassicalEducation • • Sep 16 '23

Wing Academy in MI

Thumbnail
wing.academy
0 Upvotes

New classical school being formed in SE Michigan. Looking to open in Fall 2024. If you are in the area please help spread the word. Time and finances are welcome.