r/ClassicTrek • • 6d ago

Theory/Question After I finish TOS and DS9,should I watch Voyager and Enterprise or they are bad shows that dont deserve my attention?

10 Upvotes

I made a post earlier about VOY and ENT,and lots of comments were like its a bad show don't watch it and this makes me sad. I've seen Section 31,SNW and Lower Decks,trust me i've seen worse. I also was interested in Voyager cause its the first female captain we got in Trek and Enterprise as a concept sounds great.


r/ClassicTrek • • Jun 21 '25

Is anyone else getting Romulan vibes from this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ClassicTrek • • Jul 27 '25

Character/General Discussion How do you handle the visual discrepancies between TOS and SNW?

0 Upvotes

Of course it’s no longer the 60’s, TV production has evolved majorly since TOS first aired.

As a result, SNW (while set before TOS) has a modern visual style and updated SFX.

So how do you handle these changes / discrepancies?

I personally believe that what we see in SNW (ship computers, field equipment, etc) is how it’s also supposed to look in TOS.

I hope this makes sense.


r/ClassicTrek • • Apr 12 '26

I just found this sub: is this 1966-2005 only?

3 Upvotes

I just found this sub: is this 1966-2005 only?
Are we allowed to discuss the reboot trilogy here?
Are we allowed to discuss the streaming shows and film here?

THANKS!!!


r/ClassicTrek • • Jul 26 '26

It's pretty wild that all the main Starfleet captains saved the galaxy or universe except for kirk

14 Upvotes

Picard : saved the galaxy from the time anomaly

Janeway: save the galaxy from 8472

Sisko: saved the galaxy from the pah wraith

Archer : saved the galaxy from the sphere builders

Burnham saved the galaxy from that alien species from outside the galaxy

Freeman : saved the universe

Pike saved the galaxy from that ancient energy being race

Kirk : saved earth on a few occasions

Who would have thought Kirk didnt save.tur galaxy


r/ClassicTrek • • Feb 16 '26

Would archer and Janeway be the best captains than the rest since they never lost their commands?

1 Upvotes

archer commander the nx-01 to the end of his tenure

janeway brought her ship back home in near mint condition

Kirk lost the 1701, Picard lost the 1701d and the stargazer. sisko lost the defiant.

what do you think?


r/ClassicTrek • • 16d ago

Why Did 90s Star Trek Look Like That?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/ClassicTrek • • Sep 23 '26

"Star Trek never had silly episode that didn't make sense, it was always serious, new Trek is too silly right now" TOS: what if a baby was an immortal alien and used a spirit of halloween Alien suit to trick other aliens.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/ClassicTrek • • May 31 '26

TNG Lt. Barclay was the Antithesis to Gene Roddenberry's vision of Humanity

7 Upvotes

Lt. Barclay was depicted as shy, stuttering, unable to make eye contact, and paralyzed by fear of social interaction. He was often late, accident-prone, and perceived as incompetent by everyone on the Enterprise. This ran contrary to Gene's vision where humans in the future had evolved beyond such debilitating psychological insecurities. To him, officers aboard the Enterprise were supposed to be confident, socially adept, and emotionally stable.

Barclay suffered from "holodiction," using the holodeck to escape reality. He created fantasy versions of the crew to act out aggressive or sexual scenarios he was too timid to attempt in real life, preferring a controlled fictional world over genuine human connection. This ran contrary to Gene's vision where humans were meant to find satisfaction in reality and their work, not retreat into artificial fantasies to manage their emotions.

Barclay's incompetence and odd behavior led to conflict with the crew of the Enterprise. He was mocked by the crew a lot. This contradicted Gene's no interpersonal conflicts rule among the crew, believing that by the 24th century, humans would have outgrown interpersonal conflicts and bullying.

It's interesting to note that, Barclay debuted during TNG's 3rd season, and by the 3rd season, Gene had to step away from the writing team due to health reasons.

So without the restraints imposed by Gene during the early seasons of TNG, the writers wrote Lt. Barkley's character.


r/ClassicTrek • • Aug 29 '26

DS9 The old Bajoran government deserves blame for the occupation not Dukat

Post image
0 Upvotes

Everyone agrees that the “Bajoran” occupation was wrong.

The Cardassians were on Bajor at the invitation of the Bajoran government.

Dukat was not this all powerful figure. He could not order people to the labor camps, only Secretary Kubus had that power. Remember once the government changed on Bajor, the Cardassians left, and the Federation came in.

Now you might be asking yourself why would be the Bajorans allow the suffering of other Bajorans. Simple, greed, and power. We must remember what a primitive people the Bajorans were when the Cardassians came there.

They operated on the system that you had no free choice and what you wanted to be you had to follow your Djara. Basically, if you were born, the child of a farmer, you had to be a farmer you could seek no better life. Basically, they were already slaves to their own theocratic government system.

The Cardassians gave them technology, and the power to keep their people oppressed.

The Cardassians we’re guilty of total indifference. They went along with the system because they got stuff out of it. But they were not the cause.


r/ClassicTrek • • 6d ago

Theory/Question What should I expect from Classic Trek and are Enterprise and Voyager bad shows?

0 Upvotes

So my intro to Trek was TNG. Loved that show,the cast was so good and from S3-S7 it was mostly great. Rip Patrick Stewart. I also watched some of Original series,like 8 episodes only,up to Miri now. Also did 1st season of DS9 which was eh. What should I expect for rest of DS9,TOS,all movies and ENT and VOY?


r/ClassicTrek • • Jun 09 '26

What if all star trek shows uniforms were only skants?

8 Upvotes

From enterprise to the animated shows like prodigy

Imagine archer and his crew in skants. Kirk and his crew in skants

Pike and snw in skants

Burnham and discovery in skants

Picard and tng maintained skants

Ds9 voyager etc in skants

All the animated shows in skants

Fighting the dominion in skants

What do you think?


r/ClassicTrek • • May 24 '26

Is it too late for a DS9 sequel of some kind?

8 Upvotes

TOS got TAS + 6 films + 3 reboot films.
TNG got 4 films + the Picard series.
VOY got Prodigy + a kind of scatter shot across the streaming shows.

What about DS9??? All we got was an episode of Lower Decks and an episode of Starfleet Academy. The show ran 1993-99, and it's now 2026. It's been 27 years, has it been too long? Avery retired from acting long time ago. Rene (Odo) and Aaron (Nog) have passed away. I think everyone else is still around and still acting. What do you think? Could a live-action o animated sequel work? I'm thinking just a miniseries or movie, nothing substantiated. Would you expect to see the DS9 sets be rebuilt, or go for more a mix of partial sets and CG set extensions? Do you "want" to see a sequel, and if yes, live-action or animated? Do you want the gang back together, or do you want something more like Picard or Prodigy where it's a mix of old and new characters?


r/ClassicTrek • • Oct 18 '26

TOS Films How Did Sulu Not Know This in ST III?

15 Upvotes

Rewatching the TOS movies for the umpteenth time, I realized a contradiction I had somehow overlooked before.

It has been pretty much established since the second film, at least offscreen, that Sulu was slanted to command the Excelsior. This was present in the novelization of the Wrath of Khan and was supposed to appear in a scene cut from the original script. This can be seen as the crew is approaching the Enterprise in the travel pod Sulu says "Any chance to go aboard the Enterprise" and then there is an abrupt transition to the stock image of the pod approaching the ship and by Sulu's mouth still moving it's apparent there was some dialogue taken out in between. Supposedly this was Sulu and Kirk discussing Sulu's recent assignment to command USS Excelsior and he only agreed to delay that to help out the training cruise.

Flash forward to the next movie when the Enterprise is returning to Earth and the first appearance of the USS Excelsior in Spacedock. As most of the crew is marveling at this brand-new ship, more advanced than the Enterprise (except Scotty of course), Sulu says the line, "I hear she's supposed to have Transwarp drive." which if we are to assume he was going to be the captain of Excelsior as far back as before the last film, how would he not know this definitely already?

I had always assumed Captain Styles was only given command temporarily or for Excelsior's shakedown trials and Sulu would take over once the Enterprise's training cruise was over and only Excelsior's Transwarp failure that maybe caused it to maybe be overhauled as well as the events of the next several films caused Sulu's promotion to be further delayed until ST VI. Yet, if this was the case, Sulu's line in ST III still made no sense as he would have been familiar enough with the design of the Excelsior before ST III that he was 100% aware of the existence of her Transwarp engines rather than speculating based upon second-hand rumor if it wasn't yet general knowledge. Someone in line to be captain of a vessel would or should have already had a fair degree of familiarity of its technology and components before even taking over the center seat.

My only conclusion is that since we never saw onscreen until ST VI any ties between Sulu and the Excelsior, that his assignment to command it as far back as ST II was never meant to be canon and Starfleet only made a decision to assign him as captain three years before the beginning of ST VI. Yet, since the idea has been so ingrained in beta-canon since ST II and it just seems a coincidence that the writers of ST VI decided to make him captain of the same ship most of fandom already assumed he was always going to get since the second movie, I can't accept this explanation and it would have been a lot simpler to have given his line to one of the other crew upon arriving at Spacedock as their being unfamiliar with a new ship design still in the testing phase would have made more sense.

So, has anyone else every noticed this discrepancy and how do you square it?


r/ClassicTrek • • Sep 15 '26

Humor One you see this, you cannot unsee it

Post image
0 Upvotes

A Klingon Bat'leth is an overgrown pizza cutter lol.


r/ClassicTrek • • 6d ago

Theory/Question Hot Take : Star Trek will never be good again (at least in our lifetimes)

0 Upvotes

I honestly dont know if we will ever get a good star trek movie or a tv series. Idk if theres a creative,showrunner or a writer who can make a genuinely interesting a good star trek tv show or movie. I think Terry Matalas could but I know how many of you dislike Picard Season 3. I loved his work on VisionQuest. But what do you think. Is there a future for Star Trek?


r/ClassicTrek • • Jun 11 '26

When Reginald finally blows his lid

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/ClassicTrek • • 13d ago

Theory/Question How to find the chronological order of episodes in classic trek not including the JJ films or Nutrek?

0 Upvotes

r/ClassicTrek • • Sep 09 '26

[OC] Happy 60th Birthday Star Trek!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Keep boldly going!


r/ClassicTrek • • Mar 25 '26

If only, ahhh hahaha

58 Upvotes

Now let's call Balok and have some tranya. Haha


r/ClassicTrek • • Mar 27 '26

DS9 Going to a protest tomorrow? Consider this piece by @meganlevens for your sign.

Post image
335 Upvotes

r/ClassicTrek • • Jan 26 '26

How many times have seen characters commit hara Kiri in star trek?

Post image
10 Upvotes

one of few times I can think of captain Terrell in star trek 2 and ensign kwan in tng


r/ClassicTrek • • Jul 16 '26

It appears the time period the guardian of forever is displaying might be the civil war and if Captain Kirk step through now he might actually meet President Lincoln.

Post image
91 Upvotes

Imagine if bones jumped into the guardian a little earlier they could have been in the 19th century instead.


r/ClassicTrek • • Jul 18 '25

Humor (Political) ... oof, Dukat.

Post image
5 Upvotes