r/ClassicBookClub • • Jun 27 '26

I refused to use AI so I'm here instead

0 Upvotes

So , here's the thing , I have a book report on "The Great Gatsby" by F, Scott Fitzgerald. And no , I did not buy the book (it's Saturday night and TMRW on Sunday all shops are closed) and no I do not have it's pdf or anything but the book report on it is due the day after TMRW ,that is , on Monday and I need someone who has read it to just gimme what they got from the book in their own words. Just make it under 200 words. It's handwritten anws so I'll make it really big and make it seem like a thick report.

I know I could just chatgpt it but I refuse to use AI which is why I will rather ask reddit community.


r/ClassicBookClub • • Apr 22 '25

Ernest Hemingway

0 Upvotes

Someone help me out here. I’ve read “A Farewell to Arms” and “The Sun Also Rises”, and I just can’t get into Hemingway. Did I go about this wrong? Should I have read another one of his works first? I’m having a really hard time seeing why he is such a respected and venerated author. I should say right away that I’m not a fan of first person narratives. I always feel like I’m only getting part of the story. That being said, I loved “The Great Gatsby” and “Moby Dick”, which are first person narratives, but I get annoyed with Hemingway quickly. I’ve decided to give him one more try, and to let someone else recommend which book. I feel like maybe I chose the wrong material to start with.


r/ClassicBookClub • • Jul 13 '23

What chapter Basil and Dorian Kiss in The picture of Dorian Gray?

0 Upvotes

I know they kissed and then were suggested to do more but I can't seem to remember which chapter it was and I'm struggling to find it.


r/ClassicBookClub • • Jun 18 '24

Where should I start?

0 Upvotes

I'm just beginning to dive into classics what book would you recommend me?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Jul 25 '22

When I'm done reading, I'm going to binge-read all the works that have this ship (No spoilers!)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ClassicBookClub • • Nov 04 '22

Is this crap common in Victorian-era lit? Young woman's innocence is "intoxicating" and the rich guy can't keep away from her? And he's the hero of the story?

0 Upvotes

Damned if you do, damned if you don't? So, there's this book I'm reading. Written in the mid 1880's but set around 1850. A wealthy young Viscount falls in love with a rich Count's daughter.

But there's this other girl, an innocent peasant girl who hasn't been around the block. The Viscount seems interested in her (just because she looks hot- but she's not marriage material for obvious reasons) and tries to follow her home. When the Viscount is injured, he is taken to HER home, just by coincidence. As she nurses him back to health, his horndog tendencies come to the surface and he kisses her. She doesn't have a boyfriend and only understands "love" in a familial sense.

But the author seems to keep making excuses for him!

Like this:

"The more [he] saw of her the more he came under the dominion of her irresistible charms, the empire of her physical attractiveness."

"She, moreover, lured and inflamed him in such a careless, innocent way that she acquired additional piquancy thereby."

"[She] was a pure and innocent creature, unused to the ways of the world and incapable of suspecting the wickedness of men. She was on the point of falling into a deadly snare, on the point of being wrecked upon the most dangerous shoal life presented. Her very purity and innocence would make her an easy victim. [He] was not wicked; he was merely young, the prey of the irresistible passion of youth. [Her] surpassing loveliness had fired his blood [...]"

Does this sound like the "Boys will be boys" type of attitude?

And how this this all end? Not very well (for her). She gets kidnapped and raped by bandits. He gets accused of the crime, but he's innocent. He's supposed to be the "good guy" of the story! The bandits free the girl, she runs home, but knows her life is ruined/over, so she goes to a "Convent for Fallen Women" and becomes a nun.

And for our young Viscount Horndog? After being exonerated, he gets permission to marry the (other) Count's daughter. They have a BIG wedding. Yay???


r/ClassicBookClub • • Mar 10 '26

I'm a programmer and I'm wondering if any would be interested in a tool I'm planning to design to assist with reading

0 Upvotes

Let me preface by saying I'm not attempting to sell or promote anything, not yet at least lol. Just testing the waters and seeing whether it would solve a problem people have.

The app that I'm thinking of building is one to address this core issue of not being able to retain information from books and articulate them. Just a few days ago I was trying to explain 1984 to a friend who doesn't read, and I was stumbling over my words and speaking enigmatically. ​​I'm sure you've faced a similar issue. Books should be for absorbing information and being able to apply it in a meaningful way.

So this app will incorporate the Feynman technique of teaching the concept. The app is specifically tailored towards readers of literature, and it offers correction based on strict and consistent criteria while gamifying the process at the same time. ​​​

Over time I'm hoping that this will help someone, including myself, to refine their use of words, achieve clarity of thought, and actually retain the knowledge they consume. Would anyone be interested or offer any feedback?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Mar 01 '23

Is there a point where The Conte or Monte Cristo picks up?

5 Upvotes

Please don’t attack me

So I’m getting into classics. And I was told the Count of Monte Cristo is a great book. Like revenge and prison break story.

I’m at the 100 page mark (my usual cut off point if I don’t like a book) and it’s good kinda but feels kinda slow. Like I feel like k can see where modern writers are better cause they take time to explain things. Whereas here things are mentioned and you don’t really get chance to understand it at all. Or understand what a possible consequence is or a scene. Like I’m on the but where King Louis is meeting Villefort and it just seems inconsiquetial. Am i simply missing somethjng?

Did anyone else find it kinda slow and does it pick up in pace soon at all?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Jan 15 '23

Crime and Punishment vs The Secret History

0 Upvotes

Which one is ur fav and which book should i start first?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Apr 29 '26

Misinterpreted Power Dynamics in Wuthering Heights: Who is making the tea?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been analyzing this specific exchange in Chapter 2, and I believe many translations (and even some readers) misidentify the speakers because of a tricky grammatical structure. I’d love to get your thoughts on the pronoun references here.

The Passage

‘Perhaps I can get a guide among your lads... could you spare me one?’

‘No, I could not.’ (Heathcliff)

‘Oh, indeed! Well, then, I must trust to my own sagacity.’ (Lockwood)

‘Umph!’ (Heathcliff)

‘Are you going to mak’ the tea?’ demanded he of the shabby coat, shifting his ferocious gaze from me to the young lady.

‘Is HE to have any?’ she asked, appealing to Heathcliff.

The Question: Who is "He" and who is "The Shabby Coat"?

Most readers assume the "shabby coat" (Hareton) is asking the young lady (Cathy) to make tea. However, looking at the syntax and the psychological context, I argue that Heathcliff is the one speaking.

1. The Grammatical Argument: "Demand of [Someone]"

In 19th-century English, the construction "Demanded he of the shabby coat" follows the pattern "To demand [something] of [someone]."

  • He (Subject): Heathcliff.

  • Of the shabby coat (Object of the demand): Hareton Earnshaw.

  • The "Something" (The Demand): "Are you going to mak' the tea?"

If Hareton were the one speaking, the text would simply say, "demanded the shabby coat" or "demanded he in the shabby coat." By using "of," Brontë indicates that Heathcliff is directing a command at Hareton.

2. The Context of the Following Line: "Is HE to have any?"

Immediately after, Cathy asks Heathcliff, "Is HE to have any?"

  • If Hareton had asked Cathy to make tea, her response wouldn't make much sense.

  • However, if Heathcliff just ordered Hareton (a man) to make the tea, Cathy’s question becomes a sharp, sarcastic jab. She is asking Heathcliff: "Are you actually going to let HE [Hareton, the person you've turned into a servant] have a cup of the tea he is making, or is he just a slave?"

3. The Psychological Context: Inversion of Roles

Heathcliff’s revenge is built on degradation.

  • Degrading Hareton: He forces the rightful heir of the house to perform menial tasks (making tea), stripping him of his masculine status as a gentleman.

  • Erasing Cathy: By ordering Hareton to make tea instead of Cathy, he denies her the role of "mistress of the house." He treats her as a non-entity, moving his "ferocious gaze" to her only to see if she feels the sting of being ignored.

Conclusion

I believe the correct interpretation is that Heathcliff orders Hareton to make the tea.

Does the community agree that the "demanded he of the shabby coat" syntax confirms Heathcliff as the speaker? Or is there a case to be made for the "shabby coat" being the speaker despite the preposition "of"?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Oct 09 '22

Someone's bizarro rant re: Achilles and Patroclus

2 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/books/comments/xz211s/rant_about_achilles_patroclus/

This is, like 100% relevant to the book we are reading now. I didn't want to get involved in this thread. When people THIS MAD about something that wasn't explicitly mentioned in a book (or movie or whatever media they were consuming), I doubt that any logic and sense would help them come down. It's one thing to get mad about things described in a book, but to get mad about things that aren't in it? BTW, OP did not specifically say what they were reading or watching.

For those of us reading the grownup editions, is it correct to say that The Iliad itself does not specifically say that Achilles and Patroclus were lovers? We (here) had discussed that there were multiple sources for the myth of Troy, and we have seen that key parts of the story (the Beauty Contest, the Oath by the other chieftains to support Menelaus, the Trojan Horse, the Fall of Troy) missing from the book.

Is the Achilles + Patroclus love story (or lack of it) something to get mad about? Or is it a case of looking for other books/sources that do describe it in detail?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Jan 06 '26

Let's read In Search of Lost Time!

5 Upvotes

Happy New Year!

Let this be the year to read all seven volumes of Marcel Proust's In Search of Lost Time! Join our virtual book club, to help you along. The pace will be slow--50 pages a week (or 10 pages a day on weekdays)--which will get us to completion around August 2027.

Each member of the book club will also be asked to write a post for the book club Substack once every 8-12 weeks (depending on how many people sign up). There will also be a virtual meeting via Zoom held every six weeks or so.

If you are interested, please send me a DM and I can provide more info.

Include in your DM: your name; your email (detailed info about book club structure and format will be shared in a Google Doc and reading and posting schedule will be shared in a Google Sheet); and the city where you live.

Please only sign up if you can commit to the pace and schedule above. We will stop taking new folks after Jan 8, or once we are at capacity.

We start with Lydia Davis' translation of Swann's Way and switch to the Modern Library Classics editions for volumes 2-7.

Kick off is January 12!


r/ClassicBookClub • • Dec 03 '21

Where can I find Oliver Twist (adapted classic) audio book for free? I’m having a exam on it but I can’t understand any books without an audiobook. Here is the book cover!

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicBookClub • • Apr 07 '22

Looking at this picture you immediately feel the heat of the scorching sun, a light wind walking near the Nile, the smell of fresh fruit and dusty carpets, you hear the cries of merchants. Would you like to walk here? (Agatha Christie: Death on the Nile)

1 Upvotes

r/ClassicBookClub • • Jan 29 '25

Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep: Symbolism or the 60s?

1 Upvotes

I've been reading Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, recommended to me by my brother. I'm about eight or so chapters from the end, and I'm really liking it. However, I was curious if the constant reference to boobs means anything, or if that's just an author from the 60s constantly wanting to comment on... boobs? Almost every character has her cleavage described in someway, and I genuinely have no idea if it's supposed to be part of the deeper narrative, such as how robots and women are objectified? Or if it's just something that the author liked to talk about? I know nothing about the author beyond this book, so it very well could be just what he does?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Sep 05 '25

Gulliver's travels, timeless classics

0 Upvotes

Has anyone read Gulliver's travels published by timeless classics? Its the cheapest one I've seen so far yet seems to have a great quality.

Everytime I buy classics, i research on which published version is better. Through this, I found out that the timeless classics version is abridged.

I just want to ask if a lot of parts from the original is cut off, and how different is it from the original text.


r/ClassicBookClub • • Nov 29 '25

Digressions

1 Upvotes

I’m currently reading Les Miserables and I was enjoying it until it got to the part about Waterloo. The title of this second part of the story is Cosette and I was really excited to get started on her perspective, but this digression about Waterloo is killing me! War tales bore the hell out me. How do ppl feel about this particular part in the story?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Dec 30 '25

Recommendations for yearning, heartbreaking/tragic, romance, classic book

7 Upvotes

I recently finished Persuasion by Jane Austen and adored it! It was a very light and cute story.

Given that it is winter time and I'm in the mood for cozy reading, a book that really breaks my heart would be ideal.

Deal breakers are smut/heavily detailed intimacy, MLM (can't relate so not immersive :")), fantasy, and a total focus on romance (i.e. no other themes and topics. In the case of Persuasion, [possible spoiler? not really but to be safe...] I wouldn't read it if there wasn't a clear commentary and theme around classism).

I know this is specific, so if you can't think of anything, please feel free to add books that I may not like but that you've enjoyed! Still would love to check them out!! Thanks :)


r/ClassicBookClub • • Aug 06 '25

Online book club for literature (google meet)

Post image
87 Upvotes

We’ve started something called Deep Read Society an online book club for people who want to go beyond skimming pages and really live inside the books they read. The idea came from a simple feeling: there’s plenty of talk about books online, but very little space to sit with a text, think about it, and discuss it with people who care just as much.

It’s not just novels either, we’re adding poetry appreciation sessions, because some works deserve to be savored line by line. For September, we’re reading poetry, and in October, we’re taking on The Count of Monte Cristo.

If you’d like to join the WhatsApp group, DM me or drop a comment, I’ll send you the Google Form link to sign up. You can also follow Deep Read Society on Instagram.


r/ClassicBookClub • • Oct 01 '23

Hi. I just started reading classic books. Can you recommend some?

5 Upvotes

r/ClassicBookClub • • Feb 26 '23

Sorta disappointed in Brothers Karamazov. I know it’s blasphemy to admit (Spoilers ahead). Spoiler

9 Upvotes

As much I loved Brothers K. I can’t help but walk away frustrated by it (unlike Anna Karenina).

I’m amazed by how many ppl claim it to be greatest novel without adding the following asterisks:

*It was meant to be part of a series of books - not sure if it was going to be a trilogy - and the intent of telling the story of Alyosha - the “hero” of the story according to the author was never fulfilled. This was due to Dostoyevsky dying after the publishing of BK.

*It leaves so many big questions (plot wise) unanswered. I won’t list them here but if you’ve read them you know at least three.

*The novel is uneven in terms of its intellectual ideas. The first third of it has some amazing dialogue and philosophical depth but the last two thirds are largely gossipy / soap opera - ish.

It feels taboo to speak against this novel but IMO here’s too many ppl saying it’s the “greatest of all time” with all its praises and simply leaving it there.

Is it one of the greatest? Yes. Could it have been THE greatest series of all time if it Dostoyevsky would have finished it? Possibly!

Do you disagree or agree with me? Are there other asterisks YOU would add?


r/ClassicBookClub • • Aug 30 '26

Has anyone read “A Separate Peace”?

14 Upvotes

Has anyone read “A Separate Peace” by John Knowles?

If so, HOW did you read it? I’m currently reading it for my AP English class and I’m needing to write an essay over it. Sadly, I’m finding it to be the most boring and mind-numbing book that I’ve ever laid my eyes upon.

I’ve had it for the whole summer but was told by my teacher to read it a week before school, so that’s what I did. This means I started reading it on August 5th. It’s currently August 30th and I’m only on Chapter 6 out of 13.

Every time I pick up this book, I find myself forcing it open every time like bad food I don’t want to swallow. So PLEASE, tell me how you read this book and how/if you enjoyed it.


r/ClassicBookClub • • Jan 09 '22

What does rochester mean here??

6 Upvotes

I could bend her with my finger and thumb: and what good would it do if I bent, if I uptore, if I crushed her? Consider that eye: consider the resolute, wild, free thing looking out of it, defying me, with more than courage—with a stern triumph. Whatever I do with its cage, I cannot get at it—the savage, beautiful creature! If I tear, if I rend the slight prison, my outrage will only let the captive loose."


r/ClassicBookClub • • Nov 08 '23

Am I wrong in thinking the relationship in Jane Eyre is creepy? Spoiler

52 Upvotes

I’m only halfway through the book but i remember watching the BBC movie when I was younger. Mr Rochester has always made me feel uncomfortable. The way he calls Jane “my little friend” and the fact that his wife is literally locked up in the same house that they are living in and she doesnt find this out until after they get married makes it so weird. Like I understand that it was normal for much older men to marry younger women when the book was written but the fact that he acknowledges her age and calls her little feels creepy. I think it might just be me though.


r/ClassicBookClub • • Jan 11 '25

Political books

3 Upvotes

Hi everybody, I attended the East of Eden read through last year and would really like to do another soon. So, im here to ask, are there any classics, preferably modern like 1960 -, that take on issues of political corruption graft ect? There're tons of non-fiction books about it, but you all know how classic lit goes. TY!