I'm running 3 clans in the M2 - C1 range (plus one for minis), so not quite casual (that's in the top 1% of players AFAIK ?), but not tryharders either (we do see a few coming through for a handful of months on their way up^^). Adults, just barely to retired. I'd say 2/3 F2P, 1/3 Gold pass, a very few spend more than that. About 1/3 play CWL, and of those about half are on Discord, half of those again with notifs on for direct and everyone messages I'd guess. That's for context.
With CWL coming up, I'm starting the "refresh your bases" dance again:
- find credible layouts (from Youtube, specialized Discords, Websites, those emigrated tryharders)
- put up pics and links on our discord,
- there's also a pinned post w/ sources on our dedicated Discord subchannel
- nag people to pick one and rotate it and activate it.
That's not a fun part of my job, but I can count on very few self-starters, I gotta do that chore for them. And then double check on day 1, and then track performance live during CWL, occasionnaly shouting / threatening.
I think SC could / should create a Layouts cookbook, the same way there is an Armies Coobooks. The scenario is not quite the same because the army comp is 10% of the Offense problem, while the Layout is 100% of the Defense problem. But still, nobody creates their own layout anymore, barely anyone modifies 3rd-party layouts, even just the rotation I request puts us in the top 0.01% most sophisticated from what I see in Wars CWL and L3.
For that coobook to succeed, it must
- be varied, 20 at the very least, I'd argue 50 so we don't get bored
- be commisionned from good and/or renowned creators, players, events
- all be at least good, but not the bestest so tryharders still have an edge
- be compensated. A drop in the bucket for SC I'm sure, but one large headache less for players and especially Clan Leads (we got Defense Lead positions open since 2020 ^^)
- be regularly updated, 1/4 monthly at least
- not be too documented (performance, usage) so not everyone pick the same and some skill is still required
- be Dewey'd so clans can track who uses what to avoid duplication
I understand the elite in this sub will hate the idea, and SC will hate the work + expense however piddly. But it would remove a strong friction point for 99% of players, and not impact the remaining 1%. I'm not advocating for the removal of the Layout Editor tool, on the contray, I'm secretly hoping that having a premade layout and knowing anyone can get the same will encourage regular players to try tweaks and increase their involvement in the Defense side of things. Maybe the Layouts could/should even have holes in them 4-6 defs left to be placed by the players (we never got any Defense tutorials / single-player campaign similar to what we got for Offense BTW).
So, yeah, that would be nice.