With the lack of clear information surrounding this entire situation over the past several days, I'd like to put things into a concise overview to better communicate what's happening. While I am not directly involved in the situation, this is something I think is needed. I recently posted regarding a need for this, and have decided that I might as well put something together myself. If there's any information I should add or clarify, let me know.
This post will be specifically focused on the ongoing technical efforts and their goals. While I could also summarize the community-related events that have happened over the past week, I don't feel that would be productive.
Background info
City of Heroes shut down in 2012. While we've always had access to the game client, the key piece we've been missing has been the server itself. Last week, we discovered that the code still exists and subsequently it has been made available. Since then, a few things have been happening.
Code Adaptation Effort
The game server was never intended to be downloaded and run as a compartmentalized private server program. It was a server for a live MMO client. However, code can be changed, and it's just a question of what sort of time and effort are required to do that. In this particular case, the code is difficult to work with and the effort required is significant. However, there are dozens of dedicated programmers working to make this happen.
The end goal is a readily downloadable game server that is easy to configure and run wherever you want to put it. As long as you have the necessary hardware (or VM), you can host your own server for as many or as few people as you'd like.
What version of the code is it?
This is the Issue 24 code, including test-server code, that was available when the shutdown happened. For legal reasons, existing character data was not shared, so any new server would be starting from a blank slate.
Now that we have access to the game server code, why can't we just run our own private servers? Are we missing something important?
No, we aren't missing any of the pieces. No one is standing in the way. While it's possible to get the server up and running as-is, it isn't easy. The goal of adapting the code is to make it easy.
For a more explicit summary of what is and isn't available, u/GarbledReverie has added an excellent comment detailing this below.
What are the legal ramifications?
While illegal, the server code and ancillary data files are out there now. There is no one singular location where this could get shut down, so it's reasonable to expect one way or another, through the effort of the amazing and dedicated programmers among us working on this, that it's going to happen. It's just a question of when and how much will need to be done under the radar. With open collaboration venues, things will go much quicker.
How can I help?
If you've got the requisite coding skills, check out the City of Heroes Discord. There are #coding channels available with some more information and discussion about ongoing efforts.
If you aren't a programmer, there's not much you can do right now, but make sure to let them know that you appreciate what they're doing, and do what you can to make sure there's no misinformation going around.
Public Server Project
While getting a server with the existing architecture up and running isn't easy, it is, with some modifications, possible. As a result of this, there has been an effort to spin up a public server that everyone can play on as soon as possible, even before the code adaptation is complete. This has been called the public test server, and has been available as SCoRE in the Tequila launcher.
How is this related to the code adaptation?
There's a lot of overlap between the people working on each piece, and they've been working on some of the same problems and sharing solutions where applicable. Provided that this project is successful, the changes to the server code can also be applied to the public server.
Additionally, the City of Heroes Discord is the place where both efforts are being organized.
What's the server status? How can I connect?
Check out the CoH Resurgence Project document for information about whether or not the server is online and if so, how to connect. And again, the Discord has channels for getting updates on the server status.
What version of the code is running?
The server includes the changes that have been made on the private SCoRE server over the past several years. It is sometimes called the i25 version, but it is not Issue 25; there is no Issue 25.
I don't have a comprehensive list of what the changes are, but they include a new archetype, powerset proliferation, a vendor giving access to some formerly premium items, and various QoL changes.
What are the legal ramifications?
This is illegal and, unlike the now-distributed code, presents a very clear potential target. We have to assume that NCSoft knows about this server and that we are subject to their decisions regarding whether or not to take action.
If the server gets shut down, the code adaptation effort will continue as planned. However, the community ideal of having one centralized server with hundreds or thousands of players will likely become infeasible. The next step would be to move toward a number of smaller, lower-profile servers which, while similarly illegal, would be much less likely to be the target of a shutdown.
At time of writing, no immediate legal obstacle has presented itself, and we can expect that the project will continue.
SEGS
SEGS, or the Super Entity Game Server, is a project to build a new, functional game server from scratch. SEGS has picked up a lot of steam since Summer 2018 and is closer to being able to produce a fully functional server than ever.
If the code adaptation succeeds, will SEGS be pointless?
Not exactly. SEGS has two main advantages: one is that it's a legal effort. The second is that a SEGS server will likely be better organized and more extensible than the game's actual code. That means the server will be easier to configure and modify, may use fewer resources, and will have the option to readily add new game content. There are other key advantages to an extensible solution, as well.
Is SEGS related to the other efforts?
No, SEGS is completely unrelated. They have not and will not be utilizing information from those working on the server code, as that would stand in the way of SEGS's legality.
---
The people working on this are doing so for the benefit of the community and we should show them our appreciation. There's a lot of misinformation going around lately, and it's important that we all get on the same page and focus on the goal of being able to play the game again in whatever form that takes.
Again, let me know if there's anything I've missed or gotten wrong, or anything that I need to clarify, and I can update the post accordingly.