r/Citizenship • u/Embarrassed_Fig2796 • Nov 27 '25
r/Citizenship
•
u/my_hope_
•
Oct 11 '26
Man has to prove his citizenship šš
Also the fact that nothing proves your citizenship, not DL,not PAN, not Aadhar (it has literally no value now), not a passport (it's just a travelling document) , and not even a birth certificate. They say a group of documents prove it, but all the above combined won't prove anything. Lol
r/Citizenship • u/Sea-Falcon-6315 • Aug 31 '26
Chinese citizen with Canadian PR, moving to the U.S. to acquire a green card, should I pursue Canadian citizenship or let my PR go?
Hey guys, I need advice and insights from people who have dealt with complicated immigration and citizenship situations. I am currently a Chinese citizen and Canadian permanent resident. In the near future, I expect to move to the United States with my partner(U.S. citizen and we are married) and eventually become a U.S. green card holder through consulate process.
This has created a difficult dilemma for me because I donāt know which status I should prioritize long-term.
On one hand, I genuinely like Canada and would like to keep the option of living here in the future. I see Canada as a potential long-term backup or as an exit plan in case life in the U.S. doesnāt work out or I eventually decide that I prefer living in Canada. On the other hand, I also have strong reasons for wanting to maintain my connection with China. My entire family is there, and I can imagine potentially wanting to spend significant time there later in life, especially as my parents get older. I also wonder about practical issues such as medical care and inheritance/property matters involving family members in China.
The problem is that I realistically cannot maintain Canadian PR indefinitely while living primarily in the United States. Canada requires permanent residents to meet the residency obligation, while U.S. permanent residence also requires maintaining residence in the U.S. It seems that trying to genuinely maintain both statuses long-term would be extremely difficult or impossible.
So I see a few possible paths:
Option 1: Apply for Canadian citizenship before moving to the U.S. This would allow me to keep the right to live in Canada permanently without worrying about the PR residency obligation. However, China does not recognize dual citizenship. I am concerned about the consequences of acquiring Canadian citizenship while also wanting to maintain a legal and practical connection to China. This is an area where the laws and actual enforcement can be complicated, and I do not want to make decisions based on assumptions or try to hide anything from any government even though the U.S. would be a great buffer country where I'd only head back to China with American green card, however if China finds out my dual citizenship, Iām not sure if I will be able to take the consequences or accept the penalties.
Option 2: Keep Canadian PR and move to the U.S. I could keep my PR status valid for some more time until 2031 and move to the U.S. to see whether I actually like living there. If I decide within a few years that the U.S. isnāt for me, I could potentially return to Canada while my status is still valid, fulfill my residency obligations then re-establish my life in Canada again. The downside is that this seems like kicking the decision down the road. If I eventually spend too much time outside Canada, I may lose my PR status anyway.
Option 3: Give up the possibility of Canada and focus on the U.S. This would probably be the simplest from an immigration perspective, but emotionally it feels difficult. I have built a life in Canada, I like it here, and donāt necessarily want to permanently close the door on returning one day.
I realize nobody can make this decision for me, and I will eventually speak to qualified immigration lawyers in the relevant countries. But I would really appreciate hearing from people who have been in similar situations.
How did you decide between maintaining permanent residency versus obtaining citizenship when another country did not recognize dual citizenship? Would you prioritize securing Canadian citizenship as a long-term backup, or would you avoid the potential complications with China and simply accept that moving to the U.S. may eventually mean giving up the option of living in Canada?
Iām especially interested in perspectives from people who have had to choose between citizenship in one country, permanent residency in another, and maintaining family ties in their country of origin. Thank you.
EDIT: Thank you everyone for replying!
Iām honestly very surprised by how many people took the time to respond and share their experiences and advice.
After reading through everything, Iāve made my decision to move forward with applying for Canadian citizenship. Thank you all so much for your advice and perspectives, they were genuinely helpful in making my decision!
r/Citizenship • u/Street-Reflection944 • Jan 12 '26
Uā.āS. Citizens Should Not Wait Behind Unlawful Immigration Cases
A United States citizen who legally marries abroad and files Form I-130 to bring their spouse home should not be forced to wait years while other immigration cases, including unlawful or discretionary cases, move through the system faster.
American-born citizens follow the law, pay the required fees, submit complete documentation, and comply with every requirement. Yet many families remain separated for excessive periods due to USCIS backlogs and misaligned processing priorities.
Family unity for U.S. citizens should be a top priority. Lawful petitions filed by American citizens should be processed efficiently and fairly, not delayed behind cases that do not carry the same legal standing.
We urge Congressman Jimmy Patronis and Congress to take action to:
Prioritize I-130 petitions filed by United States citizens Reduce unnecessary backlogs and delays for petitions filed by United States Citizens Improve accountability and processing efficiency at USCIS
This is about prioritizing Americans, respecting lawful immigration, and restoring common-sense priorities.
Sign to support faster I-130 processing for U.S. citizens and their spouses.
r/Citizenship • u/That1PercyJacksonFan • Jul 03 '26
Why should birthright citizenship be upheld?
My father, quite insistently, told me that birthright citizenship should be eliminated. He talked about "birth tourism" and how people from countries that hate the USA have children within the United States while traveling, having a child with dual citizenship, and using that child as a "spy" or to interfere with the governmental systems.
I was wondering what other people's thoughts were. I think it is good to get other people's opinions that are beyond my very limited perspective.
r/Citizenship • u/Equal_Leading_1449 • Sep 13 '26
Do you think the US will ever change citizenship laws and extend it to grandchildren of US citizens?
Purely a hypothetical question as This seems highly unlikely to happen rn. But, basically, my grandfather is a US citizen, born & raised in Texas, moved to the UK in the late 60s. Dad was born over here, then I was born here too.
AFAIK, right now USA citizenship only extends to children of USA citizens.
Do you think it could ever change? Canada I think recently made it much easier to get Canadian citizenship, Mexico did too, you can now claim citizenship in canada or mexico through the unbroken chain rule, which basically means you can go as far back as you need to ( even further than great great grandparents in some cases).
So what about the US, probably not now sure, but perhaps in 20 yrs or something. Maybe the government will review this and approve of people being able to claim US citizenship from grandparents?
r/Citizenship • u/Dead-flowers-96 • Jul 04 '25
Can we please retire the word āanchor babyā? Itās wildly inaccurate.
Can we please retire the word āanchor babyā? Itās wildly inaccurate.
First off, having a baby in the U.S. does not automatically guarantee citizenship to anyone but the baby.
Secondly, most people coming to the U.S. are here because theyāre afraid to be in their own countryāor theyāre hoping America will offer them a better life. Or both.
That being said, there should be ways to allow families to stay together. How can you say youāre āpro-lifeā or āpro-familyā otherwise?
Why not offer temporary visas or create a workerās residency classāa citizen class that teaches real, practical knowledge, not just presidents and dates?
r/Citizenship • u/onepiece1389 • Dec 25 '25
Advice needed: choosing a country for citizenship
Hi everyone,
Iām looking for advice on which country makes the most sense to aim for long-term residency with a realistic path to citizenship. Iāve done quite a bit of research and read many posts here, but Iād appreciate perspectives from people with lived experience.
Iām mainly considering EU countries, specifically Germany, France, Belgium, and Portugal, since they all have a ~5-year residency requirement for citizenship, which is why theyāre on my radar. Iām fully willing (and actually happy) to learn the local language.
My plan would be to study first (Masterās degree) and then work.
Some context / constraints:
Germany: seems very stable and rule-based, which I like, but the issue is that most public universities require the Masterās to closely match your Bachelorās. My Bachelorās is not directly related to what I want to study, so Germany doesnāt seem like my strongest option unless I go private.
France & Belgium: I would genuinely love to learn French, which is why Iām strongly considering these two. However, I keep hearing that France is very slow and unpredictable when it comes to citizenship, and many people advise against it. Belgium seems more administrative and clear, but Iād love to hear from people who went through the study ā work ā citizenship route there.
Portugal: also on my list because of the 5-year rule, but I hear mixed things about bureaucracy and delays.
For background: Iāve already lived abroad long-term , 6 years in South Korea (Iām not Korean). Citizenship there is extremely difficult, and Iāve decided itās not where I want to stay long term.
Because of that experience, I really value a process that is reliable, rule-based, realistic and preferably fastest
Iām also looking at Argentina and Brazil, since their naturalization timelines seem much faster, but Iām unsure how they compare long-term versus the EU in terms of stability and prospects.
Thanks in advance, and please be kind Iām genuinely trying to make a thoughtful long-term decision :)))
EDIT:
I am from Sudan, forget to mention that hahhaa
r/Citizenship • u/Mysterious_Body_352 • Nov 29 '25
America: then and now
A personal memory from an immigrant who arrived 61 years ago
When my mother and 14-year-old sister came to America in the early 1960s, the process was incredibly strict. They waited many years for their turn. A man from the Cleveland Symphony signed an affidavit promising that if we ever needed help, he would personally support us for five years. No government assistance of any kind.
When I finally arrived two years laterāafter serving in the Israeli armyāI remember the intensity of the immigration interview. I was asked unexpected and uncomfortable questions:
āHave you ever been with a prostitute?ā āHave you ever had any contact with a communist?ā āDo you have friends who have had contact with a communist?ā
My medical exam was equally detailed. Eyes, throat, chestāeverything was checked. At that time, anyone with serious illness was simply not admitted.
I still remember how nervous I was walking in. I was 20 years old, alone, hoping for a chance at a new life. When they finally stamped my papers and let me in, I felt gratitude I still carry today.
Life in America back then felt different. I could walk at midnight alone in the street without fear. People seemed calmer. Cities felt smaller, slower, and more connected.
Iām not judging todayās world, and Iām not arguing politicsāIām simply reflecting on how much has changed since 1964 and how different the immigrant experience was in those days.
Iād love to hear how others remember those earlier years, or what their own immigration experience was like.
r/Citizenship • u/IWishMusicKilledKate • May 02 '25
Dual āCitizenshipā - US/West Bank
My husband was born and raised in the West Bank and immigrated to the states as an adult. He recently naturalized and now holds US citizenship and residency in the West Bank (technically people in the West Bank are stateless).
We have two children - are there any positives to getting them PA issued travel documents and a hawiya (ID card/residency)? We donāt have any plans to live in the West Bank, just short term visits, but this would allow the kids extended visits as they grow up. My husbandās family does have property they would like to leave to him/his children which I believe they need these documents for.
My husband also has family in the 48 and it is my understanding that the children and I can travel through Ben Gurion to see them if we donāt get the kids their hawiya, and they will be under much less scrutiny then if they have it.
r/Citizenship • u/CheekOver3563 • Jul 07 '25
Citizenship interview canceled
Hey everyone, please I do apply for citizenship a day before my husband, we got fingerprint appointment 4 days separately and now we get interview his is the 14th and mine on the 17th but then they cancel his interview till now and he is anxious š. Please is there a reason for that cancelation?
r/Citizenship • u/Clear_Leather_9868 • Jun 14 '26
Can a person who live in Singapore for long time say he come from Singapore??
My English is not that good, so I am very confused if a person who is not citizen or pr of one country, can he say he come from this country after living long time.
His background: he went to Singapore to study from 14 years old until 25 years old. Then we met in Australia in his 26 years old.
I asked him two time about where are you come from, he said Singapore. Until I asked him āare you Singapore citizenā he said he is Indian citizen but he live in Singapore very long time, therefore,he said he come from Singapore.
The first time, I ask him which country people you are(my English was too shit at that time), he said Singapore.
The second time, I asked him āwhere are you come fromā, he said Singapore.
r/Citizenship • u/ThatNasusQ • Sep 12 '25
Triple Citizenship Eligible?
Hello all, wondering if anyone would have some insight into this?
My grandfather was born in Canada in the 1930's and moved to the US when he was a child. He Joined the Navy and was stationed in Scotland for 4 years. While he was there, my father was born off base in a Scottish hospital in the 60's. Would I as a US citizen, be eligible for citizenship in either or both of those countries under the recent proposed Canadian changes and current Scottish laws?
Thank you for any help!
r/Citizenship • u/akostta • Aug 28 '26
Dutch or British citizenship?
I am Non-EU citizen living currently in the UK for the past 4 years. I should be eligible for ILR in 18 months through being Skilled Worker here, which is something like green card / permanent settlement visa.
Also Iām married to a Dutch citizen, so I should be eligible for Dutch citizenship in 24 months.
If I acquire Dutch citizenship, I wouldnāt be able to get British citizenship, but could keep my ILR. Farage though threatens to abolish ILR, which worries me, but I am not sure what would be the likelihood of that.
Being British citizen definitely feels more secure, as I have a mortgage and stable job here, lived here long enough and I have never lived in the Netherlands, even though I visit my spouseās family often.
I love Dutch culture though, including language, music etc, I could see myself living there at some point, but it is so bloody expensive there, especially with housing, not sure if I would be able to afford it even with citizenship.
I do like idea having access to the EU as well, would be nice to have the freedom of travel and option to retire there at some point.
What would be best choose:
- Dutch citizenship + British ILR (with potential for travel / relocation but risk of losing access to UK);
- British citizenship (security in known location, but without freedom of travel)?
r/Citizenship • u/Easy-Drummer-1595 • Aug 31 '25
How likely is it for me to get Polish citizenship if I apply?
Hello everyone, I am a US citizen (M20) and I am thinking about applying for Polish citizenship. My grandfather was born in Poland but escaped during the Holocaust (we are Jewish). He moved around a lot in Europe before coming to the US. He became a US citizen and also regained his Polish citizenship after being in the US for a while.
My dad (grandfathers son) was born in the US and never became a Polish citizen.
I am not sure what the chances of getting citizenship are for myself. I live near D.C. so I could try to make an appointment at the Polish Embassy but I wanted some advice from other people first before I really get started.
If I were to get citizenship, what documents of mine and my grandfathers would be required? If I dont have his documents anymore is there still any hope for me? Also, how long would the citizenship process take?
r/Citizenship • u/Deep_Bass_9659 • Aug 15 '26
URGENT Am I a British Citizen? What do I do if not? Am I going to be paying international tuition fees? Should I get a British Passport?
Hi, this is my first time posting so I donāt really know reddit etiquette and whatnot, but that is besides the point! This is going to be a long one and potentially confusing one that is going to be posted on multiple groups(?) for maximum efficiency. If you can maybe help that would be VERY APPRECIATED!
I am a 18F who was born in London and has lived in London my entire life, my mum however is a Dutch immigrant and my father is African but is not in the picture and hasnāt been.
My mum and I have dutch passports, EVISAs, share codes and indefinite leave however, I had only found this out this year as I was/have applied to universities. I was accepted into my firm 2 days ago and am currently spiralling because of the enrolment process.
My uni has marked me as a āUK based overseasā whilst I was completing the first stage of questions and I guess I am spiralling over whether I am paying home tuition fees or international tuition fees.
I decided to do further research into what UK based overseas meant and it lead me to looking at who qualifies as a British Citizen⦠It claimed:
If at least one of your parents was a citizen of an EU or EEA country when you were born
Youāre automatically a British citizen if when you were born all the following applied to at least one of your parents:
they had citizenship of a country that was in the EU or the EEA at the time
they lived in the UK
they had āindefinite leave to remainā (ILR), āsettled statusā, āpermanent residence statusā, āright of abodeā or āright of re-admissionā
My mum lived in the Uk at the time of my birth, i can see it on my birth certificate however, when i asked if she had ILR she said she did and that she had this blue card. I donāt know if this blue card is valid anymore or how to go about this anymore. I donāt know if I am a British citizen or if I am eligible for a British passport or if I am going to pay international tuition fees?!?!?
Any advice is appreciated, I am genuinely spiralling. If anyone needs more information to try and help I would be happy to provide I just genuinely donāt know what to do. Thank you for reading.
r/Citizenship • u/Wolfman1961 • May 13 '25
Could I become a Russian citizen?
My grandmother was born in Minsk in 1904. It was within the Russian Empire then. She was Jewish. Could I conceivably become a Russian citizen as a result?
r/Citizenship • u/2hot4war • Dec 17 '25
UK citizenship by birth right(urgent help)
Hi, I need help urgently please. I need someone to countersign my passport application but I don't know anyone in the UK since I lived in the US till now. I have citizenship through my mom who is a UK citizenship that moved to the States with her family when she was younger. She never got me a UK passport but I have all the needed paperwork. The only issue is that the passport application is done online so they need someone to verify my identity(they call it countersign) but that person has to be from the UK. I've been here in Glasgow, for two months now and I have asked acquaintances that I have met to do it, but they either haven't gotten approved or just didn't want to do it. The passport office website gives you a list of approved work industries where the person who is verifying your identity needs to have a job in. I barely know anyone here let alone someone that's a nurse or work in finance or owns a pub or any of those jobs that'd get approve. Please, I don't know what else to do, can anyone help me with this.
r/Citizenship • u/Various_Addition1574 • 12d ago
Application for citizenship in Canada
Good day, everyone! I just wanted to clarify something. I arrived in Canada in July 2022. Does this mean I am already eligible to meet the 3-year physical presence requirement for Canadian citizenship, or do I still need to wait?
If Iām not yet eligible, would it be possible to request a refund for the payment Iāve already made?
I would really appreciate your guidance and clarification on this. Thank you in advance for your help and for sharing your insights!
r/Citizenship • u/[deleted] • Jun 03 '25
Do I qualify for Spanish citizenship?
Grandmother is a Spanish citizen (not Spanish at birth), and I have held an American passport since birth. More context: both of my parents are American (but not at birth), and my family that does live in Spain with my grandmother still have their foreign passports if that matters at all.
r/Citizenship • u/Nix_Nix522 • Jun 16 '26
About being a citizen in the US
Hello i would like to confirm something that this thing will go well for my friend, my friend lately met a guy and already in a relationship for almost 4 months. The guy is from Texas, he want to take my friend and start living there, so my friend has a sister and her sister want to also go and live there (the sister have no plans to marry just work and live there). The Texas guy promised a life for both of them. He was like he will help the sister to get a job and start a new life there. My question is.. is this legal? Like after my friend will marry the Guy then the sister can also live there i mean in instant? I wanna know the details and possibly waiting time also what is being citizen and being a green card holder differences?? I'm worried about my friend and her sister...
r/Citizenship • u/[deleted] • Jul 18 '25
What should I respond to question such as ''where are you really from? or what is your original nation''?
I am EU citizen (of course in that conversation, I mentioned my home country in Europe), but I do not look white. Sometimes I travelled and people asked me ''where you from? I said: I am from EU'' then they question one more time ''where are you actually from? you do not look like EU people''
I really do get disturbed and annoyed by that, sometimes I had to be polite to reply but I feel deeply that I am quite EU citizen, of course my ethnicity is not but it has nothing to do with me being EU citizen.
What should I answer next time?
r/Citizenship • u/dondougdondoug • Jul 16 '26
Brazilian living in the UK since age of 12, now 19. Has no british paperwork, only brazilian birth certificate. He says he was adopted by an italian lady (who had dual citzenship, she had/possibly has a uk passport) when he was 15. I have no paperwork to prove this. England
He has no right to work and doesnt know where to turn. He is worried about going to the authorities as he is scared they will send him to brazil, where he has no family. I have met this young man through a colleague and I am trying to help him get a decent start in life.
My questions are -
How do I approach right to work for him?
Does the fact hes been here since the age 12 and for now 7 years help with anything?
How can I find out if the adoption took place legally? (I can obtain the ladies details but she is currently unreachable and most likely out of the country)
Any other advice would be great. I have looked online but to no avial.
Thanks in advance
r/Citizenship • u/sunsetair • Mar 25 '25
Naturalized US citizen. Should I reach out to the Hungarian embassy to renounce my citizenship?
Should I contact the Hungarian embassy and request to give up my Hungarian citizenship?
I'm reading about it, I'm a bit confused.
For naturalized citizens the following policy is in effect.
Renunciation of Allegiance: The Oath of Allegiance requires you to declare that you "absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty, of whom or which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen".Ā
Oath of Allegiance: This oath is a formal declaration of loyalty to the United States and its Constitution, and it is a crucial part of the naturalization process.Ā
No Obligation to Give Up Passport: While you renounce allegiance to other countries, the U.S. government does not require you to give up your passport from your home country if that country allows dual citizenship.Ā
USCIS Policy: The USCIS policy manual states that an applicant must show that they intend to give up their former citizenship and that they do so voluntarily.Ā
r/Citizenship • u/Virtual_Regret6328 • Jun 30 '25
Birthright Citizenship
What happened if Birth Rights Citizenship is overturned and in you are traveling and have a layover in a state that doesnāt recognize Birthright citizenship and there laws are different then your home state,as a American born here 5 generations deep can I be detained just for being in one of those states if there laws are different, is this even a possibility?