r/CitiesSkylines • • Mar 28 '24

Discussion Modders beware - Paradox Mods

0 Upvotes

Always read the fine print. Anything you upload to Paradox Mods is then owned by Paradox along with the rights to sell it without cutting you in later down the line should they so desire.

They say it's for the good of the console players but as always it's just all about the money with this game. I urge modders to be cautious when it comes to Paradox Mods. I have modded for CS1 and I personally will not be supporting the CS2 modding platform.


r/CitiesSkylines • • May 28 '25

Tips & Guides Quick Guide on a Chance to get a Refund from Steam for Cities Skylines 2.

3 Upvotes

I pre-ordered the game for 90€ almost 2 Years ago, but never played it, because I wanted to wait and see if they make a comeback like No Man's Sky or Cyberpunk and manage to fix the game. After seeing the latest news about the upcoming patch and the DLC delay, watched a few up to date review's and I was very disappointed. So I tried to get a refund – and surprisingly it worked.

So here is a small Guide what I wrote in my Refund Request.

  1. Polite intro + acknowledge refund policy

Example: “I am requesting a refund for Cities: Skylines II, even though I understand the standard refund period has passed.”

2. Explain ongoing issues with the game

Poor performance, crashes, bugs

Missing or incomplete features compared to predecessor

Repeated delays of promised content or DLC

Example: “The game remains unfinished more than a year after release, with ongoing technical problems and missing core features.”

3. Mention prepaid DLC that hasn’t been delivered

Example: “Additionally, I pre-purchased DLC that has been repeatedly delayed without clear updates.”

4. Address Steam’s role as platform and customer fairness

Example: “As Steam is a leading platform, I believe it should ensure products meet reasonable quality standards and treat customers fairly.”

5. Kindly ask for goodwill exception

Example: “I kindly ask you to consider this refund as an exception. Thank you for your understanding.”

Use this as a template for ChatGPT and maybe you will get a refund too.

Have a nice Day.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 16 '23

Discussion Am I the only one that kinda scared about "citizens fashion"?

0 Upvotes

After one month of teasers and content creator videos, I really like the direction the game is heading towards and I love the realistic artistic direction of City Skylines 2 (no more bright pink donut van).

But i feel like the citizens are way too much detailed for a city simulator. For me it's kinda useless to see them wear coats in winter and shorts in summer. Plus Their clothes are cliping trought each layers and honestly they look like ugly unity assets.

The models in CS1 where less detailed and that made them, in my opinion, better looking. I don't want to lose simulation power for citizens when the game is that demanding. I feel it's such a small detail, that so much energy was wasted on this when they could have stick to less detailed models.

Most video we saw of gameplay was with 30 000 to 40 000 peoples on high end computers, but in CS1 I could hit 50k people, and the simulation started to slow down, untill 70k where i was stuck on x1 speed, but still be able to hit 100K without massive FPS drops. With the gameplay of youtubers we were able to watch, they where stuck of level 12 wich is half of the milestones, wich means we didn't see how stable the game is after this (ik it wasn't the definitive version). I watched a video from FewCandy i noticed big FPS drops, idk what her spec is but it's a bit concerning.

I hope there is a way to have less detail citizens or that I'm over reacting. But that's something that a lot of people just ignored, because there is so much more about the game, that it flew over our heads. Can you guys reassure me ?

PS: Sorry for grammatical errors english is my 2nd language.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Aug 07 '24

Sharing a City Small Israeli Town

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 19 '23

Sharing a City 3rd city in a row at 93%+🚦 with tmpe No despawn. Point proven?🚦🐐🏗🖤

5 Upvotes

r/CitiesSkylines • • Nov 26 '23

Game Feedback CO have got their priorities wrong imho

14 Upvotes

TL;DR at the bottom

CO have said they will not be putting out any smaller patches now, instead concentrating on what they believe will lead to meaningful performance improvements.

the team is now focusing on LODs and improving GPU performances, and while geometric LODs are largely automated, there are a ton of tweaks and adjustments required. We are expecting a relevant performance boost with these asset fixes.

Cool, except they are looking in the wrong place for a meaningful impact to the player experience imho

Thing is, there's not really a burning need to solve the GPU issue more than there is to solve the cpu issue, or rather the things tanking the simulation.

I made this post 18 days ago about my experience with a Ryzen 2700X and 1080 Ti. I reached the limit around 100K.

So firstly, out of interest I ran the same save game on linux, and got the city to 120K before reaching the same degradation in simulation. I did expect it to run better, even though CS2 is not a native linux app, but was surprised at how much I could extend the city.

The reason for mentioning that is because the final city pop I will be using for justification of what I say is inflated by the better performance on linux.

Now the point of this post is to show that it is the simulation that we need a patch for not the LODs which are ofc needed, but what's the point of watching a failing simulation at 150+ fps, it won't look any better than the same failing simulation at 25 fps.

Okay let's get to the point of this post.

Today I got that same city up to 150K, that's another 30K using the same hardware, without rebuilding any part of the city.

So what did I do?

  • OC the CPU

  • OC the GPU

  • OC the RAM

Nope, they are still running stock.

What I did was to load two mods

  • A phased traffic lights with lane control mod

  • A pedestrian pathfinding mod

I then spent some time going around changing the lane configuration on my junctions and changing the TL phasing.

And because of those two mods and a little bit of configuration work, I now have no meaningful traffic jams in my city.

The cars are behaving themselves at junctions and following the proper lanes, without doing whacky U-Turns, while allowing other traffic to pass in a civilised manner, and letting pedestrians cross, who are behaving themselves huddling like colonies of Emperor Penguins by the lights.

Also the bat shit crazy suicidal cims are using every walkway and subway I create no matter how long or how far back from the junction or how outrageous in design, they no longer jaywalk.

Because I now have the ability to control which lanes go where, and phased traffic lights, with dedicated pedestrian phases, and can plop walkways/subways at will to move the cims off the surface, my traffic is flowing around the city and my simulation is no longer tanking due to grinding blockages at more or less every junction small or large.

Cars are whizzing along the motorway, planes are shooting through the sky, trains are hurtling along the tracks, cims are like busy ants scurrying all over the place. My 1080 Ti is shrugging CS2 off.

It was like I did OC my cpu, and ram. For a while at least, I've still capped at around 150K but those two mods have added 30K to my city.

So imho CO should be prioritising balancing the driving AI, the pathfinding, lane control and anything else that degrades the simulation, because not having the cities grinding to a halt while the simulation tries to recalculate thousands of bad pathfinding decisions every cycle, and dealing with the effects of the bad pathfinding every tick, will have more of a meaningful impact on performance than the LODs will.

I'll say again, whatever issues are with LODs that CO feel the need to drop everything else for, my 1080 Ti a 6 year old tech does not seem to agree with them, as long as the traffic and cims are able to move around the graphics do not impact my gaming experience.

Also the mod platform, because these mods are not as efficient as the CO platform mods will be, and are rudimentary in function compared to the full mods that will come with release of the platform, for example you cannot tune the duration of the traffic light phases.

The modders work will have a meaningful impact on the user experience both in QoL and performance, just as they did in CS1.

ofc you may not want to use a traffic light & lane control mod regardless of the benefits it provides, because apparently according to some vocal people, tinkering with traffic light phases and lane control is a niche enthusiast pleasure.

But the pedestrian pathfinding mod is a load and forget mod. It's passive in nature, which when running makes the cims prefer walkways and subways over surface crossings, freeing your traffic passing through junctions everywhere you place one of those ridiculous walkway/subway ramps we have been cursed with that any self respecting cim laughs at as they run across the roads blocking the traffic.

One remaining area of impact to the traffic flow that the pedestrian mod does not solve, which will no doubt require CO devs to address, is cims walking across the entrances to car parks.

It seems the game is tuned for right of way for pedestrians. Which is great but when your city is even at a fledgling size, the amount of foot traffic passing a car park can clog up your networks for miles around, as cars sit in the middle of the road waiting for the cims to clear the way so they can enter the car park.

You can alleviate the problem by moving car parks to local roads away from the foot traffic, but that is not solving the underlying the issue, you're simply moving the location of the problem.

So there you have it, two mods that gave me an extra 30K pop by freeing the simulation, and even when the game slowed down as I reached my new cap, the motion of the cims is still smooth, it is not freezing and abruptly stuttering, just a graceful slowdown in motion.

TL;DR

My conclusion is that CO should concentrate on solving the AI pathfinding, providing phased traffic lights, and other areas that affect the simulation such as cims crossing car park entrances. Also releasing the mod editor/platform.

Having a higher fps is nice but does no good if the simulation is grinding to a halt. I don't want a 200 fps splash screen which is what the game looks like every time the sim tanks.

imho ofc


r/CitiesSkylines • • Feb 14 '25

Sharing a City No matter how good CS2 gets, the beauty of CS1 is unmatched.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/CitiesSkylines • • Dec 04 '23

Discussion I think i understand what the CEO meant when they said what they said.

312 Upvotes

The game is supposed to be a management and builder sandbox. The goal is not supposed to revolve around struggling with money, but this community is constantly asking for a challenging money making game. If you want such a challenging money making simulation, "this might not be the game for you" and i think they are right.

Why you should stop caring about money in city builder/management games.

Money has always been easy and does not matter in these games because it's impossible to create and balance a system of supply and demand around tax and exports. There is always a very easy way to cheese the game for income and once you have learned the games limitations and build a city designed for income it's basically impossible to lose. But the other problem is that the game is not designed to be won or lost, it's suppose to be a sandbox game where you just relax managing and building a city.

You're not supposed to be on the edge of your seat worried about losing your entire build due to cash flow issues. you're not suppose to lose an entire build because some complicated mechanic you can't figure out has completely ruined the economy of your city.

earning money in the game is simple, all you need to do is penny pinch for the first hour of the build and make a small efficient town that generates tax revenue. At that point you practically won the money mini game. start adding industry and export everything possible, congrats you have completely destroyed the money mini game and run to the forum complaining it's too easy.

I dont understand this constant desire for a challenging economy in a sandbox. what is so fun about watching the number go up and down? meanwhile everyone uses every exploit to make money as easily as possible. If you actually want a challenge then dont exploit the game.

the best part of the game is creative building and watching the simulation run, meanwhile half yall are cranking taxes to -10%, staring at graphs and number counters the entire time trying to boost that number to the stratosphere. this sub has twice as many posts showing the budget panel than there are screen shots of the build.

stop caring about your fake money and build a cool city!


r/CitiesSkylines • • Feb 06 '24

Subreddit Feedback Are we allowed to criticize the game on this sub now that the content creators are speaking out against it?

12 Upvotes

There has been a climate of rejection and censoring on this sub towards criticism and negative feedback for last the month or so. Posts have been removed by mods and users commenting on posts regarding the poor state of the game are being downvoted and lambasted into oblivion.

I realize a good bit of the negative feedback is devoid of constructive or actionable feedback but I have seen some folks on this sub behave actively hostile towards any sort of negative feedback.

With the content creators beginning to speak up about the state of the game will the toxic positivity still remain on this sub? And can we finally all admit that this game is a mess?


r/CitiesSkylines • • Sep 24 '24

Game Feedback Why is this game stupid enough to not turn on autosave itself???

0 Upvotes

Lost 5 hours of progress on a new city that i was proud of as i just moved from cities skylines 1 to cities skylines 2. BUT WHY is the autosave not on by default, so dumb. Guess i need to start a brand new city :D


r/CitiesSkylines • • Nov 09 '23

Game Feedback We have 50k workers limit.

90 Upvotes

Apologies for the incorrect post title.

When we reach 1 million population, only 5% of our workers will travel to their workplaces. It's even worse than initially described. :)

According to this post, in a city with 1 million citizens, only 5% of workers and students will travel to their workplaces/study, and separately, 10% of citizens will have the opportunity to go shopping/leisure.

Before I knew about this post, I had conducted two tests (Test 1 and Test 2) where I counted workers who came to designated office and industry zones. I found out that only about 16% of workers came to the offices and 21% to the industry in a 98k city. It's pretty close to the limits indicated in the post.

What does this mean? This means that if you have a 5k office district while your city is at 50k, only 1100 workers will come and depart each day. When you reach 300k citizens, only 550 workers will come. So, you will need to designate less public transport in specific places the larger your city is.

Why don't we have a slider for that? If you have a good CPU, you can at least try to set this limit to 100%. For example, the Total War series has an option to change the quantity of soldiers in squads for over a decade.

Btw, in FEATURE HIGHLIGHT #2 Traffic AI CO stated:

'Also, as a major improvement to the first game in the series, Cities: Skylines II doesn’t feature hard limits for agents moving about in the city. Overall, the performance of the simulation and pathfinding is vastly improved which means larger populations are possible. The only real limits to the simulation are the hardware limitations on the platform running the game.'

That's totally not true.

We are limited right from the start. Even with 1000 citizens, only 40% of workers will make their rides to work.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 23 '23

Hype (Controversial) Something I want to make very clear

23 Upvotes

I am not a moderator or administrator in this subreddit, but I believe that I have to make this statement for any future criticism.

Lately I have been noticing a lot of controversy, backlash, and criticism in this subreddit. I have read numerous posts about unoptimization, the recent discovery of unoptimized cims, and many more controversial topics. I personally believe that criticism is completely fine without completely forcing it on others and immediately shutting down any counter arguments. However I need to make something very clear for everyone involved:

DO NOT ATTACK THE DEVELOPERS, EMPLOYEES, OR ANY CONTENT CREATOR ASSOCIATED WITH CITIES: SKYLINES 2 DIRECTLY.

In the end, criticism is not about attacking, bashing, or slandering, it is about giving constructive feedback, advice, and suggestions to help improve the game. There is stuff about CS2 that sucks and I completely get it, but one thing to keep in mind is that the average employee at CO or PDX does not deserve any personal attacks in any way. They do not control which direction the game is headed to, and they can't really do anything about it. There is no single entity, person, or company that is up for blame and/or attacking. I am not saying you cannot criticize the developers or the game, rather I am making the point that direct attacks on employees and companies should not be tolerated.

If you still want to hate on or be mad at CO or PDX then I can't do anything about that, but just try to keep it to yourself rather than take it all out in a whine post here.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 22 '23

Discussion Look like a lot of PC’s are in the same boat as us Mac users. The game is basically unplayable at launch for any older/low tier systems for now.

4 Upvotes

After reviewing the incredible work, that city planner plays did for us all - it’s really does seem like they are about to release a completely half finished game.

My plan was to play on GeForce now and hope it comes to Mac OS Arm chips next year. But I think I’ll wait for 6 months instead now. I don’t have much time to play anyways and I’d rather wait a half a year and hope that the game improves with time.

To all you lovely high end pc gamers who will buy the game at launch, I thank you. You’re the reason CO can make this game. Someone has to buy it at launch.

CO! We still believe in you. You created an amazing game that so many people adore. The only reason why you ever get negative feedback is because people so desperately want this game to play perfectly because we love what you have created so much.

Keep going! You got this.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Dec 23 '24

Sharing a City An intersection that doesn't need traffic lights

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 22 '23

Discussion Stop defending a technically disastrous release just because the same mistake was made 8 years ago

0 Upvotes

People on here acting like it's acceptable to release a game with horrible performance even on a Rtx4090 and newest processors just because "Well, I've been here for the release of CS1 and let me tell you, that was horrible as well." Wtf kind of reasoning is that? You're basically saying that they learned not a single thing from their previous horrible release.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Feb 07 '24

Discussion I have a feeling management sees us as a nuisance.

12 Upvotes

The latest wording in the WOW was extremely disrespectfull and came across as 'I have to keep doing this so here is some info what the devs wrote'. Why even mention that... I don't believe that as a CEO of a company, that was a mess up. That was deliberatly left in there. It felt like a 'now, tell me how you really feel' moment.

Then there's the fact that CO has several times said 'all gameplay goals have been reached' and 'if you don't like the simulation, the game is not for you' really hit home that gameplay wise not much will change. I am also under the assumption that DLC, which has to be a stand alone mechanic, will largely be assets, props, music and some sort or mini-game mechanic you finish in 2 hours a la CS1. I don't have high hopes they introduce more management or they would have already mentioned that, did polls or went into conversations with players or content creators.

I'm kept a positive light of this game since the launch, but I'm beginning to get disturbed...


r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 31 '23

Discussion I understand negativity isn't popular. But I'm sorry. I LOVE the Cities franchise. But this game is an absolute disaster in its current state

21 Upvotes

The fact that when I'm supposed to lose 15k an hour (or 300k an hour) I still only lose a dollar an update cycle, or the fact that I've got an RTX 4090 with a 13900k, and even with several graphics options DISABLED, I still get 22fps after building my city out a bit...I just don't know how rose-tinted the glasses have to be to actually praise the game in this state. It's not even beta. It's in an early alpha state. The sheer amount of missing content from Cities 1 would be one thing, since naturally, Paradox is known for their love of DLC, and by now, anyone who's buying Paradox products for a long time knows the deal. No one is going into a Paradox game blind. So I am okay with the lack of content to some extent.

But the sheer number of bugs, some of which include features that are not even complex from a programming standpoint, like getting the UI to correctly tell you if you're gaining or losing money -- this is the kind of stuff that makes me shake my head at people saying the release is "not so bad."

Obviously, good and bad are inherently subjective, and so there is no such thing as being "correct" or "incorrect." There's just confused and not confused. And I'm confused how anyone could give this a thumbs-up in its current state.

YES, it will obviously be fixed. There's no universe i which they don't eventually get this into shape. I just don't understand why they would not release this game as Early Access which would have been far more honest than what...what this is.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 24 '23

Game Feedback The technical state of the game is unacceptable

12 Upvotes

NOTE TO MODS: Stop deleting my posts, censorship is not the way to go because it will be review bombed either way for the state it has released.

For a game that is priced at 50$ and (reportedly) released as a game NOT in early access, it is shipped in a state that is unacceptable for a game at that price point.
My specs:
GPU: RTX 4070ti
CPU: i5-13600k
RAM: 32GB DDR5-6000

The performance:
At 4K (3860x2160) I get measly 10 FPS with (mostly) 99% GPU utilisation.

At 2K (2560x1440) it jumps up to 30 with (also mostly) 99% GPU utilisation.

The performance is tested AFTER using the performance guide linked here. This is abysmal, and a lack of day one patch to at least make it a bit playable is tragic. The map is EMPTY, I am afraid what will happen to cities above certain population threshold.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 25 '23

Discussion What is happening here?

6 Upvotes

How is everybody just covering their eyes and pretending everything is fine?

This is the sequel to a legendary game, delivered in a miserable state as a « finished » game.

Why is everybody minimising this disaster?

« They’ll fix it eventually »

« They talked about it in the q&a »

« Have you seen CS1 8 years ago in early access? »

How about « this is a shit product for $50 that doesn’t respect the consumers time, money and interest »

This game came out at least a year too early, and it’s not an early access.

They should’ve delayed the PC version too, but seeing how everyone is bending over and making excuses as paying customers, people get what they deserve I guess.

Double standards. Energy wouldn’t be the same if this was literally any other franchise or publisher/dev.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Feb 01 '23

Discussion My controversial opinions about Cities Skylines

6 Upvotes
  1. The game wouldn’t be as successful as it was without the ability to mod.

  2. The Demand System is unrealistic and extremely flawed with Industries.

  3. Industrial/Offices should be able to get built on the players accord with/without mods also they should be excluded from the demand system.

  4. Citizens AI systems are too simple and unintelligent.

  5. The game relies too heavily on growables.

  6. The base game should have a RICO system universally across all platforms.

  7. Asset creation should be universal to all (players can modify or create their own assets with in game structures)

  8. Parklife DLC was a bit of a letdown.

  9. Modern City Center/University City DLC is underrated.

  10. Not enough entertainment buildings and too many parks.

  11. Natural Disasters isn’t as bad as everyone makes it out to be.

  12. Snowfall shouldn’t even be a DLC it should be a mechanic in the base game. There also should be seasons implemented to tie into this.

  13. Plazas and Promenades isn’t worth buying.

  14. Mid Century Modern DLC is good cosmetically.

  15. The Deathcare system is trash.


r/CitiesSkylines • • May 09 '26

Discussion Does anyone actually use the curved road tool?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I never find myself using it, I only ever use straight or Freeform


r/CitiesSkylines • • Oct 17 '23

Discussion Cancelling pre-order as well?

0 Upvotes

No workshop support worries me. Proprietary mods page worries me. Not too long ago everyone tried to pounce on mods and monotise them. Even Steam did, Bethesda succeeded. If we have our own in game mods page, where the guarantee it'll remain open ended and not monetised?

Cities skylines came out of nowhere and was raised to the halo city building game only because if how free it was and casual the workshop was. Even I could upload mods with the press of a button using other mods for players to use whist using other peoples mods that were automatically references and marked as dependant. The self fulfilling loop will disspear that made the game what it is.

Last time I was this hyped for a game it was Cyberpunk 2077 and then prior to that it was Simcity 2013... :/ destruction follows the things I'm excited about, why can't we have nice things...

I've pre-order the ultimate version of Cities skylines 2 but getting cold feet now. My trust in nearly every is nearly disappeared apart from a Indies and I feel like we're right about to cross a bridge where Collosal Order joins the rest of the industry.

Any of you already commited and canceled the pre order? I feel like this is a lose/lose situation.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Jan 09 '23

Discussion It's 2023 AND,

3 Upvotes

The biggest challenge of the game is still the traffic. And it's only because the game has the dumbest AI ever designed and not changed for nearly 10 years. So the biggest challenge of the game is beating the AI's dumbness. How hard is it to patch the AI to take the quickest route rather than taking the shortest one. I know traffic can be a fun challenge but after a while you get too carried away dealing with roads and planning every single lane and miss the beauty of your city and the game.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Jan 23 '24

Discussion It's Dead, Jim

0 Upvotes

The trust is broken. The alliance, shattered. To cope with the monetary losses of an already 3 years late game development, Paradox threw CO under the bus by making them release an Early Access game. But with this, they lost more than money, they lost trust.

Will the game recover, like Cyberpunk 2077? Or will it fail, like Sim City 2013?

What should be the priorities, in your opinion? Does them align with CO/Paradox priorities? Discuss here, but remember to be respectful and make constructive criticism.


r/CitiesSkylines • • Feb 20 '24

Game Feedback "Cities: Skylines 2 is garbage, and this is why"

26 Upvotes

So.

I promised myself I wouldn't write these anymore because they're not healthy. I have a pathological habit of checking up on comprehensive writing such as this and so I'll probably have to turn off notifications in the unlikely event this gets any traction. But.

C:S II is bad, and this is why.

i. The Whole Shebang

There's a lot of small improvements in C:S II that are very welcome. These are very basic quality-of-life things that I can't imagine were easy to make as intuitive as they've become; the road tool improvements, infinite terraforming, base-game industrial specialization and so on. These are simple and they work. The game's basic design is also undoubtedly an improvement from C:S 1 - just the fact you have alternatives to mass expansion to unlock more things is a great achievement already.

That's where my praise for C:S II ends.

I'm not quite sure where to start in a review of C:S II, but I suppose I should begin with my abortive first city. I booted up a game on the Barrier Island map and began planning out a mid-sized American/British city. This was where I discovered some of the problems that have continued to plague my playthroughs of the game:

  • Awful Communication. The game simply does not tell you what is causing your problems. If you're losing money, the game doesn't really offer you a reason as to why your population isn't paying taxes or why the industries you're specializing into are giving you such arbitrarily low income. When there is a clear cause, the game makes it super non-obvious as to what might be happening, and forces you to actively scrounge your own city to figure out what's going on.

  • Aesthetic Crisis. Much of the game looks pretty in isolation, but is damningly ugly without significant fenangling. The fact that the base game does not have most basic prop tools, the surface painter or even the ability to control what kind of buildings generate and how makes the aesthetic of C:S II borderline blinding.

  • Bad Economics. There's no other way to put it. C:S II's economics are confusing, faulty, and come close to the idiotic approximations of mainline Paradox games such as Victoria III or EU4. The bad economics are especially underlined by a lack of control, a lack of ability to regulate or encourage certain industries and sectors, and an extremely strange relationship to transport and time.

  • Idiosyncratic Simulation. Large parts of the simulation simply do not make sense. Why are my cims all rentiers? Why are they suffering from high land value on land they could own - why can't they own land? Why do cars have an inordinately high chance to just refuse to use main arterials and highways? How on earth do cims decide to use public transport - what even are the rules here?

Rather than breaking down the review into these four themes, I'm going to bring them up as I go through this because they all contribute to my overall ideas of what the game simply lacks at the moment. They're also very interrelated, which makes isolating them a bit difficult and frankly unnecessary.

ii. Cities: Skylines 2 carries over almost all of the first game's bad ideas

Zoning depth in C:S 1, its intricacies and how it worked, have always been awful. The simply arbitrary way zones seem to disappear and appear, and the fact they are inextricably linked to roads, forms a huge part of the restrictions for players in the base game. In my opinion, this is also an enormous part of why modding became necessary to make more immersive cities: you were actively fighting to remove weird triangular or circular gaps that in a real city would be filled just by making non-cuboidal shapes. This doesn't even mention the way that the base game made junctions and roads look awful in an extremely cheap way, and never tutorialized basic design techniques, making traffic a nightmare for the average player.

So why did the latter get fixed and not the former? I'll avoid speculating on whether or not it's a consequence of the infrastructure being constructed by modders; because in either case it has the same effect. You can build very pretty road networks and then an infinite American suburb. The game is intolerant of having the vast majority of buildings touch to a prodigious degree that buildings which would be fine clustered together, in small town squares or centers, are strange standalones. The first game had this exact issue, forcing players to mod in solutions!

But even ignoring the basic element of immersion or detail, the zoning depth system also fosters a complete reliance on roadbuilding, another major problem in the first game. The first game is not merely car-centric but in large parts hostile to public transport; buses, trams and other public transport by default will simply compete with cars for traffic space and contribute to enormous jams. With enough skill, this could be mitigated, but at its core it would still prioritize cars in every way. The extraordinarily curious part is that this has a built-in mitigator in the base game: the industrial zoning tool. Why couldn't that have been expanded, used to give us more variably sized lots and change the way our buildings look? What was stopping them?

The obvious answer is 'normal programming limits'. I can't imagine this is easy. But whatever the cause, the end result is still the same. And this applies to a lot more, so let's round-roulette this-

  1. The game retains a strong reliance on Euclidean zoning and has no capacity to model an alternative. Even mixed-use zoning doesn't really help with this, with the mixed-use type seemingly solely existing to answer player complaints that they couldn't do it previously. The even more egregious fact that office spaces and industrial spaces have no mixed-uses with other types, or the fact that the game seems to consider industry to solely encompass heavy industry, makes more interesting specialization and development borderline impossible.

  2. The game has a completely bonkers economic model, especially with taxes. In particular, the game continues to retain the 'abstract everything' model of the first game, where businesses and goods can't really be controlled outside of a specific few. Especially infuriatingly, the game incorporates elements from C:S 1's Industries DLC into the basegame, meaning you can see warehouses, production facilities and others sitting in your industry, making the most effective basegame method of specialization rolling for companies. Independent self-provision based on consumer need must apparently be a conspiracy concocted by the deep state.

  3. Service needs in C:S II are borderline nonexistent. It's exactly the problem C:S 1 had, only made more obvious because they made a whole hoo-hah about being able to build modular buildings. Modular buildings whose effects don't prevent the need to spam buildings, but simply delay when you have to do so.

  4. The game retains C:S 1's hostile waters and the difficulty of manipulating them, though in the weirdest way.

Hang on.

That water.

iii. Cities: Skylines 2 actively regresses in many ways from the first game

That damn water has been the bane of my existence.

Does it evaporate? I'm not sure. Does it rise and fall naturally with the seasons? Looks like it sometimes does? Again, the game barely knows how to communicate, which makes this utterly infuriating. The fact that the developer has to clarify basic elements in a weekly diary is madness - that diary should be for detailing development progress and patches, not telling people how the most basic systems in the game work.

Sure, water in C:S 1 was also bad, but it was functional. You understood the basics of maintaining flow, diverting water into other places, and how the whole thing works. In C:S II, not only is it opaque, it actively gets in the way of terraforming or even building any coastal structures. The water level height is never communicated properly, how on earth you're meant to divert water given it seems to simply disappear and then occasinally make its way up onto land once you do so isn't clear either, and the relation with the weather is also blurry.

The fact that quays do not exist is atrocious. The fact that players have had to effectively trick the game into giving them nice quays is even worse. Entire cities have been rendered effectively impossible without mods, when they were still reasonably achievable in C:S 1!

And this applies to the economy most of all. After building a basic but functional economic system that enabled player specialization, Colossal Order saw fit to make specialization a joke and cripple industry in C:S II. Every part of how industry is handled in this game is utterly astounding. The movement of goods and services is best determined by a diceroll, your logistics stations (train stations, cargo ports) are forced to keep a certain base amount that you cannot control, and it models an entire economy you barely have influence over.

Let's return to my abortive first city for a moment. I was planning to develop a forestry industry in the city, using the forests on the back of the island. To encourage developing wood processing and furniture, I dropped the relevant taxes and let it do its thing. Lo and behold, fifteen minutes later, my entire wood industry is dead and unprofitable for some godforsaken reason. This has been a persistent issue since the game launched and no patch has solved it for me. My industries seem to grow at random, and actual fluctuating demand doesn't seem to exist. I can't even do proper exports, because other cities don't exist beyond serving as imaginary destinations.

C:S 1 was unsophisticated and often middling in its simulation, but at the very least that simulation was functional. I didn't find myself confused nearly as constantly as I am playing C:S II, and I certainly could find some, if a weak satisfaction, in expanding my city. I mean, I can't even convince myself to buy the Ultimate Edition, which I now greatly regret buying. Because there's one critical thing that leads me to making this review...

iv. Cities: Skylines II is Unfixable

Even if Colossal Order fixed everything, made their current system make more sense, started adding in those basic details C:S 1 had, C:S II can't be anything more than a slightly more modder-friendly version of the first game.

I don't say this lightly. The only way to make C:S II a ten year game is to completely and utterly revamp the game that exists, add more complex systems, redo explanations, rebalance critical parts of the game and much more. As it stands, C:S II is a very convincing argument for players to figure out how to make C:S 1 tolerate more expansive systems as opposed to staying on it for a long time. I'm saying this without tearing into the game's even more irritating mistakes in detail. High land value, the lack of a real cim simulation, the complete absence of detailed public transport, the lack of meaningful modularity with the game's buildings. All of these would warrant five thousand word essays on their own.

But I don't see that happening. It's not financially viable, or at least not financially viable for Paradox Interactive. Redoing this game to the degree that would be required is at best unlikely. Instead, we'll be left waiting. Eventually, CO will fix a lot of this game. The egregious balancing errors will go, the DLC will finally come in, maybe even the rumored 2500+ assets dropped alongside the mod launcher last year that has never been mentioned since. But the game itself? Despite its improvements, it will be a faint, lifeless reminder of the first - and another desperate call for someone else to save the city-builder genre from its malaise.

3/10.

Addendum. 'If C:S II is just C:S 1 but slightly better, why is it not a ten year game?'. It's because the original wasn't either. C:S 1 was extraordinarily lucky that no major competitors have emerged since its release, forcing players to commit to it. In turn that helped develop the modding community and fandom that has kept it active. C:S II may end up having a community for ten years, but it won't be because of its quality. It'll markedly be in spite of it.