r/ChristianUniversalism • • 6h ago

Question Why is there so much fear in Christianity?

11 Upvotes

I posted on here a while ago, talking about my struggles with figuring out stuff about religion and Christianity. Everything I've seen in my exploring just keeps hammering home the idea of fear. I go on YouTube to watch silly videos from my childhood and recent stuff about nerd stuff I like only to be met with religious YouTube people hammering home the idea of how fast I'm going to get thrown into hell as soon as I die because of this, that, or the other.

There's a YouTuber called GGuidedProductions that seems to really hammer this home. Repeated skits about how there is a False Jesus, a False God, and the devil over and over again. He seems to insinuate that you're going to burn for all sorts of things. I always believed that as long as you TRIED YOUR BEST, you'd be okay. And he seemed to directly look into the camera and say, flat out, "THAT IS WRONG."

This seems to be EVERYWHERE. Fear, fear, and more fear. It makes my anxiety spike...I don't know what I'm asking at this point, but is this just the way it's going to be until I actually do die? Scared up until the last second?


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 15h ago

Do you believe hell exists but it’s only temporary or do you not believe in hell at all?

5 Upvotes

r/ChristianUniversalism • • 1d ago

Weekly Christian Universalism Debate Thread

8 Upvotes

Welcome to our weekly debate thread!

This space is dedicated to respectful debate about Christian Universalism. If you’d like to challenge Christian Universalist beliefs, or defend them, this is the place to do so.

If you’re new to the subreddit, we highly recommend reading our FAQ first. Many common questions and objections are addressed there, and it provides a good overview of what Christian Universalists believe.

Please keep your comments substantive and on topic. Low effort comments (such as a one line proof texts only) may be removed if they do not contribute to meaningful discussion.

As always, all subreddit rules remain in effect. Especially Rule #3: Disagree respectfully. Challenge ideas, don't attack people. Assume good faith, and remember that everyone here is a person made in the image of God.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 1d ago

After Jane Leade's Revelation of Revelations

5 Upvotes

Distilled from Leade's Revelation of Revelations.

https://sermonindex.net/speakers/jane-lead/the-revelation-of-revelations/

My spirit was carried out

to behold several Regions,

wherein I saw the Dead

numerously and variously

in their Confinements, being in dark Centers,

as bewailing and bemoaning their state,

that they had, while in the Body,

mispent their time, and lost their opportunity

of taking hold

of the redeeming Love of Christ,

Then my spirit was carried beyond them

into a Light-Orb and Principle, where I saw

the Throne of CHRIST in his KingIy and Prinstly Office,

interceding and pleading before the Father

the validity of his Redeeming Blood.

Then was my spirit was carried beyond them

into a Light-Orb and Principle,

where I saw the Throne of CHRIsT

in his KingIy and Prinstly Office,

interceding and pleading before the Father

the validity of his Redeeming Blood.

And Further I saw numerous spirits,

as bright Flames flying as it were

swiftly into this Principle,

being set free from the confinements

they were in. Whereupon, I

being as a naked spirit there,

did query:

What these were?

And the LORD himself pronounced this Word:

'These are those, for Which my Blood

was shed, tho long involved and shut up

as in the second Death, having past

through many Agonies and Anguishes:

yet now see, how they are set free,

and come here to be cloathed

with new and bright Bodies.

Whereupon I saw ADAM and EVE rise up

with exulting Joy, saying: Thus

shall our whole Offspring be restored,

and come in by degrees.

[And the second Adam said:]

“Dost thou marvel

at this full and perfect Redemption

by me of all Creatures in Humanity,

What wilt thou say,

if the Love of the immense Deity shall open

yet more wonderfully and deep,

so as to reach the Fall of Lucifer and his Hierarchy,

that they too may reducèd be

to their first primary Glory and Excellency.”

For only that, which has no beginning,

as Love, Wisdom and Goodness,

must abide and can have no end,

and must drown and swallow up

whatever is its opposite.

It is said, The Fire of Jacob shall consume

the stubble of Esau.

What Fire is that? It is not the fierce Fire,

but the Love-fire, that must do this Cure.

And this further Argument we have

for the Confirmation of this Restoration,

that the Eternal Essences of the Deity being

the Original of their first being, they must

return again to their primary Angelical Beings.

God has in every Age something still

to bring forth of his secrets,

to some one Gift, to some another,

as the Age and Time grows ripe for it.

The darkness in God did not jar against his Light,

neither the Anger against the Love;

(Admit, there was Anger in God: yet)

it all concurred together to illustrate

the Immense Love and Goodness [in him].

Which shall all serve to set forth the Fathomless Depths

of the Love Angelical Principle, with their Wonders;

when as Lucifer shall be enthroned again

in high Pomp through Humility and Purity.

Let not any think, that the highest Diabolical fierceness and pride

shall out-dare God’s Grace, Pity, Compassion and Love;

When the Love shall pierce them, it will open their Eyes so,

as to make ‘em weep and wail, that they have so long lived

to despise the Blood of the Covenant of Grace and Love.

He will not fail then to appear,

and all his mourning Dove-Flock

with his presence to comfort and cheer.

Which shall be the Joy

of the Angels above, with the perfect saints there,

as of the Regenerated Ones here below:

For only that, which has no beginning,

as Love, Wisdom and Goodness,

must abide and can have no end,

and must drown and swallow up

whatever is its opposite.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 2d ago

I’m hospitalized because of my fear of hell and my family’s salvation. I desperately need advice from people of all beliefs.

36 Upvotes

This is a long post, but I would be deeply grateful if you could read it and offer compassionate advice.
I am a Christian, but my fear of hell and whether my family and I will be saved has become so overwhelming that I have required psychiatric hospitalization.
My family does not believe in Christianity.
I have repeatedly tried to share my faith with them, but they have not accepted it.
The possibility that the people I love most could suffer eternally fills me with unbearable anxiety and panic.
Over time, I began questioning Christianity itself.

**Questions About God’s Love and Hell**
If God is all-knowing, all-powerful, and perfectly loving, why would He create a world in which human beings can sin, suffer, and potentially face eternal punishment?
Why should salvation depend on believing in Jesus?
Throughout history, countless people have never believed in Christianity, and many never even had the opportunity to hear about it.
Shouldn’t a loving God ultimately save everyone?
I have become increasingly drawn to Christian universalism, the belief that all people will eventually be reconciled to God.
However, I still struggle with different interpretations of Scripture and questions about the salvation of people who lived before Jesus.
I have also begun to wonder whether hell exists at all.
Perhaps everyone goes somewhere peaceful after death. Or perhaps consciousness simply ceases to exist.
Either way, I cannot understand why anyone should suffer eternally.
These questions have made me feel intense anger toward God.
I find it increasingly difficult to believe that a God who permits eternal torment could truly be loving.
At times, God and Jesus even seem cruel to me.
I know these are strong words, but they reflect how deeply I am suffering.

**My Previous Church Experience**
I previously attended a church with strict teachings about alcohol, sexuality, masturbation, and personal conduct.
There was also a strong emphasis on works, which made me afraid that believing in Jesus might not be enough for salvation if my actions were insufficient.
I constantly examined my behavior, worrying about whether I had sinned, repented sufficiently, or would be accepted by God.
Eventually, I became terrified not only for my family but also for myself.
I later moved to another Protestant church, but the fear remained because I continued hearing that those who do not believe cannot be saved.
I also spoke with pastors, but I did not receive answers that resolved my fears, particularly regarding my family.

**How This Affected My Family**
At one point, I became so frightened that I cried and begged my family to believe in Jesus, stop drinking alcohol, and change behaviors I had been taught were sinful, including premarital sex and masturbation.
My family was frightened by my desperation.
One family member told me something I will never forget:
“Isn’t religion supposed to help people live happier lives? Why is your faith causing suffering to the people closest to you?”
Those words deeply affected me.
I realized that I had gradually stopped seeing my family simply as people I loved.
Instead, I had begun viewing them through the categories of sin, judgment, and salvation.
Rather than appreciating their goodness and efforts, I was constantly worrying about whether they were sinning or would be saved.
I began to feel that my faith was causing suffering to the people I loved most.

**Living Under Constant Fear**
Now, even thinking about words such as sin, repentance, judgment, and hell can trigger panic.
I have tried to stop constantly monitoring my behavior according to religious rules.
I no longer want to obsess over whether drinking alcohol, masturbation, or romantic and sexual relationships are sinful.
But the anxiety has not disappeared.
Sometimes I repeat words such as “heaven,” “salvation,” “everything will be okay,” or “thank you” in my mind, hoping to calm myself.
I want to leave Christianity because of the suffering I associate with it.
However, whenever I consider leaving, I become terrified that abandoning my faith might lead to hell.
I feel trapped, as though there is no way out.
I have experienced depression in the past, and there have been times when life felt so unbearable that I wished I had never been born.
I am not currently intending to harm myself, but I want people to understand how seriously this has affected my life.
I experience frequent headaches and anxiety, and even sleeping peacefully has become difficult.

**God’s Love, Free Will, and Human Suffering**
Our world is filled with war, poverty, illness, and countless forms of suffering.
Why would God create a world containing so much suffering?
And why would people who have already suffered in this life potentially face eternal suffering after death?
I have heard the argument that love requires free will.
But even if free will is necessary, shouldn’t a loving God establish safeguards against irreversible harm?
If you had a child you deeply loved, would you knowingly leave a deadly poison within their reach?
Wouldn’t you remove that danger beforehand?
Why would God allow the possibility of something infinitely worse: eternal suffering?
The free-will argument alone does not satisfy me.
I still struggle to completely reject the possibility of a Creator because I cannot fully explain why the universe, life, and human consciousness exist.
However, I am beginning to realize that the existence of a Creator would not automatically establish that Christianity is true.
I no longer know what to believe.
I cannot attend worship as I once did, and even prayer has become difficult.
How can I trust a God whom I have come to fear?

**How Should I Live From Now On?**
I want to live peacefully and enjoy my life without being controlled by religion.
Instead of constantly worrying about whether my family will be saved or whether I will go to hell, I want to appreciate the time I have with them and the ordinary experiences of life.
But whenever I try to distance myself from Christianity, the fear of hell returns.
I have become so desperate that I sometimes wish someone could prove that God does not exist, or that hell does not exist.
At the same time, if there is an afterlife, I sincerely hope it is a place where everyone can find peace and happiness.
Why shouldn’t everyone ultimately be able to experience happiness?

**What I Am Asking From You**
I would sincerely appreciate hearing from people of all religious and philosophical backgrounds.
Christians, former Christians, atheists, agnostics, people without religious beliefs, and followers of other religions are all welcome to share their perspectives.
I am not seeking a predetermined religious conclusion.
I want to understand how I can escape this fear and reclaim my own life.
Have you ever experienced overwhelming fear of hell or your family’s salvation?
How did you overcome that fear?
What do you think about the relationship between God’s love and eternal punishment?
Do you believe God or an afterlife exists? What led you to that conclusion?
Is it possible to leave Christianity and still live happily without being controlled by the fear of hell?
What do you think I should value and focus on in my life from now on?
Please do not simply tell me to pray harder, that God loves me, or that I will go to hell if I stop believing.
I have already sought professional help and received psychiatric treatment. I am not asking Reddit to replace medical care.
What I need here is to hear your genuine experiences, perspectives, and advice.

**Regardless of your religious beliefs, I would deeply appreciate your honest thoughts about my situation and compassionate, practical advice on how to move forward without being controlled by fear.**

Thank you sincerely for taking the time to read this.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 3d ago

Miscellaneous Musings on Hell...

12 Upvotes

The text below was posted to another discussion thread but it seems more fitting for this page.

__________________________________________________________

I can sympathize with those who have a wishful hope that hell is empty but it is not realistic. However, that is what those who stubbornly insist on an eternal hell are left doing. Why do they do it? Because they know deep down on a mostly unconscious level that they are affirming an absurd contradiction; namely, the logical disconnect between a God Who Is Love with a God that would countenance such an abominable circumstance as a hell of eternal conscious torment. This could not be more obvious and yet the knots that defenders of the eternal conscious torment position will twist themselves into to try and square that circle would be laughable if this was not such a serious subject matter.

Creation is something that was/is purely God's own choosing. We had no say in the matter whatsoever and God created us freely and with full knowledge of every contingency including our final destinations. So we have to honestly ask what knowing this tells us about God Himself.

Is God good? Logically if you take the eternal conscious torment position, the answer would have to be no. For a truly good God Who is Love and knowing from the beginning of eternity that if He created a certain soul that said soul would suffer an eternal conscious torment, how could a good and loving God if He was truly Love let said soul be created in the first place?

There is no love in a God who deliberately created sentient beings in His own image and designed for union with the Divine while knowing all along that they would never achieve that for which they were designed. However, a God who with such foreknowledge chose instead to let said souls be created knowing full well they would suffer endless unremitting torment? Such an entity would be the epitome of sadistic cruelty, a kind of cosmic Pol Pot.

That is the argument against an eternal hell in a nutshell. And attempts to rebut this with the usual freewill kind of arguments fall flat because even if we are in a certain sense free, even that freedom of will has its limits.

Yes, there are limits on our freedom in numerous ways we can count and others we may not even think of that are built into the very structure and function of creation. So it makes no rational sense to try and pretend that in the most important of all areas (read: an individual's ultimate destiny for all eternity) that God would not have similar safeguards built in, especially since He knows in every possible way what stupid sheep His creation really consists of.

And yes, we are all stupid because we are all sinners. Sin makes us stupid. Even Paul recognized this in one of his Epistles when he said (paraphrasing) that he knows what he is supposed to do and does not do it or knows what he is not supposed to do yet does it anyway. So if all of this is true, what does that mean for the concept of hell?

Well, a hell that is purely punitive and tortures souls endlessly without end for all of eternity is unfitting and incongruent with a God Who is Love. However, a hell that is for the worst of sinners rehabilitative in nature (rather than punitive) would have a positive (even if terrifying) role in the salvation of the cosmos.

All of creation has a role to play in this as well if we consider our time on earth to basically be a school of love whereby we have to learn how to love as God does to ever achieve true divinization or union with the divine. And to learn to live perfectly is even for the best of us a lifelong process.

We learn in this life to help others, care for them, pray for them, even as Jesus taught us, to forgive and pray for our enemies. To help or assist with no thoughts of fame, fortune, glory, or indeed any credit whatsoever but instead to do what is right because it is right and with no self interest whatsoever.

For those who learn to do these things in this world or who come close enough, there is the reward of heaven either directly or through a bit of purification. For those who do not, the God Who Is Love will continue to reach out to them. However, because they were so closed off from learning how to love as God loves in this life, they will require rehabilitation of the most terrifying kind in the world to come in order for love to break through the hardened shells they have created out of themselves. But eventually at some point they will choose love and do so willingly as will all of creation because God's victory over evil will be actual, decisive, and complete leaving not a single triumph in the end for evil.

This is the logical end result of all things being possible with God as Jesus said.

For if all things are possible then so is Jesus being the actual Saviour of all of mankind, not just the theoretical saviour of all but the actual saviour of only a few. And that is why Paul realized as he worked his way through every possible salvation scenario in Romans that the logical end was what he specified in Romans 11: God has consigned all to disobedience so that he may have mercy on all. In the end, God will reconcile all things unto Himself and be all in all. Amen.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 4d ago

Is anyone ever truly beyond the possibility of transformation?

Thumbnail
jeremynickel.substack.com
10 Upvotes

One of the deepest hopes I carry from my years in ministry is that no one is ever finally defined by their worst suffering or the stories they’ve built around it. I recently witnessed something extraordinary that brought that hope to life, and wrote about it through the unlikely image of a ladder that has remained stuck at one of Christianity’s holiest sites for centuries.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 5d ago

Question I want to believe, is there anything I can do?

13 Upvotes

Apologies if this isn’t the right subreddit to post this in, reading through some posts it seems like a very honest & respectful community that could potentially lead me towards the right direction.

I grew up in a relatively conservative town with parents who didn’t necessarily follow the practice. With the influence of one of my parents always expressing how “fanatical” religious followers are, feeling alienated from a majority of my town’s community because we stopped going to church, & having relatives/neighbors/etc. claim to be Christian while being some of the least accepting, most hateful people I’ve met, I’ve grown with this stigma against Christianity.

I recently had a partner who was a Christian and one of the most loving people I’ve known. I was slowly reintroduced into the practice & exposed to a side of Christianity I didn’t know existed. Although I would be supportive, deep down there always was/is this bad feeling any time religion is brought up. I think the concept of Christian Universalism is absolutely beautiful though. I yearn to believe in it, but it feels as though the more I long for it the more forced/less genuine it feels. I can’t get rid of this negative connotation with Christianity, or get over the logistics of the events of the Bible. I know Jesus was a real person in history, but I cannot shake the thought of how impossible the recounts in the Bible are (and I understand that’s kind of the whole point because there is one Jesus so of course events like the Resurrection won’t happen once a week). I don’t know how to not feel forced into believing in Christianity, but Christian Universalism invokes so much emotion in me, and I catch myself aching to truly believe & put my faith/trust in it.

Again, if this isn’t the right place please let me know! I wanted to interact with this community directly at some point, & I guess I’ve decided now is the time.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 5d ago

Discussion I want to start a little weekly bible study for the subreddit. This being the first one. This week is Matthew 8:22. More info below.

17 Upvotes

Disclaimer: Hi I am relatively new to universalism and was a Lutheran most of my life. But I had a very rocky and angry relationship with God. I discovered universalism and now I am re reading the New Testament with hopefully a new light. I want to start a weekly bible study with like minded individuals for verses that strike me odd. I will start off with the gospels and then move on from there . I could write a lot more but don't tldr let's get discussing! I hope this helps me and maybe some others who want to follow along and learn what the community thinks.

So Matthew 8:22 "But Jesus said unto him, Follow Me, and let the dead bury their dead.

This verse hit me hard and left me confused. It seems very harsh at first. I've heard three different interpretations

  1. The man's father was indeed physically dead and Jesus wants him to move on with his life following the living God in front of him.

-I like this interpretation the second most but it still seems very harsh. Every culture holds funerals for their deceased loved ones and I would like to think that Jesus would allow someone to mourn. For I remember Jesus wept when Lazarus died.

2. The man was waiting for his father to die to collect is inheritance

- I like this interpretation the best because it allows me to see Jesus in a better light. Even though the Bible does not make this clear. I feel as if this detail would have been very important and its author would have been more precise in the wording if this were the case.

3. Jesus meant let the spiritually dead bury the spiritually dead.

-this is the interpolation I like the least. In many translations of the Bible this is basically what the verse says. To me it seems to contradict the teachings of Jesus like in the case of the the lost sheep and Jesus saying that healthy people are not in need of a doctor later in Matthew. He says he is there for people in need of saving not that have already been saved. So why would Jesus not help the spiritually dead become alive. Why abandon a group of people. Also in Matthew Jesus tells his disciples to shake the dust from their shoes if people do not accept what they are teaching and to move on to another place to try again. This also seems to contradict the parable of the lost sheep and the fact that Jesus came to save the sinners.

Please chime in if you have any input or thoughts on this verse or anything else. Also please let me know this is helpful to anyone because I want to do a breakdown of a verse once a week to hear people's thoughts!! Have a great day!


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 6d ago

Question need advice!

4 Upvotes

I feel like the consequences of not believing in religion, if any, the correct religion is too much to ignore. I agree with the paradox where believing in religion has almost no downsides unless you’re wrong, but also, atheists make good points. i cant just say “they’re trying to scare me” because to me, it’s a coin flip. all i want is to believe in what’s right. i dont know what’s right, i dont know how i can know what’s right. it’s man choice to seek out god and i truly am trying. but which one? am i wrong for wanting to seek out god? I agree with both sides. but i feel like atheists usually make me feel like i’m doing something wrong. but i feel like i’m doing something wrong if i’m not trying to test if religion is real. the consequences are too dire.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 7d ago

Morning thought

15 Upvotes

At Eden, humanity’s perception of God was destroyed.

At Golgotha, humanity literally killed the image of God

At the resurrection, God showed us that he always loved us, despite both


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 8d ago

simple question

3 Upvotes

ok first when i ask this question im genuine so please don’t act like im horribly stupid lik a lot of people do on reddit 😭

But im looking into u universalism and i was thinking of the verse Matthew 12:32 “Whoever speaks a word against the Son of Man will be forgiven; but whoever speaks against the Holy Spirit [by attributing the miracles done by Me to Satan] will not be forgiven, either in this age or in the age to come.”

How can they go to heaven eventually, (from my understanding of universalism that people do suffer in hell but only temporary and go to heaven, etc) if they can’t be forgiven?


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 8d ago

Weekly Christian Universalism Debate Thread

6 Upvotes

Welcome to our weekly debate thread!

This space is dedicated to respectful debate about Christian Universalism. If you’d like to challenge Christian Universalist beliefs, or defend them, this is the place to do so.

If you’re new to the subreddit, we highly recommend reading our FAQ first. Many common questions and objections are addressed there, and it provides a good overview of what Christian Universalists believe.

Please keep your comments substantive and on topic. Low effort comments (such as a one line proof texts only) may be removed if they do not contribute to meaningful discussion.

As always, all subreddit rules remain in effect. Especially Rule #3: Disagree respectfully. Challenge ideas, don't attack people. Assume good faith, and remember that everyone here is a person made in the image of God.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 9d ago

Question Lost and looking for answers

14 Upvotes

So, I'm not sure if this is the best place to put this sort of thing. If it isn't, I apologize to the mods. I'm kinda shouting into the void here.

I'm a male in his late 30s who has been through quite a bit over the past several years. I had several family members pass away, some of them before their time. I never really got hit with any grief until about a month ago when someone told me that I was 'much older than they thought I was'. And suddenly that, plus everything else, slammed into me like a truck. I was horrified at the thought of death. The idea that all of a sudden, I could just blink out of existence. That all of my hopes, dreams, wishes, likes, dislikes, experiences, memories...my sense of self, my consciousness, my SOUL would just be gone into a void of nothingness. The sheer amount of people in my life, on TV, on the internet that kept saying 'There is no God, there is no Heaven or Hell, we are all just animals and when our time is done, we go back to the Earth.' drove into me like a hot knife.

And so the spiral began. Anxiety: Someday, I'm going to die. My family is going to die. And all will blip out of existence and we'll be done. Depression: What's even the point of doing anything enjoyable?

I go to therapy and discussed this with my therapist. We've made a few strides in the right direction (I think so, anyway) and I'm not PANICKING like I was before, but I still feel low.

My family was raised a combination of Lutheran and Methodist Christian. When all this fell on me, I fell to the teachings that I learned from my parents: As long as you try your best and don't let something bad dictate your life...as long as you accept Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior and don't let something like sex or drugs or alcohol or your job or anything in particular stop you from moving forward, learning and growing as a human, God will be pleased and you'll walk into the Kingdom of Heaven. Sure, you can indulge in something from time to time, as long as it doesn't take over your life. Be a good person. Help your neighbor. You'll stumble, but just keep trying.

I've believed that my whole life. So, when all this hit, I turned to find solace with friends in my life who know more about these things. Is all that true?

The Short Answer?: Kinda. The Long Answer?: There's a few more things about it that you need to be aware of, a slew of other rules you need to follow, and a LOT of stuff you didn't know.

It felt like a bunch of stuff said in the Bible, rules and guidelines, suddenly become kinda shaky when brought into the way we do things TODAY. Stuff like Homosexuality, premartial sex, pornography, eating/not eating certain animals, and a bunch of other things.

So I tried to learn more. Some friends said I just need to read the Bible and come to my own conclusions...but all I see is people taking the Bible's teachings and saying that it means THIS or it means THAT.

Some churches are great. No, churches are terrible because they care more about themselves instead of the Scripture. Go to a big church so you can meet people. Go to a small church so you won't be another face in the crowd. This church does hymns, this church does nine piece band music, this church does satellite sermons from a different location. This is right, no that's wrong...

Did you know that, apparently, if someone follows Islam or Hinduism or something not Christianity, they're going to burn in hell because they were presented Christianity and said, 'No, we'd rather follow our religion that we've had for centuries?' I always felt that all the religions kinda got close cause they all preached the same sorta thing: Love your neighbor, do good works, don't kill or steal. Nope, it's Jesus or burn forever.

YouTube is FILLED with AI generated videos telling me that 'THIS VIDEO WAS SENT TO YOU BY GOD, TELLING YOU TO DO THIS.' or two dudes on a podcast how they never realized that THIS is what the scripture actually means or 'Here is what the Bible actually means with me highlighting words and circling stuff, explaining what both Heaven and Hell are going to be like'.

Did you know there's a video on YouTube that has a completely voice acted, sound effect laden creation of a group of people dying, going before Jesus on the white throne, being told that they weren't good enough and getting thrown into Hell, complete with terrified screams and rattling chains?

All of this did not help my anxiety. My depression.

I dug deeper. Reddit responded with subreddit posts about the Singularity going to happen soon and AI will take over, aliens are due any moment now, entire groups of people saying there is absolutely nothing after death, but you'll be FINE cause it'll be like going to sleep forever. You won't care. La dee dah.

Fear. Fear and anxiety. My brain won't let it go.

I pray every night, begging God for a path. An answer. Tell me SOMETHING. Is this AI video that came through on my YouTube feed Your message? Is this spider that landed on my arm during yard work Your message? People seem to say that God will LITERALLY TALK TO YOU IN YOUR BRAIN when the time is right. Or you will get this strong feeling to do THIS or THAT.

I do not know what to do. I do not know where to go or who to talk to. I'm scared that a message from this pastor or that preacher is going to tell me something I don't want to hear. I haven't even been baptized yet because all the churches I've been to make a HUGE spectacle out of it, doing it in front of the ENTIRE CROWD with music stings and cymbal crashes.

During ALL of this, I found someone talk about Universal Christianity. THIS seemed to make sense to me. If you screw up, you might pay for it a bit, but ultimately you serve your time and move on with the others to someplace better. But how is THIS the correct answer?? I'm not saying it's wrong, but I guess I'm asking is how do you truly know it's right? I'm a rule follower, I follow the rules as best I can and get a little grace in the end if I don't quite hit the perfect mark, then I get a hand up and success.

I just want to be a good human being. I don't want to hurt anyone. I want to help people. I don't want a ton of money or fame or things...I just want peace, calm, someone to love, a few good friends to hang out with, and that's it. If I break the rules, I'm sorry, I'm just trying to live and keep my sanity in this crazy ass world. If I do all that and the Bible tells me I'm going to **burn for eternity...**then what do I do?

This was way longer than I intended...but I don't know where else to put something like this. Not on Facebook, not on Bluesky, not on YouTube...if there's anything anyone can tell me, give me some level of peace of mind, some path or guide or something to calm myself, I'll take it. I just want it to make sense.

Thank you.

TL;DR: Modern religion freaks me the hell out, everyone argues about which way is right, and I just want to find the right path that gets me into Heaven and not into Hell or annhiliated. I want to make sure there IS a Heaven. Please help me.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 10d ago

Any charismatics/Pentecostals in this group who have come to the greater hope but kept their affinity for the supernatural?

11 Upvotes

r/ChristianUniversalism • • 10d ago

Why did God create us in such ignorance? Why not give us the knowledge, so sin (and pain) would never exist? (David Bentley Hart question)

16 Upvotes

I've been reading David Bentley Hart (That All Shall Be Saved) and keep coming back to one question he never quite answers directly: why were we created with so much ignorance?

Hart argues that sin is essentially ignorance: the will is naturally oriented toward the Good, and we only sin because, in our finitude, we mistake finite goods for the ultimate Good. Ignorance, he says, is simply the condition of being a finite creature emerging from nothingness.

But why accept that? Knowledge isn't the only thing that makes God God. A creature could surely know much more about God without being God. So why didn't God just create us with that knowledge, so sin wouldn't exist and all the pain it causes would never happen?

The problem is that Hart's own logic seems to work against him here: if ignorance is the only brake on sin, and God created that ignorance, then God bears some responsibility for sin and everything that followed from it.

Is there a serious answer to "why not create us with the knowledge" in Hart, in the Cappadocian tradition he draws on (Gregory of Nyssa, Maximus), or anywhere else? Or is this genuinely the open flank of his argument?

Disclaimer: this post was drafted with the help of AI, since English isn't my native language. The question itself is a genuine, personal one that I've been wrestling with.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 11d ago

Christian Universalist Association clergy or chaplains

9 Upvotes

Hello,

I hope you are all doing well. I am ordained in an ecumenical Christian community with interfaith dimensions. I am also a board-certified chaplain in the Association of Professional Chaplains. For a while, I have been contemplating becoming active with the Christian Universalist Association and potentially being dual-ordained. I feel like a piece of me is missing without that identity connection even though the community I am ordained in definitely has members who believe in universal reconciliation. I’m a Christian existentialist myself—

Anyways, my questions are: are any of you active members in the Christian Universalist Association? If so, are you clergy and/or ordained and working as a chaplain? I would love to hear about your experiences and thoughts about the community.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 12d ago

I believe aionios can mean eternal/forever and still be aligned with universalism

17 Upvotes

So obviously most people use verses like Matthew 25:41-46 to argue against universalism because of the wording of eternal punishment. And the typical universalist defense comes down to the meaning of aionios (e.g. everlasting) which I agree with, however, I have a complementary interpretation.

I equate sin to Satan and/or the works of his angels. I believe humans go through ‘everlasting’ finite purification until all sin / works of Satan are removed, and that ultimately it is Satan and his angels who are eternally damned. When I read Scripture I find that judgment is continuously directed toward Satan and his angels:

  • Matthew 25:41 - “Then shall he say also unto them on the left hand, Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels”

  • John 16:11 - “Of judgment, because the prince of this world is judged.”

  • Jude 1:6 - “And the angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, he hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness unto the judgment of the great day”

  • 2 Peter 2:4 - “For if God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down to hell, and delivered them into chains of darkness, to be reserved unto judgment”

Thus, when viewed in this way it is not difficult at all to accept/defend any verses that point to eternal punishment as forever because it is ultimately reserved for Satan and his angels.

Bonus commentary:

Matthew 25:31-46

  • I claim the separation of sheep and goats represents the separation of humans from sin/Satan. If you believe that the sheep and goats both represent groups of humans, then I challenge you to state what qualifies any human to pertain to the group of sheep because we know no one is good nor does anyone seek God [Romans 3:10-12]. And if you claim that people who have placed their faith in Jesus are the sheep, I challenge your faith - “And by this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments. Whoever says 'I know him' but does not keep his commandments is a liar, and the truth is not in that person." [1 John 2:3-4] and faith without works is dead [James 2:17].

Matthew 16:22-23

  • “And Peter took him aside and began to rebuke him, saying, “Far be it from you, Lord! This shall never happen to you.” But he turned and said to Peter, “Get behind me, Satan! You are a hindrance to me. For you are not setting your mind on the things of God, but on the things of man.”

  • This verse, to me, reinforces the idea that any sin we commit is attributed to Satan. Jesus could have directed any correction toward Peter yet He didn’t because He knows that it is the works of Satan within Peter.

Romans 9:21-23

  • “Has the potter no right over the clay, to make out of the same lump one vessel for honorable use and another for dishonorable use? What if God, desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, has endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, in order to make known the riches of his glory for vessels of mercy, which he has prepared beforehand for glory”

  • This, to me, reinforces humans as vessels of mercy and Satan and his angels as the vessels of wrath.

Romans 7:17

  • “So now it is no longer I who do it, but sin that dwells within me.”

  • Reinforces framework.

Matthew 8:29

  • “And behold, they cried out, ‘What have you to do with us, O Son of God? Have you come here to torment us before the time?’”

  • Demons are aware of their future judgement.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 12d ago

Question Matthew 25:47

3 Upvotes

Common objections to Matthew 25:46 are the translation of Greek, that being aionios and kolasis, which better suited pertaining to an age of correction. But wouldn't that also debunk the idea of eternity with god? Since the same word is used in both passages? One is to be understood as a temporary place but the other eternal despite both using the same word? It just seems like if one were to be eternal or temporary, the other would also judging by this verse.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 13d ago

God's existence

31 Upvotes

I'm an agnostic and a professional research scientist. I quite like Christian Universalism as it's the version of Christianity I would actually want to be true. However, I mostly engage with it as an idea. I can "put on my hat" of believing it but I don't really.

I cannot convince myself that God exists, as imagined by major religions. I could imagine something mysterious that supports existence (as described in DBH's book The Experience of God), but I wouldn't match it up with the Bible or anything like that. I think if something like that exists, it's probably not like anything people have thought of.

Why do you think it's all real? I'm not a hard line atheist (I was when I was younger) so I am interested to hear your thoughts.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 13d ago

Thought I hate God. Universalism is my last hope for reconciliation. Please, help me

Post image
29 Upvotes

Long text, sorry.

I had a good Christian upbringing. I was taught about divine love above all else, I memorized hymns, I've prayed before bed since childhood and still do today. My faith has even saved me several times, even when depression and PTSD drowned me in despair.

Everything changed in early 2025. I saw a Catholic sermon on YouTube around that time. It was the most despairing thing I had ever seen. The image of hell became vivid: I saw myself in hell; I saw my mother in hell; I saw my whole family; I saw almost all my friends. God, I could hear the screams.

I went through a year of intense obsession. I interpreted every slightest thing as a divine sign, a sign of imminent divine punishment. Gradually, despair mixed with anger. Despair, melancholy and anger. That's all I feel.

I loved God, I loved hearing and talking about Him. A single day killed me inside.

Help me, please. I want to love God again, truly. I want to feel what I felt before, without thinking that I will be condemned to eternal suffering.

By the way, this isn't my first post here. The first was about preferring to be annihilated than to go to heaven, precisely because of this anger.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 12d ago

Discussion Convince me that goats can become sheep (and that 2 Thessalonians 1:9 isn't anti-universalist)

9 Upvotes

So I am in the "hopeful universalist" camp. I find a lot of universalist arguments compelling, but there is really one big thing preventing from becoming a dogmatic universalist: the language of separation. Universalists have done a fantastic job dealing with passages about eternity, punishment and destruction, but the responses to separation language leave much to be desired to me. In particular I want to focus on two thing: the sheep and the goats and that Hell is being "away from the presence of the Lord" as stated in 2 Thessalonians 1:9. I'm hoping for some good answers to my questions here so I can jump over to being a more firm universalist.

Universalists often like to point out that Jesus never abandons his sheep and that his lost sheep are always found. But that's actually kind of the problem. Jesus never bothers to find goats, only sheep. Nowhere in scripture does it describe Jesus going out of his way to find goats or to turn goats into sheep, but rather we are already sheep.

I've seen a post on here trying to untie the sheep and goats from salvific language, claiming that goats were" valuable parts of the shepherd’s flock." That may be true, but that's just not how the term is used in the parable. Sheep are placed at his right hand and are described as the inheritors of the kingdom prepared for them since the world's creation. Goats are placed on the left hand and used to describe people who are not and who are separated from the sheep who inherit the kingdom. One will be a part of the kingdom, the other will not. There is no untying this passage from salvation language unless you think being part of God's kingdom has nothing to do with salvation.

Now, it's legitimate to say that describing people as lost does not mean they cannot be found later. But the issue here in the precise language of division that Jesus is using. He seems to make it very clear that he is only concerned with sheep and that goats will not be a part of the kingdom and does not describe any process of conversion as a goat turning into a sheep. This is further solidified by the sheep being defined as sheep since the creation of the world. If God will save everybody then why would he create a clearly stated division between people who inherit his kingdom and people who don't?

Moving onto 2 Thessalonians 1:9, the "eternal torment" part is a nothing burger to me. As I said before, universalists have done a convincing job dealing this kind of language, but the part that gets me is "away from the presence of the Lord." Universalists have this idea about Hell that it seems to be a God driven way to bring people to him. But how can the purpose of a place be to bring people to him if the place is devoid of his presence? Universalists view Hell as nudging people in the right direction and forming them into Godly people, but this is a very active sounding view of Hell which seems very much to necessitate the presence of God to accomplish. If there is some way to make sense of this view of Hell in light of God's presence not being there then I really want to see it because I think this poses a very serious issue to the universalist view of Hell.

I appreciate any comments, but would also kindly ask for no comments of a "there are passages that every side has to deal with" nature. I'm aware of that, but that does not mean that each side doesn't have the burden of actually trying to make sense of the other side's proof passages. Also, if you think the Bible is contradictory and simply reject these passages on that basis then just be honest about that.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 13d ago

Meditation about the implications of the official doctrine about the fate of baptised infants

9 Upvotes

Posted this in the r/CatholicUniversalism sub but I can't repost it automatically, so I copy the text here with slight modifications as I believe that it is a common belief that infants that die after baptism are saved.

I hope that this isn't off-topic as it is a bit tangential to Universalism but IMO it is still relevant. However, I was pondering about what the Roman Catholic Catechism says about the fate of unbaptized infants :

"As regards children who have died without Baptism, the Church can only entrust them to the mercy of God, as she does in her funeral rites for them. Indeed, the great mercy of God who desires that all men should be saved, and Jesus' tenderness toward children which caused him to say: "Let the children come to me, do not hinder them," allow us to hope that there is a way of salvation for children who have died without Baptism. All the more urgent is the Church's call not to prevent little children coming to Christ through the gift of holy Baptism." (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1261; source: https://www.catholiccrossreference.online/catechism/#!/search/1261 )

At the same time, though, the Catechism asserts quite explicitly that eternal damnation can only be a result of a mortal sin:

"God predestines no one to go to hell; for this, a willful turning away from God (a mortal sin) is necessary, and persistence in it until the end. In the Eucharistic liturgy and in the daily prayers of her faithful, the Church implores the mercy of God, who does not want "any to perish, but all to come to repentance"" (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1037; source: https://www.catholiccrossreference.online/catechism/#!/search/1037 )

This IMO poses two problems. Infants cannot make moral choices and, therefore, if hell (as is understood officially) is only possible if one dies unrepentant of mortal sins, no infant goes to hell, which seems to make Baptism superfluous with regards to their salvation (after all, infant baptism is something that isn't made out of the decision of the baptized infant). This clearly raises the problem of how to understand the 'necessity' of Baptism.

The second problem is, perhaps, more relevant to the controversy about hell. Let's consider two human beings, Alice and Bob who are siblings in the same family and they both receive baptism as infants. Alice, however, dies as an infant, before reaching the 'age of reason' and, as I understand it, this means that Alice is assured to enter into eternal life in the Kingdom of God (this is supported by what is written here: https://www.newliturgicalmovement.org/2018/12/a-child-singing-with-angels.html ). Bob, however, reaches the age of reason (let's say that he becomes an adult) and dies unrepentant of a mortal sin. So, given the official doctrine advanced by the Catechism, Bob goes to hell and is eternally damned.

However, contrary to a common view, the example above shows that salvation isn't necessarily due to freely consenting the action of grace. Alice never consented to her baptism and having died before reaching the age of reason didn't experience the risk of ever losing the state of grace. Bob, on the other hand, after reaching the age of reason basically experienced the worst imaginable misfortune: losing the assurance of salvation and risking eternal damnation. And this clearly raises another issue: it seems that God allows that some human beings are never in a position of risking their eternal fate while at the same time He allows that other human beings are put in a situation in which they do risk their eternal fate. Doesn't this imply that God isn't impartial?

Ironically, I think that the dogma about the fate of infants who die after baptism (not sure that it is a dogma, but I never encountered anything in Roman Catholic doctrines that I am aware of that contradicts this) but before reaching the age of reason poses an enormous problem for the infernalist position. On the other hand, the universalist might instead say that this shows that God can save a human being without his or her free choice of accepting the gift of salvation.

(Of course, this problem doesn't affect those views that posit that God's love isn't impartial, i.e. that God loves some human beings more than others. But I'm not sure how many find such a view congenial nowadays...also it doesn't affect those non-universalist views in which infants that die after baptism but before the age of reason are not 'automatically' saved)


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 13d ago

Help me understand Hebrews 10:26-29 please. Thank you !!

8 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm new to this subreddit. l've been a Christian Universalist for a couple of years now; however, l've always struggled with these verses in particular:

Hebrews 10:26-29
"For if we go on sinning willfully after receiving the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins, but a terrifying expectation of judgment and the fury of a fire which will consume the adversaries. Anyone who has ignored the Law of Moses is put to death without mercy on the testimony of two or three witnesses. How much more severe punishment do you think he will deserve who has trampled underfoot the Son of God, and has regarded as unclean the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified, and has insulted the Spirit of grace?"

I've heard multiple interpretations of this passage, but none have satisfied me. Some suggest that "willful sin" refers to returning to the Old Testament sacrificial system, thereby rejecting Christ's sacrifice. However, that feels like reading a bit too much into the phrase "sinning willfully."

The fact that verse 29 references severe Old Testament punishments for high-handed, deliberate sin against the Law of Moses leads me to believe that "sinning willfully" refers to a continual pattern of intentional sin that cuts a believer off from Christ. Beyond simply being cut off, verse 29 suggests there is no longer any sacrifice left for one’s sins. Naturally, this leads me to conclude that people in this category must pay for their own sins in the lake of fire or through some other form of judgment. If they are judged harshly and suffer for their deliberate, ongoing rebellion—culminating in their death (a pattern frequently seen in the OT)—they would have technically fulfilled the allotted punishment for those sins. Having "died in their sins," could these individuals ever have the hope of resurrection? If so, what is the basis of that hope, given that they paid for their own sins through judgment rather than Christ’s sacrifice not counting towards them (verse 29)? Did Christ accomplish something else that guarantees their eventual resurrection?

I truly hope so, because Universalism through Christ is the only theological perspective that makes complete sense to me. Any insights into this difficult passage and its implications would be greatly appreciated. Thank you so much !!!

Grace and Peace.


r/ChristianUniversalism • • 15d ago

Did anyone else here have a “cage stage universalist” phase?😂

7 Upvotes