r/ChineseHistory • • Aug 15 '25

Comprehensive Rules Update

31 Upvotes

Hello all,

The subreddit gained quite a bit of new traffic near the end of last year, and it became painfully apparent that our hitherto mix of laissez-faire oversight and arbitrary interventions was not sufficient to deal with that. I then proceeded to write half of a rules draft and then not finish it, but at long last we do actually have a formal list of rules now. In theory, this codifies principles we've been acting on already, but in practice we do intend to enforce these rules a little more harshly in order to head off some of the more tangential arguments we tend to get at the moment.

Rule 1: No incivility. We define this quite broadly, encompassing any kind of prejudice relating to identity and other such characteristics. Nor do we tolerate personal attacks. We also prohibit dismissal of relevant authorities purely on the basis of origin or institutional affiliation.

Rule 2: Cite sources if asked, preferably academic. We allow a 24-hour grace period following a source request, but if no reply has been received then we can remove the original comment until that is fulfilled.

Rule 3: Keep it historical. Contemporary politics, sociology, and so on may be relevant to historical study, but remember to keep the focus on the history. We will remove digressions into politics that have clearly stopped being about their historical implications.

Rule 4: Permitted post types

Text Posts

Questions:

We will continue to allow questions as before, but we expect these questions to be asked in good faith with the intent of seeking an answer. What we are going to crack down on are what we have termed ‘debate-bait’ posts, that is to say posts that seek mainly to provoke opposing responses. These have come from all sides of the aisle of late, and we intend to take a harder stance on loaded questions and posts on contentious topics. We as mods will exercise our own discretion in terms of determining what does and does not cross the line; we cannot promise total consistency off the bat but we will work towards it.

Essay posts:

On occasion a user might want to submit some kind of short essay (necessarily short given the Reddit character limit); this can be permitted, but we expect these posts to have a bibliography at minimum, and we also will be applying the no-debate-bait rule above: if the objective seems to be to start an argument, we will remove the post, however eloquent and well-researched.

Videos

Video content is a bit of a tricky beast to moderate. In the past, it has been an unstated policy that self-promotion should be treated as spam, but as the subreddit has never had any formal rules, this was never actually communicated. Given the generally variable (and generally poor) quality of most history video content online, as a general rule we will only accept the following:

  • Recordings of academic talks. This means conference panels, lectures, book talks, press interviews, etc. Here’s an example.

  • Historical footage. Straightforward enough, but examples might include this.

  • Videos of a primarily documentary nature. By this we don’t mean literal documentaries per se, but rather videos that aim to serve as primary sources, documenting particular events or recollections. Some literal documentaries might qualify if they are mainly made up of interviews, but this category is mainly supposed to include things like oral history interviews.

Images

Images are more straightforward; with the following being allowed:

  • Historical images such as paintings, prints, and photographs

  • Scans of historical texts

  • Maps and Infographics

What we will not permit are posts that deliver a debate prompt as an image file.

Links to Sources

We are very accepting of submissions of both primary sources and secondary scholarship in any language. However, for paywalled material, we kindly request that you not post links that bypass these paywalls, as Reddit frowns heavily on piracy and subreddits that do not take action against known infractions. academia.edu links are a tricky liminal space, as in theory it is for hosting pre-print versions where the author holds the copyright rather than the publisher; however this is not persistently adhered to and we would suggest avoiding such links. Whether material is paywalled or open-access should be indicated as part of the post.

Rule 5: Please communicate in English. While we appreciate that this is a forum for Chinese history, it is hosted on an Anglophone site and discussions ought to be accessible to the typical reader. Users may post text in other languages but these should be accompanied by translation. Proper nouns and technical terms without a good direct translation should be Romanised.

Rule 6: No AI usage. We adopt a zero-tolerance approach to the use of generative AI. An exception is made solely for translating text of one’s own original production, and we request that the use of such AI for translation be openly disclosed.


r/ChineseHistory • • 25d ago

Rule Updates: Questions, Artefacts, Primary Source Recommendations

18 Upvotes

Hello all, following a few recent threads we've decided to update our rules on permitted post types and add an additional rule.

Firstly, while question posts in general remain allowed, we will no longer allow

  • Counterfactual (i.e. 'what-if') questions. These are not particularly conducive to meaningful discussion and are already disallowed on most history subreddits for that reason.

  • Questions asking for value judgments and/or moralising, e.g. asking for the best/worst of something, or for a moral assessment of a certain individual or events. These mostly serve to spark acrimonious arguments with little meaningful substance.

We are also going to be much more proactive in removing potential political baiting under rule 3. These absolutely do nothing except spark arguments, and we will be taking a harder stance on what we deem to be political bait, intentional or otherwise.

Secondly, posting historical objects, art, photographs etc. will still be allowed, but these posts must be accompanied by at least some basic commentary or they will be removed, as otherwise we just get a lot of people posting contextless photos of their art collections.

Finally, we are also specifically going to disallow recommendations for uncommentated primary sources as a response to questions about resources. Uncontextualised primary sources – many of them in Classical Chinese – are not helpful to the beginner, and we also find that those making the recommendation simply name-drop them to give off an air of authority. If you have a specific passage in mind, cite it specifically and ideally quote it directly. If the user is asking for what to read to understand a given period, point to a scholarly secondary source, not a primary source absent critical commentary.


r/ChineseHistory • • 3h ago

9,000 years of Chinese Writing

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 12h ago

Why were no later dynasties called Shang?

12 Upvotes

Throughout Chinese history, state and dynasty names are often reused. However there's one notable exception, there is no Later Shang.

We have a barbarian Xia, 3 Zhou dynasties, 3 Qin state's, A lot of Han states, several Tang and Jin states.

I have a few ideas on why this could be but I'd like someone with more knowledge to confirm.

  1. Geographical reasons: the Shang crown lands around the Yellow river which later became the states of Wey and Song were quite difficult to hold onto due to their location on the Central Plains. Very few warlords started out there and managed to successfully establish themselves (Zhu Wen and Cao Cao being exceptions to this). As a result, since often states were named after the places where warlords based themselves, Shang was never used.

  2. Many later dynasties took their names from founding rulers being enfeoffed as Prince of (State). There was no Shang state although there was a Shang region in the state of Qin (which is why Shang Yang is called that, his original name was Wey Yang as he was the son of the Duke of Wey with a concubine).

  3. Cultural reasons: the Xia dynasty founded China, while the Zhou dynasty paid the foundation for all of subsequent dynastic China. People spoke the Zhou language, followed Zhou religion of ancestor worship, Zhou era philosophies shaped governance going forward, Zhou era naming system for sovereigns (Wen, Wu etc.). Zhou seal script was used for writing. On the other hand, Shang did not have this influence on later society.

  4. Descendants of the Shang kings did not gain power in later periods. This is a poor example, but Liu Yuan claimed to descend from the Han dynasty emperors and therefore named himself the Emperor of Han. Nobody did this for the Shang emperors.


r/ChineseHistory • • 1d ago

Is there a virus/plague in Chinese history that was as devastating to society as the Black Death was to Western Europe?

35 Upvotes

I’m curious as to whether there was one. If so, what? And why? Or am I making the wrong assumption here?


r/ChineseHistory • • 16h ago

The National Government's Declaration on Relocating to Chongqing, A Historic Turning Point in the Protracted War of Resistance

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 13h ago

Need recs for a couple of books on modern China

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 1d ago

How did the elites of the Ming Dynasty feel about the imperial family's policy of only choosing their consorts from lower ranking families?

2 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 1d ago

I found a hidden history of an ancient Chinese order — four stories, four dynasties, one war that never ended.

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, the r/assassinscreed auto-mod is holding my post, but I really wanted to share this here first.

I was sitting in a teahouse in Luoyang, watching the rain hit the stone pavement, when an old man across from me started talking. He didn't look like a warrior. He looked like a retired clerk. But as he spoke, I realized he was telling me about a secret war in China. A war between the Order and the Free.

It sounded familiar.

He told me four stories. Four dynasties. One endless cycle.

Story 1 — The Man Who Chased the Imperial Seal (The Fall of the Northern Wei)

The old man took a long pull from his pipe. "Long before the golden age of the Tang, China was torn apart. It was our version of the fall of Rome. Barbarians swept down from the north, and the noble clans fought each other like starving wolves."

"There was a man named Yang Qin. He was a Shadow Guardian — but also a nobleman of a fallen house. In his youth, he served under a general who couldn't even draw a bow, yet led a handful of men in white robes into the heart of the enemy empire. For a moment, it seemed the Guardians had finally won. They took the capital. They broke the back of the northern warlords."

"But the old man leaned closer, his voice dropping. "They won every battle, and still they lost. The man they crowned as emperor turned on them, terrified of their power. And then came the flood — a wall of water that washed away the white robes in a single night. The general shaved his beard, dressed as a monk, and walked home alone."

"The Order did not rise from the ashes of that defeat. It \*was\* the ashes. A warlord swept down from the north, gathered two thousand of the empire's nobles at a river bend, and slaughtered them all. He didn't hide in the shadows. He forged a new order out of blood and iron, and he made the Emperor his puppet."

"Yang Qin survived that massacre. His task, from that day on, was to find the Imperial Seal: an ancient artifact of absolute order, said to bend the minds of men to one will. He fought in three of the bloodiest wars of his age. He once slipped into the tent of a legendary enemy prince in the dead of night. They didn't cross blades. They just talked, all night, about how a war like this could ever end."

"But in the end, he understood the terrible part. His own ambitious cousin was planning to seize the throne. The Order was never going to be defeated by killing a few tyrants. It was a cycle, and the cycle fed on winners. He tried to stop the usurpation. He failed. They stripped him of everything, and he died knowing the fire of freedom had been smothered by the endless turning of power."

Story 2 — The Guardian Who Dropped His Blade (Tang Dynasty)

His tone changed on the second night. "During the great rebellion of the Tang, there was a man named Pei Kai. He was a Shadow Guardian, sent on a suicide mission: kill a warlord who had sold out the empire."

"Understand," he said, squinting through the smoke, "in those days our Guardians didn't skulk in the dark. They stood in the court. The Emperor's bureaucrats — the Legalists — were the cold, perfect machinery of order. And the Guardians were the scholars who still told the truth, and the disgraced generals who still protected the common people."

Pei Kai had already seen enough blood to break a lesser man. Years earlier, he had marched to the very edge of the world, standing shoulder-to-shoulder with foreign allies against a distant empire. But on the field, the allies turned their coats. The army shattered. He returned home a ghost, carrying the shame of a defeat that wasn't his fault.

Then came the rebellion. And the siege of a city that stood between the rebels and the fertile south.

For months, a handful of loyalists held that city against an ocean of enemies. They ate everything. Then they ate the unthinkable. Pei Kai stood on those walls. He watched his general give up his own flesh to feed the starving soldiers. They held the line. They saved the empire from collapsing.

But when the dust settled, the court didn't honor them. They debated whether the horror was justified. The Legalists wrote the general down as a monster.

In that moment, Pei Kai understood something terrifying. Inside a system that devours everything, one more dead warlord changes nothing at all.

He never used the blade. He turned around, went home, and spent the rest of his life teaching one small boy to read. He killed no one. And still, he cut straight through the darkness of an entire era.

\#### Story 3 — The Royal Blood in the Mud (Song Dynasty)

The third one was about a man named Song Ming. A wanderer out in the northern provinces, fighting alongside a legendary warrior-poet. Song Ming was a brute — a man who loved a good fight a little too much.

But the old man said he carried a secret. He was descended from the fallen imperial house, and in his veins ran a very old, very concentrated blood — the Original Blood.

When the enemy burned his home, Song Ming went back to the ruins looking for his past. In a rotting warehouse, he found a weapon out of legend: a staff once swung by the founding emperor himself.

With that artifact, he could slip into a fury no ordinary soldier could survive — walking through whole battalions like a man cutting wheat. But he could not save the empire. No single staff could.

He fought under a general whose back was tattooed with four characters: \*Serve the Country with Utmost Loyalty\*. That army was unstoppable. They pushed the enemy back, city by city. The people called them invincible.

But the Emperor feared them more than the enemy. A dozen golden tokens arrived in a single day, ordering the general to retreat. Song Ming watched his commander kneel in the mud, weeping, knowing that the empire he was saving would rather lose the war than trust him to win it.

The general was executed in prison on a charge that didn't exist. Song Ming survived. He spent the rest of his life fighting alongside the poet, leading a handful of men into a camp of thousands, capturing a traitor in the dead of night. But the fire never went out. In the end, he had to escort the artifact south, and his friend the poet stayed behind to fight a war with no final battle in it — pounding the railing of a boat, shouting at the river, until he died of a broken heart.

The last story, the old man said, was the one that would wreck you

Story 4 — The Last Scholar of Nanjing (Ming–Qing Transition)

It was after the new dynasty came through the pass, after the massacre at the gateway city — the city held for ten days of killing.

There was a man named Lu Chen. A scholar, a Guardian, a believer in the Philosophy of the Mind. When the old order collapsed and the new rulers came to recruit him, he refused.

But before the conquerors came, there was another fire. A rebel had marched into the capital and declared a new dynasty. For a few weeks, he sat on the Dragon Throne. He promised the people bread and justice. But power is a poison, and the rebel became the tyrant. He tortured the old nobility, looted the palaces, and when the real enemy came through the pass, his empire collapsed like a house of cards.

Lu Chen had watched it all. He had seen the rebel king become the very thing he fought against. He had seen the loyalists flee south, crowning a series of desperate emperors in a string of southern cities — a dynasty of ghosts, each one shorter-lived than the last.

And then there was the sea. A pirate lord, loyal to the fallen house, who refused to kneel. He took his fleet to a distant island, drove out the foreign colonizers, and built a kingdom on the water, waiting for the day he could sail back and reclaim the mainland. He died of fever at thirty-eight, still waiting.

Lu Chen never went to sea. He stayed in the occupied capital, hiding books. Ancient texts, commentaries, rubbings, records — burying them in walls and lending them to families he'd never meet, trying to keep one fire alive through a long winter. When the new regime finally took him, he stopped eating. He chose to starve in a prison cell rather than serve a system he would not consent to.

He never fought to kill anyone. He fought so that something would be remembered.

That was the last of the four. I sat there a long time after he stopped talking.

---

Historical Note: The Hidden History of the "Shadow Guardians"

The old man’s stories are not just legends. They are deeply rooted in real, often brutal, Chinese history, reflecting the core philosophy of the "Shadow Guardians": Nothing is true, everything is permitted.

Here is the truth behind the four stories:

  1. The White Robes and the Flood (The Fall of the Northern Wei)

The "general in white robes" is Chen Qingzhi, a Southern Dynasty scholar-general who led just 7,000 white-robed soldiers 3,000 li into enemy territory, winning 47 battles and capturing the northern capital of Luoyang. The folk rhyme went: "Famous generals, don't be too proud; ten thousand horses and men avoid the white robes."But victory was hollow. His puppet emperor cut off his reinforcements out of paranoia, and his army was ultimately destroyed not by the enemy, but by a flash flood. The warlord who slaughtered the nobles is Erzhu Rong, who executed over 2,000 officials at the Heyin Massacre, cementing his "Order" through absolute terror.

2. The Siege of Suiyang and the Talas Defeat (Tang Dynasty)

Pei Kai’s early defeat is based on the Battle of Talas (751 AD), where the Tang army was crushed after their Karluk mercenaries defected to the Abbasid Caliphate. The siege he witnessed is the Siege of Suiyang (757 AD), one of the most brutal events in human history. General Zhang Xun held the city with ~7,000 men against ~130,000 rebels for ten months. When food ran out, they ate horses, then birds, then tree bark, then leather armor. Finally, Zhang Xun executed his own concubine to feed his troops, and the starving soldiers resorted to cannibalism, consuming over 30,000 civilians. They saved the Tang Dynasty's economic lifeline, but were posthumously condemned by Confucian scholars for "cruelty."

3. The Twelve Gold Medals and the Warrior-Poet (Song Dynasty)

The tattooed general is Yue Fei (1103–1142), China's most famous loyalist, who was recalled by Emperor Gaozong — who feared a victorious general more than a foreign invader — and executed on trumped-up charges of "treason." The warrior-poet is Xin Qiji (1140–1207), who at age 23 led 50 men into a Jin camp of 50,000 to capture a traitor, but spent the rest of his life writing poems about the war he was never allowed to finish, repeatedly passed over for promotion due to the court's paranoia.

4. The Rebel King and the Pirate Lord (Ming–Qing Transition)

The "rebel who became tyrant" is Li Zicheng, who captured Beijing in 1644, ending the Ming Dynasty, but ruled for only 42 days before being crushed by the Qing and Ming loyalists. The "dynasty of ghosts" refers to the Southern Ming(1644–1662), a series of rump courts that resisted the Qing for nearly two decades. The "pirate lord" is Zheng Chenggong (Koxinga), who captured Taiwan from the Dutch in 1661 and used it as a base to resist the Qing — a dream that died with him at age 38.

In the end, the old man's stories echo the same truth: Nothing is true, everything is permitted.The Order is never truly defeated, and the cycle of power never truly ends. But as long as there are those who remember, the fire of freedom is never fully extinguished.

\---

(Disclaimer: This is just a story I heard in a teahouse. Not affiliated with Ubisoft or anything official. Just sharing what the old man told me.)\*

(P.S. If you want the historical shorthand the old man kept reaching for: the Northern and Southern Dynasties is our Game of Thrones — noble houses tearing each other apart while something older watches from the shadows; the Tang rebellion is our Red Dead Redemption 2 — a man realizing the world he's fighting for is already dead, and the only thing left is how he chooses to fall; the Song–Jin war is our Kingdom Come: Deliverance — a brutal, grounded struggle where one man's bloodline is both his power and his curse; and the Ming–Qing transition is our Disco Elysium — the moment the old world collapses, and the only rebellion left is refusing to let the new one rewrite what happened.)


r/ChineseHistory • • 4d ago

Gilded Bronze Dragon with an iron core from Tang Dynasty, unearthed from Caochangpo in the southern suburb of Xian in 1975. Shaanxi History Museum. 7th-10th century China.

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 4d ago

TIL about "Bo Zhong Shu Ji" (伯仲叔季), an ancient Chinese naming convention used to indicate the birth order of sons.

Post image
59 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 5d ago

She Actually Smiled Before Her Execution! The Final Moments of Cheng Benhua, a Heroine of the War of Resistance Against Japan

Post image
90 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 5d ago

TIL that Confucius's surname wasn't actually Kong (孔), that was his clan name. His actual surname/ancestral name was Zi (子).

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 5d ago

Is the Manchu conquest of China the deadliest war of the early modern period ?

2 Upvotes
210 votes, 1d left
Yes.
No.
I don't know.

r/ChineseHistory • • 6d ago

Does anyone else see the similarity?

Post image
111 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 6d ago

Did every Han Chinese believe in reincarnation in the past after the fall of the Han dynasty?

10 Upvotes

So, before westernization but after the fall the Han dynasty, were there significant parts of the ethnic Han population that did not believe in reincarnation? I know that Buddhism grew to become a big religion and that Daoism adopted reincarnation, but were there holdouts from before Buddhism, or new religious developments that rejected this view of the afterlife?


r/ChineseHistory • • 7d ago

Imperial Rome, Ancient Greece and even Choson Korea all had slavery. It was tenacious institution in each of these premodern states. But not so in China. How did the various dynasties manage to buck the trend?

55 Upvotes

Was it the ability to requisition corveé labor from among the “free” population?


r/ChineseHistory • • 7d ago

Need help identify this is Chinese Cong Jade or thumb Ring or something else

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I was able to narrow it down to a Cong Jade or thumb ring. Anyone can help out, I will be appreciated. Helf inch height, One inch long/wide. One ounce weight. Thanks!


r/ChineseHistory • • 7d ago

The Dragon-Head Guillotine: Judge Bao, the Faithless Scholar and the Execution of Chen Shimei

Thumbnail china-underground.com
3 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 8d ago

PHYS.Org: How Chinese brewers refined their booze 5,000 years ago

Thumbnail
phys.org
5 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory • • 9d ago

How did people in ancient China tell time at night? The night watches (更) and the phrase 三更半夜

5 Upvotes

Growing up in Beijing, I often heard adults say 三更半夜 (sān gēng bàn yè), meaning "in the middle of the night." Only later did I learn that 更 (gēng) was actually a unit of time at night.

From what I've read, the night was divided into five 更, each about two hours long, roughly from 7 PM to 5 AM. In cities, night watchmen called 更夫 (gēng fū) walked the streets beating wooden clappers or gongs to mark each watch, and sometimes called out reminders like 小心火烛 ("be careful with fire").

There's also the phrase 晨钟暮鼓 (morning bells, evening drums): bells in the morning and drums in the evening, often from temples or drum towers, to mark the start and end of the day.

Today we still use these expressions. 三更半夜 means very late at night, and 五更 means just before dawn.

I'm curious: does anyone know more about how night watches worked in a specific dynasty, like the Song? And did other cultures have something similar?


r/ChineseHistory • • 9d ago Bravo

Would you say that the Nanking Massacre and the Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki are comparable in terms of how they are remembered/memorialized in their respective countries?

0 Upvotes

I am asking this because I am writing a research paper for school and I am considering focusing it on how Japanese school textbooks portray domestic Japanese suffering versus the suffering they inflicted on foreign nations during the Asia Pacific War, specifically through the lens of the Nanking Massacre/Rape of Nanking and the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. I am neither Chinese nor Japanese however and I am trying my best to treat these topics with the respect and nuance they demand so I wanted a more expert opinion to weigh in on this before I proceed any further in my research. Feel free to correct/redirect me if I am crossing a line in any way.


r/ChineseHistory • • 10d ago

1930s Chinese jewelry

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

I inherited this antique Chinese sterling silver bracelet. Does anyone know what the Han character is?


r/ChineseHistory • • 11d ago

Who or what really was the "Queen Mother of the West"?

14 Upvotes

Was she a Chinese (perhaps associated with the sanxingdui) or barbarian (Qiong or indo-european)? Did she refer to a real person, or a tribe, or something else entirely?