The APEC Leaders’ Summit is scheduled to take place in Shenzhen, China, on November 18–19. Before and during the summit, the authorities are taking measures to ensure security and stability at any cost, including forcibly evacuating all residents living near the summit venue and requiring them to find accommodation elsewhere, suspending some bus services and other public transportation in Shenzhen and surrounding areas, halting the delivery of many parcels, and even prohibiting residents from installing air conditioners. As a result, the daily lives of many Chinese people have been severely disrupted, their rights violated, and substantial losses inflicted upon them.
Some people have also reported that border checkpoints between Shenzhen and Hong Kong have intensified inspections and suspended automated immigration clearance, while providing expedited passage and warm welcomes to foreigners. There have also been reports of a traffic accident in Shenzhen in which an electric vehicle injured a foreigner, reportedly leading to traffic restrictions and a ban on non-motorized vehicles.
All of this reflects the reality that the CCP disregards the rights and dignity of its own citizens in order to maintain political stability and please foreigners. And this is nothing new. Since 1949, the CCP has consistently pursued such policies and engaged in such practices, granting preferential treatment to foreign guests while mistreating its Chinese compatriots. This also demonstrates that the interests of the CCP regime are not aligned with those of the Chinese people, and that the CCP is by no means an institution that the Chinese people or overseas Chinese communities can rely upon.
This article is also a continuation of my previously published article following the Jensen Huang incident, in which I refuted the fallacious claims made by some people that “a stronger CCP benefits the Chinese people and protects them from being bullied.”
Foreigners Enjoyed Privileges in the Mao Era, While Ordinary Chinese People, Especially the Lower and Middle Strata, Were Treated as an “Underclass”: Preferential Treatment for Japanese War Criminals, “Friendship Stores” Reserved for Foreign Guests, the Toiling Masses’ Reception of Nixon and Sihanouk, and More Examples
⠀
Another reality that exposes the falsehood of the claims that “Mao Zedong/the CCP made the Chinese people stand up” and that “Chinese people were no longer bullied by foreigners” is the fact that, during the Mao Zedong era, foreigners enjoyed privileges while Chinese people suffered hunger, cold, and persecution.
⠀
The first important example is the extraordinarily favorable treatment that the CCP regime gave to Japanese war criminals who had committed numerous crimes in China during Japan’s invasion. The Fushun War Criminals Management Centre (抚顺战犯管理所) was the most representative example. It held Japanese officers of various ranks who had participated in or even directed Unit 731’s human experimentation and biological warfare (731人体实验和细菌战), the Nanjing Massacre (南京大屠杀), and the “Three Alls” Policy (三光政策) in North China. Virtually all of them had Chinese blood on their hands, including Hirohisa Suzuki (铃木启久), Shigeru Fujita (藤田茂), and others. In order to win over Japan and gain popular support, the CCP allowed Japanese military prisoners to eat refined grains, such as steamed buns made from white flour, and meat at every meal, even though China was extremely impoverished, ordinary people lacked sufficient food and clothing, and even People’s Liberation Army soldiers lived in hardship and could eat only coarse grains, such as cornmeal. Tennis courts and other recreational facilities were also provided for the war criminals’ daily entertainment.
⠀
Both official CCP media and opposition figures have documented conditions at the Fushun War Criminals Management Centre. Some of this information is reproduced below:
⠀
“The CCP provided Japanese war criminals in custody with exceptionally favorable treatment. The minimum level of treatment they received (note the word ‘minimum’) included a daily food allowance of more than 0.40 yuan. At the time, this was enough to buy half a kilogram of pork and half a kilogram of high-quality rice (whereas Chinese urban residents received ration coupons for only 200 grams of meat per person per month). This standard far exceeded the daily allowance of 0.42 yuan for People’s Liberation Army soldiers in the 1970s (when prices were much higher than in the 1950s). Japanese war criminals not only ate well, but also enjoyed excellent recreational facilities, including sports grounds, clubs, reading rooms, open-air stages, and bathhouses. Their accommodations were also extremely clean and spacious. All three daily meals provided to the war criminals consisted of refined grains, while the guards and reeducation personnel often ate coarse grains and dark steamed cornmeal buns.
⠀
Among these Japanese war criminals was Hirohisa Suzuki, a lieutenant general and commander of the Japanese Army’s 117th Division, which established depopulated zones throughout China; Shigeru Fujita, a lieutenant general and commander of the Japanese Army’s 59th Division, which perpetrated numerous bloody massacres; and Sasaki (佐佐木), a brigade commander who participated in directing the Nanjing Massacre and later became a lieutenant general and commander of the Japanese Army’s 149th Division…
⠀
One soldier guarding the Japanese war criminals actually recognized among them the executioner who had raped his own elder sister and murdered all seven members of his family. Enraged, he grabbed a kitchen knife and chased after the Japanese war criminal. Other CCP reeducation cadres forcibly restrained the soldier and took away the knife. All the soldiers present were so overwhelmed by the injustice that they wept.
⠀
Among the Nationalist Army prisoners of war, only the sick could receive meals from the special kitchen; the others ate meals prepared by the intermediate-level kitchen. Yet all Japanese war criminals received meals from the special kitchen and ate extremely well. They were also exempt from labor. Uemura (上村) and the others spent entire days playing tennis on a triangular open ground inside the compound. Uemura’s wife was also in mainland China. The CCP arranged accommodation for her near Gongdelin (功德林), so that Uemura could regularly leave the prison to live with his wife. Within three years, two more children were born into Uemura’s family.
⠀
Qiu Xingxiang (邱行湘), a Nationalist Army prisoner of war, was also imprisoned alongside the Japanese war criminals. Although the Kuomintang had suffered major losses during both periods of cooperation between the Kuomintang and the CCP, Qiu Xingxiang still dreamed of another round of Kuomintang-CCP cooperation against Japan while in prison, so that he could continue resisting Japan and teach the Japanese a lesson. But reality left Qiu Xingxiang bewildered. He asked Uemura, ‘As a prisoner, how can you afford to support your wife and children?’
⠀
Uemura smiled and replied, ‘The Chinese Communist Party treats us Japanese quite well. China operates a system of state-provided supplies, and having more children brings benefits. Whenever I have another child, the Chinese government increases my family’s supplies by one person’s allocation. I don’t have to support my family myself!’”
⠀
The Chinese government and its official media openly acknowledge their preferential treatment of Japanese war criminals and have extensively promoted it as an example of their “humanitarianism.” The following material is taken from A Documentary Account of the Reeducation of War Criminals in Fushun (抚顺战犯改造纪实). Related and similar accounts can also be found on platforms such as Sohu (搜狐), Sina (新浪), Xinhua News Agency (新华社), China News Service (中新网), and CCTV.com (央视网):
⠀
In order to provide the war criminals with a good living environment and suitable conditions for their reeducation, the Chinese government invested nearly 40 billion yuan in old currency (equivalent to 4 million yuan in today’s renminbi denominations) during a difficult period marked by continuing wars and natural disasters. The funds were used to repair prison buildings, purchase boilers, replace the previous heating arrangements with central heating, and enlarge the original glass windows to ensure that sufficient daylight entered the cells. The war criminals were provided with hot baths and places for music and entertainment. The management centre was fully equipped with bathrooms, barbershops, medical rooms, open-air stages, and other facilities, ensuring that the war criminals could pursue their daily studies and receive medical treatment without leaving the premises, and could live without worries.
⠀
Under the former Japanese military administration of Fushun Prison, there had been a saying: “Eating food fit only for pigs and dogs, sleeping on tattered straw mats, receiving no treatment when sick, and being fed to dogs after death.” After its transformation, the war criminals management centre resembled a school, a factory for reforming the human soul.
⠀
Food was a subject that left a particularly deep impression on both the war criminals and their guards.
⠀
Liu Jiachang (刘家常), a retired cadre who had worked as a prison reeducation officer for forty years, recalled that at the time, the food provisions for Japanese war criminals were based on the supply standards of the People’s Liberation Army. Three levels of meals—large, medium, and small—were provided according to whether the prisoners were generals, field-grade officers, or junior officers and below. The guards and reeducation cadres ate far worse food than the war criminals, but the overwhelming majority nevertheless implemented the Party’s policies without hesitation.
⠀
The war criminals were unaccustomed to the sorghum rice commonly eaten in Northeast China and demanded that it be replaced with ordinary rice. The very next day, the management centre served them steamed white rice. Yet these war criminals were still not satisfied. They demanded noodles and canned fish. Astonishingly, even these clearly excessive demands were accepted.
⠀
The cooks at the war criminals management centre did not know how to prepare this type of “canned fish,” so several war criminals were invited to advise them on the method of preparation. After several experiments, the war criminals actually managed to enjoy the food of their homeland while in prison.
⠀
Cui Renjie (崔仁杰) said: “This was an order from Premier Zhou (周总理). We had to respect Japanese national dietary customs. At that time, these Japanese war criminals, who had personally killed countless Chinese people, were eating foods that ordinary Chinese people would not even have dared to imagine. We were the people guarding them, and our treatment was comparable to theirs: bread, eggs, milk, and Japanese foods such as tempura and festive rice dishes were all available to the war criminals.”
⠀
Japanese war criminal Suiga Yoshio (绥贺好男子) told our reporter: “When I was in the Soviet Union, I weighed only about 53 kilograms and was in poor physical condition. After arriving at the Fushun War Criminals Management Centre, my weight increased to 63 kilograms in less than six months, and my physical condition became much stronger.”
⠀
The man, who was in his eighties, said: “I owe my health to the improvements in my diet and living conditions, which enabled me to regain my strength very quickly.”
⠀
Of course, such treatment was not limited to Fushun. Japanese war criminals throughout China received similar preferential treatment. For example, the remaining Japanese soldiers captured in Shanxi (山西), despite having committed crimes such as murder, rape, and the burning of Chinese people’s homes, were sentenced to no more than ten years in prison. They likewise received favorable treatment while imprisoned and were released one after another. Across the country, at least several thousand Japanese war criminals received similar privileges, while even greater numbers—at least tens of thousands—of Japanese officers and soldiers were released directly and repatriated, or joined the Eighth Route Army (八路军), without trial or punishment.
⠀
Such preferential treatment was justified under grandiose labels such as “humanitarianism,” “repaying evil with kindness” (以德报怨), and “Sino-Japanese friendship.” Yet these privileges constituted an enormous injustice toward the Chinese people who had been killed by Japanese invaders. The food and material resources used to provide these privileges also came from the sweat and labor of the Chinese people.
⠀
Another example that more broadly reflects the privileges enjoyed by foreigners and the treatment of Chinese people as inferior citizens was the existence of “Friendship Stores” (友谊商店) and similar institutions during the Mao era. From the Mao era until the period under Deng Xiaoping (邓小平), major Chinese cities and cities serving as gateways to the outside world had a number of “Friendship Stores,” “Friendship Hotels” (友谊宾馆), and similar institutions. Their common characteristic was that they served only foreigners, overseas Chinese, and other distinguished guests from outside mainland China. Sometimes, powerful figures within the CCP were also permitted to enter. But ordinary Chinese people, including workers, peasants, and soldiers who were so highly praised during the Mao era, were all prohibited from entering unless they received special permission, which was extremely rare. For example, a sign at the entrance to the Guangzhou Friendship Store (广州友谊商店) stated: “This store serves foreign guests. Unauthorized persons are not permitted to enter” (本店接待外宾,无关人员勿进). There were even cases in which a foreign visitor brought a Chinese relative to a Friendship Store, only for the foreign visitor to be admitted while the Chinese relative was refused entry:
⠀
“However, the store staff came out to intervene, saying, ‘We do not serve anyone other than diplomats and overseas Chinese.’ In other words, except for returned overseas Chinese, Chinese people were not permitted to enter. My elder cousin was stunned. It took her a moment to recover before she hurriedly explained, ‘She is my younger sister. She came with me.’
⠀
‘No.’
⠀
My elder cousin tried again: ‘She isn’t buying anything. I’m the one making the purchase. I want to give her a small gift, and I’d like her to choose it herself…’
⠀
‘No.’
⠀
My elder cousin could not help becoming angry. She demanded, ‘It’s raining so heavily. If you won’t let her in, how could I bear to leave my own younger sister standing outside in the rain while I go in to shop? What kind of rule is this?’ This time, the store staff did not even respond, indicating that there was no room for further discussion.
⠀
Now it was not only my elder cousin who was furious; I was furious too. What angered me was that this practice amounted to stripping Chinese people of their national dignity in front of foreigners, utterly humiliating the Chinese people.
⠀
‘What exactly is this regulation supposed to mean?’ My elder cousin seemed to be asking me with her eyes. I could not help blushing with embarrassment all the way down to my neck.
⠀
Unfortunately, such ‘minor incidents’ occurred repeatedly. On another occasion, we were on our way to visit friends when we suddenly realized halfway there that we had forgotten to bring our camera. In order to keep our appointment, we went on to our destination first, then sent the car back to the hotel with my elder cousin’s daughter and my daughter to retrieve the camera. The two little girls, who were about the same age, were very affectionate toward each other and ran hand in hand toward the hotel. Although neither child had identification documents, the foreign girl passed through the reception area without any obstruction, while my daughter was stopped by a sharp shout: ‘Where are you from? You’re not allowed in.’
⠀
My niece said in awkward Chinese, ‘She is my relative.’
⠀
But it was no use. The reply remained firm and unequivocal:
⠀
‘She is not allowed in. You may enter.’
⠀
My niece was so indignant that she took my daughter by the hand and left in frustration, abandoning this hotel, which was even more forbidding than a government magistrate’s office!”
⠀
The CCP frequently claims in its propaganda that foreign concessions and colonies in China during the Republic of China era displayed signs reading “Chinese and dogs not admitted” (华人与狗不得入内). In fact, no such signs existed, although racial discrimination against Chinese people in foreign concessions and colonies was indeed real. The CCP uses this claim to criticize colonial oppression and the “weakness and incompetence” of the Republic of China, while boasting that it defeated the reactionary Kuomintang, recovered the foreign concessions (although in reality it was the Nationalist government that recovered them), and enabled Chinese people to hold their heads high without suffering discrimination. Yet after the CCP established its regime, the Friendship Stores and similar institutions throughout China, along with various other places that served foreign guests exclusively or at least gave them priority, treated foreigners as “superior beings,” while Chinese people, especially ordinary citizens, were treated as an underclass, inferior people, and “untouchables.” This was naked discrimination. The only difference was that such discrimination was carried out by the CCP ruling group, which itself consisted of Chinese people, and disguised under labels such as “international friendship” and “earning foreign exchange through exports.”
⠀
This preferential treatment of foreign guests was retained even after Reform and Opening Up. Especially during the early period of Reform and Opening Up, in the 1980s and 1990s, people from the United States, Europe, Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan received various forms of “super-national treatment” (超国民待遇) in China. During the 2000s and afterward, the privileges enjoyed by foreigners noticeably diminished and became less conspicuous, but foreigners’ requests and complaints still often received greater priority and attention than those of Chinese citizens. Examples include police throughout Wuhan (武汉) helping a Japanese person search for a bicycle, medical personnel in Shanghai (上海) providing an expedited medical pathway for an American patient with a urinary condition during the COVID-19 pandemic, and foreign students being provided with air-conditioned single rooms while several Chinese students were crowded into one room with only an electric fan. These various cases and circumstances all reflect this reality.
⠀
During the Mao era, the CCP also vigorously promoted class struggle, opposition to feudalism, and anti-imperialism, fiercely condemning both feudal monarchs and emperors and the ruling capitalist class of the United States. Yet when US President Richard Nixon visited Beijing in 1972 and Cambodian King Norodom Sihanouk visited Shanghai in 1973, both received grand receptions from the CCP. In Beijing, Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai (周恩来) organized hundreds of thousands of people to clear snow from the Great Wall and other places that Nixon was scheduled to visit, as well as numerous other reception activities that consumed enormous amounts of manpower and material resources. In Shanghai, large numbers of people and extensive resources were mobilized to prepare rare delicacies and elaborate dishes for Sihanouk, along with extraordinarily complicated and meticulous preparations that outsiders could scarcely imagine. The following account is excerpted from Phoenix New Media (凤凰网), with related information also available from China Daily (中国日报), China National Radio (央广网), and other sources:
⠀
“Before coming to Shanghai, Prince Sihanouk had visited the Confucius Temple area in Nanjing (南京夫子庙), where he ate a meal and sampled twelve kinds of pastries and snacks. When the Nanshi District Catering Company (南市区饮食公司) heard about this, it insisted that the prince should be served fourteen kinds of pastries and snacks, demonstrating the culinary standards of Shanghai’s City God Temple (上海城隍庙). At a single command, culinary experts from throughout Yu Garden (豫园) gathered together and created a distinctive selection of fourteen delicacies, including miniature leaf-wrapped rice dumplings, osmanthus rice cakes, three-shred eyebrow-shaped pastries, pigeon-egg rice balls, and small glutinous rice balls in fermented rice wine.
⠀
After this political assignment was issued, the company’s Revolutionary Committee (革委会) worked through the night checking personnel files and investigating three generations of family backgrounds. Lu Goudu (陆苟度), a master of Suzhou-style pastries, along with Zhou Jinhua (周金华), Xie Chichuan (谢炽川), and a group of highly skilled apprentices with impeccable revolutionary family backgrounds, were selected to carry out the task. Xiao Jianping (肖建平) was also chosen because of his favorable family class background. According to his recollection, in order to ensure quality, the sesame seeds used to make the pastries had to be selected one by one, as did the grains of glutinous rice. The melon seeds had to be uniform in size and thickness. Armed militiamen were also stationed at the preparation site, ‘standing by’ with loaded weapons. Prince Sihanouk and his wife sampled the delicacies in Qizao Hall (绮藻堂) inside Yu Garden. Waiters carried the pastries in bamboo baskets from Osmanthus Hall (桂花厅) to the entrance of Yu Garden, where other staff received them and carried them into the hall, before the waiters finally served them at the table. The entire process was constantly monitored.
⠀
Xiao Jianping said: ‘The City God Temple was sealed off for three days and three nights because of this, and the area around the Nine-Bend Bridge (九曲桥) was completely silent.’
⠀
In order to allow Prince Sihanouk to enjoy authentic chicken-and-duck blood soup, it was required that the chicken eggs included in a bowl of the soup meet the ‘three identical characteristics’ standard: identical diameter, identical color, and identical shape. This placed an enormous burden on the chefs. They had to make three trips to Nanxiang (南翔) and slaughter 108 chickens before finding eggs that met such exacting standards. Unexpectedly, Prince Sihanouk postponed his visit to Yu Garden, so another 108 chickens were slaughtered the next day. But on that day, the prince suddenly became enthusiastic about playing tennis with Princess Monique (莫尼克公主) and could not bring himself to stop. As a result, the prepared chicken-and-duck blood soup had to be thrown away. On the third day, February 19, the prince finally honored the venue with his presence. He lavishly praised the fourteen delicacies, especially the chicken-and-duck blood soup, enjoying one bowl so much that he asked for a second.”
⠀
Whether Nixon, Sihanouk, or other foreign guests, they not only received grand receptions during their visits to China, at enormous expense, but the CCP also required working people and ordinary citizens to provide meticulous services to these foreign monarchs, political dignitaries, and powerful elites, performing work resembling that of servants. This was completely contrary to the principles promoted in the CCP’s propaganda.
⠀
The preferential treatment of Japanese war criminals, the exclusion of ordinary Chinese people from Friendship Stores, and the lavish receptions for Nixon and Sihanouk—these three examples all demonstrate, without exception and with striking clarity, the true nature of the CCP’s seizure of power in 1949 and its claim to have made “the Chinese people stand up.” Not only did the CCP brutally oppress the people while its privileged elites seized wealth and resources by force, but it also provided preferential treatment to foreigners and “foreign devils” (洋鬼子). This was completely contrary to its public propaganda about opposing imperialism and feudalism, resisting foreign colonialism, and freeing Chinese people from bullying by foreigners. The CCP itself assumed precisely the role of the “secondary foreign devils” (二鬼子), “foreign agents” (外国代理人), and “colonial enforcers” (殖民者打手) that it publicly condemned. Of course, the examples above are merely the tip of the iceberg, although relatively representative ones, of the CCP’s preferential treatment of foreigners and even the granting of privileges to them while mistreating its own compatriots. In reality, such practices were far more widespread and common. Other incidents, such as an Albanian diplomat killing a Chinese worker in a traffic accident, only for Chinese diplomatic authorities to comfort the diplomat instead, also reflected the same reality: “Foreign lives are precious, while Chinese lives are cheap” (洋人命贵、国人命贱).
⠀
During the same period, the overwhelming majority of Chinese people under Mao Zedong lived without rights or dignity and in conditions of extreme material deprivation. Many Chinese people died unnatural deaths from hunger and cold. Those who barely survived struggled merely to obtain sufficient food and clothing, with no opportunities for enjoyment or entertainment. Peasants lived in almost absolute poverty. Even cadres, People’s Liberation Army personnel, and workers, who belonged to the top 20% of Chinese society in terms of social class and living standards, were generally poor, deprived of rights and dignity, and struggling to make ends meet, apart from a very small number of senior officials. Their rights and their material, cultural, and intellectual lives were far inferior to those enjoyed by people in most other countries at the time—not only in Europe, the United States, and Japan, but also in Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Apart from a small privileged minority, most Chinese citizens at the time were genuinely an “underclass,” severely deprived of rights and dignity, lacking autonomy, and left at the mercy of rulers who could exploit, bully, and dispose of them as they pleased. Against this background, the CCP’s preferential treatment of foreigners and harsh treatment of the citizens and ethnic compatriots under its rule, often sacrificing and withholding the rights, dignity, and material resources of its own people in order to provide privileges to foreigners, further exposed the CCP’s ugliness, inequality, injustice, and cruelty toward the people.
⠀
The CCP behaved this way because enslaving its own population brought benefits without costs, whereas offending foreigners would expose it to various risks and pressures. It was difficult for the CCP to control foreigners’ efforts to defend their rights or retaliate, while pleasing foreigners was highly beneficial to the maintenance of its rule. Therefore, the CCP was willing to betray the interests and dignity of its own compatriots in order to satisfy the various demands of foreigners and appease outsiders. The CCP has never genuinely cared about the country, the nation, or its compatriots. The CCP ruling group is separated from and opposed to the people, lacking national sentiment and any sense of responsibility to serve the citizens. Like the Qing Dynasty regime, the Manchu aristocracy, and their subordinate Han Chinese bureaucrats, who sought to “use the material resources of China to win the favor of foreign powers” (量中华之物力,结与国之欢心), the CCP collaborates with foreigners to exploit and bully the Chinese people. The stronger it becomes, the more secure the prison in which the people are confined, the deeper the nation’s decline and suffering, and the less capable the people become of resisting their increasingly severe enslavement. This is the exact opposite of the CCP’s claim that “the stronger we become, the less we will be bullied.”
⠀
A country should belong to all its citizens, and national interests are fundamentally the collective interests of its people. On the one hand, the CCP speaks extensively about independence, self-reliance, and resistance to imperialism; on the other hand, it provides preferential treatment to foreigners at the expense of its own citizens. This clearly demonstrates that the positions, policies, and interests of the CCP regime and the state under its rule run directly counter to the rights and interests of the Chinese people and the genuine interests of the Chinese state and nation. This contradiction has persisted throughout the entire period of CCP rule over China since 1949. It was most conspicuous during the Mao Zedong era, when the people suffered the most severely from it.
China’s Foreign and Domestic Policies Under Deng, Jiang, and Hu After Reform and Opening Up: The CCP Regime’s Foreign and Domestic Policies Have Always Served the Regime’s Interests and the Stability and Survival of Its Rule, Sometimes Coinciding with and Sometimes Diverging from the Interests of the Chinese State, Nation, and People; the Two Have Never Truly Been Consistent or Unified
⠀
Mao Zedong died in 1976, and Reform and Opening Up officially began in 1978. China’s domestic and foreign policies underwent enormous changes. Some of the distorted, dogmatic, and utterly unrealistic domestic and foreign policies of the Mao era were abolished or modified. Driven by practical considerations, such as the need to prevent the people from launching a revolution and resisting the regime, and the CCP’s desire to avoid being overthrown, the CCP was compelled to take the people’s interests and demands more seriously in formulating its policies, rather than completely disregarding their genuine needs as it had during the Mao era.
⠀
For example, Reform and Opening Up itself represented an abandonment of a political and economic course that had been entirely contrary to national interests, the people’s rights, and their material needs. Instead, the development of productive forces, strengthening national power, and raising people’s living standards became its objectives and the criteria for evaluating its achievements. In foreign relations, China also ceased rigidly confronting the West and capitalist countries, and instead actively sought foreign assistance and attracted foreign capital and technology. Only in this way could China truly move from poverty toward prosperity, allowing its people to benefit as well. Such national policies and concrete measures partly coincided with the path toward national strength and prosperity and the happiness of the people.
⠀
For example, in foreign policy, the CCP abandoned its policy of “exporting revolution” (输出革命) and providing assistance to Maoist and other left-wing forces in Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Instead, it sought to establish friendly relations with developed countries such as Japan, the United States, and European nations. The CCP abandoned its efforts to hold Japan accountable and demand reparations, in exchange for Japanese economic and technological assistance to China, various investments, and international support for CCP-ruled China. China also changed its hostile attitude toward the United States and established friendly and cooperative relations with it. Although some moves in these directions had already begun in the early 1970s while Mao Zedong was still in power, it was only after Reform and Opening Up that extensive cooperation and the introduction of foreign capital and technology were truly realized.
⠀
After Reform and Opening Up, China continued to grant “super-national treatment” (超国民待遇) to visitors from developed countries such as Japan, the United States, and European nations. People from Hong Kong and Taiwan also enjoyed similar treatment for a long time. For example, when disputes arose between Chinese citizens and foreigners, the police and government often favored the foreigners. Certain illegal acts committed by foreigners in China were also dealt with leniently. Various government agencies and members of the public enthusiastically served foreigners and readily gave them special access and assistance, in stark contrast to their frequent indifference, verbal hostility, and deliberate obstruction toward their own compatriots. Influenced by the government’s preferential treatment of foreigners, and also because foreigners were often relatively wealthy and willing to spend generously, ordinary Chinese people were generally friendlier and more tolerant toward “foreigners” (老外) than toward their fellow Chinese. This “super-national treatment” was particularly conspicuous and severe during the 2000s and earlier.
⠀
For example, the Chinese official newspaper Nanfang Daily (南方日报) published an article titled “Foreigners Should Not Be Discriminated Against” (不应歧视外国人), describing how a teacher experienced discrimination at Guangzhou Baiyun Airport (广州白云机场), where Chinese people and foreigners were treated differently:
⠀
He Huixian (何慧娴), a teacher at Sun Yat-sen University (中山大学), wrote a letter to the responsible officials of the CCP Guangdong Provincial Committee (中共广东省委), earnestly arguing that Chinese people must love their own country and people.
⠀
He Huixian stated that, amid China’s increasingly flourishing international exchanges, blind admiration for foreign countries and a growing sense of national inferiority had emerged, while some service facilities were becoming increasingly enthusiastic about serving foreigners exclusively.
⠀
……
⠀
I was very angry at the time. I walked out of the stamp-selling room and looked to see whether there was a sign at the entrance saying “Chinese people are not allowed to enter,” but I found none. I then asked another female staff member whether Chinese people were allowed to buy stamps at the stamp counter. They said yes. So I asked them to convey my complaint to their superiors, expressing my hope that Chinese people would not discriminate against other Chinese people at the airport.
⠀
He Huixian pointed out that some people nowadays despise national dignity and behave like servile lackeys, bringing disgrace upon the Chinese people through their actions. Why should Chinese people, on Chinese soil, encounter such deliberate difficulties when purchasing Chinese postage stamps from a Chinese service provider? Would this not make foreigners laugh at us?
⠀
(Nanfang Daily, October 16, excerpted by Li)
⠀
There was also a 2008 article in The Beijing News (新京报) titled “Zhao Qiang: Was It Appropriate for a Train to Make an Unscheduled Stop for Japanese Passengers?” (赵强:列车为日本旅客临时而停该不该), which described the following incident:
⠀
“On August 22, Train No. 2220, operated by the Dalian Passenger Transport Section (大连客运段), made an unscheduled one-minute stop at a station near the airport to help seven Japanese passengers catch their flight. The Japanese passengers, who ultimately made their flight, subsequently wrote a letter of commendation stating: ‘The train made an unscheduled one-minute stop especially for us. This is something that could never happen in any other country in the world…’ (October 23, Liaoshen Evening News 辽沈晚报).”
⠀
However, the “super-national treatment” granted to foreigners after Reform and Opening Up was at least different from that of the Mao era, which had been driven purely by the illusory pursuit of world revolution, pointless confrontation with the United States and the Soviet Union, and attempts to “put on a brave face despite one’s weakness” (打肿脸充胖子). After Reform and Opening Up, such preferential treatment was more often intended to attract foreign investment and secure support from foreign countries, especially developed nations. This did indeed help China obtain more external support and resources and also contributed to improvements in people’s living standards.
⠀
By the periods under Jiang Zemin (江泽民) and Hu Jintao (胡锦涛), the CCP’s domestic and foreign policies had largely continued along the path established by Deng Xiaoping (邓小平). Relatively speaking, however, by the beginning of the twenty-first century, the CCP had made some progress in economic affairs and human rights. For example, Jiang Zemin’s “Three Represents” (三个代表) made the “interests of the overwhelming majority of the people” (最广大人民利益) its highest objective, while Hu Jintao’s “Scientific Outlook on Development” (科学发展观) placed “putting people first” (以人为本) at its core. The statement that “the state respects and protects human rights” (国家尊重和保障人权) was also written into the Constitution. Although these measures remained highly formalistic, they at least acknowledged the importance of civil rights in publicly proclaimed values and legal principles.
⠀
Nevertheless, “super-national treatment” still amounted to granting privileges to foreigners. It was extremely unfair to the country’s own citizens and ethnic compatriots, and violated the fundamental principles of equality for all and opposition to privilege and discrimination enshrined in China’s domestic laws and international conventions. Although China’s abandonment of efforts to hold Japan accountable arose from various practical considerations, it clearly also undermined justice and the long-term dignity of the Chinese state and nation, while once again harming and trampling upon the victims of the war.
⠀
As in the Mao era, foreigners in China received various forms of preferential treatment after Reform and Opening Up, while Chinese citizens continued to suffer serious violations of their rights. For example, peasants faced exploitation through excessive taxes and miscellaneous levies, as well as restrictions imposed by the temporary residence permit system (暂住证制度). Small vendors were subjected to extortion and exploitation by law enforcement agencies. Citizens generally faced unfair treatment by the police and government, as well as persecution under extrajudicial detention systems such as Reeducation Through Labor (劳动教养) and Custody and Repatriation (收容遣送). Foreigners, by contrast, were not only completely exempt from these human rights violations and the dangers associated with them, but also enjoyed additional privileges. This was clearly extremely unfair to Chinese people.
⠀
Most importantly, the CCP’s preferential treatment of foreigners and its friendly relations with Japan, the United States, and other foreign countries were fundamentally intended to preserve CCP rule and protect and expand the special interests of the CCP’s privileged ruling group. Strengthening national power and promoting the welfare of the people were secondary objectives, pursued only incidentally. Whether through economic development, attracting foreign investment, or improving diplomatic relations, the greatest beneficiary was always the CCP ruling group. Ordinary people could only receive a little leftover soup after the powerful and privileged had eaten their fill. In terms of both material interests and rights and dignity, ordinary Chinese people suffered dual exploitation and oppression at the hands of the CCP ruling group and foreign forces, resulting in serious harm. Nor is the CCP in any sense a reliable defender of the rights of Chinese people and overseas Chinese communities; it cannot be trusted or relied upon.