r/ChatGPTCoding • • Apr 07 '24

Discussion Efficiency when coding is only good when you're self-employed

Efficiency when programming is only good when you're self-employed. If you work for someone else and get paid hourly, efficiency doesn't help you because you put less time on the clock, you get paid less. Projects that you could've billed $30k for, you might now only make $5k for. Programmers will get paid less and have less work with AI. It's really very simple. For example, freelancers that use a timetracker to bill clients shouldn't use AI, because it makes no sense at all. To not realize this is kind of dumb.

6 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

46

u/cbarland Apr 07 '24

Loser mindset. Figure out how to add more value and make the case for better pay once you've demonstrated it.

12

u/CryptosaurusX Apr 07 '24

There’s a point where more value doesn’t translate to a higher salary.

That point is called “you’re an employee and don’t own shit in this business”.

If you have such a high ability to produce constantly increasing value then you are making a big mistake by working for someone else where your salary is capped regardless of your output.

1

u/V4G4X Apr 07 '24

If you're truly adding the amount of high value you think you are, your organisation will notice.

If they don't, you can always find other workplaces which do.

5

u/scottix Apr 07 '24

If you have a job, I wouldn't recommend leaving right now. The software market in the last year has been dismal.

2

u/V4G4X Apr 07 '24

Oh no I'm doing pretty alright for myself thank you very much :)

3

u/absurdrock Apr 07 '24

Exactly. Reputations matter. If you kick ass, everyone will know it. If you don’t get paid for kicking ass at company A, you can at company B. Also, good programmers don’t want to work with lazy or unproductive programmers, so people like this drag the whole team down and breeds animosity. It’s like a virus.

1

u/Camel_Sensitive Apr 10 '24

If you're truly adding the amount of high value you think you are, your organization will notice.

If this was true, employee value would transfer to firm value 100% efficiently, which means no employee would ever be overpaid, and no firm would ever go bankrupt. this is very obviously not the case, and there's several very obvious reasons why.

  1. People hire their friends

  2. Companies often seek growth over margins, which results in hiring, and keeping, sub-par employees, to the detriment of good employees.

  3. Middle-management is often incentive to growth relative to overall company growth, encouraging headcount instead of fewer, better employees.

The real out of truly productive people is creating their own companies. A truly productive person will almost never be paid what they are actually worth, and the disparity grows the larger the company gets.

1

u/V4G4X Apr 11 '24

Nothing is ever 100% efiicient now, is it?

Yeah nepotism and imperfect management exist.

But I've been awed by too many amazing people at my workplace to know that
what I said in my comment is still worth standing by :)

1

u/Camel_Sensitive Apr 11 '24

Meeting amazing people isn't related to organizations not paying people what they are worth, and doesn't support your comment, but good for you? Sounds exciting.

1

u/V4G4X Apr 12 '24

It does and let me break it down for you.

Do you think I am the only one being amazed by these particular colleagues?
Obviously not right? We're a smaller company so it's especially easy for directors and management to notice you.

Everyone notices, and the hard work and quality of output also gets celebrated through the multiple internal awards they get.

With such materialised accolades, do you think they must not be negotiating for better pay compared to the average employee?

If you're truly adding the amount of high value you think you are, your organisation will notice.
If they don't, you can always find other workplaces which do.

Now do you see why it supports my comment?

-6

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 07 '24

I can do that without AI tools.

4

u/mist83 Apr 07 '24

Then don’t use them, but you’re yelling into the void.

Your post made the case that AI could do exactly what you could - only faster - and that your real problem is you’re not going to be able to charge as much.

I’d start to be extremely worried about AI taking my job when my go-to defense against it is to sandbag my clients. It looks like you’re there or close.

1

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 07 '24

This is a little bit disingenuous, you said "AI could do exactly what you could - only faster", instead of "a person using AI could do exactly what you could - only faster". AI can't do anything, a programmer using AI tools could potentially code faster. But the efficiency gains right now are not that great. I am arguing in theory, if AI could make you a lot more efficient and you could essentially be a 10x programmer, that wouldn't be a good thing unless you were self-employed.

4

u/absurdrock Apr 07 '24

It’s a free market of labor though. If everyone else uses it to be better and you don’t, you will be putting yourself at a disadvantage.

2

u/moosepiss Apr 07 '24

Exactly. If I'm looking to have a home built, I'm not going to choose the contractor who swears off using power tools.

3

u/SeaRevolutionary8652 Apr 07 '24

Not sure why you're getting down voted, you're making a valid point: our entire economic ecosystem is setup so that efficiency gains disproportionately benefit the owner class, not the workers whose jobs are becoming more efficient.

Upside though - AI is making it a lot easier to become an owner on the side. I have a normal day job, but my consulting side hustle business has skyrocketed with AI assistance. The barrier to entry for starting your own business is lower now than it has ever been.

6

u/SoylentRox Apr 07 '24

You could also do 30k of work for 10k and do 5k of labor.  Aka pass on most of the savings but work less hard or double your hourly rates.  

-5

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 07 '24

You could, but then you would have to lie about what you did with the rest of your time. If you use a timetracker app you can't do that.

2

u/SoylentRox Apr 07 '24

You also could do a better job. More unit tests, higher code quality. So it nets out to where you are cheaper and your work is better than before AI. And on the margin you become a better choice on the market until all the competition catches up.

5

u/Alternative_Aide7357 Apr 07 '24

That's the point of this advancement. You achieve the project in less time. The less payment made to workers & programmers is another story. Top guys still make money though.

-5

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 07 '24

If that's the point then programmers should not use AI tools. Then you're proving my point.

1

u/Alternative_Aide7357 Apr 07 '24

Then you are fired. You either make less per job or make no shit. I'm certain there are millions of Indian coders ready to take your position.

1

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 07 '24

No, just lie and say you use AI when you don't. You're still employed, and there's no efficiency gains. And then hopefully your c*nty ass gets replaced by AI instead one day.

2

u/TransitoryPhilosophy Apr 07 '24

Why stop there? You should also eschew using computers and electricity

0

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24

Or you know use AI to "HACK THE PLANET"! Bring down the whole global money system!

Or spend time at work writing bots that intercept calls to AI and scramble the inputs so AI outputs garbage across the whole internet. Woo!

33

u/nightman Apr 07 '24 edited Apr 07 '24

Coding is only 10-20% of the work, the rest is thinking about solution, debugging, clarifying requirements etc.

4

u/Once_Wise Apr 07 '24

Excellent response. In my software business I eventually found that much of my work was in trying to figure out what the client needed, rather than what they asked for. They might ask, for example, for a feature that increased the development time by a huge amount, but actually added very little value in terms of their sales. Every client wants their product to do everything, cost nothing, and be done yesterday. So understanding their actual needs and planning how to do it is a big part of being successful. I actually never thought of myself primarily as a programmer, but rather as someone who solves problems that the software I write can solve.

7

u/pancomputationalist Apr 07 '24

Yeah, Copilot probably only provides a 5% efficiency gain, at max, if you consider all the tasks that a software developer needs to perform.

Which is still a LOT compared to what it costs, but it's not like we finish projects 30% faster now than before.

2

u/absurdrock Apr 07 '24

But ChatGPT can also help with those tasks. Sometimes you hit a wall and ChatGPT gives you a spark that ignites a good idea. That or it helps me formulate work plans and design docs quickly to pass up the chain or share.

1

u/name-taken1 Apr 07 '24

Not if you work at a startup...

0

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24

[deleted]

8

u/nightman Apr 07 '24

Like they say - AI won't replace you. People that use it, will.

1

u/cporter202 Apr 07 '24

Absolutely! It's all about leveraging the tools available. A craftsman doesn't get replaced by a better hammer, they just build more amazing things with it! 🛠️ Efficiency is key, no matter who signs the paychecks!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Apr 11 '24

Sorry, your submission has been removed due to inadequate account karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/PhotographyBanzai Apr 07 '24

Contracted software development shouldn't be hourly. Sounds more like a company wanting to not actually hire people but still benefit from them without paying the full cost of an employee.

For normal employees I don't see a drawback to them having tools that make them more efficient, but the possible outcome would be to cut the workforce rather than expand the business because that's easier and less forward thinking to do. 🤣

Whatever you or whoever else is doing hourly as "freelance", something isn't right to begin with. Change your structure to per project and don't let them see inside because that's none of the client's business unless it's a massive project where you provide updates as part of your service.

4

u/mcharytoniuk Apr 07 '24 edited Apr 08 '24

If you bill the client by the hour and not use AI you will be more expensive than someone who does and you will lose your clients eventually. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

4

u/Once_Wise Apr 07 '24

I had my own software consulting business for 35 years before retiring and purposely making yourself less efficient makes no sense to me. You do not make money by trying to maximize your income by being inefficient, you make money by maximizing your clients income and that often means getting to market fast. Time to market is critical, a product out this year might be worth a lot but if it comes out a year later it will lose out to competitors. I always charged top dollar for what I did and clients would often complain that I charged too much. But guess what. For their next project they came back to me. Why? Because they knew with certainty that their project would be completed on time and would work. And avoiding failure is worth a lot to a company.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '24

When you first started, how did you obtain clients.

1

u/JoMa4 Apr 10 '24

A fax machine.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Apr 12 '24

Sorry, your submission has been removed due to inadequate account karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/megadonkeyx Apr 07 '24

yes boss it will take six week.. you finish in two and take four weeks on idle.

1

u/Thaetos Apr 08 '24

Lmao. you got it. and if you work remote it's even more beneficial to you as a developer.

1

u/Ok_Abrocona_8914 Apr 07 '24

This op right here is why people are loving that they'll eventually be able to prompt what they want and get it for a fraction of the price they would pay a dishonest dev.

0

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 07 '24

Will never happen. Imagine if AI was so advanced that you could just prompt and it will develop anything for you at a tiny cost? Then we're all doomed, everyone's job is at risk then, not just developers. The government better give some handouts or something because we're all going to be poor.

And let's not pretend like there are not dishonest clients. Clients that try to scam developers are only willing to pay someone like $2/hr. A lot of developers don't make that much money, even though it requires a lot of education. I for example don't charge $400/hr, I charge like $40/hr if I'm lucky and I get a good client, and I'm in Canada. I'm not making that much money as a developer. I'm mostly getting used and having my time wasted by shitty scamming clients. So it's more complicated than you're making it out to be.

0

u/Ok_Abrocona_8914 Apr 08 '24

Lol dude anyone with a hint of how the world works knows it's going to be that way. First a company will come with that solution at 1000$ (example), then they start undercutting eachother until its some negligible price, not to mention open source solutions. I dont know about all jobs, but software development will be one of the easiest to replace, and its being replaced as we speak.

1

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 08 '24

You didn't even give any argument. You just stated that software development jobs would be one of the easiest to replace. Probably because you are not a software developer. In reality, think about all the other white collar jobs that are less complicated than software development, especially entry level jobs, that will be easily automated with AI agents. Like assistant, customer support, sales, telemarketing, data analysis, bookkeeping, basic financial reporting, and all repetitive administrative jobs. Like 95% of white collar jobs can be automated if software development will be automated. You just don't really know what you're talking about.

0

u/Ok_Abrocona_8914 Apr 09 '24

I'm a surgeon. Even my job will be replaced one day. You thinking software development isn't going to be replaced easily when it's one of the top priorities of these companies and one of the most asked features of the general public is just not wanting to see the obvious.

1

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 09 '24

You're just speculating about things that may or may not happen in the distant future. Like a humanoid robot that has the intelligence of a human being and motor skills and dexterity even better than a human being that can perform surgery without making any mistakes or causing any liability. You are a nutcase, that's the reason why you think software development jobs are going to be "easily" replaced. You belong on the r/singularity sub.

0

u/Ok_Abrocona_8914 Apr 09 '24

No dude. You're just blind and someone who isn't smart enough to see the obvious.

Well, after all, youre just a software developer so I wasn't expecting much from you but damn, no wonder an llm will replace you in a couple of years.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '24 edited Mar 17 '25

zephyr truck boast live racial fine hard-to-find strong future aback

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/Dr_SnM Apr 07 '24

If I heard any of my staff talking like that I'd sack them.

1

u/Particular-Sea2005 Apr 07 '24

I cannot believe this is not the top comment, for a thousand reasons.

1

u/Thaetos Apr 08 '24

The only correct answer.

2

u/Specialist-String-53 Apr 07 '24

If you're remote just use ai to be more efficient and then go do your laundry. if not remote I guess read webcomics or sm

2

u/Thaetos Apr 07 '24 edited Apr 07 '24

I do agree with you, although you don’t become a good programmer with doing jack shit effort or having a lazy mentality.

The highest earning programmers who work for companies are usually those who put in the work / hours, and have tons of experience by performing at above average levels.

If you don’t want to put in the work for a boss, just go work at a local mom & pop webdesign agency or small start-up. Their standards are usually pretty low, but so is their pay.

However, I’d pick working as a freelancer for a company rather starting my own full-blown business.

I’ve been on both sides. Running your own company is a pain in the ass.

You’re responsible for everything, all the way down to the bottom. Which over time leads to being less productive because of the administration that comes with it.

The next step is hiring people to do the productive work for you. So if you like programming eventually you will do none of that anymore.

Usually not worth the hassle unless you make a shit ton of money as founder / CEO.

2

u/SirLoremIpsum Apr 07 '24

 Projects that you could've billed $30k for, you might now only make $5k for. Programmers will get paid less and have less work with AI. It's really very simple.

If you were hiring a crew to dig your swimming pool would you hire one man with a shovel or one man with a digger? 

Productivity tools are always better for everyone.

What other tools are you using that improves your productivity? Why stop at AI? I bet you use dozens of things that saves time and improves efficiency. 

3

u/paradite Apr 07 '24

I've been self-employed, doing freelancing and building my own products for 2 years now.

I think it will take some time for the market and clients to catch up with the AI coding mindset. Before they realize that AI provides an X% increase in productivity, you can continue to charge the same amount based on the old "perceived" number of hours required, ie. how long it would take for a human to complete without AI.

After the clients realize that everyone is using AI, you could then charge by project-basis (not affected by number of hours), or charge a higher hourly-rate because of your ability to complete the project in 1 week instead of 2 weeks, I think reasonable clients will understand.

2

u/inigid Apr 07 '24

Well said. This is why I won't use a compiler when doing jobs. It's much better to spend days translating things into machine code by hand.

That way, I get paid a heck of a lot more by billing more hours, and the client is happy knowing they have a real artisan working on their project who cares to look over every single byte.

Anyone who uses computers to speed up programming is part of the problem.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24

You’ve obviously never heard of “get the job down then shut your mouth and cruise”.

1

u/Reason_He_Wins_Again Apr 07 '24

Decent trolling.

7/10 for effort.

needs a ;) at the end to get an 8

1

u/brett1231 Apr 07 '24

Don't charge by the hour. Charge by the project.

If you have to bill hours, bill the amount of hours necessary to get a fair price.

I never had a problem doing this. Most clients are interested in getting a solution that works.

1

u/InvertedVantage Apr 08 '24

That's why I bill at fixed hours or by project 

1

u/Alert-Track-8277 Apr 08 '24

You assume employers dont care about your output.

1

u/nowthatswhat Apr 08 '24

Yeah good point, consultants should start using the on screen keyboard and type with a mouse instead of using a real keyboard so they take longer.

1

u/TheDeepOnesDeepFake Apr 10 '24

"freelancers that use a timetracker to bill clients shouldn't use AI" ... ? You are going to work a certain number of hours no matter what. The promise of technology bringing efficiency, which further was said to bring shorter work days, is not a thing... You just do your day.

1

u/redditigation Oct 06 '24

This reminds me of the time when me and a coworker figured out that he was making more money than I was because he, getting paid the same as me, was doing less work, therefore spending less body or brain energy, and thereby spending less money on sustenance.

1

u/GeneralZane Apr 07 '24

The whole point of programming, coding and using these types of tools is to increase production and efficiency.

If you have that type of mentality you probably shouldn't be programming or using chat GPT at all, you should be working for the government watching the clock all day.

0

u/stonedoubt Apr 07 '24

What a cynical and pedestrian view.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24

[deleted]

-2

u/EuphoricPangolin7615 Apr 07 '24

Ooh, I bet you love the sound of that don't you? People losing their jobs. So wonderful. C*nty shit.

Except that would never actually happen, because if AI was so advanced that it replaced 85% of software engineers, then it can basically replace everyone. Then the singularity is immanent. In that case, we are either all doomed, or we're on the road to utopia. There's not really that much middle-ground. But one way or another, jobs will be the least of our worries.

But even though this is a fantasy of yours and would never (and could never) actually happen, you will always be that cnt that was rooting for people to lose their jobs. That's one thing that will never go away. That cntiness is just part of your being.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Apr 07 '24

Sorry, your submission has been removed due to inadequate account karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/AutoModerator Apr 07 '24

Sorry, your submission has been removed due to inadequate account karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.