r/CharacterRant • • Aug 03 '26

Films & TV Just came out of the theatre after watching Nolan's odyssey and wow that was shit

17 Upvotes

Spoilers obviously but man where do I even start? The changes made in the story are so bizarre and just....unnecessary I guess. I mean why remove the "Nobody" line? That's such an iconic part of the story and is the entire reason why odysseus was unable to go home in the first place. Why turn him into this generic war hero with ptsd instead of being witty and somewhat of a pathological liar like in the original story? Why turn the Odyssey into ancient Oppenheimer?

Why add Sinon in this movie? Nobody cares about Sinon. Fuck Sinon. I don't give a shit about Sinon. Nobody does. He's not even in the original poem. Why is he in this movie so much? Why did you decide to add him in the underworld scene, and then remove odysseus' mother and Achilles? You decided to remove two of the greatest scenes of the entire poem, to make room for Sinon????????????

What was the point of the laestrygonians? They show up everywhere in the trailers and posters and for what? To destroy two boats? Who gives a fuck? In the original poem, the laestrygonians acted sort of like punishment for the crew because they opened the bag of air, but in this movie, they feel like a dumb random encounter. Not to mention the scene itself is super awkward. The laestrygonians suddenly appeared fully geared up out of nowhere and they just started killing odysseus and his crew for no reason.

Also, fuck the imax cameras. Nobody gives a fuck about your cameras Nolan. 90% the population can't even watch your movie in full screen. And even if they could, seeing more of Agamemnon's dumb helmet doesn't make this movie less shitty than it already is. Fuck this movie.

Edit: Most people are missing the point of my problem with Sinon. I don't like Sinon because everything that he stands for as a character is a complete downgrade of the character Nolan decided to cut, AKA Achilles. Achilles' scene in the underworld was so great because it breaks the theme of kleos, the belief of immortal fame. Showing Achilles, the greatest warrior ever who was shown in the iliad to be this sort of YOLO, live fast die young personality to actually regret his decision was 1) a perfect closure to his character, 2) delivers an anti-war theme anyway. Why cut this pivotal scene in the epic, for a character who wasn't even in the story in the first place? And that's not all. Odysseus mother wasn't even in this movie for some reason when seeing her was one of the saddest scenes in the entirety of the poem. It genuinely feels like Nolan doesn't actually care about the Odyssey and only wants to tell his version of the story, which means fuck all when you're doing an adaptation.


r/CharacterRant • • Jan 26 '24

[One Piece] Yamato’s gender is only a “debate” if you believe in a strict gender binary Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I got into One Piece within the last 6 months, but even before, I saw people losing their minds over the question of whether or not Yamato is transgender. It’s gotten to the point where even bringing it up is controversial. It is my understanding that this topic has probably been done to death. However, this is r/CharacterRant and I need to rant about the treatment of this character.

TLDR; Yamato is definitely not cisgender and not clearly trans. If you believe everyone is a man or woman, this is a debate with two sides. If you believe gender is a spectrum, Yamato is gender non-conforming and there isn’t anything to debate until it is explicitly stated otherwise.

After reading Wano for myself, I have come to the conclusion that Yamato’s gender is only “up for debate” if you try to insert a rigid gender binary into a world that regularly plays with the idea that is not as simple as that. Bon Clay and Ivankov have been towing the line between male and female since before the timeskip. Not only that, but these characters encourage others to explore their relationship with gender in positive ways. I’m not going to pretend that Oda handles these concepts perfectly, but, gender nonconformity is a legitimate and intentional facet of the One Piece universe.

Yamato is not cisgender

Everyone in Wano who knows Yamato refers to them with male pronouns. Kaido acknowledges Yamato as his son and heir to his throne. The beast pirates accordingly refer to Yamato as “son of Kaido.” This is in contrast to a flashback where Yamato is the “oni princess.” Once luffy gets to know Yamato, he does the same, giving the nickname Yama-o implying that he acknowledges Yamato as a fellow man. Yamato regularly uses male pronouns for himself, and this is reflected in official English translations. Yamato is the only female-assigned character to use the pronoun “Boku”. The use of the pronoun “Boku” is typically used by young males. There are examples of women and girls in Japan using boku, but these examples are recent and challenge it’s historical use. This doesn’t necessarily confirm Yamato’s gender, but if anything, the decision to use this pronoun at least goes to show Yamato is not *strictly* female. Finally, when given the choice of bathing with males or females, Yamato is confidently comfortable bathing with men. Kiku, born male, prefers to bathe with the women because that’s what makes her most comfortable. The only way you can come to the conclusion that Yamato is “just a tomboy” or no more than a biological female is if you ignore an enormous amount of textual evidence, as well as the entire official English translation.

Yamato is not necessarily transgender

The main piece of evidence that “Yamato is not trans” is the Vivre Card Databook. This complimentary product identifies Yamato as a female. It also identifies Kiku as male, but a woman at heart. Kiku is someone who presents as female and easily passes as a woman. She has always felt that way, and fits into the prevailing narrative of what a trans person is. The databook is clearly giving information on biological sex, given the caveat attached to Kiku. This does not disprove that Yamato is trans, it merely implies that Yamato’s relationship with their gender is not the same as Kiku’s.

There are also arguments based on the fact that Yamato does not present as masculine. If you believe in a strict gender binary, comparing Kiku to Yamato will lead you to conclude that Kiku is trans (she is a woman at heart) and Yamato is not (he isn’t even trying to pass as a man). The idea that Yamato’s decision to not hide his breasts and curves disqualifies him from being trans is the same as “if a trans woman is bigger and harrier than me, I’m gonna call them he because that makes more sense to me.” Making this argument is a tell that you don’t believe trans men are men unless they look like what you think a male ought to look like and/or you don’t take gender expression seriously unless it matches biological sex. Still, the text is not explicit that Yamato is trans where it’s abundantly clear for Kiku. Perhaps a better point of comparison is Izo, who presents as feminine but is not a “women at heart.” Izo is proud to be a son of whitebeard regardless of how he dresses. He is respected and treated as a man by his crew mates while wearing a kimono and lipstick. In the same arc we have a person that looks like the opposite gender of their body but does not use pronouns of the opposite gender.

Yamato is just larping as Oden

This phrase is tossed around like it’s an end-all-be-all and passed off as a reasonable take. Not only is this reductionist, it’s terrible analysis. If Yamato is “just larping”, why doesn’t anyone call him out? Why doesn’t Yamato dress like Oden? Why doesn’t a single person say “Yamato is not a man”? Why doesn’t Yamato switch to female pronouns when he isn’t calling himself Oden? It’s a statement full of holes. The only textual evidence for the idea that Yamato is “just larping” is when he says “Oden was a man so I am too.” If you consider Yamato’s other lines on the subject, this fits better into Yamato’s characterization of someone who is trying to be the person they want to be by emulating a man they know to be great. There’s no delusion from Yamato that he is actually Oden, it’s an alternative name that serves as a reminder for Yamato that he can be the change in the world that inspires others the way Oden did for Yamato. It’s also a segue for Yamato to join the raid on the side of the Scabbards despite being the child of the antagonist. If you think the whole I am Oden schtick is cringe, that’s fair. I’m going to cut some slack for the person who spent their whole life locked up Rapnuzel style while getting the shit beaten out of them by the strongest man on Earth. Annoying writing choice? Maybe. Proof that Yamato is only pretending to be a man? Certainly not. “Oden was a man so I will be” only supports the argument that Yamato is a woman when you take it out of context. It’s cherry-picking.

If you are at all familiar with politics, you’ve probably heard the complaint “X is trying to change the meaning of Y media by injecting their own narrative into the story.” If you come on this website and tell people “Yamato isn’t trans she’s just larping”, you are X. You are doing the “libs making everything woke” in the opposite direction. You have cherry-picked the source material while avoiding mountains of evidence to the contrary in order to come to a conclusion that fits your personal narrative.

Is Yamato trans?

If yes, it is in a different way than Kiku. If not, Yamato lies somewhere on the spectrum between man and woman, and there’s nothing wrong with that. Yamato is clearly not tethered to the gender of his body. If trans people see Yamato as representing them, I think that’s awesome. Queer people are generally underrepresented in mainstream media and even if the character they relate to doesn’t perfectly represent who they are, it’s a net positive. If cisgender people are also inspired by Yamato, that’s awesome. No one is “claiming” this character. They’re just trying to find comfort in the media they enjoy through their personal interpretation.

One Piece is a fantastical universe with animal and fish people, communities above the clouds and denizens of the deep, giants whom you could fit in the palm of their hand and Tontattas that fit in your own palm, Frankenstein monsters and war machine automata, individuals with the powers of God at their fingertips and simple farmers who will never leave their home. If a person who looks like a woman calling themself a man is the thing that trips you up, ask yourself why that is. That reason is not that it doesn’t make sense in the story. There is simply too much evidence you need to ignore to think that way. Maybe…it’s you.


r/CharacterRant • • May 27 '26

Comics & Literature I know it's not fair, but I can't help but resent Harry Potter's popularity.

69 Upvotes

Now, this is a case where I definitely feel like I'm heavily biased here because I didn't grow up with Harry Potter. While I've always been a huge bookworm, I never really read the Harry Potter books before I turned 20. A large part of this was mostly due to a negative experience I had in high school where a few of my classmates... I don't want to say "bullied," but they did treat me as an outsider for preferring Percy Jackson over Harry Potter. It didn't exactly make me want to go out and read the books for myself.

But here we are, several years later, and I finally read them.

My feelings are incredibly mixed leaning towards negative if I'm being honest.

I already made a whole post talking about why I think Harry Potter's message is hypocritical, and honestly there's so much in these books that leaves such a bad taste in my mouth. The fatphobia, the constant contradicting of its messages, the mean-spirited tone, the insistence blood purity doesn't matter all the while showing that yes, it absolutely does, how the Wizarding World is just an elitist toxic hellhole with inconsistent worldbuilding when you break it down, how all the characters are unlikeable jackasses, the half-hearted and racist representation (I know Rick Riordan gets flak for the representation in his books by some people, but at least the guy tried), and how Harry is just a total bore of a protagonist.

And normally this would be fine; it'd just be another mediocre book series in my eyes...

Except it's popular. It's made money, even as the creator has shown herself to be a bigot who is actively hurting people in real life, and yet people are still throwing money at her because to them, a fictional universe is more important to them than those real people she's hurting.

And look, I know it's "Just a kids' book." I shouldn't be expecting "true cinema" from it or for it to be perfect. And that might be true, but here's the thing...

There are so many other better kids' book series out there.

I'm not just talking about Percy Jackson mind you; I'm talking about so many others. Wilderlore by Amanda Foody which is basically medieval fantasy (with some exceptions) Pokemon and a world-trotting adventure; Dragonborn by Struan Murray which is basically Harry Potter with dragons with a great message about letting go of grief and moving on; Fireborn by Aisling Fowler, an insanely awesome dark fantasy about child monster hunters; Amari and the Night Brothers by B.B. Alston which is basically a fantasy version of MIB with a female Black protagonist dealing with discrimination in both the regular world and the fantasy world; Story Thieves by James Riley a story about hopping into books with an incredibly meta take on books in general; and a ton of others. And that's not even getting into standalone books and/or books that are set in the "real world."

These are all great books that deserve to be read and deserve at least half, if not more, of the success of Harry Potter. Books that actually have positive representation, have proactive protagonists who have to actually struggle and need to make an effort to fit into the fantastical worlds they're a part of/enter, and most importantly, practice what they preach. Some of them are even mature and have interesting things to say...

And these books will likely never get the attention they deserve because Harry Potter has overshadowed them all. People will keep giving attention and money to a book series that, frankly, isn't that good and is funding a creator who is actively hurting people.

I know it's not fair. I know it's not the fault of Harry Potter the story, for being so popular. The story didn't ask to overshadow all those other books, and it's not like it's going around forcing people to read it instead of those other books...

It just sort of makes me sad, you know?


r/CharacterRant • • Dec 08 '23

Anime & Manga [One Piece] The Celestial Dragons are so badly written that it boggles the mind how the LA will make them work.

10 Upvotes

To get this out of the way, no, the CD's are not one bit realistic, because this isn't Epstein Island, this is if an island full of Imperial Japanese soldiers also openly became Hitler Epstein hybrids with zero ambiguity and got the island to be a legal nation while also visiting places with a 10 year old girl rape-strapped to their dick while walking around constantly.

To say that the CD's are realistic you'd have to be so mentally broken, so incapable of being social, so internet addicted that you'd barely count as a human when you're not online.

Good? Let's go.

The lack of foreshadowing from the Celestial Dragons are probably the biggest indicator that Oda had zero plans for them, even after Water 7 the way Garp is written clearly doesn't have the CD's in mind, hell the Five Elders in Jaya don't have any info to their status as Celestial Dragons, just high-ranking dudes.

And that's not even going into how the Ohara flashback has them being a bit remorseful about killing Clover, which is hilariously deranged since we all know about that line from Saturn about humans being like bugs, hell even their reaction about Lulusia Kingdom now seems inconsistent with how fans say it's them hesitating, it felt like more or less them just going "Oh, shame." in the most sarcastic, "I don't give a fuck" manner possible.

This also doesn't help how their basically doing it all over the world, we learn that they can go to places like the East Blue thanks to Saint Jalmack in the Post-War flashback, with these weird box helmets instead of the usual bubbles, and later in Doffy's flashback everyone knows about them, and has been a victim at some point or had a loved one be a victim, no outliners unless you're a noble.

So why the fuck would anyone want to be a marine? At some point this shit would've hit them, and people wouldn't even think of going to the Marines, and if you go for lack of knowledge, why on earth hasn't the RA exposed them yet?

Like this is the main issue with them, they're so evil because then Luffy would look ultra cool when defeating them, but because there's so many contradictions about the rest of the world, Oda has to neuter everyone else for it, otherwise Dragon would've destroyed them by now.

Oda wants to have his cake and eat it to with a lot of things.

He wants Garp to be the good guy of the Marines and be a brave, rebellious badass, but also wants Garp to be ineffective against the Celestial Dragons and at the same time be not complicit in serving them, but that idea doesn't exist since he his serving them by any rank, and the Buster Call proves that even the Vice Admirals are just pieces for the war crimes.

It doesn't help that Oda also has Fujitora exist in the story, and while he's also held back from being actually effective, Oda has him doing stuff that makes Garp into a chump by comparison, and that comparison is just "who's an actual rebel and who's lying to himself?"

And Dragon? Ho boy does Dragon get fucked. He's an idiot who can't suggest the idea of playing both sides to Vegapunk, can't even do anything about Ginny and the chapter that showed it, there was literally no discussion about what to do kinda shows what Oda thinks about the RA: They exist to be shat on most of the time, and aside from Sabo being super plot-armored because he's Ace model 2, the rest exist to be extras.

Hell, Sabo's success exists only because Fujitora and Cobra being the allies of Luffy before theirs.

Oda's idea of the One Piece world is Luffy being the messiah, and therefor everyone else will have developments that totally existed the whole time that only Luffy has the power to solve. And the Celestial Dragons are just the biggest indicator.

They're such a big fucking nightmare because everyone involved has to be unethical or incompetent to make it work.

Dragon and the RA can't be much unless Sabo does something, Kuma can't just push the disease away from Bonney, Newgate can't save Wano, Neko and Inu can't just ask help from Newgate, Oden can't just notice his dad being imprisoned since we know so little context of the visit to the Wano Road Poneglyph that would require them going into the country and finding out about so much shit.

So how the fuck will they actually adapt them? Frankly cutting them out works out pretty well.


r/CharacterRant • • 20d ago Bravo Heartwarming

One Piece isn't perfect, but it is notably better than most of its peers and it absolutely deserves its popularity

83 Upvotes

This is going to be very long (like the series in question).

I've come to generally "trust" One Piece. There's been many times my enjoyment of the series has been reduced, but it has always managed to pull me back with stuff that makes me interested and impressed all over again. Tomino (Gundam creator), who has talked about OP a few times, once said:

"But, you know, among the popular manga there is manga with very beautiful art and manga with bad art, but interesting nonetheless. And I don’t trust manga with very beautiful art unless it is One Piece.”

I began reading One Piece in high school (2017, I believe) through my school's library, which had an extensive manga catalogue, including what I remember as being most of One Piece. Before that I was a Dragon Ball fanboy (if you stalk my account enough you'll see I used to argue my brains off for DB on r/whowouldwin) who had also tried (though often not finished) other stuff including Hunter x Hunter, One Punch Man (anime and webcomic), Gurren Lagann, and Akira (movie and manga). At the time the manga was in Whole Cake Island. I didn't know much about the series, but I knew it was big and I had seen it referred to as being among the "Holy Shonen Trinity" (now commonly known as the Big Three). When I started it, I found it charming and cool. The concept was appealing, the main characters were likeable, the stories were entertaining, and the SBS section was fun. The art, while very different from most stuff I had seen prior, was also very appealing to me. I remember reading Baratie in band class and loving the action (Luffy breaking Don Krieg's armor was a striking moment to me); it was both cartoony and over the top but hard hitting, kinetic and brutal. When I got to the classic "Help me" moment in Arlong Park I was enamored. I kept reading, very much enjoying most of what I read up until Skypiea, where one or a few volumes were missing in the library. I wasn't as hooked and took a break for a while, and when I came back I made the dumb decision to just read the next volume available, finished Skypiea, and then picked up toward the end of Foxy when I made the switch to digital, missing crucial parts of Skypiea and most of Long Ring. I won't go into an extreme amount of detail of the process after that since I've already talked a lot, but I will say that I enjoyed most of everything that came after, and caught up during Wano. By then it was pretty much cemented as my favorite series. The fact that it was long usually wasn't really a problem to me because I wasn't watching Toei do an impression of a snail and I wasn't clamoring for the series to end.

Over the past several years, One Piece has become highly scrutinized online and has lost a portion of the good will it once carried in the public eye. A lot of this criticism is understandable and expected. There are many problems with One Piece, both lasting and more modern. I myself had become a bit unenthused when I caught up in early Wano, and since then there's been tons of polarizing stuff, including something that Oda can be seen to have anticipated to be controversial, Gear 5. But I also believe that a lot of the common criticism levied towards this series has become a series of lazy, misleading cliches and misrepresentations (largely brought on by the fact that a lot of people either haven't read the series or stopped a while ago). There's an increasingly common perception that One Piece is a low-effort, mass appeal product of unremarkable quality meant to go on forever (a.k.a slop). On the contrary, I truly believe that on balance, One Piece tends to be a high quality series, especially when you compare it to its peers.

First, what are the series' main strengths? I'd say: a knockout main character, a very wide variety of great ancillary characters, strong thematic writing, remarkable emotional resonance, relatively good internal consistency and continuity (especially considering its length and density), great worldbuilding, attention to detail, solid creativity, "vibes," and a story and world that gives a lot to talk and think about. I think that in general, even though these things will waver throughout the story, Oda's skill in these areas remain to this day. I also think that compared to most of the other stuff that would be most likely to be compared to it, One Piece is a monster in these departments. JJK is a high quality series that is absolutely huge, but it would be hard to defend the opinion that Yuji is a a better main character than Luffy for most people who enjoy both series, valid as the opinion may be. Naruto is extremely solid, but I think OP reaches higher peaks and will not have an ending arc as problematic. I got bored with Bleach in a way I didn't with One Piece. I just think it's genuinely distinguishable in quality from a lot of stuff.

Now there's so much stuff I could rant about when it comes to discussion of this series, but I'll get into some prominent topics of contention where I think there are misrepresentations. First, I actually think that One Piece's "politics," or other similar "serious topics," while notable, are not as central to its quality as a lot of the fans will say. There's tons of stuff with similar audiences that addresses that type of stuff, like Fullmetal Alchemist or Avatar the Last Airbender. I'd say in terms of themes, One Piece is actually way more noteworthy "philosophically" or "poetically" than politically. Take the arc of Skypiea, for example (which I went back and fully read, along with Foxy). There clearly are themes that could be called "political," such as claim to land, progress vs. tradition, and the struggle against the erasure of peoples and history. But there should also be talk about the themes of romance (in the literary sense) and dreams, faith, and the human desire for vindication. Don't get me wrong, One Piece has politics. But I think the incorrect framing of One Piece as a battle shonen Communist Manifesto rather than something more like a battle shonen William Blake work actually leads not only to misplaced discussion, but improper criticism! You'll hear stuff like "it's not that deep, One Piece is just dictators bad, slavery bad, racism bad, starving bad" as if the series wasn't saying tons of stuff before the revolutionary themes were even that prominent. As if the most interesting part of Fishman Island isn't that it tells you that racism is bad, but how it explores how discrimination affects a people's spirit, and the paths of healing for that. I mean why, with a series with so much analysis and discussion of parallels to real life, am I the only person I can find who has noticed the possible connection between Shandora (golden city that ascends into the heavens) and the New Jersualem from Revelation (golden city that descends from the heavens)? Especially in an arc with so much talk of "God?" People have pointed out the Israel/Palestine connection in the arc; why not this other possible theme connected to Abrahamic faith and history?

One Piece nowadays often gets flack for its female characters. For example, a viral tweet that has inspired much discourse and many derivatives posited what it would be like if Oda had wrote Maki from JJK. I won't deny that One Piece is primarily a boy's club, and that there's notable fanservice and a repetitive design template for pretty female characters. However, let's look at the actual common claim: that Oda is bad at writing women. Is this really an accurate claim, at least when compared to other shonen, and even JJK itself? When I think of One Piece women, though there's not as many super important or strong ones as the boys, I think of characters that are generally good, if not always in execution, then at least in their construction. Nami, Robin, Vivi, Pudding, Bonney, Big Mom, Carrot, and Hancock are all characters I have positive opinions on. Robin's pre-TS arc would probably be the best character arc in many series, period. People used to directly compare One Piece's relatively good female characters with series like Naruto, though there's long been criticism levied towards designs and sexualization. And with all due respect to Gege, he would have an aneurysm trying to write a character like Kureha. I think it's funny that Maki is used as the example because if you take any other JJK female character, they'd have less prominence, less notable writing, little in terms of a character arc, and likely have a far smaller fanbase. I mean, Gege often got these same "bad women" allegations! As did Horikoshi! I'd sooner accept Oda as a disgusting misogynist than as someone who couldn't write women, because I think that's blatantly untrue. Toriyama has even more direct proof of misogyny ("Lady Red" is pretty insane, content warning), has even more egregious fanservice in early DB, and his series is even more of a boy's club, but I'd he say he can write women too.

As I mentioned before, One Piece will have points where I start to enjoy it less. However, these instances are then punctuated with peaks I just can't get anywhere else. Thriller Bark, which isn't a bad arc in my opinion but is understandably less popular, ends with an absolutely insane sequence when Kuma arrives and is followed by the freaking Sabaody to Marineford stretch. Wano had tons of polarizing stuff, but it also has what might be the best fight in the series, an instant classic Roger moment that redefined what we thought of the One Piece, tons of wow factor, lore stuff, great character stuff for Sanji, and as a whole was a big part of One Piece's new wave of mainstream popularity in the West. Most recently, I personally was not as motivated to read recent Elbaf, though on paper I liked the turns of events. But the recent Sanji stuff is extremely compelling and rewarding, and now I'm really excited for the next chapter. The idea that Oda is just washed and can't make something worth reading anymore is just not true to me, and if you've seen that screenshot of someone ranting on a forum around the time of Enies Lobby complaining that the series had lowered in quality, you've seen that this type of discussion is not new. On that note, when I was reading Naruto a while back, I tended to look up old discussions for chapters after finishing them, as I often do for manga. I already knew that there was tons of criticism, but man, the discussion was brutal. It was very often filled with a significant amount of negativity, even concerning stuff that now is lauded, like Itachi or Obito. This fall from grace posture might just be a feature of the long running shonen space in the information age.

Now, One Piece certainly isn't without its flaws. Some of the main ones I'd point to are:

- Repetitiveness. I don't mean the cliche people bring up about Luffy saving a kingdom/island and princess from a dictator/oppression; One Piece actually deviates from this a lot (many of its most popular or critically acclaimed arcs don't follow this, including Baratie, Water 7, Enies Lobby, Jaya, Sabaody, Amazon Lily, Impel Down, Marineford, Whole Cake Island, Zou, Egghead) and even when it doesn't, the world and wider themes justify liberation from oppression being a common theme. I'm referring to stuff like the narrative forcing the Straw Hats to separate so that they can do a bunch of tasks and maybe have individual fights. Stuff like the forced "Ticking time bomb" element added to a lot of arcs added for tension. Stuff like Luffy conveniently befriending someone from almost everywhere he goes to give him a reason to risk everything for them while the narrative insists he's not a hero. Stuff like gags being repeated without enough variation.

- Fakeout deaths. Self explanatory, though Oda has been killing more people in recent years.

- Decreased focus on the Straw Hats, and a general feeling of flanderization there in general for a bunch of them.

- Bad paneling after the timeskip (though recently it's been more serviceable)

- Art is just not as good anymore. I think the peak of Oda's pen was probably early to mid post timeskip; things were just really sharp and pretty. Understandable; he's getting older. But it's quite noticeable.

- The fight choreo and flow is inconsistent, especially over time. There's some genuinely really good stuff and some really mediocre/bad stuff. Wano actually has some of Oda's best (read 1010 or 1037 again) and then after Wano it's just not as good. This seriously hurts an arc with a good deal of impressive writing like Egghead, because other than that it's largely a mad scramble of fights.

- Related to the fight complaint: the chapters nowadays almost feel like they're intentionally written to be adapted into the anime. As if Oda realized that Toei was putting more effort into the anime, and also that they're only going to adapt one chapter, so the best thing to do was to write them like a storyboard for an episode, bloated with text, and with deemphasized action art. Like he thought "who cares about making my chapter a good comic when the anime will make the actual fights and have cool directing?"

All in all though, I think One Piece is really good for what it is, and I trust that the ending will be good too.

TL;DR: I trust One Piece. I got into the series years ago after already experiencing other series and it captured me like very little before it. I think the increased scrutiny its gotten, while largely understandable, is also kind of inaccurate in ways. Despite its flaws, One Piece is peak battle shonen and will likely stick the landing.


r/CharacterRant • • Apr 06 '26

Films & TV I finally watched Hazbin Hotel and realized the searing hatred people have for this show is utterly pathetic and is actually fear of sincerity

36 Upvotes

Initial Perspective

There is a lot of media out there that I've never really interacted with and only have a very vague/fuzzy understanding of, largely informed by the amorphous opinion the internet parades around. Simply put, after having these takes in my peripheral for so long they tend to stick subconsciously. This was the case for Hazbin Hotel.

I had this mental image of an obnoxiously exaggerated thin proportioned artstyle, insufferable swearing, and fandom-proximity. The kind of thing you'd see someone using in a VR Chat clip and reflexively cringe at.

Some time back I ran into some video along the lines of "How Zach Hadel succeeded where Vivziepop failed", and being a massive fan of Smiling Friends who just finished season 3, I decided to bite. I have followed Zach's career for years and was excited that he was receiving wider recognition for how genuinely funny and skilled he was!

But as the title suggests, it wasn't simply singing his praises, it was comparing him with Vivziepop, someone who at this time I knew nothing about. I couldn't articulate it at the time but something felt off with how insistent the bashing was, how weak the dramas alluded to seemed. I can't remember specific lines, but I remember walking away just incredibly unimpressed by the thesis of the video.

By this time Spotify had already played one or two Hazbin songs for me over the years and I'd come to love them before realizing what the source was, so when it happened yet again with "Vox Populi", I decided it was time to finally watch the show and see what the fuss was about. At least I'd stop worrying about spoilers and get to rant if it sucked, right?

Actually Watching It

I put on an episode while I ate dinner, figuring I could get one or two in before bed. I like musicals so it couldn't be too bad.

Well, soon enough it was 2 AM and I had just ran through the entire first season and started watching Helluva Boss. I got 4 hours of sleep before going to work and then finished the rest of it during the week before beginning season 2 of Hazbin.

I fucking loved all of it.

One of the reasons I had slept so little was that I was attempting to piece together any kind of coherent explanation for why there was such a deranged hatred for this show online, but the more I looked the less sense it made. Behind every curtain was a big fat juicy nothing burger worth 0 calories.

I'm not gonna pretend the show is flawless, but jesus christ, compared to how it has been portrayed on the internet it almost does seem flawless just by the juxtaposition. The premise isn't groundbreaking, but its a fun little narrative of conflict between heaven and hell and the inherent humor in the ideas of redemption. The characters aren't the best thing since sliced bread but they're fun and surprisingly likeable.

The Criticisms

The swearing is literally- WHO THE FUCK CARES MAN. IT'S ALRIGHT. ITS FINE. THEY SWEAR A BIT LIBERALLY, YES, I GET IT. BUT GET A BETTER CRITICISM THAN THAT! I thought it was going to be in like every other sentence the way people had talked about this, so comparatively the mild overuse is literally so fucking unimportant I could not care less. Also they're literally demons in hell, its kind of their thing to be shitty and obnoxious. It also feels like such an unimportant complaint when everything else surrounding that is great.

The art style is gorgeous. Again, one of those things where in my mind I had this caricature of a very exaggerated vomit of colors in some vague association with 'tumblr bad', but the characters designs all are nice. I love Charlie's design. Sometimes they do have the quirky angst level heterochromia, but again, I truly could not care less when everything else is great. These are the kinds of nitpicks that should only be coming from the mouth of a rantsona who is nitpicking line by line a show that was absolute trash. That is not Hazbin.

The story is limited in scope and very 'tight' and fast paced, but to me it felt very obvious from episode 1 that this was an intentional choice. I have no doubt in my mind they went in with the mindset of having to prove themselves to the executives who had greenlit this show, and so they didn't go crazy and made an arc that could wrap up in the 8 episodes they had. In my opinion they did an amazing job. It wasn't looking to reinvent what a cartoon was, it was looking to be a great show, and it succeeded.

Angel is a character who I imagined I would absolutely despise from the beginning, he's perfectly set up to be my most hated being in existence, but after watching that once again also turned out to be wrong. They actually address the fact that the overly sexual veneer is just a cover for how traumatized and lost he feels. It's his attempt at regaining control of a situation where he is definitionally powerless, and people around him don't just endlessly enable it. Yes, the show does play into it for a bit, but it always makes sure to show how this is ultimately still taking advantage of angel and directly harming him. His song is explicitly about that, and I love that!

A good number of the staff didn't get explored in depth in season 1, but again that felt understandable to me and just makes me excited to see if they'll be expanded on in season 2. Also, I don't usually care about this, but for some reason it is incredibly refreshing to see up front how many characters are very casually gay, straight, bi, lesbian, etc. I think maybe the reason I like it is because I knew as soon as I saw these things that the people who hate this show absolutely latch onto these things as well when they bitch and moan about it. But the show is unabashedly itself, and itself isn't afraid to have proximity to fanfic culture or tumblr or whatever other label someone wants to throw at it. It IS fun to have ships and pairings in your show. It IS fun to have a little angst.

Vivziepop

The more I learned about this show and everything surrounding it the more frustrated I became at all the shit it gets. I tried looking for reasons why people have this hatred for not just the show, but the Author Vivziepop specifically, and everything I found was just so profoundly underwhelming.

There seems to be some strange bashing from both ends regarding the prevalence of LGBT characters. One side unsurprisingly is just convinced its woke propaganda, meanwhile the other insists that its inserted cynically and secretly Vivziepop hates LGBT people and just uses them as a useful audience to cater to, both seemingly in utter denial that any part of it could be meant earnestly. How someone sees the presence of a trans woman character and decides this is a calculated attempt to garner social credit is beyond me and just leaves me scratching my head.

The other major complaint levied at her seems to boil down to "she responds to people who dislike her show sometimes and I think that's lame and gay". In the case of the video I mentioned at the beginning, this is contrasted with the righteous and stoic Zach Hadel and Michael Cusack who very wisely and serenely are above such petty squabbles and don't stoop down to such vulgar and uncouth public displays.

The Core Issue

This is where the overarching issue in all of this starts to become visible. The real reason people circle Vivzie like sharks smelling blood is the fact that she commits the ultimate internet sin: being earnest.

Zach and Michael are Zen-like; they're detached and unbothered. Vivzie is the soyjak who has emotional outbursts.

Zach is celebrated and admired for being the slightly detached and cool dude-bro who never takes things too seriously. The show doesn't take itself too seriously, everything is laced in 10 layers of irony, and I LOVE the show for it, its great humor, but that is NOT what makes art good exclusively. Being earnest is FUCKING BEAUTIFUL and people hate to see someone being genuine and pouring their heart out. It's seen as in "bad taste". Taking things too seriously. It's fucking cringe. It's exactly what the recent usage of nonchalant online is about, this mental image of being untouchable if you just insist you don't give a fuck about anything. Can't be hurt if you never cared right?

Fuck off. Being chalant is amazing. Giving a shit about your art and telling a cheesy ass story about redemption and horribly flawed people trying to be good is AWESOME.

The Subtext

And perhaps this is where I'll lose people, but the more I think about it, the more it becomes clear that this necessity to punish sincerity all ties back into misogyny.

That's what it all stems from. That's why the protagonist of Hazbin is accused of being a Mary Sue or a self insert (the fuck kind of criticism is this?). Because no, you don't get to just have an energetic and slightly unhinged young woman as the main character, it has to be an energetic and slightly unhinged young man, also know as Pim from smiling friends, because then its very subversive and cool that he's being genuine even though someone could make fun of him for it!

You don't get to have couples that openly show affection or romantic plotlines, because that's cringey and effeminate, you can only have storylines where a love interest is a tool by which the main character learns some stupid lesson from this female character that is for some reason drawn as a perfectly normal human with normal human proportions and a normal voice and is conventionally attractive. Either that or the love interest is the butt of a joke by way of the shock factor of this nasty little man getting with a girl out of his league or because he will eventually lose her. Once again, all of this is Smiling friends.

You don't get to have emotional moments where characters break down without it being a joke, because then you're being corny and writing fan fiction and that's bad. You should be funnier!

You don't get to be quirky because that's trying too hard and women aren't funny, even though all of Smiling friends humor could just as easily be described as quirky and they depend just as much on awkward humor and odd dialogue between characters.

The character designs are shat on because a decent number of them are informed by what would be more appealing to women. Everything is just forcefully shoved through this lens of only being good if it appeals to the idea of a "normal viewer" where normal means a man in his late 20s. A male character can't be depicted as attractive without becoming "tumblr sexyman bait".

The hatred for the musical aspects of the show are yet another piece to this, as if they're something to be deeply ashamed of instead of something that a lot of people (cough cough, predominantly women) authentically love and enjoy. It's just pointing at anything people perceive as feminine and yelling "cringe!".

Career Comparisons

Both Zach and Vivzie have done amazing stuff and they're both great. Zach and Michael have even voiced characters in Helluva Boss and historically they've run in similar circles, with Oney hosting a drawing episode where she was guest. With this in mind it's frankly insane that anyone would put Zach up against Vivzie with regards to their career trajectories, it is such a manufactured conflict.

This idea of Zach being a quiet genius and Vivzie being a bumbling idiot who doesn't understand industry is so unnecessary. Hadel would be the first person to agree that the animation industry is a hellish nightmare where maintaining your artistic vision is like trying to thread a piece of hay through a stack of needles. He's intimately familiar with failure, Smiling Friends isn't the first animated show he tried to pitch, and I have no doubt he would give Vivzie props for what she has accomplished.

The fact that she simultaneously made a high production show that is free on YouTube while simultaneously pitching Hazbin to major companies, and then succeeded in delivering on both ends is nothing to scoff at. She landed a partnership A24 and Amazon no less, and somehow has navigated all of this while guaranteeing she gets to keep full control of Helluva Boss, it's nothing short of remarkable.

TL;DR

Hazbin isn't ground-shattering new stuff, but it is not even remotely deserving of the visceral contempt the internet holds for it. In fact, it's pretty good if you go in expecting what it says on the tin. The actual issue is people's unaddressed discomfort with witnessing sincerity, and frankly femininity.


r/CharacterRant • • Aug 18 '26

I hate how people say X men isn't a good allegory for bigotry because they have powers. It's a superhero series it's build into the premise.

21 Upvotes

Okay, i am sick of seeing all these takes that the X men don't work. Because they are actually dangerous unlike real minority groups.

News flash it's a superhero series. What do you expect?

It's the premise of the series. Is people are born with powers they didn't ask for and are hated for it.

The alagory is you are born as something, and people hate you for it. Which you can't change. Because it's a superhero show, they have to have powers.

It's would be like saying

Fantasy Racism doesn't work. Because Elves are literally a different species.

Or

Robot bigotry doesn't work because robots are not alive

That's the premise of the series you expect that going into it.

Also, last order of business.

2 things

  1. The x men do work in the main marvel comics. Because there is functionality nothing different between someone born with powers and someone who gets them. It's stupid and it reflects how bigotry is stupid

  2. The mutants are too dangerous. Fun fact most mutants can be killed with guns and just look different. It's only the 1% with actual food powers.


r/CharacterRant • • Jun 08 '25

Anime & Manga There's nothing wrong with queer headcanon or in reading queer subtext between rival/best friend characters in Shonen, especially with characters that have no confirmed sexual orientation.

195 Upvotes

Lots of battle Shonen will have the MC and his male best friend/rival who quite literally only ever talk about ,think about , and have intense loving and respect feelings about each other while their female love interests are practically non existent plotwise until they get together from there barely founded romance from that quick look in the eyes at the beginning of the series. Alot of them don't even get a love interests and some of these characters aren't even confirmed to be straight.

But let anyone describe the homoerotic subtext or headcanon them as in love or as gay or queer couple the heteros get upset like properly passed off about it . Always shouting "you've never had real friends before" or "let guys have healthy friendships" as though the wholly codependent "friendships" of these characters is healthy and that people who are in romantic relationships aren't also in a healthy friendship with friendship with each other.

I'm arguing with a guy right now about this specific one so I'll use it as an example: Gon and Killua from HxH. The author is known for adding LGBTQ characters to his work and neither Gon or Killua have been shown to or ever said to have any attraction to girls/women not by the anime/Manga or by word of God Togashi. So reading them as gay/bi and or a couple shouldn't hurt anyone's feelings. Especially since they have a shit ton of romantic context like the flowery language Killua used to describe Gon or their friendship like calling Gon his "light" or how Jealous he got over the whole Palm date. Gon's constant reassurance to Killua and kind of taking care of him emotionally initially. And it's just a fun way to look at it .. and people disagreeing is perfectly fine but getting utterly offended at and basically trying to fight over it is crazy as though it's just not possible even though neither of them have anything close to a female love interest. It's just giving homophobic as the young kids say.


r/CharacterRant • • Sep 07 '26 Bravo

The lack of realism in [ Re zero ]

0 Upvotes

Subaru simply doesn't act as a real person and doesn't have realistic reactions to what's going on .

He do whatever and feel whatever the plot demands at the time.

For the simplest example we have rem killing him in the mansion.

There's absolutely no way someone reaction to figuring out the person who killed him multiple times and now is torturing him and cut off his leg ( even though ram was the one who did that )

Would be to say he's grateful for them teaching him house chores.

Like seriously who is acting like this.

And the solution to the problem was staying there and doing everything to make friends with the people who killed him . So he can stay with his wifu Emilia.

The author even have the nerve to make a if story saying if he left he would have become an evil sycopath.

Like wow not wanting to be with the people who kill you on a wimp is such a bad thing.

That there's no in between either you follow my plot or i make you evil there's nothing else.

Also Emilia was the person who put him in the mansion without asking him what he wants.

And when she brought him there everyone said to simply let him die rather than healing him .

This was a red enough flag that even someone as stupid as her should have realized letting him stay is a bad idea.

But she didn't pay any attention and let rem kill him two times .

In the time she finally did something to help Subaru get over the problem that she put him in by her own accord .

She's treated like the most kind and compassionate person ever .

Even though she just talked and done nothing directly to fix the problem .

Making me hate her character as well .

Basically everyone in the mansion was a horrible person.

But somehow there's absolutely no negative feelings toward any of them from Subaru side.

Even with all the pain and suffering.

This is not how a human world act .

This is just plot .


r/CharacterRant • • Sep 12 '25

I really dont like how two male friends are always considered lovers now a days by fandom shippers

8 Upvotes

Today i saw a post shipping Superman and Lex. I m afraid what will happen when Man of tommorow will be released. I will have to shut down my twitter whole 3 months before release. I just hope that makers dont give in to this and aftially make them gay couple. I will stop watching any dcu movie.

Another bad example is Stucky. Steve and Bucky are brothees in arms. They are shown exclusively straight. Bucky was player before whole brainwashing fiasco. Steve has also been shown attracted exclusively to females. But somehow they give gay vibe to shippers. I see them as best friends and brothers.

I know that LGBT people carve for representation but it can get weird when 2 male characters cant be shown as friends without somw shippers calling them gay.

Earlier it was male and female cant be friends. Now no one can be friends


r/CharacterRant • • Jul 08 '26

Games Not having characters with values that were standard in their period is a shame

0 Upvotes

So I was playing The Witcher 3 and something came on my mind which I then thought and linked to two other games. Rdr2 and Ghost of Tsushima.

That is, these games, while masterpieces, have one issue.

The characters, the good ones, have modern point of views on discrimination, racism, homophoby etc...

So:

Arthur is against Slavery. And he's not racist against Lenny.

Geralt has modern point of views on marriage and women independency.

Jin doesn't mind lesbian relationships.

It's so weird. Like, I get it, you don't want the player to feel bad. But you spend all this time creating a realistic environment and then you only give bad uncool traits to villains?

Cause the developers know exactly what they're doing. Everyone around these characters acts like a piece of shit (maybe less In GoT) but the main character is clean on that aspect.

There's a number of bad traits that are seen as uncool to have, reasonably so, but the issue is that it makes the world these developers perfectly created feel less real.

Idk just something that came on my mind tell me your thoughts.


r/CharacterRant • • Sep 22 '25

Luffy defeating Kaido One on One did irreparable damage to One Piece's story.

0 Upvotes

Among the many defenses I hear about Wano, this is one that fans often downplay the most when it is honestly the most immersion breaking thing I have ever seen, even by One Piece standards. Crocodile vs Luffy or the 3 Admirals vs Luffy was a case of (ludicrous) plot armor, but this is leagues worse.

It's like Oda watched the 1st Broly movie and decided "yeah, let's adapt that into One Piece!".

For context, Kaido in Wano acted basically as Broly in his first movie, taking 0 damage (No, Zoro doesn't count) throughout the whole raid until he just folds to Gear 5 Luffy, just like Broly got 1 shot by Goku in that movie's ending.

Forget Gear 5 and whether it makes sense or not, whether it fits or not; this fight completely nuked any future Luffy fights from having any stakes, like at all.

Even now with the introduction of regenerative villains (copying DBZ's homework), it doesn't feel at all like Luffy is facing a major threat, which is huge disconnect from how the story portrays said villains. It feels "dangerous" for the weaker part of the crew (if you still believe Oda will kill anyone), but Luffy himself has not felt threatened at all since the resolution of fight with Kaido. Gear 5 making everything a joke certainly doesn't help.

I understand the 5 minutes limit of Gear 5 is "supposed" to fix this overwhelming hax Luffy got, but I don't think it repairs anything (it is as annoying as the recharge time of Gear 4) and it doesn't magically make the fights have stakes again.


r/CharacterRant • • Apr 12 '26

General The Amazing Digital Circus isn’t indie. Expedition 33 isn’t indie. Words have meanings, but corporations have perverted the term to get free passes for their behavior and make more money.

435 Upvotes

What is indie media? Well, let’s start at that first word. What does “indie” mean? It is a shortened term for the word “independent”. Merriam-Webster defines “independent” in this context as “not subject to control by others”, “not affiliated with a larger controlling unit”, or “not requiring or relying on something else : not contingent”. So, the term “indie media” can be expanded to “media which is not affiliated with, reliant on, or controlled by a third party”.

Wikipedia defines “independent media” specifically as “mass media, such as television, newspapers, or Internet-based publications, that is free of influence by government or corporate interests.” So, we have a pretty clear, comprehensive picture of what “indie media” is. It’s media which is controlled by its creator, not a third party corporation.

So, given that, why the hell are we calling productions which are controlled by publishers “indie”? You might have heard about The Amazing Digital Circus’s final episode coming to theaters two weeks before it releases on YouTube. This has been quite controversial, not in the least because, in an interview with Cartoon Brew, Glitch’s general manager and development producer Jasmine Yang said“We are a Youtube-first company. We believe very strongly in the future and potential of Youtube for long-form animation.” So that was a fuckin lie.

This was done by Glitch Productions, the production company which owns the rights to The Amazing Digital Circus, without any involvement or say by the creator, writer, and director of TADC, Gooseworx. Notice the paradox? A production company, not the creator/director/writer owns the rights. They can do whatever they want with it, however they want. Does this business model sound familiar to you? That’s right: it’s exactly how Disney and Nickelodeon and all the rest work.

By definition, that isn’t indie. That’s just a smaller corporation. Expedition 33 is the similar; the rights are co-owned by Kepler Interactive. “Indie” darling Disco Elysium is a bit odd, it actually did start production as an indie game. But by the time it was released, calling it an “indie game” is shaky. The founders of ZA/UM were the creators of Disco Elysium. However, to fund the game, they sold shares of the company. Then, one of the people who bought shares pulled out, and sold his shares to one of the other people that bought shares initially, giving his holding company a controlling amount of shares. Which he paid for using ZA/UM’s money, a clear case of embezzlement. But this is such a clusterfuck that frankly, either position can be argued.

But things like TADC and E33 are not indie. They’re just A and AA productions. One can debate about whether getting outside funding from a third party in exchange for revenue sharing while the creator maintains the full rights to the media, like the deal worked out between Too Kyo Games and Aniplex for The Hundred Line, counts as indie. They’re financially dependent, but they still at least own their own media outright. Aniplex cannot fire them and do whatever they want with the IP, like what Kompus did to Robert Kurvitz and the rest.

Things like Undertale and Deltarune or anything made by DevilArtemis for his own channel are definitionally indie productions, there’s no debate on that. But when the actual creator owns nothing and has no say, is merely dependent on the grace of the IP holder, that’s not indie. That’s just having an IP owner you work for who isn’t fucking you over. Until they do.

Now, why are they called indie? Simple: marketing! “Indie” has more “soul” to people than something that isn’t “indie”. People make allowances for things that are “indie” that they don’t make for things that aren’t “indie”. Why is the production time slow enough to give birth to three children? It’s indie, you have to be understanding! Why does something not have translations for some of the most common languages on Earth? It’s indie, the artist’s vision is only compatible with languages they speak and so you can’t criticize that! Why is the merch so ridiculously overpriced? Well indie creators have to get paid somehow! If it *isn’t* indie, all these things and more are fair pickings for the masses to rip a company to shreds for, but if it’s indie, you’re anti-art if you don’t give them a free pass for it.

So of course every corporation wants to market their media as indie. It gets them free passes and lets them make more money. They can lie to your face and go back on their word, as Glitch did, and you’d better celebrate it, because “this will do so much for indie media”. When it *isn’t* indie, when you make promises to the consumer with not an ounce of wiggle room or loopholes, and then you just go back on that entirely in the search for more money, the backlash is consumers standing up to a corporation fucking around. When it’s labeled as “indie”, the backlash means you hate art.

“Indie” is becoming a marketing term that means “you’re the bad guy if you criticize our corporate actions”, and by calling these obviously not independent productions “indie”, we are serving to help them.


r/CharacterRant • • Feb 10 '25

Dandadan is one of the better new gen animes but also one of the most grossest

0 Upvotes

From the original story, the stellar voice acting, the amazing animation, there's a good story there....

It just sucks that it's also has ecchi moments that ruins any enjoyment of the story.

What's even more frustrating is ...it's also part of the plot. Which makes it worse. Fire force has the same issue, but at least it's not plot relevant with that one female character (can't be bothered to remember her name) but her clothes keep coming off randomly as a gag. How is it funny? Why do they keep doing it? Was it necessary? Idk guess the creator has issues.

I really wished anime studios had higher ups who could screen these sorts of things. Maybe tell them no. On one hand, it's good their willing to give their creators creative freedom, but they need to put limits.

Do viewers in Japan and overseas just not see an issue with this? Do they just not care? Does the creator of the story just not see the criticism?

There's moments in the story that arguably works. Episodes that are actually good. But then it just can't help itself with tripping over itself with gratuitous scenes. But it's also ...a part of the plot. You can't just gloss over the scenes and move on because it's a part of the storyline

I've heard it said it doesn't happen again later on in the story but I really do hope their right, but I just can't in good conscious pretend that those scenes don't ruin any enjoyability in the story.


r/CharacterRant • • Mar 14 '26

General Native people of desertic ecosystems being white

14 Upvotes

With Vivi actress in the One Piece love action being black, my real question is why she was white to begin

The biology of One Piece is wacky, so don't take this too seriously

But, from a World building perspective, a population in a desertic environment would likely bring a population of darker skin to deal with the sun

You also have Sunagakure in Naruto, a village of ninjas that live in the desert, that are in their majority of light skin

This is gonna be my new world building pet peeve. Not a problem by any metric, but makes me 🤔

Edit: Also, important to note that not all the population in deserts aren't white, it's just curious when most of the population isn't in the universes


r/CharacterRant • • Jun 13 '25

General There is nothing wrong with TV shows and movies trying to score ‘diversity points’

0 Upvotes

Edit: I’m not talking about race swaps by the way. I realize that wasn’t clear.

There seems to be this implicit agreement, both by bigots and allies, that minorities being ‘shoehorned’ into shows just so the creators can tick off boxes is a bad thing, but I strongly disagree.

Like it or not, people are more likely to watch a show if there is a character they can project themselves into, and the more ‘boxes’ you tick, the broader the appeal of the show will be. I can personally tell you that as a gay man, I am significantly more likely to watch a TV series if there’s a gay character. And it’s not because of #representation, being ‘woke’ or needing people to see my story. I literally just care more about the show because I can get giddy about one of the romantic subplots. It’s not that deep.

But the character’s personality is just being [blank].

I hear people say this all the time, but I very rarely actually agree. It only starts to bother me when it gets brought up in random conversations. I think in our mission to tackle stereotypes, we’ve overcorrected and act like behaving in a remotely stereotypical way is inherently bad.

But there aren’t that many [blank] in real life.

Since when do you expect the spectrum of media you consume to be an accurate depiction of real-world population statistics?

But the character is poorly written.

You are allowed to dislike a character, you know? Why must you make the issue about their minority status? Or do you genuinely believe your issue with this character wouldn’t have existed were they not a minority?

But it’s bad representation.

This is only a valid criticism when the show attempts to tackle some issue and fails.

If the show doesn’t tackle the topic at all, then expecting them to do so is problematic and makes it feel like you think those minority groups are defined by their struggles.

On the flip side, I agree with the criticism of shows seemingly doing just that: defining minorities by their struggles. It gets frustrating to watch gay romances that are always about being hated by their parents and needing to run away.


r/CharacterRant • • Nov 05 '25

Hunter X Hunter Magic System isn't particularly hard or amazing

31 Upvotes

HxH has been praised for its magic system many many times by now, people say it's hard with well-defined boundaries and all.

But honestly once you are past the initial introduction, it quickly becomes an "author gives some power he made up to character". We get some vague things, but that's about it.

Aside from some very limited things like how Gon's Jajanken works, we don't really get much idea how everything else is even made.

Why again can Nen disable another's Nen? Where do all that hex stuff come from? It's all powered by Nen, so more Nen should overpower any hex like Kurapika jail chain, but I guess not.

Knuckle's APR is indestructible apparently because of some reason. Might as well have made a full body suit out of that APR stuff.

Apparently you can steal other people's abilities... somehow too. How can Nen manipulate minds? It... uh, somehow can.

Have we ever... seen a character develop their ability from scratch, from the fundamentals, beyond basic stuff? Not really. We aren't give much insight into it.

We are given basics, then jump into "so anyways, everyone has x power", without the middle step going into detail and filling us in how it works.

Restrictions make ability stronger? Exactly what does stronger even mean? Could you blow up earth if you limited yourself to a microsecond of nen and then you die?

Knowing the scope of a magic system, its limitations and methodology are important for hard magic systems, yet HxH is very hand-wavy with general vague statements about the whole thing.

You should be able to predict, and know the scope of what each character can do, but character abilities in HxH are just whatever the author feels like it, with very little explanation of why x or y isn't done in situations.


r/CharacterRant • • Aug 27 '26

General I don’t care one bit about Matt Reeves’ Batman universe anymore

3 Upvotes

Time travel back to almost 5 years ago. I was watching The Batman in cinemas, going in with almost zero expectations and completely blind to how the film would be… I would say I absolutely loved the film, how dark and gritty it was, the atmosphere, the villain dynamics, the soundtrack, everything. I was completely immersed and drawn in.

That’s how I remember feeling walking out of that experience. It’s been so long that the nitty gritty details have somewhat faded from my mind, but I heavily anticipated the sequel film to it. This gritty and realistic, younger version of Batman had potential

The film was announced like a year later with a 2025 release date… Then that became 2026, then 2027, and now it’s set at fucking 2028. Are you insane? 6 years for a sequel film, when the Dark Knight Trilogy was fully completed after 6 years, as was pretty much every other superhero film trilogy? That’s absolutely unacceptable

I don’t care how good a film is. 6 years for a sequel shows that the team making it have no urgency and are constantly over designing/over iterating on the script or something

Some higher ups really should’ve done something after the second delay. Basically tell Matt Reeves to get his shit together NOW or the film doesn’t come out ever. I simply lost all my hype or interest in this version of Batman. Too little. Too fucking late.

Edit: Today I learned people get really up in arms about this


r/CharacterRant • • Mar 14 '25

Films & TV I can't help but feel frustrated and unsure about YouTube Leftist's reaction to Arcane S2 being that it was "Centrist" or not "radical enough"

9 Upvotes

I see a lot of conflicting political perspectives about Arcane season 2, however the one that I'm most frustrated with, and the most confused/unsure about, is this sudden idea that Arcane Season 2 was "Centrist" or "liberal," or not "radical enough." That Season 2 was upholding ideas of Capitalist propaganda, or copaganda, or what have you.

Like for instance, people are bashing Arcane Season 2 (well this always was the case), for being Centrist and their justification for believing this is because Jinx is a victim of oppression but she is portrayed as a villain. Except for the fact that out of all the characters Jinx is the most favorited, sympathized with and prioritized, by both the fans and the show itself. Even while she's shooting a big giant bazooka and about to kill a bunch of people, the show goes out of it's way to show her grief, and despite all that she's done and gotten away with, still posits that she's redeemable. These criticisms come from the negative sentiment against radical positions or people in shows and media always villainized, and called the bad guys. Or, how other people have said, that the oppressors are framed as hero's while the oppressors are made out to be villains. Of course, the underlying assumption when people make these arguments is that Jinx has done nothing wrong in the first place.

I see people argue about how Sevika deserved better as a Zaunite advocate, and that in the end she merely became a token of representation when she was sat on the council. At the same time I've seen people criticize Arcane for being "centrist" or "liberal" for putting Sevika, a henchmen of a drugkingpin that oppressed the Zaunites for years on the council.

I've seen people complain for Vi, about the heavy victimization she's been subjected to by the system, while simultaneously bashing her and calling her a traitor for becoming an enforcer (Is she not allowed to have autonomy and decide for herself, as a victim of the system?).

And then there's all the claims about how Arcane pushes capitalist/centrist propaganda. Hell I've even seen people, very popularly, make claims of racism, because of some lines Caitlyn made, even though that's not what it is at all. Or say that the dynamic between both the cities is colonialist. Some have even gone so far as to compare it to Israel.

And then there's also all of the claims about copaganda, even though 99% of the scenes and the depiction of authority and enforcers/soldiers in Arcane is intentionally brutal and horrific, and they're always abusing their power in some way. Is the fact that they give some humanization to some of the enforcer characters make it copaganda? Or do they not lay into the brutality enough?

It seems like this is a general method of critique online when it comes to shows that have some political elements to it. People evaluate the show based on whether it's portrayed their desired perception of a given political whatever. For Arcane specifically, I feel like it's just been hamfisted into a box, I don't even know, I'm just putting my thoughts on paper.

And then the big one which a lot of people say is that Arcane sidestepped it's class conflict, which is technically true but people are saying they instead went with the Victor Revolution Arcane arc instead because they wanted to cop-out. And that the writers just made everything resolved, all the class conflict suddenly goes away because now they have a Zaunite on the council. But I don't think that they even present this narratively, the class conflict is not resolved, and the show makes this clear. It can also be said that this is a realistic portrayal of political events. Which connects to the next claim that Arcane is centrist propaganda because the Zaunites are never granted independence and there's no revolution, which is what should've happened instead. Which I feel is more of a desired headcannon than a genuine critique. I feel like everything that happened had sufficient logical progression, they just went with a direction most people didn't think they'd go with. Some people are even saying that the show, at it's center, was never really about the class conflict, that it was about the characters actually, or the cycle of violence or whatever.

What does it even mean to be centrist? Why is something bad if it's centrist? Could it simply be that Arcane is nuanced?

Does Arcane unfairly portray radicalism?

Does Arcane push capitalist/centrist (perhaps even colonialist) propaganda?

Does Arcane unfairly and biasedly portray oppressed people as villains?

Did Jinx do nothing wrong and were her actions simply a victim fighting against the oppressors?

Did the writers just make Sevika a token minority? Is that even a fair thing to say?

Is Arcane really Centrist, or just politically nuanced? Or is there even a difference?

My general sentiment here is that, I just feel like people are hamfisting politics, and putting Arcane in a box. This entire post is just a rant, very disorganized and not constructed with really any effort, so take it as you will. I just want to know, am I crazy? Or are my questions/concerns reasonable?


r/CharacterRant • • Jun 11 '26

Films & TV It's very unsurprising that the He-Man film bombed (for the moment).

0 Upvotes

Like, I'm going to be very honest here, who the fuck likes He-Man aside from the underdeveloped weirdos and the old-heads? This is an IP that's longest running legacy is a fucking meme song about how it's funny he's gay-looking.

A lot of people were going on about how sincerity was going to win people over, that Knight had the charm and touch to make it work and like, no? Disregarding that somehow, sincerity is just win-everything card now (for some reason), in what world would this make any money exactly? Like maybe it would've been more modest if TADC, Backrooms and Obsession didn't just manifest to rob the seats, but a 200 million budget? How was that not a death sentence?

If I have to place this into perspective, the only popular cultural export of the IP is, of course, She-Ra and the Princesses Of Power.

As much as the internet wants to twist the show into being abuser apologia, make it sound like Catra's character development was bad, or some other bullshit because non-male led queer content can't just be judged on normal standards.

Until Netflix removed it from the platform but that's more of Netflix and the streaming model being bullshit and basically crypto.

So, what made that show good? Well it just re-did things. What was needed? Barely much, and they just rewrote so much of it and that makes sense when this a toy franchise. The 80s incarnation had about as much depth as a thin piece of paper. Whatever interesting thesis one could impart about those shows were built upon fans across decades basically conjuring up those details to feel more connected.

As stupid and shitty it is to say "it ain't that deep," sometimes it really is just not that deep, because things are weird. It can be that deep, but what I'm talking about is that the lack of anything meaningful narrative past technical details is a boon for SPOP to re-invent and remake as much as it did, disregard as much as it did.

Which brings me back to He-Man. Now I'll be the first to explain this. Almost no one here knows about the Kevin Smith films, in fact I'm willing to wager that many of you never knew this shit existed.

There have been cartoons that barely anyone watched, and then there's comics that no one knows about unless it's the originals (does He-Man even have that?)

So, quite literally, is anyone actually a fan outside of old people who barely have anything creative on their heads, contrarians hating SPOP, and imagined nostalgists like people waxing about the 60s despite being born in 90s?

None. Literally who find the character designs appealing? Legitimately and not ironically? Not that big, from what I can tell.


r/CharacterRant • • Jul 18 '25

Anime & Manga Why Shoujo Struggles with Male Audiences and What It Could Do Differently

60 Upvotes

Shounen anime/manga pulls in massive female audiences alongside its core male demo, while shoujo largely remains a female space. I’m not saying shoujo needs to chase male viewers it exists for women and girls, And men absolutely don’t need to watch it. But if the goal is specifically to broaden that male audience (maybe for bigger budgets, cultural impact, whatever), then just throwing accusations at men in order to make them consume female targeted media won't help. Men have to WANT to watch female targeted media, not because you told them but because they see certain stories they might enjoy. Pointing fingers at "misogyny" as the sole reason men avoid it misses the mark and ignores how media preferences actually work. Based on how men demonstrably engage with media, shoujo would likely need to strategically reframe its storytelling not dilute its core messaging and themes (for the most part), but speak a narrative language more familiar to male-socialized audiences.

First, ditch the whole "Male Gaze" idea as some iron law. It’s mostly just market logic dressed up in academic clothes. Shows like High School of the Dead or Strike Witches aren't the creators views on real women or how they think real women should be treated. They know exaggerated fan service targets an existing male demographic looking for that specific flavor of entertainment. The director of HotD literally asked for ridiculous breast physics because he thought it was fun, not to fulfill some grandiose ideal of how real women should look or act. The result? Shows like that end up with 80% male viewership, not proof of inherent misogyny in men, but proof they got exactly what was advertised to them. Women avoiding it isn't some ideological rejection either; it's usually just disinterest in those tropes, the same way many men instinctively skip shoujo romance. Also, something important to acknolwedge, men absolutely engage with non-sexualized, emotionally rich stories featuring femininity. Men don't need sexualized female characters in order to engage with stories but it's a nice thing to have sometimes. Look at the male audience for Skip and Loafer while yes being a seinen it's generally seen as stereotypically shoujo, or Frieren, while yes being shonen there's this myth amongst shoujo fans that one of the reasons men don't engage with female targeted media is because men don't want to engage or empathize with women/female characters, however the plethora of female characters in male targeted media, and especially the well loved female main characters in male targeted media proves that men are full willing to empathize and watch stories with female characters. Men like Mitsumi's ambition and friendships and Frieren's melancholy because they're femininity isn't erased; it's integrated into a narrative structure that resonates beyond traditional shoujo tropes.

This brings us to the core difference: how emotional intimacy is packaged. It's not that men hate emotion or depth. Vinland Saga's brutal exploration of trauma through Thorfinn and Askeladd, or Naruto's foundational rivalry, proves that. Even tragic romances like Your Lie in April (a shonen!) work for guys because the intimacy is channeled through competition (music) and sacrifice. Men, broadly speaking due to socialization, tend to prefer vulnerability contextualized explored through action, rivalry, mentorship, or external goals. Shoujo, on the other hand, often excels at direct emotional expression: internal monologues, explicit conversations about feelings, romanticized catharsis. This isn't worse, it's just different. Many men find the direct shoujo approach unfamiliar or uncomfortable within their genre expectations, the same way many women might find battle shonen's emotional restraint frustrating. Men avoid shoujo romance not because they disdain emotion, but because the way it's often presented feels alien compared to the externalized metaphors they're used to in shonen/seinen. That brings me to my next point, Why women engage with male targeted media in the first place. Women are able to engage with male targeted media so easily because they don't have to go outside of genre expectations in order to enjoy male targeted media. And yet, hypocritically, shoujo fans demand men go outside of their genre expectations and start engaging with female targeted media more often. Vinland Saga, Berserk, Baki, Naruto, Haikyuu, Jujutsu Kaisen, all 6 of these series are male targeted, 3/6 have a roughly equal male-female ration, while one of them (Haikyuu) actually has a higher female ration than male ratio. One aspect that women use to engage with anime is the romance or potential romantic relationship between characters. The majority of the people who call the relationships between Gojo/Geto, Naruto/Sasuke, and the Haikyuu male characters GAY are women (which is ironic considering one of the main male characters in Baki literally has sex with men and yet it still has low female viewership but that's besides the point) These shows embed emotional depth within frameworks women already enjoy.

Stop treating femininity like kryptonite around men**.** Men demonstrably connect with feminine characters when they're integrated into frameworks they recognize and value. Riza Hawkeye is feminine and hyper-competent within a military system men respect. Makima is feminine as well as powerful. This "power-adjacent" femininity works because it taps into values (duty, competence, ambition, agency) culturally linked to admiration. It doesn't mean ditching "softer" femininity male fans of Fruits Basket exist! – but it means understanding that integrating femininity into these recognizable value systems lowers the barrier to entry. Shoujo protagonists don't need to become stoic warriors, they need their existing strengths (empathy, resilience, social intelligence) to be showcased within narratives where those strengths have clear, active power and consequence beyond the romantic sphere (e.g., navigating complex political intrigue, excelling in a competitive career, leading a community).

 Instead of relying primarily on internal monologues or explicit romantic tension, integrate the emotional core into external vehicles. Use ambition as the catalyst for growth and relationships (like Mitsumi's goals in Skip and Loafer). Frame bonding through shared conflict or rivalry (think Akatsuki no Yona's political journey or the team dynamics in a sports shoujo like Chihayafuru). Embed the emotional arc within a strong genre scaffold – adventure, fantasy (Frieren), mystery, or workplace drama. The feelings are still there, deep and complex, but they're explored through the action, the competition, the strategic challenge, or the pursuit of a non-romantic goal. This mirrors exactly how shonen attracts women by embedding emotional complexity within its action/fantasy frameworks.

Market Strategically (and Drop the Stigma) Stop boxing everything into the "romance" or "for girls" idea. Frame shoujo in a more universal context. Promote series like Akatsuki no Yona as a political action-adventure with a transformative protagonist arc. Emphasize the unique strengths complex character writing, nuanced relationships, emotional authenticity without leaning solely on tropes that signal "this is not for you" to male-socialized audiences. Show men that these stories explore ambition, loss, duty, legacy, and camaraderie in ways they might genuinely connect with, just through a different lens. This isn't to say men don't like romance, I'm sure we're all well aware of the many male targeted romance series. From the well hated harem series to the well loved and heart warming romance series such as Clannad and Horimiya. The problem is male targeted romance is *male* targeted and female targeted romance is *female* targeted. Male targeted romance still allows women to stay within their genre expectations, ESPECIALLY for romance. while the same can't be said for a lot of female targeted romance. You can see this by the fact that Fruit's Basket is a popular series and has well developed male characters that a male audience might like or even resonate with, while series like Honey Lemon Soda have an almost entirely female audience, which makes sense when you consider the main character is a stereotypical shy low confidence girl that gets saved by the rambunctious quirky boy (something often shamed whenever the reverse happens in male targeted media.) As well as series like A Sign of Affection that also have a predominantly female audience.

This isn't about blaming shoujo or crying misogyny. Men avoiding heavily tropey shoujo romance is no more proof of woman-hating than women avoiding ecchi harem shows is proof of man-hating. It's largely genre preference shaped by exposure and socialization. Men not seeking out stories centered on direct emotional interiority or traditional romantic structures isn't a moral failing; it's a reflection of the narrative languages they're most fluent and comfortable in. Shoujo editors targeting that wider audience need to become expert translators taking the core truths, emotional depth, and authentic femininity of shoujo and expressing them through narrative structures, character frameworks, and genre conventions that resonate within male socialized experiences. Skip and Loafer, Frieren, and Akatsuki no Yona show it's possible. It’s not about changing what shoujo is at its core, but about finding new and compelling ways to show that core to an audience that hasn't traditionally been listening.

To wrap this up, there are more than likely other series I could've used than the three repeated here, those three were just the first ones that came to mind. I am well aware Frieren and Skip&Loafer aren't shoujo. Lastly, I genuinely don't think shoujo has to do a single thing that I listed above, I think shoujo should stay as it and continue hardcore catering to a female demogaphic. HOWEVER, I also don't think men **need** to engage with female targeted media. If the only reasoning you can give for men to engage with female targeted media is because "it's different than male targeted media" then you might as well be saying people that like rpg video games should play banana clicker 5000 because it's different than an rpg. It being different isn't a reason to engage with it, there has to be more than that. Arguments such as "to expand and diversify your taste" basically fall into the category of "you should watch this because it's different". Male targeted media does an excellent job courting a female fanbase, men not engaging with female targeted media isn't because they're sexist and can't empathize with women or whatever. The genre expectations of shoujo simply fall outside of what men like, while the opposite mostly isn't true for women. Obviously there are some series that are male targeted that women don't like though. Men not watching female targeted media has nothing to do with the gender of the author (see Dungeon Meshi Dorohedoro FMA Frieren Gachiekuta and many more). Or because of the gender of the cast. And no I don't even think the series being explicitly stated to be female targeted makes men not want to engage with female targeted media either, if that were true then removing demographic labels all together would therefore make more men engage with female targeted media (which I'm almost certain isn't true.) it’s about narrative language compatibility. Recognizing this moves us beyond reductive accusations and towards meaningful solutions should the goal be increasing shoujo popularity.


r/CharacterRant • • Jun 15 '25

Films & TV [LES] Gravity Falls put women on a pedestal too much.

33 Upvotes

This post was inspired by this video essay, which points out that Wendy was basically never allowed to have any dimensions beyond an abstraction of coolness.

I wanted to just point out that this relates to another bit of Fandom apocrypha; it's known that Alex Hirsch based Mabel off his sister, Ariel, and many have suspected that Mabel is let off relatively light in the series in terms of consequences (see; her potentially being at fault for the events of the finale never being discussed within the show, Dipper and her never actually having a discussion about Ford's offer and the pros and cons (just an argument and then a 180 from Dipper after he realizes his side of the fault), etc).

This kind of shows a pattern; as the video points out, the writers were almost entirely male in the series, and I think this resulted in the two major female characters collectively being less realistically developed than the male ones.

(And before anyone calls me out for "just hating a 12 year old", I'd like to link to the best post in the history of this sub.)

Also there was a very simple solution for all of this.


r/CharacterRant • • Sep 09 '26

Comics & Literature YouTuber Austin McConnell spent 4 years animating his own public domain superhero CGI movie. Sadly, I think he wasted those 4 years.

85 Upvotes

Context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_aEuw2a--Uw

Austin was tired of other cinematic universes. Decided to make his own using a public domain superhero, Atlas. Now what specifically made me interested was that Austin did a re-write of the Cursed Child and it was actually adapted into a real stage play.

The Cursed Child re-write: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SxsH8zEhEkk

So, it gave me hope that Austin would write something interesting with his personal superhero cinematic universe.

The superhero movie he created after 4 years: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjNh74D0YCI

So I’m excited to watch it and… it’s not good. Without the greater context of the movie, it wouldn’t be funny. It would literally be a bargain bin dollar store movie if it didn't have the Austin McConnell production story attached to it.

Good things. The voice acting is really good. The main girl is voiced by a professional. Atlas, the main guy, has this as his only credit and he does a great job. No complaints about any of the VA work.

But where it falls apart is the story. It’s just not good. There’s nothing new or original here. Was this because Austin was using a public domain character so he had to follow the original beats? If so, Austin should’ve been using the 4 years he learned animating with an original Austin-owned superhero. This would’ve allowed his writing to be more original. I was expecting literally anything interesting or subversive or edgy from Atlas. Nothing. There's not even comedic violence. The story was very, very by-the-book. I 100% understand part of the movie’s meta joke is that “ha ha, look at how schlocky it is” but the novelty wears off immediately and you want something real.

So, it really pains me to say this… but I think Austin wasted 4 years of his life. I’m still looking forward to his upcoming superhero work, Catman. But after Atlas, I’m not expecting much.

EDIT

Seems to be some contention about the thread title. Some of you are having a seizure about it. Here's a better title:

"YouTuber Austin McConnell spent 4 years animating his own public domain superhero CGI movie. Dumb motherfucker pissed 4 years of his life on this dog shit, LMAO"

Better? Once again, Redditors stunlocked when your language isn't perfect with 1,000,000 caveats and qualifiers.


r/CharacterRant • • Sep 20 '25

Anime & Manga [Naruto] People say if you made Sasuke a girl you'd get the best love story ever, but I think you actually get one of the biggest tragedy's ever

0 Upvotes

the story just becomes about a woman whos entire clan got genocided, she was abused by her brother mentally and physically, a bunch of men like danzo and orochimaru attempt to use her and shes got some blonde asshole shit talking her and getting in her face all day.

she is also is in a village that doesnt give a fuck about her mental issues, a team that probably still treats her like shit. naruto now looks way worse, imagine him bullying her the way he did male sasuke. idk what happens with sakura if sasukes a girl tbf. she also finds out that her brother sacrificed everything to give her a chance at life and that the village she lives in is the reason for said genocide.

fast forward to the end and she basically doesnt get revenge, her whole life is a lie, she has to just live with the fact that her people got genocided. And now her childhood "rival" runs the village and calls the guy who orchestrated the worst night of her life the coolest guy ever.

she then gets to live out her adult years wandering around as a loner commiserating in her own grief and despair, except in this world unless she marries naruto she doesnt even have the small consolation of a daughter so i guess she just dies alone.

unironically i think a lot of people would be much more sympathetic to sasuke if hed been a girl. like imagine sasuke fighting orochimaru in the forest of death as a girl and sakura pulls up and calls her a pussy for trying to negotiate her way out of the fight. and then naruto shows up, calls her stupid, gets one tapped and now girl sasuke has to fight orochimaru while keeping her useless team alive. or the entire thing with orochimaru wanting her body. or how everyone just doesnt seem to stop and go "you know, i kinda get why youre angry, that genocide thing kinda did suck huh sasuke?". the optics for a girl sasukes life are insanely depressing and grim.

but as guy sasuke it just comes out to "cool brooding silent guy". very dark.