r/CharacterActionGames • • Oct 04 '25 Bravo

Discussion Everything is just so sauceless.

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This Post is overplayed. If you enjoy the games I do not like thats great. I am always for more enjoyment in the world. I am specifically just talking about the games I see highlighted in this sub. I think Indie Games are the future of this genre.

Not to be doomposting but alot of the Games that I see highlighted in this sub are just so unimaginably sauceless.

It is either guy with sword and 0 charisma or naked girl made to be just looked at.

There seems to be some promising indie stuf(morbid metal, that one gravity rush like that gives me motion sickness, genokids) but alot of what I see here is so often missing the point of what makes the CAG I like great.

I think Stellar Blade, Bayonetta 3 and all these pointless remakes really drive that point home. Either botching the gameplay, misunderstanding a big influence, being just the same again or having no charisma at all. With nothing to say and nothing to give they just all mush together to be a mindless "I mean its fine" experience.

I think it is very telling that many many people come from dmc and bayonetta, games that so are so unapollogetically themself, but todays landscape cant stop itself from crushing creatives in endless bearucratic shareholder pleasing. Just look at what happened to Platinum Games.

I'm looking forward to the new ninja gaiden, but from what I could tell it also looked very similar to the older titles again and especially with Platinum attached I do worry that this will be a midoff again.

What do you think?

Edit: Hit most controversial šŸŽ‰šŸŽ‰ Remember! Be kind, every opinion is also a Person.

Edit: Muted this btw!


r/CharacterActionGames • • Nov 05 '25

Discussion Mark(Electric Underground) is right sometimes,but when he’s wrong,he’s very wrong! In this review he’s wrong as NG4 is a great game and an overall improvement over the others!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/CharacterActionGames • • Aug 26 '24

Game Review 50% done with this game and I kind of hate it. *this ended up turning into a rant hahaha*

Post image
0 Upvotes

If you look at the reviews and steam reviews you’ll see everyone raving about this game. Mostly for the presentation and its ability to shock and awe with its spectacle. I will say presentation wise this game is amazing but gameplay wise the game is so fucking mediocre.

The combat just feels tired and sluggish when it didn’t have to be it almost feels satisfying to play but there’s a lot missing.

  1. Enemies have animations on their attacks that don’t visually convey the hitbox properly. In this game, you can jump and perform your pole stance (it literally states in the description of the stance that it should allow you to dodge over grounded attacks). Being the gamer that I am, I thought, ā€œOkay, cool! Let me see if I can use these techniques in a stylish way to dodge certain attacks.ā€ I’m jumping all over the place, thinking I’m using pro gamer strategies. While I successfully dodge some attacks, there are others that I cannot avoid despite the game visually indicating that a specific move should be jumpable or pole-vaultable. However, the actual hitbox of the move is way larger than what is being conveyed. This frustrates me to no end. There are times when you jump over a certain move and the character is visibly above the enemy, yet you still get hit. It results in this awkward jank animation where you take damage in midair and fall down clumsily. I would be okay with jumping and pole vaulting not being reliable if the visuals were consistent with what you can and cannot dodge.

  2. Enemies have disgustingly delayed timings on their attacks. SMFH, Souls-like games have caused irreversible damage to the action game genre. Why do developers think this is good game design? It’s not fun; it’s just annoying when done as poorly as it is in this game. It’s almost to the point of parody. This is one of the worst ways to introduce difficulty in a game; it feels cheap, and in this case, it’s become downright annoying. This is especially true when dodging is your only reliable defensive mechanic. This leads into my next point.

  3. The dodge is your only reliable defensive mechanic—THE DODGE FEELS SO BAD IN THIS GAME. This is mostly due to what was stated earlier, but for me, another huge reason I dislike the dodge in this game is because of Bayonetta. The whole point of the dodge mechanic in this game is to achieve a perfect dodge, and when you do, this really cool sound occurs, leaving an afterimage of the character while building your meter for a charged heavy attack. I literally can’t explain in words how frustrating it is that this doesn’t slow down or freeze the enemy. (I know this point is a little nitpicky, but it’s just my opinion.) I don’t know, it just feels like such a huge missed opportunity, especially considering there’s already a mechanic that allows you to pause the enemy. I’ve died so many times because I thought the enemy was in suspended animation when they weren’t. I wouldn’t be surprised if this was an unlock later in the game, though. I don’t know; I’m probably just coping.

  4. Stamina Bar??? Why does this game have a stamina bar? It makes the gameplay feel cluttered because of the number of meters in the game. There’s a meter for your charged attack, a meter for your mana, and a meter for each of your transformations. I also feel as if they only included it because it’s a trendy game design option right now. It shouldn’t be there, and I feel like the game knows it based on how awkward it is when you run out of stamina and try to perform options. Nothing actually happens; there’s no animation indicating that your character is out of stamina. When you try to roll, you don’t attempt to execute a pathetic roll or a fat roll—literally nothing happens. It’s interesting because when you're mid-air and execute a dive kick, you can follow it up with a strong attack. However, when you’re out of stamina and already in the air, sometimes you can still perform those attacks, but other times you can’t. My point is that I feel the stamina bar was just shoehorned in, and there wasn’t much thought put into its implementation...

  5. Lastly, primarily, this game has a mechanical identity problem. It wants to be a Souls-like without fully committing to that genre. I wish action game developers would be bolder and realize that their games don’t have to have Souls-like tendencies to succeed. There are hints of combat mechanical depth in this game that are almost interesting. For example, at the end of the light attack string, just before the big "unga bunga" move, you can cancel out of the attack with a dodge. I was experimenting and found that you can also cancel out of it with a jump. If you can jump, you can dive kick, so this little combo builds significantly more meter than simply performing the regular light attack string. When I first executed this, I thought to myself, ā€œDamn, maybe you can cancel out of other moves with the jump, too.ā€ But no, you can’t. It would be so badass if you could cancel out of the pole vault move with a jump, allowing for a sequence like pole vault, dodge over a move, dive kick, strong attack, freeze, and pummel. But alas, no.

In closing, paragraph 5 illustrates my biggest problem with the game: it almost allows you to perform cool maneuvers beyond the initial spectacle of the abilities. Don’t get me wrong; this game is cool, and the abilities look interesting, but once you play it for a while, the combat loses its luster when you realize it’s all surface-level. This game is just mediocre to me because it tries to be a Souls-like when it doesn’t have to be. Why couldn’t it just be its own thing? Also, why the hell can’t you dodge cancel out of your heal???

I don’t have the motivation to finish the rest so if this game somehow magically gets better I’m sorry lmaooo


r/CharacterActionGames • • Jun 09 '26

Discussion I played Stellar Blade. It's not a pure CAG. It's rather a CAG/Souls-like hybrid imo. But do you think there's a chance that Stellar Blade: BLOOD RAIN would be more of a CAG than it's predecessor?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Here's a link to the new trailer of Stellar Blade: BLOOD RAIN just in case:

https://youtu.be/zhdh_LspRHk?si=5frvnielZayBJFkO


r/CharacterActionGames • • Feb 18 '26

Discussion Control Resonant has the single most sauceless protagonist in any CAG ever

Post image
5 Upvotes

is anyone excited to play as john resonant? he looks like every generic sadmandeadwife guy. what's the point of a character action game that puts zero effort into the character??

EDIT: okay so some of y'all think this is about gameplay, but this is exclusively about dylan's appearance. the gameplay actually looks sick, which just makes me more disappointed by the main character's design.


r/CharacterActionGames • • Oct 23 '25

Memes This simple trick will enhance your Ninja Gaiden 4 experience and make Yakumo a more tolerable! (Hell, it even makes him actually cool!)

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/CharacterActionGames • • Sep 15 '25

Discussion Gaming Going Mainstream Was the Worst Thing to Happen to Character Action Games

1 Upvotes

When gaming went mainstream, publishers found a bigger, easier-to-please audience: people drawn to cinematic graphics and prestige storytelling more than actual play.

That crowd loves RDR2, Uncharted 4, Tlou and they’re great experiences but let’s be real: they’re basically interactive movies. Handholding, yellow-paint paths, minimal challenge. Once the story’s done, you’ve seen it all.

Developers followed the money. High skill, over the top character action games dmc, bayonetta, NG started looking ā€œsillyā€ or ā€œdatedā€ to this new audience. They weren’t grounded, didn’t have Hollywood grade narratives, and so they got written off as ā€œnot serious" or "braindead".

Even when a CAG breaks through like a Nier Automata or the GOW, it’s the cutscenes spectacle or the dramatic narrative people celebrate, not the combat depth.

We like to blame Soulslikes for the genre’s decline, but that’s backwards. Souls games arguably saved gaming and showed that games can still be games, I would rather have a thousand of soulslikes laying around than cinematic walking sims.


r/CharacterActionGames • • Feb 23 '25

Tier Lists My own personal biased

Post image
0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: ā—I really liked bayonetta 3 until I finished the game and despised most of the game afterwards ā—Nier Automata kinda disappointed me personally but only solely speaking on the combat ā—gow3 didn't need a sequel and much less a downgraded combat ā—if THE BOUNCER was based on how funny this game is in multiplayer this game is peak lmao


r/CharacterActionGames • • Mar 16 '25

Question So I would consider Zenless Zone Zero a CAG since you know there's a lot of characters and action in this game hehehe but for real why do I see that it's not? I think it's because people can't get past the beginning it's slow admittingly. This is me 350 hours in

8 Upvotes

r/CharacterActionGames • • 8d ago

CAG Adjacent Between CONTROL Resonant and Phantom Blade Zero, which CAG-adjacent do you think has better combat gameplay and level design?

Post image
0 Upvotes

About CONTROL Resonant:

It's an ARPG which is like a superhero action adventure like Prototype or Infamous.

About Phantom Blade Zero:

It's a Wuxia action game that is a hybrid of fast-paced Hack 'n Slash and Souls-lite.


r/CharacterActionGames • • Dec 12 '25

Discussion Phantom Blade Zero Combat VS True Soulslike Combat

0 Upvotes

If someone still thinks that Phantom Blade Zero is a soulslike, I don’t know what to say. Phantom Blade Zero is a mix of Ninja Gaiden and Sekiro. That’s it.


r/CharacterActionGames • • Apr 30 '26

Discussion Is Wuthering Waves a CAG too?

13 Upvotes

The gameplay is there.


r/CharacterActionGames • • Aug 03 '26

Discussion They could've made the 1st Stellar Blade game a Hack & Slash CAG instead of Sekiro-like hybrid. But sadly, this is actually a mod.

0 Upvotes

r/CharacterActionGames • • Mar 06 '26

Discussion Is this more CAG/Hack & Slash to you guys or ā€œsoulslikeā€(new Onimusha)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/CharacterActionGames • • Jun 06 '26

Close enough, Welcome Back... God Hand!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
32 Upvotes

r/CharacterActionGames • • May 08 '25

Discussion Wanted: Dead is janky AF.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

I recently played this out of curiosity as I wanted a palette cleanser after Veilguard and man is this game janky. There are good ideas in there in spite of the generic story and characters but so much of it lets it down. The voice acting is abysmal. It feels like a ps2 era game with higher resolution and framerate. I knew going in the reviews weren't great but I didnt expect it to be this repetitive. The mix of gunplay and melee was cool at first but even after unlocking a bunch of moves, I just felt frustrated constantly. It also has little to no fan service, which is normally a staple of this genre. I made an admittedly sarcastic video with my thoughts on the game. Have any of you played it to completion? Does it get better? Or did you get as frustrated as I did?

p.s the one saving grace was the karaoke mini game!


r/CharacterActionGames • • Jan 08 '26

Discussion Imo CAGs need to go for interconnected level design to appeal to casuals

3 Upvotes

Something like ninja gaiden 1. In most CAGs you just fight enemies in a boxed arena and move on to next arena which is a very dull level design with a very linear hallwayish designs. Especially ninja gaiden 4. and yeah there is exploration but it only mostly rewards with chest or some hidden combat encounter. There should be a incentive to revisit previous areas with freedom to explore. which souls game do very well they don't feel restricted that much. Also they need to work on stories as well whether its good writing or souls like style they need to step up the game. I dont feel like platinum can do both maybe if kamiya was still there since he worked on resident evil 2 but they also failed to do so with scalebound A resident evil/ninjagaiden 1 style interconnected level design. Its just not button mashing that keeps casuals away its lack of interesting environment and level design as well. i mean like they can play last of us and call it a masterpiece with simple mediocre gameplay so they can do that for CAGs as well if done right.

Only AAA devs that can do that are capcom i hope they remake dmc1 with same level design and explore the genre more. it needs some type of evolution not in combat but level design and story telling or team ninja does the environment level design for ninja gaiden 5 with their learnings from nioh 3


r/CharacterActionGames • • 12d ago

Discussion A Big Reason Why NGB Destroys Every New Game For Me

0 Upvotes

Ninja Gaiden Black (as an example, many older games fit the criteria I am going to talk about) still reigns supreme for me even 20 years later and its because all these new games are the same to me. It's color coded simon says. Light attacks barely matter, there's hardly any stagger or feedback until the right color flashes or you activate a meter based ability or something specific. Games over the last 15 years or so have been doing this with newer ones adding suck to target and hyperarmor further reducing everything into a rhythm game, player expression be damned. You don't win until you do the "thing" and every game reduces to "not much matters till you do the "thing" then it matters all of a sudden until it doesn't again." It's all surface level.

Perfect example of what I am talking about: Just last night in the airship level of NGB I hit a light attack and then a hold heavy on a dude with a shield, the light attack bounced off but the hold heavy knocked his shield back just a tad and I used that opening to hit a second light attack into a combo. Not because he flashed the right color or I burned one of my meters. I just saw the shield move and capitalized. And that's why I am playing it 20 years later and barely any new ones. It was a physics based reaction not the game going "okay now now now!"

EDIT: It's being shown to me in the comments that I might have fucked up a bit here. This is not supposed to be a Ninja Gaiden Black>>>>>everything else have a nice day post. I worded it that way and used it as my example because it's my personal measuring stick but really what this should be called is more like "AS AN EXAMPLE NGB is this, I find newer games tend to do THIS and I believe melee action games have declined as a result, here's an example using NGB"

NO I DONT WANT A WAR BETWEEN FANS. I honestly want a discussion of mechanics and design philosophies and maybe some other old folks who remember the old days to chime in and see if they see things differently.

And if it matters I have thoroughly enjoyed many new games. Sifu was a standout to me. And of the classics I sure as hell enjoyed DMC 1 (love that game) 3 4 5 (somewhat less) Bayonetta 1 (was OBSESSED with that game for a while) and is this a cag or a beat em up? GOD HAND.

Last edit: If I could change my title I would have said "I believe the design philosophy of melee games has changed for the worse" and then went on to use NGB as my example. My original title carried over from me posting in the NG subreddit where this would not have happened.

I'm serious, I'm not trolling or a pr bot for that youtuber I am accused of parroting or w/e. I'm an old man I don't even go on YT much at all


r/CharacterActionGames • • Sep 17 '24

Discussion Can an action game without Devil May Cry's complexity be just as good as Devil May Cry?

2 Upvotes

Devil May Cry is the gold standard for action game combat to pretty much anyone experienced in the genre. The biggest reason for that? In terms of sheer player freedom and choice, no other game touches it. There's such a deep pool of actions you can use that you can also perform at pretty much any time you want. So when something like, say, the Batman Arkham games or Spider-Man is brought into play, they come across as Devil May Cry combat, but with less complexity and more restrictions. Basically, an objectively worse action game. You also have what happened with the God of War reboot, where it removed many of the DMC-like elements from the old trilogy in favor of a more simplistic and restricted combat experience. Naturally, many people were upset at this even if the game went on to garner critical praise.

At the end of the day though, games with drastically more simple and restricted combat still have plenty of fans. Even DMC fans will play them. So my question is, can it be possible for an action game to reach the heights of Devil May Cry even if they lack the complexity and freedom it offers? Or are they doomed to just be inferior action games unless they step up and attempt what DMC offers?


r/CharacterActionGames • • Dec 25 '25

Question Anyone else feels like Ninja Gaiden is probably one of the worst of this genre? The difficulty seems to be based around all the wrong thigns

2 Upvotes

I just played Ninja Gaiden Sigma and I have beaten it before. And I just don't understand how this is good.

It is a lot of enemies that non stop attack in groups and if you block too much or appearently block at all with little warning, they do a 0 frame start up grab.

If you try to dodge enemies you are bound to take some damage as they are completly relentless.

I am watching videos on youtube and some of them are literally about running away from enemies or exploiting the games engine.

I just don't understand. Is this game only praised for its difficulty? Is that enough to make it good?

I have beaten this twice before,but with Ninja Gaiden 4 coming out, I went back and I just go. What is this?


r/CharacterActionGames • • Aug 13 '26

Wolverine game should have been more character action like

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

made this post in the video games sub wanted to see opinions here too. I think a great opportunity was lost on the upcoming wolverine game


r/CharacterActionGames • • 13d ago

Gameplay SSShowcase Best Mid-Game Weapons, PB0

4 Upvotes

Absolutely brutal weapons with amazing combos and flow. Fiend Saw is missable, so if you want it, make sure to complete certain side quests!


r/CharacterActionGames • • Jan 24 '25

Discussion Hey as CAGs just had an awesome day today. I just want to share some sub we made to discuss DMC and similar games with a bit more edge. Please join if you are interested at r/DevilsNeverCry_. Link in comments.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/CharacterActionGames • • Nov 28 '25

Discussion There are some points with the target system,Mark (TEU)is right on here,but praising NG2OG again and speaking badly about DMC5,a game he hasn’t even reviewed yet,is just messy!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Suck to target and less weapons are indeed problems that need to fixed,but the game is still great despite these issues.However I think the main issue when reviewing NG and DMC,is people comparing them to older titles like NG2OG or DMC3.

After playing and replaying enough hours of NG4,I can agree that suck to target and lack of weapons are issues,but the game plays great enough that I wouldn’t be surprised if newbies and veterans alike overlooked such issues.

Overall despite the flaws it’s still a great game that is Ninja Gaiden. It’s weird to me in Mark’s review he talks badly about DMC5 a game he hasn’t even scratched the surface of or reviewed yet.