r/Catholicism • • Dec 16 '24 Heart of Silver

Brigaded DON'T Play indiana jones and the great circle

0 Upvotes

Do NOT support Indiana Jones and the Great Circle. Its just another piece of trash media that makes fun of all things Catholic. To cut to the chase there is a large part of the game dedicated to the Vatican where Indy dresses up as a priest in disguise. Now that is not what I find offensive, as I can understand this aspect of the plot (similar to Mission Impossible 3), but the part that i DO find offensive is when they take a consecrated bottle of Our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ's blood (given to Indy BY A PRIEST) and use it in part of a stupid level puzzle. You have to pour it down several drains and manipulate it to write on surfaces, I won't get into it because it's so vile.

There are various other things in the game that just show a complete lack of respect and laziness for the catholic faith, like for example a scene where Indy pretends to give a confession and when he hears the sin, he takes the Lord's name in vain pretty badly and then just punches the guy IN THE CONFESSIONAL. Don't believe me?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CEU59QcLM4A

There is also a love interest who is a nun in the game also, to top it all off. WHILE Indy is dressed as a priest. They know EXACTLY what they are doing.

I am just so sick and tired of media profaning our faith and treating it as the last acceptable bigotry. I am so angry that I played through half of this game just for me to have to discard it because the developers are so bigoted.

Please do not play this game, please do not support this game, and please share this with any catholic who is even thinking about buying this for Christmas. Do. Not. Bother.

Edit: I am a huge indiana jones fan, I am so disapointed they went this direction and turned a beloved character who actually respected the faith in the movies into this slop.

Edit: amazing the hate I’ve gotten for this lol, if you want to play it then fine, play it! No one’s stopping you. Looks like I struck a nerve here. I have played through most of the game, so I know exactly what it contains. Of course they didn’t get the consecration right but they still called the blood of Christ. And even if it wasn’t that, and it was just blessed water, I still wouldn’t play it because that is profane to use a sacred object in that manner. God bless 🙏


r/Catholicism • • May 19 '22

Be a man and dress up for Mass

15 Upvotes

Let me start off by saying no, clothes don't make the man, what's inside counts most.

Clothing is an exterior superficial aesthetic that doesn't necessarily reflect what a man's interior life is like. Dressing well however, doesn't make a person vain any more than dressing fashionably does, nor incessantly dressing casually does. Vanity is a separate issue from dressing well and I'm not sure why so many people conflate the two things together.

Looking back at previous generations, dressing well was a standard for pretty much everyone, even bums wore tattered suits.

Wearing a suit to Mass ought to simply be a cultural standard. Jesus Christ is the most significant person you will ever encounter and frankly if you have the means, wearing a sweatshirt and jeans, or t-shirt and shorts to Mass is just not good enough. Mass is heaven on earth, why wouldn't you dress up for it?

Many people nowadays says that how you dress doesn't matter, ironically though, making such a claim just proves the point further that having a preference for clothes really is important. If it truly didn't matter, why prefer a t-shirt over a button-down shirt?

So why dress up you ask?

Simply put, respect.

Modern fashion is extremely vulgar and decadent. It's all about showing off and peacocking, flashing your brand names, expressing yourself with words, pictures, and symbols that don't actually mean anything.

It is much better to express yourself with patterns, colors, fabrics, and proper fit; using nuances and refinement rather than vulgar logos, brand names, and flashy lettering. Today's fashion is about showing off, classic style is exactly the opposite, it's about respect and refinement.

If truth, goodness, and beauty matter, then aesthetics matter.

There's much more I'd like to say but I'm at work and don't have time for all of it.


r/Catholicism • • May 16 '22

Unpopular opinion: Kids should behave in Mass

0 Upvotes

Hear me out for 5 minutes here. Yes, "a no crying church is a dying one." I've heard it a million times and yes kids are a blessing. I've been in church since I was 6 weeks old. There needs to be a line drawn. For those that has busy lives, Mass at 11:30 on Sunday, 4PM on Saturday, etc is the only hour in the week or month they have away from the world. Having a toddler play with the kneelers, play with books, bang on the pews several times and what not is extremely distracting. It's one thing if a baby is cooing, but a toddler should be slightly better.

Growing up kids were not loud at the church I went to. Even when I was a teen I don't remember toddlers acting out in church every week. There's a family that loves to sit behind me and kids are ridiculously loud. The parents does zero and says nothing. IDK if it's home raising, but it's bad. Single people without kids has right to be in church as well as families. Parents, I know it's hard raising kids these days. Please don't let your 3 year old kick the person front of them 8+ times or crawl all over the place. It's not cute at all.


r/Catholicism • • Jun 24 '22

Megathread Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey are overruled

Thumbnail supremecourt.gov
1.1k Upvotes

r/Catholicism • • Sep 09 '26

Thinking of leaving the church

6 Upvotes

I (30M) am a recent convert. I’m starting to regret making that decision. I joined because I, as a gay man, initially appreciated the church’s dedication to tradition and honest interpretation of scripture (meaning they don’t lie about sodomy being okay).

I honestly expected the church to be sincere when it said that gay people are to be treated with love and respect despite our tendency towards a certain sin. Now I’m starting to think those were just empty words. The ban on gay clergy offends me so deeply. The abuse crisis wasn’t our fault. Stop blaming us.

Does the church even think there are any forms of discrimination against us that are “unjust”? The way people have talked on this Reddit about gay people has deeply discouraged me. I question if I should bother staying seeing as I’ll just be further harassed for being effeminate despite my celibacy. I have zero faith in this new generation of traditionalist priests’ ability or frankly even desire to protect us. I don’t have the energy to constantly correct people’s wrong opinions about effeminacy and virtue. I feel like I could spend my whole life fighting just for people like me to be treated with respect and it wouldn’t even bring a bit of change.

Why should I stay?


r/Catholicism • • Jun 29 '26

Politics Monday The climate catastrophe should be on top of our priority list

6 Upvotes

As christians, as children of God we are called to take care of our world, even for the short time we spend on it. I trust God and know ultimately the main goal is to be in heaven with him, but I feel horrified by what's happening on earth. I wish every person would realise the severity of what's happening and would take great measures to do something against it. Right now Europe is the hottest continent on earth, not Africa... Europe! Thousands are dying because of the heat and nothing is happening. I think it's time the Pope and Church started to really take a stance and tell people that things cannot keep going the way they are now. We're constantly consuming, feeding the rich, while the poor die and rationalize it with ,,We're in the hands of God". It is true, but what else is true? That we were given free will and an earth to populate and rule. So far, we are destroying it. I ask everybody who's reading this to pray for everyone on earth, pray for the animals and nature, but also start to change your ways of living. Stop consuming what you don't need, stop making megacompanies grow, stop filling up landfills. Do whatever you can! And even if that's just a little... that can go a long way!


r/Catholicism • • May 08 '24

Told friend I can’t come to her invalid wedding

3 Upvotes

I had to tell my friend of 12 years that I couldn’t be at her wedding because she is marrying outside of the Church and it will be invalid. I didn’t get to expand on the invalidity part or even say the word “invalid” but long story short, I’m sure I just lost a friend over this and I am grieving. Prayers are appreciated, for her and for myself.

If you’ve had an experience like this, I would love to know if they were understanding and if you were able to remain friends.

[Catholic marrying non-Catholic outside of the Church with no special dispensation]


r/Catholicism • • Mar 10 '25

A Muslim's Reflection on Islamophobia, Lent, and Cardinal Dolan’s Words

3 Upvotes

Hello brothers and sisters,

I know this is a sacred time for you as you observe Lent, and I apologize if this post feels like an interruption. I am reaching out as a Muslim who values faith and respects Christianity, hoping to share some thoughts on rising Islamophobia and certain misconceptions about Islam.

Recently, I have seen some commentators, who I believe are Catholic or Christian (though I’m not sure if they are Protestant), criticizing Cardinal Dolan for acknowledging similarities between Muslim fasting in Ramadan and Christian fasting during Lent. Some have argued that taking inspiration from Muslims is wrong, as if Islam has nothing good to offer. This attitude is concerning because it dismisses the fact that people of faith can learn from one another, even while holding different beliefs.

I also want to address a tragic event that has been brought up—the recent killing of Nigerian Christians by radical extremists who claim to be Muslim. As a conservative Muslim, I want to make it absolutely clear: these groups do not represent Islam, and their actions are completely against its teachings. In reality, these extremists have killed far more Muslims than anyone else.

These terrorists are not Muslim and will never be Muslim. They have murdered my own cousins back home, kidnapped others, and even poisoned innocent people. How could I ever respect them? The overwhelming majority of Muslims, including those who are conservative in their beliefs, completely reject and despise these groups. We do not support them in any way.

I have never harmed a Christian, nor would I ever. So it saddens me to see some commentators using these tragedies to stir up hatred against all Muslims. Islamophobia is on the rise in America, and I worry that narratives like these only make it worse. I am not asking anyone to compromise their faith, but rather to recognize that hatred and division only serve those who wish to see us fight rather than understand each other.

Cardinal Dolan’s acknowledgment of fasting in Islam was not an endorsement of all Islamic beliefs—he was simply recognizing a shared value that exists between our traditions. If we truly seek truth, we should not fear recognizing good wherever it exists.

Thank you for taking the time to read this. I hope and pray for peace, understanding, and respect between our communities. Wishing you all a meaningful and blessed Lent.

With respect

Your Brother Mohamed

*Edit: More Thoughts*

I also want to highlight the long history of intellectual and respectful interactions between Muslims and Christians. Thinkers like Al-Ghazali and Thomas Aquinas engaged with each other's works, learning and debating with deep respect. These exchanges show that our traditions, while different, have enriched each other over time.

Personally, I admire friars and seminarians for their dedication to their faith and their discipline in religious study. I would love to befriend people like them because I see them as fellow seekers of truth. I believe that meaningful friendships between devout Muslims and devout Christians can foster more understanding, rather than division.

Once again, thank you for reading. May God bless you all.

edit:I want to begin by saying that I deeply regret if my words caused any hurt—that was never my intention. My aim was always to have a peaceful and respectful discussion. I would never speak of Jesus Christ in a disrespectful manner, just as I would never insult any other figure in faith. It deeply saddens me to see such hatred and division, especially when it comes to the way my Prophet is insulted. If anyone took anything from my words, let it be this: I speak with respect, not without knowledge. I don’t claim to know enough about Paul to make any judgments about him, and I certainly wouldn’t speak on matters I don’t fully understand. My goal has always been to engage in a meaningful conversation based on respect and understanding. I pray for peace and for a world where we can all talk about our differences without hatred. May you all be blessed with peace and love.


r/Catholicism • • Jun 10 '24

It is impossible to be a liberal and a Catholic.

60 Upvotes

By liberal I mean classical liberalism, not political liberalism.

The enlightenment is a disaster in general, it was what "killed" God in the West. But perhaps it was a necessary deluge.

The sooner religious conservatives become aware of this, the better.

Insofar as conservatism is tied to classical liberalism, it is anti-Catholic. Liberalism is irreconcilable to Catholicism.

The tripartite ills of the age are: Liberalism, Scientism, Capitalism. Thank God that we now know better than to fall into Scientism - but that still leaves the other two.

The sooner we understand that Capitalism is an inevitable consequence of Scientism, the sooner we can begin to comprehend it and thus to reject it.

Capitalism is NOT to be understood as the "natural state of human affairs" - it is the economic and industrial expression of liberalism. It simply did not exist prior to the Enlightenment and the Scientific Revolution. And if by your definition it did - then I'm not talking about your definition, I'm talking about the undeniable historical-economic phenomenon.

(Communism is not the answer, because it is merely the antithesis of Capitalism, it is by its very nature borne out of Capitalism and could not exist without it)

And well, what is Liberalism? It is the coup d'etat of God's eternal Law by man's freedom. It is the absurd notion that one should tolerate evil - if not in oneself, then in others (rules for me, not for thee) - and that this tolerance is in itself a good instead of a concession. It is the bedrock of the notion of the separation of Church and State - one that has been rightfully declared to be contrary to the Faith.

We who have grown up in this liberal, Godless age have much to unlearn - our support for free speech without limits, our notion that power should rest in the people (what idolatry! Power rests in God and God alone, and he raises up whomever He wishes), our insistence on personal rights even above our obligation to others, our general notion of "every man for themselves," our toleration of rampantly usurious practices and morbidly high inequality rates, even our tacit acceptance that "business is business" - that money should matter more than friendships and family - the lot of it needs to go.

The right and the left in the West are of the same stock: they are liberals quarreling with themselves. There needs to be more of a voice for authentic Catholic political positions, and that starts with recognizing this very fact.

To the conservatives I say: would that you be more conservative to realize that your liberalism does not date back 2000 years, and is a philosophical innovation! Would that you do not brush off the apparent contradictions between your faith and your politics, would that you were hot or cold!

To the progressives I say: you are now advancing further and starting to leave behind liberalism, but instead you are falling into tyranny and authoritarianism. Even in "leaving liberalism behind" you are confused, for what you wish for is nothing but advancing liberal principles, and in the process you unravel the contradictions within it. And is that not the fate of any ideology that does not recognize its God! You are trying to reach for something new, but there is nothing new under the sun. Only the Church stands, as She shall forever - unto the ages of ages.

Edit: since many are asking, I post below New Advent's summary of the principles of Liberalism which I am against:

The most fundamental principle asserts an absolute and unrestrained freedom of thought, religion, conscience, creed, speech, press, and politics. The necessary consequences of this are, on the one hand, the abolition of the Divine right and of every kind of authority derived from God; the relegation of religion from the public life into the private domain of one's individual conscience; the absolute ignoring of Christianity and the Church as public, legal, and social institutions; on the other hand, the putting into practice of the absolute autonomy of every man and citizen, along all lines of human activity, and the concentration of all public authority in one "sovereignty of the people". 

A fundamental principle of Liberalism is the proposition: "It is contrary to the natural, innate, and inalienable right and liberty and dignity of man, to subject himself to an authority, the root, rule, measure, and sanction of which is not in himself". This principle implies the denial of all true authority; for authority necessarily presupposes a power outside and above man to bind him morally.


r/Catholicism • • Mar 06 '25

Why Communion on the Tongue, Kneeling, Must Be Restored

Thumbnail
epistles.online
0 Upvotes

Though Communion in the hand is valid, it is irreverent and wrong. It fosters abuse, weakens faith, and contributes to the crisis in the Church. If we continue on this path, future generations may never know true Catholic worship.

Therefore, let no faithful Catholic—lay or cleric—promote or permit the practice of Communion in the hand. Instead, let us receive our Lord as He truly deserves: on the tongue, kneeling, in profound reverence and adoration.


r/Catholicism • • Aug 13 '23

can a "racist" get into heaven?

7 Upvotes

I went to confession the other day and confessed that I have feelings of "racism," or anger at seeing other ethnicities pop-up in my mostly white neighborhood. The priest sounded very appalled and gave me a seemingly heavy penance (a decade of the rosary while contemplating the strife of people in Africa, usually I just get two our fathers or something).

Here is my issue. I am committed to truth, and loving all people as God's creation and recognizing their inherent dignity. And I think I do, or try my best. But can't I love them from afar? Can't I just choose to live among people who I get along with? Is racism simply a term applied to people who aren't accepting the multiculturalism that's forced upon them?

I am a White American. I get that our ancestors "stole" this country from people (actually not mine, I am Irish). I am not saying all black people need to go back to Africa or Mexicans should be deported en masse. I just want a safe neighborhood to raise my kids.

Why do I equate non-white with unsafe? Well, like I said earlier, because it's true. Easily provable by crime statistics on google. I know it may be caused by "systemic racism" and all that, and sure let's combat systemic racism together. But at the end of the day I want my wife and kids to be safe. Seeing a purposed threat to them naturally causes me to become angry. And like I said, I am committed to truth. Racism is defined as

prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism by an individual, community, or institution against a person or people on the basis of their membership in a particular racial or ethnic group.

Prejucide is:

preconceived opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience.

Here's the thing, my prejudice IS based on reason and actual experience. I have been mugged by a minority three times growing up in a multi-cultural area. I can give many examples of things I saw and experienced but I won't. Therefore these definitions of "prejudice" and "racism" seem unfalsifiable, paradoxical, and almost meaningless.

I just want a little area separate from them. I love them, I want to help them and do good works for them, and I know they should be treated all as individuals, they ain't all bad, actually maybe even the majority aren't, but my natural discernment tells me the less white an area is, the higher crime is going to be, and that is just a very easily-provable statistical fact. I know it's caused by "systemic racism," but I am not looking to outline the causes, I am looking to avoid the effects.

Thoughts? Sorry if I offended anyone.


r/Catholicism • • Jun 12 '23

As thousands of subreddits go dark in protest of Reddit's new API policies, let the light of Our Lord's Sacred Heart shine on the front page

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/Catholicism • • Sep 16 '24

Pope Francis is WRONG about Trump

0 Upvotes

“Pope Francis is wrong when he says it’s up to the individual to decide if “that man” or “ that woman” is the lesser of two evils.

For American Catholics, Donald Trump, without a doubt is the lesser of two evils when it comes to abortion, which is, according to the US bishops, the “preeminent priority” for US Catholics voting in 2024.

Trump believes in the “three exceptions” like Ronald Reagan (rape, incest, life of the mother) while Kamala Harris wants ZERO restrictions on abortion nationwide. Also, over 90% of abortions are elective, while only 1% are due to rape and incest, and life of the mother. This FURTHER proves that Donald Trump is the lesser of two evils.

He’s also incorrect when he says Trump wants to throw out migrants, which is not true, he wants to deport criminal illegal aliens Who are coming into the country unvetted and raping, trafficking, and killing American citizens. A 12 year old girl was just recently raped and killed by an MS 13 gang member who was here illegally. This is one of countless examples.

I really hope Pope Francis is just ignorant of the situation, to my understanding, he doesn’t watch TV or go on the Internet, so I’d be real curious to know where, or WHO, he’s getting his information from….?”


r/Catholicism • • Oct 13 '25

Politics Monday Not Your Average Immigration Post

9 Upvotes

I wanted to conduct a thought experiment here today since its politics Monday.

A few of the common reasons provided for being against the enforcement of immigration laws (particularly in the USA) are as follows:

It’s against human dignity (inhumane).

It’s embarrassing and belittling to them.

Separating families.

It’s bad because it’s for people who are different.

They just want acceptance.

These arguments are along the same lines as the ones used for just about everything in modern times that everyone knows should not be tolerated.  The problem is too many people lead with their hearts and ignore their minds.  That doesn’t work.  Lead with your mind guided by your heart.  This way feelings don’t have you do irrational things.

I wanted to see if we could apply the same logic to the Church.  Would it work?  Let’s find out.

To join the Church, one must go through the proper process of either being raised in the Church or going through RCIA/OCIA.

Worldly response:  That’s discriminatory.  Why are you not letting people in who want in?  Why make it so difficult for people to become Catholic?   Why can’t a practicing Muslim join the Catholic Church? I thought Catholic meant Universal.  You guys are racist!  They still believe in God.  You just don’t like them because they are not like you.  You realize if you let them in your numbers would go up, right?  I thought Christianity was supposed to be embracing and loving.  Why do you have such disdain for people who are not like you?  I am going to protest in front of your parish until you give in.

To receive absolution of ones sins, one must go to Confession.

Worldly response:  Why?  That belittles people and is embarrassing.  Why should we tell a priest just so he can enjoy it?  You need to change the rules on this.  We can go straight to God.  Call no man Father, remember?  It’s disgusting for some perv to listen with glee to all of our sins.  This must stop. What is wrong with you people?

To receive the Eucharist, one must be Catholic and in a state of grace.

Worldly response:  That’s just wrong!  Why keep the Eucharist away from other people who want it?  That is discrimination! Does it make you feel big and tough to keep Jesus from people?  State of grace?  We are all sinners and restricting the Eucharist is inhumane.  Using labels like “Catholic in a state of grace” is discriminatory in nature.  Why are you labeling people?  How do you know if the person is in a state of grace?  Maybe an unrepentant homosexual can still love Jesus.  Why are you all homophobic?  Why do you want to break up a loving home of same sex couples?  Where is your compassion?  Why can’t you accept them as God created them this way?  You are judging other people and need to stop.

Only men can be priests.

Worldly response:  That is misogynistic!  Why do you hate women?  There are women priests in other churches.  You people are sexist and just want to keep women in the kitchen barefoot and pregnant!  Are you afraid of women or something?

You see, the Catholic Church has rules just like our government and for the same reasons.  We should not and cannot change rules just because some people do not like them. It is for our protection and theirs.

We all know the proper responses to what I wrote, but I guess my question is why use the worlds responses when it is convenient for your argument rather than use logic and reason regularly?

 EDIT: Welp, that went terribly. No thought whatsoever. Just people using the very arguments I presented here with no real solutions. Not a single person provided a real world, viable, realistic solution to correct the problem. Though, I do give them credit for their creative ability to argue with the wrong objections. Most also seemed painfully unaware of what I was actually saying with this post and it's truly disturbing. Perhaps I should, in the future, not ask people to think when they are so comfortable feeling their way through everything.


r/Catholicism • • Mar 31 '25

Politics Monday [Politics Monday] Nationalism is anti-Catholic

128 Upvotes

American Catholics, especially, should know well of the 19th and 20th century history of “America First” nativist movements in the US that stoked fear, violence, and economic resentment against Catholic migrants from Ireland and Italy, but here are some of the Church’s statements to make it clear this point clear…

Second Vatican Council

“Citizens must cultivate a generous and loyal spirit of patriotism, but without narrowing their minds to a particular nation, refusing to love and aid the rest of the human family.” (Gaudium et Spes)

Pope St. Paul VI

“Narrow nationalism and economic selfishness are contrary to the plan of God.” (Populorum Progressio)

Pope Benedict XVI

“The development of peoples depends above all on a recognition that the human race is a single family working together in true communion, not on narrow nationalistic interests.” (Caritas in Veritate)

US Conference of Catholic Bishops

“Any policy that leads to the forced separation of families, arbitrary deportations, or the exclusion of vulnerable peoples is inconsistent with Catholic moral teaching.” (Justice for Immigrants Statement, 2018)

Pope Francis

“Closed forms of nationalism disregard the common good. They are incapable of seeing other people as equally endowed with inalienable dignity … Racism is a virus that quickly mutates and, instead of disappearing, goes into hiding, and lurks in waiting.” (Fratelli Tutti)

“It is easy to stir up people’s darkest instincts. But this is not Christian. Populism is not the way.” (Interview with Reuters, 2018)

Why this is relevant for the American Church:

Catholic ~ universal


r/Catholicism • • May 30 '22

Politics Monday [Politics Monday] Shouldn't Catholics be in favor of more rigorous gun control laws?

18 Upvotes

With the recent mass shootings gun control is once again a very hot topic and as expected we have two opposite political sides arguing about wether we should ban all weapons and even disarm the general population or that guns are not the problem and that more regulation is unnecessary.

I know The Church doesn't have a defined position on the issue of gun control but she does teach that humans have a right to self defense even if it leads, by necessity, to putting the aggressor to death. As such you can argue that owning a gun is very much a right tied to your right to life/self-defense.

But even so, doesn't it makes sense for Catholics to be in favor or more rigorous gun control laws? Surely the current laws in the USA seem too permissive. An 18 year old who can't drink legally yet can just walk into a store and buy a semi auto rifle and nearly 400 rounds (which is what the latest killer did), surely this shouldn't be normal?

Sure you won't completely prevent people from obtaining a gun in some other way but surely it would mitigate things?


r/Catholicism • • Nov 13 '23

Is the Pope pushing people away from the Church?

10 Upvotes

speaking on my own experience, as a catechumen, for a long awhile I was on fire about catholicism, and my parish, and experience of the Mass is a reverent NO, and I really like our Mass too.

but now, when it seems like every week, if not every other day there is some new thing from the Pope adding even more ambiguity and confusion in an already very ambiguous and confusing world--its starting to make me question on whether ive made a mistake or not. I have considered eastern orthodoxy as well, but I too sold on the papacy to ever truly commit(even if im not a huge fan of Francis) I did go to an orthodox church though, and honestly I kinda prefer the Mass over Divine Liturgy lol. I guess I dont get the hype. no offense to any eastern catholics reading this, its just not for me haha.

The other issue I personally have is, even if I look past all this and I join the church anyway, I dont want to just add more division than there already is, you know? I want to find peace, and simply enjoy, and live out my new found faith.

I am curious to hear from life long catholics, or other converts to the faith, and what their experience was like/or is like. And even if you aren't shaken, do you still think the Pope is indeed pushing people away?


r/Catholicism • • Aug 24 '26

ISO Catholic thinkers who are critical of the US and capitalism as well as communism.

0 Upvotes

Not a communist but I am in dire need of catholic thinkers who are as critical of capitalism and America as they are the soviet union and communism.

New to the faith and struggling with how much of the prevailing political thought (that I am encountering) feels like political catholicism for westerners. Just went on a pilgrimage where the speaker was going off about how "communism is responsible for weakening the family unit in America", "western civilization is declining because of communism" and "church membership has suffered because communism.....".

I NEED to see a Church that can be critical of the world I live in, and isn't trying to blame all of it's/our problems on a political system that persecuted it decades ago. I need to hear people critical of a style of capitalism that breeds materialism and has shifted the focus from community to the self.

Somebody started me on St. John Chrysostom but it would be nice to hear living, breathing leaders who can talk about the evils America is responsible for, and who can face up to the fact that the church and American capitalism have some responsibility for it's decline in the west.


r/Catholicism • • Mar 19 '25

Why doesn’t Pope Francis step down?

2 Upvotes

Hello everybody! I am a Protestant coming in peace to ask a genuine question. The pope is sadly incredibly ill and of course I have been praying for his well being but due to his illness shouldn’t he step down from the papacy?

I’m ignorant to Roman Catholic Church structure so forgive me if I’m asking anything rude I’m sincerely asking here.

God bless.


r/Catholicism • • Sep 07 '24

Question for the Catholics of Reddit (Controversial probably) NSFW

Post image
1 Upvotes

Disclaimer: -I am a Faithful Catholic to the Magisterium -I fully adhere to the teachings of the church with transgenderism and homosexuality (I am actually quite conservative) -This is a hypothetical, please be charitable to me and others in the comment section

Prompt: Hello fellow Catholics! I'm an advid anime watcher and I enjoy RomComs ALOT! But there was this one RomCom anime I was watching last night that was very...interesting. It is called "Life with an Ordinary Guy Who Reincarnated into a Total Fantasy Knockout".

The story goes around the idea of your average "isekai" genre (Reincarnated or transported into another world, mostly fantasy rpgs and such). But this one is a little different. Two characters get reincarnated into this world, 2 men, but 1 of the men turn into a woman. A real woman! Not a transgender! And they start falling in love with each other (I know right, what the heck?!)

My question for yall is, what if a man or woman in real life was to swap genders, in the real sense of different working genitalia, brain chemistry and etc. Would a faithful Catholic who had gone through this process through either by the work of God or twisted science have to become celibate? Or would they be allowed to pursue which was once the same sex (now the opposite sex)?

Again, please don't think Im a sicko, Im just genuinely curious how that would correlate to Catholic teaching....


r/Catholicism • • Sep 18 '23

Why doesn't the Church care about marriage?

0 Upvotes

It seems in this Church, no one cares about trying to promote marriage or providing the means for young adults to meet their future spouses. Parishes almost seem to think that people are gonna go to college, meet their spouses there, and then return with a big, happy family, Yet the sad truth is only step one is happening and it all stops there. Like why can't the Church just wake up and realize just being Catholic alone doesn't mean people are gonna marry someone else; there's a whole multitude of things that are also taken into account that will actually make a relationship and marriage flourish and prosper in the long run. And take being a man like me, it seems that unless you are becoming a priest and trying to go to the seminary, then it's your problem. So being a 20 year old single man who wants to meet a future spouse that's Catholic, looks attractive, has a good personality, agrees with me on some values, etc. really badly, it's almost disheartening in a world that is hostile to our faith and at the same time, doesn't want me to marry until I'm a lot older, when in the past marrying around my age was normal and even encouraged.


r/Catholicism • • Oct 31 '22

are there any less conservative Catholic subs?

5 Upvotes

This sub seems to be pretty anti-Pope (?) for being too "liberal". I've never counted him as liberal, but it's quickly becoming apparent that people only really think this way because he doesn't think Liberation Theology is the work of the devil.

Anyway, I don't see any subs that are pro-Pope, or at least give him the benefit of the doubt, and take a less US-style conservative approach... Are there any? Anybody thinking of making one?


r/Catholicism • • Feb 28 '25

As a Catholic I fail to see what's wrong with being traditional

35 Upvotes

All I ask is to be a traditional man. What is wrong with that? I consider myself more educated than most Catholics on matters of faith and morals (not exactly a high bar) but find myself caught up by American politics in general.

I try to vote with Jesus in my heart and the Holy Spirit in my mind, but inevitably a news story comes up, or a Reddit post (which I try to use less and less frequently) and it's of course a heavily politically charged one. Politically charged on Reddit typically means liberal/progressive.

What concerns me most about this is the fact that so many liberals are apparently anti-tradition. If I want to raise a family the traditional way, to have a future and follow God, why can't I? I'm not saying the right is perfect by any means, but they aren't telling me how to live my life, at least in the long-term.

For reference I am a teenager. This is part of the reason I'm posting this: I wish I grew up decades ago and had a much higher chance to have a traditional family in the Catholic sense. What do you brothers and sisters in Christ think?


r/Catholicism • • May 05 '14

Lets talk about this reasonably: Reddit management has come out directly opposed to Catholic views, so what do we do?

2 Upvotes

As you are all aware by now, or should be now due to this post, Reddit management has come out directly in favor of gay "marriage" and opposing Catholic views openly now. Obviously, this is an issue for many of us as to continue to provide financial support for this organization would be a sin.

So the question is: What do we do?

Edit: To the person buying us reddit gold: We don't care, we didn't directly support reddit so its not a sin for us to be gilded nor are we going to "freak out" you are spending your own money. If you are going to support reddit's misguided goal just donate directly to them.

Edit 2: Alright seem like the resolution is there - I (We) can continue to use Reddit, do not purchase Reddit gold anymore but at the same time do not use adblock, I (we) cannot steal from Reddit just because they are committing evil acts. Thank you all for your input, helped me a lot.


r/Catholicism • • Jul 22 '12

If God doesn't approve of homosexual relationships, then why did He create homosexuals?

2 Upvotes

The title sums it up, but basically, why would God create something destined to do evil? I think He wouldn't, and so the church's position is horribly wrong, and has driven at least one person from faith because of this. thoughts?

EDIT: Thanks for downvoting instead of taking time to reason/think and answer the question.