r/CaseyAnthony • • Jul 28 '26

The definition of butterface

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

I see SO many men defending her based on her looks, I only bring this up because it’s one of the main things I see in conversation about her is how attractive she is, not just her body but her face, but for the life of God can’t see it, but every time I bring it up I get called jealous even by other CA haters🥴🥴.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 07 '22

By episode 2, my opinions shifted greatly

1 Upvotes

Going into this, I had my opinions from growing up with this case. That the overwhelming evidence showed Casey more likely than not killed her daughter.

But honestly, now I’m not so sure. I think George is really sketchy and her defense theories actually make sense. I think it was really easy to hate her back then because, let’s face it, America loves blaming women - especially back then.

The only thing holding me back is the 31 days of thinking your daughter is safe without any contact whatsoever. Just makes no sense.

But then again, the evidence really wasn’t there for her.

Thoughts? It seems most people still hold their original opinions.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 03 '22

Casey Anthony = Amber Heard

6 Upvotes

I just can’t get over the similarities in their mannerisms, face expressions, and allegations. No tears. This doc makes me sick. I realize the two are guilty of much different crimes, but the similarities in their physical presence and reactions when testifying and giving this interview are unreal.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Sep 24 '26

Demand justice for Caylee Anthony by reinvestigating Casey Anthony

Thumbnail
change.org
5 Upvotes

r/CaseyAnthony • • Nov 30 '22

I’ve noticed her facial mannerisms are similar to Amber heard

5 Upvotes

r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 05 '22

Georgie Porgie Fans

5 Upvotes

I’ve read a solid 5 posts today and am absolutely bewildered how people can say George isn’t sus. Or, even make him sound like he is a good person.

He’s not y’all.

He doesn’t even have his own bank account because of his lying and theft. That’s just a piece of the iceberg. Cindy herself said Casey gets her BS from him!

I mean if that’s not enough let’s discuss the mistress he picked up at a search for Caylee tent.

Wild that anyone wouldn’t put him into the same basket as Casey. Who was he calling at 3pm? Thought Casey went to work? Why is George calling the house ONE minute after he gets to work?

I’m not pro Casey but George is definitely cut from the same cloth. Or he is the cloth. Who knows.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Mar 24 '25

Imagine if her TikTok account stays forever, bare in mind just because I following it doesn’t mean I support her in anyway shape or form I am following out of pure curiosity and just to keep tabs

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/CaseyAnthony • • May 02 '24

Casey reminds me of Amber Heard in Depp vs Heard

30 Upvotes

I never was into or knew a ton about this case, but i started warching on Peacock.

Only an episode in 'Where Truth Lies' & finally put my finger on who she reminded me of. Amber Heard during the Depp Vs Heard trials. Everything feels so fake and calculated.

She is coming across as a psychopath with all her lies.

I know I'm late to the party, but anyone else?? I can't be the only one who sees it haha.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Sep 01 '24

Mental Health Crisis?

2 Upvotes

Does Casey have any mental health diagnoses? I keep wondering if Caylee’s death was a result of some sort of mental health crisis— almost if Casey was trying to protect Caylee from her parents? Casey Anthony was a known liar/manipulator, incredibly self-centered, and made chaotic choices. She grew up before we talked about mental health, before people were more willing to take their children to professionals, and was constantly appeased/saved face by her parents.

I just wonder if Casey was convinced Cindy was going to somehow get Caylee’s custody, or if she was worried about George around Caylee, or both. Like everyone else, I’m just interested in the how/why it happened. Anyone have thoughts/sources that discuss this theory?


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 09 '22

Just a theory......

1 Upvotes

Casey takes a nap, Caylee is beside her initially but being only 2.5 years old sneaks out of the room once Casey is asleep. George is home, I believe he said he was watching tv, but could have also fallen asleep. Regardless, no one knows little Caylee snuck out of the room and is now completely unsupervised. If George too was sleeping, Caylee was free to do whatever. Even if he wasn't sleeping I can see little Caylee being a typical 2.5 year old, being sneaky and going about undetected. She ends up having an accident, eats/drinsk something poisonous, chokes etc. and dies. Cindy did say she had chloroform in the house for some of her outdoor plants. George wakes up or if not asleep decides to check on Casey and Caylee and sees Caylee isn't beside Casey. He shakes Casey awake asking where Caylee is. They both search the house and George finds little Caylee deceased. They blame each other for who's responsible and ultimately panic because they know admitting their negligence to Cindy would be too painful. They come up with an elaborate plan and agree to evade and outsmart law enforcement because it's much easier to pretend someone else harmed Caylee then to own she died under their watch. Another scenario would be identical to this minus George being home. Again, just another one of many theories trying to sort out what could have happened. Let me know your thoughts and please be respectful to each other.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Sep 03 '26

Why do people act like Casey had/has power?

0 Upvotes

Is it her looks? I think she’s attractive, but is she so beautiful that people need to turn her into some kind of powerful, calculating witch? I genuinely don’t understand it.

Because when you actually look at the circumstances of her life, where exactly was this supposed power?

She had no money. No stable career. No real independence. No obvious social status. By most accounts, she was living a chaotic life and struggling to hold things together. She was raised by controlling, morally compromised parents and, from a very young age, appears to have learned to survive by managing other people’s reactions to her.

She was also a young mother carrying the responsibility of caring for a child while apparently having very little stability of her own.

Yet somehow, when people talk about her, she gets transformed into this almost mythical figure: calculating, powerful, manipulative, playing everyone around her like chess pieces.

But where is the power?

I'm genuinely interested in understanding why people make that leap.

Is it because we tend to interpret certain traits—attractiveness, confidence, lying, emotional detachment, sexuality, charm—as evidence of power? Do we find it easier to believe that someone who commits or is accused of something terrible must have been highly calculating and in control, rather than deeply dysfunctional and operating from a lifetime of survival strategies?

And does an attractive woman behaving badly trigger a particular kind of reaction where people retroactively assign her far more agency, intelligence, and control than the facts actually support?

Because to me, that's the fascinating part.

Please, no “she killed her kid” comments. I understand that argument. That's not what I'm asking.

I'm asking about something else: why do people seem so determined to see her as this extraordinarily powerful person when the circumstances of her actual life suggest someone who had very little power at all?

It's like we're staring so hard at the trees that we've forgotten there is an entire forest.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 07 '22

Why did Casey's dad seemingly push for the death penalty if he truly thought it was an accident?

3 Upvotes

This question arose in the documentary and I can't stop thinking about it. He was the star witness for the prosecution, yet made some contradicting claims in interviews. Is he trying to hide that he actually killed Caylee and abused both Casey and Caylee by attempting to silence Casey? Or, if Casey did kill Caylee, does he know it was more sinister than an accidental drowning?

Another thing, after his accident, he makes a statement saying he wants forgiveness from Casey? This could be referring to different things depending on how you view his motives in the trial.

What do you think?


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 15 '22

George Anthony

1 Upvotes

This is gonna be a little all over place. I’m having trouble trying to fill in some of these blanks. I know a lot of people disagree that george was involved but I feel he could have been. I don’t know if i believe that he was abusing casey as a child but he clearly wanted to protect his family from judgments. I think that casey could have killed caylee by suffocating her with a pillow and either george found out somehow and disposed of her body for casey or he knew what had happened even if he wasn’t directly involved. Many people say that they don’t think he was involved because he was a cop and would have done a better job covering it up but i don’t think that’s necessarily true. It very apparent there was no investigation into him and everyone knows cops stick with cops. It’s clear they immediately took everything george said as fact. In casey’s new series she describes george suffocating her with a pillow which i believe was her planting the seeds to later “discover” george was abusing caylee as well and say that’s how he killed her. I’m in school for forensic psychology so I know how to read body language and things. George is overall just a creepy guy and something weird was going on with him. There’s a lot of other details that led me to believe george helped or at least knew. I’d like to hear other peoples opinions on george and maybe some people could correct me or fill in gaps. I also wanna make it clear i do not support casey and i do believe she murdered her daughter and should be held accountable.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Jul 12 '26

Who would you rather sit next to?

0 Upvotes

You will be given 1 billion dollars but you must talk to the person sitting next to you on a flight for 12 hours who would you choose

104 votes, Jul 15 '26
40 Casey Anthony
12 Susan smith
12 Chris watts
18 Scott Peterson
22 Jeffery Epstein

r/CaseyAnthony • • Apr 21 '24

Casey Anthony’s lawyer does interview with Matthew Cox

8 Upvotes

He makes a very compelling argument for why he thinks she’s innocent. Also all around a great interview, he’s had a long and storied life. Only part of it discusses the case. Highly recommend y’all check it out

Link: https://youtu.be/gOSS4gD458Y?si=fzY-ueQVjoSzU6wN

Edit: what a charming community here, I can only imagine how hard y’all clicked that downvote


r/CaseyAnthony • • Feb 09 '26

I actually believe Casey.

8 Upvotes

I know it’s not a popular opinion and when all of it was happening I also just kind of assumed she was every bit as evil as she was portrayed. But I’m older now and have listened and watched everything I could find about her, her trial and most recently the actual docuseries on Peacock where Casey actually sits down and answers all the questions we all had about pretty much everything and honestly I believe her, for the most part. I think there’s details that she can’t really reconcile with even herself but I don’t think she killed Caylee and I believe that George had way more closely to the role Casey describes in her interview. Even before the interview I was leaning way more in the direction of it was an accident she drown and then there were countless terrible decisions made by both Casey and her dad. I thought Casey’s actions in the following weeks much more closely resembled a mother in total shock and out of touch with her reality. Casey is a liar but that doesn’t make her a murderer.

Again I know most people will disagree with me and that’s okay you’re equally as entitled to your opinion.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Feb 26 '26

Innocent or guilty

2 Upvotes

Do you believe she is innocent or guilty of murder? Or do you think it was an accident she panicked and it snowballed out of control? I still think it was the accident and she probably panicked and obviously she didn’t think the whole world would be watching her case unfold.. most people who commit crimes do it again or they keep visiting the scene of the murder like Scott Peterson did.. she has never been in trouble with the law since not even a speeding ticket.. look at OJ yes he was found not guilty but we all knew it and he committed more crimes.. she also has kept a low profile for the better part of two decades.. yes people only take video or photos of her when she is at a club.. notice no one takes pics of her at a grocery store or anywhere else.. so guilty or innocent or accident?


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 06 '22

George Anthony

0 Upvotes

After watching the entire new documentary, it is hard to believe many things from what the Anthony’s have to say. However though, I’m convinced that George is gross from his pedophilic comments at Caylee’s funeral. I don’t fully believe Casey but her and her father were both definitely involved.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 23 '23

Lie detector test

0 Upvotes

I firmly believe Casey didn’t murder her child and have always believed George did it and got away with it.. however let’s play devils advocate here.. would you change your opinion on who killed caylee if George fails the lie detector test? If Cindy fails? Would that change your mind? What if Casey did one and she told the truth? I am just curious if your mind could be changed based on them passing or failing?


r/CaseyAnthony • • Dec 04 '22

I think Jose Baez didn’t participate after the accusations that he and Casey were in a sexual relationship - and knew he killed Caylee

0 Upvotes

In a deposition, the private investigator hired by Casey’s defense team says Baez and Anthony were involved in a sexual relationship and claims Baez told him “Casey had murdered Caylee and dumped the body somewhere and, he needed all the help he could get to find the body before anyone else did.”

Dominic Casey made the accusations during a deposition for Anthony’s bankruptcy proceedings.

In the affidavit, the investigator says Anthony wanted to pin Caylee’s murder on her family or the meter reader who found the toddler’s body.

Baez hired Casey in August 2008. Casey says a month later, he overheard Baez tell Anthony that she owed him oral sex in exchange for canceling a television interview.

“He called the network saying they would have to take a raincheck, hung up the phone," and the told Anthony she owed him oral sex, Casey testified.

According to Casey, two weeks later he found a naked Anthony coming out of Baez’s private office.

“Casey told me she had to do what Jose said because she had no money for her defense. I reminded her that Baez had more than enough money from the network he sold the photographs to pay for her defense. Casey apologized and assured me it would not happen again,” he said in the deposition.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Mar 05 '25

Sign the Petition

Thumbnail
chng.it
0 Upvotes

r/CaseyAnthony • • Aug 25 '24

Lesson I learned and I hope you did too

14 Upvotes

I recently finally had the opportunity to watch the Peacock special.

I also watched a few others from a different viewpoint

It reiterated to me, personally how MUCH perspective can be changed depending on who is behind the camera.

I don’t feel sympathy for anyone in the family aside from that poor child. Either way I believe they were all aware of what really happened and are all full of lies.

The part where her own father was the STAR witness for the death penalty astonished me. They all lied, and covered up the truth in my opinion. None of them are innocent. I truly believe they orchestrated events leading to the cover up.

Until I finally saw this I thought she was acting alone. Now I believe more were involved. I’d bet that mother of her will spill one day

It’s a sick world we live in. Always remember there are three sides to a story. Them, her and the truth, don’t ever believe one side of the story. Always keep that in mind.

I am not here to argue, I just needed to get this out. The true crime world is vast. Do your research.


r/CaseyAnthony • • Jul 09 '26

Police investigation

1 Upvotes

I know most of you dislike me or even hate me bc you think I am her or a fan of hers.. I am not her or a fan.. this case just has me captivated.. anyway onto the question for all of you.. I know of at least two instances where the police botched this case.. 1) the computer search.. and 2) when Roy kronk first calls in saying he saw human remains.. I know those are the two biggest things but was there anything else that they missed or you thought may have overlooked? I feel this case reminds me of several others in terms of how mishandled it was by the police.. like the jonbenet case or baby Sabrina case or even baby Trenton duckett..


r/CaseyAnthony • • Nov 30 '22

I see George in a new light

29 Upvotes

I just got done watching the Casey Anthony documentary and I have to admit that I have reasonable doubt. I think George may have done this. When they showed the video of him testifying against Casey, he had kind of a smile on his face. I believe the micro expression is called “Dupers Delight”. Also, thinking back, he attempted suicide. Is that due to a guilty conscience? Also, why was HE asking for forgiveness if he had NOTHING to do with this? He practically CONFESSED to Dr Oz!


r/CaseyAnthony • • Mar 07 '25

Casey describing Caylee as “infectious”

3 Upvotes

In her documentary, that I am now just watching from 2022… Casey describes Caylee as “infectious”. Very interesting choice of words. Infectious? why not contagious personality. that choice of wording is more appropriate. I would never describe my child as infectious. What do you think?