Is it her looks? I think she’s attractive, but is she so beautiful that people need to turn her into some kind of powerful, calculating witch? I genuinely don’t understand it.
Because when you actually look at the circumstances of her life, where exactly was this supposed power?
She had no money. No stable career. No real independence. No obvious social status. By most accounts, she was living a chaotic life and struggling to hold things together. She was raised by controlling, morally compromised parents and, from a very young age, appears to have learned to survive by managing other people’s reactions to her.
She was also a young mother carrying the responsibility of caring for a child while apparently having very little stability of her own.
Yet somehow, when people talk about her, she gets transformed into this almost mythical figure: calculating, powerful, manipulative, playing everyone around her like chess pieces.
But where is the power?
I'm genuinely interested in understanding why people make that leap.
Is it because we tend to interpret certain traits—attractiveness, confidence, lying, emotional detachment, sexuality, charm—as evidence of power? Do we find it easier to believe that someone who commits or is accused of something terrible must have been highly calculating and in control, rather than deeply dysfunctional and operating from a lifetime of survival strategies?
And does an attractive woman behaving badly trigger a particular kind of reaction where people retroactively assign her far more agency, intelligence, and control than the facts actually support?
Because to me, that's the fascinating part.
Please, no “she killed her kid” comments. I understand that argument. That's not what I'm asking.
I'm asking about something else: why do people seem so determined to see her as this extraordinarily powerful person when the circumstances of her actual life suggest someone who had very little power at all?
It's like we're staring so hard at the trees that we've forgotten there is an entire forest.