first, i support cart narcs cuz its funny and good for society. however, theres a few arguments that i disagree with.
"theres an implied contract that you return the cart to the cart corral." come on thats ridiculous. theres no implied contract you return the cart anywhere. its a nice gesture but to say someone implied you need to return the cart is not true. the sign at the cart return is not at the store entrance. theres a chance you park somewhere that the cart corral sign is not visible, and the sign is usually ambiguous like the word "return." no actual contractual language or agreement.
"if this abandoned cart hits a car, you'd be at fault." once the cart is abandoned, it is no longer connected to the person who left it there. if wind pushes the cart, thats an act of nature that no one can control. even if it were true that the person is at fault, that is the prerogative of the lazybones who wants to risk being at fault for a potential collision.
"making it hard to park" usually parking lots are massive so a few spots being occupied by a pile of carts isnt that bad. also it could be a sign that more cart corrals are needed or their locations arent optimal. some stores i go to have NO corrals or only like 1 or 2, so theres that too.